Cara Swain
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Cara Swain has a total of 62 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Klas Karlgren
Department of Learning, Informatics, Management and Ethics (LIME), Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden
5 shared publications - Natalia Stathakarou
Department of Learning, Informatics, Management and Ethics (LIME), Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden
5 shared publications - Andrzej A. Kononowicz
Department of Bioinformatics and Telemedicine, Jagiellonian University Medical College, Krakow, Poland
4 shared publications Klas Karlgren
Department of Learning, Informatics, Management & Ethics (LIME) Widerströmska huset, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden
4 shared publicationsG. Helgesson
Department of Learning, Informatics, Management & Ethics (LIME), Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden
3 shared publications- David N. Naumann
Academic Department of Military Surgery and Trauma, Royal Centre for Defence Medicine, Birmingham, UK
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Infection Prevention in Practice
- Vol. 8 (3) , 100566
Implementation of an SSI care bundle for patients undergoing emergency laparotomy
- 10 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Infection Prevention in Practice
- Vol. 8 (3) , 100566
Open AccessImplementation of an SSI care bundle for patients undergoing emergency laparotomy
- Open Access
- 1 April 2026
- Published by BMJ in Trauma Surgery & Acute Care Open
- Vol. 11 (2) , e002274
‘Not the basic ABC of how you control a blood vessel’: perceptions of UK Defence Medical Services personnel toward live tissue training for the surgical management of trauma
Introduction: ‘Live tissue training’ (LTT) is simulation using live anaesthetized animals as human patient substitutes. The educational benefits specific to LTT are unclear. This study aimed to explore the perceptions and attitudes of UK Defence Medical Services (DMS) personnel toward the use of LTT in the surgical management of trauma. Methods: Five virtual focus groups were conducted, with 20 regular and reservist DMS personnel representing surgical specialties, anesthesia, emergency medicine and primary care. Participants discussed their experiences of LTT and the impact on their professional development. Systematic text condensation was used to thematically analyze transcribed data. Results: Six themes were constructed, titled: (1) LTT: Who should do it and when; (2) conducting LTT as a military team; (3) psychomotor learning; (4) affective learning; (5) fidelity; (6) ethics and justification . Differences in perspectives were noted for prehospital and secondary care learners - LTT is used to individually train primary care personnel and military medics in basic, initial trauma management skills; secondary care personnel consider LTT a ‘finishing school’ for experienced clinicians to practice rare and high-risk procedures, within a military team setting. Conclusion: DMS personnel report positively about LTT, consider it to be realistic (higher fidelity) simulation training, and have educational and moral rationales to justify its use. The educational attributes of LTT appear to be context-specific and dependent on DMS learner role. This knowledge should influence the design and delivery of military trauma simulation involving live animals, allowing for replacement, reduction and refinement in their use for training different cohorts of learners. Level of evidence: 6 – qualitative research.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by BMJ in Trauma Surgery & Acute Care Open
- Vol. 11 (2) , e002274
Open Access‘Not the basic ABC of how you control a blood vessel’: perceptions of UK Defence Medical Services personnel toward live tissue training for the surgical management of trauma
Introduction: ‘Live tissue training’ (LTT) is simulation using live anaesthetized animals as human patient substitutes. The educational benefits specific to LTT are unclear. This study aimed to explore the perceptions and attitudes of UK Defence Medical Services (DMS) personnel toward the use of LTT in the surgical management of trauma. Methods: Five virtual focus groups were conducted, with 20 regular and reservist DMS personnel representing surgical specialties, anesthesia, emergency medicine and primary care. Participants discussed their experiences of LTT and the impact on their professional development. Systematic text condensation was used to thematically analyze transcribed data. Results: Six themes were constructed, titled: (1) LTT: Who should do it and when; (2) conducting LTT as a military team; (3) psychomotor learning; (4) affective learning; (5) fidelity; (6) ethics and justification . Differences in perspectives were noted for prehospital and secondary care learners - LTT is used to individually train primary care personnel and military medics in basic, initial trauma management skills; secondary care personnel consider LTT a ‘finishing school’ for experienced clinicians to practice rare and high-risk procedures, within a military team setting. Conclusion: DMS personnel report positively about LTT, consider it to be realistic (higher fidelity) simulation training, and have educational and moral rationales to justify its use. The educational attributes of LTT appear to be context-specific and dependent on DMS learner role. This knowledge should influence the design and delivery of military trauma simulation involving live animals, allowing for replacement, reduction and refinement in their use for training different cohorts of learners. Level of evidence: 6 – qualitative research.
- Open Access
- 17 March 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Serious Games
- Vol. 14, e79163
Game Elements in Military Trauma Care Education: Systematic Review
Background: Game elements may inform the design of both simulations and games. However, evidence on how individual game elements inform the design of military trauma training simulations and their educational purpose remains limited. Objective: This systematic review aimed to examine which game elements are used in the design of educational simulations for military trauma management, how they are implemented, for what purpose, and what outcomes are reported related to the game elements. Methods: This is a systematic review conducted in accordance with PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. We included qualitative, quantitative, mixed methods, and design studies describing simulation-based training for military trauma management that incorporated game elements. Studies focusing solely on assessment, noninteractive interventions, or psychological trauma were excluded. Searches were conducted in Medline (Ovid), PubMed, IEEE Xplore, ERIC, Web of Science, ACM Digital Library, and CINAHL from inception to October 14, 2025, identifying 2487 records. Screening and data extraction were performed independently by 2 reviewers. Methodological quality was assessed using the Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument (MERSQI) and the Côté and Turgeon grid. Results were synthesized using qualitative thematic synthesis. Results: Forty-two studies published between 1986 and 2025 were included. Most studies were conducted in the United States and included a wide range of simulation modalities and learner populations. Sixteen game elements were identified, with narrative, sensation, imposed choice, time pressure, and scoring being most prevalent. The thematic synthesis identified multiple categories describing how these game elements were implemented. Justifications for the use of game elements were rarely provided; when present, they were primarily linked to realism, emotional engagement, adaptive learning, and feedback. Elements such as badges and competition were seldom used. No study explicitly linked individual game elements to specific educational outcomes. This review is constrained by heterogeneity across studies, an imperfect fit of quality appraisal tools for some study types, and the possibility of missed studies due to search vocabulary limitations. Conclusions: This systematic review is innovative in providing the first comprehensive synthesis of how game elements are used in military trauma simulations. Unlike previous reviews, it explicitly focuses on the pedagogical purposes of these elements. It offers an overview of the prevalence of game elements in military trauma care education and synthesizes the pedagogical rationales for their use. The lack of studies explicitly linking individual game elements to learning outcomes highlights the need for more intentional research and transparent reporting. Future studies should treat gamification as a set of targeted design choices rather than as a single overarching strategy, and explore how its motivational dimensions can be effectively leveraged in military trauma training. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): RR2-10.2196/45969
- 17 March 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Serious Games
- Vol. 14, e79163
Open AccessGame Elements in Military Trauma Care Education: Systematic Review
Background: Game elements may inform the design of both simulations and games. However, evidence on how individual game elements inform the design of military trauma training simulations and their educational purpose remains limited. Objective: This systematic review aimed to examine which game elements are used in the design of educational simulations for military trauma management, how they are implemented, for what purpose, and what outcomes are reported related to the game elements. Methods: This is a systematic review conducted in accordance with PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. We included qualitative, quantitative, mixed methods, and design studies describing simulation-based training for military trauma management that incorporated game elements. Studies focusing solely on assessment, noninteractive interventions, or psychological trauma were excluded. Searches were conducted in Medline (Ovid), PubMed, IEEE Xplore, ERIC, Web of Science, ACM Digital Library, and CINAHL from inception to October 14, 2025, identifying 2487 records. Screening and data extraction were performed independently by 2 reviewers. Methodological quality was assessed using the Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument (MERSQI) and the Côté and Turgeon grid. Results were synthesized using qualitative thematic synthesis. Results: Forty-two studies published between 1986 and 2025 were included. Most studies were conducted in the United States and included a wide range of simulation modalities and learner populations. Sixteen game elements were identified, with narrative, sensation, imposed choice, time pressure, and scoring being most prevalent. The thematic synthesis identified multiple categories describing how these game elements were implemented. Justifications for the use of game elements were rarely provided; when present, they were primarily linked to realism, emotional engagement, adaptive learning, and feedback. Elements such as badges and competition were seldom used. No study explicitly linked individual game elements to specific educational outcomes. This review is constrained by heterogeneity across studies, an imperfect fit of quality appraisal tools for some study types, and the possibility of missed studies due to search vocabulary limitations. Conclusions: This systematic review is innovative in providing the first comprehensive synthesis of how game elements are used in military trauma simulations. Unlike previous reviews, it explicitly focuses on the pedagogical purposes of these elements. It offers an overview of the prevalence of game elements in military trauma care education and synthesizes the pedagogical rationales for their use. The lack of studies explicitly linking individual game elements to learning outcomes highlights the need for more intentional research and transparent reporting. Future studies should treat gamification as a set of targeted design choices rather than as a single overarching strategy, and explore how its motivational dimensions can be effectively leveraged in military trauma training. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): RR2-10.2196/45969
- Open Access
- 5 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Global Surgical Education - Journal of the Association for Surgical Education
- Vol. 5 (1)
Validity and fidelity in the context of live animal training in surgical education
Validity and fidelity are medical education concepts that characterise how well a simulated learning event maps onto real practice. Surgical simulation for educational purposes is not a new phenomenon, but despite advances in technology, the use of live anaesthetised animals as simulator models persists. Within surgical training, while live animal simulation may be considered to be “high-fidelity”, it should not necessarily be regarded as having validity as an educational method. This article aims to more fully describe the concepts of validity and fidelity in the context of simulation for surgical education and considers the current status of validity assessment. Finally, the balance between the educational and ethical challenges that arise when medical educators design simulated learning activities for surgeons is reviewed. There remains an undue emphasis on fidelity, and an underutilised process of validation in surgical simulation education, both of which have been used to defend the use of live animals. Yet, a specific choice of simulator will never be as important as the decision of how it is used for learning.
- 5 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Global Surgical Education - Journal of the Association for Surgical Education
- Vol. 5 (1)
Open AccessValidity and fidelity in the context of live animal training in surgical education
Validity and fidelity are medical education concepts that characterise how well a simulated learning event maps onto real practice. Surgical simulation for educational purposes is not a new phenomenon, but despite advances in technology, the use of live anaesthetised animals as simulator models persists. Within surgical training, while live animal simulation may be considered to be “high-fidelity”, it should not necessarily be regarded as having validity as an educational method. This article aims to more fully describe the concepts of validity and fidelity in the context of simulation for surgical education and considers the current status of validity assessment. Finally, the balance between the educational and ethical challenges that arise when medical educators design simulated learning activities for surgeons is reviewed. There remains an undue emphasis on fidelity, and an underutilised process of validation in surgical simulation education, both of which have been used to defend the use of live animals. Yet, a specific choice of simulator will never be as important as the decision of how it is used for learning.
- Open Access
- 8 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Ethics
- Vol. 26 (1) , 1-8
How do medical professionals justify their involvement with live tissue training?
Background: “Live tissue training” (LTT) is simulation that uses a live anaesthetised animal in place of a human patient. It is a training practice which is significantly contested, but continues to occur despite availability of alternative simulator models. The aim of this study was to explore if, and how, medical professionals who participate in LTT justify their own professional involvement. Methods: Fifteen semi-structured interviews of physicians who had knowledge and prior experience of LTT were performed as part of a wider research project and initially analysed using the Framework Method. Data categorised as ‘ethical views’ underwent a secondary thematic analysis to answer this research aim. Data were grouped by similar meaning to produce themes in the form of beliefs or views expressed by the participants. Results: Although no participant used language to explicitly indicate moral theorising, there is a set of identifiable coherent beliefs/views among the cohort. A belief that training must be conducted in order to save human patients’ lives (1); that human life is of higher value than animal life (2); and that there is no sufficiently good alternative to LTT (3). It is felt that LTT is reasonable as the numbers of animals used are minimised and opportunities for learning or other uses maximised (4); animals are well cared for and are not suffering (5) and reasonable in comparison to other animal uses (6). Conclusion: There is a predominant consequentialist thinking regarding the use of live animals, with evidence that the 3Rs principles are being considered, if not explicitly, as a restriction on the use of animals for LTT and also partly to justify or defend medical professionals’ involvement. We suggest that professional identity is likely to have a role in forming these justificatory arguments, but personal views about the moral standing of animals and notions of speciesism could also influence decisions about being involved in LTT.
- 8 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Ethics
- Vol. 26 (1) , 1-8
Open AccessHow do medical professionals justify their involvement with live tissue training?
Background: “Live tissue training” (LTT) is simulation that uses a live anaesthetised animal in place of a human patient. It is a training practice which is significantly contested, but continues to occur despite availability of alternative simulator models. The aim of this study was to explore if, and how, medical professionals who participate in LTT justify their own professional involvement. Methods: Fifteen semi-structured interviews of physicians who had knowledge and prior experience of LTT were performed as part of a wider research project and initially analysed using the Framework Method. Data categorised as ‘ethical views’ underwent a secondary thematic analysis to answer this research aim. Data were grouped by similar meaning to produce themes in the form of beliefs or views expressed by the participants. Results: Although no participant used language to explicitly indicate moral theorising, there is a set of identifiable coherent beliefs/views among the cohort. A belief that training must be conducted in order to save human patients’ lives (1); that human life is of higher value than animal life (2); and that there is no sufficiently good alternative to LTT (3). It is felt that LTT is reasonable as the numbers of animals used are minimised and opportunities for learning or other uses maximised (4); animals are well cared for and are not suffering (5) and reasonable in comparison to other animal uses (6). Conclusion: There is a predominant consequentialist thinking regarding the use of live animals, with evidence that the 3Rs principles are being considered, if not explicitly, as a restriction on the use of animals for LTT and also partly to justify or defend medical professionals’ involvement. We suggest that professional identity is likely to have a role in forming these justificatory arguments, but personal views about the moral standing of animals and notions of speciesism could also influence decisions about being involved in LTT.
- Open Access
- 10 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 25 (1) , 1-14
Optimising the educational utility of live tissue training in trauma surgery
Background: Live tissue training (LTT) refers to the use of live anaesthetised animals for the purpose of medical education. It is a type of simulation training that is contentious, and there is an ethical imperative for educators to justify the use of animals. This should include scrutinising educational practices. The authors’ aim was to explore learners’ and educators’ experiences of LTT for surgical learning, employing simulation theory to analyse how LTT can be optimised as a simulated learning event. Methods: This study used semi-structured interviews to generate data from fifteen physicians who had participated in LTT as learners or educators. The data were thematically analysed using the Framework Method. Findings: Suggestions on how LTT could be optimised were discussed by the participants across three themes: Planning, Delivering, and Experiencing LTT. The Planning theme provides context into what specific learning aims LTT should be used for, and whom this type of learning would benefit. The Delivering theme centred around the idea of delivering the curriculum content using various pedagogic methods and framing the animal as a patient rather than a model. The Experiencing theme describes the learner’s experience of clinical reality and the importance of real-life survival of the animal during training. Conclusion: These themes along with simulation theory have been used to create a series of recommendations about how LTT could be optimised to ensure educational quality. Key recommendations include clarifying which learners should attend, restructuring courses to include a brief and debrief, teaching technical and non-technical skills in tandem, and focusing learning on the animal as a patient, in order to promote a realistic experience.
- 10 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 25 (1) , 1-14
Open AccessOptimising the educational utility of live tissue training in trauma surgery
Background: Live tissue training (LTT) refers to the use of live anaesthetised animals for the purpose of medical education. It is a type of simulation training that is contentious, and there is an ethical imperative for educators to justify the use of animals. This should include scrutinising educational practices. The authors’ aim was to explore learners’ and educators’ experiences of LTT for surgical learning, employing simulation theory to analyse how LTT can be optimised as a simulated learning event. Methods: This study used semi-structured interviews to generate data from fifteen physicians who had participated in LTT as learners or educators. The data were thematically analysed using the Framework Method. Findings: Suggestions on how LTT could be optimised were discussed by the participants across three themes: Planning, Delivering, and Experiencing LTT. The Planning theme provides context into what specific learning aims LTT should be used for, and whom this type of learning would benefit. The Delivering theme centred around the idea of delivering the curriculum content using various pedagogic methods and framing the animal as a patient rather than a model. The Experiencing theme describes the learner’s experience of clinical reality and the importance of real-life survival of the animal during training. Conclusion: These themes along with simulation theory have been used to create a series of recommendations about how LTT could be optimised to ensure educational quality. Key recommendations include clarifying which learners should attend, restructuring courses to include a brief and debrief, teaching technical and non-technical skills in tandem, and focusing learning on the animal as a patient, in order to promote a realistic experience.
- 18 August 2025
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Military Health
- Vol. 172 (4) , 296-300
Academic Department of Military Surgery and Trauma (ADMST): preparedness for the next conflict through collaboration in research and innovation
The UK Strategic Defence Review 2025 provides a compelling examination of the threats faced by the UK. The UK as a whole, and the Ministry of Defence in particular, must become ready for large-scale conflict operations (LSCO) and learn the lessons from Ukraine. A successful academic military surgical department should regularly re-evaluate its mission, its surgical priorities and its outputs. This paper describes the principles by which the UK Defence Medical Services’ Academic Department of Military Surgery and Trauma will work to address the likely clinical realities of LSCO. Three overarching themes to departmental work are described, underpinned by a commitment to collaboration via research partnerships—both within and external to Defence—to enable the delivery of best possible outcomes as the country’s armed forces rapidly pivot to the future and adapt to new threats.
- 18 August 2025
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Military Health
- Vol. 172 (4) , 296-300
Academic Department of Military Surgery and Trauma (ADMST): preparedness for the next conflict through collaboration in research and innovation
The UK Strategic Defence Review 2025 provides a compelling examination of the threats faced by the UK. The UK as a whole, and the Ministry of Defence in particular, must become ready for large-scale conflict operations (LSCO) and learn the lessons from Ukraine. A successful academic military surgical department should regularly re-evaluate its mission, its surgical priorities and its outputs. This paper describes the principles by which the UK Defence Medical Services’ Academic Department of Military Surgery and Trauma will work to address the likely clinical realities of LSCO. Three overarching themes to departmental work are described, underpinned by a commitment to collaboration via research partnerships—both within and external to Defence—to enable the delivery of best possible outcomes as the country’s armed forces rapidly pivot to the future and adapt to new threats.
- Open Access
- 31 July 2025
- Published by Karolinska Institutet
Living matter(s) : exploring the educational use of live animals in learning to manage surgical traumatic injuries
Background: Live anaesthetised animals are used in many countries for medical professionals to practice surgical techniques. This type of simulation - known as "live tissue training" (LTT) - has been used specifically by military organisations to learn to manage complex traumatic injuries, and criticised by animal rights activists. There is a moral and ethical imperative to reduce live animal use in medical research and education, in accordance with the principles of the 3Rs (replacement, reduction and refinement) of humane animal experimentation. Yet, many advocates argue that there are currently no available simulation models that can replace all which can be achieved by using an anaesthetised pig. One significant component of the debate relates to the perceived realism or fidelity of using an animal in place of a human patient. Although the educational effectiveness of simulation is not in question, the benefit of this specific practice is unclear, in terms of educational outcomes for learners or improved health outcomes for patients.Aim: This doctoral research project aimed to explore how live animals are being used as simulators to educate medical professionals in the context of trauma, with a specific focus on surgeons and surgical teams. By improving our understanding of this type of simulated practice, it may be possible to contribute to an argument for justification of LTT in certain situations or contexts, inform educators on the most optimal way to use live animals for learning, guide technological developments to produce open surgical simulators, and assist with the rational reduction of animals in unnecessary medical training.Methods: A sociomaterial approach was adopted, focusing on how materials interact with social practices. Four sub-studies - a review of the literature and three empirical qualitative studies - were used to explore the research questions. Studies I(a) and I(b) reviewed the literature to understand how live animals are used as a simulation modality and what the associated ethical arguments are. Studies II-IV contributed to understanding how LTT is used in different contexts and for different learner populations. Study II used focus groups of UK military medical personnel to explore the use of LTT in a military environment. Study III involved focused ethnographic observations of seven international military and civilian surgical courses that use a live animal to train in the management of trauma. Study IV used fifteen qualitative semi-structured interviews of the learners and educators involved with LTT to explore how this sort of training could be optimised to maximise educational benefit.Findings: By concept, LTT is simulation, but the observed training is not delivered according to the established practices of simulation-based education. Instead, LTT appears more akin to a traditional surgical apprenticeship. Training is typically orientated toward learning procedural skills with in-situ feedback delivered by expert educators; there is no formal debriefing. Military LTT tends to be more aligned to pre-hospital and surgical team training in an operational context, whereas civilian LTT is typically orientated toward educating surgeons. Most learners and educators apply a consequentialist ethical outlook aligned with 'the end justifies the means'.The animals exist on an ontological spectrum, as a model for training and a patient that needs to be saved, which influences how learning is mediated. The tactile nature of the animal is important for all, but can be interpreted and valued differently. Survival of the animal is critical, at least until the learning objectives have been completed, when the animal is euthanised. During LTT, life and death are interpreted as success and failure. Premature death of the animal is problematic - superficially, as the perceived value for learning diminishes, and on a deeper level, as clear evidence presented to the learner that their actions truly matter in relation to patient outcomes.The experience of participating in live animal training is highly valued because it is considered to be realistic. An authentic learning experience is more likely to be perceived when animals are framed as patients, with a focus on the technical and non-technical skills of surgical practice. This facilitates multimediation of learning and a wider range of both intended, and unintended, learning outcomes.Conclusions: By considering the dual ontological nature of the animal alongside how this training is conceptualised - as simulation or a surrogate clinical experience - pedagogic knowledge could be used to optimise the learning that occurs through this educational event. It is also ethically and morally reasonable for each use of a live animal to be thoroughly considered as to whether the educational value, compared to alternative simulation models, outweighs the ethical cost. This approach would not only comply with the principles of the 3Rs, but ensure training in the context of trauma is the best available to improve patient care.List of scientific papersI. Swain CS, Cohen HML, Helgesson G, Rickard RF, Karlgren K. A Systematic Review of Live Animal Use as a Simulation Modality ("Live Tissue Training") in the Emergency Management of Trauma. Journal of Surgical Education. 2023;80(9):1320-39. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsurg.2023.06.018II. Swain C, Rickard R, Karlgren K, Helgesson G. Considering the ethics of live tissue training in trauma surgery. Journal of Medical Ethics. 2025 Mar 5:jme-2023-109761. Epub ahead of print. https://doi.org/10.1136/jme-2023-109761III. Swain CS, Harjani MG, Helgesson G, Rickard RF, Karlgren K. The perceptions and attitudes of British Armed Services medical personnel toward live tissue training for the surgical management of trauma. [Submitted]IV. Swain C, Silen C, Karlgren K. Living matter(s) for learning: an international, multi-sited ethnography exploring how surgeons' learning is mediated through the use...
- 31 July 2025
- Published by Karolinska Institutet
Open AccessLiving matter(s) : exploring the educational use of live animals in learning to manage surgical traumatic injuries
Background: Live anaesthetised animals are used in many countries for medical professionals to practice surgical techniques. This type of simulation - known as "live tissue training" (LTT) - has been used specifically by military organisations to learn to manage complex traumatic injuries, and criticised by animal rights activists. There is a moral and ethical imperative to reduce live animal use in medical research and education, in accordance with the principles of the 3Rs (replacement, reduction and refinement) of humane animal experimentation. Yet, many advocates argue that there are currently no available simulation models that can replace all which can be achieved by using an anaesthetised pig. One significant component of the debate relates to the perceived realism or fidelity of using an animal in place of a human patient. Although the educational effectiveness of simulation is not in question, the benefit of this specific practice is unclear, in terms of educational outcomes for learners or improved health outcomes for patients.Aim: This doctoral research project aimed to explore how live animals are being used as simulators to educate medical professionals in the context of trauma, with a specific focus on surgeons and surgical teams. By improving our understanding of this type of simulated practice, it may be possible to contribute to an argument for justification of LTT in certain situations or contexts, inform educators on the most optimal way to use live animals for learning, guide technological developments to produce open surgical simulators, and assist with the rational reduction of animals in unnecessary medical training.Methods: A sociomaterial approach was adopted, focusing on how materials interact with social practices. Four sub-studies - a review of the literature and three empirical qualitative studies - were used to explore the research questions. Studies I(a) and I(b) reviewed the literature to understand how live animals are used as a simulation modality and what the associated ethical arguments are. Studies II-IV contributed to understanding how LTT is used in different contexts and for different learner populations. Study II used focus groups of UK military medical personnel to explore the use of LTT in a military environment. Study III involved focused ethnographic observations of seven international military and civilian surgical courses that use a live animal to train in the management of trauma. Study IV used fifteen qualitative semi-structured interviews of the learners and educators involved with LTT to explore how this sort of training could be optimised to maximise educational benefit.Findings: By concept, LTT is simulation, but the observed training is not delivered according to the established practices of simulation-based education. Instead, LTT appears more akin to a traditional surgical apprenticeship. Training is typically orientated toward learning procedural skills with in-situ feedback delivered by expert educators; there is no formal debriefing. Military LTT tends to be more aligned to pre-hospital and surgical team training in an operational context, whereas civilian LTT is typically orientated toward educating surgeons. Most learners and educators apply a consequentialist ethical outlook aligned with 'the end justifies the means'.The animals exist on an ontological spectrum, as a model for training and a patient that needs to be saved, which influences how learning is mediated. The tactile nature of the animal is important for all, but can be interpreted and valued differently. Survival of the animal is critical, at least until the learning objectives have been completed, when the animal is euthanised. During LTT, life and death are interpreted as success and failure. Premature death of the animal is problematic - superficially, as the perceived value for learning diminishes, and on a deeper level, as clear evidence presented to the learner that their actions truly matter in relation to patient outcomes.The experience of participating in live animal training is highly valued because it is considered to be realistic. An authentic learning experience is more likely to be perceived when animals are framed as patients, with a focus on the technical and non-technical skills of surgical practice. This facilitates multimediation of learning and a wider range of both intended, and unintended, learning outcomes.Conclusions: By considering the dual ontological nature of the animal alongside how this training is conceptualised - as simulation or a surrogate clinical experience - pedagogic knowledge could be used to optimise the learning that occurs through this educational event. It is also ethically and morally reasonable for each use of a live animal to be thoroughly considered as to whether the educational value, compared to alternative simulation models, outweighs the ethical cost. This approach would not only comply with the principles of the 3Rs, but ensure training in the context of trauma is the best available to improve patient care.List of scientific papersI. Swain CS, Cohen HML, Helgesson G, Rickard RF, Karlgren K. A Systematic Review of Live Animal Use as a Simulation Modality ("Live Tissue Training") in the Emergency Management of Trauma. Journal of Surgical Education. 2023;80(9):1320-39. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsurg.2023.06.018II. Swain C, Rickard R, Karlgren K, Helgesson G. Considering the ethics of live tissue training in trauma surgery. Journal of Medical Ethics. 2025 Mar 5:jme-2023-109761. Epub ahead of print. https://doi.org/10.1136/jme-2023-109761III. Swain CS, Harjani MG, Helgesson G, Rickard RF, Karlgren K. The perceptions and attitudes of British Armed Services medical personnel toward live tissue training for the surgical management of trauma. [Submitted]IV. Swain C, Silen C, Karlgren K. Living matter(s) for learning: an international, multi-sited ethnography exploring how surgeons' learning is mediated through the use...
- Open Access
- 31 July 2025
- Published by Karolinska Institutet
Living matter(s) : exploring the educational use of live animals in learning to manage surgical traumatic injuries
Background: Live anaesthetised animals are used in many countries for medical professionals to practice surgical techniques. This type of simulation - known as "live tissue training" (LTT) - has been used specifically by military organisations to learn to manage complex traumatic injuries, and criticised by animal rights activists. There is a moral and ethical imperative to reduce live animal use in medical research and education, in accordance with the principles of the 3Rs (replacement, reduction and refinement) of humane animal experimentation. Yet, many advocates argue that there are currently no available simulation models that can replace all which can be achieved by using an anaesthetised pig. One significant component of the debate relates to the perceived realism or fidelity of using an animal in place of a human patient. Although the educational effectiveness of simulation is not in question, the benefit of this specific practice is unclear, in terms of educational outcomes for learners or improved health outcomes for patients.Aim: This doctoral research project aimed to explore how live animals are being used as simulators to educate medical professionals in the context of trauma, with a specific focus on surgeons and surgical teams. By improving our understanding of this type of simulated practice, it may be possible to contribute to an argument for justification of LTT in certain situations or contexts, inform educators on the most optimal way to use live animals for learning, guide technological developments to produce open surgical simulators, and assist with the rational reduction of animals in unnecessary medical training.Methods: A sociomaterial approach was adopted, focusing on how materials interact with social practices. Four sub-studies - a review of the literature and three empirical qualitative studies - were used to explore the research questions. Studies I(a) and I(b) reviewed the literature to understand how live animals are used as a simulation modality and what the associated ethical arguments are. Studies II-IV contributed to understanding how LTT is used in different contexts and for different learner populations. Study II used focus groups of UK military medical personnel to explore the use of LTT in a military environment. Study III involved focused ethnographic observations of seven international military and civilian surgical courses that use a live animal to train in the management of trauma. Study IV used fifteen qualitative semi-structured interviews of the learners and educators involved with LTT to explore how this sort of training could be optimised to maximise educational benefit.Findings: By concept, LTT is simulation, but the observed training is not delivered according to the established practices of simulation-based education. Instead, LTT appears more akin to a traditional surgical apprenticeship. Training is typically orientated toward learning procedural skills with in-situ feedback delivered by expert educators; there is no formal debriefing. Military LTT tends to be more aligned to pre-hospital and surgical team training in an operational context, whereas civilian LTT is typically orientated toward educating surgeons. Most learners and educators apply a consequentialist ethical outlook aligned with 'the end justifies the means'.The animals exist on an ontological spectrum, as a model for training and a patient that needs to be saved, which influences how learning is mediated. The tactile nature of the animal is important for all, but can be interpreted and valued differently. Survival of the animal is critical, at least until the learning objectives have been completed, when the animal is euthanised. During LTT, life and death are interpreted as success and failure. Premature death of the animal is problematic - superficially, as the perceived value for learning diminishes, and on a deeper level, as clear evidence presented to the learner that their actions truly matter in relation to patient outcomes.The experience of participating in live animal training is highly valued because it is considered to be realistic. An authentic learning experience is more likely to be perceived when animals are framed as patients, with a focus on the technical and non-technical skills of surgical practice. This facilitates multimediation of learning and a wider range of both intended, and unintended, learning outcomes.Conclusions: By considering the dual ontological nature of the animal alongside how this training is conceptualised - as simulation or a surrogate clinical experience - pedagogic knowledge could be used to optimise the learning that occurs through this educational event. It is also ethically and morally reasonable for each use of a live animal to be thoroughly considered as to whether the educational value, compared to alternative simulation models, outweighs the ethical cost. This approach would not only comply with the principles of the 3Rs, but ensure training in the context of trauma is the best available to improve patient care.List of scientific papersI. Swain CS, Cohen HML, Helgesson G, Rickard RF, Karlgren K. A Systematic Review of Live Animal Use as a Simulation Modality ("Live Tissue Training") in the Emergency Management of Trauma. Journal of Surgical Education. 2023;80(9):1320-39. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsurg.2023.06.018II. Swain C, Rickard R, Karlgren K, Helgesson G. Considering the ethics of live tissue training in trauma surgery. Journal of Medical Ethics. 2025 Mar 5:jme-2023-109761. Epub ahead of print. https://doi.org/10.1136/jme-2023-109761III. Swain CS, Harjani MG, Helgesson G, Rickard RF, Karlgren K. The perceptions and attitudes of British Armed Services medical personnel toward live tissue training for the surgical management of trauma. [Submitted]IV. Swain C, Silen C, Karlgren K. Living matter(s) for learning: an international, multi-sited ethnography exploring how surgeons' learning is mediated through the use...
- 31 July 2025
- Published by Karolinska Institutet
Open AccessLiving matter(s) : exploring the educational use of live animals in learning to manage surgical traumatic injuries
Background: Live anaesthetised animals are used in many countries for medical professionals to practice surgical techniques. This type of simulation - known as "live tissue training" (LTT) - has been used specifically by military organisations to learn to manage complex traumatic injuries, and criticised by animal rights activists. There is a moral and ethical imperative to reduce live animal use in medical research and education, in accordance with the principles of the 3Rs (replacement, reduction and refinement) of humane animal experimentation. Yet, many advocates argue that there are currently no available simulation models that can replace all which can be achieved by using an anaesthetised pig. One significant component of the debate relates to the perceived realism or fidelity of using an animal in place of a human patient. Although the educational effectiveness of simulation is not in question, the benefit of this specific practice is unclear, in terms of educational outcomes for learners or improved health outcomes for patients.Aim: This doctoral research project aimed to explore how live animals are being used as simulators to educate medical professionals in the context of trauma, with a specific focus on surgeons and surgical teams. By improving our understanding of this type of simulated practice, it may be possible to contribute to an argument for justification of LTT in certain situations or contexts, inform educators on the most optimal way to use live animals for learning, guide technological developments to produce open surgical simulators, and assist with the rational reduction of animals in unnecessary medical training.Methods: A sociomaterial approach was adopted, focusing on how materials interact with social practices. Four sub-studies - a review of the literature and three empirical qualitative studies - were used to explore the research questions. Studies I(a) and I(b) reviewed the literature to understand how live animals are used as a simulation modality and what the associated ethical arguments are. Studies II-IV contributed to understanding how LTT is used in different contexts and for different learner populations. Study II used focus groups of UK military medical personnel to explore the use of LTT in a military environment. Study III involved focused ethnographic observations of seven international military and civilian surgical courses that use a live animal to train in the management of trauma. Study IV used fifteen qualitative semi-structured interviews of the learners and educators involved with LTT to explore how this sort of training could be optimised to maximise educational benefit.Findings: By concept, LTT is simulation, but the observed training is not delivered according to the established practices of simulation-based education. Instead, LTT appears more akin to a traditional surgical apprenticeship. Training is typically orientated toward learning procedural skills with in-situ feedback delivered by expert educators; there is no formal debriefing. Military LTT tends to be more aligned to pre-hospital and surgical team training in an operational context, whereas civilian LTT is typically orientated toward educating surgeons. Most learners and educators apply a consequentialist ethical outlook aligned with 'the end justifies the means'.The animals exist on an ontological spectrum, as a model for training and a patient that needs to be saved, which influences how learning is mediated. The tactile nature of the animal is important for all, but can be interpreted and valued differently. Survival of the animal is critical, at least until the learning objectives have been completed, when the animal is euthanised. During LTT, life and death are interpreted as success and failure. Premature death of the animal is problematic - superficially, as the perceived value for learning diminishes, and on a deeper level, as clear evidence presented to the learner that their actions truly matter in relation to patient outcomes.The experience of participating in live animal training is highly valued because it is considered to be realistic. An authentic learning experience is more likely to be perceived when animals are framed as patients, with a focus on the technical and non-technical skills of surgical practice. This facilitates multimediation of learning and a wider range of both intended, and unintended, learning outcomes.Conclusions: By considering the dual ontological nature of the animal alongside how this training is conceptualised - as simulation or a surrogate clinical experience - pedagogic knowledge could be used to optimise the learning that occurs through this educational event. It is also ethically and morally reasonable for each use of a live animal to be thoroughly considered as to whether the educational value, compared to alternative simulation models, outweighs the ethical cost. This approach would not only comply with the principles of the 3Rs, but ensure training in the context of trauma is the best available to improve patient care.List of scientific papersI. Swain CS, Cohen HML, Helgesson G, Rickard RF, Karlgren K. A Systematic Review of Live Animal Use as a Simulation Modality ("Live Tissue Training") in the Emergency Management of Trauma. Journal of Surgical Education. 2023;80(9):1320-39. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsurg.2023.06.018II. Swain C, Rickard R, Karlgren K, Helgesson G. Considering the ethics of live tissue training in trauma surgery. Journal of Medical Ethics. 2025 Mar 5:jme-2023-109761. Epub ahead of print. https://doi.org/10.1136/jme-2023-109761III. Swain CS, Harjani MG, Helgesson G, Rickard RF, Karlgren K. The perceptions and attitudes of British Armed Services medical personnel toward live tissue training for the surgical management of trauma. [Submitted]IV. Swain C, Silen C, Karlgren K. Living matter(s) for learning: an international, multi-sited ethnography exploring how surgeons' learning is mediated through the use...