Faranak Hardcastle
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Faranak Hardcastle has a total of 36 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Anneke Lucassen
University of Oxford
2 shared publicationsDaniel Kochin
Clinical Ethics, Law and Society group (CELS), and Centre for Personalised Medicine, Wellcome Centre for Human Genetics, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
2 shared publicationsJosé David Gómez Urrego
Clinical Ethics, Law and Society (CELS), The NIHR Southampton Biomedical Research Centre, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
2 shared publicationsKate Lyle
Clinical Ethics, Law and Society group (CELS), and Centre for Personalised Medicine, Wellcome Centre for Human Genetics, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
2 shared publicationsLyra Nightingale
Genomics England Ltd, London, UK
2 shared publicationsMaxine Mackintosh
Genomics England Ltd, London, UK
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 4 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Science Computer Review
- Vol. 44 (1) , 131-149
Unblackboxing How Sociotemporalities Inform AI Accountability: The Case of Targeted Advertising
In recent years, numerous accountability interventions have been introduced to address the harms and inequalities associated with Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems. Early efforts concentrated on transparency and explainability, often operationalized as technical fixes intended to “open the black box” and render algorithmic processes more intelligible. However, sociological research has revealed the limitations of these interventions, particularly their narrow focus on the technical and operational dimensions of AI. In response, sociologists have broadened the scope of “unblackboxing” to include the sociomaterialities of AI, or the social, political, and environmental relations that both shape and are shaped by AI technologies and their infrastructures. This article extends this agenda by focusing on sociotemporalities: the narratives and structures of time that shape both AI systems and the interventions meant to improve their accountability. We re-analyze interviews from a retrospective study of transparency in targeted advertising, a domain long associated with concerns about privacy, discrimination and opaque practices. Drawing on the sociology of time, and especially the sociology of the future, we examine the sociotemporalities that actively shaped the development of targeted advertising technologies at the time and influenced key informants’ thinking about approaches to improve accountability. Our analysis suggests that sociotemporalities exerted a structuring influence on how “appropriate” accountability interventions were imagined and enacted, ultimately shaping the emergent present of targeted advertising. We discuss the application of such an approach in the context of emerging AI technologies and AI accountability interventions. We conclude by arguing that expanding unblackboxing to include sociotemporal as well as sociomaterial dimensions can help open new pathways for designing and implementing more practical, effective, and context-specific AI accountability interventions.
- 4 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Science Computer Review
- Vol. 44 (1) , 131-149
Open AccessUnblackboxing How Sociotemporalities Inform AI Accountability: The Case of Targeted Advertising
In recent years, numerous accountability interventions have been introduced to address the harms and inequalities associated with Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems. Early efforts concentrated on transparency and explainability, often operationalized as technical fixes intended to “open the black box” and render algorithmic processes more intelligible. However, sociological research has revealed the limitations of these interventions, particularly their narrow focus on the technical and operational dimensions of AI. In response, sociologists have broadened the scope of “unblackboxing” to include the sociomaterialities of AI, or the social, political, and environmental relations that both shape and are shaped by AI technologies and their infrastructures. This article extends this agenda by focusing on sociotemporalities: the narratives and structures of time that shape both AI systems and the interventions meant to improve their accountability. We re-analyze interviews from a retrospective study of transparency in targeted advertising, a domain long associated with concerns about privacy, discrimination and opaque practices. Drawing on the sociology of time, and especially the sociology of the future, we examine the sociotemporalities that actively shaped the development of targeted advertising technologies at the time and influenced key informants’ thinking about approaches to improve accountability. Our analysis suggests that sociotemporalities exerted a structuring influence on how “appropriate” accountability interventions were imagined and enacted, ultimately shaping the emergent present of targeted advertising. We discuss the application of such an approach in the context of emerging AI technologies and AI accountability interventions. We conclude by arguing that expanding unblackboxing to include sociotemporal as well as sociomaterial dimensions can help open new pathways for designing and implementing more practical, effective, and context-specific AI accountability interventions.
- Open Access
- 3 April 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 25 (4) , 130-132
Technologies Do Not Build Trust, People Do: A Critical Response to Promises of Trust in Biobanking Through Blockchain and Generative AI
- 3 April 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 25 (4) , 130-132
Open AccessTechnologies Do Not Build Trust, People Do: A Critical Response to Promises of Trust in Biobanking Through Blockchain and Generative AI
- Open Access
- 12 September 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Cambridge Prisms: Precision Medicine
- Vol. 2, e1
The ethical challenges of diversifying genomic data: A qualitative evidence synthesis
This article aims to explore the ethical issues arising from attempts to diversify genomic data and include individuals from underserved groups in studies exploring the relationship between genomics and health. We employed a qualitative synthesis design, combining data from three sources: 1) a rapid review of empirical articles published between 2000 and 2022 with a primary or secondary focus on diversifying genomic data, or the inclusion of underserved groups and ethical issues arising from this, 2) an expert workshop and 3) a narrative review. Using these three sources we found that ethical issues are interconnected across structural factors and research practices. Structural issues include failing to engage with the politics of knowledge production, existing inequities, and their effects on how harms and benefits of genomics are distributed. Issues related to research practices include a lack of reflexivity, exploitative dynamics and the failure to prioritise meaningful co-production. Ethical issues arise from both the structure and the practice of research, which can inhibit researcher and participant opportunities to diversify data in an ethical way. Diverse data are not ethical in and of themselves, and without being attentive to the social, historical and political contexts that shape the lives of potential participants, endeavours to diversify genomic data run the risk of worsening existing inequities. Efforts to construct more representative genomic datasets need to develop ethical approaches that are situated within wider attempts to make the enterprise of genomics more equitable.
- 12 September 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Cambridge Prisms: Precision Medicine
- Vol. 2, e1
Open AccessThe ethical challenges of diversifying genomic data: A qualitative evidence synthesis
This article aims to explore the ethical issues arising from attempts to diversify genomic data and include individuals from underserved groups in studies exploring the relationship between genomics and health. We employed a qualitative synthesis design, combining data from three sources: 1) a rapid review of empirical articles published between 2000 and 2022 with a primary or secondary focus on diversifying genomic data, or the inclusion of underserved groups and ethical issues arising from this, 2) an expert workshop and 3) a narrative review. Using these three sources we found that ethical issues are interconnected across structural factors and research practices. Structural issues include failing to engage with the politics of knowledge production, existing inequities, and their effects on how harms and benefits of genomics are distributed. Issues related to research practices include a lack of reflexivity, exploitative dynamics and the failure to prioritise meaningful co-production. Ethical issues arise from both the structure and the practice of research, which can inhibit researcher and participant opportunities to diversify data in an ethical way. Diverse data are not ethical in and of themselves, and without being attentive to the social, historical and political contexts that shape the lives of potential participants, endeavours to diversify genomic data run the risk of worsening existing inequities. Efforts to construct more representative genomic datasets need to develop ethical approaches that are situated within wider attempts to make the enterprise of genomics more equitable.
- Open Access
- 9 December 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Ethical, Legal and Social Issues in Diversifying Genomic Data: Literature Review and Synthesis
Advances in technology have resulted in the ability to sequence entire human genomes as a routine, relatively inexpensive, investigation in healthcare. This offers many promises of personalising, stratifying, and targeting healthcare with an understanding of genetic susceptibility to particular diseases or conditions. However, research collections (databases, biobanks etc) that underpin these developments are significantly skewed towards populations of European ancestry meaning that our understanding of genetic susceptibility (or indeed of genetic protection to disease) is less good for many other populations in the world. Just as a dermatology text book skewed towards skin problems on white skin may be less useful to black populations, so genomic knowledge derived from one particular ancestry means it may be less useful to people with different ancestries. The need to diversify genomic data, to improve the evidence base for genomic medicine for all ancestries, is well recognised, but is more complex than simply increasing the collection of data from people from a range of ancestries. We reviewed the literature to understand the challenges of diversifying genomic data to identify key ethical, legal and social issues. Our findings were: 1.Many research practices are exclusionary and need to change. Examples include approaches to recruitment or data collection that do not consider the cultural setting in which potential participants are situated. Research also often lacks reflexivity about diversity on the part of researchers and research institutions. 2.Co-design is key to identifying and avoiding potential problems around data diversification. This requires an understanding of the concerns of underserved individuals and communities regarding exploitation and stigmatisation, as well as issues of data ownership and sovereignty. Without attention to group as well as individual concerns, participant engagement may become tokenistic which in turn risks exacerbating existing, as well as creating new, inequalities. 3.There are wider structural issues that influence researchers’ and participants’ attempts to generate diverse data. For example, (a) some researchers view data as neutral, but this ignores the social construction of data and technologies, and their tendencies to reflect societal inequalities. (b). Efforts to diversify data should be contextualised within the historical trajectory of structural racism and legacies of colonialism. (c) Classification and categorisation of populations have political consequences and need to be closely interrogated. These findings show that deliberation between researchers and participants, during all stages of research from planning and recruitment through to analysis, interpretation and dissemination is key to successful diversification.
- 9 December 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessEthical, Legal and Social Issues in Diversifying Genomic Data: Literature Review and Synthesis
Advances in technology have resulted in the ability to sequence entire human genomes as a routine, relatively inexpensive, investigation in healthcare. This offers many promises of personalising, stratifying, and targeting healthcare with an understanding of genetic susceptibility to particular diseases or conditions. However, research collections (databases, biobanks etc) that underpin these developments are significantly skewed towards populations of European ancestry meaning that our understanding of genetic susceptibility (or indeed of genetic protection to disease) is less good for many other populations in the world. Just as a dermatology text book skewed towards skin problems on white skin may be less useful to black populations, so genomic knowledge derived from one particular ancestry means it may be less useful to people with different ancestries. The need to diversify genomic data, to improve the evidence base for genomic medicine for all ancestries, is well recognised, but is more complex than simply increasing the collection of data from people from a range of ancestries. We reviewed the literature to understand the challenges of diversifying genomic data to identify key ethical, legal and social issues. Our findings were: 1.Many research practices are exclusionary and need to change. Examples include approaches to recruitment or data collection that do not consider the cultural setting in which potential participants are situated. Research also often lacks reflexivity about diversity on the part of researchers and research institutions. 2.Co-design is key to identifying and avoiding potential problems around data diversification. This requires an understanding of the concerns of underserved individuals and communities regarding exploitation and stigmatisation, as well as issues of data ownership and sovereignty. Without attention to group as well as individual concerns, participant engagement may become tokenistic which in turn risks exacerbating existing, as well as creating new, inequalities. 3.There are wider structural issues that influence researchers’ and participants’ attempts to generate diverse data. For example, (a) some researchers view data as neutral, but this ignores the social construction of data and technologies, and their tendencies to reflect societal inequalities. (b). Efforts to diversify data should be contextualised within the historical trajectory of structural racism and legacies of colonialism. (c) Classification and categorisation of populations have political consequences and need to be closely interrogated. These findings show that deliberation between researchers and participants, during all stages of research from planning and recruitment through to analysis, interpretation and dissemination is key to successful diversification.