Moldir Akmadi
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Moldir Akmadi has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Gulnara Ismukhanova
Казахский национальный университет имени Аль-Фараби, г. Алматы, Казахстан
3 shared publications - Dana Burkhanova
Nazarbayev University
2 shared publications - Gulnara Kenzhakimova
Казахский национальный университет имени аль-Фараби, Алматы, Казахстан
2 shared publications M. Ақмади
Қазақ ұлттық қыздар педагогикалық университеті, Алматы, Қазақстан
2 shared publications- Raushan Umbet
Al-Farabi Kazakh National University , Kazakhstan image/svg+xml
2 shared publications - Adilet Baktybay
Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 29 September 2026
- Published by Institute of Philosophy, Political Science and Religious Studies CS MSHE RK in journalsociology.kz
- Vol. 1 (3(3))
DIGITAL SKILLS AND CAREER ADAPTABILITY AMONG YOUTH IN KAZAKHSTAN: THE TRANSITION FROM HIGHER EDUCATION TO A TRANSFORMING LABOUR MARKET
The transition from higher education to employment is becoming increasingly difficult, as digitalization shifts job requirements and places greater emphasis on people’s ability to adapt, learn, and manage their own careers. This study examines the relationship between digital competence, career adaptability, practical experience and the degree with which young people in Kazakhstan feel ready to enter the labor market. The study was conducted from January to April 2026. The sample used for analysis consisted of 1,015 university and college students, as well as recent graduates at various stages of transition from education to work. Career adaptability was assessed using six indicators related to career planning, job flexibility, adapting to changes in the labor market, confidence in acquiring new skills, developing a career development strategy in the context of digital transformation, and an emphasis on the skills being transmitted; this measure showed a satisfactory internal sequence (α Kronbach = 0.860). Digital competence was found to be significantly related to perceived readiness for work, although this link was weak and non-linear, χ2(12) = 77.69, p <0.001, V Kramer = 0.160. Both internship experience and current employment status were also significantly related to willingness, but the scale of the effect was small. By contrast, neither adaptability to a career nor willingness to consider alternative career paths showed a significant link to perceived readiness. The results show that availability of digital, adaptive, or empirical resources does not automatically lead to greater readiness for employment. For young people facing changes in the labor market in Kazakhstan, a key issue may be not only acquiring employment resources, but also conditions that allow those resources to be turned into real labor-market opportunities.
- 29 September 2026
- Published by Institute of Philosophy, Political Science and Religious Studies CS MSHE RK in journalsociology.kz
- Vol. 1 (3(3))
Open AccessDIGITAL SKILLS AND CAREER ADAPTABILITY AMONG YOUTH IN KAZAKHSTAN: THE TRANSITION FROM HIGHER EDUCATION TO A TRANSFORMING LABOUR MARKET
The transition from higher education to employment is becoming increasingly difficult, as digitalization shifts job requirements and places greater emphasis on people’s ability to adapt, learn, and manage their own careers. This study examines the relationship between digital competence, career adaptability, practical experience and the degree with which young people in Kazakhstan feel ready to enter the labor market. The study was conducted from January to April 2026. The sample used for analysis consisted of 1,015 university and college students, as well as recent graduates at various stages of transition from education to work. Career adaptability was assessed using six indicators related to career planning, job flexibility, adapting to changes in the labor market, confidence in acquiring new skills, developing a career development strategy in the context of digital transformation, and an emphasis on the skills being transmitted; this measure showed a satisfactory internal sequence (α Kronbach = 0.860). Digital competence was found to be significantly related to perceived readiness for work, although this link was weak and non-linear, χ2(12) = 77.69, p <0.001, V Kramer = 0.160. Both internship experience and current employment status were also significantly related to willingness, but the scale of the effect was small. By contrast, neither adaptability to a career nor willingness to consider alternative career paths showed a significant link to perceived readiness. The results show that availability of digital, adaptive, or empirical resources does not automatically lead to greater readiness for employment. For young people facing changes in the labor market in Kazakhstan, a key issue may be not only acquiring employment resources, but also conditions that allow those resources to be turned into real labor-market opportunities.
- Open Access
- 30 August 2026
- Published by University of Management and Technology in Journal of Islamic Thought and Civilization
- Vol. 16 (2) , 177-192
Bibliographic Analysis of Research on the Religious Identity of Muslim Women on Social Media
This study presents a bibliometric analysis of scholarly research on the religious identity of Muslim women on social media from 2005 to 2024. Drawing on 269 publications indexed in Scopus and organized using the PRISMA protocol, the study employs bibliometric and visualization tools, including VOSviewer and Bibliometrix in RStudio, to identify major thematic clusters, regional trends, and gaps in the existing research. The analysis revealed three dominant thematic clusters: platform-oriented digital self-presentation and Islamic feminism; politicized and critical interpretations of religious identity, including Islamophobia and post-colonial criticism; and methodological formalization with intersectional approaches in empirical studies. The results demonstrated a steady increase in the number of publications, a dominance of English-speaking countries, limited coverage of Central Asia and post-Soviet space, and a concentration of research on Instagram and YouTube, with comparatively limited attention to TikTok, Facebook, and Telegram. Thematic mapping highlighted three clusters, encompassing digital self-presentation and Islamic feminism, criticism of dominant discourses, and standardized empirical approaches. The findings systematize existing knowledge, identify gaps, and suggest directions for future research, including expansion of geographical and cross-platform coverage as well as integration of quantitative and mixed methods in the study of religious identity in a digital environment.
- 30 August 2026
- Published by University of Management and Technology in Journal of Islamic Thought and Civilization
- Vol. 16 (2) , 177-192
Open AccessBibliographic Analysis of Research on the Religious Identity of Muslim Women on Social Media
This study presents a bibliometric analysis of scholarly research on the religious identity of Muslim women on social media from 2005 to 2024. Drawing on 269 publications indexed in Scopus and organized using the PRISMA protocol, the study employs bibliometric and visualization tools, including VOSviewer and Bibliometrix in RStudio, to identify major thematic clusters, regional trends, and gaps in the existing research. The analysis revealed three dominant thematic clusters: platform-oriented digital self-presentation and Islamic feminism; politicized and critical interpretations of religious identity, including Islamophobia and post-colonial criticism; and methodological formalization with intersectional approaches in empirical studies. The results demonstrated a steady increase in the number of publications, a dominance of English-speaking countries, limited coverage of Central Asia and post-Soviet space, and a concentration of research on Instagram and YouTube, with comparatively limited attention to TikTok, Facebook, and Telegram. Thematic mapping highlighted three clusters, encompassing digital self-presentation and Islamic feminism, criticism of dominant discourses, and standardized empirical approaches. The findings systematize existing knowledge, identify gaps, and suggest directions for future research, including expansion of geographical and cross-platform coverage as well as integration of quantitative and mixed methods in the study of religious identity in a digital environment.
- 20 June 2026
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Eurasian Journal of Religious studies
- Vol. 46 (2)
Картирование религиозных мотивов девиантного поведения в исламистском экстремизме: библиометрический и контент-анализ
This study examines the role of religious deviant behavior in Islamist extremism. The aim of the study was to analyze the religious motives underlying deviant behavior in extremism using bibliometric and content analyses. The results of the literature review showed that although considerable research has been conducted in this area, some aspects remain insufficiently studied due to the field's ongoing development and expansion. Based on publications in Scopus-indexed journals, a quantitative analysis was performed, and key texts were further selected for in-depth analysis. As a result of qualitative analysis, five dominant categories of religious motives were identified: normative-religious, eschatological, socio-religious, politico-religious and cultural-psychological. The results of the study also confirm that religious motives act not only as secondary reinforcement of social discontent, but also as the main legitimizing narratives of deviant behavior. In the context of Central Asia, these motives take a distinct form, focusing on justice and identity, rather than on apocalyptic themes more common in Middle Eastern discourse. This suggests that religious narratives provide not only a moral justification but also a structural basis for deviant practices. The study makes a theoretical contribution by proposing a structured map of religious motives and emphasizing both regional and practical aspects, suggesting that effective prevention strategies should be context-dependent and narrative-oriented. Keywords: deviant behavior, elastic motives, bibliometric analysis, Central Asia, radicalization
- 20 June 2026
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Eurasian Journal of Religious studies
- Vol. 46 (2)
Картирование религиозных мотивов девиантного поведения в исламистском экстремизме: библиометрический и контент-анализ
This study examines the role of religious deviant behavior in Islamist extremism. The aim of the study was to analyze the religious motives underlying deviant behavior in extremism using bibliometric and content analyses. The results of the literature review showed that although considerable research has been conducted in this area, some aspects remain insufficiently studied due to the field's ongoing development and expansion. Based on publications in Scopus-indexed journals, a quantitative analysis was performed, and key texts were further selected for in-depth analysis. As a result of qualitative analysis, five dominant categories of religious motives were identified: normative-religious, eschatological, socio-religious, politico-religious and cultural-psychological. The results of the study also confirm that religious motives act not only as secondary reinforcement of social discontent, but also as the main legitimizing narratives of deviant behavior. In the context of Central Asia, these motives take a distinct form, focusing on justice and identity, rather than on apocalyptic themes more common in Middle Eastern discourse. This suggests that religious narratives provide not only a moral justification but also a structural basis for deviant practices. The study makes a theoretical contribution by proposing a structured map of religious motives and emphasizing both regional and practical aspects, suggesting that effective prevention strategies should be context-dependent and narrative-oriented. Keywords: deviant behavior, elastic motives, bibliometric analysis, Central Asia, radicalization
- Open Access
- 30 March 2026
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of Philosophy Culture and Political Science
- Vol. 95 (1)
Art-activism in Kazakhstan: socio-political analysis of value memes
This article examines the value systems revealed in public discussions of four contemporary Kazakh art activists: Saule Suleimenova, Saule Dyussembina, Vladislav Sludsky and Galiya Toremuratova. The article employs an analytical approach based on Spiral Dynamics theory and conducts a content analysis of 61,263 words from digital publications, interviews, public statements, and other publicly available materials. The study identifies the primary and secondary vMEMEs presented in these narratives. It is studied how these value structures are connected with the socio-political landscape of Kazakhstan. For all significant units of the body, a coding matrix based on the eight-level model «spiral dynamics» was used, which allowed a comparative analysis of different cases. The results show that all four artists operate in complex value systems, with «orange», «green» and «yellow» being the main vMEMEs influencing their communication practices. These levels demonstrate a general orientation towards innovation, civic humanism, systematic reflection and ethical criticism. Secondary memes, especially blue and purple, serve as cultural and moral foundations, while turquoise selectively appears in discussions related to collective healing and universal dignity. Although each artist has a unique value profile, their collective understanding reveals a broader movement towards postmaterialistic and integrative forms of civil expression in Kazakhstan. By focusing on value discourse rather than public perception, the study highlights the capacity of art activism to shape cultural meanings, harmonize collective identities, and express new ethical perspectives in a rapidly changing society. Keywords: art; art-activism; spiral dynamics; visual politics; value systems. Keywords: vMEMEs, art, art-activism, Spiral Dynamics, visual politics, value systems.
- 30 March 2026
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of Philosophy Culture and Political Science
- Vol. 95 (1)
Open AccessArt-activism in Kazakhstan: socio-political analysis of value memes
This article examines the value systems revealed in public discussions of four contemporary Kazakh art activists: Saule Suleimenova, Saule Dyussembina, Vladislav Sludsky and Galiya Toremuratova. The article employs an analytical approach based on Spiral Dynamics theory and conducts a content analysis of 61,263 words from digital publications, interviews, public statements, and other publicly available materials. The study identifies the primary and secondary vMEMEs presented in these narratives. It is studied how these value structures are connected with the socio-political landscape of Kazakhstan. For all significant units of the body, a coding matrix based on the eight-level model «spiral dynamics» was used, which allowed a comparative analysis of different cases. The results show that all four artists operate in complex value systems, with «orange», «green» and «yellow» being the main vMEMEs influencing their communication practices. These levels demonstrate a general orientation towards innovation, civic humanism, systematic reflection and ethical criticism. Secondary memes, especially blue and purple, serve as cultural and moral foundations, while turquoise selectively appears in discussions related to collective healing and universal dignity. Although each artist has a unique value profile, their collective understanding reveals a broader movement towards postmaterialistic and integrative forms of civil expression in Kazakhstan. By focusing on value discourse rather than public perception, the study highlights the capacity of art activism to shape cultural meanings, harmonize collective identities, and express new ethical perspectives in a rapidly changing society. Keywords: art; art-activism; spiral dynamics; visual politics; value systems. Keywords: vMEMEs, art, art-activism, Spiral Dynamics, visual politics, value systems.
- Open Access
- 19 March 2026
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Psychology & Sociology
- Vol. 96 (1) , 140-153
Assessing the accessibility of higher education: index indicators of rural youth
Ensuring equal access to higher education for rural youth is one of the main objectives of the development policy and the regional policy of Kazakhstan. This study aims to assess the accessibility of higher education for rural school graduates by using a set of index indicators that reflect national trends in university admissions and quota use. The study has both scientific and practical relevance, as it offers a quantitative and comparable basis for assessing the continuing inequalities that exist despite ongoing national reforms. Methodologically, the study uses secondary statistical data from the Bureau of National Statistics and the Ministry of Science and Higher Education for the period from 2020 to 2025. Three indices were calculated: the rural higher education access index, the rural quota utilisation index and the composite rural accessibility index. Indicators measure overall access, dependence on government quota systems and aggregate affordability using sound weighting approaches. The results show a significant decrease in general access to higher education with little recovery. Moreover, reliance on the rural youth quota has increased as the quality of education index rose from 27.8% to 31.9%, indicating that rural youth are increasingly dependent on state support for access to higher education. An additional analysis of the education level of the rural population reveals the intergenerational gap and the concentration of low levels of education among older rural people, which limits mobility between generations. The study presents a proven system for measuring educational inequality in rural areas. The study broadens the empirical basis for policy evaluation and highlights the need for reforms in rural school education, digital readiness and admission policies taking into account regional differences. In practice, the results can help policymakers to improve quota systems, expand training programmes and better allocate opportunities for higher education across regions. Keywords: access to higher education, rural youth, index indicators, educational inequality, rural quota.
- 19 March 2026
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Psychology & Sociology
- Vol. 96 (1) , 140-153
Open AccessAssessing the accessibility of higher education: index indicators of rural youth
Ensuring equal access to higher education for rural youth is one of the main objectives of the development policy and the regional policy of Kazakhstan. This study aims to assess the accessibility of higher education for rural school graduates by using a set of index indicators that reflect national trends in university admissions and quota use. The study has both scientific and practical relevance, as it offers a quantitative and comparable basis for assessing the continuing inequalities that exist despite ongoing national reforms. Methodologically, the study uses secondary statistical data from the Bureau of National Statistics and the Ministry of Science and Higher Education for the period from 2020 to 2025. Three indices were calculated: the rural higher education access index, the rural quota utilisation index and the composite rural accessibility index. Indicators measure overall access, dependence on government quota systems and aggregate affordability using sound weighting approaches. The results show a significant decrease in general access to higher education with little recovery. Moreover, reliance on the rural youth quota has increased as the quality of education index rose from 27.8% to 31.9%, indicating that rural youth are increasingly dependent on state support for access to higher education. An additional analysis of the education level of the rural population reveals the intergenerational gap and the concentration of low levels of education among older rural people, which limits mobility between generations. The study presents a proven system for measuring educational inequality in rural areas. The study broadens the empirical basis for policy evaluation and highlights the need for reforms in rural school education, digital readiness and admission policies taking into account regional differences. In practice, the results can help policymakers to improve quota systems, expand training programmes and better allocate opportunities for higher education across regions. Keywords: access to higher education, rural youth, index indicators, educational inequality, rural quota.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2026
- Published by Kazakhstan Institute for Strategic Studies under the President of The Republic of Kazakhstan in Journal of Central Asian Studies
- Vol. 24 (1) , 27-41
FORMATION OF ANTI-CORRUPTION CULTURE IN KAZAKHSTAN: THE INFLUENCE OF MEDIA
In recent years, Kazakhstan has undergone an active institutional transformation of the anti-corruption system, and the media is one of the important aspects in the formation of this culture.The purpose of the research is to analyze the influence of media on the formation of anti-corruption culture in Kazakhstan, where attention is paid to the consumption model, trust in sources of information, and how people interact with corruption-related content.The analysis is based on a population survey, covering all regions of Kazakhstan (N = 2685). Data was collected through a combination of face-to-face and online interviews. The survey assessed the frequency of consumption of media content, trust in public, independent, and digital media, views on media coverage of corruption, evaluative interaction with media, and anti-corruption policies. Descriptive statistics and correlation analysis were used to test the proposed theories. The results show that media content related to corruption is weakly and inconsistently linked to anti-corruption policies, indicating the limited influence of passive media consumption. The reliability of media sources has only a partial, context-dependent relationship with the perception of objectivity and effectiveness of the media. However, active interaction with media content through critical evaluation, checking information, and awareness of media influence is the strongest predictor of media effectiveness in shaping an anti-corruption culture. The results show that media influence manifests itself through reflexive and interpretative processes, rather than through simple familiarization or blind reliance on specific sources. The practical significance of the study is that anti-corruption reforms in Kazakhstan are focused on legal and institutional measures, and less attention is paid to the social and cultural impact of media on public opinion and ethical norms. This study fills in the gap, as well as examining how media use and audience engagement relate to perceptions of corruption and how effectively media promote anti-corruption values.
- 1 March 2026
- Published by Kazakhstan Institute for Strategic Studies under the President of The Republic of Kazakhstan in Journal of Central Asian Studies
- Vol. 24 (1) , 27-41
Open AccessFORMATION OF ANTI-CORRUPTION CULTURE IN KAZAKHSTAN: THE INFLUENCE OF MEDIA
In recent years, Kazakhstan has undergone an active institutional transformation of the anti-corruption system, and the media is one of the important aspects in the formation of this culture.The purpose of the research is to analyze the influence of media on the formation of anti-corruption culture in Kazakhstan, where attention is paid to the consumption model, trust in sources of information, and how people interact with corruption-related content.The analysis is based on a population survey, covering all regions of Kazakhstan (N = 2685). Data was collected through a combination of face-to-face and online interviews. The survey assessed the frequency of consumption of media content, trust in public, independent, and digital media, views on media coverage of corruption, evaluative interaction with media, and anti-corruption policies. Descriptive statistics and correlation analysis were used to test the proposed theories. The results show that media content related to corruption is weakly and inconsistently linked to anti-corruption policies, indicating the limited influence of passive media consumption. The reliability of media sources has only a partial, context-dependent relationship with the perception of objectivity and effectiveness of the media. However, active interaction with media content through critical evaluation, checking information, and awareness of media influence is the strongest predictor of media effectiveness in shaping an anti-corruption culture. The results show that media influence manifests itself through reflexive and interpretative processes, rather than through simple familiarization or blind reliance on specific sources. The practical significance of the study is that anti-corruption reforms in Kazakhstan are focused on legal and institutional measures, and less attention is paid to the social and cultural impact of media on public opinion and ethical norms. This study fills in the gap, as well as examining how media use and audience engagement relate to perceptions of corruption and how effectively media promote anti-corruption values.
- Open Access
- 5 November 2025
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of Philosophy Culture and Political Science
- Vol. 93 (3)
Value transitions in civil discourse amid conflict institutionalization in kazakhstan: a spiral dynamics approach to human rights rhetoric
Under conditions of increasing political transformation and change in the realities of Kazakhstan, the human rights discourse becomes increasingly important as a site for the articulation of alternative value systems and critical reflection of public order. This study aims to identify levels of value consciousness in the public rhetoric of four leading Kazakh human rights defenders based on the theory of spiral dynamics. The study analyzes the texts of four human rights defenders with a legal education, actively participating in public space between 2016 and 2024. The methodology of work is based on a combined content-analysis, paragraph coding and construction of a categorical matrix vMEMEs, adapted to the human rights and legal discourse. The reliability of the coding was tested using the Cohen’s Kappa method (κ=0.82), which indicates a high degree of consistency in the evaluations. The results of the analysis show the dominance of three levels of value consciousness, namely blue, where it is about normative, legal and order. Next is the green, which implies inclusion, solidarity and humanism, and the yellow, which includes systemic thinking, reflexivity, and adaptability. For each of the speakers, individual variations in the configuration of levels and rhetorical strategies are fixed. Elements of red, violet and, in some cases, turquoise levels were also identified, which indicates the existence of transitional forms of consciousness and strategic adaptation. The scientific novelty of the research is the first empirical application of the theory of spiral dynamics to the analysis of human rights rhetoric in the Kazakh context. The theoretical significance lies in the development of a cognitive-value approach to the study of civil consciousness. The practical applicability of the results consists in the possibility to use the proposed methodology for monitoring value transformations, predicting the evolution of civic rhetoric, as well as for educational and primary education purposes. Keywords: spiral dynamics, human rights discourse, vMEMEs, social conflicts, Kazakhstan, civic consciousness.
- 5 November 2025
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of Philosophy Culture and Political Science
- Vol. 93 (3)
Open AccessValue transitions in civil discourse amid conflict institutionalization in kazakhstan: a spiral dynamics approach to human rights rhetoric
Under conditions of increasing political transformation and change in the realities of Kazakhstan, the human rights discourse becomes increasingly important as a site for the articulation of alternative value systems and critical reflection of public order. This study aims to identify levels of value consciousness in the public rhetoric of four leading Kazakh human rights defenders based on the theory of spiral dynamics. The study analyzes the texts of four human rights defenders with a legal education, actively participating in public space between 2016 and 2024. The methodology of work is based on a combined content-analysis, paragraph coding and construction of a categorical matrix vMEMEs, adapted to the human rights and legal discourse. The reliability of the coding was tested using the Cohen’s Kappa method (κ=0.82), which indicates a high degree of consistency in the evaluations. The results of the analysis show the dominance of three levels of value consciousness, namely blue, where it is about normative, legal and order. Next is the green, which implies inclusion, solidarity and humanism, and the yellow, which includes systemic thinking, reflexivity, and adaptability. For each of the speakers, individual variations in the configuration of levels and rhetorical strategies are fixed. Elements of red, violet and, in some cases, turquoise levels were also identified, which indicates the existence of transitional forms of consciousness and strategic adaptation. The scientific novelty of the research is the first empirical application of the theory of spiral dynamics to the analysis of human rights rhetoric in the Kazakh context. The theoretical significance lies in the development of a cognitive-value approach to the study of civil consciousness. The practical applicability of the results consists in the possibility to use the proposed methodology for monitoring value transformations, predicting the evolution of civic rhetoric, as well as for educational and primary education purposes. Keywords: spiral dynamics, human rights discourse, vMEMEs, social conflicts, Kazakhstan, civic consciousness.
- Open Access
- 30 September 2025
- Published by Kazakhstan Institute for Strategic Studies under the President of The Republic of Kazakhstan in Journal of Central Asian Studies
- Vol. 23 (3) , 90-104
A Value-Oriented Analysis of Expert Political Discourse in Kazakhstan: A Spiral Dynamics Approach to Public Social Media Communication
This article aims to provide a systematic analysis of the public discourse of leading Kazakh political experts from the perspective of the theory of spiral dynamics (C. Graves, D. Beck, C. Cowan). In the context of political reforms, growing public mistrust, and institutional transformations, expert discourse serves as a channel for articulating values. The aim of the study is to identify and interpret the dominant and auxiliary value memes based on the analysis of public interviews, articles, speeches, and publications in social networks. Methodologically, it is based on qualitative and quantitative content analysis of more than 670,000 words of direct speech, Kazakh experts Dosym Satpayev, Sanzhar Bokayev, Andrei Chebotarev, and Karlygash Yezhenova. In the course of the study, the data were encoded according to the developed matrix, and the consistency index for Cohen’s Kappa was 0.84, which demonstrates a high level of reliability. In the process of coding, an eight-level model of spiral dynamics was applied, namely beige, purple, red, blue, orange, green, yellow, and turquoise. The analysis also used MAXQDA and Python software tools. The results of the study showed the presence of stable value polyphony in public statements of experts. The most frequently encountered value levels in their discourse were blue, demonstrating institutional order and accountability; orange, showing rationality, efficiency, development, and green, which demonstrates humanism, social justice, and dialogue. Moreover, each expert’s value meme structure varies, forming unique configurations that reflect their analytical styles and cognitive priorities.
- 30 September 2025
- Published by Kazakhstan Institute for Strategic Studies under the President of The Republic of Kazakhstan in Journal of Central Asian Studies
- Vol. 23 (3) , 90-104
Open AccessA Value-Oriented Analysis of Expert Political Discourse in Kazakhstan: A Spiral Dynamics Approach to Public Social Media Communication
This article aims to provide a systematic analysis of the public discourse of leading Kazakh political experts from the perspective of the theory of spiral dynamics (C. Graves, D. Beck, C. Cowan). In the context of political reforms, growing public mistrust, and institutional transformations, expert discourse serves as a channel for articulating values. The aim of the study is to identify and interpret the dominant and auxiliary value memes based on the analysis of public interviews, articles, speeches, and publications in social networks. Methodologically, it is based on qualitative and quantitative content analysis of more than 670,000 words of direct speech, Kazakh experts Dosym Satpayev, Sanzhar Bokayev, Andrei Chebotarev, and Karlygash Yezhenova. In the course of the study, the data were encoded according to the developed matrix, and the consistency index for Cohen’s Kappa was 0.84, which demonstrates a high level of reliability. In the process of coding, an eight-level model of spiral dynamics was applied, namely beige, purple, red, blue, orange, green, yellow, and turquoise. The analysis also used MAXQDA and Python software tools. The results of the study showed the presence of stable value polyphony in public statements of experts. The most frequently encountered value levels in their discourse were blue, demonstrating institutional order and accountability; orange, showing rationality, efficiency, development, and green, which demonstrates humanism, social justice, and dialogue. Moreover, each expert’s value meme structure varies, forming unique configurations that reflect their analytical styles and cognitive priorities.
- Open Access
- 19 June 2025
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Psychology & Sociology
- Vol. 93 (2) , 64-76
Role of identity in shaping the well-being of Kazakh youth
The relationship between identity and well-being is one of the central themes of modern sociological research, especially in youth studies. The present study aims to analyze the influence of different identity styles (informational, normative, and diffuse-avoidant) on well-being indicators among young people aged 18 to 35. An integrated methodology was used to achieve the goal, including the ISI-5 identity style survey and the Gallup Healthways Well-Being Index. The ISI-5 questionnaire evaluates three styles of processing identities: informational, related to active search and analysis of information; normative, based on following social norms and expectations; and diffuse-avoidant. The avoidance of complex decisions and thinking about the future. The Gallup Healthways Well-Being Index measures well-being across six key dimensions: subjective life assessment, emotional and physical health, healthy behavior, satisfaction with the work environment, and access to essential resources. The survey covered all regions of Kazakhstan, including republican cities, regional centers, and rural settlements. Data collection was conducted in Kazakh and Russian, considering respondents' preferences. The study results showed that the informational identity style positively affects emotional resilience and life satisfaction, while the normative style promotes stability and a sense of security. In contrast, the diffuse-avoidant style temporarily reduces stress but limits long-term life prospects. The study's results significantly contribute to the study of the relationship between identity and well-being, complementing the existing literature with new empirical data. The study's practical significance lies in its use for developing social policies and programs to strengthen the well-being of young people under socio-economic and cultural transformations in Kazakhstan. Keywords: identity, well-being, identity styles, Kazakhstani youth.
- 19 June 2025
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Psychology & Sociology
- Vol. 93 (2) , 64-76
Open AccessRole of identity in shaping the well-being of Kazakh youth
The relationship between identity and well-being is one of the central themes of modern sociological research, especially in youth studies. The present study aims to analyze the influence of different identity styles (informational, normative, and diffuse-avoidant) on well-being indicators among young people aged 18 to 35. An integrated methodology was used to achieve the goal, including the ISI-5 identity style survey and the Gallup Healthways Well-Being Index. The ISI-5 questionnaire evaluates three styles of processing identities: informational, related to active search and analysis of information; normative, based on following social norms and expectations; and diffuse-avoidant. The avoidance of complex decisions and thinking about the future. The Gallup Healthways Well-Being Index measures well-being across six key dimensions: subjective life assessment, emotional and physical health, healthy behavior, satisfaction with the work environment, and access to essential resources. The survey covered all regions of Kazakhstan, including republican cities, regional centers, and rural settlements. Data collection was conducted in Kazakh and Russian, considering respondents' preferences. The study results showed that the informational identity style positively affects emotional resilience and life satisfaction, while the normative style promotes stability and a sense of security. In contrast, the diffuse-avoidant style temporarily reduces stress but limits long-term life prospects. The study's results significantly contribute to the study of the relationship between identity and well-being, complementing the existing literature with new empirical data. The study's practical significance lies in its use for developing social policies and programs to strengthen the well-being of young people under socio-economic and cultural transformations in Kazakhstan. Keywords: identity, well-being, identity styles, Kazakhstani youth.
- Open Access
- 20 December 2024
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Psychology & Sociology
- Vol. 91 (4) , 64-75
Assessment of the relationship between religion, spirituality and well-being among young people of Kazakhstan
The study investigates and evaluates the relationship between religion, spirituality, and well-being among young people. The study aims to understand how Kazakh youth's religiosity and spirituality affect their well-being. The importance of the study lies in its significant contribution to understanding social changes in Kazakhstan, providing both empirical evidence and conceptual ideas on the relationship between the aspects mentioned above. The research methods are based on the measurement of the Duke University Religiosity Index (DUREL) for assessment of organizational, non-organizational, and internal religiosity, and the Pemberton Happiness Index and the Gallup Healthways Well-being Index were also used to measure the well-being of respondents. The study included 2,654 participants from all regions of Kazakhstan, using quotas based on region, age group, and gender, ensuring data representativeness. The results of the study showed that religious and spiritual people feel more comfortable, with a high level of positive emotions and a lower level of negative ones such as stress and depression. Whereas atheists and agnostics, despite higher rates of optimism about future perceptions, face greater difficulties in managing stress. The value of the study is that it provides new evidence on how religious and spiritual factors affect youth well-being. The work contributes to understanding how religious beliefs contribute to emotional well-being. The practical significance of the study is that its results can be used as supporting material in the development of programs aimed at young people, taking into account religious and spiritual factors. The data obtained complement existing literature on the influence of religion and spirituality on well-being, opening up new possibilities for further research in this field. Keywords: sociology of religion, religiosity, spirituality, well-being.
- 20 December 2024
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Psychology & Sociology
- Vol. 91 (4) , 64-75
Open AccessAssessment of the relationship between religion, spirituality and well-being among young people of Kazakhstan
The study investigates and evaluates the relationship between religion, spirituality, and well-being among young people. The study aims to understand how Kazakh youth's religiosity and spirituality affect their well-being. The importance of the study lies in its significant contribution to understanding social changes in Kazakhstan, providing both empirical evidence and conceptual ideas on the relationship between the aspects mentioned above. The research methods are based on the measurement of the Duke University Religiosity Index (DUREL) for assessment of organizational, non-organizational, and internal religiosity, and the Pemberton Happiness Index and the Gallup Healthways Well-being Index were also used to measure the well-being of respondents. The study included 2,654 participants from all regions of Kazakhstan, using quotas based on region, age group, and gender, ensuring data representativeness. The results of the study showed that religious and spiritual people feel more comfortable, with a high level of positive emotions and a lower level of negative ones such as stress and depression. Whereas atheists and agnostics, despite higher rates of optimism about future perceptions, face greater difficulties in managing stress. The value of the study is that it provides new evidence on how religious and spiritual factors affect youth well-being. The work contributes to understanding how religious beliefs contribute to emotional well-being. The practical significance of the study is that its results can be used as supporting material in the development of programs aimed at young people, taking into account religious and spiritual factors. The data obtained complement existing literature on the influence of religion and spirituality on well-being, opening up new possibilities for further research in this field. Keywords: sociology of religion, religiosity, spirituality, well-being.