Neil Philip Hobbs
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Neil Philip Hobbs has a total of 17 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ian Michael Hastings
Department of Tropical Disease Biology, Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine, Liverpool, United Kingdom
6 shared publications Ian Hastings
Affiliation Department of Tropical Disease Biology, Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine, Liverpool, United Kingdom
2 shared publicationsBusiku Hamainza
National Malaria Elimination Centre, Chainama Hills Hospital Grounds, PO Box 32509, Lusaka, Republic of Zambia
1 shared publicationDavid Weetman
Department of Vector Biology Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine Pembroke Place Liverpool L3 5QA UK
1 shared publication- David Weetman
Department of Vector Biology Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine Liverpool UK
1 shared publication - Dingani Chinula
National Malaria Elimination Centre, Chainama Hills Hospital Grounds, PO Box 32509, Lusaka, Zambia
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Potential impacts of supplementing next generation long-lasting insecticidal nets with household-scale micro-mosaic deployment of indoor residual spraying with insecticides upon rates of incipient resistance trait emergence and selection
Prolonged use of the few insecticide classes available for long-lasting insecticidal nets (LLINs) and indoor residual spraying (IRS) has driven widespread physiological resistance of malaria vector mosquitoes to this limited arsenal of active ingredients. However, recent innovations like next-generation LLINs (NG-LLINs) containing two complementary insecticides and new insecticide classes for IRS offer new opportunities for pre-emptive resistance management by deploying more diversified actives as mixtures, combinations, rotations or mosaics. Here a deterministic model of mosquito foraging behaviour was formulated to predict the probabilities of deterrence, mortality or successful feeding across repeated feeding attempts in scenarios with different combinations of NG-LLINs and/or IRS micro-mosaics with varying levels of insecticide diversification between neighbouring houses. Final fates were classified based on whether or not the mosquito eventually died or successfully fed, and whether the latter occurred indoors or outdoors after exposure to zero, one or several IRS insecticides. The primary outcome was the probability that a single F₀ mosquito carrying a novel resistance trait to a new IRS insecticide successfully feeds, survives and reproduces, thereby establishing those traits within the population. The secondary outcome was the selection coefficient governing the spread of such novel resistance traits from the F₁ generation onwards. For highly anthropophagic and endophagic vectors like Anopheles funestus , combining NG-LLINs with IRS micro-mosaics using two insecticides may reduce emergence rates for novel resistance traits against IRS insecticides by approximately 2 to 2.5-fold, mainly through direct killing by NG-LLINs, although exposure to both IRS actives when forced to visit multiple houses also contributes to a lesser extent. However, such resistance management benefits are fundamentally constrained by outdoor feeding behaviours that limit or completely prevent indoor insecticide exposure. Increasing IRS micro-mosaic insecticide diversity beyond two actives is unlikely to further dampen resistance emergence rates because few mosquitoes survive long enough without feeding to encounter several IRS treatments. Once a resistance trait becomes established in the vector population, selection coefficients remain consistently high enough to force the spread of those traits, regardless of intervention combination. For more exophagic, zoophagic vectors like An. arabiensis , NG-LLINs plus IRS micro-mosaics are not expected to provide any meaningful resistance management benefit because frequent outdoor feeding, often on animals, allows them to largely avoid insecticide exposure altogether. Exclusively indoor-focused vector control strategies may not satisfactorily slow insecticide resistance emergence and spread, so new outdoor protection measures that close these coverage gaps with complementary insecticides will be needed.
Open AccessPotential impacts of supplementing next generation long-lasting insecticidal nets with household-scale micro-mosaic deployment of indoor residual spraying with insecticides upon rates of incipient resistance trait emergence and selection
Prolonged use of the few insecticide classes available for long-lasting insecticidal nets (LLINs) and indoor residual spraying (IRS) has driven widespread physiological resistance of malaria vector mosquitoes to this limited arsenal of active ingredients. However, recent innovations like next-generation LLINs (NG-LLINs) containing two complementary insecticides and new insecticide classes for IRS offer new opportunities for pre-emptive resistance management by deploying more diversified actives as mixtures, combinations, rotations or mosaics. Here a deterministic model of mosquito foraging behaviour was formulated to predict the probabilities of deterrence, mortality or successful feeding across repeated feeding attempts in scenarios with different combinations of NG-LLINs and/or IRS micro-mosaics with varying levels of insecticide diversification between neighbouring houses. Final fates were classified based on whether or not the mosquito eventually died or successfully fed, and whether the latter occurred indoors or outdoors after exposure to zero, one or several IRS insecticides. The primary outcome was the probability that a single F₀ mosquito carrying a novel resistance trait to a new IRS insecticide successfully feeds, survives and reproduces, thereby establishing those traits within the population. The secondary outcome was the selection coefficient governing the spread of such novel resistance traits from the F₁ generation onwards. For highly anthropophagic and endophagic vectors like Anopheles funestus , combining NG-LLINs with IRS micro-mosaics using two insecticides may reduce emergence rates for novel resistance traits against IRS insecticides by approximately 2 to 2.5-fold, mainly through direct killing by NG-LLINs, although exposure to both IRS actives when forced to visit multiple houses also contributes to a lesser extent. However, such resistance management benefits are fundamentally constrained by outdoor feeding behaviours that limit or completely prevent indoor insecticide exposure. Increasing IRS micro-mosaic insecticide diversity beyond two actives is unlikely to further dampen resistance emergence rates because few mosquitoes survive long enough without feeding to encounter several IRS treatments. Once a resistance trait becomes established in the vector population, selection coefficients remain consistently high enough to force the spread of those traits, regardless of intervention combination. For more exophagic, zoophagic vectors like An. arabiensis , NG-LLINs plus IRS micro-mosaics are not expected to provide any meaningful resistance management benefit because frequent outdoor feeding, often on animals, allows them to largely avoid insecticide exposure altogether. Exclusively indoor-focused vector control strategies may not satisfactorily slow insecticide resistance emergence and spread, so new outdoor protection measures that close these coverage gaps with complementary insecticides will be needed.
- Open Access
- 3 August 2026
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 22 (8) , e1014612
Impact of insecticide resistance evolution on malaria vector control
Background: Insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) are the staple of malaria vector control. Given their importance, insecticide resistance (IR) is extremely concerning. Understanding how ITNs simultaneously impact the evolution of IR and malaria control is of critical importance, especially with next-generation mixture ITNs (NGM-ITNs) becoming available. Method: We developed a mosquito population dynamics and genetics model to explore the simultaneous impact of ITNs on both malaria transmission (measured as vectorial capacity, an entomological measure of transmission) and IR evolution (resistance gene frequencies), and their interactions. We explored the long-term impact of interventions often neglected in other modelling exercises. We conducted three sets of simulations and sensitivity analyses. The first set investigated the impact of pyrethroid-only ITNs (PYR-ITNs) on IR evolution and its consequent impact on malaria vector control. The second set investigated the dual impact of NGM-ITNs in controlling malaria transmission and mitigating the evolution of resistance: IR management (IRM). The third set further considered net retention and insecticide decay. Results: For both ITN types, higher ITN coverage provided greater malaria vector control than lower coverage (of the same ITN type), even when considering IR evolution. In addition, NGM-ITNs were superior to PYR-ITNs for both malaria vector control and IRM. Even when NGM-ITNs were deployed at reduced coverage (up to 30%) than PYR-ITNs (to account for their higher procurement costs), their transmission control efficacy remains superior to PYR-ITNs by providing an additional IRM benefit through reduced selection pressures. Moreover, we found that insecticide selection on male mosquitoes may be an important consideration for malaria vector control loss. While male mosquitoes do not contribute to transmission, they propagate resistance genes, and their importance in this process is a knowledge gap. Discussion: Our results highlight the need to consider IRM when evaluating NGM-ITNs, which is not adequately considered in the evaluation pipeline. Not accounting for IRM means new interventions are being undervalued, as a component of their long-term effectiveness is being overlooked.
- 3 August 2026
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 22 (8) , e1014612
Open AccessImpact of insecticide resistance evolution on malaria vector control
Background: Insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) are the staple of malaria vector control. Given their importance, insecticide resistance (IR) is extremely concerning. Understanding how ITNs simultaneously impact the evolution of IR and malaria control is of critical importance, especially with next-generation mixture ITNs (NGM-ITNs) becoming available. Method: We developed a mosquito population dynamics and genetics model to explore the simultaneous impact of ITNs on both malaria transmission (measured as vectorial capacity, an entomological measure of transmission) and IR evolution (resistance gene frequencies), and their interactions. We explored the long-term impact of interventions often neglected in other modelling exercises. We conducted three sets of simulations and sensitivity analyses. The first set investigated the impact of pyrethroid-only ITNs (PYR-ITNs) on IR evolution and its consequent impact on malaria vector control. The second set investigated the dual impact of NGM-ITNs in controlling malaria transmission and mitigating the evolution of resistance: IR management (IRM). The third set further considered net retention and insecticide decay. Results: For both ITN types, higher ITN coverage provided greater malaria vector control than lower coverage (of the same ITN type), even when considering IR evolution. In addition, NGM-ITNs were superior to PYR-ITNs for both malaria vector control and IRM. Even when NGM-ITNs were deployed at reduced coverage (up to 30%) than PYR-ITNs (to account for their higher procurement costs), their transmission control efficacy remains superior to PYR-ITNs by providing an additional IRM benefit through reduced selection pressures. Moreover, we found that insecticide selection on male mosquitoes may be an important consideration for malaria vector control loss. While male mosquitoes do not contribute to transmission, they propagate resistance genes, and their importance in this process is a knowledge gap. Discussion: Our results highlight the need to consider IRM when evaluating NGM-ITNs, which is not adequately considered in the evaluation pipeline. Not accounting for IRM means new interventions are being undervalued, as a component of their long-term effectiveness is being overlooked.
- Open Access
Evolutionary and epidemiological considerations for anthelmintic treatments in ruminant livestock
Anthelmintic drug resistance is a concern for the sustained control of gastrointestinal nematodes (GINs) in ruminant livestock globally. Evolutionary-epidemiological modelling, which considers both parasite dynamics and resistance dynamics in response to interventions, can be useful in determining which anthelmintic resistance management (ARM) strategies may be effective without compromising parasite control. We address two key questions in ARM. First, how to improve the measurement of AR in populations. Second, identifying effective ARM strategies to slow the spread of AR while maintaining effective parasite control. We developed a simulation framework which tracks the weather-dependent epidemiology of GINs and AR evolution, providing a highly flexible methodology to evaluate multiple ARM strategy options in a single modelling framework, allowing for novel insights due to direct comparisons between strategies. Simulations to refine our understanding of anthelmintic resistance management evaluated the impact of key areas of uncertainty, including transmission intensity, resistance intensity, resistance frequency, drug decay and linking faecal egg count reduction tests (FECRT) to resistance allele frequency. Large-scale simulations present a methodologically thorough evaluation of how treatment choices simultaneously impact epidemiological and evolutionary outcomes. Phenotypic classifications of resistance status using FECRT failed to capture fine scale changes in resistance allele frequency. The pharmacokinetics of drug decay strongly influenced ARM outcomes, and trade-offs between ARM and effective parasite control depends on genetic factors underpinning resistance. Combination therapies appear to be the most effective resistance management strategy evaluated. Our findings suggest practical implementations to manage anthelmintic resistance must simultaneously consider parasite transmission, pharmacology and parasite genetics to be robust and sustainable. We provide a rigorous simulation framework to enable such discussions allowing for a refinement into our understanding of parasite control in the presence of resistance evolution.
Open AccessEvolutionary and epidemiological considerations for anthelmintic treatments in ruminant livestock
Anthelmintic drug resistance is a concern for the sustained control of gastrointestinal nematodes (GINs) in ruminant livestock globally. Evolutionary-epidemiological modelling, which considers both parasite dynamics and resistance dynamics in response to interventions, can be useful in determining which anthelmintic resistance management (ARM) strategies may be effective without compromising parasite control. We address two key questions in ARM. First, how to improve the measurement of AR in populations. Second, identifying effective ARM strategies to slow the spread of AR while maintaining effective parasite control. We developed a simulation framework which tracks the weather-dependent epidemiology of GINs and AR evolution, providing a highly flexible methodology to evaluate multiple ARM strategy options in a single modelling framework, allowing for novel insights due to direct comparisons between strategies. Simulations to refine our understanding of anthelmintic resistance management evaluated the impact of key areas of uncertainty, including transmission intensity, resistance intensity, resistance frequency, drug decay and linking faecal egg count reduction tests (FECRT) to resistance allele frequency. Large-scale simulations present a methodologically thorough evaluation of how treatment choices simultaneously impact epidemiological and evolutionary outcomes. Phenotypic classifications of resistance status using FECRT failed to capture fine scale changes in resistance allele frequency. The pharmacokinetics of drug decay strongly influenced ARM outcomes, and trade-offs between ARM and effective parasite control depends on genetic factors underpinning resistance. Combination therapies appear to be the most effective resistance management strategy evaluated. Our findings suggest practical implementations to manage anthelmintic resistance must simultaneously consider parasite transmission, pharmacology and parasite genetics to be robust and sustainable. We provide a rigorous simulation framework to enable such discussions allowing for a refinement into our understanding of parasite control in the presence of resistance evolution.
- Open Access
- 28 April 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 21 (4) , e1012944
Simulating dynamic insecticide selection pressures for resistance management in mosquitoes assuming polygenic resistance
Insecticide resistance management (IRM) is critical to maintain the operational effectiveness of insecticides used in public health vector control. Evaluating IRM strategies rests primarily on computational models. Most models assume monogenic resistance, but polygenic resistance may be a more appropriate assumption. Conventionally, polygenic models assume selection differentials are constant over successive generations. We present a dynamic method for calculating the selection differentials accounting for the level of resistance and insecticide efficacy. This allows the inclusion of key parameters namely insecticide dosing, insecticide decay and cross resistance, increasing biological and operational realism. Two methods for calculating the insecticide selection differential were compared: truncation (only the most resistant individuals in the population survive) and probabilistic (individual survival depends on their level of resistance). The probabilistic calculation is extendable to multiple gonotrophic cycles, whereby mosquitoes may encounter different insecticides over their life span. A range of IRM strategies of direct policy relevance can be simulated, including the implication of reduced dose mixtures. We describe in detail the calculation and calibration of these models. We demonstrate the ability of the models to simulate a variety of IRM strategies and implications of including these features of the models. In simple IRM strategy evaluations, the truncation and probabilistic models give comparable results to each other and against published polygenic and monogenic models. Analysis of model simulations indicates there is often little difference between sequences or rotations of insecticides. Full-dose mixtures remain the best evaluated IRM strategy. Consistency between models increases confidence in their predictions especially when demonstrating model assumptions do not significantly impact key operational decisions. Using the multiple-gonotrophic cycle model we calculate the age distributions of mosquitoes which provides a framework to link resistance management with disease transmission. Future applications will investigate more scenario-specific evaluations of IRM strategies to inform public health policy.
- 28 April 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 21 (4) , e1012944
Open AccessSimulating dynamic insecticide selection pressures for resistance management in mosquitoes assuming polygenic resistance
Insecticide resistance management (IRM) is critical to maintain the operational effectiveness of insecticides used in public health vector control. Evaluating IRM strategies rests primarily on computational models. Most models assume monogenic resistance, but polygenic resistance may be a more appropriate assumption. Conventionally, polygenic models assume selection differentials are constant over successive generations. We present a dynamic method for calculating the selection differentials accounting for the level of resistance and insecticide efficacy. This allows the inclusion of key parameters namely insecticide dosing, insecticide decay and cross resistance, increasing biological and operational realism. Two methods for calculating the insecticide selection differential were compared: truncation (only the most resistant individuals in the population survive) and probabilistic (individual survival depends on their level of resistance). The probabilistic calculation is extendable to multiple gonotrophic cycles, whereby mosquitoes may encounter different insecticides over their life span. A range of IRM strategies of direct policy relevance can be simulated, including the implication of reduced dose mixtures. We describe in detail the calculation and calibration of these models. We demonstrate the ability of the models to simulate a variety of IRM strategies and implications of including these features of the models. In simple IRM strategy evaluations, the truncation and probabilistic models give comparable results to each other and against published polygenic and monogenic models. Analysis of model simulations indicates there is often little difference between sequences or rotations of insecticides. Full-dose mixtures remain the best evaluated IRM strategy. Consistency between models increases confidence in their predictions especially when demonstrating model assumptions do not significantly impact key operational decisions. Using the multiple-gonotrophic cycle model we calculate the age distributions of mosquitoes which provides a framework to link resistance management with disease transmission. Future applications will investigate more scenario-specific evaluations of IRM strategies to inform public health policy.
- Open Access
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Malaria Journal
- Vol. 24 (1) , 1-19
The impact of insecticide decay on the rate of insecticide resistance evolution for monotherapies and mixtures
Background: The problem of insecticide decay following their deployment in public health applications is frequently highlighted as an issue for sustained disease control. There are additional concerns that it also increases selection for insecticide resistance. Despite these concerns insecticide decay is largely absent from models evaluating insecticide resistance management strategies. Methodology: The impact of insecticide decay is investigated using a model which assumes a polygenic basis of insecticide resistance. Single generation evaluations are conducted that cover the insecticide efficacy and insecticide resistance space for insecticides when deployed as monotherapies or mixtures to mechanistically investigate how insecticide decay impacts selection for resistance. The outcome is the between generation change in bioassay survival to the insecticides. The monotherapy sequence and mixture strategies were compared in multi-generation simulations incorporating insecticide decay, with the outcome being the difference in strategy lifespan. Results: The results demonstrate that as insecticides decay, they can apply a much greater selection pressure than that imposed by newly deployed, non-decayed insecticides; this applies to both monotherapies and mixtures. For mixtures, selection for resistance is highest when both insecticides have reduced decayed efficacies; this also occurs if reduced dosages are deliberately used in mixtures. Insecticide decay was found to reduce the benefit of mixtures compared to sequential monotherapies, especially when reduced-dose mixtures are used. Conclusions: Insecticide decay is often highlighted as an important consideration for mixtures and these results indicate its absence in previous modelling studies may be over-inflating the performance of full-dose mixtures. In summary: as insecticides decay, they can impose increasing selection pressures for resistance with reduced ability to control the target insect populations. The optimal frequency with which decaying insecticides should be replenished is an important policy consideration.
- 18 February 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Malaria Journal
- Vol. 24 (1) , 1-19
Open AccessThe impact of insecticide decay on the rate of insecticide resistance evolution for monotherapies and mixtures
Background: The problem of insecticide decay following their deployment in public health applications is frequently highlighted as an issue for sustained disease control. There are additional concerns that it also increases selection for insecticide resistance. Despite these concerns insecticide decay is largely absent from models evaluating insecticide resistance management strategies. Methodology: The impact of insecticide decay is investigated using a model which assumes a polygenic basis of insecticide resistance. Single generation evaluations are conducted that cover the insecticide efficacy and insecticide resistance space for insecticides when deployed as monotherapies or mixtures to mechanistically investigate how insecticide decay impacts selection for resistance. The outcome is the between generation change in bioassay survival to the insecticides. The monotherapy sequence and mixture strategies were compared in multi-generation simulations incorporating insecticide decay, with the outcome being the difference in strategy lifespan. Results: The results demonstrate that as insecticides decay, they can apply a much greater selection pressure than that imposed by newly deployed, non-decayed insecticides; this applies to both monotherapies and mixtures. For mixtures, selection for resistance is highest when both insecticides have reduced decayed efficacies; this also occurs if reduced dosages are deliberately used in mixtures. Insecticide decay was found to reduce the benefit of mixtures compared to sequential monotherapies, especially when reduced-dose mixtures are used. Conclusions: Insecticide decay is often highlighted as an important consideration for mixtures and these results indicate its absence in previous modelling studies may be over-inflating the performance of full-dose mixtures. In summary: as insecticides decay, they can impose increasing selection pressures for resistance with reduced ability to control the target insect populations. The optimal frequency with which decaying insecticides should be replenished is an important policy consideration.
- Open Access
Household level insecticide deployments (micro-mosaics) for insecticide resistance management: Evaluating deliberate and accidental deployments
Mixtures of two insecticides in a single formulation at full-dose are frequently evaluated as the “best” insecticide resistance (IRM) strategy in public health. However, this requires both insecticides to be mixed together in a single formulation which may not be possible or practical. Deploying different insecticides in different households (“micro-mosaics”) may allow for mosquitoes to encounter different insecticides in subsequent gonotrophic cycles obtaining a “temporal mixture”. We evaluate micro-mosaics considering their deliberate use and their accidental use using a mathematical model assuming polygenic resistance. Deliberate micro-mosaics are evaluated against rotations and mixtures (full-dose or half-dose) over a range of scenarios allowing for cross resistance and insecticide decay on their ability to slow the development of resistance. Accidental micro-mosaics are evaluated to understand the implication of mixture insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) and standard (pyrethroid only) ITNs being deployed alongside one another on the development of resistance across a range of initial resistance scenarios. Deliberate micro-mosaics are found to not differ substantially in their IRM capability from either rotations or half-dose mixtures. When micro-mosaics do outperform rotations or half-dose mixtures the benefit is often small. Micro-mosaics are found to perform worse than full-dose mixtures. Accidental micro-mosaics are found to reduce the ability of mixtures to slow the development of resistance. The deployment of deliberate micro-mosaics was found to not be beneficial versus rotations or mixtures indicating this strategy should not be pursued. Micro-mosaics occurring accidentally due to multiple distribution channels inhibits the effectiveness of mixture ITNs in slowing the development of resistance. Where mixture ITNs are used keep the coverage of the mixture high relative to standard (pyrethroid-only) ITNs is key.
Open AccessHousehold level insecticide deployments (micro-mosaics) for insecticide resistance management: Evaluating deliberate and accidental deployments
Mixtures of two insecticides in a single formulation at full-dose are frequently evaluated as the “best” insecticide resistance (IRM) strategy in public health. However, this requires both insecticides to be mixed together in a single formulation which may not be possible or practical. Deploying different insecticides in different households (“micro-mosaics”) may allow for mosquitoes to encounter different insecticides in subsequent gonotrophic cycles obtaining a “temporal mixture”. We evaluate micro-mosaics considering their deliberate use and their accidental use using a mathematical model assuming polygenic resistance. Deliberate micro-mosaics are evaluated against rotations and mixtures (full-dose or half-dose) over a range of scenarios allowing for cross resistance and insecticide decay on their ability to slow the development of resistance. Accidental micro-mosaics are evaluated to understand the implication of mixture insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) and standard (pyrethroid only) ITNs being deployed alongside one another on the development of resistance across a range of initial resistance scenarios. Deliberate micro-mosaics are found to not differ substantially in their IRM capability from either rotations or half-dose mixtures. When micro-mosaics do outperform rotations or half-dose mixtures the benefit is often small. Micro-mosaics are found to perform worse than full-dose mixtures. Accidental micro-mosaics are found to reduce the ability of mixtures to slow the development of resistance. The deployment of deliberate micro-mosaics was found to not be beneficial versus rotations or mixtures indicating this strategy should not be pursued. Micro-mosaics occurring accidentally due to multiple distribution channels inhibits the effectiveness of mixture ITNs in slowing the development of resistance. Where mixture ITNs are used keep the coverage of the mixture high relative to standard (pyrethroid-only) ITNs is key.
- Open Access
Combinations of Insecticide-Treated Nets and Indoor Residual Spraying for Insecticide Resistance Management: A Modelling Exploration
Insecticides are heavily used for the control of vectors of disease. Malaria control has been reliant on insecticide treated nets (ITNs) and indoor residual spraying (IRS). There are concerns insecticide resistance will impede malaria control. The use of insecticide resistance management (IRM) strategies is recommended. One proposed IRM strategy is the combination of ITNs and IRS. Using a mathematical model of polygenic insecticide resistance evolution, this combination strategy is evaluated. First, combinations are evaluated against ITNs alone to determine if and when combinations may be beneficial in slowing resistance evolution to the pyrethroid on the ITN. Second combinations where multiple IRS insecticides are available are compared against full-dose mixture ITNs. Results of the simulations indicate the addition of IRS to ITNs may be beneficial, providing coverage of both interventions is high. The greater number IRS insecticides available for rotation the better, however even when combinations rotate three different IRS insecticides this is still a less potent IRM strategy than deploying full-dose mixtures. In conclusion the combination of ITNs and IRS appears to offer limited benefit over full-dose mixture ITNs for an IRM perspective
Open AccessCombinations of Insecticide-Treated Nets and Indoor Residual Spraying for Insecticide Resistance Management: A Modelling Exploration
Insecticides are heavily used for the control of vectors of disease. Malaria control has been reliant on insecticide treated nets (ITNs) and indoor residual spraying (IRS). There are concerns insecticide resistance will impede malaria control. The use of insecticide resistance management (IRM) strategies is recommended. One proposed IRM strategy is the combination of ITNs and IRS. Using a mathematical model of polygenic insecticide resistance evolution, this combination strategy is evaluated. First, combinations are evaluated against ITNs alone to determine if and when combinations may be beneficial in slowing resistance evolution to the pyrethroid on the ITN. Second combinations where multiple IRS insecticides are available are compared against full-dose mixture ITNs. Results of the simulations indicate the addition of IRS to ITNs may be beneficial, providing coverage of both interventions is high. The greater number IRS insecticides available for rotation the better, however even when combinations rotate three different IRS insecticides this is still a less potent IRM strategy than deploying full-dose mixtures. In conclusion the combination of ITNs and IRS appears to offer limited benefit over full-dose mixture ITNs for an IRM perspective
- Open Access
Exploring operational requirements of mixtures for insecticide resistance management in public health using a mathematical model assuming polygenic resistance
Long-lasting insecticide treated nets (LLINs) have been developed which contain two active ingredients. Mixture products for vector control are now an available insecticide resistance management (IRM) strategy. There is a theoretical concern around the use mixtures pertaining to dosing, insecticide decay, initial resistance, and cross resistance. Mixture LLINs all currently have a pyrethroid as one of the partner insecticides. Using previously described mathematical models of polygenic insecticide resistance evolution, which implement selection either by truncation (“polytrucate) or as a probabilistic process (“polysmooth”) mixtures are evaluated for their IRM potential. Scenarios are developed to explore the impact of the initial levels of resistance to the pyrethroid insecticide, insecticide decay rates, and insecticide doses, and cross resistance. Results from our simulations indicate that mixtures should be deployed at full doses. As the initial level of resistance to the pyrethroid increases the benefit of mixture decreases. Insecticide decay was found to be less important than might be thought, with other variables having a greater impact. The mechanism of selection demonstrated consistent results, diverging only at very high levels of resistance to the pyrethroid. Our simulations demonstrate that the impact of positive cross resistance is best mitigated using full-dose mixtures. Insecticide decay less important than previously considered, and opens up the opportunity to mix a wider variety of insecticides. However, as mixtures remain a challenge to develop and therefore strategies which could generate an effect of a “temporal” mixture should be evaluated.
Open AccessExploring operational requirements of mixtures for insecticide resistance management in public health using a mathematical model assuming polygenic resistance
Long-lasting insecticide treated nets (LLINs) have been developed which contain two active ingredients. Mixture products for vector control are now an available insecticide resistance management (IRM) strategy. There is a theoretical concern around the use mixtures pertaining to dosing, insecticide decay, initial resistance, and cross resistance. Mixture LLINs all currently have a pyrethroid as one of the partner insecticides. Using previously described mathematical models of polygenic insecticide resistance evolution, which implement selection either by truncation (“polytrucate) or as a probabilistic process (“polysmooth”) mixtures are evaluated for their IRM potential. Scenarios are developed to explore the impact of the initial levels of resistance to the pyrethroid insecticide, insecticide decay rates, and insecticide doses, and cross resistance. Results from our simulations indicate that mixtures should be deployed at full doses. As the initial level of resistance to the pyrethroid increases the benefit of mixture decreases. Insecticide decay was found to be less important than might be thought, with other variables having a greater impact. The mechanism of selection demonstrated consistent results, diverging only at very high levels of resistance to the pyrethroid. Our simulations demonstrate that the impact of positive cross resistance is best mitigated using full-dose mixtures. Insecticide decay less important than previously considered, and opens up the opportunity to mix a wider variety of insecticides. However, as mixtures remain a challenge to develop and therefore strategies which could generate an effect of a “temporal” mixture should be evaluated.
- Open Access
The impact of insecticide decay on the rate of insecticide resistance evolution for monotherapies and mixtures
The issue of insecticide decay in the public health deployments of insecticides is frequently highlighted as an issue for disease control. There are additional concerns insecticide decay also impacts the selection for insecticide resistance. Despite these concerns insecticide decay is lacking from models evaluating insecticide resistance management strategies. The impact of insecticide decay is modelled using a model which assumes a polygenic basis of insecticide resistance. Single generation selection events covering the insecticide efficacy and insecticide resistance space for both monotherapies and mixtures are conducted. With the outcome being the between generation change in the bioassay survival to the insecticides. The monotherapy sequence strategy and mixture strategy were compared against each other when including insecticide decay, with the outcome being the difference in strategy lifespan. The results demonstrate that as insecticides decay, they can apply a greater selection pressure than newly deployed insecticides, a process which can occur for both monotherapies and mixtures. For mixtures, it is seen that the rate of selection is highest when both insecticides are at reduced efficacies which would occur if reduced dose mixtures were used. Inclusion of insecticide decay in simulations was found to reduce the benefit of mixtures against monotherapy sequences, and this is especially so when reduced-dose mixtures are used. Insecticide decay is often highlighted as an important consideration for mixtures. The inclusion of insecticide decay in models is often lacking, and these results indicate this is absence may be over-inflating the performance of full-dose mixtures. As insecticides decay, they still provide selection pressures with reduced ability to control transmission, replenishing worn-out insecticides more frequently should be considered.
Open AccessThe impact of insecticide decay on the rate of insecticide resistance evolution for monotherapies and mixtures
The issue of insecticide decay in the public health deployments of insecticides is frequently highlighted as an issue for disease control. There are additional concerns insecticide decay also impacts the selection for insecticide resistance. Despite these concerns insecticide decay is lacking from models evaluating insecticide resistance management strategies. The impact of insecticide decay is modelled using a model which assumes a polygenic basis of insecticide resistance. Single generation selection events covering the insecticide efficacy and insecticide resistance space for both monotherapies and mixtures are conducted. With the outcome being the between generation change in the bioassay survival to the insecticides. The monotherapy sequence strategy and mixture strategy were compared against each other when including insecticide decay, with the outcome being the difference in strategy lifespan. The results demonstrate that as insecticides decay, they can apply a greater selection pressure than newly deployed insecticides, a process which can occur for both monotherapies and mixtures. For mixtures, it is seen that the rate of selection is highest when both insecticides are at reduced efficacies which would occur if reduced dose mixtures were used. Inclusion of insecticide decay in simulations was found to reduce the benefit of mixtures against monotherapy sequences, and this is especially so when reduced-dose mixtures are used. Insecticide decay is often highlighted as an important consideration for mixtures. The inclusion of insecticide decay in models is often lacking, and these results indicate this is absence may be over-inflating the performance of full-dose mixtures. As insecticides decay, they still provide selection pressures with reduced ability to control transmission, replenishing worn-out insecticides more frequently should be considered.
- Open Access
Mathematical Methodology for Dynamic Models of Insecticide Selection Assuming a Polygenic Basis of Resistance
Mathematical models for evaluating insecticide resistance management (IRM) have primarily assumed insecticide resistance (IR) is monogenic. Modelling using a quantitative genetics framework to model polygenic IR has less frequently been used. We introduce a complex mathematical model for polygenic IR with a focus on public health insecticide deployments for vector control. Conventional polygenic models assume selection differentials are constant over the course of selection. We instead propose calculating the selection differentials dynamically depending on the level of IR and the amount of insecticide encountered. Dynamically calculating the selection differentials increases biological and operational realism, allowing for the evaluation of strategies of policy relevance, including reduced dose mixtures or the deployment of long-lasting insecticide-treated nets and indoor residual spraying in combination. The dynamic calculations of insecticide selection allow for two methods: 1) Truncation (“polytruncate”) – where only the most resistant individuals in the population survive, and 2) Probabilistic (“polysmooth”) – where an individual’s survival probability is dependent on their own level of IR. We describe in detail the calculation and calibration of these models. The models (“polytruncate” and “polysmooth”) are compared against a previous polygenic model (“polyres”) and the monogenic literature for the IRM strategies of rotations, sequences and full-dose mixtures. We demonstrate consistency in results of full-dose mixtures remaining the best IRM strategy, with sequences and rotations being similar in their efficacy between the two selection processes, and consistency in “global conclusions” with previous models. Consistency between the “polysmooth”, “polytruncate” and previous models helps provide confidence in their predictions, as operational interpretations are not overly impacted by model assumptions. This increases confidence in the application of these dynamic models to investigate more complex IRM strategies and scenarios, and their future applications will investigate more scenario specific evaluations of IRM strategies.
Open AccessMathematical Methodology for Dynamic Models of Insecticide Selection Assuming a Polygenic Basis of Resistance
Mathematical models for evaluating insecticide resistance management (IRM) have primarily assumed insecticide resistance (IR) is monogenic. Modelling using a quantitative genetics framework to model polygenic IR has less frequently been used. We introduce a complex mathematical model for polygenic IR with a focus on public health insecticide deployments for vector control. Conventional polygenic models assume selection differentials are constant over the course of selection. We instead propose calculating the selection differentials dynamically depending on the level of IR and the amount of insecticide encountered. Dynamically calculating the selection differentials increases biological and operational realism, allowing for the evaluation of strategies of policy relevance, including reduced dose mixtures or the deployment of long-lasting insecticide-treated nets and indoor residual spraying in combination. The dynamic calculations of insecticide selection allow for two methods: 1) Truncation (“polytruncate”) – where only the most resistant individuals in the population survive, and 2) Probabilistic (“polysmooth”) – where an individual’s survival probability is dependent on their own level of IR. We describe in detail the calculation and calibration of these models. The models (“polytruncate” and “polysmooth”) are compared against a previous polygenic model (“polyres”) and the monogenic literature for the IRM strategies of rotations, sequences and full-dose mixtures. We demonstrate consistency in results of full-dose mixtures remaining the best IRM strategy, with sequences and rotations being similar in their efficacy between the two selection processes, and consistency in “global conclusions” with previous models. Consistency between the “polysmooth”, “polytruncate” and previous models helps provide confidence in their predictions, as operational interpretations are not overly impacted by model assumptions. This increases confidence in the application of these dynamic models to investigate more complex IRM strategies and scenarios, and their future applications will investigate more scenario specific evaluations of IRM strategies.