MNMfanelo Patrick Ntsobi

Mfanelo Patrick Ntsobi

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Mfanelo Patrick Ntsobi has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Determining Sample Size in Qualitative Research Across Case Study, Phenomenology, Grounded Theory, Narrative Inquiry and Ethnography: A Systematic Review

    by King Costa, Mfanelo Ntsobi, Gail Parker, Letlhogonolo Mfolo, Danisizitha Thusi

    Introduction: Sample-size determination in qualitative research remains contested because adequacy is shaped by the research question, methodological purpose, participant specificity, data richness, analytical strategy and stopping rationale. The supplied literature reports numerical ranges, but does not establish universal minimums across qualitative methodologies. Methods: The researcher-selected databases and information sources were Google Scholar, ERIC. The eligibility protocol restricted publication years to 2025–2026. The exact calendar date of search execution was not recorded in the verified identification provenance; this is distinct from the publication-year eligibility range. A systematic review searched Google Scholar and ERIC using a prespecified Boolean strategy and publication eligibility range of 2025–2026. Results: Across the synthesis, sample adequacy was primarily treated as a design-sensitive judgement rather than a universal numerical threshold. Focused, homogeneous and information-rich samples generally supported smaller samples, whereas broad, comparative and heterogeneous designs required more data. Saturation was useful when operationalised as an ongoing evaluative process, but its meaning and applicability were contested. Grounded Theory provided the clearest method-specific stopping logic through theoretical sampling and theoretical saturation. Ethnographic guidance was comparatively underdeveloped, while numerical ranges for phenomenology and narrative inquiry remained illustrative rather than definitive. Discussion/Conclusion: While there was no generally accepted minimum sample size was established for any reviewed methodology, there seem to be a recommendation of 10 to 15 interviews. Furthermore, a defensible sample-size decision should be justified prospectively in relation to design, scope, sampling logic, information power, data quality, analytic aims and an explicitly documented stopping assessment.

  • Open Access

    A Theoretical Perspective of Teaching Qualitative Evidence Synthesis in Higher Education Institutions as a Research Method

    by King Costa, Nisi Thusi, Mfanelo Patrick Ntsobi, Letlhogonolo Nolo Mfolo, Bongani June Mwale, Nkateko Raymond Maluleke

    Introduction: The teaching of qualitative evidence synthesis (QES) in higher education is crucial for producing comprehensive and rigorous qualitative research. Despite its importance, teaching QES faces challenges such as methodological complexity and a lack of standardized materials. This study explores theoretical perspectives on teaching QES and proposes effective methodologies for higher education.Methods: A qualitative evidence synthesis approach was adopted using the SALSA (Search, Appraisal, Synthesis, and Analysis) framework. Articles were selected using the SPIDER (Sample, Phenomenon of Interest, Design, Evaluation, Research type) tool, which is tailored for qualitative and mixed-methods research. Data were collected through interviews with educators and students and analyzed using thematic analysis to identify key themes and patterns.Results: Effective teaching strategies for QES include interactive workshops, practical sessions, and the use of real-world examples and case studies. Technology integration, such as qualitative data analysis software and virtual learning environments, enhances learning experiences. Feedback from students highlights the importance of hands-on activities and collaboration. Educators emphasize the need for innovative teaching strategies and continuous professional development.Discussion: Integrating constructivist and experiential learning theories into QES education promotes active engagement and critical thinking. Institutional support and comprehensive curriculum development are essential for successful integration. Continuous training for educators ensures they are equipped to teach QES effectively. Conclusion: Teaching QES in higher education presents unique challenges and opportunities. By applying constructivist and experiential learning theories, educators can develop effective strategies that enhance student understanding of QES methodologies. Future research should explore additional strategies for improving QES education and its long-term impacts on students' research skills.

  • Open Access

    The Evolution of STEM as Praxis: Reimagining Science Education for a Changing World – a 21st Century Perspective

    by King Costa, Mfanelo Patrick Ntsobi, Letlhogonolo Nolo Mfolo, Bongani June Mwale, Dumisani Nyingwa, Nkateko Raymond Maluleke, Vincent Zulu, Nisi Thusi, Sibusiso Nhlapo, Blondel Nyamkure, et al.

    The transition from STEM to STEAM and STREAM education, integrating the arts into science, technology, research, engineering, and mathematics, addresses the demand for comprehensive skills. This study identifies significant gaps, including the lack of enactive-ecological perspectives, robust technical foundations for integrating diverse knowledge domains, and the potential of mixed reality technologies in STEAM education. A literature review was conducted to explore these issues, revealing the need for continued research in the STREAM framework (STEM + Research + Arts). Addressing these gaps can enhance STEAM pedagogy, offering a richer educational experience that equips students for a complex global landscape, emphasizing interdisciplinary learning and creativity.

  • Strengthening financial sustainability: Evaluating strategic revenue diversification at the sci-bono discovery centre, South Africa

    by Mfanelo Ntsobi, Blondel Nyamkure, Bongani June Mwale, Dumisani Nyingwa

    The study examines various evidence-based strategies for diversifying revenue streams to mitigate Sci-Bono's financial deficiencies and issues, aiming to decrease dependence on conventional sources. Social capital theory (SCT), in conjunction with resource dependency theory (RDT) and stakeholder theory, elucidates dependence on external resources and the necessity of stakeholder engagement in financing diversification, emphasizing the importance of networks and trust in obtaining funding options. The study employed a mixed-methods approach grounded in a pragmatic paradigm to encourage methodological heterogeneity. It incorporated qualitative interviews with significant stakeholders and quantitative surveys of relevant demographics to establish validity through triangulation, pilot testing, and member verification. The study utilized purposive sampling with 30 respondents possessing extensive knowledge of science centre operations. Qualitative data was analyzed through thematic techniques, and surveys for qualitative constructs employed NVivo and SPSS for qualitative and quantitative analyses, respectively. To ensure financial sustainability, the study considers government grants, business partnerships, and community-based initiatives, including crowdsourcing and local fundraising, as well as governmental policies. Based on effective case studies from various institutions worldwide, the research offers tips that enable Sci-Bono to diversify its funding sources. The report emphasizes that maintaining Sci-Bono's sustainability and expansion depends on a deliberate mix of thematic diversity, stakeholder involvement, digital visibility, and cooperation with both national and international organizations. The study concludes that Sci-Bono should prioritize strengthening relationships between companies and communities, utilizing digital channels to enhance outreach and support bases, and adopting science-aligned programs to diversify income streams.

  • Open Access

    AN ANALYSIS OF COSTS OF PRIVATE PRISONS AGAINST PUBLIC PRISONS IN SOUTH AFRICA

    by Mfanelo Ntsobi

    This paper examines the costs, benefits, accountability, and human rights implications of private against public prisons in South Africa. The rationale is to determine which investment model between the two (public and private) is most economically viable as expressed in quantitative and financial terms. As such, the positive gains of the cost-benefit analysis should provide guidance in maintaining any prison model. The methodology that the study followed is Qualitative Systematic Archival Article Review. Data was collected through global and local archives, coded and analysed through triangulation, thematic and content analysis. This process was followed to establish robust themes and insights regarding the subject matter thereby enhancing rigor, reliability, and validity of the results. Consequently, the study noted that public prisons provide more value than private prisons in South Africa at this moment because of astronomical costs and human rights abuses associated with private prisons compared to public prisons. However, private prisons exhibit better maintenance as they provide improved living conditions for their smaller inmates’ population unlike public prisons. The study recommends that there should be robust training, strict monitoring, phased and gradual implementation of private prisons in South Africa. There should also be continuous evaluation of private prisons to ensure that they comply with government regulations.


  • Digital Tools and Techniques in Qualitative Research: Digital Skills and Research Optimisation

    by Mfanelo Pat Ntsobi, António Pedro Costa, Judita Kasperiuniene, Catarina Brandão, Jaime Ribeiro


  • Open Access

    THE EVOLUTION OF STEM AS A CONCEPT, IN SCIENCE EDUCATION – A 21ST CENTURY PERSPECTIVE

    by King Costa, Mfanelo Patrick Ntsobi, Nandipha Daphne Siwahla-Madiba

    The transition from STEM to STEAM education signifies a profound shift in contemporary pedagogy, acknowledging the need to integrate not just science, technology, engineering, and mathematics but also the arts into the learning process. This transformation is primarily driven by evolving job market demands, necessitating a more comprehensive skill set in students. Practical implications of this shift involve creative teaching techniques and technologies that foster imagination, experiential learning, and interdisciplinary comprehension. However, within the STEAM domain, significant knowledge gaps remain, offering opportunities for further exploration and development. The primary knowledge gap involves framing STEAM from an enactive-ecological viewpoint. While broader STEM and STEAM research is well-established, the application of enactive and ecological theories in the context of STEAM education is largely uncharted territory. Addressing this gap has the potential to enhance STEAM pedagogy by integrating insights from these theories into educational practices. The second gap relates to the technical underpinnings of integrated teaching and learning in STEM/STEAM contexts. Seamless integration of knowledge domains is vital for meaningful learning experiences that transcend traditional disciplinary boundaries. Robust technical foundations are needed, encompassing digital learning ecosystems, interdisciplinary content development, innovative pedagogical frameworks, accessibility, and inclusivity, professional development for educators, data analytics, and assessment, collaborative environments, real-world application, and immersive technologies. The third gap involves the incorporation of mixed reality (XR) as an educational technology approach within the STEAM framework from an enactive-ecological perspective. XR technologies, including augmented reality (AR), virtual reality (VR), and mixed reality, have the potential to greatly enhance STEAM education. However, further research is required to maximize the use of these technologies from an enactive-ecological standpoint, emphasizing active learning, sensorimotor engagement, experiential learning, and contextual understanding. The fourth knowledge gap emphasizes the importance of ongoing research in the STREAM (STEM + Research + Arts) narrative. Research is a cornerstone for advancing our understanding of the efficacy of various pedagogical approaches, the impact of integrating arts into STEM, the role of enactive-ecological theories, the outcomes of immersive technologies, and the development of unified models for interdisciplinary learning. Strong research practices inform evidence-based teaching and consistently enhance STEAM education. Finally, transition from STEM to STREAM is a crucial development in education, equipping students with the skills and knowledge needed to thrive in a rapidly changing world. While this shift promotes innovative teaching methods and technologies, addressing the identified knowledge gaps and prioritizing research are essential to fully realize the potential of STEAM education. Ultimately, it empowers students to excel in a dynamic and complex global landscape while advancing educational practices through empirical research and evidence-based approaches.


  • Open Access

    A Systematic Review of the Potential for Promotion of Southern Epistemologies in Educational Research: Ubuntu Philosophy as a Research Paradigm, a Conceptual Model

    by King Costa, Mfanelo Patrick Ntsobi

    INTRODUCTION The fast changing global trends, practices and ideologies have a potential to dissipate cultural identities of historically colonized nations, in favor for adoption of popularized perspectives. This problem is becoming more and more evident in South Africa due to urbanization and impact of globalization. However, this becomes a constant barrier in knowledge creation, development and management due to the fact that southern epistemologies remain pacified and under-utilized in scholarship and educational research. One such pacified epistemology in both social and educational research is Ubuntu. RESEARCH AIMS: The aim of this study is to determine the suitable application of Ubuntu philosophy in educational research. This will be achieved by answering a theoretical question: How can Ubuntu be adopted as a paradigm for research inquiries within a southern epistemological context?METHODS: The philosophy of Ubuntu is located within a subjective realist ontology. Applying non-intrusive research measures, a Scoping Review method was used to postulate evidence for adoption and application of Ubuntu philosophy as a research paradigm. Using a search engine comprising a number of social sciences databases (AnthroSource, ASSIA, Wilson Web and CSA), articles were appraised using the Systematic Review research protocols and analyzed using Critical Appraisal Skills Programme. The final activity for data analysis culminated into thematic analysis, using COSTA QDA technique. RESULTS: This study played a crucial role in magnifying the pacified voices of cultural epistemological contexts and existential realities. While the concept of Ubuntu is well researched across different disciplines, there was paucity of research on its adoption as a research paradigm and research design. The study found out that there were seminal works of established researchers on decoloniality and Afrocentrism, requesting consideration of Ubuntu as a research method. Thus, this scoping review found evidence that Ubuntu can and should be used as a research method in African contexts within social, economic and management sciences, as well as health and politics. CONCLUSION: It was concluded that institutions of higher learning should start teaching Ubuntu Action Research as a method of inquiry in their undergraduate and postgraduate research programmes. Consultants are also encouraged to investigate this research design approach for business and policy research.

  • Open Access

    PRIVATISATION OF PRISONS AND PRISON SERVICES IN SOUTH AFRICA

    by Mfanelo Patrick Ntsobi

    This study explored options for the provision of efficient prison services in South Africa. The researcher compared public and private prisons with respect to costs, quality, accountability and impact on jobs. The study also drew lessons from the international experience on prison privatisation. The primary objective of the study was to develop practical options for privatisation of prison and prison services in South Africa. The study includes a literature review as well as an assessment and selection of theoretical frameworks. The researcher relied on reports and legislation(s) with respect to prison privatisation. A case study was developed on three countries where prison privatisation had gained momentum (USA, Australia and UK). In Africa, at the research report focused on Lesotho, Malawi and Botswana, focusing on the extent of overcrowding and prison privatisation in these respective countries. The study found that, the legislation regulating private prisons favours private contractors and needs to be revisited. It also emerged that the privatisation of prisons and prison services has become an international trend, spreading to other continents such as Africa, Asia and South America. The study also found that the project on private prisons was rushed and not properly piloted in South Africa, however, it also came out that private prisons could coexist alongside private prisons. The general claim that private prisons are cheaper than public prisons could not be proved, especially in relation to South Africa. The main finding in relation to costs was that, private prisons have at least helped to come up with a formula to establish how much it really costs to keep a person in prison. Finally, the study concluded that the topic on prison privatisation needs further exploration and that; there is a need for renewed partnerships between private and public prisons that would be mutually beneficial.

  • Open Access

    The exigency of ICT Resources on Teaching and Learning in South African Primary Schools

    by Mfanelo Patrick Ntsobi

    The effect of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) on the teaching and learning fraterinity has globally necessitated its integration in the classroom. Nevertheless, it is important to note that the quest for Integration in individual school contexts remains an uphill task in-spite of ICT integration being a policy prerogative in a number of countries. This survey has the sole objective of unpacking how the teaching and learning process has been affected due to lack of ICT resources. By use of a simple questionnaire, the researcher made use of semi-structured interviews in order to solicit data from educators in selected South African primary schools. The interviews were transcribed manually and coded. The data analysis process was conducted by use of a thematic mode of analysis. The findindings thereof demonstrated that, due to many reasons, many schools do not make use of ICT tools in teaching and learning, as expected, and, in most cases, they do not maximise of the use of the existing resources, thus affecting the teaching and learningn processes. The reasearcher recommends that the South African Department of Basic Education (DBE) seriously takes into consideration individual school contexts when allocating ICT resources in order to try and mitigate the challenges. Stepping up the monitoring and evaluation mechanisms that are currently at play will help identify contextual challenges and the provision of assistance where necessary. Security issues also call for schools to team up with local communities to try and fight the theft and vandalization of IT resources. All these measures are meant to facilitate the preservation and use of ICT resources in the classroom for the betterment of the learning process.