E. V. Smirnova
Research Subjects
E. V. Smirnova has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Vasiliy G. Kaleda
FSBSI Mental Health Research Centre
4 shared publications - A. G. Alekseeva
FSBSI “Mental Health Research Centre
3 shared publications - Ekaterina V. Gedevani
Mental Health Research Center
2 shared publications - Grigoriy I. Kopeyko
Mental Health Research Center
2 shared publications - Olga A. Borisova
FSBSI “Mental Health Research Centre
2 shared publications - Yu. A. Chaika
Russian Mental Health Research Center
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 17 October 2026
- Published by Medical Informational Agency Publishers in Psychiatry (Moscow) (Psikhiatriya)
- Vol. 24 (4) , 93-102
Dynamics of Religiosity in Endogenous Psychoses with ReligiousDepressive-Delusional Syndrome: Clinical and Follow-Up Study
Background : it remains unclear whether religiosity in depressive-delusional states represents exclusively a pathoplastic factor or whether the patterns of its changes at different stages of the disease constitute an independent prognostic marker. The Aim was to identi cate patterns of religiosity transformation at various stages of the course of endogenous disorders accompanied by religious-depressive-delusional syndrome (RDDS), and to substantiate their differential diagnostic and prognostic signi cance. Patients and Methods : a total of 104 patients with endogenous mental disorders (F31.5, F33.3, F25.1, F20.01, F20.0 on ICD-10) with clinical picture RDDS were included. There are two groups of patients: a clinical group (n = 58) and a follow-up group ( n = 46; mean follow-up period 12.24 ± 2.7 years). Three typological variants of RDDS were identi ed: Type I (with predominance of affectcongruent depressive delusions) — 22 cases (21.2%), Type II (with acute sensory delusions) — 36 patients (34.6%). Type III (with predominance of Kandinsky–Clérambault syndrome) — 46 (44.2%) cases. Religiosity at the pre-manifest stage was assessed using the history analysis ( n = 58) based on G. Allport's religious orientation concept and C.Y. Glock's multidimensional model. The Centrality of Religiosity Scale (CRS; S. Huber) and the Religious Coping Scale (K. Pargament) were applied in remission and follow-up stages ( n = 46). Clinical-psychopathological, clinical-follow-up, psychometric, and statistical methods (χ 2 , Cramér's V) were used. Results : type-speci c patterns of religiosity dynamics were closely associated with disease follow-up outcome. Stable harmonious hyperreligiosity with a protective function developed (mean CRS score 4.1 [3.89; 4.37]) in Type I. Bidirectional changes in religious worldview were observed in Type II: in some cases religiosity declined (CRS subtype 1: 3.4 [3.33; 3.47]), in others it intensi ed (subtype 2: 4.1 [4.0; 4.2]). Pathological “patchwork” religiosity was found in Type III (CRS 4.48 [4.47; 4.6]), intricately associated with residual productive symptomatology. A statistically signi cant association was established between RDDS type and both the pattern of religiosity dynamics (χ 2 = 38.38; p < 0.001; V = 0.655) and follow-up outcome (χ 2 = 28.25; p < 0.001; V = 0.6). Conclusion : religiosity in religious depressive-delusional syndrome represents not only a pathoplastic factor determining the content of psychopathological experiences, but may also be regarded as a clinically signi cant indicator associated with the type of disease course and outcome, which substantiates the necessity of differentiated therapeutic management.
- 17 October 2026
- Published by Medical Informational Agency Publishers in Psychiatry (Moscow) (Psikhiatriya)
- Vol. 24 (4) , 93-102
Open AccessDynamics of Religiosity in Endogenous Psychoses with ReligiousDepressive-Delusional Syndrome: Clinical and Follow-Up Study
Background : it remains unclear whether religiosity in depressive-delusional states represents exclusively a pathoplastic factor or whether the patterns of its changes at different stages of the disease constitute an independent prognostic marker. The Aim was to identi cate patterns of religiosity transformation at various stages of the course of endogenous disorders accompanied by religious-depressive-delusional syndrome (RDDS), and to substantiate their differential diagnostic and prognostic signi cance. Patients and Methods : a total of 104 patients with endogenous mental disorders (F31.5, F33.3, F25.1, F20.01, F20.0 on ICD-10) with clinical picture RDDS were included. There are two groups of patients: a clinical group (n = 58) and a follow-up group ( n = 46; mean follow-up period 12.24 ± 2.7 years). Three typological variants of RDDS were identi ed: Type I (with predominance of affectcongruent depressive delusions) — 22 cases (21.2%), Type II (with acute sensory delusions) — 36 patients (34.6%). Type III (with predominance of Kandinsky–Clérambault syndrome) — 46 (44.2%) cases. Religiosity at the pre-manifest stage was assessed using the history analysis ( n = 58) based on G. Allport's religious orientation concept and C.Y. Glock's multidimensional model. The Centrality of Religiosity Scale (CRS; S. Huber) and the Religious Coping Scale (K. Pargament) were applied in remission and follow-up stages ( n = 46). Clinical-psychopathological, clinical-follow-up, psychometric, and statistical methods (χ 2 , Cramér's V) were used. Results : type-speci c patterns of religiosity dynamics were closely associated with disease follow-up outcome. Stable harmonious hyperreligiosity with a protective function developed (mean CRS score 4.1 [3.89; 4.37]) in Type I. Bidirectional changes in religious worldview were observed in Type II: in some cases religiosity declined (CRS subtype 1: 3.4 [3.33; 3.47]), in others it intensi ed (subtype 2: 4.1 [4.0; 4.2]). Pathological “patchwork” religiosity was found in Type III (CRS 4.48 [4.47; 4.6]), intricately associated with residual productive symptomatology. A statistically signi cant association was established between RDDS type and both the pattern of religiosity dynamics (χ 2 = 38.38; p < 0.001; V = 0.655) and follow-up outcome (χ 2 = 28.25; p < 0.001; V = 0.6). Conclusion : religiosity in religious depressive-delusional syndrome represents not only a pathoplastic factor determining the content of psychopathological experiences, but may also be regarded as a clinically signi cant indicator associated with the type of disease course and outcome, which substantiates the necessity of differentiated therapeutic management.
- 30 June 2026
- Published by PANORAMA Publishing House in Vestnik Nevrologii, Psihiatrii i Nejrohirurgii (Bulletin of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery)
- No. 7,p. 1116-1129
Depressive-delusional states with religious content (evolution of concepts and unresolved issues)
Depressive-delusional states with religious content represent a distinct clinical form of psychotic depression, characterized by a distinctive psychopathological presentation, therapeutic resistance, elevated suicidal risk, and an unfavorable prognosis relative to non-psychotic depressive disorders. Despite a lengthy history of clinical description, targeted systematic investigation of this subject has not been conducted. The present review is devoted to the systematization and analysis of Russian and international literature addressing the psychopathology, nosological differentiation, dynamics of religiosity, and therapeutic management of depressive-delusional states with religious content. Publications of historical, clinical-psychopathological, therapeutic, and rehabilitative orientation are examined. It has been established that depressive religious delusion does not represent a phenomenologically neutral coloring of psychosis: it exerts an independent effect on the course, therapeutic dynamics, and prognosis of endogenous disorders, and is associated with reduced treatment adherence, attenuated symptom reduction, and, in a proportion of cases, increased suicidal risk. Based on the reviewed literature, the principles of pharmacotherapy and psychosocial rehabilitation have been systematized with due consideration of patients’ religious worldview, including confessionally oriented forms of psychotherapeutic intervention; issues of instrumental clinical assessment of religiosity are also addressed. The analyzed data substantiate the necessity of conducting a targeted comprehensive study of depressive-delusional states with religious content, incorporating clinical and clinical-follow-up components, aimed at the development of differentiated approaches to the treatment and rehabilitation of this patient population.
- 30 June 2026
- Published by PANORAMA Publishing House in Vestnik Nevrologii, Psihiatrii i Nejrohirurgii (Bulletin of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery)
- No. 7,p. 1116-1129
Depressive-delusional states with religious content (evolution of concepts and unresolved issues)
Depressive-delusional states with religious content represent a distinct clinical form of psychotic depression, characterized by a distinctive psychopathological presentation, therapeutic resistance, elevated suicidal risk, and an unfavorable prognosis relative to non-psychotic depressive disorders. Despite a lengthy history of clinical description, targeted systematic investigation of this subject has not been conducted. The present review is devoted to the systematization and analysis of Russian and international literature addressing the psychopathology, nosological differentiation, dynamics of religiosity, and therapeutic management of depressive-delusional states with religious content. Publications of historical, clinical-psychopathological, therapeutic, and rehabilitative orientation are examined. It has been established that depressive religious delusion does not represent a phenomenologically neutral coloring of psychosis: it exerts an independent effect on the course, therapeutic dynamics, and prognosis of endogenous disorders, and is associated with reduced treatment adherence, attenuated symptom reduction, and, in a proportion of cases, increased suicidal risk. Based on the reviewed literature, the principles of pharmacotherapy and psychosocial rehabilitation have been systematized with due consideration of patients’ religious worldview, including confessionally oriented forms of psychotherapeutic intervention; issues of instrumental clinical assessment of religiosity are also addressed. The analyzed data substantiate the necessity of conducting a targeted comprehensive study of depressive-delusional states with religious content, incorporating clinical and clinical-follow-up components, aimed at the development of differentiated approaches to the treatment and rehabilitation of this patient population.
- 21 December 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in S.S. Korsakov Journal of Neurology and Psychiatry
- Vol. 123 (11) , 101-107
Psychopathology of depressive-delusional states with religious content
Objective. Identification of psychopathological characteristics of depressive-delusional states with religious content, development of a typology, determination of formation features, nosological assessment. Material and methods. A total of 79 patients (47 female, 32 male, mean age 27±6.5 years) with depressive-delusional states with religious content within the affective and schizophrenia spectrum disorders were studied. Clinical-psychopathological, psychometric (PANSS, HDRS, S. Huber CRS) and statistical methods were used. Results. Based on the psychopathological structure, specific mechanisms of development of delusions and themes of the religious experiences, three types of depressive-delusional states were identified: type 1 — with a predominance of depressive delusions congruent with affect and delusional ideas of guilt, sinfulness, abandonment of God (14 patients, 17.7%; 6 women, 8 men; mean age 28±4.5 years; HDRS score 33±5.6, the total PANSS score 71±5.3, the PANSS positive subscale score 15.8±3.7); type 2 — with the addition of incongruent delusional constructs, persecutory disorders and acute sensory delusions to the existing depressive religious delusion, with the phenomenon of confessional ambivalence (27 patients, 34.2%; 16 women, 11 men; mean age at attack manifestation 25±9 years; HDRS score 29.6±4.4, the total PANSS score 87±6.2, the PANSS positive subscale score 23.5±4.2); type 3 — depressive-paranoid states with a predominance of Kandinsky-Clerambault syndrome of religious content (38 cases, 48.1%; 20 women, 18 men; mean age at attack manifestation 23.4±2.5 years; HDRS score 32.7±3.7, the total PANSS score 102±7.3, the PANSS positive subscale score 32.5±4.5). Conclusion. The study of depressive-delusional states with religious content has shown their clinical-psychopathological heterogeneity. The religious experiences served as a pathoplastic factor, which essentially modified the clinical-psychopathological picture of the disease due to presence of the specific religious phenomena. The identified types of depressive-delusional disorders with religious content had different diagnostic value.
- 21 December 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in S.S. Korsakov Journal of Neurology and Psychiatry
- Vol. 123 (11) , 101-107
Psychopathology of depressive-delusional states with religious content
Objective. Identification of psychopathological characteristics of depressive-delusional states with religious content, development of a typology, determination of formation features, nosological assessment. Material and methods. A total of 79 patients (47 female, 32 male, mean age 27±6.5 years) with depressive-delusional states with religious content within the affective and schizophrenia spectrum disorders were studied. Clinical-psychopathological, psychometric (PANSS, HDRS, S. Huber CRS) and statistical methods were used. Results. Based on the psychopathological structure, specific mechanisms of development of delusions and themes of the religious experiences, three types of depressive-delusional states were identified: type 1 — with a predominance of depressive delusions congruent with affect and delusional ideas of guilt, sinfulness, abandonment of God (14 patients, 17.7%; 6 women, 8 men; mean age 28±4.5 years; HDRS score 33±5.6, the total PANSS score 71±5.3, the PANSS positive subscale score 15.8±3.7); type 2 — with the addition of incongruent delusional constructs, persecutory disorders and acute sensory delusions to the existing depressive religious delusion, with the phenomenon of confessional ambivalence (27 patients, 34.2%; 16 women, 11 men; mean age at attack manifestation 25±9 years; HDRS score 29.6±4.4, the total PANSS score 87±6.2, the PANSS positive subscale score 23.5±4.2); type 3 — depressive-paranoid states with a predominance of Kandinsky-Clerambault syndrome of religious content (38 cases, 48.1%; 20 women, 18 men; mean age at attack manifestation 23.4±2.5 years; HDRS score 32.7±3.7, the total PANSS score 102±7.3, the PANSS positive subscale score 32.5±4.5). Conclusion. The study of depressive-delusional states with religious content has shown their clinical-psychopathological heterogeneity. The religious experiences served as a pathoplastic factor, which essentially modified the clinical-psychopathological picture of the disease due to presence of the specific religious phenomena. The identified types of depressive-delusional disorders with religious content had different diagnostic value.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in S.S. Korsakov Journal of Neurology and Psychiatry
- Vol. 122 (6) , 49-55
Suicidal risk in depressions with religious content
The review highlights the main issues of positive and negative religious coping in depression with suicidal behavior. The number of clinical and psychological factors related to suicide risk (age, gender, clinics of depression, internal and external religious orientation, the role of religious community, social support and ethical assessment of suicide) is discussed. To develop personalized approaches to the complex therapy of suicidal behavior, it is advisable to devote further research to studying the influence of the religious factor on depressive states with different levels of severity of psychopathological disorders.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in S.S. Korsakov Journal of Neurology and Psychiatry
- Vol. 122 (6) , 49-55
Suicidal risk in depressions with religious content
The review highlights the main issues of positive and negative religious coping in depression with suicidal behavior. The number of clinical and psychological factors related to suicide risk (age, gender, clinics of depression, internal and external religious orientation, the role of religious community, social support and ethical assessment of suicide) is discussed. To develop personalized approaches to the complex therapy of suicidal behavior, it is advisable to devote further research to studying the influence of the religious factor on depressive states with different levels of severity of psychopathological disorders.