HKHarshada Karnik

Harshada Karnik

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Harshada Karnik has a total of 46 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Quality of causes of death data in Minnesota from 2011 to 2021 – A descriptive analysis of the usage and correlates of garbage codes

    by Harshada Karnik, Zachary Levin, Jovin Lasway, Jonathon P. Leider, Elizabeth Wrigley-Field

  • Evaluating Worker Preferences to Tackle Staffing Shortages in Local Health Departments: A Discrete Choice Experiment

    by Harshada Karnik, Sezen O. Onal

    Objective: This study aimed to enhance recruitment strategies of local health departments (LHDs) by examining worker preferences for compensation and organizational characteristics. Study Design: Data from a discrete choice experiment conducted in September 2022 were analyzed using a multinomial logit model to estimate the value of workplace characteristics including salary, contract length, flexible arrangements, employer type, and perks. The study included working-age adults (18-65 years) willing or able to work for pay, without prior experience in governmental public health departments. Findings: All workers prioritized competitive salaries, flexible work arrangements, and jobs at nonprofit organizations with compelling missions. Some workers valued loan forgiveness programs and performance-based promotions. Finally, applicants generally did not avoid jobs in the public health sector. Conclusions and implications: Competitive salaries are pivotal in attracting and retaining skilled workers in the public health sector. LHDs should conduct comprehensive salary studies benchmarked against other competing employers, effectively highlight the mission and public service responsibilities of jobs posted, and update internal policies, including flexible work hours and remote work options, to align with the preferences of the modern workforce.

  • Enumeration 2024: What We Know and What We Wish We Knew About the Governmental Public Health Workforce in a COVID-19 Recovery Landscape

    by Jonathon P. Leider, Casey P. Balio, Rachel Hogg-Graham, Nicole M. Weiss, Abby Vogel, Sezen O. Onal, Xiao Zang, Paula Kett, Joyce Edmonds, Harshada Karnik, et al.

    Objectives. To expand on previous enumerations by assessing the size and composition of the governmental public health workforce in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, identifying workforce trends, occupational distributions, and potential gaps in staffing. Methods. From 2023 to 2024, using 2022 data in the United States, we conducted 3 distinct analyses: (1) estimating the total workforce size, (2) profiling occupation-specific distributions, and (3) evaluating the role and prevalence of public health nurses using novel data sources. For total counts, we used multiple imputation by chained equations to develop robust agency-level estimates and address missingness from multiple data sets. Results. State and local public health agencies grew to approximately 239 000 staff in 2022, up from an estimated 206 500 in 2019. The largest occupation groups included office and administrative support workers (37 576) and public health or community health nurses (29 387). We found that 73 478 (1.8%) of registered nurses nationwide served in governmental public health roles. Conclusions. The size of the workforce during the COVID-19 response has returned to 2008 levels although temporary staff largely constitute the increase. Public Health Implications. An undersized workforce leaves the United States vulnerable to future disasters and current challenges. ( Am J Public Health. 2025;115(5):707–715. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2024.307960 )


  • Building Adaptive Leaders: A Formative Evaluation of the Region V Public Health Leadership Institute Using Ripple Effect Mapping and Focus Groups

    by Harshada PhD Karnik, Julieta Barbiero, Danielle J. Zemmel, Nicole M. Weiss, Phoebe K.G. Mph Kulik, Laura E. Power, Jonathon P. Leider

    Objectives: The Region V Public Health Training Center implemented an inaugural Leadership Institute (RVPHLI) from January to June 2023. This paper outlines a formative evaluation of the program to qualitatively assess its potential outcomes and influence on participants’ leadership capacity. Design, Setting, and Participants: Thirty-eight public health and primary care professionals participated in 40 hours of online learning activities focused on adaptive leadership themes. Main Outcome Measure: We conducted ripple effect mapping (REM) exercises and focus group discussions with 32 participants. Results: REM analysis using the Community Capitals Framework suggested benefits to participants’ cultural, social, and human capital. The following themes emerged as takeaways from the focus groups: leaders as collaborators, new approaches to work and leadership, better understanding of individual leadership qualities and skills, current challenges, and validated existing definitions of leadership. Conclusions: REM analysis showed participants gaining confidence and skills. They identified beneficiaries beyond themselves and shared challenges and resources. Findings will shape future RVPHLI iterations and potentially enhance development of other leadership programs in both the public health and primary care sectors.


  • Accredited Public Health Department Characteristics Associated With Workforce Gaps Identified in Workforce Development Plans

    by Ashlyn Burns, Haleigh Kampman, Harshada PhD Karnik, Jonathon P. Leider, Valerie A. DrPH Yeager

    Objective: When pursuing accreditation by the Public Health Accreditation Board, local health departments (LHDs) must submit a workforce development plan (WDP). The purpose of this study was to examine LHD characteristics associated with workforce gaps identified and strategies implemented by LHDs. Design: We conducted a qualitative content analysis of all WDPs submitted to the Public Health Accreditation Board between March 2016 and November 2021. Setting: We examined WDPs from all accredited LHDs (n = 183) at the time of data collection in January 2022. A majority of LHDs had more than 50 staff members (n = 106, 57.9%), had a decentralized governance structure (n = 164, 89.6%), had county-level jurisdictions (n = 99, 54.1%), and served rural populations (n = 146, 79.8%). Main Outcome Measures: For each overarching theme, we constructed 2 binary variables indicating whether the LHD identified a workforce gap or strategy among any subthemes within each overarching theme. Logistic regressions were used to examine relationships between LHD characteristics and identification of a workforce gap or strategy for each theme. Results: Few LHD characteristics were significantly associated with gaps identified or strategies implemented by LHDs. LHDs applying for reaccreditation had higher odds (adjusted odds ratio [AOR], 2.44; confidence interval [CI], 1.04-5.83) of identifying a leadership gap and of identifying a recruitment gap (AOR, 2.94; CI, 1.11-7.52) compared to LHDs applying for accreditation for the first time. LHDs serving urban populations had higher odds (AOR, 2.83; CI, 1.32-6.25) of identifying a recruitment strategy compared to LHDs that only served suburban/rural populations. Conclusions: Overall, many workforce gaps reported by LHDs were universally observed irrespective of LHD characteristics. While most LHDs identified strategies to address gaps, our findings also reveal workforce areas where LHDs reported gaps without an accompanying strategy, indicating areas where LHDs could use more technical assistance and support.


  • Relationship between local food environment and reliance on food pantries: insights from a statewide client survey in Minnesota

    by Harshada Karnik, Hikaru Peterson, Laura Bohen, Caitlin Caspi

    Aim Food pantries are a vital component of the emergency food environment in the United States; however, little is known about how low-income households use food pantries in relation to the food retail outlets located around them. This study investigated the relationship between the food environment (characterized by the number of retail stores around food pantries and the local cost of food) and the reliance on food pantries among their clients. Subject and methods The analysis draws on data from a statewide survey conducted in 2017 among food pantry clients (n = 4267) in Minnesota. We documented the characteristics of food pantry clients and food retail establishments around them and the relationship between food pantry usage and the retail food environment using logistic regressions. Results We found that high reliance on food pantries was positively associated with the area-level cost of food (OR = 1.16, p < 0.01) and negatively associated with the number of food retail outlets around the food pantries (OR = 0.98, p < 0.01). Conclusion Our findings confirm food pantries are filling a gap in food access and the retail food environment and serve as a steady source of food for their clients. Findings suggest the need to reconsider food pantry offerings, particularly in locations where they fill the void left by food retail stores to serve clients adequately.


  • Enhancing Workforce Pathways: Insights From a Paid Internship Pilot Program Linking Public Health Students and Local Health Departments

    by Harshada Karnik, Kari Oldfield-Tabbert, Rachel Schulman, Bonnie Brueshoff, Chelsey Kirkland, Jason Orr

    The persistent understaffing of the governmental public health workforce has led to program cutbacks, staff burnout at local health departments (LHDs), and an urgent need to replenish staffing. To build recruitment pathways into LHDs and build their workforce capacity, we introduced a paid internship initiative connecting Master’s in Public Health students from a Midwestern university with LHDs in the state. This article presents the pilot program developed and the insights gained from it. Program participants included nine LHDs that hosted 10 students for 12-week internships. Internship projects were developed by LHDs with support from the state’s association of county and city health officials. All students completed their internship projects satisfactorily. The experience highlighted that while students contributed to LHDs through short-term projects, with sustained backing and minor adjustments, this model can serve to reinforce the governmental public health sector’s existing and future capacity in the long term.


  • Examining Excess Mortality Among Critical Workers in Minnesota During 2020–2021: An Occupational Analysis

    by Harshada Karnik, Elizabeth Wrigley-Field, Zachary Levin, Yea-Hung Chen, Erik W. Zabel, Marizen Ramirez, Jonathon P. Leider

    Objectives. To understand the occupational risk associated with COVID-19 among civilian critical workers (aged 16–65 years) in Minnesota. Methods. We estimated excess mortality in 2020 to 2021 for critical occupations in different racial groups and vaccine rollout phases using death certificates and occupational employment rates for 2017 to 2021. Results. Excess mortality during the COVID-19 pandemic was higher for workers in critical occupations than for noncritical workers. Some critical occupations, such as transportation and logistics, construction, and food service, experienced higher excess mortality than did other critical occupations, such as health care, K–12 school staff, and agriculture. In almost all occupations investigated, workers of color experienced higher excess mortality than did White workers. Excess mortality in 2021 was greater than in 2020 across groups: occupations, vaccine eligibility tiers, and race/ethnicity. Conclusions. Although workers in critical occupations experienced greater excess mortality than did others, excess mortality among critical workers varied substantially by occupation and race. Public Health Implications. Analysis of mortality across occupations can be used to identify vulnerable populations, prioritize protective interventions for them, and develop targeted worker safety protocols to promote equitable health outcomes. (Am J Public Health. 2023;113(11):1219–1222. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2023.307395 )


  • Open Access

    Staffing Local Health Departments in Minnesota—Needs, Priorities, and Concerns

    by Harshada PhD Karnik, Kari Jd Oldfield-Tabbert, Chelsey PhD Kirkland, Jason M. Orr, Jonathon P. Leider

    Context: The roles and responsibilities of local health departments (LHDs), as well as the hiring challenges they face, have changed since the pandemic started. Objectives: To explore (1) staffing needs and priorities of LHDs in Minnesota, and (2) financial and community-level factors impeding health departments from maintaining optimal staffing. Design, Setting, and Participants: A cross-sectional online survey was administered via Qualtrics in July 2022 to city and county health departments in Minnesota (97% participation rate). It included both open- and close-ended questions concerning staffing needs and priorities of LHDs and challenges to hiring after the pandemic started. Results: Staffing priorities of LHDs included public health nurses, community health workers, and health planners/researchers/analysts. Hiring concerns included creating new permanent positions, offering competitive salaries, and filling open positions. Inadequate funds made it difficult to create new permanent positions and offer competitive salaries. External factors such as lack of affordable or reliable childcare, housing, and transportation also contributed to hiring challenges. Conclusions: There is a need to increase staffing levels of the Minnesota public health enterprise by filling vacant positions and creating new positions. Increasing the public health workforce requires adequate sustainable funding along with creative solutions.