Matthew Muir
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Matthew Muir has a total of 42 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nancy Ockendon
Conservation Science Group, Department of Zoology, Cambridge University, The David Attenborough Building, Pembroke Street, Cambridge, CB2 3QZ, UK
2 shared publications Aida Kowalska
On the Edge London UK
1 shared publicationAlex Bowmer
On the Edge London UK
1 shared publication- Alex Caruana
Institute of Applied Sciences, Malta College for Arts, Sciences and Technology, Fgura, Malta
1 shared publication Becky Holmes
The Helvellyn Foundation Crewe Cheshire UK
1 shared publication- Charles Latrémouille
Independent Consultant & CMP Montreal Québec Canada
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 7 (5)
The cost of knowing what will stop wildlife trafficking: Organizations reallocating 3% annually could reveal what works to protect species
Wildlife trafficking is a multibillion‐dollar illicit business that drives biodiversity loss, compromises bio‐ and national security, and can threaten the safety and wellbeing of local communities. A new study reveals that we have profound opportunities to expand the evidence about what works to stop wildlife trafficking and that we have clear models to inform rigorous evaluation of interventions. These findings present an opportune invitation: How will the conservation community fund at scale the evidence testing to establish what works to stop wildlife trafficking? We amplify this call and urge donor governments, multilateral institutions, and private foundations globally to help transform the way we combat wildlife trafficking by dedicating at least 1–3% of budgets to testing the effectiveness of interventions. We calculate allocations based on current evidence and funding levels by intervention category and find that this would translate into global donors investing only US$2.6–5.7 million annually in evidence testing. By reallocating a small portion of investments to building evidence through evaluation, we can significantly advance our understanding of what effectively works to stop wildlife trafficking.
- 22 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 7 (5)
Open AccessThe cost of knowing what will stop wildlife trafficking: Organizations reallocating 3% annually could reveal what works to protect species
Wildlife trafficking is a multibillion‐dollar illicit business that drives biodiversity loss, compromises bio‐ and national security, and can threaten the safety and wellbeing of local communities. A new study reveals that we have profound opportunities to expand the evidence about what works to stop wildlife trafficking and that we have clear models to inform rigorous evaluation of interventions. These findings present an opportune invitation: How will the conservation community fund at scale the evidence testing to establish what works to stop wildlife trafficking? We amplify this call and urge donor governments, multilateral institutions, and private foundations globally to help transform the way we combat wildlife trafficking by dedicating at least 1–3% of budgets to testing the effectiveness of interventions. We calculate allocations based on current evidence and funding levels by intervention category and find that this would translate into global donors investing only US$2.6–5.7 million annually in evidence testing. By reallocating a small portion of investments to building evidence through evaluation, we can significantly advance our understanding of what effectively works to stop wildlife trafficking.
- Open Access
- 9 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Solutions and Evidence
- Vol. 6 (1)
Approaches for integrating evidence of the effectiveness of actions in conservation funding to inspire more effective practice
In the midst of a biodiversity crisis, it is critical that commonly used interventions to protect wildlife and recover losses are effective and learnings are widely shared. It is acknowledged that considerable gains could be made for society and biodiversity if conservation practices build on existing evidence of effectiveness. While funders can have a positive effect on conservation by funding effective conservation actions, their potential role in changing common practice is less well acknowledged. We believe that those providing funds could have a significant impact on the use of evidence, and thus practice, by encouraging and demonstrating best practice. We represent 18 funder organisations that ask applicants to reflect on and present available evidence, when requesting financial support, to justify why they believe their suggested management actions are likely to be effective. We use a variety of approaches to encourage and ensure the integration of evidence and provide the details of those here to encourage adoption (and adaption) by other funders. They range from simple requests for evidence in application forms to substantial support in designing a project (potentially including testing an action where evidence is lacking), depending on the scale, length and topic of proposed work. Reflecting on our experiences, we provide recommendations to help other funders adopt a more evidence‐based approach. These include considering how funders could improve funding impact, communicating with other funders to learn and adapt and the need to provide support to grantees to access evidence of effectiveness, explain different evidence types, how to use evidence in different contexts and what to do when no evidence exists. Practical implication. Funders have a unique role in setting expectations, providing guidance and helping advance how we do conservation work, through a unified approach. The gains we envisage from widespread adoption of funders asking for evidence of actions are that conservationists become used to reflecting on available evidence when planning projects and it becomes easier for funders to select and support effective approaches and evidence‐led practitioners. As conservation practice becomes increasingly professional and impactful, more funders will be attracted, ensuring even greater effectiveness.
- 9 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Solutions and Evidence
- Vol. 6 (1)
Open AccessApproaches for integrating evidence of the effectiveness of actions in conservation funding to inspire more effective practice
In the midst of a biodiversity crisis, it is critical that commonly used interventions to protect wildlife and recover losses are effective and learnings are widely shared. It is acknowledged that considerable gains could be made for society and biodiversity if conservation practices build on existing evidence of effectiveness. While funders can have a positive effect on conservation by funding effective conservation actions, their potential role in changing common practice is less well acknowledged. We believe that those providing funds could have a significant impact on the use of evidence, and thus practice, by encouraging and demonstrating best practice. We represent 18 funder organisations that ask applicants to reflect on and present available evidence, when requesting financial support, to justify why they believe their suggested management actions are likely to be effective. We use a variety of approaches to encourage and ensure the integration of evidence and provide the details of those here to encourage adoption (and adaption) by other funders. They range from simple requests for evidence in application forms to substantial support in designing a project (potentially including testing an action where evidence is lacking), depending on the scale, length and topic of proposed work. Reflecting on our experiences, we provide recommendations to help other funders adopt a more evidence‐based approach. These include considering how funders could improve funding impact, communicating with other funders to learn and adapt and the need to provide support to grantees to access evidence of effectiveness, explain different evidence types, how to use evidence in different contexts and what to do when no evidence exists. Practical implication. Funders have a unique role in setting expectations, providing guidance and helping advance how we do conservation work, through a unified approach. The gains we envisage from widespread adoption of funders asking for evidence of actions are that conservationists become used to reflecting on available evidence when planning projects and it becomes easier for funders to select and support effective approaches and evidence‐led practitioners. As conservation practice becomes increasingly professional and impactful, more funders will be attracted, ensuring even greater effectiveness.
- Open Access
- 24 November 2024
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 6 (12)
Lessons lost: Lack of requirements for post‐project evaluation and reporting is hindering evidence‐based conservation
For conservation to be based on evidence, the outcomes of conservation actions need to be shared. The European Union (EU) is a major funder of conservation action in Europe through the well‐studied LIFE program. Less well‐known, but also funding substantial conservation action, is the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF). Through a systematic review of conservation projects funded by LIFE and ERDF, we identify substantial expenditure on biodiversity conservation (€1300 M and €760 M between 2014 and 2024 respectively). We explore the extent to which LIFE and ERDF contribute to building an evidence base about the effectiveness of conservation actions. There were differences between LIFE and ERDF in the extent to which documentation about the project was publicly available (89% and 26% respectively), and large differences in whether any form of project evaluation was available (63% and 5% respectively). A possible explanation for these results is differing funder requirements regarding the monitoring and reporting of project implementation and outcomes. We explore funder requirements across a sample of other conservation funders and suggest how changes could incentivize higher quality sharing of project outcomes. This would expand the evidence base needed to improve the effectiveness of conservation actions.
- 24 November 2024
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 6 (12)
Open AccessLessons lost: Lack of requirements for post‐project evaluation and reporting is hindering evidence‐based conservation
For conservation to be based on evidence, the outcomes of conservation actions need to be shared. The European Union (EU) is a major funder of conservation action in Europe through the well‐studied LIFE program. Less well‐known, but also funding substantial conservation action, is the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF). Through a systematic review of conservation projects funded by LIFE and ERDF, we identify substantial expenditure on biodiversity conservation (€1300 M and €760 M between 2014 and 2024 respectively). We explore the extent to which LIFE and ERDF contribute to building an evidence base about the effectiveness of conservation actions. There were differences between LIFE and ERDF in the extent to which documentation about the project was publicly available (89% and 26% respectively), and large differences in whether any form of project evaluation was available (63% and 5% respectively). A possible explanation for these results is differing funder requirements regarding the monitoring and reporting of project implementation and outcomes. We explore funder requirements across a sample of other conservation funders and suggest how changes could incentivize higher quality sharing of project outcomes. This would expand the evidence base needed to improve the effectiveness of conservation actions.
- Open Access
- 6 December 2022
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 269-304
9. Creating Evidence-Based Policy and Practice
Transforming conservation depends on evidence being embedded within decision-making processes. This chapter presents general principles for embedding evidence into a wide range of approaches and processes. These include creating action plans (habitat or species), guidance documents, funding applications, policy, business environmental strategies, and management plans, as well as deciding what to fund, what to report or how to construct models. How well evidence is used in these processes can be evaluated through various processes and indices.
- 6 December 2022
- Published by Open Book Publishers
- p. 269-304
Open Access9. Creating Evidence-Based Policy and Practice
Transforming conservation depends on evidence being embedded within decision-making processes. This chapter presents general principles for embedding evidence into a wide range of approaches and processes. These include creating action plans (habitat or species), guidance documents, funding applications, policy, business environmental strategies, and management plans, as well as deciding what to fund, what to report or how to construct models. How well evidence is used in these processes can be evaluated through various processes and indices.