DMDauren Bakhtybayuly Makhambetsaliyev

Dauren Bakhtybayuly Makhambetsaliyev

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Dauren Bakhtybayuly Makhambetsaliyev has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The Executable Statute: Agency Code and the Interpretation Loper Bright Cannot See

    by Dauren Makhambetsaliyev

    Loper Bright held that courts, not agencies, decide what statutes mean. But the agency readings that govern the most people never reach a court. They are written into the software that determines eligibility for benefits, flags returns, and screens claims. In that code a statutory standard becomes a numerical threshold, a statutory silence becomes a rule, and a permissive power becomes a default. Each choice is an interpretation, and none is published. This Article calls the phenomenon the executable statute and documents it in federal and federally supervised programs, drawing on agency records, inspector general audits, and judicial findings. It then identifies the Loper Bright paradox. A reading an agency writes down receives at most Skidmore weight and yields to the court's own reading, while a reading an agency computes governs every case and is weighed by no one. The Article argues that the Administrative Procedure Act already supplies the cure. An encoded component that fixes an outcome-determinative reading, with no structural path for an official to depart from it, is a rule under section 551(4)-an executable rule. As such, it must be published, opened to comment where section 553 requires, explained in a version note, and reviewed and remedied at the level of the rule rather than the individual case.

  • Beyond the ballot box: Evaluating institutional coupling between citizens’ assemblies and parliamentary procedures in Ireland and France

    by Dauren B Makhambetsaliyev

    This article examines the institutional mechanisms through which citizens’ assemblies (CAs) connect with parliamentary procedures in Ireland and France, two pioneering democracies in the institutionalization of deliberative mini-publics. Drawing on a comparative case study analysis of the Irish Citizens’ Assembly (2016–2018) and the French Convention Citoyenne pour le Climat (2019–2020), we develop a typology of institutional coupling mechanisms that mediate between deliberative and representative institutions. Our findings reveal that while both jurisdictions have embraced CAs as supplements to parliamentary democracy, they exhibit distinct patterns of integration: Ireland demonstrates “tight coupling” through formalized procedural integration—specifically the use of dedicated joint parliamentary committees and constitutional referendums—whereas France exhibits “loose coupling” characterized by executive mediation and high-stakes presidential commitments that lack robust legislative follow-through. We argue that effective institutional coupling requires a tripartite alignment of formal transmission protocols, dedicated parliamentary accountability structures, and sustained political commitment to implementation. The article contributes to the scholarship on democratic innovation by demonstrating that the efficacy of citizens’ assemblies depends not merely on their internal deliberative quality, but critically on how they are institutionally embedded within the existing parliamentary architecture.

  • Proportionality and the interpretation of conflicting equality rights: lessons from For Women Scotland

    by Dauren B Makhambetsaliyev

    The Supreme Court in For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers [2025] UKSC 16 held that ‘sex’ in the Equality Act 2010 means biological sex only, resolving through statutory interpretation a conflict between sex-based rights and trans recognition interests. This article critiques the Court’s refusal to engage in proportionality analysis when adjudicating conflicts between protected characteristics. Drawing on comparative jurisprudence, rights-balancing theory, and equality law scholarship, it argues that such conflicts require transparent proportionate balancing rather than categorical resolution through interpretative technique. The article proposes a structured, context-sensitive framework grounded in established proportionality doctrine that would enable principled adjudication whilst maintaining legal certainty for duty-bearers. It contends that binary interpretative choices, while providing surface clarity, present as textually determined what are in fact normative judgments about the relative weight of competing equality interests, thereby obscuring the evaluative reasoning inherent in rights adjudication and foreclosing more sophisticated responses to the graduated nature of equality conflicts.

  • Retrospective legislation and the rule of law: a doctrinal and comparative analysis

    by Dauren B Makhambetsaliyev

    Retrospective legislation—laws that alter the legal consequences of actions committed before their enactment—poses a persistent challenge to the foundational principles of the rule of law. This article provides a doctrinal and comparative analysis of retrospective statutes, employing a dual analytical framework that examines the tension they create between parliamentary sovereignty and the requirements of legal certainty, non-arbitrariness, and fairness through both rule of law principles and human rights considerations. While the UK constitutional tradition recognizes the supremacy of Parliament to legislate retrospectively, this power remains controversial, especially when viewed through the lens of Diceyan orthodoxy and more recent conceptions of the rule of law articulated by Lord Bingham. The article begins by distinguishing between criminal and civil retrospective laws, and between truly and apparently retrospective measures, while acknowledging important exceptions such as war crimes legislation and curative retrospective laws. It then critically assesses leading UK case law, including Burmah Oil, War Damage Act 1965, ex parte Pierson, AXA General Insurance Ltd v HM Advocate, and recent legislation such as the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023 and the Post Office (Horizon System) Offences Act 2024, to examine the judiciary’s evolving stance on the legitimacy and limits of retrospective legislation. The discussion is enriched by a comparative perspective, drawing on legal frameworks in the European Union, Germany, and the USA—selected to represent distinct constitutional approaches ranging from formal prohibition to principle-based limitation—each of which imposes constitutional or judicial constraints on retroactive law-making. The article demonstrates that retrospective legislation is not inherently illegitimate but requires careful justification and procedural safeguards. The UK’s flexible constitutional order, while pragmatic, lacks sufficient institutional mechanisms to prevent the misuse of retrospective legislation, particularly in contexts involving fundamental rights or punitive effects. Rather than advocating for absolute prohibition, the article concludes by proposing enhanced procedural constraints, clearer doctrinal guidance, and the potential development of soft constitutional principles that can guide both Parliament and the judiciary in ensuring retrospective law-making remains exceptional, transparent, and aligned with rule of law values. The analysis reveals that the future of responsible retrospective legislation lies not in categorical prohibition but in principled governance through reason, clarity, and institutional accountability.


  • Open Access

    Religion, Morality, Law and Abortion Policy

    by Dauren Makhambetsaliyev

    The abortion controversy often affects both religion and politics. Abortion is a highly politicized issue, as governments often seek to amend abortion laws according to elected leaders' preferences or the electorate's mood. However, few studies establish a causal relationship between leader preferences and abortion outcomes. In this article, we reveal whether the religious affiliation of legislators affects the number of abortions in the districts they elect, provided their party affiliation. The question is why the debate about abortion does not stop, why it becomes an arena of intense struggle not only around changes in the family, where politics is at stake. Regulation of abortion was not widespread at the time of the republic's founding, but it became pervasive within the next century. By the twentieth century, abortion had become strictly regulated throughout the nation. As time progressed, numerous states relaxed their laws in response to pressure for political change. Typical grounds for allowing abortion included pregnancies that presented a danger to the mother's life, resulted from rape or incest, or carried the likelihood of congenital disabilities, to establish a woman's freedom to choose as a fundamental national right, advocates for a woman's freedom to choose expanded their plan from the legislature to the courts. A natural person explains this by a lack of political commitment. We investigate the role of preferences of legislators around the world. In particular, since Muslims express more tremendous opposition to abortion than Hindus, we ask whether Muslim legislators are more effective in reducing sexual intercourse.

  • Open Access

    UNRAVELING THE THREADS OF CONSTITUTIONAL INTERPRETATION: EXPLORING KEY PRINCIPLES

    by D.B. Makhambetsaliyev, A.B. Rakymgaliyeva

    The analysis looks at how each of these principles influences the process of constitutional interpretation and how they may conflict or complement each other. Such an analysis helps to better understand how the judicial system makes decisions based on these principles and how they affect legal proceedings and enforcement within the constitutional framework. The principles of constitutional interpretation encompass a nuanced framework that defines the understanding and application of a country's foundational legal document. The cornerstone is textualism, which emphasises a literal reading of the constitutional text in order to ascertain its original intent. Such an approach is often aligned with originalism, which asserts that the constitution should be interpreted in accordance with the understanding of its framers. Conversely, living constitutionalism recognises the ability of the document to adapt to changes in society over time. It asserts that the meaning of the constitution evolves to address contemporary issues while preserving its core values. Precedent plays a crucial role and judicial decisions serve as a guide for future interpretations. The doctrine of stare decisis promotes consistency and stability in the interpretation of the law, thus promoting predictability in the application of constitutional principles. The structural approach to interpretation involves analysing the constitutional framework and the distribution of powers among the branches of government. This approach recognises that the architecture of the constitution reflects a deliberate choice in favour of maintaining a system of checks and balances. Keywords: Constitution, interpretation, princeples, constitutional law, origanalism, textualism, living constitutionalism, judicial review, historical context, strict construction, precedent, broad construction, original meaning, contextual interpretation, evolving standarts, rule of law, stare decisis.


  • Open Access

    Религия, мораль, закон и политика в отношении абортов

    by D. B. Makhambetsaliyev

    Споры об абортах часто затрагивают как религию, так и политику. Аборты - это крайне политизированный вопрос, поскольку правительства часто стремятся внести поправки в законы об абортах в соответствии с предпочтениями избранных лидеров или настроением электората. Однако лишь немногие исследования устанавливают причинно-следственную связь между предпочтениями лидера и исходами абортов. В этой статье мы раскрываем, влияет ли религиозная принадлежность законодателей на количество абортов в округах, которые они избирают, при условии их партийной принадлежности. Вопрос в том, почему дебаты об абортах не прекращаются, почему они становятся ареной напряженной борьбы не только вокруг изменений в семье, где на карту поставлена политика. Регулирование абортов не было широко распространено во время основания республики, но оно стало повсеместным в течение следующего столетия. К двадцатому веку аборты стали строго регулироваться по всей стране. С течением времени многие государства смягчили свои законы в ответ на давление, требующее политических перемен. Типичными основаниями для разрешения абортов были беременности, которые представляли опасность для жизни матери, были результатом изнасилования или кровосмешения или несли в себе вероятность врожденных отклонений. Чтобы закрепить свободу выбора женщины в качестве основного национального права, сторонники свободы выбора женщины расширили свой план от законодательного органа до суды. Физическое лицо объясняет это отсутствием политической приверженности. Мы исследуем роль предпочтений законодателей по всему миру. В частности, поскольку мусульмане выражают более решительное несогласие с абортами, чем индуисты, мы спрашиваем, являются ли мусульманские законодатели более эффективными в сокращении половых сношений. Ключевые слова: права на аборт, политика, либеральные взгляды, консервативные взгляды, эмбрион.

  • Open Access

    Как может отразиться утверждения судей (судейские кандидатуры) в Верховный суд США в американской политике?

    by D. B. Makhambetsaliyev, A. M. Karatayeva

    Новые кандидаты в Верховный суд США неизбежно и неизбежно носят политический правовой характер. В то время как общественные наблюдатели опасаются, что политические споры о кандидатах подрывают поддержку квалифицированных кандидатов и угрожают легитимности Суда, существует мало эмпирических доказательств в поддержку этих утверждений. Автор утверждает, что политическая борьба кандидатов в судьи даёт сигналы, которые формируют общественное мнение о кандидатах и Суде и поляризуют общественное мнение по партийным линиям. Данные совместного эксперимента, проведённого в первые дни президентства Трампа, подтверждают этот аргумент. Политическая риторика, приписываемая президенту Трампу и сенатским демократам, значительно поляризовала партийные взгляды на кандидатов и оценки легитимности Суда, причём республиканцы (демократы) выражали значительно более (менее) благоприятное отношение. Дополнительные анализы показывают, что вызов порождает различные партийные реакции, влияющие на мнение о беспристрастности кандидата. Эти выводы бросают вызов существующим взглядам, которые изображают отношение к судебной системе как стойкое к партийным соображениям и имеют важные последствия для легитимности Суда в поляризованную эпоху. Ключевые слова: совместный эксперимент; судебная легитимность; судебные номинации; поляризация; общественное мнение и суды.

  • CONSTITUTIONAL LEGAL REGULATION OF THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH IN THE UNITED STATES

    by Aigul Muratbayevna Karatayeva, Dauren Bakhtybayuly Makhambetsaliyev

    Американдық атқарушы (президенттік) билік ұзақ уақыттан бері әлеуметтік ғылымдарға қызығушылық танытып келеді және зерттеушілер мен бұқаралық ақпарат құралдарының назарын аударуда. АҚШ Конституциясы АҚШ үкіметінің тармақтарын, оларға берілген өкілеттіктер мен шектеулерді сипаттайды. II бапта атқарушы биліктің міндеттері баяндалады. Атқарушы билікке назар аудармағанына қарамастан, тарихшы Джек Раков президенттік лауазымды құрушылардың «ең шығармашылық әрекет» деп атады. Конституцияның II бабында жасаушылар әлемге мүлдем жаңа нәрсе ұсынды: билік тұқым қуалаушылықтан немесе күштен емес, халықтан шыққан атқарушы биліктің басшысы. Алайда Конституция Президенттің қазіргі кездегідей күшті болатындығы туралы аз мәлімет береді. Әзірлеушілер заң шығарушы билік әлдеқайда ықпалды болады деп нақты болжады. Мэдисон «егер біз ұсынған атқарушы билік заң шығарушы билікке қарсы тұру үшін жеткілікті беріктікке ие болса, сирек кездеседі» деп жазды. Кейіннен үкіметтің өзіне сеніп тапсырылған заңды билікпен тиімді басқару мүмкіндігі оның Америка халқының сенімін сақтау қабілетіне байланысты екендігін көрсетуге болады. Америка Құрама Штаттарының федералды үкіметінің атқарушы тармағы - өмірдің әртүрлі салаларынан шыққан және әртүрлі жеке құндылықтар жүйесін ұстанатын мыңдаған адам құрамдастарынан тұратын кең ауқымды, күрделі және көп деңгейлі ұйым болып табылады. Президенттің өкілеттіктері мен міндеттерін белгілейтін Конституцияның таңқаларлық қысқаша бөлімі (II бап) президенттер өз өкілеттіктерін икемді түрде түсіндіре алатын кең ауқымды қалдырады. (Президенттер мұны өз пайдасына жасауы таңқаларлық емес шығар). Көбінесе Президенттің өкілеттіктері II бапта нақты жазылмаған, бірақ тарихтың екі ғасырында жасалған нормаларды көрсетіп...

  • Open Access

    Conservative ideology in the U.S. Supreme Court in the 21st century

    by D.B. Makhambetsaliyev

    At the beginning of the new millennium, the United States entered a new Republican Party cycle. The competition between the two leading parties in the 2000 elections was more acute than ever. It even resulted in a protracted constitutional and political crisis, when the U.S. Supreme Court had to stop the prolonged recounts in Florida (five votes in favor, four against), which was beneficial to the Republican parties. However, the Republicans managed to strengthen their future positions, and Democrat Barack Obama replaced Republican George W. Bush in the White House only after his two presidential terms. Should understand American constitutional judicial lawmaking primarily as the Supreme Court’s lawmaking as the activity of processing, interpreting, applying, and repealing regulations. Lawmaking activities aim to fill the gaps in legislation and reflect the objective needs of public life. Hence the importance of constitutional judicial lawmaking in human rights and other areas of legal regulation. As a legal tool, the U.S. Supreme Court uses procedural requirements and arguments in relatively (and specifically) undeveloped and unmodified legislation. The basis of constitutional lawmaking is the U.S. Supreme Court’s role in overseeing the implementation of judicial procedures. The requirement to comply with the procedural guarantees included in the U.S. Constitution’s text, which coincides with common law’s procedural requirements, is given the meaning of constitutional principles by the U.S. Supreme Court. Thus, there was no reason for conservatism’s full triumph in the early 21st century, as in the last decade of the 20th century. This celebration is not visible in the activities of the Supreme Court. Due to the death of W. Rehnquist in 2005, John Roberts, whose biography was very similar to Rehnquist’s in terms of close ties to the Washington bureaucracy, filled the Chairman’s vacancy. The Supreme Court of the United States in national minorities’ rights until the 2000s, despite the turn to constitutional judicial conservatism, did not move to a complete activism revision. The Court’s main goal was not to attack affirmative measures but to interpret state regulation’s doctrinal grounds, such as equal protection by law and due process. Still, conservative courts failed to change the role and reformat the meaning of doctrines. Keywords: conservative ideology, conservatism, U.S. Supreme Court, constitutional judicial doctrines, U.S. Constitution, dissenting opinions of U.S. Supreme Court justices, conservative decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court. References: [1] Alden v. Maine, 527 U.S. 706 (1999). [2] Arizona v. Evans 514 U.S. 1 (1995). [3] Bowers v. Hardwick 478 U.S. 186 (1986) [4] Burns J. M. Packing the Court. P. 99. [5] Cases and Material. P. 478- 561. [6] Chemerinsky E. The Conservative Assault on the Constitution. 2010. P. 176. [7] Eisenstadt v. Baird 435 U.S. 438 (1972). [8] Ibid, P. 577. [9] Griswold v. Connecticut, 381 U.S. 479 (1965). [10] Gonrales v. Carhart, 550 U.S. 124 (2007). [11] Hudson v. Michigan, 547 U.S. 586 (2006). [12] Johnson J. Privacy and the Judgment of Others // Journal of Value Inquiry. 1989. Vol. 23. №3. 157-168. [13] Kozochkın I. D. Ýgolovnoe pravo SShA. Ýspehı ı problemy reformırovanııa. SPb.: Iýrıdıcheskıı tsentr-Press, 2007. 478 s. [14] Kimel v. Florida Board of Regents 528 U.S. (2001). [15] Marbury v. Madison, 5 U.S. 137 (1803). [16] Miranda v. Arizona 384 U.S. 436 (1966). [17] Mueller v. Mena, 544 U.S. 293 (2005). [18] Mobil Oil Exploration v. United States 530 U.S. 604 (2000). [19] Pozner R. How Judges Think. P. 371-372. 2009. [20] Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey 505 U.S. 833 (1992). [21] Lawrence v. Texas, 539 U.S. 558 (2003). [22] Lindquist S. Op. cit. p. 18; Auerbach J. Unequal Justice. Lawyers and Social Change in America. P. 10-12. [23] Rossum R. Antonin Scalia’s Jurisprudence. P. 8 (2006). [24] Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973). [25] Safonov V. N. Konstıtýtsııa SShA ı sotsıalno-ekonomıcheskoe prava grajdan. M.: Norma, 2007-2008. [26] SShA. Konstıtýtsııa ı zakonodatelnye akty. / Pod red. O.A. Jıdkova - M., 1993. - 768. [27] Vlasıhın V. Fenomen Verhovnogo Sýda SShA. Amerıkanskıı areopag v pervom dome na pervoı ýlıtse // Rossııskaıa ıýstıtsııa. 2000. №11. S. 55-58. [28] Vlasıhın V. Fenomen Verhovnogo Sýda SShA. Amerıkanskıı areopag v pervom dome na pervoı ýlıtse // Rossııskaıa ıýstıtsııa. 2000. №11. S. 56. [29] Obergeffel v. Hodges, (2015). [30] Vacco v. Quill, 117 S. Ct. 2293 (1997). [31] 14 Penn Plaza v. Pyett, 129 S. Ct. 1456 (2009). [32] Washington v. Glucksberg 117 v. S. Ct. 2258 (1997).