Axel G. Ekström
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Axel G. Ekström has a total of 56 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Jens Edlund
Speech, Music & Hearing, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden
12 shared publications- Steven Moran
Institute of Biology, University of Neuchâtel
10 shared publications - Adriano R. Lameira
University of Warwick
4 shared publications David S. Strait
Paleo-Research Institute, University of Johannesburg, Johannesburg, South Africa
3 shared publicationsMelina Tsapos
Department of Philosophy, Lund University, Lund, Sweden
3 shared publicationsPeter Gärdenfors
Department of Philosophy, Lund University, Lund, Sweden
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 18 September 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Behavioral and Brain Sciences
- Vol. 49, e402
Sequence representation and cultural systems are necessary for cumulative culture
Chater and Christiansen explain cultural complexity as emerging through local social tinkering. We argue that this account can be complemented by two minimal principles: sequence representation as a cognitive prerequisite for cumulative culture and cultural-systems dynamics as a formal account of how interacting traits stabilize, constrain, and reshape later tinkering. Together, they explain how simple mechanisms generate complex cultural organization.
- 18 September 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Behavioral and Brain Sciences
- Vol. 49, e402
Sequence representation and cultural systems are necessary for cumulative culture
Chater and Christiansen explain cultural complexity as emerging through local social tinkering. We argue that this account can be complemented by two minimal principles: sequence representation as a cognitive prerequisite for cumulative culture and cultural-systems dynamics as a formal account of how interacting traits stabilize, constrain, and reshape later tinkering. Together, they explain how simple mechanisms generate complex cultural organization.
- Open Access
Structure without semantics: no evidence for bonobo compositionality in Berthet et al. (2025)
Understanding the evolutionary origins of combinatorial communication has motivated studies that analyse the semantic capacities of great ape vocal repertoires. A prominent example is the study by Berthet et al. (2025), which used Multiple Correspondence Analysis (MCA) on a large multidimensional dataset of bonobo calls and concluded that certain call combinations exhibit compositional meaning. We applied the published analytical pipeline to randomized datasets lacking any genuine association between call types and contextual features. Depending on implementation choices, the procedure identified significant relationships in 34.5–84.3% of simulations, suggesting substantial inflation of false-positive results. We therefore re-examined the statistical assumptions underlying the analysis itself. Because the MCA was constructed from repeated measures and uneven sampling across call types, its geometry reflects sampling frequencies and hierarchical dependencies in addition to any semantic structure. As such, any subsequent linear modelling of distances within this fixed space further violates assumptions of independence. We introduced a full permutation test in which a weighted MCA is recomputed under random reassignment of call-type labels, thereby generating a null distribution that respects the dependence structure of the data. Applying this procedure to the original dataset yielded a non-significant Monte Carlo p -value ( p = 0.2597), indicating that the observed between-call-type separation does not exceed chance expectations. We argue that interpreting MCA distances as semantic relations requires theoretically motivated feature selection and dependence-aware inference, both of which are lacking in the original analysis. We conclude that Berthet et al. (2025) do not provide any statistically significant evidence for bonobo compositionality and highlight the broader limitations of relying on exploratory post-hoc statistical inference to identify semantic structure in animal communication.
Open AccessStructure without semantics: no evidence for bonobo compositionality in Berthet et al. (2025)
Understanding the evolutionary origins of combinatorial communication has motivated studies that analyse the semantic capacities of great ape vocal repertoires. A prominent example is the study by Berthet et al. (2025), which used Multiple Correspondence Analysis (MCA) on a large multidimensional dataset of bonobo calls and concluded that certain call combinations exhibit compositional meaning. We applied the published analytical pipeline to randomized datasets lacking any genuine association between call types and contextual features. Depending on implementation choices, the procedure identified significant relationships in 34.5–84.3% of simulations, suggesting substantial inflation of false-positive results. We therefore re-examined the statistical assumptions underlying the analysis itself. Because the MCA was constructed from repeated measures and uneven sampling across call types, its geometry reflects sampling frequencies and hierarchical dependencies in addition to any semantic structure. As such, any subsequent linear modelling of distances within this fixed space further violates assumptions of independence. We introduced a full permutation test in which a weighted MCA is recomputed under random reassignment of call-type labels, thereby generating a null distribution that respects the dependence structure of the data. Applying this procedure to the original dataset yielded a non-significant Monte Carlo p -value ( p = 0.2597), indicating that the observed between-call-type separation does not exceed chance expectations. We argue that interpreting MCA distances as semantic relations requires theoretically motivated feature selection and dependence-aware inference, both of which are lacking in the original analysis. We conclude that Berthet et al. (2025) do not provide any statistically significant evidence for bonobo compositionality and highlight the broader limitations of relying on exploratory post-hoc statistical inference to identify semantic structure in animal communication.
- Open Access
- 6 August 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Anatomical Reorganisation Channels the Emergence of the Infant Vocal Repertoire
Why do infants the world over begin their vocal lives with growls, grunts, squeals, and creaky phonation? And why does this pattern hold across radically different languages and caregiving environments? We propose that the mechanical geometry of the vocal tract at each developmental stage acts as a continuously changing constraint on what infant vocal exploration can discover. Beyond limiting what sounds are possible, this geometry actively generates certain acoustic events as the natural consequence of ordinary exploratory activity. In the neonatal larynx, tissue properties lower the thresholds for phonatory regime transitions; in the tongue, fibre geometry confines early exploration to a single axis until hyoid descent and palatal deepening open new dimensions; in the anterior articulators, independently available components, such as lip closure and jaw oscillation, await the reorientation of suprahyoid muscles that makes their coupling discoverable. Drawing on the motor development literature and neuropsychology of learning, we argue that vocal repertoire emerges through the same discover-stabilise-differentiate logic that governs early limb control: the body generates variation before any intent exists, sensory consequences draw the infant back to the patterns that produced them, and stabilised motor-auditory mappings gradually become communicative resources. The sequence of vocal development can thus be understood as the natural output of exploration within a continuously reorganising anatomy, where each new configuration, through its own mechanical properties, redefines the acoustic possibilities that undirected exploration will discover.
- 6 August 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessAnatomical Reorganisation Channels the Emergence of the Infant Vocal Repertoire
Why do infants the world over begin their vocal lives with growls, grunts, squeals, and creaky phonation? And why does this pattern hold across radically different languages and caregiving environments? We propose that the mechanical geometry of the vocal tract at each developmental stage acts as a continuously changing constraint on what infant vocal exploration can discover. Beyond limiting what sounds are possible, this geometry actively generates certain acoustic events as the natural consequence of ordinary exploratory activity. In the neonatal larynx, tissue properties lower the thresholds for phonatory regime transitions; in the tongue, fibre geometry confines early exploration to a single axis until hyoid descent and palatal deepening open new dimensions; in the anterior articulators, independently available components, such as lip closure and jaw oscillation, await the reorientation of suprahyoid muscles that makes their coupling discoverable. Drawing on the motor development literature and neuropsychology of learning, we argue that vocal repertoire emerges through the same discover-stabilise-differentiate logic that governs early limb control: the body generates variation before any intent exists, sensory consequences draw the infant back to the patterns that produced them, and stabilised motor-auditory mappings gradually become communicative resources. The sequence of vocal development can thus be understood as the natural output of exploration within a continuously reorganising anatomy, where each new configuration, through its own mechanical properties, redefines the acoustic possibilities that undirected exploration will discover.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 159 (6) , 5650-5666
Vocal-tract length estimation from vowel formants benchmarked against acoustic pharyngometry
Estimating vocal-tract length (VTL) from vowel formants can aid speaker normalization, but few methods have been benchmarked against an anatomical reference in the same speakers. We combined acoustic pharyngometry (APh) and speech data from 42 adults to benchmark eight widely used formant-based VTL estimators against incisors-to-glottis length and to test an interpretable two-stage bias-corrected linear estimator. Across more than 400 000 central frames with valid F1–F4, traditional quarter-wave, odd-harmonic, and dispersion-type estimators correlated with VTLAPh but showed poor out-of-sample anatomical recovery and strong calibration compression. Re-estimated one-stage linear models reduced mean absolute error (MAE; median ≈1.0 cm) but still overestimated shorter tracts and underestimated longer tracts. A two-stage model markedly improved calibration and agreement, outperforming one-stage linear and nonlinear alternatives (median per-vowel MAE 0.39 cm, median out-of-sample R2=0.83). Front and front-rounded vowels were the most informative. Speaker-level 95% limits of agreement were about ±0.9 cm, indicating that the method is better suited to aggregated tract-scale estimation than to direct anatomical measurement. These results identify calibration bias as a central limitation of standard formant-based VTL estimators and provide a practical, interpretable route to tract-scale estimation from similarly processed labeled-vowel data under matched conditions.
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 159 (6) , 5650-5666
Open AccessVocal-tract length estimation from vowel formants benchmarked against acoustic pharyngometry
Estimating vocal-tract length (VTL) from vowel formants can aid speaker normalization, but few methods have been benchmarked against an anatomical reference in the same speakers. We combined acoustic pharyngometry (APh) and speech data from 42 adults to benchmark eight widely used formant-based VTL estimators against incisors-to-glottis length and to test an interpretable two-stage bias-corrected linear estimator. Across more than 400 000 central frames with valid F1–F4, traditional quarter-wave, odd-harmonic, and dispersion-type estimators correlated with VTLAPh but showed poor out-of-sample anatomical recovery and strong calibration compression. Re-estimated one-stage linear models reduced mean absolute error (MAE; median ≈1.0 cm) but still overestimated shorter tracts and underestimated longer tracts. A two-stage model markedly improved calibration and agreement, outperforming one-stage linear and nonlinear alternatives (median per-vowel MAE 0.39 cm, median out-of-sample R2=0.83). Front and front-rounded vowels were the most informative. Speaker-level 95% limits of agreement were about ±0.9 cm, indicating that the method is better suited to aggregated tract-scale estimation than to direct anatomical measurement. These results identify calibration bias as a central limitation of standard formant-based VTL estimators and provide a practical, interpretable route to tract-scale estimation from similarly processed labeled-vowel data under matched conditions.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews
- Vol. 34 (3) , e70019
Rethinking Hominin Air Sac Loss in Light of Phylogenetically Meaningful Evidence
The evolution of laryngeal air sacs in hominins has been a subject of considerable debate, with particular attention given to the inferred presence of air sacs in Australopithecus afarensis and inferred absence in Middle and Upper Pleistocene hominins. We challenge several assumptions prevalent in relevant discourse and assert that (1) while exhibiting morphological similarity, it cannot be ruled out that relationships between hyoid morphology and air sac morphology in extant African great apes may reflect convergence; (2) while the only known A. afarensis hyoid exhibits “ape‐like” bulla, this feature may have persisted following the loss of air sacs, and not be indicative of their presence per se; (3) because there are currently only five known hominin hyoid bones represented in the fossil record (with a single specimen predating the Middle Pleistocene) the evidential basis for interpreting air sac presence or absence is minimal; and (4) inferences toward a role of sexual selection and communicative behavior in explicating the loss of air sacs in the hominin lineage are undermined by the atypical sexual dimorphism patterns in early hominins. We advocate for a cautious approach to interpreting hominin behavior and evolution which prioritizes data over speculation, and underscore the need for rigorous evidence when constructing evolutionary narratives about early hominin vocal anatomy and its evolution.
- 18 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews
- Vol. 34 (3) , e70019
Open AccessRethinking Hominin Air Sac Loss in Light of Phylogenetically Meaningful Evidence
The evolution of laryngeal air sacs in hominins has been a subject of considerable debate, with particular attention given to the inferred presence of air sacs in Australopithecus afarensis and inferred absence in Middle and Upper Pleistocene hominins. We challenge several assumptions prevalent in relevant discourse and assert that (1) while exhibiting morphological similarity, it cannot be ruled out that relationships between hyoid morphology and air sac morphology in extant African great apes may reflect convergence; (2) while the only known A. afarensis hyoid exhibits “ape‐like” bulla, this feature may have persisted following the loss of air sacs, and not be indicative of their presence per se; (3) because there are currently only five known hominin hyoid bones represented in the fossil record (with a single specimen predating the Middle Pleistocene) the evidential basis for interpreting air sac presence or absence is minimal; and (4) inferences toward a role of sexual selection and communicative behavior in explicating the loss of air sacs in the hominin lineage are undermined by the atypical sexual dimorphism patterns in early hominins. We advocate for a cautious approach to interpreting hominin behavior and evolution which prioritizes data over speculation, and underscore the need for rigorous evidence when constructing evolutionary narratives about early hominin vocal anatomy and its evolution.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Human Nature
- Vol. 36 (3) , 526-530
Correction: Correlates of Vocal Tract Evolution in Late Pliocene and Pleistocene Hominins
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Human Nature
- Vol. 36 (3) , 526-530
Open AccessCorrection: Correlates of Vocal Tract Evolution in Late Pliocene and Pleistocene Hominins
- Open Access
Neural network-assisted analysis of tube vocal tract models
We present a pipeline for deep neural network assisted modeling and analysis of tube vocal tract models. Such models are composed of a series of cylindrical tube segments, each characterized by length and cross-sectional area. A large synthetic dataset of such tube configurations is generated, and a circuit theory–based algorithm predicts corresponding formant frequencies. To explore the mapping between tube sequence shapes and predicted resonance (formant) values, the pipeline integrates both linear regression and nonlinear machine learning models —including multi-layer perceptrons. Model interpretability is assessed using Shapley Additive Explanations (SHAP), which quantifies the contribution of each segment to predicted formant frequencies. The proposed framework enables detailed exploration of the articulatory-acoustic relationships inherent to an acoustic tube and vocal tract simulacrum. We present and describe the pipeline in the context of modeling effects of perturbations on the first three predicted resonances for a 16- cm tube, divided into 1 cm segments. Our pipeline can be applied to any method that models predictions of behavior of an acoustic tube, where the tube is conceived as a series of segmented units.
Open AccessNeural network-assisted analysis of tube vocal tract models
We present a pipeline for deep neural network assisted modeling and analysis of tube vocal tract models. Such models are composed of a series of cylindrical tube segments, each characterized by length and cross-sectional area. A large synthetic dataset of such tube configurations is generated, and a circuit theory–based algorithm predicts corresponding formant frequencies. To explore the mapping between tube sequence shapes and predicted resonance (formant) values, the pipeline integrates both linear regression and nonlinear machine learning models —including multi-layer perceptrons. Model interpretability is assessed using Shapley Additive Explanations (SHAP), which quantifies the contribution of each segment to predicted formant frequencies. The proposed framework enables detailed exploration of the articulatory-acoustic relationships inherent to an acoustic tube and vocal tract simulacrum. We present and describe the pipeline in the context of modeling effects of perturbations on the first three predicted resonances for a 16- cm tube, divided into 1 cm segments. Our pipeline can be applied to any method that models predictions of behavior of an acoustic tube, where the tube is conceived as a series of segmented units.
- Open Access
- 26 May 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Human vowels and great ape vowel-like calls reflect species-unique constraints on production
This paper introduces the “phonetic equifinality” problem in speech evolution, namely, how similar ostensibly speech-like sounds can be produced by different species, while their execution is still subject to distinct articulatory constraints. Several (nonhuman) great ape vocalizations share acoustic and perceptual similarities with human speech sounds. However, their vocal tract morphology—featuring a species-typical tongue and lack of an expanded pharynx—precludes identical articulation. The present paper combines two studies. In the first, [u]-like vocalizations by all great ape genera were sampled and compared against acoustic properties for close back rounded vowel [u]. In the second, using vocal tract models based on MRI data and behavior, we conducted computer simulations to predict formant values for [u]-like sounds in adult chimpanzees. Results indicate that [u]-like sounds in chimpanzees are consistent with tongue retraction and lip protrusion, suggesting shared articulatory strategies with human speech but, nevertheless, execution subject to species-unique constraints on production. We highlight the complexity of articulation and challenge claims that evolution of primate vocal tract physiology was superfluous to the evolution of speech. As a framing device, the equifinality problem states that identifying overlapping acoustic or spectral properties alone is insufficient to demonstrate a phylogenetically meaningful relationship between primate calls and human speech data.
- 26 May 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessHuman vowels and great ape vowel-like calls reflect species-unique constraints on production
This paper introduces the “phonetic equifinality” problem in speech evolution, namely, how similar ostensibly speech-like sounds can be produced by different species, while their execution is still subject to distinct articulatory constraints. Several (nonhuman) great ape vocalizations share acoustic and perceptual similarities with human speech sounds. However, their vocal tract morphology—featuring a species-typical tongue and lack of an expanded pharynx—precludes identical articulation. The present paper combines two studies. In the first, [u]-like vocalizations by all great ape genera were sampled and compared against acoustic properties for close back rounded vowel [u]. In the second, using vocal tract models based on MRI data and behavior, we conducted computer simulations to predict formant values for [u]-like sounds in adult chimpanzees. Results indicate that [u]-like sounds in chimpanzees are consistent with tongue retraction and lip protrusion, suggesting shared articulatory strategies with human speech but, nevertheless, execution subject to species-unique constraints on production. We highlight the complexity of articulation and challenge claims that evolution of primate vocal tract physiology was superfluous to the evolution of speech. As a framing device, the equifinality problem states that identifying overlapping acoustic or spectral properties alone is insufficient to demonstrate a phylogenetically meaningful relationship between primate calls and human speech data.
- Open Access
- 11 May 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Rounding and the third formant: An assumption revisited with deep neural networks
A student of the phonetic sciences who consults a relevant coursebook will find there the claim that F3 is related to the degree of lip rounding. However, the exact relationship between the two is variable and inconsistent. Here, we present results of an exploratory computational-acoustic model where changes to F3 are interpreted in relationship to changes to vocal tract area transfer function of a large sample (N = 10,000) of systematically varied tube model sequences. The results show a consistent pattern: constriction at the front of the vocal tract, followed by an open area and a secondary constriction, systematically shapes F3. This pattern aligns with acoustic signatures of both rounding and rhoticity, without presupposing phonological categories. These results offer a principled acoustic account of why the traditional link between rounding and lowered F3 varies in natural speech. Future work will explore whether certain vocal tract regions are more acoustically “sensitive” than others.
- 11 May 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessRounding and the third formant: An assumption revisited with deep neural networks
A student of the phonetic sciences who consults a relevant coursebook will find there the claim that F3 is related to the degree of lip rounding. However, the exact relationship between the two is variable and inconsistent. Here, we present results of an exploratory computational-acoustic model where changes to F3 are interpreted in relationship to changes to vocal tract area transfer function of a large sample (N = 10,000) of systematically varied tube model sequences. The results show a consistent pattern: constriction at the front of the vocal tract, followed by an open area and a secondary constriction, systematically shapes F3. This pattern aligns with acoustic signatures of both rounding and rhoticity, without presupposing phonological categories. These results offer a principled acoustic account of why the traditional link between rounding and lowered F3 varies in natural speech. Future work will explore whether certain vocal tract regions are more acoustically “sensitive” than others.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Human Nature
- Vol. 36 (1) , 22-69
Correlates of Vocal Tract Evolution in Late Pliocene and Pleistocene Hominins
Despite decades of research on the emergence of human speech capacities, an integrative account consistent with hominin evolution remains lacking. We review paleoanthropological and archaeological findings in search of a timeline for the emergence of modern human articulatory morphological features. Our synthesis shows that several behavioral innovations coincide with morphological changes to the would-be speech articulators. We find that significant reductions of the mandible and masticatory muscles and vocal tract anatomy coincide in the hominin fossil record with the incorporation of processed and (ultimately) cooked food, the appearance and development of rudimentary stone tools, increases in brain size, and likely changes to social life and organization. Many changes are likely mutually reinforcing; for example, gracilization of the hominin mandible may have been maintainable in the lineage because food processing had already been outsourced to the hands and stone tools, reducing selection pressures for robust mandibles in the process. We highlight correlates of the evolution of craniofacial and vocal tract features in the hominin lineage and outline a timeline by which our ancestors became ‘pre-adapted’ for the evolution of fully modern human speech.
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Human Nature
- Vol. 36 (1) , 22-69
Open AccessCorrelates of Vocal Tract Evolution in Late Pliocene and Pleistocene Hominins
Despite decades of research on the emergence of human speech capacities, an integrative account consistent with hominin evolution remains lacking. We review paleoanthropological and archaeological findings in search of a timeline for the emergence of modern human articulatory morphological features. Our synthesis shows that several behavioral innovations coincide with morphological changes to the would-be speech articulators. We find that significant reductions of the mandible and masticatory muscles and vocal tract anatomy coincide in the hominin fossil record with the incorporation of processed and (ultimately) cooked food, the appearance and development of rudimentary stone tools, increases in brain size, and likely changes to social life and organization. Many changes are likely mutually reinforcing; for example, gracilization of the hominin mandible may have been maintainable in the lineage because food processing had already been outsourced to the hands and stone tools, reducing selection pressures for robust mandibles in the process. We highlight correlates of the evolution of craniofacial and vocal tract features in the hominin lineage and outline a timeline by which our ancestors became ‘pre-adapted’ for the evolution of fully modern human speech.