Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Dagmar Gesmann-Nuissl has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Towards Hybrid Personae?

    by Stefanie Meyer, Michael R. Müller, Anne Sonnenmoser, Sarah Mandl, Anja Strobel, Dagmar Gesmann-Nuissl

    When we think of future hybrid societies, this goes far beyond conventional scenarios. We have long since moved away from humans working only by hand or with the help of machines, and we already find technologized humans, humanized technology, and hybrid entities within a society, and even more so in the future. In this paper, we explore how all these entities fit into existing legal, psychological, and sociological constructions. We shed light on the attributions to an acting entity from the respective disciplines and explore whether hybrid entities can possess personality, paving the way for a hybrid personae. It becomes clear that at the core of conventional considerations is the biological person. Based on common definitions of person and personality, psychological considerations do not, up to now, grant personality to artificial actors. This explicitly excludes all kinds of technology where a human being is involved, irrespective of the level of technicity. Sociology can also designate machine entities as actors. The concept of person is always connected with the human being. In legal science, it is conceivable and not excluded in advance, to extend the concept of personhood to hybrid entities as well, at least under certain conditions and perspectives.

  • Open Access

    Gyro Gearloose or Little Helper?—Two Perspectives of AI and Patent Law

    by Dagmar Gesmann-Nuissl, Stefanie Meyer

    Recently, patent offices around the world were concerned with the patent application for a blinking light and a fractal food container, and extensively discussed the requirements for granting a patent. This unprecedented case sparked extensive discussions as “Dabus AI” was filed as an inventor—an autonomously acting software. This case raised a number of issues concerning patent law, in particular whether an invention in the field of artificial intelligence (AI) is patentable, and moreover, whether the invention made by an AI is patentable. In this paper, we address these two perspectives by discussing the legal requirements for filing a patent application and applying the two perspectives described to these requirements. We conclude that, as of now, only the human inventor Gyro Gearloose can be a patentable inventor. The time when his little helper will occupy a similar position is still in the future—but it is worth looking beyond the horizon into the future.

  • Umweltmanagement und Recht

    by Dagmar Gesmann-Nuissl

  • Open Access

    ELSA for the Smart City: Ethical, Legal, and Social Technologization of Homes, Cities, and Societies Through Standardized ELSA-Assessment—A Legal Point of View

    by Dagmar Gesmann-Nuissl, Ines Tacke, Bianca Olschewski

    Smart living environments such as the Smart Home or the Smart City are created by connecting various smart devices. The data-driven character of these IoT devices (IoT—Internet of Things) leads not only to an increase in comfort, but gives also rise to new legal, ethical, and social risks. Even though, IoT devices that are to be placed on the market in Europe shall undergo an approval process during which they are evaluated for their compliance with the entire legal system. Nevertheless, there is still a need to improve the analysis of the legal, ethical, and social impact on society prior to approving new technologies. Moreover, when different sets of data from individual devices are connected, more comprehensive information about residents can be accessed. Thus, legal, ethical, and social challenges also arise from the combination of several devices in a network in the context of Smart Homes or Smart Cities. We propose a standardized ELSA-assessment (ELSA—ethical, legal, social aspects) as a tool for the comprehensive analysis of IoT devices as well as networks. If the structure and composition of the IoT network is changed by adding a device or service, the assessment should be repeated. The standardized ELSA assessment could support responsible stakeholders in identifying and successfully mitigating unacceptable risks. Standardization of the assessment should enable repeatability and thus comparability of assessment results. In this way, legal, ethical, and social technologization of the Smart City can be ensured.


  • Open Access

    „Stop it, Fridge!“ – Legally Secure and Interest-Based Data Sharing in the Age of Modern (Cyber) Technology

    by Dagmar Gesmann-Nuissl, Ines Maria Tacke, Stefanie Meyer

    As part of the modern Internet, Internet of Things (IoT) devices are particularly indispensable. The reason these devices fit so seamlessly into our everyday lives is that they constantly generate, process and evaluate data (using the Internet) and can react smoothly to circumstances – such as the refrigerator that automatically reorders missing food or a maintenance monitory system in smart homes that assigns digital maintenance orders to the responsible tradesmen. These data flows and underlying information are the subject of a wide variety of legal projects: Europe aims to become a pioneer of the data economy by providing access to available data accessible for further value and business models. Subject matter includes both personal data and non-personal data, such as IoT machine data. To achieve these politicaleconomic goals, but also to ensure the interests of users and especially manufacturers in confidentiality and fair competition, we introduce the person of the neutral data intermediary: the data innovator.

  • Open Access

    Black Hole Instead of Black Box?: The Double Opaqueness of Recommender Systems on Gaming Platforms and Its Legal Implications

    by Dagmar Gesmann-Nuissl, Stefanie Meyer

    Recommender systems that support us in our everyday lives are becoming more precise and accurate in terms of the appropriateness of recommendations to users’ needs – with the result that the user often follows these recommendations. This is mainly due to the filtering methods and various algorithms used. In our paper, we will look specifically at the recommender systems on gaming platforms. These consist of different components: a shopping component, a streaming component and a social media component. The recommender systems of these components, when considered individually, have certain characteristics in terms of the machine learning and filtering methods used, which are mixed by combining them on one platform. As a result, it is unclear which of the information collected about the user at any time is lost and disappears into obscurity, and what information is used to generate recommendations. The frequently discussed “black box” problem exacerbates at this point and becomes a “black hole.” With the interests of platform users, platform operators, and software developers in mind, we examine the legal provisions that have been established to address this opaqueness: transparency obligations. Derived from the Digital Services Act and the Artificial Intelligence Act, we present various legally valid solutions to address the “black hole” problem and also lead them to practical suggestions for implementation.


  • Miniaturized Smart Systems Securing Credence Attributes and Responsibility in Products and Supply Chains

    by Marlen G. Arnold, Dagmar Gesmann-Nuissl, Thomas Blaudeck, Daniil Karnaushenko, Oliver G. Schmidt

    Product safety in terms of authenticity of components and other hardware elements of the value chain is still limited in terms of responsibility and sustain ability. Although there are various strategies for securing product safety, including diverse technologies, fraud is still happening. There is a lack of appropriate technologies for securing supply chains including goods beyond the component level. Miniaturized smart systems could be an option for increasing responsibility and security in this context. This paper investigates pivotal SWOTs of miniaturized smart systems for securing credence attributes along supply chains including goods beyond the component level. Results show great potentials and the need for further investigation, including a comprehensive discussion of legal and ethical challenges.


  • Open Access

    Siri 2.0—Conversational Commerce of Social Bots and the New Law of Obligations of Data: Explorations for the Benefit of Consumer Protection

    by Dagmar Gesmann-Nuissl, Stefanie Meyer

    The possibilities and reach of social networks are increasing, designs are becoming more diverse, and ideas more visionary. Most recently, the former company “Facebook” announced the creation of a metaverse. With these technical possibilities, however, the danger of fraudsters is also growing. Using social bots, consumers are increasingly influenced on such platforms and business transactions are brought about through communication, i.e., conversational commerce. Minors or the elderly are particularly susceptible. This technical development is accompanied by a legal one: it is permitted by the Digital Services Directive and the Sale of Goods Directive to demand the provision of data as consideration for the sale of digital products. This raises legal problems at the level of the law of obligations and data protection law, whose regulations are intended to protect the aforementioned groups of individuals. This protection becomes even more important the more gullible consumers are influenced by communicative bots. We show that there is a lack of knowledge about what value objective data can have in business transactions. The sufficient transparency of objective data value can maintain legal protection, especially of vulnerable groups, and ensure the purpose of the laws.


  • Untying the Gordian Knot: Legally Compliant Sound Data Collection and Processing for TTS Systems in China

    by Stefanie Meyer, Sven Albrecht, Maximilian Eibl, Günter Daniel Rey, Josef Schmied, Rewa Tamboli, Stefan Taubert, Dagmar Gesmann-Nuissl