GFGavin Fay

Gavin Fay

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Gavin Fay has a total of 30 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Evaluating the Performance of Summer Flounder (Paralichthys dentatus) Recreational Fishery Management Measures

    by Kamran Walsh, Andrew Carr-Harris, Geret DePiper, Sarah Gaichas, Brandon Muffley, Tracey Bauer, Julia Beaty, Chelsea L. Tuohy, Gavin Fay

    The recreational fishing sector plays a substantial role in shaping abundance and trends of Summer Flounder (Paralichthys dentatus) along the Atlantic Coast of the United States, with recreational landings comparable to commercial in magnitude. There is a clear need to assess the predicted outcomes of alternative management strategies on metrics of fishery performance including stock status, angler opportunity, and economic productivity. A Management Strategy Evaluation (MSE) for summer flounder was developed in 2022 to provide a framework for assessing how regulatory strategies impact the recreational fishery. Here, we expand upon the MSE to evaluate the predicted outcomes of alternative harvest control rules (HCR) that determine output controls and recreational fishing regulations (i.e., input controls) on biological and socioeconomic fishery performance. HCRs informed by the Recreational Harvest Limit achieved better conservation outcomes, while those informed by interannual changes in stock status more effectively promoted angler opportunity. Outcomes varied with fishing regulation decisions. For example, minimum size limit changes were associated with greater conservation outcomes, and bag limit changes improved angler opportunity. The effectiveness of HCRs was driven by fishing regulation decisions and vice versa, and HCRs with better conservation outcomes required more restrictive fishing regulations. Results were consistent across starting stock status assumptions, but more contrast between management strategies was seen when starting simulations at higher or lower relative stock sizes. These methods provide an approach for quantifying the expected impacts of management strategies and fishing regulations on recreational fishery sustainability, and the findings improve understanding of how biological and socioeconomic indicators can inform management.

  • Factors affecting inferences on natural mortality and associated environmental effects in state-space age-structured assessment models

    by Timothy J. Miller, Gregory L. Britten, Elizabeth N. Brooks, Gavin Fay, Alexander C. Hansell, Christopher M. Legault, Brandon Muffley, John Wiedenmann, Brandon Muffley

    Treatment of natural mortality is a major consideration in assessment models and state-space approaches allow estimation of temporal variation in this mortality rate as well as effects of specific covariates. However, there has been no investigation of the reliability of inferences made from state-space assessment models when there is process error or covariate effects on natural mortality. We conducted a large-scale simulation study with operating models simulating data assuming alternative levels of observation error, types and magnitude of process error, and magnitude of covariate effects on natural mortality. We fit estimating models to the simulated data with alternative assumptions regarding the inclusion of covariate effects, estimation of the median natural mortality rate, and type of process error. We found estimating covariate effects on natural mortality required ideal scenarios with lower observation uncertainty, contrast in fishing pressure, and higher covariate variability, but the source of process error could be mis-specified. Estimating annual natural mortality rates as random effects was also challenging, but spawning stock biomass and fishing mortality were reliable in a wide range of scenarios.


  • An investigation of factors affecting inferences from and reliability of state-space age-structured assessment models

    by Timothy J. Miller, Gregory L. Britten, Elizabeth N. Brooks, Gavin Fay, Alexander C. Hansell, Christopher M. Legault, Chengxue Li, Brandon Muffley, Brian C. Stock, John Wiedenmann

    State-space models have been promoted as the next-generation of fisheries stock assessment and evaluation of their reliability is needed. We simulated operating models that varied fishing pressure, magnitude of observation error, and sources of process error. For each operating model, we fit a range of estimating models with correct and incorrect configurations. We measured reliability of estimating models by convergence rate, accuracy of Akaike information criterion (AIC)-based model selection, estimation bias, and magnitude of retrospective patterns. All reliability measures were generally better with lower observation error, contrast in fishing pressure over time, and when median natural mortality rate is known. The magnitude of the log-likelihood gradients was not a reliable indicator of convergence. AIC can generally distinguish process error source with lower observation error and higher true process error variability. Distinguishing the stock–recruit relationship with AIC required large contrast in spawning biomass and low recruitment variation, but bias in stock–recruit parameter estimation was prevalent. Retrospective patterns were not large for mis-specified models. These findings improve our understanding of when results from state-space models will be reliable.


  • Open Access

    Navigating concepts of social-ecological resilience in marine fisheries under climate change: shared challenges and recommendations from the northeast United States

    by K M Maltby, J G Mason, H Cheng, G Fay, R L Selden, L Williams, C L Alves

    Climate change is increasingly impacting marine fisheries worldwide. Concurrently, scientific interest has grown to understand how these systems can cope and adapt, with research shifting from examining vulnerability to assessing risks to focusing on determining and operationalizing resilience. As fisheries-climate-resilience researchers and practitioners navigating a sea of frameworks, toolkits, strategies, policy goals, and management desires, we take stock to ask: what does resilience mean to us? Drawing on our experiences in the northeast United States, we discuss the challenges and ambiguity we encounter in concepts of social-ecological resilience and explore implications for research and implementation. We bring together perspectives to discuss various approaches to resilience, highlighting shared and unique challenges we face. We outline three key considerations as we move forward in resilience research and practice: (1) the need for greater transparency and reflexivity among researchers regarding how they frame and approach resilience; (2) the value of increasing coordination and communication among fisheries groups working on these topics; and (3) the use of co-developed and co-produced resilience research and strategies. We urge for greater centring of communities in these discussions and to explicitly consider how resilience interacts with equity outcomes.


  • Data-rich but model-resistant: an evaluation of data-limited methods to manage fisheries with failed age-based stock assessments

    by Christopher M. Legault, John Wiedenmann, Jonathan J. Deroba, Gavin Fay, Timothy J. Miller, Elizabeth N. Brooks, Richard J. Bell, Joseph A. Langan, Jamie Marie Cournane, Andrew W. Jones, et al.

    Age-based stock assessments are sometimes rejected by review panels due to large retrospective patterns. When this occurs, data-limited approaches are often used to set catch advice, under the assumption that these simpler methods will not be impacted by the problems causing retrospective patterns in the age-based assessment. This assumption has never been formally evaluated. Closed-loop simulations were conducted where a known source of error caused a retrospective pattern in an age-based assessment. Twelve data-limited methods, an ensemble of a subset of these methods, and a statistical catch-at-age model with retrospective adjustment were all evaluated to examine their ability to prevent overfishing and rebuild overfished stocks. Overall, none of the methods evaluated performed best across the scenarios. A number of methods performed consistently poorly, resulting in frequent and intense overfishing and low stock sizes. The retrospective adjusted statistical catch-at-age assessment performed better than a number of the alternatives explored. Thus, using a data-limited approach to set catch advice will not necessarily result in better performance than relying on the age-based assessment with a retrospective adjustment.