Ninad Gore
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Ninad Gore has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Shriniwas Arkatkar
SVNIT
4 shared publications - Srinivas S. Pulugurtha
Department of Civil Engineering, The University of Mississippi, University, MS 38677, USA
4 shared publications - Khushbu Bhatt
Civil Engineering Department, Institute of Infrastructure, Technology Research and Management, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India
2 shared publications Shriniwas Arkatkar
Sardar Vallabhbhai National Institute of Technology
2 shared publications- Abhinav Grandhi
Department of Civil & Environmental Engineering, The University of North Carolina at Charlotte, Charlotte, NC 28223, USA
1 shared publication Amirhossein Ghasemi
Mechanical Engineering & Engineering Science Department, The University of North Carolina at Charlotte, Charlotte, NC
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Future Transportation
- Vol. 5 (1) , 9
Integrating Autonomous Shuttles: Insights, Challenges, and Strategic Solutions from Practitioners and Industry Experts’ Perceptions
Integrating autonomous shuttles into public transportation systems holds immense potential to revolutionize urban mobility and enhance accessibility. This paper focuses on a comprehensive analysis of the perceptions of practitioners and industry experts and proposes best practices for effectively integrating autonomous shuttles into public transportation systems. Perceptions of stakeholders have been collected, and a two-fold analysis was performed. Critical barriers for the adoption of autonomous shuttles were identified using the Garette ranking method and principal component analysis (PCA). Recommendations covering different aspects, including underutilization, safety concerns, seating arrangements, reliability, data security, operational aspects, sensor technology, and lane use, are provided. They encompass operational adjustments, infrastructure enhancements, safety measures, policy considerations, and economic foresight. The findings emphasize the importance of extending pilot deployment trial periods, improving autonomy, strategically positioning sensors, enhancing road signage, and providing dedicated lanes for autonomous shuttles. Data-security policies, operator training, and stakeholder responsibilities are also highlighted to build trust and facilitate a seamless transition to autonomous shuttles. This paper concludes by providing recommendations to ensure the successful integration of autonomous shuttles, fostering widespread acceptance and shaping the future of urban transportation.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Future Transportation
- Vol. 5 (1) , 9
Open AccessIntegrating Autonomous Shuttles: Insights, Challenges, and Strategic Solutions from Practitioners and Industry Experts’ Perceptions
Integrating autonomous shuttles into public transportation systems holds immense potential to revolutionize urban mobility and enhance accessibility. This paper focuses on a comprehensive analysis of the perceptions of practitioners and industry experts and proposes best practices for effectively integrating autonomous shuttles into public transportation systems. Perceptions of stakeholders have been collected, and a two-fold analysis was performed. Critical barriers for the adoption of autonomous shuttles were identified using the Garette ranking method and principal component analysis (PCA). Recommendations covering different aspects, including underutilization, safety concerns, seating arrangements, reliability, data security, operational aspects, sensor technology, and lane use, are provided. They encompass operational adjustments, infrastructure enhancements, safety measures, policy considerations, and economic foresight. The findings emphasize the importance of extending pilot deployment trial periods, improving autonomy, strategically positioning sensors, enhancing road signage, and providing dedicated lanes for autonomous shuttles. Data-security policies, operator training, and stakeholder responsibilities are also highlighted to build trust and facilitate a seamless transition to autonomous shuttles. This paper concludes by providing recommendations to ensure the successful integration of autonomous shuttles, fostering widespread acceptance and shaping the future of urban transportation.
- Open Access
Mixed-Effects Model to Assess the Effect of Disengagements on Speed of an Automated Shuttle with Sensors for Localization, Navigation, and Obstacle Detection
The focus of this study is to investigate the underexplored operational effects of disengagements on the speed of an automated shuttle, providing novel insights into their disruptive impact on performance metrics. For this purpose, global positioning system data, disengagement records, weather reports, and roadway geometry data from an automated shuttle pilot program, from July to December 2023, at the University of North Carolina in Charlotte, were collected. The automated shuttle uses sensors for localization, navigation, and obstacle detection. A multi-level mixed-effects Gaussian regression model with a log-link function was employed to analyze the effect of disengagement events on the automated shuttle speed, while accounting for control variables such as roadway geometry, weather conditions, time-of-the-day, day-of-the-week, and number of intermediate stops. When these variables are controlled, disengagements significantly reduce the automated shuttle speed, with the expected log of speed decreasing by 0.803 units during such events. This reduction underscores the disruptive impact of disengagements on the automated shuttle’s performance. The analysis revealed substantial variability in the effect of disengagements across different route segments, suggesting that certain segments, likely due to varying traffic conditions, road geometries, and traffic control characteristics, pose greater challenges for autonomous navigation. By employing a multi-level mixed-effects model, this study provides a robust framework for quantifying the operational impact of disengagements. The findings serve as vital insights for advancing the reliability and safety of autonomous systems through targeted improvements in technology and infrastructure.
Open AccessMixed-Effects Model to Assess the Effect of Disengagements on Speed of an Automated Shuttle with Sensors for Localization, Navigation, and Obstacle Detection
The focus of this study is to investigate the underexplored operational effects of disengagements on the speed of an automated shuttle, providing novel insights into their disruptive impact on performance metrics. For this purpose, global positioning system data, disengagement records, weather reports, and roadway geometry data from an automated shuttle pilot program, from July to December 2023, at the University of North Carolina in Charlotte, were collected. The automated shuttle uses sensors for localization, navigation, and obstacle detection. A multi-level mixed-effects Gaussian regression model with a log-link function was employed to analyze the effect of disengagement events on the automated shuttle speed, while accounting for control variables such as roadway geometry, weather conditions, time-of-the-day, day-of-the-week, and number of intermediate stops. When these variables are controlled, disengagements significantly reduce the automated shuttle speed, with the expected log of speed decreasing by 0.803 units during such events. This reduction underscores the disruptive impact of disengagements on the automated shuttle’s performance. The analysis revealed substantial variability in the effect of disengagements across different route segments, suggesting that certain segments, likely due to varying traffic conditions, road geometries, and traffic control characteristics, pose greater challenges for autonomous navigation. By employing a multi-level mixed-effects model, this study provides a robust framework for quantifying the operational impact of disengagements. The findings serve as vital insights for advancing the reliability and safety of autonomous systems through targeted improvements in technology and infrastructure.
- 26 October 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2679 (3) , 1054-1075
Modeling and Estimating the Effect of a Mix of Varying Levels of Automated Vehicles on Operational Performance of Urban Freeways
Automated vehicles (AVs) will likely influence various aspects of the existing transportation system in the next few decades. Existing literature documents the operational benefits of AVs at different penetration rates. However, estimating the effect of the mix of different levels of AVs on the operational performance of traffic flow has not been explored in the past. This study employs a microsimulation approach to model and estimate the potential effect of varying levels of AVs on the operational performance of freeways. The proposed approach involves a two-step process for calibrating the simulation model. In the first step, the model is calibrated from an operational perspective. In the second step, the calibration is performed from a safety perspective. Thirteen scenarios were generated considering varying penetration rates of different levels of AVs. Congestion index (CI), buffer time (BT), travel time uncertainty (TTU), and delay were computed for each scenario and segment type. The estimations indicate that increasing the penetration of level 3 to level 5 AVs significantly reduces CI, BT, TTU, and delay. In contrast, the effect of level 1 and 2 AVs on freeway operational performance is negligible. Notably, the operational benefits are more pronounced with higher penetration of level 3 and higher AVs. Additionally, the reduction in delay is greater on interchange segments compared with basic freeway segments. The study findings are valuable insights concerning the operational performance of freeways under varying penetration of different levels of AVs, assisting practitioners in formulating AVs-inclusive policies.
- 26 October 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2679 (3) , 1054-1075
Modeling and Estimating the Effect of a Mix of Varying Levels of Automated Vehicles on Operational Performance of Urban Freeways
Automated vehicles (AVs) will likely influence various aspects of the existing transportation system in the next few decades. Existing literature documents the operational benefits of AVs at different penetration rates. However, estimating the effect of the mix of different levels of AVs on the operational performance of traffic flow has not been explored in the past. This study employs a microsimulation approach to model and estimate the potential effect of varying levels of AVs on the operational performance of freeways. The proposed approach involves a two-step process for calibrating the simulation model. In the first step, the model is calibrated from an operational perspective. In the second step, the calibration is performed from a safety perspective. Thirteen scenarios were generated considering varying penetration rates of different levels of AVs. Congestion index (CI), buffer time (BT), travel time uncertainty (TTU), and delay were computed for each scenario and segment type. The estimations indicate that increasing the penetration of level 3 to level 5 AVs significantly reduces CI, BT, TTU, and delay. In contrast, the effect of level 1 and 2 AVs on freeway operational performance is negligible. Notably, the operational benefits are more pronounced with higher penetration of level 3 and higher AVs. Additionally, the reduction in delay is greater on interchange segments compared with basic freeway segments. The study findings are valuable insights concerning the operational performance of freeways under varying penetration of different levels of AVs, assisting practitioners in formulating AVs-inclusive policies.
- 26 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 447-454
Estimation of Travel Time Reliability Using Wi-Fi Detections on an Urban Arterial Road
- 26 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 447-454
Estimation of Travel Time Reliability Using Wi-Fi Detections on an Urban Arterial Road
- Open Access
- 1 December 2023
- Published by San Jose State University Library
Understanding the Effect of Pervasive Events on Vehicle Travel Time Patterns
The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted daily activities and travel patterns, affecting personal and commercial trips. This study investigates the effect of different stages of the pandemic on travel time patterns. Eighty-six geographically distributed links (sections of road) in Mecklenburg County and Buncombe County, North Carolina, were selected for analysis. The selected links accounted for the variation in road geometry, land use, and speed limit. Travel time data for three years (i.e., 2019, 2020, and 2021) were extracted from a private data source at 5-min intervals. Travel time reliability (TTR) and travel time variability (TTV) are estimated for different phases of the pandemic and compared to analyze the effect of COVID-19 on TTR and TTV. The seasonal arithmetic integrated moving average (SARIMA) model was developed to investigate the effect of COVID-19 on average daily travel time patterns. Unreliable and uncertain travel times were observed on lower speed limit links during the off-peak hours while reliable and certain travel times were observed during morning and evening peak hours of the COVID-19 pandemic. This highlights that the COVID-19 pandemic significantly affected the scheduling of trips. For higher speed limits, travel times were reliable and certain during off-peak and peak hours. Among the different phases of COVID-19, significant improvement in TTR and TTV was observed during Phase II, which could be attributed to stay-at-home directives. Trucks followed a similar pattern as passenger cars. Post-COVID-19, i.e., for 2021, travel times were reliable and certain for most links during the morning peak hours. The SARIMA model revealed a significant effect of COVID-19 on average daily travel time patterns. Stable travel time patterns were noted during Phase II of COVID-19. Moreover, a maximum reduction in travel time was observed during Phase II of the COVID-19 pandemic. The findings emphasize the influence of government norms and regulations on travel time patterns during pervasive events such as COVID-19.
- 1 December 2023
- Published by San Jose State University Library
Open AccessUnderstanding the Effect of Pervasive Events on Vehicle Travel Time Patterns
The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted daily activities and travel patterns, affecting personal and commercial trips. This study investigates the effect of different stages of the pandemic on travel time patterns. Eighty-six geographically distributed links (sections of road) in Mecklenburg County and Buncombe County, North Carolina, were selected for analysis. The selected links accounted for the variation in road geometry, land use, and speed limit. Travel time data for three years (i.e., 2019, 2020, and 2021) were extracted from a private data source at 5-min intervals. Travel time reliability (TTR) and travel time variability (TTV) are estimated for different phases of the pandemic and compared to analyze the effect of COVID-19 on TTR and TTV. The seasonal arithmetic integrated moving average (SARIMA) model was developed to investigate the effect of COVID-19 on average daily travel time patterns. Unreliable and uncertain travel times were observed on lower speed limit links during the off-peak hours while reliable and certain travel times were observed during morning and evening peak hours of the COVID-19 pandemic. This highlights that the COVID-19 pandemic significantly affected the scheduling of trips. For higher speed limits, travel times were reliable and certain during off-peak and peak hours. Among the different phases of COVID-19, significant improvement in TTR and TTV was observed during Phase II, which could be attributed to stay-at-home directives. Trucks followed a similar pattern as passenger cars. Post-COVID-19, i.e., for 2021, travel times were reliable and certain for most links during the morning peak hours. The SARIMA model revealed a significant effect of COVID-19 on average daily travel time patterns. Stable travel time patterns were noted during Phase II of COVID-19. Moreover, a maximum reduction in travel time was observed during Phase II of the COVID-19 pandemic. The findings emphasize the influence of government norms and regulations on travel time patterns during pervasive events such as COVID-19.
- 13 June 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2678 (3) , 82-97
Drivers’ Dilemma at High-Speed Unsignalized Intersections
At unsignalized intersections, drivers typically reject smaller gaps and accept larger gaps in traffic. However, drivers experience a dilemma or confusion over a wide range of gaps, since incorrect decisions by them can lead to crashes. The present study quantifies the drivers’ dilemma at high-speed unsignalized intersections. Traffic data on gap size (temporal and spatial), driver’s decision (acceptance or rejection), the waiting time of the offending vehicle, the offending and conflicting vehicle types, and the speed of the conflicting vehicle are extracted from recorded video. The decisions by drivers to accept or reject gaps are modeled as a function of the gap size, the waiting time of the offending vehicle, and the speed of the conflicting vehicle using binary logit regression. The results reveal that the probability of rejection decreases as the gap size and waiting time of the subject vehicle increases. On the contrary, as the speed of the conflicting vehicle increases, the probability of rejection increases. The length and location of the dilemma zone were investigated using vehicle type, right-turning movement, and the speed of the conflicting vehicle, and a significant effect was noted. Moreover, the length and location of the dilemma zone are analytically quantified based on drivers’ compliance with a driver assistance system (DAS). The length of the dilemma decreases as the proportion of drivers’ compliance with the DAS increases. Further, the location of the dilemma zone shifts upstream of the intersection with an increase in drivers’ compliance with the DAS.
- 13 June 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2678 (3) , 82-97
Drivers’ Dilemma at High-Speed Unsignalized Intersections
At unsignalized intersections, drivers typically reject smaller gaps and accept larger gaps in traffic. However, drivers experience a dilemma or confusion over a wide range of gaps, since incorrect decisions by them can lead to crashes. The present study quantifies the drivers’ dilemma at high-speed unsignalized intersections. Traffic data on gap size (temporal and spatial), driver’s decision (acceptance or rejection), the waiting time of the offending vehicle, the offending and conflicting vehicle types, and the speed of the conflicting vehicle are extracted from recorded video. The decisions by drivers to accept or reject gaps are modeled as a function of the gap size, the waiting time of the offending vehicle, and the speed of the conflicting vehicle using binary logit regression. The results reveal that the probability of rejection decreases as the gap size and waiting time of the subject vehicle increases. On the contrary, as the speed of the conflicting vehicle increases, the probability of rejection increases. The length and location of the dilemma zone were investigated using vehicle type, right-turning movement, and the speed of the conflicting vehicle, and a significant effect was noted. Moreover, the length and location of the dilemma zone are analytically quantified based on drivers’ compliance with a driver assistance system (DAS). The length of the dilemma decreases as the proportion of drivers’ compliance with the DAS increases. Further, the location of the dilemma zone shifts upstream of the intersection with an increase in drivers’ compliance with the DAS.
- Open Access
- 8 June 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2678 (2) , 118-134
Novel Traffic Conflict-Based Framework for Real-Time Traffic Safety Evaluation Under Heterogeneous and Weak Lane-Discipline Traffic
The present study proposed a real-time traffic safety evaluation framework using macroscopic flow variables. To this end, open-access extended vehicle trajectories were employed. Rear-end traffic conflicts and macroscopic traffic flow variables were derived from the trajectory data and were integrated for real-time safety evaluation. The Proportion of Stopping distance ( PSD ) accounts for all types of interactions (both safe and unsafe) in the traffic stream; therefore, the same was adopted to analyze the rear-end traffic conflicts. A macroscopic indicator termed “time spent in conflict ( TSC )” was derived to evaluate the rear-end traffic conflicts. Machine learning models, namely, Random Forest (RF), Support Vector Machines (SVM), and eXtreme Gradient Boosting (XGB), were employed to predict TSCs using macroscopic traffic flow variables. The results revealed that the TSC computed based on PSD exhibits a reliable and explainable relationship with the macroscopic traffic flow variables. TSC computed based on PSD revealed that intermediately congested traffic flow conditions are critical in traffic safety and can be attributed to complex traffic phenomena such as traffic hysteresis, traffic oscillations, and increased speed variance. Moreover, a stable relation between traffic safety and traffic flow was suggested for varying threshold values. Among different machine learning models, the RF model was observed as the best-fitted model to predict TSC based on macroscopic traffic variables. TSC quantifies the safety status of a given traffic flow condition, where a higher value of TSC for a particular traffic flow condition indicates that vehicles prevail in the conflicting scenario for a longer time and, therefore, reflect higher operational risk. The developed machine learning model can be employed to predict TSC (operational risk) in real time using the macroscopic traffic flow variables and, therefore, facilitate traffic safety monitoring.
- 8 June 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2678 (2) , 118-134
Open AccessNovel Traffic Conflict-Based Framework for Real-Time Traffic Safety Evaluation Under Heterogeneous and Weak Lane-Discipline Traffic
The present study proposed a real-time traffic safety evaluation framework using macroscopic flow variables. To this end, open-access extended vehicle trajectories were employed. Rear-end traffic conflicts and macroscopic traffic flow variables were derived from the trajectory data and were integrated for real-time safety evaluation. The Proportion of Stopping distance ( PSD ) accounts for all types of interactions (both safe and unsafe) in the traffic stream; therefore, the same was adopted to analyze the rear-end traffic conflicts. A macroscopic indicator termed “time spent in conflict ( TSC )” was derived to evaluate the rear-end traffic conflicts. Machine learning models, namely, Random Forest (RF), Support Vector Machines (SVM), and eXtreme Gradient Boosting (XGB), were employed to predict TSCs using macroscopic traffic flow variables. The results revealed that the TSC computed based on PSD exhibits a reliable and explainable relationship with the macroscopic traffic flow variables. TSC computed based on PSD revealed that intermediately congested traffic flow conditions are critical in traffic safety and can be attributed to complex traffic phenomena such as traffic hysteresis, traffic oscillations, and increased speed variance. Moreover, a stable relation between traffic safety and traffic flow was suggested for varying threshold values. Among different machine learning models, the RF model was observed as the best-fitted model to predict TSC based on macroscopic traffic variables. TSC quantifies the safety status of a given traffic flow condition, where a higher value of TSC for a particular traffic flow condition indicates that vehicles prevail in the conflicting scenario for a longer time and, therefore, reflect higher operational risk. The developed machine learning model can be employed to predict TSC (operational risk) in real time using the macroscopic traffic flow variables and, therefore, facilitate traffic safety monitoring.
- 16 February 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Transportation Letters
- Vol. 16 (3) , 263-278
Modified two-fluid model of traffic flow
Researchers widely use the two-fluid model (TFM) to evaluate the performance of urban networks. However, the TFM is deterministic and does not capture the stochastic relation between speed and density. The present study develops a modified two-fluid model (MTFM). The variance function or the distribution of speed or travel time for a given density is incorporated using a percentile-based indicator, travel time uncertainty (TTU). The percentile-based indicators for the speed distribution are more robust than the variance or other moment-based indicators. The effect of TTU is incorporated using two parameters, and . The applicability of the proposed MTFM is demonstrated using empirical data collected at the corridor and network levels. The TFM and MTFM were calibrated by formulating a nonlinear optimization problem. Based on the investigation using the corridor and network-level data, it was concluded that the MTFM showed better performance than the existing model. .- 16 February 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Transportation Letters
- Vol. 16 (3) , 263-278
Modified two-fluid model of traffic flow
Researchers widely use the two-fluid model (TFM) to evaluate the performance of urban networks. However, the TFM is deterministic and does not capture the stochastic relation between speed and density. The present study develops a modified two-fluid model (MTFM). The variance function or the distribution of speed or travel time for a given density is incorporated using a percentile-based indicator, travel time uncertainty (TTU). The percentile-based indicators for the speed distribution are more robust than the variance or other moment-based indicators. The effect of TTU is incorporated using two parameters, and . The applicability of the proposed MTFM is demonstrated using empirical data collected at the corridor and network levels. The TFM and MTFM were calibrated by formulating a nonlinear optimization problem. Based on the investigation using the corridor and network-level data, it was concluded that the MTFM showed better performance than the existing model. .- 8 December 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2677 (5) , 966-990
Modified Bureau of Public Roads Link Function
The Bureau of Public Roads (BPR) function is a widely used link cost function in transportation planning because of its simple mathematical form, easily measurable field variables, and consistent performance. However, the BPR function is deterministic and does not capture the stochastic relation between travel time and traffic flow. The present study develops a modified BPR (MBPR) function by incorporating travel time uncertainty (TTU) in the deterministic BPR function. In the MBPR function, the effect of TTU is incorporated using two parameters, [ ] and [ ]. A nonlinear optimization problem is formulated, and the generalized reduced gradient method is used to calibrate the BPR and the MBPR function. The applicability of the proposed MBPR function is demonstrated using empirical data collected for an urban arterial in India and simulated data developed for a real-world urban road network. The proposed MBPR function captures the heterogeneity in travel time for different traffic flow values. The function (a) captures the variability in travel time under oversaturated conditions and (b) captures the time-dependent relation between traffic volume and delay. The physical meaning of [ ] and [ ] in the context of inter-day heterogeneity, infrastructure potential, and traffic flow heterogeneity are discussed. The practical application of MBPR as an analytical tool for system-wide performance evaluation is demonstrated by investigating the impact of traffic signal control on travel times using a before–after perspective. Compared with the before case, a 13% reduction in travel time is observed for the after case. Therefore, the installation of traffic signal control has reduced congestion.
- 8 December 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2677 (5) , 966-990
Modified Bureau of Public Roads Link Function
The Bureau of Public Roads (BPR) function is a widely used link cost function in transportation planning because of its simple mathematical form, easily measurable field variables, and consistent performance. However, the BPR function is deterministic and does not capture the stochastic relation between travel time and traffic flow. The present study develops a modified BPR (MBPR) function by incorporating travel time uncertainty (TTU) in the deterministic BPR function. In the MBPR function, the effect of TTU is incorporated using two parameters, [ ] and [ ]. A nonlinear optimization problem is formulated, and the generalized reduced gradient method is used to calibrate the BPR and the MBPR function. The applicability of the proposed MBPR function is demonstrated using empirical data collected for an urban arterial in India and simulated data developed for a real-world urban road network. The proposed MBPR function captures the heterogeneity in travel time for different traffic flow values. The function (a) captures the variability in travel time under oversaturated conditions and (b) captures the time-dependent relation between traffic volume and delay. The physical meaning of [ ] and [ ] in the context of inter-day heterogeneity, infrastructure potential, and traffic flow heterogeneity are discussed. The practical application of MBPR as an analytical tool for system-wide performance evaluation is demonstrated by investigating the impact of traffic signal control on travel times using a before–after perspective. Compared with the before case, a 13% reduction in travel time is observed for the after case. Therefore, the installation of traffic signal control has reduced congestion.