Nicholas R. Hart
Nicholas R. Hart has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Melvin M. Mark
Department of Psychology, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, USA
2 shared publications - Karol Olejniczak
SWPS University
1 shared publication - Kathryn E. Newcomer
Trachtenberg School of Public Policy and Public Administration The George Washington University Washington DC USA
1 shared publication Nicholas R. Hart
Data Foundation Washington D.C. USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2026 (189) , 57-64
A Critical Perspective on 50 Years of Evaluation Policy: Imagining a Framework for Better, Cheaper, Faster, Usable Evaluation
National evaluation policy in the United States has substantially improved over the past half century, yet honest assessment requires acknowledging where fundamental challenges persist. This article provides a policy perspective on structural failures in evaluation policy design, drawing on the author's experience helping lead the U.S. Commission on Evidence‐Based Policymaking, negotiating the Evidence Act's passage, and designing implementation frameworks. Using Lee Cronbach's 95 theses as an organizing framework, the article examines six failures in national evaluation policy: pretending evaluation isn't political, aspiring to evaluate everything instead of prioritizing strategically, obsessing over internal validity at the expense of external validity, building dependency rather than sustainable capacity, failing to build knowledge translation infrastructure, and treating evaluation as judgment rather than learning. These failures share a common thread: evaluation policy was designed for researchers' preferences rather than decision‐makers' needs. The article argues that neither political party deserves a gold star on evaluation policy implementation, and that hyperpoliticization of data and evaluation is a bipartisan and longstanding challenge. Looking ahead, the article proposes five adjustments for a future evaluation policy framework oriented toward better, faster, cheaper, and more usable evaluation — including honest acknowledgment of politics, strategic prioritization, increased focus on core components, internal capacity building, and alignment of cost, timeline, and quality.
- 1 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2026 (189) , 57-64
Open AccessA Critical Perspective on 50 Years of Evaluation Policy: Imagining a Framework for Better, Cheaper, Faster, Usable Evaluation
National evaluation policy in the United States has substantially improved over the past half century, yet honest assessment requires acknowledging where fundamental challenges persist. This article provides a policy perspective on structural failures in evaluation policy design, drawing on the author's experience helping lead the U.S. Commission on Evidence‐Based Policymaking, negotiating the Evidence Act's passage, and designing implementation frameworks. Using Lee Cronbach's 95 theses as an organizing framework, the article examines six failures in national evaluation policy: pretending evaluation isn't political, aspiring to evaluate everything instead of prioritizing strategically, obsessing over internal validity at the expense of external validity, building dependency rather than sustainable capacity, failing to build knowledge translation infrastructure, and treating evaluation as judgment rather than learning. These failures share a common thread: evaluation policy was designed for researchers' preferences rather than decision‐makers' needs. The article argues that neither political party deserves a gold star on evaluation policy implementation, and that hyperpoliticization of data and evaluation is a bipartisan and longstanding challenge. Looking ahead, the article proposes five adjustments for a future evaluation policy framework oriented toward better, faster, cheaper, and more usable evaluation — including honest acknowledgment of politics, strategic prioritization, increased focus on core components, internal capacity building, and alignment of cost, timeline, and quality.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2022 (173) , 117-124
The future of evaluation policy
We highlight some key issues regarding evaluation policy, including themes that emerged across chapters of this volume. These topics include what an evaluation policy is, the kind of content that evaluation policies can have, learning agendas (which are an increasingly common component of evaluation policies, especially at the U.S. federal level), the processes by which evaluation policies are developed and implemented, the role of relationships in evaluation policies, and the consequences of evaluation policy. We briefly highlight how the chapters in this volume offer guidance to those involved with developing, implementing, or revising an evaluation policy, especially—but not only—in the U.S. federal context in the wake of legislation signed into law in 2019. Looking to the future, we also share suggestions for further advances with respect to advocacy, accountability, research, and practice related to evaluation policies.
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2022 (173) , 117-124
Open AccessThe future of evaluation policy
We highlight some key issues regarding evaluation policy, including themes that emerged across chapters of this volume. These topics include what an evaluation policy is, the kind of content that evaluation policies can have, learning agendas (which are an increasingly common component of evaluation policies, especially at the U.S. federal level), the processes by which evaluation policies are developed and implemented, the role of relationships in evaluation policies, and the consequences of evaluation policy. We briefly highlight how the chapters in this volume offer guidance to those involved with developing, implementing, or revising an evaluation policy, especially—but not only—in the U.S. federal context in the wake of legislation signed into law in 2019. Looking to the future, we also share suggestions for further advances with respect to advocacy, accountability, research, and practice related to evaluation policies.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2022 (173) , 9-16
Evaluation policy: An introduction
Evaluation policy involves the dictates that guide the planning, conduct, and use of evaluation in any organization. It is – or at least should be – a central concern to those involved with evaluation. Evaluation policy shapes what evaluation practice looks like, while enabling or constraining what it can accomplish. This chapter offers a brief and selective history of evaluation policy in the United States. A description of the American Evaluation Association's activities regarding evaluation policy follows. The chapter then sets the stage for the other contributions in the current set of papers about evaluation policy.
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2022 (173) , 9-16
Open AccessEvaluation policy: An introduction
Evaluation policy involves the dictates that guide the planning, conduct, and use of evaluation in any organization. It is – or at least should be – a central concern to those involved with evaluation. Evaluation policy shapes what evaluation practice looks like, while enabling or constraining what it can accomplish. This chapter offers a brief and selective history of evaluation policy in the United States. A description of the American Evaluation Association's activities regarding evaluation policy follows. The chapter then sets the stage for the other contributions in the current set of papers about evaluation policy.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2022 (173) , 63-83
Learning agendas: Motivation, engagement, and potential
In 2017, the U.S. Commission on Evidence‐Based Policymaking recommended that federal agencies produce strategic plans focused on research and evaluation, referred to as learning agendas. This requirement was later incorporated into the Foundations for Evidence‐Based Policymaking Act of 2018 (Evidence Act) for the 24 largest federal agencies. Prior to the Evidence Act, only a few federal agencies had experimented with learning agendas, a relatively new concept in the evaluation literature. Learning agendas hold potential for supporting organizational strategic planning that focuses on the generation of relevant knowledge for decision‐makers, organizational leaders, and stakeholders. An inclusively‐ and strategically‐developed learning agenda provides a list of important questions as well as plans for addressing the questions, balancing the interests, informational needs, and time horizons for different organizational decision‐makers. We draw upon the policy design and the evaluation capacity building literature, our analysis of existing learning agendas, and interviews with federal evaluation leaders who guided their development to describe how the process of developing a learning agenda can support intentional learning and impactful evaluation practice within public agencies. Our work should contribute to the development of both theory and practice regarding the implementation of the new expectation to produce learning agendas in federal agencies that contribute to the increased use of evaluation and evidence in policymaking.
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2022 (173) , 63-83
Open AccessLearning agendas: Motivation, engagement, and potential
In 2017, the U.S. Commission on Evidence‐Based Policymaking recommended that federal agencies produce strategic plans focused on research and evaluation, referred to as learning agendas. This requirement was later incorporated into the Foundations for Evidence‐Based Policymaking Act of 2018 (Evidence Act) for the 24 largest federal agencies. Prior to the Evidence Act, only a few federal agencies had experimented with learning agendas, a relatively new concept in the evaluation literature. Learning agendas hold potential for supporting organizational strategic planning that focuses on the generation of relevant knowledge for decision‐makers, organizational leaders, and stakeholders. An inclusively‐ and strategically‐developed learning agenda provides a list of important questions as well as plans for addressing the questions, balancing the interests, informational needs, and time horizons for different organizational decision‐makers. We draw upon the policy design and the evaluation capacity building literature, our analysis of existing learning agendas, and interviews with federal evaluation leaders who guided their development to describe how the process of developing a learning agenda can support intentional learning and impactful evaluation practice within public agencies. Our work should contribute to the development of both theory and practice regarding the implementation of the new expectation to produce learning agendas in federal agencies that contribute to the increased use of evaluation and evidence in policymaking.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2022 (173) , 7-8
Editors’ notes
- 1 March 2022
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2022 (173) , 7-8
Open AccessEditors’ notes