Bangfan Liu
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Bangfan Liu has a total of 48 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Junjie Li
School of Public Administration, Yanshan University, Qinhuangdao 066004, China
12 shared publications - Xin Dai
Hebei Public Policy Evaluation and Research Center, Qinhuangdao 066004, China
8 shared publications - Meng Qi
School of Public Administration, Yanshan University, Qinhuangdao 066004, China
6 shared publications - Bei Zhang
Hebei Public Policy Evaluation and Research Center, Qinhuangdao 066004, China
5 shared publications - Xuehang Sun
School of Public Administration, Yanshan University, Qinhuangdao 066004, China
4 shared publications - Wenbo Ma
Teacher Education College of Jining University, Jining, China
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Retraction
- 31 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Optical and Quantum Electronics
- Vol. 58 (12) , 620
Retraction Note: Guided mode in LiF filled slab waveguide bounded by uniform plasma
- 31 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Optical and Quantum Electronics
- Vol. 58 (12) , 620
RetractionRetraction Note: Guided mode in LiF filled slab waveguide bounded by uniform plasma
- Open Access
- 8 September 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 18 (18) , 9234
Sustainable Development of Rural Cultural Construction Policies: An Integrated Analytical Framework of Policy Attention, Change and Evaluation
Rural cultural revitalization is the soul and endogenous driving force of comprehensive rural revitalization. The continuous optimization and effective implementation of the policy system serve as the core guarantee for promoting the sustainable development of rural cultural construction. Existing studies mostly conceptualize policy operation as a linear process, overlooking the dynamic closed-loop relationship among attention allocation, policy change, and effect evaluation, which results in fragmented policy implementation and insufficient sustainability. Accordingly, this study constructs an integrated analytical framework of “Attention–Change–Evaluation” for policy, incorporating policy attention (A), policy change (B), policy implementation (C), policy evaluation (D), and policy feedback (E) into a unified closed-loop system. It proposes H1–H14 hypothetical paths to reveal the multiple mechanisms through which attention influences effect evaluation via policy change, policy implementation, and their chained combinations. The findings indicate that the operation of rural cultural construction policies is not a unidirectional causal chain, but rather a periodic closed loop formed by the end-to-end connection of the main transmission chain (A→B→C→D) and the reverse feedback path (D→E→A). Policy attention jointly affects policy evaluation through both direct effects and indirect chained effects, driving the policy shift from one-off task fulfillment to continuous dynamic adjustment. The study suggests that establishing an effective linkage mechanism between policy feedback and attention reconfiguration is the key pathway to achieving sustainable development of rural cultural construction policies.
- 8 September 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 18 (18) , 9234
Open AccessSustainable Development of Rural Cultural Construction Policies: An Integrated Analytical Framework of Policy Attention, Change and Evaluation
Rural cultural revitalization is the soul and endogenous driving force of comprehensive rural revitalization. The continuous optimization and effective implementation of the policy system serve as the core guarantee for promoting the sustainable development of rural cultural construction. Existing studies mostly conceptualize policy operation as a linear process, overlooking the dynamic closed-loop relationship among attention allocation, policy change, and effect evaluation, which results in fragmented policy implementation and insufficient sustainability. Accordingly, this study constructs an integrated analytical framework of “Attention–Change–Evaluation” for policy, incorporating policy attention (A), policy change (B), policy implementation (C), policy evaluation (D), and policy feedback (E) into a unified closed-loop system. It proposes H1–H14 hypothetical paths to reveal the multiple mechanisms through which attention influences effect evaluation via policy change, policy implementation, and their chained combinations. The findings indicate that the operation of rural cultural construction policies is not a unidirectional causal chain, but rather a periodic closed loop formed by the end-to-end connection of the main transmission chain (A→B→C→D) and the reverse feedback path (D→E→A). Policy attention jointly affects policy evaluation through both direct effects and indirect chained effects, driving the policy shift from one-off task fulfillment to continuous dynamic adjustment. The study suggests that establishing an effective linkage mechanism between policy feedback and attention reconfiguration is the key pathway to achieving sustainable development of rural cultural construction policies.
- Open Access
- 25 February 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 18 (5) , 2192
How China’s Global Trade Expansion Shapes Transport-Sector CO2 Emissions: An Export-Driven Analytical Perspective
China’s export-oriented economic expansion has substantially influenced transport-sector CO2 emissions, raising critical concerns about the environmental impacts of sustained industrial growth and global trade integration. Understanding the interplay between macroeconomic dynamics, trade composition, and industrial structure is essential for aligning economic development with climate mitigation objectives. This study examines transport-related CO2 emissions in China over the period 1990–2023, employing a hybrid methodological framework that combines econometric modeling—including Autoregressive Distributed Lag (ARDL) bounds testing, Fully Modified Ordinary Least Squares (FMOLS), and Dynamic Ordinary Least Squares (DOLS)—with machine-learning techniques using Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) interpreted through SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP). The analysis confirms a long-run cointegration relationship between transport emissions and the selected macroeconomic variables. Short-run dynamics indicate a strong sensitivity of emissions to GDP growth, while long-run estimates reveal that higher export-to-GDP ratios and industrial value added contribute to reducing transport emissions, reflecting the efficiency gains from industrial upgrading and cleaner trade practices. By contrast, the expansion of medium- and high-technology exports increases emissions due to the energy- and logistics-intensive nature of high-value goods. The XGBoost model achieves high predictive performance, with an out-of-sample R2 of 0.9975 and a Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) of 87.16, confirming the dominant contribution of medium- and high-technology exports to transport-sector emissions. The results underscore the critical role of aligning trade structure, industrial productivity, and low-carbon logistics within China’s policy agenda. Implementing strategies that enhance industrial energy efficiency and develop sustainable transport infrastructure can substantially reduce the environmental impacts associated with export-driven economic expansion.
- 25 February 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 18 (5) , 2192
Open AccessHow China’s Global Trade Expansion Shapes Transport-Sector CO2 Emissions: An Export-Driven Analytical Perspective
China’s export-oriented economic expansion has substantially influenced transport-sector CO2 emissions, raising critical concerns about the environmental impacts of sustained industrial growth and global trade integration. Understanding the interplay between macroeconomic dynamics, trade composition, and industrial structure is essential for aligning economic development with climate mitigation objectives. This study examines transport-related CO2 emissions in China over the period 1990–2023, employing a hybrid methodological framework that combines econometric modeling—including Autoregressive Distributed Lag (ARDL) bounds testing, Fully Modified Ordinary Least Squares (FMOLS), and Dynamic Ordinary Least Squares (DOLS)—with machine-learning techniques using Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) interpreted through SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP). The analysis confirms a long-run cointegration relationship between transport emissions and the selected macroeconomic variables. Short-run dynamics indicate a strong sensitivity of emissions to GDP growth, while long-run estimates reveal that higher export-to-GDP ratios and industrial value added contribute to reducing transport emissions, reflecting the efficiency gains from industrial upgrading and cleaner trade practices. By contrast, the expansion of medium- and high-technology exports increases emissions due to the energy- and logistics-intensive nature of high-value goods. The XGBoost model achieves high predictive performance, with an out-of-sample R2 of 0.9975 and a Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) of 87.16, confirming the dominant contribution of medium- and high-technology exports to transport-sector emissions. The results underscore the critical role of aligning trade structure, industrial productivity, and low-carbon logistics within China’s policy agenda. Implementing strategies that enhance industrial energy efficiency and develop sustainable transport infrastructure can substantially reduce the environmental impacts associated with export-driven economic expansion.
- Open Access
- 9 February 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 18 (4) , 1756
Assessment of Urban Resilience and Spatiotemporal Patterns in Small and Medium-Sized Chinese Cities
Amid the compounded impacts of climate change, economic volatility, and sudden shocks, small and medium-sized cities (SMSCs) have become a critical yet frequently overlooked weak link in urban resilience research. Objective assessment of resilience in SMSCs is essential for improving the design and effectiveness of resilience-building policies. Following China’s official city-size classification criteria—i.e., using urban-district resident population as the statistical basis and defining SMSCs as cities with less than 1 million urban-district residents—this study examines 510 Chinese SMSCs from 2012 to 2023. An entropy-weighted Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) method is employed to construct an urban resilience index. Subsequently, spatiotemporal disparities are characterized using nonparametric kernel density estimation and Dagum Gini coefficient decomposition. The results indicate that: (1) from 2012 to 2023, the resilience index of Chinese SMSCs rose from 0.1108 to 0.1121, with an average annual growth rate of 0.1067%. Overall resilience remains low, and the increase is modest, showing a clear regional gradient of Eastern > Central > Western > Northeastern China. (2) Spatiotemporal differentiation reveals the fastest growth in the Eastern region, a similar trajectory in the Central region, slower growth in the Western region, and a decline in the Northeastern region, reinforcing a pattern of gradient divergence. Within-region disparities generally converged, whereas between-region disparities expanded markedly; nonetheless, the transvariation (overlapping) component remained the primary contributor to overall inequality. (3) The resilience of Chinese SMSCs may face a potential Matthew-effect risk driven by the interaction of scale disadvantage and regional disadvantage. These findings provide evidence to support policies aimed at enhancing resilience in SMSCs and inform the development of differentiated resilience-building strategies across regions.
- 9 February 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 18 (4) , 1756
Open AccessAssessment of Urban Resilience and Spatiotemporal Patterns in Small and Medium-Sized Chinese Cities
Amid the compounded impacts of climate change, economic volatility, and sudden shocks, small and medium-sized cities (SMSCs) have become a critical yet frequently overlooked weak link in urban resilience research. Objective assessment of resilience in SMSCs is essential for improving the design and effectiveness of resilience-building policies. Following China’s official city-size classification criteria—i.e., using urban-district resident population as the statistical basis and defining SMSCs as cities with less than 1 million urban-district residents—this study examines 510 Chinese SMSCs from 2012 to 2023. An entropy-weighted Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) method is employed to construct an urban resilience index. Subsequently, spatiotemporal disparities are characterized using nonparametric kernel density estimation and Dagum Gini coefficient decomposition. The results indicate that: (1) from 2012 to 2023, the resilience index of Chinese SMSCs rose from 0.1108 to 0.1121, with an average annual growth rate of 0.1067%. Overall resilience remains low, and the increase is modest, showing a clear regional gradient of Eastern > Central > Western > Northeastern China. (2) Spatiotemporal differentiation reveals the fastest growth in the Eastern region, a similar trajectory in the Central region, slower growth in the Western region, and a decline in the Northeastern region, reinforcing a pattern of gradient divergence. Within-region disparities generally converged, whereas between-region disparities expanded markedly; nonetheless, the transvariation (overlapping) component remained the primary contributor to overall inequality. (3) The resilience of Chinese SMSCs may face a potential Matthew-effect risk driven by the interaction of scale disadvantage and regional disadvantage. These findings provide evidence to support policies aimed at enhancing resilience in SMSCs and inform the development of differentiated resilience-building strategies across regions.
- Open Access
- 6 November 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 17 (21) , 9902
Coastal Wetland Conservation and Urban Sustainable Development Synergy Pathway Research: Insights from Qingdao and Weihai for Qinhuangdao
This study addresses the critical challenge of balancing coastal wetland conservation with urban sustainable development, a pivotal issue for ecological civilization in rapidly developing regions. Through an in-depth analysis of Qingdao and Weihai—exemplary cases in Shandong Province—this research systematically investigates mechanisms for achieving synergistic win–win outcomes. Employing a mixed-methods approach, including systems analysis to deconstruct governance frameworks, comparative case study to identify transferable strategies, and policy deduction to formulate actionable pathways, the study reveals how integrated approaches yield tangible results. Qingdao’s “Five Ocean Usages” concept and Weihai’s segmented coastal zoning have significantly improved key ecological metrics. By contrast, Qinhuangdao faces pronounced challenges, including degraded wetlands, spatial conflict between ports and core habitats, and underdeveloped synergistic governance. To address these, the study proposes a targeted strategy for Qinhuangdao, emphasizing a data-informed “wetland+” multi-format integration plan, the establishment of wetland mitigation banking and green finance instruments, digitally enabled public participation, and deeper policy alignment with national strategies such as Maritime Power. This research provides both a replicable analytical framework and practical guidance for coastal cities seeking to realize “development within protection and protection within development”.
- 6 November 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 17 (21) , 9902
Open AccessCoastal Wetland Conservation and Urban Sustainable Development Synergy Pathway Research: Insights from Qingdao and Weihai for Qinhuangdao
This study addresses the critical challenge of balancing coastal wetland conservation with urban sustainable development, a pivotal issue for ecological civilization in rapidly developing regions. Through an in-depth analysis of Qingdao and Weihai—exemplary cases in Shandong Province—this research systematically investigates mechanisms for achieving synergistic win–win outcomes. Employing a mixed-methods approach, including systems analysis to deconstruct governance frameworks, comparative case study to identify transferable strategies, and policy deduction to formulate actionable pathways, the study reveals how integrated approaches yield tangible results. Qingdao’s “Five Ocean Usages” concept and Weihai’s segmented coastal zoning have significantly improved key ecological metrics. By contrast, Qinhuangdao faces pronounced challenges, including degraded wetlands, spatial conflict between ports and core habitats, and underdeveloped synergistic governance. To address these, the study proposes a targeted strategy for Qinhuangdao, emphasizing a data-informed “wetland+” multi-format integration plan, the establishment of wetland mitigation banking and green finance instruments, digitally enabled public participation, and deeper policy alignment with national strategies such as Maritime Power. This research provides both a replicable analytical framework and practical guidance for coastal cities seeking to realize “development within protection and protection within development”.
- Open Access
- 25 September 2025
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Marine Science
- Vol. 12, 1671987
Research on the dynamic evolution and differential analysis of the development efficiency of China’s marine economic circles
This study focuses on the economic development efficiency of China’s three major marine economic zones, aiming to explore their dynamic evolution rules and regional disparity characteristics, thereby providing theoretical foundations and practical guidance for promoting sustainable marine economic development. Based on panel data from 11 coastal provinces in China (2012-2021), the research employs a three-stage super-efficient slack-based measure (SBM) model with undesirable outputs to measure marine economic development efficiency Additionally, it uses Dagum Gini coefficient decomposition method to systematically investigate regional disparities and their sources, and applies the kernel density estimation to analyze dynamic evolutionary characteristics. The study reveals three key findings: First, compared with the first stage, the measured marine economic development efficiency of China in the third stage generally increases, yet the rankings of provinces change to varying degrees. Second, it exhibits significant “polarization effects” among the three marine economic zones, each displaying distinct developmental patterns and distribution characteristics. Third, there is substantial spatial disequilibrium across the zones, with inter - regional differences constituting the primary source of developmental imbalances. These findings not only clarify the spatial configuration characteristics of China’s marine economic development but also provide crucial evidence for devising differentiated regional development policies.
- 25 September 2025
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Marine Science
- Vol. 12, 1671987
Open AccessResearch on the dynamic evolution and differential analysis of the development efficiency of China’s marine economic circles
This study focuses on the economic development efficiency of China’s three major marine economic zones, aiming to explore their dynamic evolution rules and regional disparity characteristics, thereby providing theoretical foundations and practical guidance for promoting sustainable marine economic development. Based on panel data from 11 coastal provinces in China (2012-2021), the research employs a three-stage super-efficient slack-based measure (SBM) model with undesirable outputs to measure marine economic development efficiency Additionally, it uses Dagum Gini coefficient decomposition method to systematically investigate regional disparities and their sources, and applies the kernel density estimation to analyze dynamic evolutionary characteristics. The study reveals three key findings: First, compared with the first stage, the measured marine economic development efficiency of China in the third stage generally increases, yet the rankings of provinces change to varying degrees. Second, it exhibits significant “polarization effects” among the three marine economic zones, each displaying distinct developmental patterns and distribution characteristics. Third, there is substantial spatial disequilibrium across the zones, with inter - regional differences constituting the primary source of developmental imbalances. These findings not only clarify the spatial configuration characteristics of China’s marine economic development but also provide crucial evidence for devising differentiated regional development policies.
- Retracted
- 16 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Optical and Quantum Electronics
- Vol. 57 (6) , 1-10
RETRACTED ARTICLE: Guided mode in LiF filled slab waveguide bounded by uniform plasma
- 16 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Optical and Quantum Electronics
- Vol. 57 (6) , 1-10
RetractedRETRACTED ARTICLE: Guided mode in LiF filled slab waveguide bounded by uniform plasma
- Open Access
- 13 March 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 17 (6) , 2517
How to Form the Rural Digital Governance Platform—Under the Framework of Mixed-Scanning–Multiple Streams—Based on an Empirical Investigation of the Platform of “JuHaoban” in Julu County, Hebei Province
The rural digital governance platform is closely related to rural sustainable development. By playing the role of the rural digital governance platform, it can optimize the allocation of rural resources, improve the efficiency of rural governance, promote the development of rural industries, improve the quality of life of rural residents, promote the inheritance and innovation of rural culture, and provide a strong guarantee for the sustainable development of rural areas. Through the continuous advancement of the rural digital governance platform, it is anticipated to achieve the modernization of rural governance, promote industrial prosperity, optimize public services, encourage talent return, and foster cultural inheritance and innovation. This will provide a robust foundation for the implementation of the rural revitalization strategy. Guided by the “digital village” strategy, digital platforms serve as pivotal vehicles for the transformation of rural digital governance. Taking the policymaking process facilitated by the “JuHaoban” platform as a case study, this paper integrates theoretical frameworks with practical applications to construct a “Mixed-Scanning–Multiple-Stream” framework. This framework elucidates the policy innovation process at the local-decision-making level under the influence of the central strategy. The findings indicate that the problem stream can be generated through both proactive scanning and reactive response mechanisms, which can operate concurrently. Decision makers at various levels function as policy entrepreneurs, leading the policymaking community, and the policy window can open either opportunistically or continuously, driven by these decision makers. The policy establishment process of Julu County’s “JuHaoban” platform exemplifies an “up-and-down” dynamic, primarily influenced by political streams. By proactively identifying social issues and responding to emergencies, county-level decision makers implement policy innovations in alignment with the “digital village” strategy. The “Mixed-Scanning–Multiple-Stream” framework provides substantial explanatory power regarding local policy innovation processes within central–local interactions. The conclusions and recommendations offer significant policymaking implications for the development of rural digital governance platforms.
- 13 March 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 17 (6) , 2517
Open AccessHow to Form the Rural Digital Governance Platform—Under the Framework of Mixed-Scanning–Multiple Streams—Based on an Empirical Investigation of the Platform of “JuHaoban” in Julu County, Hebei Province
The rural digital governance platform is closely related to rural sustainable development. By playing the role of the rural digital governance platform, it can optimize the allocation of rural resources, improve the efficiency of rural governance, promote the development of rural industries, improve the quality of life of rural residents, promote the inheritance and innovation of rural culture, and provide a strong guarantee for the sustainable development of rural areas. Through the continuous advancement of the rural digital governance platform, it is anticipated to achieve the modernization of rural governance, promote industrial prosperity, optimize public services, encourage talent return, and foster cultural inheritance and innovation. This will provide a robust foundation for the implementation of the rural revitalization strategy. Guided by the “digital village” strategy, digital platforms serve as pivotal vehicles for the transformation of rural digital governance. Taking the policymaking process facilitated by the “JuHaoban” platform as a case study, this paper integrates theoretical frameworks with practical applications to construct a “Mixed-Scanning–Multiple-Stream” framework. This framework elucidates the policy innovation process at the local-decision-making level under the influence of the central strategy. The findings indicate that the problem stream can be generated through both proactive scanning and reactive response mechanisms, which can operate concurrently. Decision makers at various levels function as policy entrepreneurs, leading the policymaking community, and the policy window can open either opportunistically or continuously, driven by these decision makers. The policy establishment process of Julu County’s “JuHaoban” platform exemplifies an “up-and-down” dynamic, primarily influenced by political streams. By proactively identifying social issues and responding to emergencies, county-level decision makers implement policy innovations in alignment with the “digital village” strategy. The “Mixed-Scanning–Multiple-Stream” framework provides substantial explanatory power regarding local policy innovation processes within central–local interactions. The conclusions and recommendations offer significant policymaking implications for the development of rural digital governance platforms.
- Open Access
- 31 May 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (5) , e0301828
Trade shocks and trade diversion due to epidemic diseases: Evidence from 110 countries
COVID-19 has been a massive trade shock that has disrupted global trade, making the last few years a special phase. Even during normal times, epidemic diseases have acted as trade shocks in specific countries, albeit not to the same extent as COVID-19. For some trade shocks, the situation normalizes after the disease transmission is over; for some, it does not. Thus, specific countries can sometimes lose their original trade ratio due to trade diversion; that is, an epidemic disease could lead to unexpected industry restructuring. To examine this, based on data on 110 WHO members from 1996 to 2018, we use a fixed-effect panel model supported by the Hausman Test to empirically identify whether epidemic diseases can cause trade shocks and trade diversion. We find: First, epidemic disease can lead to negative shocks to a country’s trade growth and its ratio of worldwide trade. Second, with a longer epidemic, the probability of the trade diversion effect increases. Our results hold even after considering country heterogeneity. This presents a considerable concern about the shock of COVID-19 lasting further. Many countries are not just facing the problem of temporary trade shocks, but also the challenge of trade diversions. In particular, the probability of trade diversions is increasing rapidly, especially for late-developed countries due to their lack of epidemic containment and vaccine-producing capabilities. Even middle and high income countries cannot ignore global industry chain restructuring. Forward-looking policies should be implemented in advance; it may be too late when long-term trade damage is shown.
- 31 May 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (5) , e0301828
Open AccessTrade shocks and trade diversion due to epidemic diseases: Evidence from 110 countries
COVID-19 has been a massive trade shock that has disrupted global trade, making the last few years a special phase. Even during normal times, epidemic diseases have acted as trade shocks in specific countries, albeit not to the same extent as COVID-19. For some trade shocks, the situation normalizes after the disease transmission is over; for some, it does not. Thus, specific countries can sometimes lose their original trade ratio due to trade diversion; that is, an epidemic disease could lead to unexpected industry restructuring. To examine this, based on data on 110 WHO members from 1996 to 2018, we use a fixed-effect panel model supported by the Hausman Test to empirically identify whether epidemic diseases can cause trade shocks and trade diversion. We find: First, epidemic disease can lead to negative shocks to a country’s trade growth and its ratio of worldwide trade. Second, with a longer epidemic, the probability of the trade diversion effect increases. Our results hold even after considering country heterogeneity. This presents a considerable concern about the shock of COVID-19 lasting further. Many countries are not just facing the problem of temporary trade shocks, but also the challenge of trade diversions. In particular, the probability of trade diversions is increasing rapidly, especially for late-developed countries due to their lack of epidemic containment and vaccine-producing capabilities. Even middle and high income countries cannot ignore global industry chain restructuring. Forward-looking policies should be implemented in advance; it may be too late when long-term trade damage is shown.
- Open Access
- 18 April 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (4) , e0301667
Research on the generative logic and configuration effects of the policy implementation environment in China’s grassroots digital construction: Traceability based on grounded theory and the validation of the csQCA method
Using NVivo12plus software, this study constructs a generation model of the policy implementation environment in China’s grassroots digital construction by examining the data from interviews with 37 Chinese grassroots civil servants as its research object. At the same time, with the help of the csQCA method and on the basis of rooted coding, using Tosmana software, the model validation and model expansion of 37 cases were carried out. This study shows that the main components of the policy implementation environment in China’s grassroots digital construction include five main dimensions: cognitive, emotional, behavioral, normative and control. At the initial stage of China’s grassroots digital construction, the cognitive environment dimension is the most critical link in the environmental governance of policy implementation. The cognitive and normative environments dominate the effect pattern of China’s grassroots digital policy implementation. There are six types of motivation patterns for the environmental effect of the implementation of grassroots digital policy: know-doing-norm, cognitive-dominant, know-doing-control, emotion-control, behavior-lacking and regulation-dominant types. Based on the above analysis, there are three main policy suggestions to promote the generation of a productive policy implementation environment and positive policy effects in China’s digital construction: "degree", "force" and "sense". These suggestions include strengthening the top-level design, improving the integration and cooperation degree of the environment, taking the root at the grassroots level to improve the adaptability of the environment, as well as increasing publicity and promotion to improve the sense of environmental experience.
- 18 April 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (4) , e0301667
Open AccessResearch on the generative logic and configuration effects of the policy implementation environment in China’s grassroots digital construction: Traceability based on grounded theory and the validation of the csQCA method
Using NVivo12plus software, this study constructs a generation model of the policy implementation environment in China’s grassroots digital construction by examining the data from interviews with 37 Chinese grassroots civil servants as its research object. At the same time, with the help of the csQCA method and on the basis of rooted coding, using Tosmana software, the model validation and model expansion of 37 cases were carried out. This study shows that the main components of the policy implementation environment in China’s grassroots digital construction include five main dimensions: cognitive, emotional, behavioral, normative and control. At the initial stage of China’s grassroots digital construction, the cognitive environment dimension is the most critical link in the environmental governance of policy implementation. The cognitive and normative environments dominate the effect pattern of China’s grassroots digital policy implementation. There are six types of motivation patterns for the environmental effect of the implementation of grassroots digital policy: know-doing-norm, cognitive-dominant, know-doing-control, emotion-control, behavior-lacking and regulation-dominant types. Based on the above analysis, there are three main policy suggestions to promote the generation of a productive policy implementation environment and positive policy effects in China’s digital construction: "degree", "force" and "sense". These suggestions include strengthening the top-level design, improving the integration and cooperation degree of the environment, taking the root at the grassroots level to improve the adaptability of the environment, as well as increasing publicity and promotion to improve the sense of environmental experience.