LCLydia Castronovo

Lydia Castronovo

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Lydia Castronovo has a total of 9 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Logic Operations for Assessment of Experts’ Weight in Fuzzy Rule-Based Systems

    by Lydia Castronovo, Giuseppe Filippone, Giuseppe Giacopelli, Gianmarco La Rosa, Marco Elio Tabacchi

    In Multi-Criteria Group Decision-Making (MCGDM), the assignment of weights to decision-makers is a crucial but methodologically delicate step, especially when the group includes both human experts and artificial experts such as intelligent agents, Artificial Intelligences (AIs) or Large Language Models (LLMs). Existing weighting strategies are often either difficult to interpret or poorly suited to heterogeneous groups of evaluators. In this paper, we investigate a fuzzy rule-based approach to expert weighting, building on a previously introduced methodological framework and focusing here on its application-oriented validation. The proposed method models expert weighting as a Fuzzy Rule-Based System (FRBS) in which the relevant properties of the experts are represented by linguistic variables and combined through interpretable IF–THEN rules. In this way, weighting policies can be expressed transparently and adapted to the requirements of the decision domain. The framework produces normalised weights in the interval [0,1], which can then be incorporated into standard MCGDM aggregation procedures. To assess the operational behaviour of the approach, we consider an application involving the weighting of four open-source LLMs (apertus:8b, gemma4:e4b, mistral-small3.2:24b, and nemotron-cascade-2:30b) over three multilingual criteria (English, Italian, Portuguese) and two resource-side criteria (VRAM, open-sourceness), each modelled by three trapezoidal fuzzy sets and combined into a five-class output partition; the underlying dataset is built from 10 independent repetitions of 100 questions per model. Under a language-focused rule base of five IF–THEN rules, the four experts receive sharply separated normalised weights (0.003,0.149,0.301,0.548)—a top-to-bottom ratio above 180—whereas a combined linguistic/resource-aware rule base of five rules flattens the distribution to (0.227,0.360,0.222,0.191) and selects a different winner, demonstrating that policy changes are encoded explicitly in the output. A 100-run Kendall’s τ perturbation analysis confirms that the induced rankings remain stable under moderate input noise, particularly for the language-focused policy, while substituting the Product t-norm with Gödel or Lukasiewicz leaves the language-focused ranking invariant but induces rank reversals in the more discriminative resource-aware policy. A comparison against three independent baselines (Markov Logic Networks, ProbLog, TOPSIS) shows that ProbLog reproduces the FRBS ordering in both case studies, MLN compresses the normalised scores under its global probabilistic interaction, and TOPSIS diverges whenever conditional IF–THEN preferences must be encoded. A worked end-to-end aggregation example with three alternatives, three criteria, and four experts further shows that the FRBS weights propagate into a clear selection of the best alternative, with aggregated scores (S1,S2,S3)=(8.88,6.78,6.21). These results confirm both the practical usability of the method and its suitability for contexts in which multiple, potentially competing, objectives must be balanced explicitly. Overall, the paper provides an application-oriented study of an FRBS-based weighting scheme for artificial experts, highlighting its interpretability, adaptability, and potential relevance for contemporary MCGDM settings.

  • SDF FuzzIA: A Fuzzy-Based, AI Support System for Decision-Making Frameworks

    by Lydia Castronovo, Giuseppe Filippone, Mario Galici, Gianmarco La Rosa, Arianna Maria Pavone, Marco Elio Tabacchi


  • Open Access

    Logic Operations For Assessment of Experts’ Weight In Fuzzy Rule-Based Systems

    by Lydia Castronovo, Giuseppe Filippone, Giuseppe Giacopelli, Gianmarco La Rosa, Marco Elio Tabacchi

    In Multi-Criteria Group Decision-Making (MCGDM), the assignment of weights to decision-makers is a crucial but methodologically delicate step, especially when the group includes both human experts and artificial experts such as intelligent agents, Artificial Intelligences (AIs) or Large Language Models (LLMs). Existing weighting strategies are often either difficult to interpret or poorly suited to heterogeneous groups of evaluators. In this paper, we investigate a fuzzy rule-based approach to expert weighting, building on a previously introduced methodological framework and focusing here on its application-oriented validation. The proposed method models expert weighting as a Fuzzy Rule-Based System (FRBS) in which relevant properties of the experts are represented by linguistic variables and combined through interpretable IF–THEN rules. In this way, weighting policies can be expressed transparently and adapted to the requirements of the decision domain. The framework produces normalised weights in the interval [0,1], which can then be incorporated into standard MCGDM aggregation procedures. To assess the operational behaviour of the approach, we consider an application involving the weighting of four LLMs evaluated over multilingual performance, computational requirements, and open-sourceness. The experiments show that the proposed framework is flexible enough to encode different weighting policies and that changes in the rule base produce clear and interpretable changes in the resulting rankings. This confirms both the practical usability of the method and its suitability for contexts in which multiple, potentially competing, objectives must be balanced explicitly. Overall, the paper provides an application-oriented study of an FRBS-based weighting scheme for artificial experts, highlighting its interpretability, adaptability, and potential relevance for contemporary MCGDM settings.

  • Open Access

    Logic and Probabilistic Operations on a Decision Matrix in a Fuzzy Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Problem

    by Lydia Castronovo, Giuseppe Filippone, Gianmarco La Rosa, Giuseppe Sanfilippo, Marco Elio Tabacchi

    In the framework of (fuzzy) Multi-Criteria Decision-Making, we propose a method that allows decision-makers to subjectively approach problems by suitably modifying a decision matrix. We consider a decision problem related to a random quantity X with a set of values {x1,x2,…,xn} and a set of properties {C1,C2,…,Cm} of X. In this setting, the properties Cj are the criteria of the decision problem, the alternatives represent the events Ai=(X=xi), for i=1,…,n, and the criteria’s weights wj, for j=1,…,m, are seen as the probabilities for the event that “Cj is relevant with respect to the decision problem”. For each i=1,…,n and j=1,…,m, we interpret the scores aij as membership functions representing “how much alternative Ai satisfies criterion Cj”. By adopting an interpretation of membership functions as suitable conditional probabilities together with the theory of logical operations between conditional events, we allow logical operations between criteria and consistently apply this interpretation to the corresponding scores. In particular, when considering the complement, conjunction, and disjunction of criteria, the resulting scores are the (coherent) previsions of the respective compound conditionals within the framework of conditional random quantities. To illustrate our approach, we present an example concerning career choices.


  • Open Access

    Logic and Probabilistic Operations on the Decision Matrix in a Fuzzy Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Problem

    by Lydia Castronovo, Giuseppe Filippone, Gianmarco La Rosa, Giuseppe Sanfilippo, Marco Elio Tabacchi

    In the framework of (fuzzy) Multi-Criteria Decision-Making, we propose a method that1 allows the decision maker to subjectively approach the problem by suitably modifying the decision matrix. We consider a decision problem related to a random quantity X with set of values {x1, x2, . . . , xn}, and a set of properties {C1, C2, . . . , Cm}of X. In this setting, the properties Cj are the criteria of the decision problem, the alternatives represent the events Ai = (X= xi), for i= 1, . . . , n, and the criteria’s weights wj, for j= 1, 2, . . . , m, are seen as the probabilities of the events “Cj is relevant with respect to the decision problem”. For each i= 1, . . . , n and j= 1, 2, . . . , m, we interpret the scores aij as membership functions representing “how much alternative Ai satisfies criterion Cj”. By adopting the interpretation of membership functions as suitable conditional probabilities, together with the theory of logical operations among conditional events, we allow logical operations among criteria and consistently apply this interpretation to the corresponding scores. In particular, when considering the complement, conjunction, and disjunction of criteria, the resulting scores are the coherent) previsions of the respective compound conditionals within the framework of conditional random quantities.

  • Towards an Algebraic and Probabilistic Setting for Iterated Boolean Conditionals

    by Lydia Castronovo, Tommaso Flaminio, Lluis Godo, Giuseppe Sanfilippo

  • Open Access

    Fuzzy MCGDM Approach for Ontology Fuzzification

    by Lydia Castronovo, Giuseppe Filippone, Mario Galici, Gianmarco La Rosa, Marco Elio Tabacchi

    This paper extends a novel method for fuzzifying crisp ontologies through a fuzzy Multi-Criteria Group Decision-Making (MCGDM) approach. The key feature of the method is the achievement of a geometric compromise obtained by minimising distances among the best alternatives provided by experts, and by assigning and refining membership degrees for entities and relations in order to better capture uncertainty and vagueness. Its effectiveness is demonstrated on two case studies, the Cognitive Task Ontology (CogiTO) and the BrainTeaser Ontology (BTO), which showcase the potential of the proposed method in complex decision-making scenarios. Many applications are possible, including the enhancement of knowledge integration and the development of more informative reasoning under uncertainty.


  • Ontology Aggregation with Maximum Consensus Based on a Fuzzy Multi-criteria Group Decision-Making Method

    by Lydia Castronovo, Giuseppe Filippone, Mario Galici, Gianmarco La Rosa, Marco Elio Tabacchi