Guldana Akhmetova
Research Subjects
Guldana Akhmetova has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mir Afzal Tajik
Nazarbayev University
2 shared publications A. Murzalinova
1 shared publication- Duishon Shamatov
Nazarbayev University
1 shared publication - Gulnissa Zhunussova
Süleyman Demirel University
1 shared publication JSC subsidiary“NCAT”Orleu”The Institute for Advanced Training of teachers in the North-Kazakhstan region
1 shared publicationKaraganda Medical University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 December 2025
- Published by L. N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University in Jete – Jоurnal of Philosophy, Religious аnd Cultural Studies
- Vol. 153 (4) , 7-21
THE PHYLOSOPHY BEHIND A PHD PROGRAM IN KAZAKHSTAN
The Kazakhstani education system has gradually shifted to the three-tiered European system after joining the European Higher Education Area in 2010. This transition to the new directions of training for specialists triggered doubts and concerns among Kazakhstani scholars. Hence, this study aims to examine the educational philosophy underlying PhD programs based on the experience of PhD candidates at one Kazakhstani University. This study employed the exploratory sequential design, and PhD candidates from the 2021-2022 and 2022-2023 cohorts in one Kazakhstani University took part in the study. In total, 29 respondents out of 40 completed a survey at the end of the course, and three PhD candidates agreed to participate in an in-depth individual interview. The open-ended questions of the survey and three interview responses were analyzed through the constructivist grounded theory analysis. Research results indicate that, according to the normative rules, PhD candidates are required to publish articles in order to receive permission to defend their thesis. Individual interviewers stated that money is either collected in advance or requested from a project fund in order to get published in Q1-Q4 journals. As a matter of fact, 68% of respondents confirmed the feasibility of their being published within three years, whereas 21% highlighted their preference for writing their thesis and further expanding their knowledge. Thereby, the philosophy of educating PhD candidates leads to the mantra “publish or perish” rather than nurturing young researchers.
- 10 December 2025
- Published by L. N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University in Jete – Jоurnal of Philosophy, Religious аnd Cultural Studies
- Vol. 153 (4) , 7-21
Open AccessTHE PHYLOSOPHY BEHIND A PHD PROGRAM IN KAZAKHSTAN
The Kazakhstani education system has gradually shifted to the three-tiered European system after joining the European Higher Education Area in 2010. This transition to the new directions of training for specialists triggered doubts and concerns among Kazakhstani scholars. Hence, this study aims to examine the educational philosophy underlying PhD programs based on the experience of PhD candidates at one Kazakhstani University. This study employed the exploratory sequential design, and PhD candidates from the 2021-2022 and 2022-2023 cohorts in one Kazakhstani University took part in the study. In total, 29 respondents out of 40 completed a survey at the end of the course, and three PhD candidates agreed to participate in an in-depth individual interview. The open-ended questions of the survey and three interview responses were analyzed through the constructivist grounded theory analysis. Research results indicate that, according to the normative rules, PhD candidates are required to publish articles in order to receive permission to defend their thesis. Individual interviewers stated that money is either collected in advance or requested from a project fund in order to get published in Q1-Q4 journals. As a matter of fact, 68% of respondents confirmed the feasibility of their being published within three years, whereas 21% highlighted their preference for writing their thesis and further expanding their knowledge. Thereby, the philosophy of educating PhD candidates leads to the mantra “publish or perish” rather than nurturing young researchers.
- Open Access
- 30 March 2025
- Published by Karagandy University of the name of academician E.A. Buketov in Bulletin of the Karaganda university Pedagogy series
- Vol. 11730 (1) , 141-149
Teamwork experiences of international students in a project-based learning at a Kazakhstani university
The first experience of the implementation of a project-based learning has indicated positive perspectives from international students and few challenges from local students. Due to most of the international students found the teamwork experience valuable, this study aims to explore teamwork experiences of international students during project-based learning. The study employed a survey design. It consists of three stages of survey, at the beginning, in the middle and at the end of the course. A total of 204 students participated in the course. In the first stage 163 responses were collected, in the second stage 113 responses, in the final 200 responses. Data was analyzed through the inductive approach within a qualitative analysis. The findings were discussed through the prism of the Teamwork Indicator. The study found that three out of four dimensions correlated with the framework. First, students reported an improvement in their social skills, enabling them to interact and express their ideas, aligning with the first dimension. Second, project management revealed that some students took on dominant roles. Third, work contribution was evident, with tasks being completed both individually and collaboratively. The fourth dimension, peer assessment, was under-researched, as students had limited experience with it.
- 30 March 2025
- Published by Karagandy University of the name of academician E.A. Buketov in Bulletin of the Karaganda university Pedagogy series
- Vol. 11730 (1) , 141-149
Open AccessTeamwork experiences of international students in a project-based learning at a Kazakhstani university
The first experience of the implementation of a project-based learning has indicated positive perspectives from international students and few challenges from local students. Due to most of the international students found the teamwork experience valuable, this study aims to explore teamwork experiences of international students during project-based learning. The study employed a survey design. It consists of three stages of survey, at the beginning, in the middle and at the end of the course. A total of 204 students participated in the course. In the first stage 163 responses were collected, in the second stage 113 responses, in the final 200 responses. Data was analyzed through the inductive approach within a qualitative analysis. The findings were discussed through the prism of the Teamwork Indicator. The study found that three out of four dimensions correlated with the framework. First, students reported an improvement in their social skills, enabling them to interact and express their ideas, aligning with the first dimension. Second, project management revealed that some students took on dominant roles. Third, work contribution was evident, with tasks being completed both individually and collaboratively. The fourth dimension, peer assessment, was under-researched, as students had limited experience with it.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Non-profit limited company - Akhmet Baitursynuly Kostanay Regional University in 3i: intellect, idea, innovation - интеллект, идея, инновация
- Vol. 3 (2) , 47-54
ЖОБАНЫ ОРЫНДАУ САПАСЫ: СТУДЕНТТЕР КӨЗІМЕН
The Department of History of Kazakhstan and Social-Political Disciplines continues to employ a variety of innovative teaching methods to improve the quality of students’ learning. The authors explore students’ experiences, including the challenges they face and the opportunities available to them in the course of project work. In order to examine this theme in depth, the study focused on students’ own evaluation of their projects. Authors decided to explore the point behind the students’ confident statement "we did a great job" or "we are unsatisfied." Thus, the aim of the study to scrutinize the meaning behind the students' assessment of their project. This is a qualitative study with mixed-methods design. The total number of survey participants in the 2020-2021 academic year - 194. In the 2021-2022 academic year, three focus group interviews were conducted among 11 students. Focus group interview questions were based on the survey responses. The survey responses have revealed that the majority of students, 92% (178), perceived the project work positively. The focus group interviews highlighted that students interested in a work that they did as a group, sought additional information, and conduct a survey among peers. The remaining 11% (21) perceived the project work negatively, due to some difficulties. There were a lot of disagreements among students, the motivation of the students within the groups was low, and the feeling of competition prevailed, rather than completing the tasks well.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Non-profit limited company - Akhmet Baitursynuly Kostanay Regional University in 3i: intellect, idea, innovation - интеллект, идея, инновация
- Vol. 3 (2) , 47-54
Open AccessЖОБАНЫ ОРЫНДАУ САПАСЫ: СТУДЕНТТЕР КӨЗІМЕН
The Department of History of Kazakhstan and Social-Political Disciplines continues to employ a variety of innovative teaching methods to improve the quality of students’ learning. The authors explore students’ experiences, including the challenges they face and the opportunities available to them in the course of project work. In order to examine this theme in depth, the study focused on students’ own evaluation of their projects. Authors decided to explore the point behind the students’ confident statement "we did a great job" or "we are unsatisfied." Thus, the aim of the study to scrutinize the meaning behind the students' assessment of their project. This is a qualitative study with mixed-methods design. The total number of survey participants in the 2020-2021 academic year - 194. In the 2021-2022 academic year, three focus group interviews were conducted among 11 students. Focus group interview questions were based on the survey responses. The survey responses have revealed that the majority of students, 92% (178), perceived the project work positively. The focus group interviews highlighted that students interested in a work that they did as a group, sought additional information, and conduct a survey among peers. The remaining 11% (21) perceived the project work negatively, due to some difficulties. There were a lot of disagreements among students, the motivation of the students within the groups was low, and the feeling of competition prevailed, rather than completing the tasks well.
- Open Access
- 20 July 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Reflective Practice
- Vol. 24 (6) , 693-706
Reflective writing in social sciences: challenges and opportunities for medical students
- 20 July 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Reflective Practice
- Vol. 24 (6) , 693-706
Open AccessReflective writing in social sciences: challenges and opportunities for medical students
- Open Access
- 28 September 2022
- Published by Russian State Vocational Pedagogical University in The Education and science journal
- Vol. 24 (8) , 95-115-115
Students’ struggles with EMI in Kazakhstani universities
Introduction. Fascination with English medium instruction (EMI) is fast growing in higher education institutions in non-native English-speaking countries, including Kazakhstan. The Kazakhstani government adopted a trilingual education policy in 2007 and the Bologna Process in 2010. Both these initiatives motivated universities to offer academic programmes in the English language. As a result, EMI programmes are offered in over 70 higher education institutions across Kazakhstan. In addition, there are four major Kazakhstani universities which offer academic programmes in English only. Despite the increase in the number of EMI programmes, there is a lack of empirical evidence about the difficulties and challenges faced by students in the EMI programmes.Aim. The present study aimed to investigate the nature, forms, and levels of challenges graduate students face in academic reading and writing in English and the way they cope with these challenges. The study was conducted with graduate students and faculty in 10 selected Kazakhstani universities, which offer academic programmes in EMI.Research methodology and methods. The study is based on a mixed-method design, involving an online survey and semi-structured interviews. The closed-ended questions have been analysed using SPSS software (Statistical Package for the Social Sciences). The grounded theory analysis was utilised to scrutinise open-ended questions and interview transcripts.Results and scientific novelty. The study’s results indicated two major challenges faced by graduate students in academic reading and writing: the personal-psychological challenge and sociological challenge. The first challenge includes students’ previous academic backgrounds, exposure, and learning experiences. The second challenge is related to English academic culture and students’ worldviews, concepts, and values about English as a language and medium of instruction. As a result, graduate students experienced a lack of vocabulary, inadequate academic literacy skills, unfamiliarity with academic writing styles in English, and lack of skills to synthesise reading materials.Practical significance. Hence, this study recommends systematising English language programmes across secondary and higher education institutions to help students acquire advanced English language proficiency. Also, the study results suggest that local faculty members should be trained according to international standards in terms of their English language skills and innovative teaching methods.
- 28 September 2022
- Published by Russian State Vocational Pedagogical University in The Education and science journal
- Vol. 24 (8) , 95-115-115
Open AccessStudents’ struggles with EMI in Kazakhstani universities
Introduction. Fascination with English medium instruction (EMI) is fast growing in higher education institutions in non-native English-speaking countries, including Kazakhstan. The Kazakhstani government adopted a trilingual education policy in 2007 and the Bologna Process in 2010. Both these initiatives motivated universities to offer academic programmes in the English language. As a result, EMI programmes are offered in over 70 higher education institutions across Kazakhstan. In addition, there are four major Kazakhstani universities which offer academic programmes in English only. Despite the increase in the number of EMI programmes, there is a lack of empirical evidence about the difficulties and challenges faced by students in the EMI programmes.Aim. The present study aimed to investigate the nature, forms, and levels of challenges graduate students face in academic reading and writing in English and the way they cope with these challenges. The study was conducted with graduate students and faculty in 10 selected Kazakhstani universities, which offer academic programmes in EMI.Research methodology and methods. The study is based on a mixed-method design, involving an online survey and semi-structured interviews. The closed-ended questions have been analysed using SPSS software (Statistical Package for the Social Sciences). The grounded theory analysis was utilised to scrutinise open-ended questions and interview transcripts.Results and scientific novelty. The study’s results indicated two major challenges faced by graduate students in academic reading and writing: the personal-psychological challenge and sociological challenge. The first challenge includes students’ previous academic backgrounds, exposure, and learning experiences. The second challenge is related to English academic culture and students’ worldviews, concepts, and values about English as a language and medium of instruction. As a result, graduate students experienced a lack of vocabulary, inadequate academic literacy skills, unfamiliarity with academic writing styles in English, and lack of skills to synthesise reading materials.Practical significance. Hence, this study recommends systematising English language programmes across secondary and higher education institutions to help students acquire advanced English language proficiency. Also, the study results suggest that local faculty members should be trained according to international standards in terms of their English language skills and innovative teaching methods.
- 30 September 2021
- Published by Toraighyrov University in Bulletin of Toraighyrov University. Pedagogics series
- No. 3.2021,p. 276-285
THE CHALLENGES THAT KAZAKHSTANI GRADUATE STUDENTS EXPERIENCE WITH ACADEMIC READING AND WRITING IN ENGLISH
"Since Kazakhstan’s independence in 1991, several English medium universities have appeared in the country. These universities were created to educate a new generation of thinkers and change agents who will lead Kazakhstan in concordance with the new global tendencies and directions. The staff and faculty members to serve at these universities were invited from across the world. It has been around 29 years since the official launch of the first English medium university in the country; however, there is no research on how students cope with reading and writing in their L3, after Kazakh and Russian. Against this backdrop, a team of professors and researchers of Nazarbayev University, KIMEP University, and Suleyman Demirel University have designed a study to examine graduate students’ struggle with academic reading and writing at English medium universities in Kazakhstan. This article elicits early findings related to graduate students’ challenges in reading and writing obtained from an online survey. This study employed a mixed-method approach. Graduate students’ perceptions of reading and writing in English were obtained through an online survey comprising closed- and open-ended questions. The result of quantitative data was analyzed employing inferential statistics. The total number of respondents is 269. The findings of the study reveal that Kazakhstani graduate students face several challenges in reading and writing although they have obtained the required scores in their IELTS and TOEFL tests. They asserted that reading in English is challenging because the ideas, concepts, and terminologies used in academic papers are difficult to grasp. The study confirms that there is no significant difference in challenges among genders; however, in terms of age, more mature students respond to challenges less stressfully compared to their younger counterparts. "
- 30 September 2021
- Published by Toraighyrov University in Bulletin of Toraighyrov University. Pedagogics series
- No. 3.2021,p. 276-285
THE CHALLENGES THAT KAZAKHSTANI GRADUATE STUDENTS EXPERIENCE WITH ACADEMIC READING AND WRITING IN ENGLISH
"Since Kazakhstan’s independence in 1991, several English medium universities have appeared in the country. These universities were created to educate a new generation of thinkers and change agents who will lead Kazakhstan in concordance with the new global tendencies and directions. The staff and faculty members to serve at these universities were invited from across the world. It has been around 29 years since the official launch of the first English medium university in the country; however, there is no research on how students cope with reading and writing in their L3, after Kazakh and Russian. Against this backdrop, a team of professors and researchers of Nazarbayev University, KIMEP University, and Suleyman Demirel University have designed a study to examine graduate students’ struggle with academic reading and writing at English medium universities in Kazakhstan. This article elicits early findings related to graduate students’ challenges in reading and writing obtained from an online survey. This study employed a mixed-method approach. Graduate students’ perceptions of reading and writing in English were obtained through an online survey comprising closed- and open-ended questions. The result of quantitative data was analyzed employing inferential statistics. The total number of respondents is 269. The findings of the study reveal that Kazakhstani graduate students face several challenges in reading and writing although they have obtained the required scores in their IELTS and TOEFL tests. They asserted that reading in English is challenging because the ideas, concepts, and terminologies used in academic papers are difficult to grasp. The study confirms that there is no significant difference in challenges among genders; however, in terms of age, more mature students respond to challenges less stressfully compared to their younger counterparts. "
- 30 June 2021
- Published by Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University in Pedagogy and Psychology
- Vol. 47 (2) , 17-31
The development of IT competence of teachers in a personalized educational environment of training
The article justified the need for the development of IT competence of teachers in the structure and logic of professional and pedagogical competence. The system of advanced training of NCAT “Orleu” is considered as a personalized educational environment for the development of the researched competence. The methodology of the research carried out in the subsidiary NCAT “Orleu” in the North Kazakhstan region is presented. At the same time, the results of a survey of teachers of the region are shown, the system of work in the conditions of post-course support of the development of IT competence is described, and the positive dynamics of the researched development through the data of aspect monitoring is substantiated. Based on the results of the research, the conclusions about the effectiveness of the three-unified approach in professional development, its resources and educational environment for the systematic and managed/self-managed development of IT competence were formulated ,that is came out in the processes of purposeful learning and motivated self-education of teachers, their self-realization and enhancement in the creation of digital didactic products and their methodologically applying and using in their own practice.
- 30 June 2021
- Published by Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University in Pedagogy and Psychology
- Vol. 47 (2) , 17-31
The development of IT competence of teachers in a personalized educational environment of training
The article justified the need for the development of IT competence of teachers in the structure and logic of professional and pedagogical competence. The system of advanced training of NCAT “Orleu” is considered as a personalized educational environment for the development of the researched competence. The methodology of the research carried out in the subsidiary NCAT “Orleu” in the North Kazakhstan region is presented. At the same time, the results of a survey of teachers of the region are shown, the system of work in the conditions of post-course support of the development of IT competence is described, and the positive dynamics of the researched development through the data of aspect monitoring is substantiated. Based on the results of the research, the conclusions about the effectiveness of the three-unified approach in professional development, its resources and educational environment for the systematic and managed/self-managed development of IT competence were formulated ,that is came out in the processes of purposeful learning and motivated self-education of teachers, their self-realization and enhancement in the creation of digital didactic products and their methodologically applying and using in their own practice.