Phil Kim
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Phil Kim has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Wonhyuk Cho
Department of Public Administration, Ewha Womans University, Seoul, Republic of Korea
3 shared publications - Daewook Kim
Chonnam National University, Gwangju, South Korea
1 shared publication - Hemin Choi
Incheon National University
1 shared publication In Yang
Seoul National University, Republic of Korea
1 shared publication- Jesse W. Campbell
Incheon National University, South Korea
1 shared publication Ran Kim
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 14 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Review of Public Personnel Administration
Halos, Performance Matching, and PSM: Experimental Evidence of Performance Appraisal Bias Among Korean Government Workers
Performance appraisal is a central human resource management tool in government, and high-quality, fair, and objective appraisals contribute to organizational performance. By contrast, biased performance appraisal undermines employee morale and, ultimately, the merit system. This study examines three sources of bias in performance evaluations: the halo effect, similarity-attraction factors between rater and rate, and public service motivation (PSM). Using a two-by-two vignette-based survey experiment and a large sample of Korean government workers, we confirm earlier findings on the biasing influence of unrelated information on performance ratings. Second, while we find no effect of gender matching, we show that raters who self-identify as high-performance employees give lower than average ratings to low-performance workers, thereby amplifying the halo effect. Finally, we find that PSM is associated with inflated performance ratings across genders and performance categories. We discuss how our results can inform efforts to improve the fairness and accuracy of employee performance appraisals.
- 14 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Review of Public Personnel Administration
Halos, Performance Matching, and PSM: Experimental Evidence of Performance Appraisal Bias Among Korean Government Workers
Performance appraisal is a central human resource management tool in government, and high-quality, fair, and objective appraisals contribute to organizational performance. By contrast, biased performance appraisal undermines employee morale and, ultimately, the merit system. This study examines three sources of bias in performance evaluations: the halo effect, similarity-attraction factors between rater and rate, and public service motivation (PSM). Using a two-by-two vignette-based survey experiment and a large sample of Korean government workers, we confirm earlier findings on the biasing influence of unrelated information on performance ratings. Second, while we find no effect of gender matching, we show that raters who self-identify as high-performance employees give lower than average ratings to low-performance workers, thereby amplifying the halo effect. Finally, we find that PSM is associated with inflated performance ratings across genders and performance categories. We discuss how our results can inform efforts to improve the fairness and accuracy of employee performance appraisals.
- 7 February 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Personnel Management
Serving the Greater Good With Less: Survey Experiment on How Public Service Motivation Shapes Perception of Staff Shortages
Personnel shortages are presenting significant challenges for many municipalities, as well-qualified civil servants in smaller cities and non-urban areas leave their positions. Given this dynamic, understanding how local government employees perceive staff shortages is key to designing effective strategies for promoting staff well-being and productivity. This article analyzes the influence of public service motivation (PSM) on shaping the perceptions of job demand and resources in local governments, through an experimental design ( n = 120) and a survey of local government employees ( n = 414), and further interprets the findings through semi-structured interviews. The experiment results show evidence of bi-directional effects—activating PSM heightened the perceived severity of staff burnout, while simultaneously lowering the perceived need for increased manpower. These findings suggest that PSM may raise an individual’s expectations of their job, which is possibly associated with feelings of frustration with current demands in local government. Conversely, the reduced perception of the need for additional manpower may show an increased sense of responsibility toward the job and willingness to overstretch for the local communities they serve. The employee survey results show that perceptions of the causes and solutions of staff shortages vary depending on their managerial rank, years of experience, and marital status.
- 7 February 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Personnel Management
Serving the Greater Good With Less: Survey Experiment on How Public Service Motivation Shapes Perception of Staff Shortages
Personnel shortages are presenting significant challenges for many municipalities, as well-qualified civil servants in smaller cities and non-urban areas leave their positions. Given this dynamic, understanding how local government employees perceive staff shortages is key to designing effective strategies for promoting staff well-being and productivity. This article analyzes the influence of public service motivation (PSM) on shaping the perceptions of job demand and resources in local governments, through an experimental design ( n = 120) and a survey of local government employees ( n = 414), and further interprets the findings through semi-structured interviews. The experiment results show evidence of bi-directional effects—activating PSM heightened the perceived severity of staff burnout, while simultaneously lowering the perceived need for increased manpower. These findings suggest that PSM may raise an individual’s expectations of their job, which is possibly associated with feelings of frustration with current demands in local government. Conversely, the reduced perception of the need for additional manpower may show an increased sense of responsibility toward the job and willingness to overstretch for the local communities they serve. The employee survey results show that perceptions of the causes and solutions of staff shortages vary depending on their managerial rank, years of experience, and marital status.
- Top Cited Papers
- 6 May 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Review of Public Personnel Administration
- Vol. 44 (1) , 86-115
Workplace Disruption in the Public Sector and HRM Practices to Enhance Employee Resilience
This article aims to analyze workplace dynamics in the public sector under highly disruptive environments. Survey data collected from 1,430 public employees in South Korea reveal that workload and work intensity have increased 13% to 15% on average compared to pre-pandemic conditions. Yet this impact on working conditions seems to be unevenly distributed across the public sector; the proportion of pandemic-affected workforce in each public organization ranged from 10% to 80%. More than 70% reported flexible work arrangements in place to alleviate the disruption, though less than 20% enjoyed access to occupational health and safety consultation to handle this change. We found that baby boomer men, who have the fewest family responsibilities, are most satisfied with flexible work arrangements, while millennial women, with the most domestic commitments, are least satisfied, leaving ample room for improvement. Results of a randomized survey experiment showed that resilience-enhancing Human Resource Management (HRM) practices such as special leave assistance programs influenced civil servants’ perceptions of workload and work intensity. Higher levels of satisfaction with resilience-enhancing HRM were found to be associated with lower levels of turnover intention, though this relationship was weaker among employees whose work became too intense or heavy (“numbing effect”) under the pandemic.
- 6 May 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Review of Public Personnel Administration
- Vol. 44 (1) , 86-115
Top Cited PapersWorkplace Disruption in the Public Sector and HRM Practices to Enhance Employee Resilience
This article aims to analyze workplace dynamics in the public sector under highly disruptive environments. Survey data collected from 1,430 public employees in South Korea reveal that workload and work intensity have increased 13% to 15% on average compared to pre-pandemic conditions. Yet this impact on working conditions seems to be unevenly distributed across the public sector; the proportion of pandemic-affected workforce in each public organization ranged from 10% to 80%. More than 70% reported flexible work arrangements in place to alleviate the disruption, though less than 20% enjoyed access to occupational health and safety consultation to handle this change. We found that baby boomer men, who have the fewest family responsibilities, are most satisfied with flexible work arrangements, while millennial women, with the most domestic commitments, are least satisfied, leaving ample room for improvement. Results of a randomized survey experiment showed that resilience-enhancing Human Resource Management (HRM) practices such as special leave assistance programs influenced civil servants’ perceptions of workload and work intensity. Higher levels of satisfaction with resilience-enhancing HRM were found to be associated with lower levels of turnover intention, though this relationship was weaker among employees whose work became too intense or heavy (“numbing effect”) under the pandemic.
- Open Access
- 31 March 2022
- Published by Graduate School of Public Administration, Seoul National University (GSPA) in Journal of Policy Studies
- Vol. 37 (1) , 27-43
Which Combinations of Human Resource Management and National Culture Optimize Government Effectiveness?
Despite the need for culturally-grounded public sector management practices, only a few studies have empirically investigated the compatibility between HRM practices and national culture. This study used fsQCA to investigate ‘bundles’ of HRM practices (recruitment, appraisal, and compensation) and Hofstede’s original four dimensions of national culture as antecedent conditions for government effectiveness in 30 OECD countries. We found that performance-based appraisal, compensation and informal recruitment form a causal relationship with high individualism and low uncertainty avoidance for stronger government effectiveness. The results imply that local national culture is an important context for the transferability of public management practices.
- 31 March 2022
- Published by Graduate School of Public Administration, Seoul National University (GSPA) in Journal of Policy Studies
- Vol. 37 (1) , 27-43
Open AccessWhich Combinations of Human Resource Management and National Culture Optimize Government Effectiveness?
Despite the need for culturally-grounded public sector management practices, only a few studies have empirically investigated the compatibility between HRM practices and national culture. This study used fsQCA to investigate ‘bundles’ of HRM practices (recruitment, appraisal, and compensation) and Hofstede’s original four dimensions of national culture as antecedent conditions for government effectiveness in 30 OECD countries. We found that performance-based appraisal, compensation and informal recruitment form a causal relationship with high individualism and low uncertainty avoidance for stronger government effectiveness. The results imply that local national culture is an important context for the transferability of public management practices.