YHYuliia Hartman

Yuliia Hartman

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Yuliia Hartman has a total of 17 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    FEATURES OF EVIDENCE AND PROOF IN CASES CONCERNING COMPENSATION FOR DAMAGE CAUSED BY ARMED AGGRESSION

    by Yuliia Hartman

    Background. Proof is one of the key institutions of civil procedure, as it directly determines whether a court will render a decision in favor of one of the parties and the effective implementation of the adversarial principle. Ukrainian civil procedural legislation establishes the obligation of the parties to prove the circumstances of the case by submitting evidence that is relevant, admissible, reliable, and sufficient. In this context, the standard of proof acquires particular significance as a category that is relatively new to domestic civil procedural scholarship. The relevance of this study is due to the active development of judicial practice in cases concerning compensation for damage caused by the armed aggression of the Russian Federation against Ukraine, which have acquired the characteristics of a distinct category of civil cases. The purpose of the article is to identify the specific features of proof in this category of disputes, taking into account their subject matter of proof and the applicable standard of proof. Methods. The methodological framework of the study is based on general scientific and special legal methods, including analysis, synthesis, comparative legal, and formal legal methods. The research combines a theoretical analysis of doctrinal approaches to the standard of proof in civil proceedings with an empirical study of judicial practice. The study analyzes decisions of courts of first instance in cases where proceedings were initiated after 24 February 2022, using the tools of the Unified State Register of Court Decisions, as well as relevant legal positions of the Supreme Court сформовані after the 2019 reform of the Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine. Results. The study identifies the characteristic features of the subject matter of proof and the means of proof in cases concerning compensation for damage caused by armed aggression. A differentiated approach of the courts to the standard of proof depending on the type of damage has been revealed: the application of a heightened standard of reasonable conviction in cases concerning compensation for material damage, and the standard of greater probability in cases concerning compensation for non-pecuniary (moral) damage. The typical nature of the evidentiary base has been substantiated, which predominantly consists of written and electronic evidence. Conclusions. The analysis of decisions of courts of first instance and the legal positions of the Supreme Court indicates that judicial practice is consistent in the scope and relevance of the evidence required to prove the fact of damage and the causal link between the damage and the event that caused it.

  • Open Access

    From Editors: Artificial Intelligence and Law in a World of Accelerating Change

    by Goda Strikaitė-Latušinskaja, Yuliia Hartman

    This editorial introduction to the AJEE Special Issue on Artificial Intelligence and Law situates current technological developments within a rapidly evolving global environment where the growing use of digital and algorithmic tools intersects with fundamental rights, public governance, and the core functions of justice systems. The text highlights how artificial intelligence (AI) challenges long-standing legal assumptions (about accountability, procedural fairness, and institutional design), while simultaneously offering new opportunities for efficiency, innovation, and access to justice. The contributions to this Special Issue examine these questions across diverse jurisdictions: from Kazakhstan’s emerging AI regulatory framework and the complexities of AI-assisted adjudication to civil-law challenges in Arab legal systems, criminal justice developments in Germany and Ukraine, and evolving digital rights governance in Saudi Arabia. Together, these works underscore that the legal and institutional questions raised by AI cannot be confined to any single discipline or national setting; instead, they require an interdisciplinary, comparative, and human-rights-centred approach attuned to local realities and global standards. This Introduction invites scholars and practitioners to reflect on the conditions under which AI can strengthen, rather than erode, the rule of law and public trust.

  • Open Access

    International Experience of Damages Compensation in Armed Conflicts: Lessons for Ukraine

    by Yuliia Hartman

    Background Access to justice, enshrined as a fundamental human right in international conventions, includes the right to a fair trial and to just compensation. This dimension of justice is particularly crucial in contexts of armed conflict, where victims of military aggression require effective reparation mechanisms. Historically, both judicial and quasi-judicial bodies have been created to address mass claims, from restitution in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Kosovo, and Kuwait to processes in post-authoritarian or post-communist states. Such mechanisms highlight the need for specialised institutions, as ordinary courts are often unable to manage the volume and complexity of conflict-related claims. Since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, reparations have become central to legal and political debate. Methods This study employed an empirical approach, combining systematic data collection with comparative legal analysis. Sources included UN and Council of Europe acts, reports by international organisations (CoE, OSCE), NGO publications, and scholarly works. Three compensation models were examined in depth: the UN Compensation Commission, Kosovo property claims mechanisms, and Bosnia’s Commission for Real Property Claims. These were selected for their effectiveness, European relevance, and addressed harms. Comparative analysis evaluated their procedures, accessibility, and recognition of harm, contrasted with Ukraine’s emerging compensation mechanism. Results The study highlights lessons from the UNCC, Kosovo, and Bosnia, focusing on mandates, procedures, accessibility, and types of harm recognised. It identifies best practices and challenges, offering comparative insights for designing Ukraine’s future compensation system. Conclusions International commissions share key features: defined jurisdiction, politically sensitive and lengthy processes, and reliance on transparent procedures to ensure legitimacy. For Ukraine, enabling direct individual claims is essential to uphold the right to reparation. Yet enforcement challenges and risks of duplicative proceedings remain. Adapting global experience to Ukraine’s context is crucial for developing an effective and trusted compensation mechanism.

  • Open Access

    Stolen Journals: Safeguarding the Integrity of Academic Publishing in Occupied Territories

    by Iryna Izarova, Yuliia Hartman, Victoria Ivanova, Bohdana Zagrebelna, Olena Rachynska, Oleksandr Izarov

    Background Since 2014, and especially following the full-scale invasion in 2022, Ukrainian academic institutions from the temporarily occupied territories have faced systematic violations of their intellectual property rights. Over 50 academic journals originally issued by Ukrainian universities have been appropriated or misused by occupation authorities. While the displaced Ukrainian institutions continue to publish these journals from government-controlled areas, illegal entities have unjustifiably claimed legal succession, often along with the entire historical archives — some spanning over a century. This situation presents multiple threats to the integrity of scholarly communication: (1) Unauthorized use and re-registration of journal titles under Russian law or by unrecognized occupation regimes. (2) Misuse of ISSNs: in some cases, original ISSNs were falsely used; in others, new ISSNs were obtained under false pretenses for stolen journals. (3) Parallel publication: the same journal title appears under different authorities, creating confusion, distorting citation records, and eroding trust in academic metadata systems. (4) Loss of authorship integrity and copyright violations: scholars, unaware of such misuse, risk being associated with compromised publications. Methods To document the issue, we collected detailed records of the affected journals, including original and current ISSN assignments, registration metadata, website analysis, and copyright/ownership information. Additionally, we compared archival data from before and after the occupation, highlighting cases of parallel or false publishing. Our focus was on appropriation patterns and the legal bans on cooperation with these occupying entities. Results Many journals are no longer published by their rightful institutions, while occupation authorities falsely claim editorial and legal continuity. In some cases, archives were repurposed, erasing or rewriting historical publishing records. ISSNs were manipulated — some hijacked journals continue under the same ISSN; others acquired groundless new identifiers. This has led to disinformation in academic indexing systems, undermining the work of genuine editorial teams and deceiving readers and researchers. Solution The International ISSN Centre has responded by introducing new rules for assigning ISSNs to journals from occupied territories. These rules include: (1) An explicit note in the ISSN record detailing the origin and occupation-related status of the title. (2) A distinction between legitimate and illegitimate continuations of the same title. Conclusion The global scholarly community must be informed about these violations: (1) To support legal publishers — the Ukrainian displaced universities; (2) To protect authors and researchers from being misled; (3) To preserve the integrity of the academic record and identifiers; (4) To emphasize the inadmissibility of collaboration with entities established in the temporarily occupied territories. To conclude, this is not just a Ukrainian issue — it is a test for global academic publishing standards, calling for solidarity, vigilance, and institutional transparency.

  • Open Access

    FROM QUANTITY TO QUALITY: EVALUATING SCIENTIFIC WORK OF TERTIARY SCHOOL TEACHERS AND RESEARCHERS

    by Iryna Izarova, Oleksandr Bediukh, Yuliia Hartman, Yuliia Baklazhenko

    The article is dedicated to analyzing modern approaches to evaluating the work of researchers in Europe, with a focus on qualitative indicators that serve as alternatives to traditional quantitative metrics. This research topic was selected in response to the growing number of discussions surrounding the challenges of evaluating scientific work, as well as the rise of initiatives being implemented by leading institutions and universities worldwide. The study examines the impact of initiatives such as the Leiden Manifesto, the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA) of 2012, the Hong Kong Principles, and the Open Science Career Evaluation Matrix (OS-CAM), as well as the European Research Area (ERA), on the development of new criteria for assessing scientific research. Special attention is given to the role of open science and inclusivity in evaluation processes. Additionally, examples of practices adopted by leading European universities and the potential for adapting these approaches in Ukraine are explored. The article emphasizes the importance and promise of qualitative evaluation of research activity, encouraging a shift away from conventional quantitative practices toward more meaningful and impactful assessment methods. The empirical method was employed to collect and analyze relevant information, forming the foundation of the research. An analytical method was also used to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the proposed evaluation practices. Furthermore, a comparative method was applied to investigate the differences between the suggested practices and to assess the effectiveness of each one. As a result of the study, global and national trends in the evaluation of researchers' work were identified, and recommendations were developed for implementing best practices of qualitative evaluation in Ukraine's academic sphere. The findings can be useful for Ukrainian higher education institutions when introducing internal evaluation practices for academic staff, as well as for central executive authorities responsible for shaping state education policy and initiating relevant legislative changes.


  • Open Access

    Procedural Issues in Compensation Cases: Insights from Court Practice in Ukraine

    by Iryna Izarova, Oksana Uhrynovska, Yuliia Hartman

    This chapter delves into the procedural issues encountered in compensation cases arising from the armed aggression of the Russian Federation against Ukraine. It highlights the necessity of restoring violated rights through effective legal mechanisms, particularly focusing on compensation for damages via judicial proceedings. The study examines Ukrainian court practices since 2014, aiming to understand social demands and propose efficient dispute resolution methods. Financial constraints initially hindered justice, with victims reluctant to pay court fees. Legislative changes in 2018 exempted plaintiffs from fees in cases against Russia, prompting increased claims. The text categorizes damages into property and moral losses, detailing subtypes such as real estate forfeiture, loss of profits, and forced displacement. It also addresses the legal intricacies of property mobilization during war and the assessment of moral suffering. Moreover, it discusses the government’s efforts to ascertain damages and losses comprehensively. The paper concludes by emphasizing the importance of substantiating claims and aligning legal precedents with principles of fairness and proportionality. Overall, the paper sheds light on the multifaceted challenges and developments in compensatory procedures amid ongoing conflict.


  • Open Access

    Ecosystem of Ukrainian scientific publications. Harmonisation of editorial practices with international standards. Part 1: Challenges for authors in the scientific and publishing ecosystem

    by Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, Oleksandr Bediukh, Olha Dunaievska, Yuliia Hurtman, Maryna Zhenchenko, Iryna Izarova, Mariia Naumova, Ganna Kharlamova, Ольга Валеріївна Дунаєвська, Ірина Олександрівна Ізарова, et al.

    The first section focuses on the effectiveness of communication in the subsystem ‘author - journal editorial board’, conducting content analysis of the accessibility of journals with a high impact factor. ‘Accessibility’ in our content means the clarity and comprehensibility of the requirements for manuscript submission and the criteria for assessing their quality. The second section analyses in detail the global and European initiatives and European initiatives, university programmes to introduce systemic changes in the evaluation of researchers' work, in particular, the Leiden Manifesto 2015, the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment 2012, the Hong Kong Principles 2019, the Open Science Career Assessment Matrix 2017, the Coalition for the Advancement of Research Assessment 2022, etc. and proposed generalised criteria for researcher performance assessment based on the results of the monitoring analysis of European practices criteria for evaluating the work of researchers. The third section is devoted to the important topic of determining the costs of authors for publication in open access journals. It describes different business models for publishing scientific journals in open access journals, models of payment for scientific articles; descriptive statistics on the amount of publication fees in Ukrainian scientific journals of category A; the ways of financial financial support for researchers to pay for articles, etc. In the fourth section, based on the analysis of the practices of moral and financial incentives for researchers to prepare quality research and publish it in highly rated journals, the main trends and models of moral and financial incentives for publication activity in foreign and Ukrainian universities. The methodological materials (Appendices 1-2) are of great practical importance for authors and editors of scientific journals.


  • Open Access

    COMPENSATION FOR DAMAGES CAUSED BY WAR: INVESTIGATING THE ISSUE USING THE EXAMPLE OF ARMED AGGRESSION BY THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AGAINST UKRAINE

    by Iryna Izarova, Oksana Uhrynovska, Yuliia Hartman

    Вступ. Війна завдає значних руйнувань, і в цьому випадку йдеться як про майнові втрати, так і про життя та здоров'я звичайних громадян. Збитки, яких зазнала Україна та її громадяни протягом років окупації територій і війни, обраховуються в мільярдах, хоча важко остаточно визначити як методологію розрахунків, так і конкретні цифри. Для відновлення справедливості є набагато важливішим створити справедливу, прозору та зрозумілу процедуру компенсації збитків, завданих громадянам і підприємствам унаслідок цих подій. Це особливо важливо в контексті необхідності реалізації цілей сталого розвитку, зокрема й забезпечення рівного доступу до правосуддя для всіх. Статтю присвячено цим і пов'язаним питанням. Методи. Для розроблення процедури відшкодування втрат і збитків, завданих війною, спочатку ми визначили, що саме може бути компенсовано та хто може подати заяву про відшкодування. Ці й інші фактори визначають особливості процедури відновлення прав і відшкодування шкоди, завданої війною в Україні. Під час пошуку відповіді на це питання ми проаналізували чинне законодавство України та проєкти законів, запропоновані для регулювання відносин, пов'язаних із компенсацією збитків. Також був проведений комплексний аналіз понять, таких як втрати, збитки, компенсація, репарації та відшкодування, які визначені в національному законодавстві та міжнародних угодах. Узагальнення судової практики національних судів (понад 250 проаналізованих рішень судів першої та апеляційної і касаційної інстанцій за період із 20 лютого 2014 р. по 1 вересня 2023 р., приклади яких наведені в дослідженні) свідчить про наявність різних підходів до відшкодування шкоди та розуміння того, як відновити порушені права громадян. Результати. Для розроблення шляхів можливого врегулюння цих проблем був проведений аналіз досвіду країн, що стикалися зі схожими подіями. Особливу увагу приділено практиці Європейського суду з прав людини, що має вирішальне значення для України (рішення у справах про компенсацію збитків, завданих окупацією). Висновки. У висновку пропонуємо визначити підходи до застосування інститутів компенсації та компенсування втрат і збитків, узгоджуючи їх із міжнародними підходами, а також відповідно до очікувань суспільства для визначення найефективніших форм захисту таких прав на основі визначених критеріїв.


  • Open Access

    ADOPTION DURING THE WAR IN UKRAINE: HOW NOT TO LOSE A CHILD

    by Yuliia Hartman

    Summary: 1. Introduction: children amid war in Ukraine. – 2. Information on children who suffered as a result of full- scale military operations. – 3. Legal mechanisms for ensuring the rights of children who were left without parental care during the war in Ukraine – 3.1. Reunification of adoptive parents with an adopted child. – 3.2. Transferring processes from placement of children to a digital format. – 3.3. Conditions for adoption and registration of children during martial law. – 3.4. Registration of candidates for adopters. – 3.5. Entities that can be adopters. – 3.6. Institute of Temporary Placement of Children in Ukraine. – 3.7. Institute of guardianship and care during martial law. – 3.8. Procedure for trial of adoption cases. – 3.9. National control mechanisms for displaced children. – 3.10. Foreign experience regarding the problem of “children of war”. – 4. Conclusions.