APAllegra Pearce

Allegra Pearce

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Allegra Pearce has a total of 135 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Relationships Among MHC Diversity, Parasites and Secondary Sexual Colouration

    by Allegra E. Love, Jackie Lighten, Cock van Oosterhout, Alexander S. T. Papadopulos, Stanley D. King, Ian G. Paterson, Lari C. Delaire, Lyndsey Baillie, Ian R. Bradbury, Janay A. Fox, et al.

    Sexual selection via honest (costly) signals of fitness can generate patterns in immunogenetic diversity at the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). MHC diversity explains variation in immunocompetence—and therefore fitness—thus impacting the ability to generate honest signals. Differences in guppy ( Poecilia reticulata ) colour patterns can be driven by opposing selection pressures of predation and female mate choice, but the effect of parasitism has received less attention. By studying 21 wild guppy populations in Trinidad, we sought to quantify covariation among parasitic Gyrodactylus spp. infections, male sexual ornamentation (orange and black colouration) and genetic variation at the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) at both individual and population levels. We found population level support for a correlation between MHC diversity and Gyrodactylus prevalence, including an overall association between MHC supertype composition and prevalence. At the individual level, supertype (functional) diversity again emerged as a more informative measure than allelic richness alone. Predation was associated with Gyrodactylus prevalence and orange, but not black, colouration. Notably, some of these relationships differed between the individual and population levels. Further, much of this variation was explained by processes acting at a broader geographic scale within river drainages, which comprise divergent guppy lineages. These findings suggest that evolutionary history and processes such as genetic drift and gene flow contribute substantially to these relationships, but that ecological variation (i.e., predation) interacts with these processes. Our findings indicate that multi‐trait relationships between colour, immunogenetic diversity and infection are best examined within their broader evolutionary and ecological contexts.

  • Open Access

    Assessments of Credibility in the Social and Behavioral Sciences

    by Anna Lou Abatayo, Titipat Achakulvisut, Daniel Acuna, Balazs Aczel, Laxmaan Balaji, Anita Bandrowski, Daniel M. Benjamin, Michael Metcalf Bishop, Gary L. Brase, Andrew William Brown, et al.

    Credibility assessment — determining whether research findings are trustworthy or believable — is essential to the research process. One aspect of credibility is repeatability, which includes assessing whether consistent results are obtained when using new data to answer the same question (replicability), when repeating the original analyses with the original data (reproducibility), or when conducting alternative analyses about the same question with the original data (robustness). These features of repeatability differ in the resources required to investigate them, and it is unknown how they relate with one another and with other features of credibility. We investigated relationships among credibility measures in a stratified random sample of claims made across the social and behavioral sciences. Measures of repeatability were modestly correlated with each other (r’s = 0.30, -0.04, -0.23) though the correlation between robustness and reproducibility is likely misestimated because selecting claims for robustness testing was partly contingent on reproducibility success. Replicability and human and machine predictions of replicability were modestly correlated (Median r = 0.23; Range = -0.10 to 0.47). Though estimated with substantial uncertainty in some cases, no discipline showed consistently higher repeatability than other disciplines across measures. For example, Education had the highest replicability estimate (0.63, 95% CI [.32 - .86]) and the lowest reproducibility estimate (0.25, 95% CI [.25, 95% CI [.06 - .38]), whereas Economics had the lowest replicability estimate (0.43, 95% CI [.28 - .64]) and nearly the highest reproducibility estimate (0.70, 95% CI [.56 - .85]). Repeatability measures were modestly and heterogeneously associated with other potential indicators of credibility (Median |r| = 0.08; Range = 0.01 to 0.55). Credibility assessment is multidimensional with substantial opportunity for innovation and validation of its measurement.


  • Open Access

    Shifting forage selection subsidizes seasonal resource scarcity

    by Jack G. Hendrix, Kristy M. Ferraro, Allegra E. Love, Jill M. Kusch, Dara Albrecht, Shawn J. Leroux, Quinn M. R. Webber, Eric Vander Wal

    Nitrogen (N) is limiting for terrestrial herbivores, particularly over winter. Caribou ( Rangifer tarandus ) have adapted to seasonal scarcity of N by accruing muscle mass during the growing season when N is more abundant. Nitrogen stored in muscle tissue is then relied upon during winter to compensate for dietary deficits. Once their diet shifts from N-rich vascular plants to N-poor lichen over winter, caribou can lose ∼30% of their muscle mass. As catabolized N is shed in urine on wintering grounds, caribou could act as elemental transport across seasons and landscapes. Furthermore, if deposited N is taken up by lichen or other winter forage, it might enrich the nitrogen-poor winter diet of caribou in the future. We tested this potential transport via three steps. We analysed Cladonia spp. lichen and vascular plants upon which caribou forage across Fogo Island, Newfoundland, using %N content as our metric of forage quality. We then compared seasonal habitat selection responses to forage quality by caribou using integrated step selection analyses. In summer, caribou selected areas with higher vascular plant %N but did not select nor avoid Cladonia quality. In contrast, caribou selected sites with higher quality Cladonia in winter but responded neutrally to vascular plant quality. We compared seasonal distributions of caribou to determine whether nitrogen consumed in summer and deposited in winter would occur in spatially discrete locations. Population-level kernel density estimates for summer and winter in this island herd were mostly non-overlapping, lending credence to the potential landscape effects of N transport. When viewed together with established seasonal changes in woodland caribou physiology, sociality, and forage preferences, the shifts in habitat selection and seasonal ranges we observe here could serve as an adaptive strategy for caribou to recycle N and mitigate winter nutrient scarcity.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Trait‐based approaches to restoration ecology: Synthesizing insights from diverse systems

    by Julia K. Briand, Sheryl C. Hosler, Thomas K. Merchant, Rolf D. Vinebrooke, Rebecca Ostertag, Celia C. Symons, Marc W. Cadotte, Valerie T. Eviner, Matthew E. S. Bracken, Rachel R. Carlson, et al.

    Under accelerating global change, trait‐based approaches are emerging as essential tools in the ecological restoration toolbox. Where restoration has traditionally focused on the recovery of focal species in isolated systems, trait‐based methods can provide a common language that extends beyond species‐ or system‐specific contexts, allowing scientists and practitioners to translate insights across organisms and ecosystems and predict functional variation critical to resilience in the face of rapidly changing environmental conditions. Trait‐based insights can thus help achieve restoration that is both adaptable and scalable as future climate scenarios unfold. To date, trait‐based approaches to restoration have developed and proceeded independently across habitats and ecosystems, limiting information sharing and innovation. Here, we synthesize diverse perspectives and research on trait‐informed restoration across ecosystems, distilling our findings into three key insights. First, variable contexts and trade‐offs in trait–function linkages shape restoration outcomes at distinct ecological scales and project stages. For example, individual‐level traits that underpin stress tolerance may play a critical role in initial survival and establishment during early project stages, while traits that influence species interactions and modify energy transformation may play a larger role as communities reassemble and ecosystem function becomes a priority at later stages. Second, coordinating trait‐informed restoration across ecosystems can advance multi‐trophic and multi‐system restoration by closing the divide between “top down” approaches that target individual organisms or populations typically in large, mobile animal reintroductions and “bottom‐up” approaches that target community‐level organization in the restoration of foundation species. Finally, enhanced interdisciplinary communication and knowledge‐sharing can help develop solutions to major challenges hindering the progress of trait‐informed restoration (e.g., accounting for intraspecific variation). As novel environmental conditions continue to arise, an integrative approach to trait‐informed restoration that spans ecological scales, promotes knowledge‐sharing across diverse ecosystems, and fosters management–science collaboration can help unify and advance restoration efforts under current and future disturbance scenarios.


  • Open Access

    Addled by antlers: Synchronous disruption to female caribou antler phenology

    by A. E. Love, J. A. Fox, J. G. Hendrix, S. Jackson, K. Ferraro, E. Vander Wal, Q. M. R. Webber

    Caribou are the only deer species in which females also grow antlers; however, female antler phenology differs from males. While males grow antlers over summer and hold them through autumn rut, female caribou grow antlers in summer and carry the polished antlers through winter until parturition. The pathways associated with antler casting in females are thought to be related to hormonal changes during parturition. Yet not every female caribou is pregnant every year, and nonpregnant individuals must use an alternative cue to trigger antler casting. While populations are typically consistent in antler phenology there are observations of individual caribou on an alternate phenological timeline, casting antlers 1 month prior to parturition, and growing velvety antlers a few inches long during the calving time. Indeed, this is generally observed in barren females and only in small proportions of the population. Here we report on observations of a population‐wide change in antler phenology on Fogo Island, Newfoundland. We observed several individuals growing velvety antlers during calving season, earlier than in previous years, including two individuals who were confirmed to have been pregnant. Additionally, we observed no female caribou with polished antlers from the previous autumn, when our field observations generally show ~20% of the adult female caribou in this population have antlers at this time. We discuss possible disruptions to this phenology, commenting specifically on environmental cues that differed in comparison to years with the more commonly observed phenology. We found evidence suggesting that years with early antler casting had earlier spring warming, as well as earlier reduction in snow cover when compared to previous years. Our observations suggest that changing climate patterns may impact antler growth in female caribou, causing growth to coincide with the increased nutritional and energetic demands associated with gestation and lactation. Specifically, it is possible that earlier warming patterns may change which cue triggers antler growth in pregnant individuals from a hormonal cue during pregnancy to an environmental cue more commonly used by barren individuals. We highlight potential research questions surrounding the resilience of antler phenology, and the potential fitness consequences of disruptions to antler growth.


  • Open Access

    Taking cues from ecological and evolutionary theories to expand the landscape of disgust

    by A. E. Love, A. M. Heckley, Q. M. R. Webber

    Behavioural avoidance of parasites in the environment generates what is known as the ‘landscape of disgust’ (analogous to the predator-induced ‘landscape of fear’). Despite the potential for improving our inference of host–parasite dynamics, three limitations of the landscape of disgust restrict the insight that is gained from current research: (i) many host–parasite systems will not be appropriate for invoking the landscape of disgust framework; (ii) existing research has primarily focused on immediate choices made by hosts on small scales, limiting predictive power, generalizability, and the value of the insight obtained; and (iii) relevant ecological and evolutionary theory has yet to be integrated into the framework, challenging our ability to interpret the landscape of disgust within the context of most host–parasite systems. In this review, we explore the specific requirements for implementing a landscape of disgust framework in empirical systems. We also propose greater integration of habitat selection and evolutionary theories, aiming to generate novel insight, by exploring how the landscape of disgust varies within and across generations, presenting opportunities for future research. Despite interest in the impacts of parasitism on animal movement and behaviour, many unanswered questions remain.


  • Open Access

    Taking cues from ecological and evolutionary theories to expand the landscape of disgust

    by Allegra Love, Alexis Heckley, Quinn Webber

    1. Individual animals can attempt to prevent or mitigate parasite risks by altering their behaviour or space use. Behavioural change in response to the presence of parasites in the environment generates what is known as the “landscape of disgust” (analogous to the predator-induced “landscape of fear”). Using a spatial description of cues that indicate parasite risk, and characterizing individual responses to those cues, can allow researchers to quantify and interpret how hosts navigate the landscape of disgust. The landscape of disgust framework could facilitate much needed research on the ecological impacts of parasitism, advancing the fields of disease, spatial, and behavioural ecology. 2. Despite the potential for improving our inference of host-parasite dynamics, three key limitations of the landscape of disgust restrict the potential insight that can be gained from current research. First, many host-parasite systems will not be appropriate for invoking the landscape of disgust framework. Second, existing research has primarily focused on immediate choices made by hosts on small scales, limiting predictive power, generalizability, and the value of the insight obtained from the landscape of disgust framework. Finally, relevant ecological and evolutionary theory has not been integrated into the framework, challenging our ability to interpret and understand the application of the landscape of disgust within the context of most host-parasite systems. 3. In this review, we explore the specific requirements for implementing a landscape of disgust framework in empirical systems. We propose an expansion to the landscape of disgust framework that integrates principles from habitat selection and evolutionary theories, aiming to generate novel insight. To discuss the integration of classic ecological and evolutionary theory, we explore how the landscape of disgust varies both within and across generations, presenting opportunities for future research. 4. Despite recent interest in understanding the impact of parasitism on animal behavioural, spatial, and movement ecology, many unanswered questions remain. We build on the landscape of disgust framework by identifying weaknesses and possible applications in different ecological and evolutionary contexts. We encourage researchers to implement this framework empirically to further our understanding of host-parasite systems.

  • Compiling forty years of guppy research to investigate the factors contributing to (non)parallel evolution

    by Alexis M. Heckley, Allegra E. Pearce, Kiyoko M. Gotanda, Andrew P. Hendry, Krista B. Oke

    Examples of parallel evolution have been crucial for our understanding of adaptation via natural selection. However, strong parallelism is not always observed even in seemingly similar environments where natural selection is expected to favour similar phenotypes. Leveraging this variation in parallelism within well‐researched study systems can provide insight into the factors that contribute to variation in adaptive responses. Here we analyse the results of 36 studies reporting 446 average trait values in Trinidadian guppies, Poecilia reticulata, from different predation regimes. We examine how the extent of predator‐driven phenotypic parallelism is influenced by six factors: sex, trait type, rearing environment, ecological complexity, evolutionary history, and time since colonization. Analyses show that parallel evolution in guppies is highly variable and weak on average, with only 24.7% of the variation among populations being explained by predation regime. Levels of parallelism appeared to be especially weak for colour traits, and parallelism decreased with increasing complexity of evolutionary history (i.e., when estimates of parallelism from populations within a single drainage were compared to estimates of parallelism from populations pooled between two major drainages). Suggestive – but not significant – trends that warrant further research include interactions between the sexes and different trait categories. Quantifying and accounting for these and other sources of variation among evolutionary ‘replicates’ can be leveraged to better understand the extent to which seemingly similar environments drive parallel and nonparallel aspects of phenotypic divergence.