Shakhrizat Agaidarova
Shakhrizat Agaidarova has a total of 11 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nuri Balta
SDU University, Almaty, Kazakhstan
2 shared publications - Samat Maxutov
SDU University, Almaty, Kazakhstan
2 shared publications - Abbas Bodaubekov
SDU University, Almaty, Kazakhstan
1 shared publication - Alberto Fernández-Costales
University of Oviedo
1 shared publication - Davronzhon Gaipov
SDU University
1 shared publication - Elvira Barrios
Universidad de Málaga
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 14 September 2026
- Published by Toraighyrov University in Bulletin of Toraighyrov University. Pedagogics series
- No. 3, 2026
Scoping Review of Disciplinary Literacy Development in Content and Language Integrated Learning
Disciplinary literacy development is an emerging issue in multilingual education, where Content and Language Integrated Learning is a contributing tool. Numerous studies investigated disciplinary literacy in CLIL from different perspectives, locations, and backgrounds. This systematic review aims to synthesize and identify the research gap to understand the central phenomenon better. Evident from the results, included studies employed diverse methodologies such as exploratory studies, design-based research, longitudinal case studies, and cross-sectional studies. Moreover, research instruments included oral and written tasks, video-recorded lessons, competency-based and practical activity tasks, reflective journals, and portfolios. The selected studies utilized Cognitive Discourse Functions, Uptake, Systemic Functional Linguistics, Genre-based pedagogy, and Pluraliteracies as primary theoretical constructs. The novelty is that this is the first paper to conduct a systematic review of disciplinary literacy in CLIL, where recommendations for further contextual research are provided. A novel contribution of this systematic review is the integration of quantitative and qualitative data analysis when presenting the synthesis of the selected articles. This paper tabulates the selected articles’ key characteristics, forming a groundwork for further research. Correspondingly, the study concludes with the limitations and scholars’ assumptions. Keywords: disciplinary literacy, CLIL, multilingual education, systematic review, cognitive discourse functions, language across curriculum, subject-specific vocabulary, content education
- 14 September 2026
- Published by Toraighyrov University in Bulletin of Toraighyrov University. Pedagogics series
- No. 3, 2026
Scoping Review of Disciplinary Literacy Development in Content and Language Integrated Learning
Disciplinary literacy development is an emerging issue in multilingual education, where Content and Language Integrated Learning is a contributing tool. Numerous studies investigated disciplinary literacy in CLIL from different perspectives, locations, and backgrounds. This systematic review aims to synthesize and identify the research gap to understand the central phenomenon better. Evident from the results, included studies employed diverse methodologies such as exploratory studies, design-based research, longitudinal case studies, and cross-sectional studies. Moreover, research instruments included oral and written tasks, video-recorded lessons, competency-based and practical activity tasks, reflective journals, and portfolios. The selected studies utilized Cognitive Discourse Functions, Uptake, Systemic Functional Linguistics, Genre-based pedagogy, and Pluraliteracies as primary theoretical constructs. The novelty is that this is the first paper to conduct a systematic review of disciplinary literacy in CLIL, where recommendations for further contextual research are provided. A novel contribution of this systematic review is the integration of quantitative and qualitative data analysis when presenting the synthesis of the selected articles. This paper tabulates the selected articles’ key characteristics, forming a groundwork for further research. Correspondingly, the study concludes with the limitations and scholars’ assumptions. Keywords: disciplinary literacy, CLIL, multilingual education, systematic review, cognitive discourse functions, language across curriculum, subject-specific vocabulary, content education
- 30 June 2026
- Published by SDU University in Педагогика и методы обучения
- Vol. 75 (2) , 52-67
Developing Kazakhstani science capital through CLIL in the context of international olympiads
Science capital development is becoming a priority in Kazakhstan. The country endeavors to incorporate international best practices into its education system, yet insufficient research and preparation hinder effective implementation. However, bottom-up practice blends post-Soviet educational methodologies with modern approaches, resulting in a hybrid approach. One such initiative is teaching science through Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) employing English. CLIL serves as a transformative strategy in multilingual educational contexts, bridging language and content for deeper comprehension. This study explores how students develop their science capital within CLIL settings through the lens of the Science Capital framework. We examined students' perspectives through interviews, observations, and analyzed official policy documents to support the findings. Our findings align with previous literature. However, this study introduces a novel perspective on languages used in science education. It was found that Russian remains one of the dominant languages in science education despite ongoing efforts to implement the Kazakhization policy. Moreover, field notes indicate that participants lack practical skills and experimental knowledge, hindering their ability to compete in high-stakes Olympiads and limiting the full development of their science capital. Correspondingly, to unlock Kazakhstan's holistic capital and foster an informed citizenry, it is crucial to integrate the local language(s) more effectively into science education policy and improve the curriculum to enhance theoretical and practical scientific competencies.
- 30 June 2026
- Published by SDU University in Педагогика и методы обучения
- Vol. 75 (2) , 52-67
Developing Kazakhstani science capital through CLIL in the context of international olympiads
Science capital development is becoming a priority in Kazakhstan. The country endeavors to incorporate international best practices into its education system, yet insufficient research and preparation hinder effective implementation. However, bottom-up practice blends post-Soviet educational methodologies with modern approaches, resulting in a hybrid approach. One such initiative is teaching science through Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) employing English. CLIL serves as a transformative strategy in multilingual educational contexts, bridging language and content for deeper comprehension. This study explores how students develop their science capital within CLIL settings through the lens of the Science Capital framework. We examined students' perspectives through interviews, observations, and analyzed official policy documents to support the findings. Our findings align with previous literature. However, this study introduces a novel perspective on languages used in science education. It was found that Russian remains one of the dominant languages in science education despite ongoing efforts to implement the Kazakhization policy. Moreover, field notes indicate that participants lack practical skills and experimental knowledge, hindering their ability to compete in high-stakes Olympiads and limiting the full development of their science capital. Correspondingly, to unlock Kazakhstan's holistic capital and foster an informed citizenry, it is crucial to integrate the local language(s) more effectively into science education policy and improve the curriculum to enhance theoretical and practical scientific competencies.
- Open Access
- 18 November 2025
- Published by University of Windsor Leddy Library in Journal of Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 19 (5)
Building Disciplinary Literacies in Content and Language Integrated Learning
Research on disciplinary literacy (DL) development in Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) demonstrates that it is an amalgamation of cognitive skills, academic content, and literacy. As an umbrella term, CLIL is an ideal teaching practice for building students’ content-specific disciplinary literacies (DLs) by simultaneously integrating cognition and language within a multilingual learning environment.
- 18 November 2025
- Published by University of Windsor Leddy Library in Journal of Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 19 (5)
Open AccessBuilding Disciplinary Literacies in Content and Language Integrated Learning
Research on disciplinary literacy (DL) development in Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) demonstrates that it is an amalgamation of cognitive skills, academic content, and literacy. As an umbrella term, CLIL is an ideal teaching practice for building students’ content-specific disciplinary literacies (DLs) by simultaneously integrating cognition and language within a multilingual learning environment.
- 3 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Intercultural Education
- Vol. 36 (6) , 761-769
Research note: science teachers’ intercultural competence in CLIL education
- 3 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Intercultural Education
- Vol. 36 (6) , 761-769
Research note: science teachers’ intercultural competence in CLIL education
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Bastas Publications in Contemporary Educational Technology
- Vol. 17 (1) , ep548
Leveraging AI to enhance writing skills of senior TFL students in Kazakhstan: A case study using “Write & Improve”
This study investigates the effectiveness of feedback provided by teachers versus feedback generated by the Write & Improve platform in enhancing the writing skills of senior undergraduate students enrolled in a “two foreign language” program at a private university in Kazakhstan. The quasi-experimental design involved four teachers, each teaching one control and one experimental class, totaling eight groups of students. Pre- and post-tests were conducted over a period of five weeks, focusing on task achievement, coherence and cohesion, lexical resource, grammar and accuracy, and overall score. Data analysis included descriptive statistics, Mann-Whitney U tests for pre-test comparisons, and MANCOVA analyses for post-test comparisons. Results show no significant difference in the impact of Write & Improve feedback compared to traditional teacher feedback across multiple dimensions of the writing test, both within individual teachers’ classes and when combined. Longitudinal analysis reveals fluctuating scores over time with no consistent improvement. Thus, the study concludes that the Write & Improve tool is equally effective as teacher feedback in improving students’ writing skills. This implies that educational institutions can potentially integrate technology-based feedback systems like Write & Improve alongside traditional teaching methods to enhance student learning outcomes in writing proficiency.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Bastas Publications in Contemporary Educational Technology
- Vol. 17 (1) , ep548
Open AccessLeveraging AI to enhance writing skills of senior TFL students in Kazakhstan: A case study using “Write & Improve”
This study investigates the effectiveness of feedback provided by teachers versus feedback generated by the Write & Improve platform in enhancing the writing skills of senior undergraduate students enrolled in a “two foreign language” program at a private university in Kazakhstan. The quasi-experimental design involved four teachers, each teaching one control and one experimental class, totaling eight groups of students. Pre- and post-tests were conducted over a period of five weeks, focusing on task achievement, coherence and cohesion, lexical resource, grammar and accuracy, and overall score. Data analysis included descriptive statistics, Mann-Whitney U tests for pre-test comparisons, and MANCOVA analyses for post-test comparisons. Results show no significant difference in the impact of Write & Improve feedback compared to traditional teacher feedback across multiple dimensions of the writing test, both within individual teachers’ classes and when combined. Longitudinal analysis reveals fluctuating scores over time with no consistent improvement. Thus, the study concludes that the Write & Improve tool is equally effective as teacher feedback in improving students’ writing skills. This implies that educational institutions can potentially integrate technology-based feedback systems like Write & Improve alongside traditional teaching methods to enhance student learning outcomes in writing proficiency.
- Open Access
- 5 September 2022
- Published by Modestum Ltd in EURASIA Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education
- Vol. 18 (10) , em2160
The effect of CLIL combined with language instruction on language learning and the role of individual and institutional factors in students’ perspectives: Empirical evidence from Kazakhstan
Content and language integrated learning (CLIL) is still a growing area of research. In this study, we investigated the effect of a one-semester CLIL intervention combined with English language instruction on university students’ general English skills the associations between institutional and individual factors and views on CLIL. A total of 105 students from two academic programs (biology-chemistry, and physic-informatics) at a private university in Kazakhstan participated in the study. Quantitative data were collected through two different instruments. MANOVA and correlation analyses were carried out to analyze the data. A large effect of CLIL combined with language instruction was observed on language gains. Additionally, the study identified two factors that are significantly associated with student recognition of higher language and disciplinary knowledge learning, more positive attitudes to and higher satisfaction with CLIL: being a non-first-year student and having CLIL experience in pre-university education. In light of the results obtained, our findings reinforce the case for integrating language instruction that includes general, academic, and subject-specific goals in English-medium programs and courses in higher education.
- 5 September 2022
- Published by Modestum Ltd in EURASIA Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education
- Vol. 18 (10) , em2160
Open AccessThe effect of CLIL combined with language instruction on language learning and the role of individual and institutional factors in students’ perspectives: Empirical evidence from Kazakhstan
Content and language integrated learning (CLIL) is still a growing area of research. In this study, we investigated the effect of a one-semester CLIL intervention combined with English language instruction on university students’ general English skills the associations between institutional and individual factors and views on CLIL. A total of 105 students from two academic programs (biology-chemistry, and physic-informatics) at a private university in Kazakhstan participated in the study. Quantitative data were collected through two different instruments. MANOVA and correlation analyses were carried out to analyze the data. A large effect of CLIL combined with language instruction was observed on language gains. Additionally, the study identified two factors that are significantly associated with student recognition of higher language and disciplinary knowledge learning, more positive attitudes to and higher satisfaction with CLIL: being a non-first-year student and having CLIL experience in pre-university education. In light of the results obtained, our findings reinforce the case for integrating language instruction that includes general, academic, and subject-specific goals in English-medium programs and courses in higher education.