Uma Prashant Navare
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Uma Prashant Navare has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Agnieszka Wykowska
5 shared publications- Agnieszka Wykowska
Italian Institute of Technology, Genoa, Italy
3 shared publications - Cecilia Roselli
Social Cognition in Human-Robot Interaction, Italian Institute of Technology, Genoa, Italy
3 shared publications Francesca Ciardo
3 shared publications- Serena Marchesi
Italian Institute of Technology, Genoa, Italy
3 shared publications - Davide De Tommaso
Social Cognition in Human-Robot Interaction Group, Italian Institute of Technology, Genoa, Italy
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 26 June 2024
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Robotics
- Vol. 9 (91) , eadj3665
When performing actions with robots, attribution of intentionality affects the sense of joint agency
Sense of joint agency (SoJA) is the sense of control experienced by humans when acting with others to bring about changes in the shared environment. SoJA is proposed to arise from the sensorimotor predictive processes underlying action control and monitoring. Because SoJA is a ubiquitous phenomenon occurring when we perform actions with other humans, it is of great interest and importance to understand whether—and under what conditions—SoJA occurs in collaborative tasks with humanoid robots. In this study, using behavioral measures and neural responses measured by electroencephalography (EEG), we aimed to evaluate whether SoJA occurs in joint action with the humanoid robot iCub and whether its emergence is influenced by the perceived intentionality of the robot. Behavioral results show that participants experienced SoJA with the robot partner when it was presented as an intentional agent but not when it was presented as a mechanical artifact. EEG results show that the mechanism that influences the emergence of SoJA in the condition when the robot is presented as an intentional agent is the ability to form similarly accurate predictions about the sensory consequences of our own and others’ actions, leading to similar modulatory activity over sensory processing. Together, our results shed light on the joint sensorimotor processing mechanisms underlying the emergence of SoJA in human-robot interaction and underscore the importance of attribution of intentionality to the robot in human-robot collaboration.
- 26 June 2024
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Robotics
- Vol. 9 (91) , eadj3665
When performing actions with robots, attribution of intentionality affects the sense of joint agency
Sense of joint agency (SoJA) is the sense of control experienced by humans when acting with others to bring about changes in the shared environment. SoJA is proposed to arise from the sensorimotor predictive processes underlying action control and monitoring. Because SoJA is a ubiquitous phenomenon occurring when we perform actions with other humans, it is of great interest and importance to understand whether—and under what conditions—SoJA occurs in collaborative tasks with humanoid robots. In this study, using behavioral measures and neural responses measured by electroencephalography (EEG), we aimed to evaluate whether SoJA occurs in joint action with the humanoid robot iCub and whether its emergence is influenced by the perceived intentionality of the robot. Behavioral results show that participants experienced SoJA with the robot partner when it was presented as an intentional agent but not when it was presented as a mechanical artifact. EEG results show that the mechanism that influences the emergence of SoJA in the condition when the robot is presented as an intentional agent is the ability to form similarly accurate predictions about the sensory consequences of our own and others’ actions, leading to similar modulatory activity over sensory processing. Together, our results shed light on the joint sensorimotor processing mechanisms underlying the emergence of SoJA in human-robot interaction and underscore the importance of attribution of intentionality to the robot in human-robot collaboration.
- Open Access
- 10 November 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Social Robotics
- Vol. 16 (1) , 185-196
Type of Education Affects Individuals’ Adoption of Intentional Stance Towards Robots: An EEG Study
Research has shown that, under certain circumstances, people can adopt the Intentional Stance towards robots and thus treat them as intentional agents. Previous evidence showed that there are factors at play in modulating the Intentional Stance, for example individuals’ years of education. In the present study, we aimed at investigating whether, given the same years of education, participants’ type of formal education- in terms of theoretical background- affected their adoption of the Intentional Stance.To do so, we recruited two samples of participants varying in their type of formal education, namely, a sample of participants comprised individuals with a background in robotics, whereas the other comprised individuals with a background in psychotherapy. To measure their likelihood of adopting the Intentional Stance, we asked them to complete the InStance Test (IST). To do it at the neural level, we recorded their neural activity during a resting state via electroencephalography (EEG).Results showed that therapists attributed higher IST scores of intentionality to the robot than roboticists, i.e., they were more likely to attribute Intentional Stance to explain robot’s behaviour.This result was mirrored by participants’ EEG neural activity during resting state, as we found higher power in the gamma frequency range (associated with mentalizing and the adoption of Intentional Stance) for therapists compared to roboticists.Therefore, we conclude that the type of education that promotes mentalizing skills increases the likelihood of attributing intentionality to robots.
- 10 November 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Social Robotics
- Vol. 16 (1) , 185-196
Open AccessType of Education Affects Individuals’ Adoption of Intentional Stance Towards Robots: An EEG Study
Research has shown that, under certain circumstances, people can adopt the Intentional Stance towards robots and thus treat them as intentional agents. Previous evidence showed that there are factors at play in modulating the Intentional Stance, for example individuals’ years of education. In the present study, we aimed at investigating whether, given the same years of education, participants’ type of formal education- in terms of theoretical background- affected their adoption of the Intentional Stance.To do so, we recruited two samples of participants varying in their type of formal education, namely, a sample of participants comprised individuals with a background in robotics, whereas the other comprised individuals with a background in psychotherapy. To measure their likelihood of adopting the Intentional Stance, we asked them to complete the InStance Test (IST). To do it at the neural level, we recorded their neural activity during a resting state via electroencephalography (EEG).Results showed that therapists attributed higher IST scores of intentionality to the robot than roboticists, i.e., they were more likely to attribute Intentional Stance to explain robot’s behaviour.This result was mirrored by participants’ EEG neural activity during resting state, as we found higher power in the gamma frequency range (associated with mentalizing and the adoption of Intentional Stance) for therapists compared to roboticists.Therefore, we conclude that the type of education that promotes mentalizing skills increases the likelihood of attributing intentionality to robots.
- Open Access
- 8 February 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Theta Synchronization as a Neural Marker of flexible (re-)use of socio-cognitive mechanisms for a new category of (artificial) interaction partners
Previous work shows that in some instances artificial agents, such as robots, can elicit higher-order socio-cognitive mechanisms, similar to those elicited by humans. This suggests that these socio-cognitive mechanisms, such as mentalizing processes, originally developed for interaction with other humans, might be flexibly (re-)used, or “hijacked”, for approaching this new category of interaction partners (Wykowska, 2020). In this study, we set out to identify neural markers of such flexible reuse of socio-cognitive mechanisms. We focused on fronto-parietal theta synchronization, as it has been proposed to be a substrate of cognitive flexibility in general (Fries, 2005). We analyzed EEG data from two experiments (Bossi et al., 2020; Roselli et al., submitted), in which participants completed a test measuring their individual likelihood to adopt the intentional stance towards robots, the intentional stance (IST) test. Our results show that participants with higher scores on the IST, indicating that they had higher likelihood of adopting the intentional stance towards a robot, had a significantly higher theta synchronization value, relative to participants with lower scores on the IST. These results suggest that long-range synchronization in the theta band might be a marker socio-cognitive process that can be flexibly applied towards non-human agents, such as robots.
- 8 February 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessTheta Synchronization as a Neural Marker of flexible (re-)use of socio-cognitive mechanisms for a new category of (artificial) interaction partners
Previous work shows that in some instances artificial agents, such as robots, can elicit higher-order socio-cognitive mechanisms, similar to those elicited by humans. This suggests that these socio-cognitive mechanisms, such as mentalizing processes, originally developed for interaction with other humans, might be flexibly (re-)used, or “hijacked”, for approaching this new category of interaction partners (Wykowska, 2020). In this study, we set out to identify neural markers of such flexible reuse of socio-cognitive mechanisms. We focused on fronto-parietal theta synchronization, as it has been proposed to be a substrate of cognitive flexibility in general (Fries, 2005). We analyzed EEG data from two experiments (Bossi et al., 2020; Roselli et al., submitted), in which participants completed a test measuring their individual likelihood to adopt the intentional stance towards robots, the intentional stance (IST) test. Our results show that participants with higher scores on the IST, indicating that they had higher likelihood of adopting the intentional stance towards a robot, had a significantly higher theta synchronization value, relative to participants with lower scores on the IST. These results suggest that long-range synchronization in the theta band might be a marker socio-cognitive process that can be flexibly applied towards non-human agents, such as robots.
- Open Access
- 3 February 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Performing actions with robots: attribution of intentionality affects the joint sense of agency
Joint sense of agency (JSoA) is the feeling of control experienced in joint action over one’s own and a partner’s actions and is proposed to arise from the sensorimotor predictive processes underlying action control and monitoring. In the current study, using interval estimates and neural responses measured by EEG, we aimed to evaluate whether JSoA is influenced by the perceived intentionality of a partner (a humanoid robot). Our behavioral results show that participants experienced JSoA with the partner when it was presented as seemingly intentional, but not when it was presented as a seemingly unintentional. Our EEG results support the idea that when a partner is introduced as intentional, self- and other-forward models are better integrated into a joint model, relative to when the partner is introduced as unintentional. Together, our results provide novel evidence that JSoA and joint sensorimotor processing are influenced by the perceived intentionality of the partner.
- 3 February 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessPerforming actions with robots: attribution of intentionality affects the joint sense of agency
Joint sense of agency (JSoA) is the feeling of control experienced in joint action over one’s own and a partner’s actions and is proposed to arise from the sensorimotor predictive processes underlying action control and monitoring. In the current study, using interval estimates and neural responses measured by EEG, we aimed to evaluate whether JSoA is influenced by the perceived intentionality of a partner (a humanoid robot). Our behavioral results show that participants experienced JSoA with the partner when it was presented as seemingly intentional, but not when it was presented as a seemingly unintentional. Our EEG results support the idea that when a partner is introduced as intentional, self- and other-forward models are better integrated into a joint model, relative to when the partner is introduced as unintentional. Together, our results provide novel evidence that JSoA and joint sensorimotor processing are influenced by the perceived intentionality of the partner.
- Open Access
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Type of education affects individuals’ adoption of Intentional Stance towards robots: an EEG study
Research has shown that, under certain circumstances, people can adopt the Intentional Stance towards robots and thus treat them as intentional agents. One factor potentially affecting individuals’ adoption of the Intentional Stance is the type of education (and presumably their prior knowledge about robots). In the present study, we investigated whether participants’ type of (formal) education modulated their adoption of the Intentional Stance. We asked two samples of participants to complete the InStance Test, to measure the individual tendency to attribute mental states to robots. One sample comprised individuals with a background in robotics, while the other comprised individuals with a background in psychotherapy. Before the beginning of the task, we recorded participants’ neural activity during a resting state. At the behavioral level, results showed that therapists scored higher in the InStance Test than roboticists, i.e., their likelihood of adopting the Intentional Stance was higher. This result was mirrored by participants’ neural activity during resting state, as we found higher power in the gamma frequency range (associated with mentalizing and the adoption of Intentional Stance) for therapists compared to roboticists.Therefore, we conclude that the type of education that promotes mentalizing skills increases the likelihood of attributing intentionality to robots.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessType of education affects individuals’ adoption of Intentional Stance towards robots: an EEG study
Research has shown that, under certain circumstances, people can adopt the Intentional Stance towards robots and thus treat them as intentional agents. One factor potentially affecting individuals’ adoption of the Intentional Stance is the type of education (and presumably their prior knowledge about robots). In the present study, we investigated whether participants’ type of (formal) education modulated their adoption of the Intentional Stance. We asked two samples of participants to complete the InStance Test, to measure the individual tendency to attribute mental states to robots. One sample comprised individuals with a background in robotics, while the other comprised individuals with a background in psychotherapy. Before the beginning of the task, we recorded participants’ neural activity during a resting state. At the behavioral level, results showed that therapists scored higher in the InStance Test than roboticists, i.e., their likelihood of adopting the Intentional Stance was higher. This result was mirrored by participants’ neural activity during resting state, as we found higher power in the gamma frequency range (associated with mentalizing and the adoption of Intentional Stance) for therapists compared to roboticists.Therefore, we conclude that the type of education that promotes mentalizing skills increases the likelihood of attributing intentionality to robots.
- Open Access
- 15 November 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Does Embodiment and Interaction Affect the Adoption of the Intentional Stance Towards a Humanoid Robot?
Humanoid robots are a useful research tool to understand which factors trigger the adoption of the Intentional Stance (i.e., the attribution of mental states). The InStance Test (IST), assesses this with the isolated robot subscale and the social robot subscale - where higher scores reflect a greater tendency to adopt the Intentional Stance. Previous work found that when a human interacts with an embodied robot exhibiting human-like behaviour, their IST scores in-crease. However, it is not yet known whether this effect is robust to changes in embodiment or interaction. Subsequently, we administered both subscales before and after participants witnessed a humanoid robot exhibiting human-like behav-iour. There was a significant increase in both scales after participants (1) inter-acted with the embodied robot, (2) watched a video of the robot interacting with a human and (3) watched a video of the robot without interaction. Secondly, to check there were no differences across the human-like experiments, we compared the differences of the magnitude of the IST score increase. We found no signifi-cant differences across the experiments. Additionally, we conducted follow-up control analyses’ with the robot exhibiting machine-like behaviour, to ensure the increases were not due to exposure effects. We found no significant difference in the IST after participants (1) interacted with the embodied robot or (2) watched a video of the robot interacting with a human. These results show that the in-creased IST scores after witnessing iCub behaving in a human-like way, is not due to mere exposure and is robust to changes in embodiment and interaction.
- 15 November 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessDoes Embodiment and Interaction Affect the Adoption of the Intentional Stance Towards a Humanoid Robot?
Humanoid robots are a useful research tool to understand which factors trigger the adoption of the Intentional Stance (i.e., the attribution of mental states). The InStance Test (IST), assesses this with the isolated robot subscale and the social robot subscale - where higher scores reflect a greater tendency to adopt the Intentional Stance. Previous work found that when a human interacts with an embodied robot exhibiting human-like behaviour, their IST scores in-crease. However, it is not yet known whether this effect is robust to changes in embodiment or interaction. Subsequently, we administered both subscales before and after participants witnessed a humanoid robot exhibiting human-like behav-iour. There was a significant increase in both scales after participants (1) inter-acted with the embodied robot, (2) watched a video of the robot interacting with a human and (3) watched a video of the robot without interaction. Secondly, to check there were no differences across the human-like experiments, we compared the differences of the magnitude of the IST score increase. We found no signifi-cant differences across the experiments. Additionally, we conducted follow-up control analyses’ with the robot exhibiting machine-like behaviour, to ensure the increases were not due to exposure effects. We found no significant difference in the IST after participants (1) interacted with the embodied robot or (2) watched a video of the robot interacting with a human. These results show that the in-creased IST scores after witnessing iCub behaving in a human-like way, is not due to mere exposure and is robust to changes in embodiment and interaction.
- Open Access
- 22 August 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Task sharing with the humanoid robot iCub increases the likelihood of adopting the intentional stance
When acting together with another human agent, humans form shared representations with their partner in order to predict and adjust to their partner’s behaviors and ensure a smooth and efficient joint action. Previous work has shown that humans do not form shared representations when acting with partners they do not perceive as intentional, such as computers or robots. In the current study, we investigated the effect in the opposite direction: we asked whether engaging in a task with the humanoid robot iCub, in order to achieve a shared goal, could influence the perceived intentionality of the robot. In our study, participants completed a target tracking and detection task with iCub, in which each agent fulfilled different but complementary roles, thus sharing the task. Participants’ likelihood of perceiving the robot as intentional was assessed before and after the interaction. Results showed that participants were more likely to perceive iCub as an intentional agent after they shared the task with it, suggesting that interacting with a robot to achieve a common goal promotes attribution of intentionality toward the robot.
- 22 August 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessTask sharing with the humanoid robot iCub increases the likelihood of adopting the intentional stance
When acting together with another human agent, humans form shared representations with their partner in order to predict and adjust to their partner’s behaviors and ensure a smooth and efficient joint action. Previous work has shown that humans do not form shared representations when acting with partners they do not perceive as intentional, such as computers or robots. In the current study, we investigated the effect in the opposite direction: we asked whether engaging in a task with the humanoid robot iCub, in order to achieve a shared goal, could influence the perceived intentionality of the robot. In our study, participants completed a target tracking and detection task with iCub, in which each agent fulfilled different but complementary roles, thus sharing the task. Participants’ likelihood of perceiving the robot as intentional was assessed before and after the interaction. Results showed that participants were more likely to perceive iCub as an intentional agent after they shared the task with it, suggesting that interacting with a robot to achieve a common goal promotes attribution of intentionality toward the robot.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 357-366
Does Embodiment and Interaction Affect the Adoption of the Intentional Stance Towards a Humanoid Robot?
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 357-366
Does Embodiment and Interaction Affect the Adoption of the Intentional Stance Towards a Humanoid Robot?