Niels Suitner
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Niels Suitner has a total of 24 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jens Hartmann
Department of Earth System Sciences, University of Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany
24 shared publications - Charly Andre Moras
Department of Earth System Sciences, University of Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany
15 shared publications - Ulf Riebesell
GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel, Kiel, Germany
15 shared publications - Giulia Faucher
GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel, Kiel, Germany
14 shared publications - Carl Lim
KU Leuven, Bruges, Department of Materials Engineering, B-8200, Belgium
11 shared publications Julieta Schneider
Biological Oceanography, GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel, Düsternbrooker Weg 20, 24105 Kiel, Germany
8 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Biogeosciences
- Vol. 23 (11) , 3965-3980
Surface area and Ω-aragonite oversaturation as controls of the runaway precipitation process in ocean alkalinity enhancement
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added TA, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of TA is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA-loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the TA stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are (i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and (ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ∼11 °C, Sal.: ∼32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or halting the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30 %–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added TA. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes, reducing the available reactive particle surface area, is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.
- 16 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Biogeosciences
- Vol. 23 (11) , 3965-3980
Open AccessSurface area and Ω-aragonite oversaturation as controls of the runaway precipitation process in ocean alkalinity enhancement
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added TA, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of TA is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA-loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the TA stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are (i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and (ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ∼11 °C, Sal.: ∼32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or halting the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30 %–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added TA. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes, reducing the available reactive particle surface area, is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.
- Open Access
- 19 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Applied Geochemistry
- Vol. 203
Assessment of solid ikaite release into seawater – implications for ocean alkalinity enhancement
- 19 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Applied Geochemistry
- Vol. 203
Open AccessAssessment of solid ikaite release into seawater – implications for ocean alkalinity enhancement
- Open Access
- 29 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Reply on RC2
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added alkalinity, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of alkalinity is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the alkalinity stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ~11 °C, Sal.: ~32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or stopping the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added alkalinity. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes reducing the available reactive particle surface area is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.
- 29 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Open AccessReply on RC2
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added alkalinity, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of alkalinity is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the alkalinity stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ~11 °C, Sal.: ~32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or stopping the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added alkalinity. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes reducing the available reactive particle surface area is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.
- Open Access
- 29 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Reply on RC1
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added alkalinity, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of alkalinity is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the alkalinity stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ~11 °C, Sal.: ~32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or stopping the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added alkalinity. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes reducing the available reactive particle surface area is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.
- 29 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Open AccessReply on RC1
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added alkalinity, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of alkalinity is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the alkalinity stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ~11 °C, Sal.: ~32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or stopping the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added alkalinity. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes reducing the available reactive particle surface area is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.
- Open Access
- 29 August 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 20 (9) , 094053
Stability of alkalinity in the land-ocean transition zone: a geochemical CDR perspective for the Elbe River, Germany
Carbon dioxide removal (CDR) strategies like enhanced weathering and river/ocean alkalinity enhancement have been suggested to increase alkalinity in rivers, coastal areas, and eventually oceans. The effectiveness and sustainability of these CDR approaches depend on the persistence of added alkalinity, since exceeding certain Ω-thresholds for a given water composition may lead to carbonates formation, causing the loss of previously added alkalinity. In this research, stability of alkalinity was tested using incubation experiments with Elbe estuary freshwater from two seasons (March and August). Alkalinity was increased up to 4000 μmol kgw−1, with varying salinity from 0 to 16. This study shows that the stability of alkalinity depends on the presence and quantity of suspended particles, seasonality of water chemistry, and salinity. Based on the experimental data, the Elbe estuary may take up additional alkalinity in the freshwater part, corresponding to ∼3.0 MtCO2 yr−1 being transported towards the North Sea. Estimates of alkalinity additions from the 1970s to 2010s show a decreasing potential due to changes in pCO2 and pH. The upper geochemical limit for transporting additional alkalinity through estuarine systems serves as a critical boundary. Environmentally feasible levels may be lower than identified here and depend on environmental regulations.
- 29 August 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 20 (9) , 094053
Open AccessStability of alkalinity in the land-ocean transition zone: a geochemical CDR perspective for the Elbe River, Germany
Carbon dioxide removal (CDR) strategies like enhanced weathering and river/ocean alkalinity enhancement have been suggested to increase alkalinity in rivers, coastal areas, and eventually oceans. The effectiveness and sustainability of these CDR approaches depend on the persistence of added alkalinity, since exceeding certain Ω-thresholds for a given water composition may lead to carbonates formation, causing the loss of previously added alkalinity. In this research, stability of alkalinity was tested using incubation experiments with Elbe estuary freshwater from two seasons (March and August). Alkalinity was increased up to 4000 μmol kgw−1, with varying salinity from 0 to 16. This study shows that the stability of alkalinity depends on the presence and quantity of suspended particles, seasonality of water chemistry, and salinity. Based on the experimental data, the Elbe estuary may take up additional alkalinity in the freshwater part, corresponding to ∼3.0 MtCO2 yr−1 being transported towards the North Sea. Estimates of alkalinity additions from the 1970s to 2010s show a decreasing potential due to changes in pCO2 and pH. The upper geochemical limit for transporting additional alkalinity through estuarine systems serves as a critical boundary. Environmentally feasible levels may be lower than identified here and depend on environmental regulations.
- Open Access
- 25 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Comment on egusphere-2025-381
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added alkalinity, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of alkalinity is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the alkalinity stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ~11 °C, Sal.: ~32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or stopping the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added alkalinity. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes reducing the available reactive particle surface area is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.
- 25 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-381
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added alkalinity, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of alkalinity is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the alkalinity stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ~11 °C, Sal.: ~32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or stopping the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added alkalinity. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes reducing the available reactive particle surface area is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 18 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Biogeosciences
- Vol. 22 (12) , 2749-2766
Ocean alkalinity enhancement in an open-ocean ecosystem: biogeochemical responses and carbon storage durability
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is considered for the long-term removal of gigatonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere to achieve our climate goals. Little is known, however, about the ecosystem-level changes in biogeochemical functioning that may result from the chemical sequestration of CO2 in seawater and how stable the sequestration is. We studied these two aspects in natural plankton communities under carbonate-based, CO2-equilibrated OAE of up to a doubling of ambient alkalinity (+2400 µeq kg−1, Ωaragonite∼10) in the nutrient-poor North Atlantic. During our month-long mesocosm experiment, the majority of biogeochemical pools, including inorganic nutrients, particulate organic carbon and phosphorus, and biogenic silica, remained unaltered across all OAE levels. Noticeable exceptions were a minor decrease in particulate organic nitrogen and an increase in the carbon-to-nitrogen ratio (C:N) of particulate organic matter in response to OAE. Thus, in our nitrogen-limited system, nitrogen turnover processes appear more susceptible than those of other elements, which could lead to decreased food quality and increased organic carbon storage. However, alkalinity and chemical CO2 sequestration were not stable at all levels of OAE. Two weeks after alkalinity addition, we measured a loss of added alkalinity and of the initially stored CO2 in the mesocosm where alkalinity was highest. The loss rate in this mesocosm accelerated over time and amounted to ∼10 % of stored CO2 within 4 weeks after alkalinity enhancement. Additional tests showed that such secondary precipitation can be initiated by particles acting as precipitation nuclei and that this process can occur even at lower levels of OAE. In conclusion, in scenarios like our study with carbonate-based OAE, where the carbon is already sequestered, the risk of major and sustained impacts on biogeochemical functioning may be low in the nutrient-poor ocean. However, the durability of carbon sequestration using OAE could be constrained by alkalinity loss in supersaturated waters with precipitation nuclei present. Our study provides an evaluation of the ecosystem impacts of an idealised OAE deployment for monitoring, reporting, and verification in an oligotrophic system. Whether biogeochemical functioning is resilient to more technically simple and economically viable approaches that induce stronger water chemistry perturbations remains to be seen.
- 18 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Biogeosciences
- Vol. 22 (12) , 2749-2766
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessOcean alkalinity enhancement in an open-ocean ecosystem: biogeochemical responses and carbon storage durability
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is considered for the long-term removal of gigatonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere to achieve our climate goals. Little is known, however, about the ecosystem-level changes in biogeochemical functioning that may result from the chemical sequestration of CO2 in seawater and how stable the sequestration is. We studied these two aspects in natural plankton communities under carbonate-based, CO2-equilibrated OAE of up to a doubling of ambient alkalinity (+2400 µeq kg−1, Ωaragonite∼10) in the nutrient-poor North Atlantic. During our month-long mesocosm experiment, the majority of biogeochemical pools, including inorganic nutrients, particulate organic carbon and phosphorus, and biogenic silica, remained unaltered across all OAE levels. Noticeable exceptions were a minor decrease in particulate organic nitrogen and an increase in the carbon-to-nitrogen ratio (C:N) of particulate organic matter in response to OAE. Thus, in our nitrogen-limited system, nitrogen turnover processes appear more susceptible than those of other elements, which could lead to decreased food quality and increased organic carbon storage. However, alkalinity and chemical CO2 sequestration were not stable at all levels of OAE. Two weeks after alkalinity addition, we measured a loss of added alkalinity and of the initially stored CO2 in the mesocosm where alkalinity was highest. The loss rate in this mesocosm accelerated over time and amounted to ∼10 % of stored CO2 within 4 weeks after alkalinity enhancement. Additional tests showed that such secondary precipitation can be initiated by particles acting as precipitation nuclei and that this process can occur even at lower levels of OAE. In conclusion, in scenarios like our study with carbonate-based OAE, where the carbon is already sequestered, the risk of major and sustained impacts on biogeochemical functioning may be low in the nutrient-poor ocean. However, the durability of carbon sequestration using OAE could be constrained by alkalinity loss in supersaturated waters with precipitation nuclei present. Our study provides an evaluation of the ecosystem impacts of an idealised OAE deployment for monitoring, reporting, and verification in an oligotrophic system. Whether biogeochemical functioning is resilient to more technically simple and economically viable approaches that induce stronger water chemistry perturbations remains to be seen.
- Open Access
- 9 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Comment on egusphere-2025-381
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added alkalinity, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of alkalinity is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the alkalinity stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ~11 °C, Sal.: ~32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or stopping the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added alkalinity. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes reducing the available reactive particle surface area is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.
- 9 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-381
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added alkalinity, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of alkalinity is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the alkalinity stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ~11 °C, Sal.: ~32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or stopping the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added alkalinity. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes reducing the available reactive particle surface area is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.
- Open Access
- 17 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Surface area and Ω-aragonite oversaturation as controls of the runaway precipitation process in ocean alkalinity enhancement
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added alkalinity, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of alkalinity is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the alkalinity stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ~11 °C, Sal.: ~32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or stopping the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added alkalinity. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes reducing the available reactive particle surface area is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.
- 17 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Open AccessSurface area and Ω-aragonite oversaturation as controls of the runaway precipitation process in ocean alkalinity enhancement
Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a strategy for marine carbon dioxide removal that aims to increase the total alkalinity (TA) of seawater to sequester atmospheric CO2 in the form of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC). An intense alkalinization of seawater resulting from OAE treatment could trigger a significant runaway carbonate precipitation process, which may lead to a loss of initially added alkalinity, thereby limiting its efficiency. Even under natural background aragonite saturation states, a continuous yet barely detectable loss of alkalinity is theoretically expected to occur in seawater. With the additional increase through OAE, time ranges to initiate an appreciable TA loss process could be reduced significantly. Therefore, predicting the alkalinity stability ranges might be a necessity for application scenarios. The main drivers of the precipitation process are i) the aragonite saturation state of seawater and ii) the available surface area for heterogeneous precipitation. In this study, we refined the use of logistic functions to describe the temporal evolution of both drivers, with experimental datasets using natural seawater from the Raunefjorden (Bergen, Norway; Temp.: ~11 °C, Sal.: ~32.6). The observed patterns were then used to derive a process-based model for calculating TA-loss rates, focusing on the accelerated precipitation phase of the runaway process while considering saturation levels and available particle surface area. The formation of carbonate phases reduces seawater TA concentrations, inducing a delay or stopping the TA-loss process. In addition, the sinking of precipitated particles decreases the potential for further precipitation by reducing the available surface area in the system. To assess the impact of particle sinking on TA-loss, their shape and size distribution were determined. Under the environmental conditions presented here, TA-loss rates could be reduced by up to 30–40 % due to the sinking of particles, after just one day. Integrating the proposed concepts into ocean models could enhance the accuracy of predictions regarding the fate of added alkalinity. Gaining insights into the evolution of the identified, seemingly stable TA levels can help prevent accelerated precipitation phases. Additionally, an understanding of particle sinking or dilution processes reducing the available reactive particle surface area is relevant to assess the efficacy and durability of OAE.