MPMark Paton

Mark Paton

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Mark Paton has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Inferred winds and atmospheric circulation during the descent of Beagle 2 on Mars

    by Mark Paton, Tanguy Bertrand, Charlotte Segonne, Hannu Savijärvi, Peter Grindrod, Joel Davis, Ari-Matti Harri

    We present new global and mesoscale model results for the time of the Beagle 2 landing. We compare these results to inferred wind speed and direction profiles obtained from the analyisis of the Beagle 2 lander and its surrounding landing gear as seen in images of the landing site. On Mars, like on Earth, the lower layer of the atmosphere interacts thermally and mechanically with the surrounding terrain to produce, e.g. buoyancy driven slope winds and mountain waves. Understanding the role of the surrounding terrain on regional and local winds is important for understanding the transport of moisture and dust on Mars and interpretating lander meteorological observations. It is also important to understand and determine the resolution of an atmospheric model required to resolve the effects of topography on the atmosphere. Isidis Planitia, where Beagle 2 landed, is a plain in a giant impact structure on Mars spanning over 1000 km in diameter. It makes for a convenient region for study due to its enclosed nature and because it fits nicely within the typical domain sizes of mesoscale models.IntroductionBeagle 2 landed in the Isidis basin back in 2003. Unfortunately, it did not transmit any data, but images from orbit show the apparently intact lander surrounded by its landing gear, such as parachutes and a heat shield (Bridges et al., 2017). The distribution of this equipment contains a valuable record of the winds that were blowing during its descent and landing. The reason this information is valuable is because the amount of data on Martian winds above the surface is almost non-existent, especially in terms of vertical profiles. We decipher the images of Beagle 2 to infer wind speed and direction profiles and compare these with atmospheric models to advance our knowledge of the atmospheric circulations in the Isidis basin and the Martian atmosphere.MethodA lander opens its parachute just before its descent through the most dynamic region of the atmosphere. Many of the early landers on Mars, from the 1990s onwards such as Pathfinder, Spirit, Opportunity and Beagle 2, did not measure the winds during their descent. However, images of their landing sites taken from orbit provide evidence of winds due to the deviation of jettisoned hardware, such as parachutes and heat shields, from the nominally straight line of the entry trajectory. To extract the wind speed and direction from these images we fit a trajectory model of Beagle 2 to the impact locations of its landing gear on the surface. The inferred wind speed and direction are then compared to the Laboratoire de Météorologie Dynamique (LMD) mesoscale and global atmospheric models.ResultsFrom the mesoscale atmospheric model the circulation at the Beagle 2 landing site appears to be a complex interplay of the Hadley circulation, topography and heating at the equator. The higher resolution of the mesoscale model modified the wind profile prediction from the GCM, especially in terms of wind direction. This is most likely due to the higher resolution of the topographic influenced circulations in the mesoscale model. A similar result was found with the Perseverance landing site (Paton et al., 2024), where increasing the resolution had dramatic effects on both wind speed and direction. The GCM and mesoscale results here also support the results from mesoscale modelling efforts made by Rafkin et al. (2004) and GCM modelling results made by Bingham et al. (2003) in preparation for the Beagle 2 mission. Differences in wind direction between the atmospheric model and inferred wind profile suggest convective cell activity in the afternoon planetery boundary layer.ConclusionsWe have inferred the wind speed and direction during the Beagle 2 landing and compared these to new mesoscale atmospheric model results. The inferred wind profile appears consistent with the mesoscale atmospheric model, although initial calculations did suggest high wind speeds above the planetary boundary layer. We found an improvement in the match between the inferred wind profile and the atmospheric model if the Beagle 2 airbags were deflected, after being released from the parachute, perhaps due to the aeolian landforms apparent in images of the landing site.The results also demonstrate the need to carefully consider the grid size of the atmospheric model when the influence of topography is suspected. This is particularly important for Mars because of the dramatic variations in topography due to impact basins and other large geological features such as the north south dichotomy.ReferencesBingham, S.J., Lewis, S.R., Newman, C.E., Read, P.L., Environmental predictions for the Beagle 2 lander, based on GCM climate simulations, Planetary and Space Science, 52, 259–269 (2004)Bridges J. C., Clemmet J., Croon M., Sims M. R., Pullan D., Muller J.-P., Tao Y., Xiong S., Putri A. R., Parker T., Turner S. M. R. and Pillinger J. M., Identification of the Beagle 2 lander on Mars, Royal Society Open Science 4170785 (2017)Paton, M. D., Savijärvi, H., Harri, A. -M., Leino, J., Bertrand, T., Viúdez-Moreiras, D., Lorenz, R. D. and Newman, C., Inferred wind speed and direction during the descent and landing of Perseverance on Mars, Icarus, 415, 116045 (2024)Rafkin, S. C. R., Michaels, T. I. and Haberle, R. M., Meteorological predictions for the Beagle 2 mission to Mars, Geophysical Research Letters, 31, L01703 (2004)

  • Open Access

    Inferred wind profiles and surface roughness during the Beagle 2 landing on Mars

    by Mark Paton, Peter Grindrod, Joel Davis, Tanguy Bertrand, Hannu Savijärvi, Ari-Matti Harri

    The Planetary Boundary Layer (PBL) on Mars is a dynamic region of the atmosphere that extends several kilometres above the surface. It is sensitive to solar heating during the day, generating turbulent circulations and large convective cells. The background wind is influenced by the large-scale winds and interactions with the surface. It is important to characterise this region of the atmosphere to better understand atmospheric circulations and to verify atmospheric models.Wind profiles between the surface and to several kilometres above the PBL are generally lacking for Mars. However these can be inferred by analysing the displacement of jettisoned hardware at landing sites. This has been done for a variety of landers in the past to help verify atmospheric models and investigate the Martian atmosphere. Here we determine the wind speed and direction during the descent of Beagle 2 and also investigate the surface. 1. IntroductionBeagle 2 landed in Isidis Planitia basin in the early afternoon, during the northern hemisphere winter at Ls=322°. The region where Beagle 2 landed is relatively flat suggesting the lack of local slope winds. However around sides of the basin are steep slopes that are susceptible to slope winds, e.g. Chojnacki et al. (2019) which drive the circulation at the landing site (Rafkin et al., 2004). Atmospheric modelling data from the Mars Climate Database (MCD) indicates a strong influence on the winds from the thermal tide (Bingham et al., 2004). Results from the Mars Regional Atmospheric Modeling System (MRAMS) (Rafkin et al., 2004) indicate slope-wind driven circulations modulated by the large-scale circulations.2. MethodThe wind profiles at the landing site are inferred based on the location of hardware identified in HiRISE images of the Beagle 2 landing site (Bridges et al., 2017; Clemmet et al., 2017). We use a trajectory model (Paton et al., 2018) to calculate the impact locations of Beagle 2’s heat shield, backshell-pilot parachute, main parachute and the airbags. The winds in the trajectory model are varied until the end points in the model match the actual locations of Beagle 2 hardware.The modelling of the airbag trajectory, as it bounces across the surface, can tell us something about the surface roughness. For a smooth surface the airbags bounce in a straight line while for a rough surface the airbags can be deflected from its path. By comparing the inferred wind profile to an atmospheric model wind profile we can constrain the surface roughness. The surface roughness parameter used in the model is the maximum metre-scale slope angle.The elevation of the Beagle 2 landing site is established using a Digital Terrain Model (DTM) together with MOLA elevation data. The DTM is also be used to estimate the flatness over the distance bounced by the airbags (about 100 m). Noise in the HiRISE images, used to make the DTM, makes it difficult to estimate the metre-scale roughness which is relevant to the airbag’s traverse across the surface.3. Results A three-layer wind profile was inferred for the Beagle 2 landing. A good match between the inferred and MCD wind speed profiles was found when the metre-scale surface roughness in the trajectory model is comparable to that at the Pathfinder landing site. There is a good match with high-resolution results from MRAMS. The inferred, MRAMS and MCD wind profiles indicate high-speed winds of about 15 m s-1 above 3 to 4 km. Below these altitudes the wind speed drops down to 5 m s-1. Below ~3 km altitude the wind speed is relatively uniform, typical of a well mixed PBL. The inferred wind direction above 3 km altitude matches the MCD quite well with a wind approximately from the east. There is a significant discrepancy between the inferred wind direction and the MCD near the surface. This may be due to large-scale convective structures that at the Beagle 2 landing site.Comparisons between an inferred wind speed profile and atmospheric model data from the time of the Perseverance landing (Paton et al., 2024), requires high resolution atmospheric modelling for a good match. At the Beagle 2 landing site, which DTM data indicates is relatively flat, both the MCD and MRAMS atmospheric models appear to agree with the inferred wind speed profile.4. ConclusionsThe lower layers of the inferred wind profiles at the Beagle 2 landing site appears to be broadly consistent with predictions. These winds are primarily driven by the slope-driven winds occurring at the edges of Isidis Planitia. The upper layer of the wind speed profile is consistent with the large scale flow above the PBL when surface roughness is included in the trajectory model for the airbags.ReferencesBingham, S.J., et al., 2004, Environmental predictions for the Beagle 2 lander, based on GCM climate simulations, Planetary and Space Science, 52, 259–269Bridges, J. C. et al., 2017, Identification of the Beagle 2 lander on Mars., Royal Society Open Science, 4Chojnacki, M., et al., 2019., Boundary condition controls on the high-sand-flux regions of Mars, Geology, 47, 427–430Clemmet, J., et al., 2017, Beagle 2 on Mars - the Discovery Assessed, Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, 70, 262–277Paton, M. D., Harri, et al., 2018, Measurement of Martian boundary layer winds by the displacement of jettisoned lander hardware, Icarus, 309, 345-362Paton, M. D., et al., 2024, Inferred wind speed and direction during the descent and landing of Perseverance on Mars. Icarus, 415Rafkin, S. C. R., et al., 2004, Meteorological predictions for the Beagle 2 mission to Mars, Geophysical Research Letters, 3

  • Open Access

    Modelling trajectories of wind-blown particles in the Martian atmosphere

    by Mark Paton, Joonas Leino, Ari-Matti Harri, Hannu Savijärvi

    Martian dust storms can obscure the lower reaches of the atmosphere from orbiting spacecraft and at the same time obscure the upper atmosphere from landed spacecraft. Inferring the paths of wind-blown particles and their spatial distributions in the atmosphere may help understand the role of the winds in distributing the dust in the atmosphere and on the surface. We describe a simple but useful transport model that calculates the paths of multiple particles using wind data imported from a Mars climate model. We plan to use our model to help understand the role of the winds in the transport of dust around Mars and how the vertical distribution of dust above a landing site may change over time during a dust storm, e.g. to help with our column modelling work.BackgroundTwo great dust storms of a planetary scale occurred during the first year of the Viking lander missions [1] one starting at Ls=205° (1977a) and the other at Ls=275° (1977b). They are both thought to have originated somewhere in Thaumasia Fossae and Solis Planum in the southern hemisphere about 2000 km southwest of Valles Marineris. The 2018 global dust storm started unusually for a planet-wide dust storm in Acidalia Planitia in the northern hemisphere [2] and started early in the dust storm season at Ls=185°. The dust from this storm is thought to have reached the Curiosity site about Ls=192°.MethodWe use global wind fields from the Mars Climate Database to trace the path of virtual dust particles using a simple transport model based on [3]. The global wind fields are imported into our transport model up to an altitude of 20 km and we interpolate vertically between these fields. In this study we initialise the model by placing 100 particles at altitudes ranging from 200 m to 20000 m at the coordinates of the dust storm origin. The particles are added to the atmosphere at midnight of the first sol and then travel with the winds, i.e. they act like tracers. The vertical velocity of the particles are set to zero in the current version of the transport model.ResultsFigure 1 shows a simulation for the 2018 global dust storm using MCD wind fields. These results indicate the distance a particle would travel after 10 sols given the horizontal wind speeds and directions given in the MCD for an average solar climate. The general trend of the transport of the particles in figures 1 and 2 is that the lower winds transport particles to the south and the upper winds keep particles in a narrow east-west band.Figure 1 : Particle end points after 10 sols (Ls=185°).Figure 2 : Vertical profile of the figure 1 particles.SummaryA simple transport model was used in conjunction with wind fields from the Mars Climate Database to explore dust transport on Mars. It was found that the winds below 10 km could transport dust to the vicinity of Curiosity within 10-15 sols from the start of the 2018 dust storm which is consistent with observations.The evolution of the 1977A dusts storm was also modelled. As the origin and evolution of the storm is less well known [1] we tried various longitudes and latitudes within the regions of Thaumasia Fossae and Solis Planum. The model inidcates the dust arrived at the Viking lander 1 site at a higher altitude than indicated for Curiosity in figure 2.The next steps will be to incorperate a vertical velocity component to the particle motion that will involve using MCD vertical velocity fields and the correct physics for modelling the particle's motion in a fluid. The transport model will then be better suited for comparisons with observations at different lander locations and more useful for our analyses of lander meteorological observations using the column model. The transport model could also be useful for understanding the transport of water vapour in the Martian atmosphere.References[1] Zurek, Z.W.: Martian great dust storms: An update, Icarus, 50, 288-310, 1982.[2] Guzewich, S., Lemmon, M. T., Martinez, G., Vicente-Retortillo, Á., Newman, C. E., Baker, M. M., Campbell, C., Cooper, B., Crisp, J., Gomez-Elvira, J., Harri, A. M., Hassler, D., Martin-Torres, F. J., McConnochie, T. H., Moores, J., Kahanpää, H., Khayat, A. S. J., Smith, C. L., Smith, M. D. and Sullivan, R. J., Jr.: Mars Science Laboratory Observations of the 2018/Mars Year 34 Global Dust Storm, Geophysical Research Letters, 46, 71-79, 2019. [3] Paton, M. D., Harri, A.-M. and Savijärvi, H.: Measurement of Martian boundary layer winds by the displacement of jettisoned lander hardware, Icarus, 309, 345-362, 2018.

  • Open Access

    The winds in the Martian nocturnal boundary layer at the time of the Pathfinder landing

    by Mark Paton, Hannu Savijärvi, Ari-Matti Harri, Joonas Leino

    In 1997 Pathfinder descended on its parachute through the nocturnal boundary layer of Mars. Pathfinder descended early in the morning a few hours before the possible formation of a low level jet [1]. We use an EDL trajectory model to simulate the landing of Pathfinder and its jettisoned hardware and together with HiRISE images of the landing site we are able to constrain the wind speeds and directions during its descent.BackgroundPathfinder parachute deployment occured at an altitude of around 10 km. The heat shield was jettisoned 15 s later. Shortly afterwards Pathfinder enveloped in its deflated airbags was lowered down on a bridle. The airbags were then inflated at an altitude of a few hundred metres. High powered rockets, attached to the back shell, were fired at an altitude of about 80 m reducing the vertical velocity to nearly zero at an altitude of 20 m above the surface. The lander was then released and dropped to the surface while the rockets used the remaining propellant to shoot the backshell and parachute upwards and away from the lander. The lander proceeded to bounce about 1 km towards the northeast coming to rest after about two minutes [2].MethodWe numerically integrate the equations of motion to model the trajectories of the Pathfinder spacecraft and its heat shield. The relative distance between the heat shield and the lander in HiRISE images is compared to that in the model using a similar method used in [3]. The first impact point of the airbags, which we require to help constrain the trajectory of the lander, is not visible in the HiRISE image so we reconstruct the likely impact point based on information in [2]. To infer wind speeds and directions we vary the wind speeds in the EDL model using a Hill climbing algorithm until the predicted impact points match those of the heat shield in the HiRISE image and the reconstructed impact point of the airbags. There are two levels of winds between 0 and 9.6 km in the EDL model an upper and a lower one. The division line between the two levels is a free parameter. In figure 1 the division line is set to 1 km altitude.ResultsFigure 1 shows the ground track of Pathfinder starting from parachute deployment at 9.6 km. The dots on the tracks are intervals of 1 km. The predicted impact points from the EDL model have been fitted to the locations of the jettisoned Pathfinder heat shield in the HiRISE image and the inferred first bounce location. Figure 1 : Ground track of Pathfinder and the heat shield.SummaryWe varied the line dividing the upper and lower wind levels in the EDL model from 500 m to 2000 m. We also varied the distance between the first bounce and the lander at rest from 400 and 1000 m. We found the wind directions can be fairly well constrained even if these two parameters are varied. Above 500-2000 m the upper level wind was inferred to be coming from the west (240-310°) and below 500-2000 m the lower level wind was inferred to be coming from the southeast (120-150°). To obtain fits between the model and observations the upper level wind speed was required to be between 15 and 30 m s-1 while the lower level wind speed in the model was found to be in a similar range.References[1] Savijärvi, H., Määttänen, A., Kauhanen, J. and Harri, A.-M.: Mars pathfinder: New data and new model simulations, Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society, 130, 669-683, 2004.[2] Golombek, M.P., Anderson, Robert, Barnes, Jeffrey, Bell, J.F., Bridges, Nathan, Britt, Daniel, Brückner, J., Cook, R.A., Crisp, David, Crisp, J.A., Economou, Thanasis, Folkner, W., Greeley, R., Haberle, R., Hargraves, R.B., Harris, J.A., Haldemann, A., Herkenhoff, K., Hviid, S.F., Wilson, G.R.: Overview of the Mars Pathfinder Mission: Launch through Landing, Surface Operations, Data Sets, and Science Results, Journal of Geophysical Research, 104, 8523-8554, 1999.[3] Paton, M. D., Harri, A.-M. and Savijärvi, H.: Measurement of Martian boundary layer winds by the displacement of jettisoned lander hardware, Icarus, 309, 345-362, 2018.

  • Open Access

    A user-orientated column modelling framework for efficient analyses of the Martian atmosphere

    by Mark Paton, Ari-Matti Harri, Oliver Vierkens, Hannu Savijärvi

    As spacecraft missions return ever more data from Mars, additional tools will be required to explore and analyse these datasets efficiently. To streamline research into the atmosphere of Mars, a user-orientated modelling capability is developed that enables automatic initialisation and running of a column model. As a demonstration we utilise the modelling framework to provide additional verification for the University of Helsinki and Finnish Meteorological Institute Mars column model temperature profiles above the height of typical lander meteorological measurements, i.e. above 2 m. We utilise the framework at landing site locations that are well characterised to understand the model's applicability and to identify future opportunities for modifications to the framework. We do this by using the framework to compare the column model to temperature soundings made by the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter. We find that the column model, without any modification, is able to reproduce the observed lapse rates and average temperatures closely in most cases except for a 20–60 K increase over the northern hemisphere mid-winter. We can reproduce this discrepancy by incorporating an adiabatic heating term into the column model. Fitting of the modified column model to the observations results in estimated maximum downward vertical wind velocities of ∼ 10 cm s−1 at altitudes of 15–20 km over the winter solstice at the VL-1 and VL-2 sites. The approach developed here may possibly provide a way to independently estimate or observe the vertical motion in the Martian atmosphere. However, even though the magnitude of the vertical wind speed appears reasonable, it is not clear at this point how much the atmospheric heating is due to other mechanisms such as advection. We have introduced new application software that can quickly find and display the requested data and can be immediately analysed using the included tools. We have demonstrated the potential of this type of software application with a glimpse into the upper atmosphere of Mars.


  • Open Access

    A user-orientated column modelling framework for efficient analyses of the Martian atmosphere

    by Mark Paton, Ari-Matti Harri, Oliver Vierkens, Hannu Savijärvi

    As spacecraft missions return ever more data from Mars additional tools will be required to explore and analyse these datasets efficiently. To streamline research into the atmosphere of Mars a user-orientated modelling capability is developed that enables automatic initialisation and running of a column model. As a demonstration we utilise the modelling framework to provide additional verification for the University of Helsinki/Finnish Meteorological Institute Mars column model temperature profiles at the higher altitudes. We utilise the framework at well characterised landing sites to understand the model's applicability and to identify future opportunities for modifications to the framework. We do this by using the framework to compare the column model to temperature soundings made by Mars Reconaissance Orbiter. We find the column model is able to reproduce the observed lapse rates and average temperatures closely in most cases except for a 20–60 K increase over the northern hemisphere mid-winter. By incorporating an adiabatic heating term into the column model we suggest this discrepancy is likely due to the adiabatic compression of down welling air. We estimate maximum downward vertical velocities at the VL-1 and VL-2 latitudes of 8 and 12 cm s−1 at altitudes of 15 and 20 km respectively over the winter solstice. The fitting approach developed here provides a way to independently estimate or observe the vertical motion in the Martian atmosphere. We have introduced new application software that can quickly find and display the requested data and can be immediately analysed using the included tools. We have demonstrated the potential of this software application with a glimpse into the upper atmosphere of Mars and identified future modifications to the framework.

  • Open Access

    High-fidelity subsurface thermal model as part of a Martian atmospheric column model

    by M. D. Paton, A.-M. Harri, T. Mäkinen, H. Savijärvi

    As the Martian atmosphere is observed in ever greater detail, more realistic computer models are required to interpret these measurements. Physical exchange processes between the atmosphere's lower boundary and the surface are often simplified. This is because the atmospheric calculations can describe the behaviour of the atmosphere accurately in many cases and simplifying the boundaries saves computing resources. However, the vertical heterogeneity of the subsurface (such as the presence of dust and ice layers) will interact via heat and mass transfer with the atmosphere. Here a new realistic numerical thermal conductivity scheme is introduced for use with a 1-D atmospheric column model useful for investigating the subsurface for layered material and to provide more accurate modelling of the Martian atmosphere. The model with the updated scheme produces results that are identical to the previous versions of the model in identical (non-layered) conditions. The updated model fits well to Viking 1 temperature data from the atmosphere using realistic thermal parameters. Introducing layered material, with different thermal properties, produces noticeable changes in the maximum and diurnal temperatures when changing the thickness of its top layer. The time of maximum surface temperature is only significantly changed when the thickness of the top layer is a moderate fraction of the top layer's skin depth.


  • Open Access

    Investigating thermal properties of gas-filled planetary regoliths using a thermal probe

    by M. D. Paton, A.-M. Harri, T. Mäkinen, S. F. Green

    We introduce a general purpose penetrator, fitted with a heater, for measuring temperature and thermal diffusivity. Due to its simplicity of deployment and operation the penetrator is well suited for remote deployment by spacecraft into a planetary regolith. Thermal measurements in planetary regoliths are required to determine the surface energy balance and to measure their thermal properties. If the regolith is on a planet with an atmosphere a good understanding of the role of convection is required to properly interpret the measurements. This could also help to identify the significant heat and mass exchange mechanisms between the regolith and the atmosphere. To understand the role of convection in our regolith analogues we use a network of temperature sensors placed in the target. In practical applications a penetrator will push material out of the way as it enters a target possible changing its thermal properties. To investigate this effect a custom built test rig, that precisely controls and monitors the motion of the penetrator, is used. The thermal diffusivity of limestone powder and sand is derived by fitting a numerical thermal model to the temperature measurements. Convection seems to play an important role in the transfer of heat in this case. Firstly a diffusion-convection model fits the laboratory data better than a diffusivity-only model. Also the diffusivity derived from a diffusivity-convection model was found to be in good agreement with diffusivity derived using other methods published in the literature. Thermal diffusivity measurements, inspection of the horizontal temperature profiles and visual observations suggests that limestone powder is compacted more readily than sand during entry of the penetrator into the target. For both regolith analogues the disturbance of material around the penetrator was determined to have an insignificant effect on the diffusivity measurements in this case.