Francesca Dakin
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Francesca Dakin has a total of 59 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Trisha Greenhalgh
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences University of Oxford Oxford UK
9 shared publications - Emma Ladds
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
8 shared publications - Joseph Wherton
University of Oxford, Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, Oxford, England
7 shared publications - Sara Shaw
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences University of Oxford Oxford UK
7 shared publications - Sietse Wieringa
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
7 shared publications - Aileen Clarke
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 July 2026
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 76 (769) , 376-379
Ambient scribes in general practice — help or hindrance?
- 30 July 2026
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 76 (769) , 376-379
Open AccessAmbient scribes in general practice — help or hindrance?
- Open Access
- 15 June 2026
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in NIHR Open Research
- Vol. 5, 96
Social and Ethical Aspects of Remote and Hybrid Care in the Special Allocation Scheme in general practice (SEARCH): A mixed methods feasibility study protocol
Background Despite the growing body of research on remote primary care and access for (digitally) excluded groups, very little is known about care for patients who have been deliberately excluded from mainstream services. The ‘Special Allocation Scheme’ (SAS) in England provides GP services to patients who have been excluded from their GP practice after being reported for violent behaviour. Patients registered on SAS are likely to be offered remote services, in part because patients are often placed in an ‘out-of-area’ SAS practice. Our aim is to find out more about the needs of patients on the SAS, whether and when it is appropriate to offer remote options, and who these options might benefit or disadvantage. We also aim to develop safe, ethical, and meaningful ways to involve patients with experience on the scheme in research and service development. Methods Workstream 1 includes a national scoping survey of SAS provision across England. Workstream 2 comprises of three ethnographic case studies of SAS services, including observation and interviews with patients, NHS staff and national/regional decision makers. Workstream 3 involves two codesign workshops with patients, researchers, clinicians, support staff and third sector care providers to co-produce a set of reflections and best practices to inform future research and service redesign in this context. An iterative and participatory-informed PPIE approach is adopted throughout, involving patients and other stakeholders from early conceptualisation to study design, analysis and codesign of outputs. Conclusions Whilst remote solutions can improve access to primary care for some, they are not suitable for every patient population and can widen health inequalities. This is a novel study in a critically under-researched area of service delivery with clear practical and ethical implications for practice. Findings will develop understanding and transferable learning for SAS delivery and inform the design of a future study.
- 15 June 2026
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in NIHR Open Research
- Vol. 5, 96
Open AccessSocial and Ethical Aspects of Remote and Hybrid Care in the Special Allocation Scheme in general practice (SEARCH): A mixed methods feasibility study protocol
Background Despite the growing body of research on remote primary care and access for (digitally) excluded groups, very little is known about care for patients who have been deliberately excluded from mainstream services. The ‘Special Allocation Scheme’ (SAS) in England provides GP services to patients who have been excluded from their GP practice after being reported for violent behaviour. Patients registered on SAS are likely to be offered remote services, in part because patients are often placed in an ‘out-of-area’ SAS practice. Our aim is to find out more about the needs of patients on the SAS, whether and when it is appropriate to offer remote options, and who these options might benefit or disadvantage. We also aim to develop safe, ethical, and meaningful ways to involve patients with experience on the scheme in research and service development. Methods Workstream 1 includes a national scoping survey of SAS provision across England. Workstream 2 comprises of three ethnographic case studies of SAS services, including observation and interviews with patients, NHS staff and national/regional decision makers. Workstream 3 involves two codesign workshops with patients, researchers, clinicians, support staff and third sector care providers to co-produce a set of reflections and best practices to inform future research and service redesign in this context. An iterative and participatory-informed PPIE approach is adopted throughout, involving patients and other stakeholders from early conceptualisation to study design, analysis and codesign of outputs. Conclusions Whilst remote solutions can improve access to primary care for some, they are not suitable for every patient population and can widen health inequalities. This is a novel study in a critically under-researched area of service delivery with clear practical and ethical implications for practice. Findings will develop understanding and transferable learning for SAS delivery and inform the design of a future study.
- 26 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Sociology of Health & Illness
- Vol. 48 (4) , e70156
Health Messaging in Menstrual Product Marketing on Social Media: Neoliberalism and Normalisation
Menstrual product advertisements have undergone shifts in discourse over recent decades, from messages surrounding hygiene towards those of liberation, but discretion narratives have remained. Social media marketing is prominent for menstrual product companies, and much menstrual advocacy is also on social media. This paper explores health messaging, a neglected area, in menstrual product advertising on social media. Multi‐modal critical discourse analysis on 480 unique Instagram and TikTok menstrual product advertisements, collected by five researchers over 1 month. There are tensions in menstrual brand marketing incorporating health messaging around which that we have characterised as: normal or not, challenging or maintaining stereotypes, breaking taboos—or reinforcing them, combatting shame or perpetuating social norms, activism or neoliberal co‐option. These are explored through the lenses of bio‐medicalisation and doctorability. Marketing strategies co‐opt language from advocacy and health messaging. It remains uncertain whether and how marketing campaigns on experiences of menstruation and conceptualisations of menstruation affect healthcare‐related decision making. Our analysis demonstrates how inconsistent messaging may exacerbate shame, reinforce menstrual inequities and expand the corporate role in women's health and illness.
- 26 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Sociology of Health & Illness
- Vol. 48 (4) , e70156
Health Messaging in Menstrual Product Marketing on Social Media: Neoliberalism and Normalisation
Menstrual product advertisements have undergone shifts in discourse over recent decades, from messages surrounding hygiene towards those of liberation, but discretion narratives have remained. Social media marketing is prominent for menstrual product companies, and much menstrual advocacy is also on social media. This paper explores health messaging, a neglected area, in menstrual product advertising on social media. Multi‐modal critical discourse analysis on 480 unique Instagram and TikTok menstrual product advertisements, collected by five researchers over 1 month. There are tensions in menstrual brand marketing incorporating health messaging around which that we have characterised as: normal or not, challenging or maintaining stereotypes, breaking taboos—or reinforcing them, combatting shame or perpetuating social norms, activism or neoliberal co‐option. These are explored through the lenses of bio‐medicalisation and doctorability. Marketing strategies co‐opt language from advocacy and health messaging. It remains uncertain whether and how marketing campaigns on experiences of menstruation and conceptualisations of menstruation affect healthcare‐related decision making. Our analysis demonstrates how inconsistent messaging may exacerbate shame, reinforce menstrual inequities and expand the corporate role in women's health and illness.
- Open Access
- 2 February 2026
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 76 (767) , e464-e478
Teamwork and relational infrastructure: a qualitative study of modern UK general practice
Background: Clinical and support staff in modern general practice must work across in-person and digital modalities to deliver high-quality, safe care in a context of high workload, constant change, and intermittent crisis. Navigating this environment is cognitively and emotionally demanding, and requires complex teamwork. Staff morale may often be low, and staff turnover high. Aim: To understand how the context of modern UK general practice affects staff wellbeing and teamwork, and to develop our understanding of how to improve these aspects of work culture. Design and setting: This paper reports on a multi-sited case study of 10 general practices across England, Wales, and Scotland. Method: Multiple qualitative methods, including ethnographic observations, interviews, and focus groups, were used to develop case studies. First, we conducted in-depth longitudinal case studies of two practices focused on developing theory, which we cross-compared with eight other, more focused case studies. Our analysis was informed by theories from organisational research, including psychological safety, relational coordination, and attentional infrastructure. Results: Staff wellbeing and effective teamwork depended on positive team relations. Practices in which such relations were valued and nurtured (that is, those with a strong relational infrastructure) appeared to have stronger team identities, better coordination of work tasks, and higher overall staff wellbeing than those in which team relations were not actively nurtured. Staff relations were built and sustained through various individual actions and organisational routines. Conclusion: This study has identified several elements of 'relational infrastructure' with the potential to improve team relations, communication, and coordination, which may also enhance practices' resilience to withstand change and crises.
- 2 February 2026
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 76 (767) , e464-e478
Open AccessTeamwork and relational infrastructure: a qualitative study of modern UK general practice
Background: Clinical and support staff in modern general practice must work across in-person and digital modalities to deliver high-quality, safe care in a context of high workload, constant change, and intermittent crisis. Navigating this environment is cognitively and emotionally demanding, and requires complex teamwork. Staff morale may often be low, and staff turnover high. Aim: To understand how the context of modern UK general practice affects staff wellbeing and teamwork, and to develop our understanding of how to improve these aspects of work culture. Design and setting: This paper reports on a multi-sited case study of 10 general practices across England, Wales, and Scotland. Method: Multiple qualitative methods, including ethnographic observations, interviews, and focus groups, were used to develop case studies. First, we conducted in-depth longitudinal case studies of two practices focused on developing theory, which we cross-compared with eight other, more focused case studies. Our analysis was informed by theories from organisational research, including psychological safety, relational coordination, and attentional infrastructure. Results: Staff wellbeing and effective teamwork depended on positive team relations. Practices in which such relations were valued and nurtured (that is, those with a strong relational infrastructure) appeared to have stronger team identities, better coordination of work tasks, and higher overall staff wellbeing than those in which team relations were not actively nurtured. Staff relations were built and sustained through various individual actions and organisational routines. Conclusion: This study has identified several elements of 'relational infrastructure' with the potential to improve team relations, communication, and coordination, which may also enhance practices' resilience to withstand change and crises.
- 9 October 2025
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in NIHR Open Research
- Vol. 5, 96
Social and Ethical Aspects of Remote and Hybrid Care in the Special Allocation Scheme in general practice (SEARCH): A mixed methods feasibility study protocol
Background Despite the growing body of research on remote primary care and access for (digitally) excluded groups, very little is known about care for patients who have been deliberately excluded from mainstream services. The ‘Special Allocation Scheme’ (SAS) in England provides GP services to patients who have been excluded from their GP practice after being reported for violent behaviour. Patients registered on SAS are likely to be offered remote services, in part because patients are often placed in an ‘out-of-area’ SAS practice. Our aim is to find out more about the needs of patients on the SAS, whether and when it is appropriate to offer remote options, and who these options might benefit or disadvantage. We also aim to develop safe, ethical, and meaningful ways to involve patients with experience on the scheme in research and service development. Methods Workstream 1 includes a national scoping survey of SAS provision across England. Workstream 2 comprises of three ethnographic case studies of SAS services, including observation and interviews with patients, NHS staff and national/regional decision makers. Workstream 3 involves two codesign workshops with patients, researchers, clinicians, support staff and third sector care providers to co-produce a set of reflections and best practices to inform future research and service redesign in this context. An iterative and participatory-informed PPIE approach is adopted throughout, involving patients and other stakeholders from early conceptualisation to study design, analysis and codesign of outputs. Conclusions Whilst remote solutions can improve access to primary care for some, they are not suitable for every patient population and can widen health inequalities. This is a novel study in a critically under-researched area of service delivery with clear practical and ethical implications for practice. Findings will develop understanding and transferable learning for SAS delivery and inform the design of a future study.
- 9 October 2025
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in NIHR Open Research
- Vol. 5, 96
Social and Ethical Aspects of Remote and Hybrid Care in the Special Allocation Scheme in general practice (SEARCH): A mixed methods feasibility study protocol
Background Despite the growing body of research on remote primary care and access for (digitally) excluded groups, very little is known about care for patients who have been deliberately excluded from mainstream services. The ‘Special Allocation Scheme’ (SAS) in England provides GP services to patients who have been excluded from their GP practice after being reported for violent behaviour. Patients registered on SAS are likely to be offered remote services, in part because patients are often placed in an ‘out-of-area’ SAS practice. Our aim is to find out more about the needs of patients on the SAS, whether and when it is appropriate to offer remote options, and who these options might benefit or disadvantage. We also aim to develop safe, ethical, and meaningful ways to involve patients with experience on the scheme in research and service development. Methods Workstream 1 includes a national scoping survey of SAS provision across England. Workstream 2 comprises of three ethnographic case studies of SAS services, including observation and interviews with patients, NHS staff and national/regional decision makers. Workstream 3 involves two codesign workshops with patients, researchers, clinicians, support staff and third sector care providers to co-produce a set of reflections and best practices to inform future research and service redesign in this context. An iterative and participatory-informed PPIE approach is adopted throughout, involving patients and other stakeholders from early conceptualisation to study design, analysis and codesign of outputs. Conclusions Whilst remote solutions can improve access to primary care for some, they are not suitable for every patient population and can widen health inequalities. This is a novel study in a critically under-researched area of service delivery with clear practical and ethical implications for practice. Findings will develop understanding and transferable learning for SAS delivery and inform the design of a future study.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2025
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 13 (31) , 1-49
Remote and digital services in UK general practice 2021–2023: the Remote by Default 2 longitudinal qualitative study synopsis
Background: Remote services (in which the patient and staff member are not physically colocated) and digital services (in which a patient encounter is digitally mediated in some way) were introduced extensively when the COVID-19 pandemic began in 2020. We undertook a longitudinal qualitative study of the introduction, embedding, evolution and abandonment of remote and digital innovations in United Kingdom general practice. This synoptic paper summarises study design, methods, key findings, outputs and impacts to date. Overview of the study and key findings: From September 2021 to December 2023, we collected > 500 hours of ethnographic observation from a diverse sample of 12 general practices. Other data sources included over 200 interviews (with practice staff, patients and wider stakeholders), 4 multi-stakeholder workshops (184 participants), grey literature (e.g. Care Quality Commission reports) and safety incident reports. Patient involvement included digitally excluded individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds (e.g. homeless, complex needs). Data were de-identified, uploaded to NVivo (QSR International, Warrington, UK), coded thematically and analysed using various theoretical lenses. Despite an adverse context for general practice including austerity, workforce shortages, rising demand, rising workload and procurement challenges, all 12 participating practices adjusted to some extent to a ‘new normal’ of hybrid (combined traditional and remote/digital) provision following the external shock of the pandemic. By late 2023, practices showed wide variation in digital maturity from a ‘trailblazer’ practice which used digital technologies extensively and creatively to ‘strategically traditional’ practices offering mainly in-person services to deprived and vulnerable populations. We explained practices’ varied fortunes using diffusion of innovations theory, highlighting the extensive work needed to embed and routinise technologies and processes. Digitally enabled patients often, but not always, found remote and digital services convenient and navigable, but vulnerable groups experienced exclusion. We explored these inequities through the lenses of digital candidacy, fractured reflexivity and intersectionality. For staff, remote and digital tasks and processes were often complex, labour-intensive, stressful and dependent on positive interpersonal relations – findings that resonated with theories of technostress, suffering and relational co-ordination. Our initial plan for workshop-based co-design of access pathways with patients was unsuccessful due to dynamic complexities; shifting to a more bespoke and agile design process generated helpful resources for patients and staff. Discussion: This study has confirmed previous findings from sociotechnical research showing that new technologies are never ‘plug and play’ and that appropriate solutions vary with context. Much variation in digital provision in United Kingdom general practice reflects different practice priorities and population needs. However, some practices’ low digital maturity may indicate a need for additional resources, organisational support and strengthening of absorptive capacity. Negative impacts of digitalisation are common but not always inevitable; an ‘inefficient’ digital pathway may become more efficient over time as people adapt; and digitalisation does not affect all work processes equally (back-office tasks may be easier to routinise than clinical judgements). We have developed novel ways of involving patients from vulnerable and excluded groups, and have extended the evidence base on codesign for the busy and dynamic setting of general practice. Findings are being taken forward by national, locality-based and practice-level decision-makers; national regulators (e.g. in relation to safety); and educational providers for undergraduate, postgraduate and support staff (via a new set of competencies). Future work: Ongoing and planned work to maximise impact from this study includes using our competency framework to inform training standards, pursuing our insights on quality and safety with policy-makers, a cross-country publication for policy-makers with examples from colleagues in other countries, resources to convey key messages to different audiences, and continuing speaking engagements for academic, policy and lay audiences. Limitations: The sampling of practices was limited to Great Britain. Patient interviews were relatively sparse. While the study generated rich qualitative data which was useful in its own right, a larger sample of practices with a quantitative component could support formal hypothesis-testing, and a health economics component could allow firmer statements about efficiency. Funding: This synopsis presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme as award number NIHR132807.
- 1 September 2025
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 13 (31) , 1-49
Open AccessRemote and digital services in UK general practice 2021–2023: the Remote by Default 2 longitudinal qualitative study synopsis
Background: Remote services (in which the patient and staff member are not physically colocated) and digital services (in which a patient encounter is digitally mediated in some way) were introduced extensively when the COVID-19 pandemic began in 2020. We undertook a longitudinal qualitative study of the introduction, embedding, evolution and abandonment of remote and digital innovations in United Kingdom general practice. This synoptic paper summarises study design, methods, key findings, outputs and impacts to date. Overview of the study and key findings: From September 2021 to December 2023, we collected > 500 hours of ethnographic observation from a diverse sample of 12 general practices. Other data sources included over 200 interviews (with practice staff, patients and wider stakeholders), 4 multi-stakeholder workshops (184 participants), grey literature (e.g. Care Quality Commission reports) and safety incident reports. Patient involvement included digitally excluded individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds (e.g. homeless, complex needs). Data were de-identified, uploaded to NVivo (QSR International, Warrington, UK), coded thematically and analysed using various theoretical lenses. Despite an adverse context for general practice including austerity, workforce shortages, rising demand, rising workload and procurement challenges, all 12 participating practices adjusted to some extent to a ‘new normal’ of hybrid (combined traditional and remote/digital) provision following the external shock of the pandemic. By late 2023, practices showed wide variation in digital maturity from a ‘trailblazer’ practice which used digital technologies extensively and creatively to ‘strategically traditional’ practices offering mainly in-person services to deprived and vulnerable populations. We explained practices’ varied fortunes using diffusion of innovations theory, highlighting the extensive work needed to embed and routinise technologies and processes. Digitally enabled patients often, but not always, found remote and digital services convenient and navigable, but vulnerable groups experienced exclusion. We explored these inequities through the lenses of digital candidacy, fractured reflexivity and intersectionality. For staff, remote and digital tasks and processes were often complex, labour-intensive, stressful and dependent on positive interpersonal relations – findings that resonated with theories of technostress, suffering and relational co-ordination. Our initial plan for workshop-based co-design of access pathways with patients was unsuccessful due to dynamic complexities; shifting to a more bespoke and agile design process generated helpful resources for patients and staff. Discussion: This study has confirmed previous findings from sociotechnical research showing that new technologies are never ‘plug and play’ and that appropriate solutions vary with context. Much variation in digital provision in United Kingdom general practice reflects different practice priorities and population needs. However, some practices’ low digital maturity may indicate a need for additional resources, organisational support and strengthening of absorptive capacity. Negative impacts of digitalisation are common but not always inevitable; an ‘inefficient’ digital pathway may become more efficient over time as people adapt; and digitalisation does not affect all work processes equally (back-office tasks may be easier to routinise than clinical judgements). We have developed novel ways of involving patients from vulnerable and excluded groups, and have extended the evidence base on codesign for the busy and dynamic setting of general practice. Findings are being taken forward by national, locality-based and practice-level decision-makers; national regulators (e.g. in relation to safety); and educational providers for undergraduate, postgraduate and support staff (via a new set of competencies). Future work: Ongoing and planned work to maximise impact from this study includes using our competency framework to inform training standards, pursuing our insights on quality and safety with policy-makers, a cross-country publication for policy-makers with examples from colleagues in other countries, resources to convey key messages to different audiences, and continuing speaking engagements for academic, policy and lay audiences. Limitations: The sampling of practices was limited to Great Britain. Patient interviews were relatively sparse. While the study generated rich qualitative data which was useful in its own right, a larger sample of practices with a quantitative component could support formal hypothesis-testing, and a health economics component could allow firmer statements about efficiency. Funding: This synopsis presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme as award number NIHR132807.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2025
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- p. 1-37
After the disruptive innovation: How remote and digital services were embedded, blended and abandoned in UK general practice – longitudinal study
Background: United Kingdom general practices transitioned rapidly to remote-by-default services in 2020 and subsequently considered whether and how to continue these practices. Their diverse responses provided a unique opportunity to study the longer-term embedding, adaptation and abandonment of digital innovations. Research questions: What was the range of responses to the expansion of remote and digital triage and consultations among United Kingdom general practices in the period following the acute phase of the coronavirus disease discovered in 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic? What can we learn from this example about the long-term impacts of crisis-driven sociotechnical change in healthcare settings? Methods: We collected longitudinal data from 12 general practices from 2021 to 2023, comprising 500 hours of ethnographic observation, 163 interviews in participating practices and linked organisations (132 staff, 31 patients), 39 stakeholder interviews and 4 multi-stakeholder workshops (210 participants), with additional patient and public involvement input. Data were de-identified, uploaded to NVivo (QSR International, Warrington, UK) and synthesised into case studies, drawing on theories of organisational innovation. Results: General practices’ longitudinal progress varied, from a near-total return to traditional in-person services to extensive continuing use of novel digital technologies and pathways. Their efforts to find the right balance were shaped and constrained by numerous contextual factors. Large size, slack resources, high absorptive capacity, strong leadership and good intrapractice relationships favoured innovation. Readiness for remote and digital modalities varied depending on local tension for change, practice values and patient characteristics. Technologies' uptake and use were influenced by their material properties and functionality. Embedding and sustaining technologies required ongoing work to adapt and refine tasks and processes and adjust (or, where appropriate, selectively abandon) technologies. Adoption and embedding of technologies were affected by various staff and patient factors. When technologies fitted poorly with tasks and routines or when embedding efforts were unsuccessful, inefficiencies and ‘techno-stress’ resulted, with compromises to patient access and quality of care. Limitations: Sampling frame was limited to United Kingdom and patient interviews were relatively sparse. Conclusion: There is wide variation in digital maturity among United Kingdom general practices. Low use of remote and digital technologies and processes may be warranted and reflect local strategic choices, but it may also indicate lack of awareness and a reactive rather than strategic approach to digital innovation. We offer an updated typology of digital maturity in general practice with suggestions for tailored support. Future work: The typology of digital maturity could be applied further to identify in more detail the kind of support needed for practices that are at different stages of maturity and are serving different populations. The need for strategically traditional practices in deprived settings should also be explored. Funding: This article presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme as award number NIHR132807.
- 1 June 2025
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- p. 1-37
Open AccessAfter the disruptive innovation: How remote and digital services were embedded, blended and abandoned in UK general practice – longitudinal study
Background: United Kingdom general practices transitioned rapidly to remote-by-default services in 2020 and subsequently considered whether and how to continue these practices. Their diverse responses provided a unique opportunity to study the longer-term embedding, adaptation and abandonment of digital innovations. Research questions: What was the range of responses to the expansion of remote and digital triage and consultations among United Kingdom general practices in the period following the acute phase of the coronavirus disease discovered in 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic? What can we learn from this example about the long-term impacts of crisis-driven sociotechnical change in healthcare settings? Methods: We collected longitudinal data from 12 general practices from 2021 to 2023, comprising 500 hours of ethnographic observation, 163 interviews in participating practices and linked organisations (132 staff, 31 patients), 39 stakeholder interviews and 4 multi-stakeholder workshops (210 participants), with additional patient and public involvement input. Data were de-identified, uploaded to NVivo (QSR International, Warrington, UK) and synthesised into case studies, drawing on theories of organisational innovation. Results: General practices’ longitudinal progress varied, from a near-total return to traditional in-person services to extensive continuing use of novel digital technologies and pathways. Their efforts to find the right balance were shaped and constrained by numerous contextual factors. Large size, slack resources, high absorptive capacity, strong leadership and good intrapractice relationships favoured innovation. Readiness for remote and digital modalities varied depending on local tension for change, practice values and patient characteristics. Technologies' uptake and use were influenced by their material properties and functionality. Embedding and sustaining technologies required ongoing work to adapt and refine tasks and processes and adjust (or, where appropriate, selectively abandon) technologies. Adoption and embedding of technologies were affected by various staff and patient factors. When technologies fitted poorly with tasks and routines or when embedding efforts were unsuccessful, inefficiencies and ‘techno-stress’ resulted, with compromises to patient access and quality of care. Limitations: Sampling frame was limited to United Kingdom and patient interviews were relatively sparse. Conclusion: There is wide variation in digital maturity among United Kingdom general practices. Low use of remote and digital technologies and processes may be warranted and reflect local strategic choices, but it may also indicate lack of awareness and a reactive rather than strategic approach to digital innovation. We offer an updated typology of digital maturity in general practice with suggestions for tailored support. Future work: The typology of digital maturity could be applied further to identify in more detail the kind of support needed for practices that are at different stages of maturity and are serving different populations. The need for strategically traditional practices in deprived settings should also be explored. Funding: This article presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme as award number NIHR132807.
- Open Access
- 8 January 2025
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 75 (752) , e211-e221
Technostress, technosuffering, and relational strain: a multi-method qualitative study of how remote and digital work affects staff in UK general practice
Background: The introduction of remote and digital forms of working in UK general practice has driven the development of new routines and working styles. Aim: To explore and theorise how new forms of work have affected general practice staff. Design and setting: Multi-sited, qualitative case study in UK general practice. Method: Using longitudinal ethnography by researchers in residence, we followed 12 practices for 28 months (September 2021 to December 2023). This core dataset was supplemented by workshops and stakeholder interviews. Data analysis applied theories from the sociology of work, organisation studies, and internet studies. Results: Staff made significant efforts to adapt to and embed digital services into their work. When technologies work well they can offer improved convenience, efficiency, more comprehensive patient care, and workplace fulfilment for staff. However, for many clinical and administrative staff, compromises and frictions embedded in digitalised workplace routines and processes could also lead to job dissatisfaction, worsened wellbeing, and misalignments with professional values and identities. We found that this workplace suffering caused relational strain between team members and had an impact on team cohesiveness and coordination. Conclusion: The digitalisation of working routines in UK general practice poses a unique challenge to the workforce, risking technostress, workplace suffering, and increased relational strain within and between teams. To embed the benefits of digitalisation, we must first improve practice teams’ readiness for change, which includes strengthening practices’ relational structures that provide support during periods of adaptation. Practices must be empowered to determine a locally appropriate configuration of digital tools and given the resources and time to adapt working routines.
- 8 January 2025
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 75 (752) , e211-e221
Open AccessTechnostress, technosuffering, and relational strain: a multi-method qualitative study of how remote and digital work affects staff in UK general practice
Background: The introduction of remote and digital forms of working in UK general practice has driven the development of new routines and working styles. Aim: To explore and theorise how new forms of work have affected general practice staff. Design and setting: Multi-sited, qualitative case study in UK general practice. Method: Using longitudinal ethnography by researchers in residence, we followed 12 practices for 28 months (September 2021 to December 2023). This core dataset was supplemented by workshops and stakeholder interviews. Data analysis applied theories from the sociology of work, organisation studies, and internet studies. Results: Staff made significant efforts to adapt to and embed digital services into their work. When technologies work well they can offer improved convenience, efficiency, more comprehensive patient care, and workplace fulfilment for staff. However, for many clinical and administrative staff, compromises and frictions embedded in digitalised workplace routines and processes could also lead to job dissatisfaction, worsened wellbeing, and misalignments with professional values and identities. We found that this workplace suffering caused relational strain between team members and had an impact on team cohesiveness and coordination. Conclusion: The digitalisation of working routines in UK general practice poses a unique challenge to the workforce, risking technostress, workplace suffering, and increased relational strain within and between teams. To embed the benefits of digitalisation, we must first improve practice teams’ readiness for change, which includes strengthening practices’ relational structures that provide support during periods of adaptation. Practices must be empowered to determine a locally appropriate configuration of digital tools and given the resources and time to adapt working routines.
- Open Access
- 8 August 2024
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 75 (750) , e1-e11
Challenges to quality in contemporary, hybrid general practice a multi-site longitudinal case study
Background: Since 2022, general practice has shifted from responding to the acute challenges of COVID-19 to restoring full services using a hybrid of remote, digital, and in-person care. Aim: To examine how quality domains are addressed in contemporary UK general practice. Design and setting: Multi-site, mostly qualitative longitudinal case study, placed in UK national policy context. Method: Data were collected from longitudinal ethnographic case studies of 12 general practices (2021–2023), multi-stakeholder workshops, stakeholder interviews, patient surveys, official reports, and publicly accessible patient experience data. Data were coded thematically and analysed using multiple theories of quality. Results: Quality efforts in UK general practice occur in the context of cumulative impacts of financial austerity, loss of resilience, increasingly complex patterns of illness and need, a diverse and fragmented workforce, material and digital infrastructure that is unfit for purpose, and physically distant and asynchronous ways of working. Providing the human elements of traditional general practice (such as relationship-based care, compassion, and support) is difficult and sometimes even impossible. Systems designed to increase efficiency have introduced new forms of inefficiency and have compromised other quality domains such as accessibility, patient-centredness, and equity. Long-term condition management varies in quality. Measures to mitigate digital exclusion (such as digital navigators) are welcome but do not compensate for extremes of structural disadvantage. Many staff are stressed and demoralised. Conclusion: Contemporary hybrid general practice features changes (digitalisation, physical distancing, extension of roles, and protocolisation) that have had the unintended effect of dehumanising, compromising, and fragmenting care. Policymakers and practices should urgently address the risks to patients and the traditional core values of general practice should be urgently addressed.
- 8 August 2024
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 75 (750) , e1-e11
Open AccessChallenges to quality in contemporary, hybrid general practice a multi-site longitudinal case study
Background: Since 2022, general practice has shifted from responding to the acute challenges of COVID-19 to restoring full services using a hybrid of remote, digital, and in-person care. Aim: To examine how quality domains are addressed in contemporary UK general practice. Design and setting: Multi-site, mostly qualitative longitudinal case study, placed in UK national policy context. Method: Data were collected from longitudinal ethnographic case studies of 12 general practices (2021–2023), multi-stakeholder workshops, stakeholder interviews, patient surveys, official reports, and publicly accessible patient experience data. Data were coded thematically and analysed using multiple theories of quality. Results: Quality efforts in UK general practice occur in the context of cumulative impacts of financial austerity, loss of resilience, increasingly complex patterns of illness and need, a diverse and fragmented workforce, material and digital infrastructure that is unfit for purpose, and physically distant and asynchronous ways of working. Providing the human elements of traditional general practice (such as relationship-based care, compassion, and support) is difficult and sometimes even impossible. Systems designed to increase efficiency have introduced new forms of inefficiency and have compromised other quality domains such as accessibility, patient-centredness, and equity. Long-term condition management varies in quality. Measures to mitigate digital exclusion (such as digital navigators) are welcome but do not compensate for extremes of structural disadvantage. Many staff are stressed and demoralised. Conclusion: Contemporary hybrid general practice features changes (digitalisation, physical distancing, extension of roles, and protocolisation) that have had the unintended effect of dehumanising, compromising, and fragmenting care. Policymakers and practices should urgently address the risks to patients and the traditional core values of general practice should be urgently addressed.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 12 April 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Social Science & Medicine
- Vol. 349, 116885
Access and triage in contemporary general practice: A novel theory of digital candidacy
- 12 April 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Social Science & Medicine
- Vol. 349, 116885
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessAccess and triage in contemporary general practice: A novel theory of digital candidacy