Anish Kirtane
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Anish Kirtane has a total of 33 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Kristy Deiner
ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
7 shared publications - Enrico van der Loo
Institute of Biogeochemistry and Pollutant Dynamics, Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule Zürich Zürich Switzerland
2 shared publications Hannah Kleyer
Institute of Biogeochemistry and Pollutant Dynamics Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule Zürich Zürich Switzerland
2 shared publications- Zora Doppmann
Institute of Biogeochemistry and Pollutant Dynamics, Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule Zürich Zürich Switzerland
2 shared publications - Alex R. Hall
Department of Environmental Systems Science, Institute of Integrative Biology, ETH Zurich, Zurich 8092, Switzerland
1 shared publication - Alexandra Anh-Thu Weber
Department of Aquatic Ecology, Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology (EAWAG), Dübendorf, Switzerland
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Stream–lake network position structures freshwater microbial communities across multiple catchments
Streams and lakes form hydrologically connected freshwater networks. Different environmental conditions and dispersal dynamics along the stream–lake continuum potentially affect bacterial community composition, although the strength of such effects may vary among individual catchments. Here, we analysed 224 water samples from 58 streams draining into eight lakes across Switzerland, covering the full continuum from headwaters to lake outlets. Bacterial community composition analyzed via 16S metabarcoding differed between streams and lakes, with a sharp turnover at stream-lake confluence, and this pattern was repeatable across all catchments. Lake communities had lower alpha diversity and lower overall beta dispersion than stream communities, despite hydrological connectivity with a diverse stream microbiome. Community composition in both lakes and streams differed between catchments, but this pattern was more pronounced in lakes. Lake communities were dominated by a small set of widespread and abundant core taxa, primarily established pelagic freshwater genera, that captured the catchment-level differences through shifts in relative abundance. In contrast, stream communities contained a comparatively less abundant core microbiome dominated by soil- and groundwater-associated genera, together with a larger and more diverse peripheral microbiome. Together, these findings show that bacterial community composition changes repeatably across the different positions of hydrological networks.
Open AccessStream–lake network position structures freshwater microbial communities across multiple catchments
Streams and lakes form hydrologically connected freshwater networks. Different environmental conditions and dispersal dynamics along the stream–lake continuum potentially affect bacterial community composition, although the strength of such effects may vary among individual catchments. Here, we analysed 224 water samples from 58 streams draining into eight lakes across Switzerland, covering the full continuum from headwaters to lake outlets. Bacterial community composition analyzed via 16S metabarcoding differed between streams and lakes, with a sharp turnover at stream-lake confluence, and this pattern was repeatable across all catchments. Lake communities had lower alpha diversity and lower overall beta dispersion than stream communities, despite hydrological connectivity with a diverse stream microbiome. Community composition in both lakes and streams differed between catchments, but this pattern was more pronounced in lakes. Lake communities were dominated by a small set of widespread and abundant core taxa, primarily established pelagic freshwater genera, that captured the catchment-level differences through shifts in relative abundance. In contrast, stream communities contained a comparatively less abundant core microbiome dominated by soil- and groundwater-associated genera, together with a larger and more diverse peripheral microbiome. Together, these findings show that bacterial community composition changes repeatably across the different positions of hydrological networks.
- Open Access
- 28 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology Resources
- Vol. 26 (7)
Distinct Environmental DNA States Reveal Biodiversity and Transport Patterns Across Alpine Watersheds
Environmental DNA (eDNA) exists in three states: membrane‐bound, adsorbed and dissolved. These states differ in persistence and degradation, strongly influencing the interpretation of eDNA data. Despite this, they have rarely been separated and analyzed independently from environmental samples. We developed a state‐sorting workflow to isolate and analyze them, applying it to samples from 221 sites from 58 streams across eight lake watersheds with COI and ITS metabarcoding, targeting metazoans and plants, respectively, to reveal differences in biodiversity content and transport dynamics. Our results show that all three states contain both shared and unique taxonomic diversity of metazoan eDNA. However, the plant eDNA was only detected in the membrane‐bound state. For metazoans, membrane‐bound eDNA contained 87.8% of observed ASVs, far exceeding the adsorbed (37.2%) and dissolved (20.5%) states. Only membrane‐bound eDNA showed evidence of downstream transport, but its extent varied among watersheds due to local hydrology. While upstream eDNA was transported to stream–lake confluences, lake surface samples showed a turnover in community composition. Clarifying the fate of membrane‐bound eDNA within lakes will enhance catchment‐level detection from lake samples and understanding of lake hydrodynamics. Of the environmental parameters assessed, water temperature was most strongly aligned with changes in community composition between sites. Most previous studies have likely captured the majority of the eDNA diversity within their samples by inadvertently targeting the membrane‐bound state. This study demonstrates the utility of eDNA state‐sorting, but the methods require further refinement. Analyzing states independently improves the interpretation of eDNA data and elucidates the processes governing eDNA fate and transport.
- 28 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology Resources
- Vol. 26 (7)
Open AccessDistinct Environmental DNA States Reveal Biodiversity and Transport Patterns Across Alpine Watersheds
Environmental DNA (eDNA) exists in three states: membrane‐bound, adsorbed and dissolved. These states differ in persistence and degradation, strongly influencing the interpretation of eDNA data. Despite this, they have rarely been separated and analyzed independently from environmental samples. We developed a state‐sorting workflow to isolate and analyze them, applying it to samples from 221 sites from 58 streams across eight lake watersheds with COI and ITS metabarcoding, targeting metazoans and plants, respectively, to reveal differences in biodiversity content and transport dynamics. Our results show that all three states contain both shared and unique taxonomic diversity of metazoan eDNA. However, the plant eDNA was only detected in the membrane‐bound state. For metazoans, membrane‐bound eDNA contained 87.8% of observed ASVs, far exceeding the adsorbed (37.2%) and dissolved (20.5%) states. Only membrane‐bound eDNA showed evidence of downstream transport, but its extent varied among watersheds due to local hydrology. While upstream eDNA was transported to stream–lake confluences, lake surface samples showed a turnover in community composition. Clarifying the fate of membrane‐bound eDNA within lakes will enhance catchment‐level detection from lake samples and understanding of lake hydrodynamics. Of the environmental parameters assessed, water temperature was most strongly aligned with changes in community composition between sites. Most previous studies have likely captured the majority of the eDNA diversity within their samples by inadvertently targeting the membrane‐bound state. This study demonstrates the utility of eDNA state‐sorting, but the methods require further refinement. Analyzing states independently improves the interpretation of eDNA data and elucidates the processes governing eDNA fate and transport.
- Open Access
Mechanistic assessment of eDNA passive samplers: a case study with invasive freshwater bivalves
Passive sampling is the deployment of a collection material in the environment to continuously capture environmental DNA (eDNA) over time, offering the potential to integrate biodiversity signals while reducing the need for repeated active water collection. However, the mechanisms governing eDNA capture and retention on passive samplers remain poorly understood, limiting the interpretation of passive eDNA signals and their broader application. Here, we investigated the mechanistic performance of glass fibre passive samplers using controlled mesocosm experiments with three invasive freshwater bivalves: zebra mussels ( Dreissena polymorpha ), quagga mussels ( Dreissena bugensis ), and Asian clams ( Corbicula fluminea ). Specifically, we quantified eDNA accumulation dynamics, evaluated the contribution of different eDNA states, tested the persistence of captured eDNA, and compared passive sampler signals with conventional active sampling. Passive samplers rapidly accumulated target eDNA within hours of deployment, after which concentrations either plateaued or continued to increase depending on species. Sequential transfer of passive samplers between mesocosms containing different species showed that previously captured eDNA declined while new target eDNA accumulated to concentrations comparable to freshly deployed samplers, demonstrating continual turnover rather than permanent retention. Dissolved eDNA showed little evidence of accumulation beyond the concentration retained in the pore water within the membrane, suggesting that it is unlikely to be the dominant contributor to long-term passive sampler signals. Instead, the observed variability among replicate samplers, together with the physical properties of glass fibre membranes, suggests that membrane-bound and particulate eDNA are the primary contributors to passive eDNA capture. Collectively, these findings support a model in which glass fibre passive sampler signals reflect a dynamic equilibrium between ongoing eDNA capture and concurrent loss processes rather than cumulative accumulation over time. This mechanistic framework provides a foundation for interpreting passive eDNA data and informs the future development of passive sampling materials, deployment strategies, and biodiversity monitoring applications.
Open AccessMechanistic assessment of eDNA passive samplers: a case study with invasive freshwater bivalves
Passive sampling is the deployment of a collection material in the environment to continuously capture environmental DNA (eDNA) over time, offering the potential to integrate biodiversity signals while reducing the need for repeated active water collection. However, the mechanisms governing eDNA capture and retention on passive samplers remain poorly understood, limiting the interpretation of passive eDNA signals and their broader application. Here, we investigated the mechanistic performance of glass fibre passive samplers using controlled mesocosm experiments with three invasive freshwater bivalves: zebra mussels ( Dreissena polymorpha ), quagga mussels ( Dreissena bugensis ), and Asian clams ( Corbicula fluminea ). Specifically, we quantified eDNA accumulation dynamics, evaluated the contribution of different eDNA states, tested the persistence of captured eDNA, and compared passive sampler signals with conventional active sampling. Passive samplers rapidly accumulated target eDNA within hours of deployment, after which concentrations either plateaued or continued to increase depending on species. Sequential transfer of passive samplers between mesocosms containing different species showed that previously captured eDNA declined while new target eDNA accumulated to concentrations comparable to freshly deployed samplers, demonstrating continual turnover rather than permanent retention. Dissolved eDNA showed little evidence of accumulation beyond the concentration retained in the pore water within the membrane, suggesting that it is unlikely to be the dominant contributor to long-term passive sampler signals. Instead, the observed variability among replicate samplers, together with the physical properties of glass fibre membranes, suggests that membrane-bound and particulate eDNA are the primary contributors to passive eDNA capture. Collectively, these findings support a model in which glass fibre passive sampler signals reflect a dynamic equilibrium between ongoing eDNA capture and concurrent loss processes rather than cumulative accumulation over time. This mechanistic framework provides a foundation for interpreting passive eDNA data and informs the future development of passive sampling materials, deployment strategies, and biodiversity monitoring applications.
- Open Access
Sorting States of Environmental DNA Reveals State-Specific Biodiversity Signals and Transport Patterns in Eight Alpine Watersheds
Environmental DNA (eDNA) exists in three states: membrane bound, adsorbed, and dissolved. These states differ in persistence and degradation, strongly influencing the interpretation of eDNA data. Despite this, they have rarely been separated and analyzed independently from environmental samples. We developed a state sorting workflow to isolate and analyze them, applying it to samples from 221 sites from 58 streams across eight lake watersheds with COI and ITS metabarcoding to reveal differences in biodiversity content and transport dynamics. Our results show that all three states contain both shared and unique taxonomic diversity for COI, and that plant DNA was only detected in the membrane bound state. For COI, membrane bound eDNA contained 87.8% of observed ASVs, far exceeding the adsorbed (37.2%) and dissolved (20.5%) states. Only membrane bound eDNA showed evidence of downstream transport, but its extent varied among watersheds due to local hydrology. While upstream eDNA was transported to stream lake confluences, lake surface samples showed marked turnover in community composition. Clarifying the fate of membrane bound eDNA within lakes will enhance catchment level detection from lake samples and understanding of lake hydrodynamics. Of the environmental parameters assessed, water temperature was most strongly aligned with changes in community composition between sites. Most previous studies have likely captured the majority of the eDNA diversity within their samples by inadvertently targeting the membrane-bound state. This study demonstrates the utility of eDNA state sorting, but the methods require further refinement. Analyzing states independently improves the interpretation of eDNA data and elucidates the processes governing eDNA fate and transport.
Open AccessSorting States of Environmental DNA Reveals State-Specific Biodiversity Signals and Transport Patterns in Eight Alpine Watersheds
Environmental DNA (eDNA) exists in three states: membrane bound, adsorbed, and dissolved. These states differ in persistence and degradation, strongly influencing the interpretation of eDNA data. Despite this, they have rarely been separated and analyzed independently from environmental samples. We developed a state sorting workflow to isolate and analyze them, applying it to samples from 221 sites from 58 streams across eight lake watersheds with COI and ITS metabarcoding to reveal differences in biodiversity content and transport dynamics. Our results show that all three states contain both shared and unique taxonomic diversity for COI, and that plant DNA was only detected in the membrane bound state. For COI, membrane bound eDNA contained 87.8% of observed ASVs, far exceeding the adsorbed (37.2%) and dissolved (20.5%) states. Only membrane bound eDNA showed evidence of downstream transport, but its extent varied among watersheds due to local hydrology. While upstream eDNA was transported to stream lake confluences, lake surface samples showed marked turnover in community composition. Clarifying the fate of membrane bound eDNA within lakes will enhance catchment level detection from lake samples and understanding of lake hydrodynamics. Of the environmental parameters assessed, water temperature was most strongly aligned with changes in community composition between sites. Most previous studies have likely captured the majority of the eDNA diversity within their samples by inadvertently targeting the membrane-bound state. This study demonstrates the utility of eDNA state sorting, but the methods require further refinement. Analyzing states independently improves the interpretation of eDNA data and elucidates the processes governing eDNA fate and transport.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
From Fragments to Flow: Decoding eDNA States to Illuminate Hydrologic Processes
Environmental DNA (eDNA) analysis for rapid non-invasive species detection across the tree of life. Once the eDNA is released into the environment it can move through a landscape, aggregating as waterways converge. Thus, hydrological knowledge of a landscape benefits the interpretation of eDNA data. Simultaneously, eDNA may be utilized as a natural hydrologic tracer. To fully utilize eDNA as a tracer molecule, the ecology of eDNA i.e. its production, degradation, and transport have to be well understood. However, eDNA itself is a complex mixture comprising of different states, namely membrane-bound, dissolved, and adsorbed states with varying persistence times and transport potentials.In this presentation, I will provide an overview of eDNA states, how they are formed and what we know about them. Then I will explore methods for sorting these eDNA states from a single sample. Lastly, I will show data from large study spanning eight lake watersheds comprising samples collected from 221 sites collected from the headwaters to lakes of 58 streams in eight Swiss watersheds. All the samples were state sorted and analyzed with board range metabarcoding assays for identifying metazoan diversity. The results show that while most biodiversity information is enveloped in the membrane-bound state, each eDNA state has a district diversity signature. Our results show that the metazoan diversity signals remain closely linked for samples within a given stream, they diverge significantly once the stream enters a lake, highlighting the use of natural eDNA input to track water movement.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessFrom Fragments to Flow: Decoding eDNA States to Illuminate Hydrologic Processes
Environmental DNA (eDNA) analysis for rapid non-invasive species detection across the tree of life. Once the eDNA is released into the environment it can move through a landscape, aggregating as waterways converge. Thus, hydrological knowledge of a landscape benefits the interpretation of eDNA data. Simultaneously, eDNA may be utilized as a natural hydrologic tracer. To fully utilize eDNA as a tracer molecule, the ecology of eDNA i.e. its production, degradation, and transport have to be well understood. However, eDNA itself is a complex mixture comprising of different states, namely membrane-bound, dissolved, and adsorbed states with varying persistence times and transport potentials.In this presentation, I will provide an overview of eDNA states, how they are formed and what we know about them. Then I will explore methods for sorting these eDNA states from a single sample. Lastly, I will show data from large study spanning eight lake watersheds comprising samples collected from 221 sites collected from the headwaters to lakes of 58 streams in eight Swiss watersheds. All the samples were state sorted and analyzed with board range metabarcoding assays for identifying metazoan diversity. The results show that while most biodiversity information is enveloped in the membrane-bound state, each eDNA state has a district diversity signature. Our results show that the metazoan diversity signals remain closely linked for samples within a given stream, they diverge significantly once the stream enters a lake, highlighting the use of natural eDNA input to track water movement.
- Open Access
- 15 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Consideration of eDNA states to analyze bulk soil samples via metabarcoding
Environmental DNA (eDNA) analysis can facilitate biodiversity monitoring within a bulk sample, especially valuable to evaluate soil ecosystems. eDNA can persist in soil as living cells, dead cells, and extracellular DNA either as free or adsorbed to particles in the soil. Each of these ‘states’ of eDNA can have differing persistence times from a few days to hundreds of years. Better understanding to target and isolate particular states of eDNA is imperative to derive valuable information, for instance, recent occupancy indicated by freshly released eDNA or eDNA within living cells.This presentation will present cases showing the variability of eDNA persistence in different states with a focus on the adsorbed state. I will then discuss the adsorption mechanism of eDNA and introduce novel methods of isolating the states of eDNA from a single sample for independent analysis. Lastly, I will show data from a landscape level study with water samples collected from 221 sites from 58 streams in eight Swiss watersheds. All the samples were state sorted and analyzed with board range metabarcoding assays for identifying metazoan diversity. The results show that each state consists of unique diversity information and state sorting methodologies should be considered when processing bulk soil samples for eDNA analysis. While this presentation will have some studies using water samples, they elucidate the behavior of eDNA bound to soil and sediment particles as well.
- 15 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessConsideration of eDNA states to analyze bulk soil samples via metabarcoding
Environmental DNA (eDNA) analysis can facilitate biodiversity monitoring within a bulk sample, especially valuable to evaluate soil ecosystems. eDNA can persist in soil as living cells, dead cells, and extracellular DNA either as free or adsorbed to particles in the soil. Each of these ‘states’ of eDNA can have differing persistence times from a few days to hundreds of years. Better understanding to target and isolate particular states of eDNA is imperative to derive valuable information, for instance, recent occupancy indicated by freshly released eDNA or eDNA within living cells.This presentation will present cases showing the variability of eDNA persistence in different states with a focus on the adsorbed state. I will then discuss the adsorption mechanism of eDNA and introduce novel methods of isolating the states of eDNA from a single sample for independent analysis. Lastly, I will show data from a landscape level study with water samples collected from 221 sites from 58 streams in eight Swiss watersheds. All the samples were state sorted and analyzed with board range metabarcoding assays for identifying metazoan diversity. The results show that each state consists of unique diversity information and state sorting methodologies should be considered when processing bulk soil samples for eDNA analysis. While this presentation will have some studies using water samples, they elucidate the behavior of eDNA bound to soil and sediment particles as well.
- Open Access
- 1 November 2024
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 6 (6)
How, What, and Where You Sample Environmental DNA Affects Diversity Estimates and Species Detection
Environmental DNA (eDNA) is a complex mixture of DNA, varying in particle sizes and distributed heterogeneously in aquatic systems. Optimizing eDNA sampling is crucial for maximizing species detection, particularly in high‐risk scenarios like invasive species management. In this study, we compare two eDNA sampling methods ‐ namely tow net and grab sample, where the tow nets process large volumes of water (3500–7000 L) through a 64 μm pore size and the grab samples process 1 L sample at a single point through 0.45–1.2 μm pore size membranes. We compared these methods to ascertain what most influences (1) the detection of invasive species (Dreissena mussels and Burmese pythons) using qPCR or ddPCR and (2) total diversity monitoring of metazoan, protist, and fungi community using a COI marker and plant communities using the ITS marker. Sampling was conducted across a wide geography and diverse aquatic environments in Minnesota and Florida, USA, and Switzerland. The tow net samples had significantly higher eDNA yield compared to grab samples; however, they exhibited equal or lower alpha diversity of OTUs (Operational Taxonomic Units). The two sampling methods measured different beta diversity of communities detected with the COI marker across all three regions, highlighting the impact of the sampling method on the diversity of eDNA captured. In comparison, the beta diversity of plant eDNA was less impacted by the sampling method. We found no clear difference in detection for the invasive species targets based on the eDNA sampling method. These results underscore the need for pilot studies before conducting biodiversity inventory and monitoring, and a need for a greater understanding of not just how much, but also what, eDNA is captured depending on method choice, considering both spatial and particle size heterogeneity.
- 1 November 2024
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 6 (6)
Open AccessHow, What, and Where You Sample Environmental DNA Affects Diversity Estimates and Species Detection
Environmental DNA (eDNA) is a complex mixture of DNA, varying in particle sizes and distributed heterogeneously in aquatic systems. Optimizing eDNA sampling is crucial for maximizing species detection, particularly in high‐risk scenarios like invasive species management. In this study, we compare two eDNA sampling methods ‐ namely tow net and grab sample, where the tow nets process large volumes of water (3500–7000 L) through a 64 μm pore size and the grab samples process 1 L sample at a single point through 0.45–1.2 μm pore size membranes. We compared these methods to ascertain what most influences (1) the detection of invasive species (Dreissena mussels and Burmese pythons) using qPCR or ddPCR and (2) total diversity monitoring of metazoan, protist, and fungi community using a COI marker and plant communities using the ITS marker. Sampling was conducted across a wide geography and diverse aquatic environments in Minnesota and Florida, USA, and Switzerland. The tow net samples had significantly higher eDNA yield compared to grab samples; however, they exhibited equal or lower alpha diversity of OTUs (Operational Taxonomic Units). The two sampling methods measured different beta diversity of communities detected with the COI marker across all three regions, highlighting the impact of the sampling method on the diversity of eDNA captured. In comparison, the beta diversity of plant eDNA was less impacted by the sampling method. We found no clear difference in detection for the invasive species targets based on the eDNA sampling method. These results underscore the need for pilot studies before conducting biodiversity inventory and monitoring, and a need for a greater understanding of not just how much, but also what, eDNA is captured depending on method choice, considering both spatial and particle size heterogeneity.
- Open Access
- 29 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in WIREs Water
- Vol. 11 (6)
A new flow path: eDNA connecting hydrology and biology
Environmental DNA (eDNA) has revolutionized ecological research, particularly for biodiversity assessment in various environments, most notably aquatic media. Environmental DNA analysis allows for non‐invasive and rapid species detection across multiple taxonomic groups within a single sample, making it especially useful for identifying rare or invasive species. Due to dynamic hydrological processes, eDNA samples from running waters may represent biodiversity from broad contributing areas, which is convenient from a biomonitoring perspective but also challenging, as hydrological knowledge is required for meaningful biological interpretation. Hydrologists could also benefit from eDNA to address unsolved questions, particularly concerning water movement through catchments. While naturally occurring abiotic tracers have advanced our understanding of water age distribution in catchments, for example, current geochemical tracers cannot fully elucidate the timing and flow paths of water through landscapes. Conversely, biological tracers, owing to their immense diversity and interactions with the environment, could offer more detailed information on the sources and flow paths of water to the stream. The informational capacity of eDNA as a tracer, however, is determined by the ability to interpret the complex biological heterogeneity at a study site, which arguably requires both biological and hydrological expertise. As eDNA data has become increasingly available as part of biomonitoring campaigns, we argue that accompanying eDNA surveys with hydrological observations could enhance our understanding of both biological and hydrological processes; we identify opportunities, challenges, and needs for further interdisciplinary collaboration; and we highlight eDNA's potential as a bridge between hydrology and biology, which could foster both domains.This article is categorized under: Science of Water > Hydrological Processes Science of Water > Methods Water and Life > Nature of Freshwater Ecosystems
- 29 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in WIREs Water
- Vol. 11 (6)
Open AccessA new flow path: eDNA connecting hydrology and biology
Environmental DNA (eDNA) has revolutionized ecological research, particularly for biodiversity assessment in various environments, most notably aquatic media. Environmental DNA analysis allows for non‐invasive and rapid species detection across multiple taxonomic groups within a single sample, making it especially useful for identifying rare or invasive species. Due to dynamic hydrological processes, eDNA samples from running waters may represent biodiversity from broad contributing areas, which is convenient from a biomonitoring perspective but also challenging, as hydrological knowledge is required for meaningful biological interpretation. Hydrologists could also benefit from eDNA to address unsolved questions, particularly concerning water movement through catchments. While naturally occurring abiotic tracers have advanced our understanding of water age distribution in catchments, for example, current geochemical tracers cannot fully elucidate the timing and flow paths of water through landscapes. Conversely, biological tracers, owing to their immense diversity and interactions with the environment, could offer more detailed information on the sources and flow paths of water to the stream. The informational capacity of eDNA as a tracer, however, is determined by the ability to interpret the complex biological heterogeneity at a study site, which arguably requires both biological and hydrological expertise. As eDNA data has become increasingly available as part of biomonitoring campaigns, we argue that accompanying eDNA surveys with hydrological observations could enhance our understanding of both biological and hydrological processes; we identify opportunities, challenges, and needs for further interdisciplinary collaboration; and we highlight eDNA's potential as a bridge between hydrology and biology, which could foster both domains.This article is categorized under: Science of Water > Hydrological Processes Science of Water > Methods Water and Life > Nature of Freshwater Ecosystems
- Open Access
- 1 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 6 (3)
Improving the recovery for dissolved eDNA state: A comparative analysis of isopropanol precipitation, magnetic bead extraction, and centrifugal dialysis
Environmental DNA consists of multiple states including but not limited to membrane‐bound, adsorbed, and dissolved states. Because of their chemical and physical properties, each of these states may have different degradation and transport potential. Essential to the study of eDNA states is being able to isolate them from an environmental sample. Here, we focus on improving the DNA recovery of the dissolved state of eDNA from water. We compared three recovery methods, namely isopropanol precipitation, magnetic bead extraction, and centrifugal dialysis. We evaluated the effectiveness of these methods based on the measured DNA recovery of two different species' DNA of different sizes. DNA recovery was assessed with qPCR. We also checked for the effect of inhibitor removal, and lastly, we estimated the cost of reagents and consumables (not labor). The DNA recovery varied among extraction methods, with isopropanol precipitation yielding the highest recovery (52.47 ± 19.69%), followed by centrifugal dialysis (12.58 ± 7.15%) and magnetic bead extraction (9.92 ± 3.89%). However, isopropanol precipitation's efficacy was influenced by humic acid concentration in the water matrix. The presence of humic acids significantly affected isopropanol precipitation, with higher humic acid concentrations leading to increased DNA recovery. This suggests that humic acids act as co‐precipitators during isopropanol precipitation. We observed that longer DNA fragments (chicken) had lower recovery compared to shorter fragments (salmon) across all extraction methods. Magnetic bead extraction effectively removed inhibitors, while centrifugal dialysis and isopropanol extraction required an additional inhibitor removal step. Isopropanol, magnetic bead extraction, and centrifugal dialysis methods have estimated costs of 7.74, 8.53, and 23.62 USD in 2023 respectively. Overall, isopropanol precipitation was the least expensive and most effective with the highest measured recoveries, but it was dependent on humic acid concentration in the environmental sample.
- 1 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 6 (3)
Open AccessImproving the recovery for dissolved eDNA state: A comparative analysis of isopropanol precipitation, magnetic bead extraction, and centrifugal dialysis
Environmental DNA consists of multiple states including but not limited to membrane‐bound, adsorbed, and dissolved states. Because of their chemical and physical properties, each of these states may have different degradation and transport potential. Essential to the study of eDNA states is being able to isolate them from an environmental sample. Here, we focus on improving the DNA recovery of the dissolved state of eDNA from water. We compared three recovery methods, namely isopropanol precipitation, magnetic bead extraction, and centrifugal dialysis. We evaluated the effectiveness of these methods based on the measured DNA recovery of two different species' DNA of different sizes. DNA recovery was assessed with qPCR. We also checked for the effect of inhibitor removal, and lastly, we estimated the cost of reagents and consumables (not labor). The DNA recovery varied among extraction methods, with isopropanol precipitation yielding the highest recovery (52.47 ± 19.69%), followed by centrifugal dialysis (12.58 ± 7.15%) and magnetic bead extraction (9.92 ± 3.89%). However, isopropanol precipitation's efficacy was influenced by humic acid concentration in the water matrix. The presence of humic acids significantly affected isopropanol precipitation, with higher humic acid concentrations leading to increased DNA recovery. This suggests that humic acids act as co‐precipitators during isopropanol precipitation. We observed that longer DNA fragments (chicken) had lower recovery compared to shorter fragments (salmon) across all extraction methods. Magnetic bead extraction effectively removed inhibitors, while centrifugal dialysis and isopropanol extraction required an additional inhibitor removal step. Isopropanol, magnetic bead extraction, and centrifugal dialysis methods have estimated costs of 7.74, 8.53, and 23.62 USD in 2023 respectively. Overall, isopropanol precipitation was the least expensive and most effective with the highest measured recoveries, but it was dependent on humic acid concentration in the environmental sample.
- Open Access
- 10 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 5 (3) , 582-596
Sorting states of environmental DNA: Effects of isolation method and water matrix on the recovery of membrane‐bound, dissolved, and adsorbed states of eDNA
Environmental DNA (eDNA) once shed can exist in numerous states with varying behaviors including degradation rates and transport potential. In this study, we consider three states of eDNA: (1) a membrane‐bound state referring to DNA enveloped in a cellular or organellar membrane, (2) a dissolved state defined as the extracellular DNA molecule in the environment without any interaction with other particles, and (3) an adsorbed state defined as extracellular DNA adsorbed to a particle surface in the environment. Capturing, isolating, and analyzing a target state of eDNA provides utility for better interpretation of eDNA degradation rates and transport potential. While methods for separating different states of DNA have been developed, they remain poorly evaluated due to the lack of state‐controlled experimentation. We evaluated the methods for separating states of eDNA from a single sample by spiking DNA from three different species to represent the three states of eDNA as state‐specific controls. We used chicken DNA to represent the dissolved state, cultured mouse cells for the membrane‐bound state, and salmon DNA adsorbed to clay particles as the adsorbed state. We performed the separation in three water matrices, two environmental and one synthetic, spiked with the three eDNA states. The membrane‐bound state was the only state that was isolated with minimal contamination from nontarget states. The membrane‐bound state also had the highest recovery (54.11 ± 19.24%), followed by the adsorbed state (5.08 ± 2.28%), and the dissolved state had the lowest total recovery (2.21 ± 2.36%). This study highlights the potential to sort the states of eDNA from a single sample and independently analyze them for more informed biodiversity assessments. However, further method development is needed to improve recovery and reduce cross‐contamination.
- 10 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 5 (3) , 582-596
Open AccessSorting states of environmental DNA: Effects of isolation method and water matrix on the recovery of membrane‐bound, dissolved, and adsorbed states of eDNA
Environmental DNA (eDNA) once shed can exist in numerous states with varying behaviors including degradation rates and transport potential. In this study, we consider three states of eDNA: (1) a membrane‐bound state referring to DNA enveloped in a cellular or organellar membrane, (2) a dissolved state defined as the extracellular DNA molecule in the environment without any interaction with other particles, and (3) an adsorbed state defined as extracellular DNA adsorbed to a particle surface in the environment. Capturing, isolating, and analyzing a target state of eDNA provides utility for better interpretation of eDNA degradation rates and transport potential. While methods for separating different states of DNA have been developed, they remain poorly evaluated due to the lack of state‐controlled experimentation. We evaluated the methods for separating states of eDNA from a single sample by spiking DNA from three different species to represent the three states of eDNA as state‐specific controls. We used chicken DNA to represent the dissolved state, cultured mouse cells for the membrane‐bound state, and salmon DNA adsorbed to clay particles as the adsorbed state. We performed the separation in three water matrices, two environmental and one synthetic, spiked with the three eDNA states. The membrane‐bound state was the only state that was isolated with minimal contamination from nontarget states. The membrane‐bound state also had the highest recovery (54.11 ± 19.24%), followed by the adsorbed state (5.08 ± 2.28%), and the dissolved state had the lowest total recovery (2.21 ± 2.36%). This study highlights the potential to sort the states of eDNA from a single sample and independently analyze them for more informed biodiversity assessments. However, further method development is needed to improve recovery and reduce cross‐contamination.