Azat Aituar
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Azat Aituar has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
M. Narikbayev KAZGUU University
2 shared publications- Omar Bolatbay
M. Narikbayev KAZGUU University
2 shared publications - Saule Kemelbayeva
M. Narikbayev KAZGUU University, Astana, Kazakhstan
2 shared publications - Zarina Adilkhanova
Economic Modeling Development Center, NAC Analytica, Nazarbayev University
2 shared publications - А.R. Sagynayev
International School of Economics, Maqsut Narikbayev University
2 shared publications A. Akhmedyarova
Nazarbayev University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 December 2025
- Published by Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Public Administration and Civil Service
- Vol. 95 (4) , 89-101
STAGE-CONTINGENT FUNDAMENTALS OF STRUCTURAL TRANSFORMATION: EVIDENCE FROM UNIVARIATE LOGISTIC REGRESSIONS
This paper explores the fundamental factors influencing movement across five developmental stages within a global country classification as proposed by Aituar et al. We operationalize the staged frameworks of Rostow, Ohno, and Porter by estimating stage-specific univariate logistic regressions for each transition, utilizing a comprehensive set of institutional, policy, and capability variables while reporting odds ratios and ranking the leading predictors for each transition. In this framework of structural transformation, economies advance along a path of manufacturing led development, progressing from pre-industrial conditions to early manufacturing, followed by diversification through enhanced domestic linkages and integration into global value chains, increased complexity, and ultimately reaching an innovation frontier. Our findings support and refine this narrative: the take-off stage is most closely linked to investment capacity and basic appropriability; diversification is associated with administrative and legal predictability as well as external-risk management; maturity correlates with significant investment and appropriability effects alongside regulatory alignment and advanced factor conditions; and entry into the frontier and sustained presence there is tied to robust rule-of-law institutions and disciplined openness. Indicators tend to strengthen systematically across stages. Two refinements emerge from our analysis: appropriability (proxied by intellectual property as % of GDP) plays a more significant role earlier than the literature suggests, and the positive associations observed between inflation volatility (proxied by standard deviation of inflation) reflects temporary reform turbulence rather than causal growth and stage advancement. Keywords: structural transformation; stage of development; industrialization; diversification; complexity; innovation; univariate logistic regression.
- 30 December 2025
- Published by Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Public Administration and Civil Service
- Vol. 95 (4) , 89-101
Open AccessSTAGE-CONTINGENT FUNDAMENTALS OF STRUCTURAL TRANSFORMATION: EVIDENCE FROM UNIVARIATE LOGISTIC REGRESSIONS
This paper explores the fundamental factors influencing movement across five developmental stages within a global country classification as proposed by Aituar et al. We operationalize the staged frameworks of Rostow, Ohno, and Porter by estimating stage-specific univariate logistic regressions for each transition, utilizing a comprehensive set of institutional, policy, and capability variables while reporting odds ratios and ranking the leading predictors for each transition. In this framework of structural transformation, economies advance along a path of manufacturing led development, progressing from pre-industrial conditions to early manufacturing, followed by diversification through enhanced domestic linkages and integration into global value chains, increased complexity, and ultimately reaching an innovation frontier. Our findings support and refine this narrative: the take-off stage is most closely linked to investment capacity and basic appropriability; diversification is associated with administrative and legal predictability as well as external-risk management; maturity correlates with significant investment and appropriability effects alongside regulatory alignment and advanced factor conditions; and entry into the frontier and sustained presence there is tied to robust rule-of-law institutions and disciplined openness. Indicators tend to strengthen systematically across stages. Two refinements emerge from our analysis: appropriability (proxied by intellectual property as % of GDP) plays a more significant role earlier than the literature suggests, and the positive associations observed between inflation volatility (proxied by standard deviation of inflation) reflects temporary reform turbulence rather than causal growth and stage advancement. Keywords: structural transformation; stage of development; industrialization; diversification; complexity; innovation; univariate logistic regression.
- Open Access
Forks in the Road: Globalization, Deindustrialization, and Economic Growth Pathways
Utilizing a panel of 125 economies spanning from 1970 to 2019, we examine the role of manufacturing as a fundamental pillar of development in the era of global value chains (GVCs). We employ a layered clustering approach that categorizes countries based on income per capita and structural characteristics, such as the share of manufacturing, export complexity, resource dependence, productivity, and wages while maintaining consistency over time. Prior to 1990, most trajectories exhibited a progression from early industrialization to diversification, enhanced industrialization, increased export complexity, rising income levels, and subsequently to deindustrialization. However, post-1990, deindustrialization began to permeate middle- and low-income economies, with export complexity frequently increasing in the absence of deeper domestic industrial development. Two distinct manufacturing pathways are evident: one characterized by functional specialization amid moderate manufacturing levels and another exemplified by the East Asian model, which demonstrates sustained high manufacturing intensity. Resource-driven growth has led to income increases without significant structural transformation, and such growth has not enabled economies to achieve high-income status without initial industrialization. Manufacturing remains essential as a domestic foundation; therefore, policy efforts should focus on securing this base, enhancing capabilities within higher-value GVCs, and strategically investing resource revenues to bolster industrial capacity.
Open AccessForks in the Road: Globalization, Deindustrialization, and Economic Growth Pathways
Utilizing a panel of 125 economies spanning from 1970 to 2019, we examine the role of manufacturing as a fundamental pillar of development in the era of global value chains (GVCs). We employ a layered clustering approach that categorizes countries based on income per capita and structural characteristics, such as the share of manufacturing, export complexity, resource dependence, productivity, and wages while maintaining consistency over time. Prior to 1990, most trajectories exhibited a progression from early industrialization to diversification, enhanced industrialization, increased export complexity, rising income levels, and subsequently to deindustrialization. However, post-1990, deindustrialization began to permeate middle- and low-income economies, with export complexity frequently increasing in the absence of deeper domestic industrial development. Two distinct manufacturing pathways are evident: one characterized by functional specialization amid moderate manufacturing levels and another exemplified by the East Asian model, which demonstrates sustained high manufacturing intensity. Resource-driven growth has led to income increases without significant structural transformation, and such growth has not enabled economies to achieve high-income status without initial industrialization. Manufacturing remains essential as a domestic foundation; therefore, policy efforts should focus on securing this base, enhancing capabilities within higher-value GVCs, and strategically investing resource revenues to bolster industrial capacity.
- Open Access
- 5 September 2024
- Published by Narxoz University - Non-profit joint stock company in Central Asian Economic Review
- No. 3,p. 8-20
ANALYSIS OF THE DEGREE OF DEPENDENCE OF KAZAKHSTAN'S ECONOMIC SECTORS ON IMPORT AND ASSESSMENT OF THE POTENTIAL FOR REDUCING DEPENDENCE ON IMPORTS
АНАЛИЗ СТЕПЕНИ ЗАВИСИМОСТИ ОТРАСЛЕЙ ЭКОНОМИКИ КАЗАХСТАНА ОТ ИМПОРТА И ОЦЕНКА ПОТЕНЦИАЛА СНИЖЕНИЯ ЗАВИСИМОСТИ ОТ ИМПОРТА
- 5 September 2024
- Published by Narxoz University - Non-profit joint stock company in Central Asian Economic Review
- No. 3,p. 8-20
Open AccessANALYSIS OF THE DEGREE OF DEPENDENCE OF KAZAKHSTAN'S ECONOMIC SECTORS ON IMPORT AND ASSESSMENT OF THE POTENTIAL FOR REDUCING DEPENDENCE ON IMPORTS
АНАЛИЗ СТЕПЕНИ ЗАВИСИМОСТИ ОТРАСЛЕЙ ЭКОНОМИКИ КАЗАХСТАНА ОТ ИМПОРТА И ОЦЕНКА ПОТЕНЦИАЛА СНИЖЕНИЯ ЗАВИСИМОСТИ ОТ ИМПОРТА
- Open Access
- 26 December 2023
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Economic Research & Business Administration
- Vol. 146 (4) , 13-25
Assessing the degree of involvement of Kazakhstani industries in global value chains
The economy structure, availability of resources and production capacities generally define the involvement of country’s goods in global production chains. This research aims to evaluate the degree of global value chain (GVC) involvement for Kazakhstani industries for understanding the country's integration into the global economy and its competitiveness in international markets. The evaluation of the involvement of Kazakhstani goods in GVCs incorporates widely acknowledged indicators of forward and backward integrations introduced by World Bank experts. This analysis delves into the causal relationships within the demand model, providing insights into the intricacies of Kazakhstani goods' integration into production chains. The results revealed that Kazakhstan's participation in GVCs is predominantly driven by forward participation. The peak of GVC involvement occurred during 2004-2008, with total participation exceeding 45%, particularly in sectors like mining, energy production, rubber and plastic products, and base metals. While the role of the country as a global provider of commodity sector goods has been long discussed in literature, results of this study defined the industries with relatively higher degree of backward integration. Certain sectors including rubber and plastic products, computer and electronic equipment, transport equipment, and textiles, exhibit higher backward participation rates (30.3%, 25.5%, 24.3%, and 26% respectively) compared to forward participation. This suggests a significant reliance on imported components, emphasizing a notable proportion of the cost structure for exports in these sectors. The base metals sector stands out with a participation rate exceeding 40%, indicating a notable position in the global value chain. The practical significance of the work relates to the defining industries that can be backward integrated to GVC. While the study discussed Kazakhstan's position in GVC and explored opportunities for defining high-end production, it underscores the need for further in-depth research to assess the potential for integrating Kazakhstan into GVC as a manufacturing site. Key words: global value chains, international markets, trade policy, forward and backward integration, trade indicators
- 26 December 2023
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Economic Research & Business Administration
- Vol. 146 (4) , 13-25
Open AccessAssessing the degree of involvement of Kazakhstani industries in global value chains
The economy structure, availability of resources and production capacities generally define the involvement of country’s goods in global production chains. This research aims to evaluate the degree of global value chain (GVC) involvement for Kazakhstani industries for understanding the country's integration into the global economy and its competitiveness in international markets. The evaluation of the involvement of Kazakhstani goods in GVCs incorporates widely acknowledged indicators of forward and backward integrations introduced by World Bank experts. This analysis delves into the causal relationships within the demand model, providing insights into the intricacies of Kazakhstani goods' integration into production chains. The results revealed that Kazakhstan's participation in GVCs is predominantly driven by forward participation. The peak of GVC involvement occurred during 2004-2008, with total participation exceeding 45%, particularly in sectors like mining, energy production, rubber and plastic products, and base metals. While the role of the country as a global provider of commodity sector goods has been long discussed in literature, results of this study defined the industries with relatively higher degree of backward integration. Certain sectors including rubber and plastic products, computer and electronic equipment, transport equipment, and textiles, exhibit higher backward participation rates (30.3%, 25.5%, 24.3%, and 26% respectively) compared to forward participation. This suggests a significant reliance on imported components, emphasizing a notable proportion of the cost structure for exports in these sectors. The base metals sector stands out with a participation rate exceeding 40%, indicating a notable position in the global value chain. The practical significance of the work relates to the defining industries that can be backward integrated to GVC. While the study discussed Kazakhstan's position in GVC and explored opportunities for defining high-end production, it underscores the need for further in-depth research to assess the potential for integrating Kazakhstan into GVC as a manufacturing site. Key words: global value chains, international markets, trade policy, forward and backward integration, trade indicators
- Open Access
- 1 July 2022
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 17 (2) , 178-189
The Effects of changes in Tariff Rates on Imports: Evidence from Kazakhstan
This paper is the continuation of the research on the impact of Eurasian Customs Union policies on the economy of Kazakhstan. The study provides new evidence on the effects of Customs Unions on its members. In particular, this paper investigates the impact of tariff rate changes in Kazakhstan due to the establishment of the Eurasian Economic Union. Kazakhstan joined Eurasian Customs Union in 2010. Then the Eurasian Customs Union became the Eurasian Economic Union in May 2014. Since the establishment of the ECU, Kazakhstan’s trade policy has experienced considerable change. The tariff rates in Kazakhstan with countries outside the ECU almost doubled, with average tariff rates increasing from 6.45 to 12.24 %. This paper uses the dataset on bilateral trade flows between ECU countries and other 195 countries for 20 years from 2000 to 2019. An empirical analysis is performed on a country level, and panel data techniques are used to estimate whether the increase in the tariffs with non-members of CU will lead to trade diversion with suppliers outside the CU. The analysis demonstrated that the increase in tariff rates negatively affected imports to Kazakhstan from non-ECU countries. The effect of tariff increase, using the dynamic gravity model and GMM econometric technique, is estimated to be a 1.8 % decrease in imports if the average external tariff rate of Kazakhstan increases by one percentage point (e. g. from 7 % to 8 %). Due to the increase in tariff rates, the overall estimated reduction of imports of Kazakhstan is 10.66 %.
- 1 July 2022
- Published by The economy: strategy and practice, Institute of Economics Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Economy: strategy and practice
- Vol. 17 (2) , 178-189
Open AccessThe Effects of changes in Tariff Rates on Imports: Evidence from Kazakhstan
This paper is the continuation of the research on the impact of Eurasian Customs Union policies on the economy of Kazakhstan. The study provides new evidence on the effects of Customs Unions on its members. In particular, this paper investigates the impact of tariff rate changes in Kazakhstan due to the establishment of the Eurasian Economic Union. Kazakhstan joined Eurasian Customs Union in 2010. Then the Eurasian Customs Union became the Eurasian Economic Union in May 2014. Since the establishment of the ECU, Kazakhstan’s trade policy has experienced considerable change. The tariff rates in Kazakhstan with countries outside the ECU almost doubled, with average tariff rates increasing from 6.45 to 12.24 %. This paper uses the dataset on bilateral trade flows between ECU countries and other 195 countries for 20 years from 2000 to 2019. An empirical analysis is performed on a country level, and panel data techniques are used to estimate whether the increase in the tariffs with non-members of CU will lead to trade diversion with suppliers outside the CU. The analysis demonstrated that the increase in tariff rates negatively affected imports to Kazakhstan from non-ECU countries. The effect of tariff increase, using the dynamic gravity model and GMM econometric technique, is estimated to be a 1.8 % decrease in imports if the average external tariff rate of Kazakhstan increases by one percentage point (e. g. from 7 % to 8 %). Due to the increase in tariff rates, the overall estimated reduction of imports of Kazakhstan is 10.66 %.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2022
- Published by Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Public Administration and Civil Service
- No. 2,p. 128-149
PREDICTING HIGH-GROWTH FIRMS IN KAZAKHSTAN WITH MACHINE LEARNING METHODS
- 30 June 2022
- Published by Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Public Administration and Civil Service
- No. 2,p. 128-149
Open AccessPREDICTING HIGH-GROWTH FIRMS IN KAZAKHSTAN WITH MACHINE LEARNING METHODS
- Open Access
- 29 April 2022
- Published by Narxoz University - Non-profit joint stock company in Central Asian Economic Review
- No. 1,p. 48-60
THE EFFECT OF ONLINE EDUCATION ON THE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE OF STUDENTS DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC: EVIDENCE FROM KAZAKHSTAN
Purpose of the research. This study explores COVID19-imposed online education at one of the universities in Kazakhstan to understand whether and in what way it has affected students’ academic performance.Methodology. We use several methodologies, such as the principal component analysis, the nearestneighbour propensity score matching and the latent variable multilevel model.Originality / value of the research. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first attempt to estimate the effect of COVID19-imposed online teaching on academic performance in Kazakhstan.Findings. Though our data suggest that the students exposed to online education had slightly lower academic performance than the earlier cohort of similar students who studied in class, this result is not statistically significant. In fact, for both cohorts of students, their past academic performance reflecting their academic abilities and attitudes, such as university entry test score and past accumulative GPA, matter much more than the mode of study. However, we found out that certain technical variables which characterise the “quality” of Zoom® sessions affect students’ academic performance. Specifically, using a smartphone instead of a personal computer to enter a class conducted in Zoom® negatively affects students’ achievement. Some other characteristics also produce expected effects though they turned out to be statistically insignificant possibly due to aggregation and a small dataset.
- 29 April 2022
- Published by Narxoz University - Non-profit joint stock company in Central Asian Economic Review
- No. 1,p. 48-60
Open AccessTHE EFFECT OF ONLINE EDUCATION ON THE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE OF STUDENTS DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC: EVIDENCE FROM KAZAKHSTAN
Purpose of the research. This study explores COVID19-imposed online education at one of the universities in Kazakhstan to understand whether and in what way it has affected students’ academic performance.Methodology. We use several methodologies, such as the principal component analysis, the nearestneighbour propensity score matching and the latent variable multilevel model.Originality / value of the research. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first attempt to estimate the effect of COVID19-imposed online teaching on academic performance in Kazakhstan.Findings. Though our data suggest that the students exposed to online education had slightly lower academic performance than the earlier cohort of similar students who studied in class, this result is not statistically significant. In fact, for both cohorts of students, their past academic performance reflecting their academic abilities and attitudes, such as university entry test score and past accumulative GPA, matter much more than the mode of study. However, we found out that certain technical variables which characterise the “quality” of Zoom® sessions affect students’ academic performance. Specifically, using a smartphone instead of a personal computer to enter a class conducted in Zoom® negatively affects students’ achievement. Some other characteristics also produce expected effects though they turned out to be statistically insignificant possibly due to aggregation and a small dataset.
- 30 March 2022
- Published by Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Public Administration and Civil Service
- No. 1(80),p. 169-182
Economic Returns to Skills in Kazakhstan in the context of international comparisons
The study examines the economic returns to literacy, numeracy and problem-solving skills in adults in Kazakhstan with the OECD data. Unlike in other countries, the returns to skills are neither economically nor statistically significant. This finding, however, is fully driven by the public sector of the economy, while in the private sector the skills significantly improve one’s earnings. The returns to formal education accounting for skills are comparable in public and private sectors. This likely causes the outflow of most productive workers to the private sector and question the efficiency of the public sector of the economy in Kazakhstan.
- 30 March 2022
- Published by Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Public Administration and Civil Service
- No. 1(80),p. 169-182
Economic Returns to Skills in Kazakhstan in the context of international comparisons
The study examines the economic returns to literacy, numeracy and problem-solving skills in adults in Kazakhstan with the OECD data. Unlike in other countries, the returns to skills are neither economically nor statistically significant. This finding, however, is fully driven by the public sector of the economy, while in the private sector the skills significantly improve one’s earnings. The returns to formal education accounting for skills are comparable in public and private sectors. This likely causes the outflow of most productive workers to the private sector and question the efficiency of the public sector of the economy in Kazakhstan.
- 22 September 2021
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Peace Economics, Peace Science and Public Policy
- Vol. 27 (4) , 549-566
Trade Sanctions and Customs Union Partners of the Target Country: Evidence from Kazakhstan
This paper analyses the effects of trade sanctions between Russia and Western countries on Kazakhstan. The nature of these sanctions is characterized by unilateral sanctions from Russia and multilateral sanctions against Russia. Although Kazakhstan refused to participate in these sanction wars, this might affect its economy significantly as it is highly integrated into the Russian economy. An empirical analysis is performed on the product level and time series techniques are used to estimate the effects of the sanctions. The paper assesses the overall effectiveness of trade sanctions through aggregating product level results into a sanction index. The derived sanction index shows that multilateral sanctions did not divert the trade flows from Western countries. On the other hand, the index indicates the existence of sanction busting activities against Russian unilateral counter-sanctions, confirming the hypothesis that unilateral sanctions are ineffective and allow for third-country effects.
- 22 September 2021
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Peace Economics, Peace Science and Public Policy
- Vol. 27 (4) , 549-566
Trade Sanctions and Customs Union Partners of the Target Country: Evidence from Kazakhstan
This paper analyses the effects of trade sanctions between Russia and Western countries on Kazakhstan. The nature of these sanctions is characterized by unilateral sanctions from Russia and multilateral sanctions against Russia. Although Kazakhstan refused to participate in these sanction wars, this might affect its economy significantly as it is highly integrated into the Russian economy. An empirical analysis is performed on the product level and time series techniques are used to estimate the effects of the sanctions. The paper assesses the overall effectiveness of trade sanctions through aggregating product level results into a sanction index. The derived sanction index shows that multilateral sanctions did not divert the trade flows from Western countries. On the other hand, the index indicates the existence of sanction busting activities against Russian unilateral counter-sanctions, confirming the hypothesis that unilateral sanctions are ineffective and allow for third-country effects.