Tim Clarke
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Tim Clarke has a total of 55 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jon Wilson
Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust
5 shared publications - Brioney Gee
Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust
4 shared publications - David Turner
Norwich Medical School, University of East Anglia, Norwich, UK
3 shared publications - Jamie Murdoch
School of Life Course and Population Sciences, King’s College London, London, UK
3 shared publications - Allan Clark
Norwich Medical School, University of East Anglia, Norwich, UK
2 shared publications - Andrew Laphan
Research and Development, Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust, Norwich, UK
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 29 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties
- Vol. 31 (1) , 93-109
Evaluating the implementation of a novel approach to increasing access to evidence-based treatment for child anxiety difficulties through enhancing collaboration between the health and education systems
- 29 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties
- Vol. 31 (1) , 93-109
Evaluating the implementation of a novel approach to increasing access to evidence-based treatment for child anxiety difficulties through enhancing collaboration between the health and education systems
- Open Access
- 25 August 2025
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Innovations
Facilitating innovation in healthcare: insights from the frontline of adoption
Innovation has long shaped healthcare but the art of adopting innovation remains a challenge. In the UK’s National Health Service (NHS), a system founded on the principles of continuous improvement and equitable care, the ability to adopt and spread innovation is essential for delivering better patient outcomes, improving efficiency and addressing evolving health needs. Despite a multitude of frameworks, barriers remain entrenched for those who facilitate adoption. As part of work to develop a toolkit on innovative organisational culture, the NHS InInSites (Innovation Sites) programme sought to understand the optimal determinants of successful innovation adoption from the perspective of those facilitating the process. What do those who facilitate innovation in publicly-funded healthcare systems think are the key factors in successful adoption? Through a qualitative analysis of 27 survey responses from staff working in innovation roles, this work examined what enables successful adoption of innovations, beyond the barriers and challenges that are often cited. Seven common themes arose: engagement and support from clinicians and other stakeholders; sufficient (and ring-fenced) funding; support from senior leaders; tangible impact; clear innovation need; practical enablers and a supportive culture. A number of key learnings and tensions or contradictions were outlined, including the challenge of yearly funding cycles and siloed funding pots hindering longer-term impact. It appears that in publicly-funded healthcare systems, like the NHS, financial and structural enablers have greater significance for driving adoption than individual factors. As such, future efforts to promote innovation within such systems should focus on delivering sustained funding, aligning policy and processes and fostering more supportive organisational culture to accelerate innovation adoption.
- 25 August 2025
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Innovations
Open AccessFacilitating innovation in healthcare: insights from the frontline of adoption
Innovation has long shaped healthcare but the art of adopting innovation remains a challenge. In the UK’s National Health Service (NHS), a system founded on the principles of continuous improvement and equitable care, the ability to adopt and spread innovation is essential for delivering better patient outcomes, improving efficiency and addressing evolving health needs. Despite a multitude of frameworks, barriers remain entrenched for those who facilitate adoption. As part of work to develop a toolkit on innovative organisational culture, the NHS InInSites (Innovation Sites) programme sought to understand the optimal determinants of successful innovation adoption from the perspective of those facilitating the process. What do those who facilitate innovation in publicly-funded healthcare systems think are the key factors in successful adoption? Through a qualitative analysis of 27 survey responses from staff working in innovation roles, this work examined what enables successful adoption of innovations, beyond the barriers and challenges that are often cited. Seven common themes arose: engagement and support from clinicians and other stakeholders; sufficient (and ring-fenced) funding; support from senior leaders; tangible impact; clear innovation need; practical enablers and a supportive culture. A number of key learnings and tensions or contradictions were outlined, including the challenge of yearly funding cycles and siloed funding pots hindering longer-term impact. It appears that in publicly-funded healthcare systems, like the NHS, financial and structural enablers have greater significance for driving adoption than individual factors. As such, future efforts to promote innovation within such systems should focus on delivering sustained funding, aligning policy and processes and fostering more supportive organisational culture to accelerate innovation adoption.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2024
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health Technology Assessment
- p. 1-26
Energetic activity for depression in young people aged 13–17 years: the READY feasibility RCT
Background: Prevalence of depression is increasing in young people. Behaviour change interventions providing benefits equal to or greater than talking therapies or pharmacological alternatives are needed. Exercise could be beneficial for young people with depression, but we lack robust trials of its effectiveness. Objective: To test whether an exercise intervention targeting young people with depression is feasible, including recruitment and retention of young people, recruitment and training of exercise professionals and intervention delivery. Design: Three-arm cluster feasibility randomised controlled trial with embedded process evaluation and health economic data collection. Setting: Local community venues in Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and Norfolk. Participants: Young people aged 13–17 years experiencing mild to moderate low mood or depression (indicated by scoring 17–36 on the Child Depression Inventory version 2) identified by mental health services, schools or self-referral. Interventions: Participants were randomised to one of three groups: high-intensity exercise, low-intensity exercise or a social activity control. Group sessions ran twice-weekly for 12 weeks delivered by registered exercise professionals, supported by mental health support workers. Main outcome measures: Referral, recruitment and retention rates; attendance at group sessions; adherence to and ability to reach intensity during exercise sessions; proportions of missing data, and adverse events measured at baseline and at 3 and 6 months; resource use; and reach and representativeness. Results: Of 321 referrals to the study, 173 were assessed for eligibility, and of the target sample size of 81, 15 were recruited and 14 were randomised (one withdrew). The retention rate was 71.4% and attendance at intervention sessions was > 67%; data completeness was > 80% for baseline assessments. Follow-up completion rate at 14 weeks was > 80% for most outcomes, with 50% for accelerometer data in the low-intensity group. Trial processes and the intervention were acceptable to young people. Barriers to and facilitators of intervention delivery were identified. Limitations: Findings highlighted challenges around recruitment, delivery of exercise interventions and informed ways of addressing barriers to recruitment for future studies. The study was conducted between October 2020 and August 2022 and consequently the COVID-19 pandemic had a disruptive impact on implementation. Conclusions: A large randomised trial of the effectiveness of the intervention is not feasible using the current study design, but issues relating to recruitment could be addressed with further work. Future work: Developing appropriate recruitment strategies via triage services, general practitioner practices, schools and social media and early engagement with the local Clinical Research Network to support recruitment to the study would address the significant shortfalls identified. Young people who are deemed unsuitable for mental health services should be followed up to be offered participation in such interventions. Collaborations between the NHS services and sports delivery partners should consider in-person contact with young people rather than remote consultations. Recruiting through general practitioner practices is effective and relatively inexpensive. The role of community engagement (socialmedia, public health agencies, community groups) needs to be further explored. Strong public and patient involvement and engagement via young people advisory groups is important to ensure that research is relevant to young people. Funding: This article presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme as award number 17/78/10.
- 1 December 2024
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health Technology Assessment
- p. 1-26
Open AccessEnergetic activity for depression in young people aged 13–17 years: the READY feasibility RCT
Background: Prevalence of depression is increasing in young people. Behaviour change interventions providing benefits equal to or greater than talking therapies or pharmacological alternatives are needed. Exercise could be beneficial for young people with depression, but we lack robust trials of its effectiveness. Objective: To test whether an exercise intervention targeting young people with depression is feasible, including recruitment and retention of young people, recruitment and training of exercise professionals and intervention delivery. Design: Three-arm cluster feasibility randomised controlled trial with embedded process evaluation and health economic data collection. Setting: Local community venues in Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and Norfolk. Participants: Young people aged 13–17 years experiencing mild to moderate low mood or depression (indicated by scoring 17–36 on the Child Depression Inventory version 2) identified by mental health services, schools or self-referral. Interventions: Participants were randomised to one of three groups: high-intensity exercise, low-intensity exercise or a social activity control. Group sessions ran twice-weekly for 12 weeks delivered by registered exercise professionals, supported by mental health support workers. Main outcome measures: Referral, recruitment and retention rates; attendance at group sessions; adherence to and ability to reach intensity during exercise sessions; proportions of missing data, and adverse events measured at baseline and at 3 and 6 months; resource use; and reach and representativeness. Results: Of 321 referrals to the study, 173 were assessed for eligibility, and of the target sample size of 81, 15 were recruited and 14 were randomised (one withdrew). The retention rate was 71.4% and attendance at intervention sessions was > 67%; data completeness was > 80% for baseline assessments. Follow-up completion rate at 14 weeks was > 80% for most outcomes, with 50% for accelerometer data in the low-intensity group. Trial processes and the intervention were acceptable to young people. Barriers to and facilitators of intervention delivery were identified. Limitations: Findings highlighted challenges around recruitment, delivery of exercise interventions and informed ways of addressing barriers to recruitment for future studies. The study was conducted between October 2020 and August 2022 and consequently the COVID-19 pandemic had a disruptive impact on implementation. Conclusions: A large randomised trial of the effectiveness of the intervention is not feasible using the current study design, but issues relating to recruitment could be addressed with further work. Future work: Developing appropriate recruitment strategies via triage services, general practitioner practices, schools and social media and early engagement with the local Clinical Research Network to support recruitment to the study would address the significant shortfalls identified. Young people who are deemed unsuitable for mental health services should be followed up to be offered participation in such interventions. Collaborations between the NHS services and sports delivery partners should consider in-person contact with young people rather than remote consultations. Recruiting through general practitioner practices is effective and relatively inexpensive. The role of community engagement (socialmedia, public health agencies, community groups) needs to be further explored. Strong public and patient involvement and engagement via young people advisory groups is important to ensure that research is relevant to young people. Funding: This article presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme as award number 17/78/10.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2024
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 12 (48) , 1-121
Interpersonal counselling for adolescent depression delivered by youth mental health workers without core professional training: the ICALM feasibility RCT
Background: As milder cases of adolescent depression do not meet treatment thresholds for specialist mental health services, young people often receive support from non-qualified professionals in third-sector/voluntary agencies. Early psychological interventions to meet growing demand with limited resources are crucial. Objectives: The study aimed to explore the effectiveness and cost effectiveness of interpersonal counselling for adolescents by (1) assessing the feasibility and acceptability of trial procedures; (2) exploring the delivery of, and differences between, interpersonal counselling for adolescents and treatment as usual; (3) evaluating the extent of contamination of the control arm and if it should be mitigated against in a future trial; and (4) investigating whether the interval estimate of benefit of interpersonal counselling for adolescents over treatment as usual in depression post treatment includes a clinically significant effect. Design: This was a feasibility randomised controlled trial. Non-qualified professionals from non-specialist mental health services received interpersonal counselling for adolescent training. Participants were randomised to receive either interpersonal counselling for adolescents plus treatment as usual or treatment as usual only. Assessments occurred at baseline and were followed up at weeks 5, 10 and 23. A health economics component was included to inform the design of the economic evaluation in a future study. A process evaluation examined implementation of the intervention across settings, acceptability and contamination. Interviews, observations and focus groups were analysed using thematic analysis. Session recordings were analysed using conversation analysis. Setting: The trial was conducted in 13 non-speicialist mental health services across Norfolk and Suffolk. Participants: Help-seeking adolescents aged 12–18 years with mild depression as the primary difficulty were eligible to participate. Comorbid presentations were not an exclusion criterion. Of a target of 60, 16 participants were randomised, and 2 participants withdrew following study suspensions related to COVID-19. Of the remaining 14 participants, 7 received an intervention, with 3 receiving interpersonal counselling for adolescents and 4 receiving treatment as usual. The rest either disengaged, withdrew or were signposted. Interventions: Participants were randomised to receive either interpersonal counselling for adolescents plus treatment as usual or treatment as usual only. Main outcome measures: The primary outcome was the Revised Children’s Anxiety and Depression Scale, although the proposed study was not designed to assess efficacy. The primary output of the feasibility trial was to design a subsequent full-scale trial. Results: Feasibility outcomes did not meet the estimated progression criteria. Despite efforts to increase referrals, the 80% recruitment rate was not achieved. Interpersonal counselling for adolescents' attendance rates at 10 weeks were less than the 70% progression criteria estimation, impacting intervention feasibility. Retention was high, with 85.7% of participants reaching 23-week follow-up. The health economic measures appeared to perform well and were completed. Implementation and theoretical fidelity of interpersonal counselling for adolescents were analysed from four participant recordings. Adherence to the principles of interpersonal counselling for adolescents was identified, with 100% satisfactory fidelity and no indication of contamination in the control arm. The two interventions were clinically non-significant due to the study being underpowered. Limitations: The feasibility of the randomised controlled trial was impacted by COVID-19. Services had to change standard practices, disrupting trial procedures. Challenges were identified when implementing a randomised controlled trial in non-specialist services. Conclusions: Findings indicate a randomised controlled trial of interpersonal counselling for adolescents in non-specialist services is not feasible, yet the data collection and outcome measures were suitable. COVID-19 challenges, sites’ lack of familiarity with research procedures and the research team’s unfamiliarity with how different early intervention services operate led to challenges. High staff shortages, turnover and inconsistent training could have been considered. This study demonstrated the difficulties in conducting a randomised controlled trial in this service setting. Further work is needed to improve the feasibility of conducting such trials before they are attempted in future. Trial registration: This trial is registered as ISRCTN82180413. Funding: This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme (NIHR award ref: 17/112/16) and is published in full in Health and Social Care Delivery Research; Vol. 12, No. 48. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information.
- 1 December 2024
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 12 (48) , 1-121
Open AccessInterpersonal counselling for adolescent depression delivered by youth mental health workers without core professional training: the ICALM feasibility RCT
Background: As milder cases of adolescent depression do not meet treatment thresholds for specialist mental health services, young people often receive support from non-qualified professionals in third-sector/voluntary agencies. Early psychological interventions to meet growing demand with limited resources are crucial. Objectives: The study aimed to explore the effectiveness and cost effectiveness of interpersonal counselling for adolescents by (1) assessing the feasibility and acceptability of trial procedures; (2) exploring the delivery of, and differences between, interpersonal counselling for adolescents and treatment as usual; (3) evaluating the extent of contamination of the control arm and if it should be mitigated against in a future trial; and (4) investigating whether the interval estimate of benefit of interpersonal counselling for adolescents over treatment as usual in depression post treatment includes a clinically significant effect. Design: This was a feasibility randomised controlled trial. Non-qualified professionals from non-specialist mental health services received interpersonal counselling for adolescent training. Participants were randomised to receive either interpersonal counselling for adolescents plus treatment as usual or treatment as usual only. Assessments occurred at baseline and were followed up at weeks 5, 10 and 23. A health economics component was included to inform the design of the economic evaluation in a future study. A process evaluation examined implementation of the intervention across settings, acceptability and contamination. Interviews, observations and focus groups were analysed using thematic analysis. Session recordings were analysed using conversation analysis. Setting: The trial was conducted in 13 non-speicialist mental health services across Norfolk and Suffolk. Participants: Help-seeking adolescents aged 12–18 years with mild depression as the primary difficulty were eligible to participate. Comorbid presentations were not an exclusion criterion. Of a target of 60, 16 participants were randomised, and 2 participants withdrew following study suspensions related to COVID-19. Of the remaining 14 participants, 7 received an intervention, with 3 receiving interpersonal counselling for adolescents and 4 receiving treatment as usual. The rest either disengaged, withdrew or were signposted. Interventions: Participants were randomised to receive either interpersonal counselling for adolescents plus treatment as usual or treatment as usual only. Main outcome measures: The primary outcome was the Revised Children’s Anxiety and Depression Scale, although the proposed study was not designed to assess efficacy. The primary output of the feasibility trial was to design a subsequent full-scale trial. Results: Feasibility outcomes did not meet the estimated progression criteria. Despite efforts to increase referrals, the 80% recruitment rate was not achieved. Interpersonal counselling for adolescents' attendance rates at 10 weeks were less than the 70% progression criteria estimation, impacting intervention feasibility. Retention was high, with 85.7% of participants reaching 23-week follow-up. The health economic measures appeared to perform well and were completed. Implementation and theoretical fidelity of interpersonal counselling for adolescents were analysed from four participant recordings. Adherence to the principles of interpersonal counselling for adolescents was identified, with 100% satisfactory fidelity and no indication of contamination in the control arm. The two interventions were clinically non-significant due to the study being underpowered. Limitations: The feasibility of the randomised controlled trial was impacted by COVID-19. Services had to change standard practices, disrupting trial procedures. Challenges were identified when implementing a randomised controlled trial in non-specialist services. Conclusions: Findings indicate a randomised controlled trial of interpersonal counselling for adolescents in non-specialist services is not feasible, yet the data collection and outcome measures were suitable. COVID-19 challenges, sites’ lack of familiarity with research procedures and the research team’s unfamiliarity with how different early intervention services operate led to challenges. High staff shortages, turnover and inconsistent training could have been considered. This study demonstrated the difficulties in conducting a randomised controlled trial in this service setting. Further work is needed to improve the feasibility of conducting such trials before they are attempted in future. Trial registration: This trial is registered as ISRCTN82180413. Funding: This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme (NIHR award ref: 17/112/16) and is published in full in Health and Social Care Delivery Research; Vol. 12, No. 48. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information.
- Open Access
- 22 October 2024
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Mental Health
- Vol. 11 (1) , e52866
Outcomes of Providing Children Aged 7-12 Years With Access to Evidence-Based Anxiety Treatment Via a Standalone Digital Intervention Using Immersive Gaming Technology: Real-World Evaluation
Background: Anxiety disorders are among the most common mental health conditions in childhood, but most children with anxiety disorders do not access evidence-based interventions. The delivery of therapeutic interventions via digital technologies has been proposed to significantly increase timely access to evidence-based treatment. Lumi Nova (BfB Labs Limited) is a digital therapeutic intervention designed to deliver evidence-based anxiety treatment for those aged 7‐12 years through a mobile app incorporating immersive gaming technology. Objective: We aimed to evaluate the real-world impact of providing access to Lumi Nova through UK National Health Service–funded mental health services. Methods: We analyzed precollected anonymized data routinely captured through the implementation of Lumi Nova from children aged 7‐12 years, who lived in the United Kingdom and had the opportunity to use the intervention for at least 1 week over an 18-month period. Engagement indices included whether the game key was activated, number of unique sessions, time spent engaging, and number of “challenges” completed. Clinical outcomes were assessed using the Goal-Based Outcomes measure and Child Outcome Rating Scale. Demographic data were analyzed to assess the health equality implications of Lumi Nova. Results: Of 1029 eligible families invited to use Lumi Nova, 644 (62.5%) activated their game key, of whom 374 (58.1%) completed at least one in-game graded exposure challenge. The median number of unique sessions was 6 (IQR 3‐12) and the median time spent engaging with the intervention was 42 (IQR 15‐79) minutes. For the subset of young people with paired outcomes, there were statistically significant small to medium improvements in goal-based outcome scores (n=224; t223=5.78, P<.001; d=0.37, 95% CI 0.25‐0.52) and Child Outcome Rating Scale scores (n=123; t122=5.10, P<.001; d=0.46, 95% CI 0.27‐0.65) between the first and last data points. Two in 5 young people’s scores reflected a change that would be considered reliable. Analysis of demographic characteristics tentatively suggested that children from ethnic minority backgrounds and those living in the most deprived neighbourhoods may be less likely to access Lumi Nova, but children from socioeconomically deprived areas were more likely to successfully complete a challenge once they accessed the intervention (P=.02). However, the level of missing data and small number of children in some demographic groups limited meaningful statistical comparisons. Conclusions: This study provides initial evidence that Lumi Nova may be associated with improved outcomes for those aged 7‐12 years seeking anxiety treatment in real-world settings. However, the lack of a control comparator group and information about concurrent treatments accessed by the young people, in addition to substantial attrition, limited the analysis that could be conducted and confidence in the conclusions drawn.
- 22 October 2024
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Mental Health
- Vol. 11 (1) , e52866
Open AccessOutcomes of Providing Children Aged 7-12 Years With Access to Evidence-Based Anxiety Treatment Via a Standalone Digital Intervention Using Immersive Gaming Technology: Real-World Evaluation
Background: Anxiety disorders are among the most common mental health conditions in childhood, but most children with anxiety disorders do not access evidence-based interventions. The delivery of therapeutic interventions via digital technologies has been proposed to significantly increase timely access to evidence-based treatment. Lumi Nova (BfB Labs Limited) is a digital therapeutic intervention designed to deliver evidence-based anxiety treatment for those aged 7‐12 years through a mobile app incorporating immersive gaming technology. Objective: We aimed to evaluate the real-world impact of providing access to Lumi Nova through UK National Health Service–funded mental health services. Methods: We analyzed precollected anonymized data routinely captured through the implementation of Lumi Nova from children aged 7‐12 years, who lived in the United Kingdom and had the opportunity to use the intervention for at least 1 week over an 18-month period. Engagement indices included whether the game key was activated, number of unique sessions, time spent engaging, and number of “challenges” completed. Clinical outcomes were assessed using the Goal-Based Outcomes measure and Child Outcome Rating Scale. Demographic data were analyzed to assess the health equality implications of Lumi Nova. Results: Of 1029 eligible families invited to use Lumi Nova, 644 (62.5%) activated their game key, of whom 374 (58.1%) completed at least one in-game graded exposure challenge. The median number of unique sessions was 6 (IQR 3‐12) and the median time spent engaging with the intervention was 42 (IQR 15‐79) minutes. For the subset of young people with paired outcomes, there were statistically significant small to medium improvements in goal-based outcome scores (n=224; t223=5.78, P<.001; d=0.37, 95% CI 0.25‐0.52) and Child Outcome Rating Scale scores (n=123; t122=5.10, P<.001; d=0.46, 95% CI 0.27‐0.65) between the first and last data points. Two in 5 young people’s scores reflected a change that would be considered reliable. Analysis of demographic characteristics tentatively suggested that children from ethnic minority backgrounds and those living in the most deprived neighbourhoods may be less likely to access Lumi Nova, but children from socioeconomically deprived areas were more likely to successfully complete a challenge once they accessed the intervention (P=.02). However, the level of missing data and small number of children in some demographic groups limited meaningful statistical comparisons. Conclusions: This study provides initial evidence that Lumi Nova may be associated with improved outcomes for those aged 7‐12 years seeking anxiety treatment in real-world settings. However, the lack of a control comparator group and information about concurrent treatments accessed by the young people, in addition to substantial attrition, limited the analysis that could be conducted and confidence in the conclusions drawn.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2022
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 10 (37) , 1-112
Brief education supported psychological treatment for adolescent borderline personality disorder: the BEST feasibility RCT
Background: Borderline personality disorder is a severe mental health condition characterised by a pattern of emotional instability, interpersonal dysfunction, disturbed self-image and impulsive behaviour, including self-harm. Symptoms of borderline personality disorder typically emerge during adolescence. Although there is compelling evidence in support of early intervention for borderline personality disorder, current evidence-based interventions are resource intensive, with the result that few young people access timely treatment. Therefore, there is an urgent need for accessible interventions to facilitate early intervention for adolescents with borderline personality disorder symptoms.Objectives: The first objective was to adapt a brief psychological treatment for adolescent borderline personality disorder that had previously been delivered within secondary mental health services for co-delivery within schools and colleges. The second objective was to assess the feasibility of evaluating the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of this intervention in a future randomised controlled trial.Design: We first conducted a rapid evidence synthesis of barriers to and facilitators of the implementation of indicated mental health interventions for adolescents within educational settings and piloted the prototype intervention with three schools/colleges. Based on the findings of the evidence synthesis and pilot, we refined the intervention and study procedures in preparation for a feasibility randomised controlled trial. The feasibility randomised controlled trial involved 12 schools and colleges, whose pastoral staff members received training to deliver the intervention alongside a mental health practitioner. Participants were randomised in a 1 : 1 ratio to receive either the BEST (Brief Education Supported Treatment) intervention plus treatment as usual or treatment as usual alone. Participants were assessed pre randomisation (baseline) and at 12 and 24 weeks post randomisation. Mixed-methods process data were collected to understand how the intervention was implemented, to assess acceptability and to monitor contamination of the control arm.Participants: Young people eligible to participate were aged 13–18 years, reported symptoms of borderline personality disorder above an established threshold and had a history of repeated self-harm.Results: The intervention was refined based on findings of the rapid evidence synthesis, which included 50 studies, feedback from staff participants in the pilot and analysis of session recordings. In the feasibility randomised controlled trial, we randomised 32 participants prior to the premature closure of recruitment. The rate of recruitment was slower than anticipated but would probably have narrowly surpassed our progression criterion over the full recruitment window. Participant retention was high (89.5% at 12 weeks and 73.7% at 24 weeks) and the performance of the proposed outcome measures was satisfactory. We did not find any evidence that participants allocated to the treatment-as-usual arm received the BEST intervention or its components. Fidelity of intervention delivery was high (93.5% of recordings rated as adherent) and the intervention was viewed as offering benefits for individual participants, practitioners involved in co-delivery and the wider school/college.Limitations: The feasibility randomised controlled trial was disrupted by the closure of schools and colleges in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. This reduced the window for participant recruitment and limited the data that could be collected.Conclusions: The refined BEST intervention was able to be delivered successfully within schools and colleges and was found to be acceptable to staff and young people. The findings provide support for continuing this programme of research and would inform the design of a future trial.Trial registration: This trial is registered as ISRCTN16862589.Funding: This project was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme and will be published in full inHealth and Social Care Delivery Research; Vol. 10, No. 37. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project information.
- 1 December 2022
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 10 (37) , 1-112
Open AccessBrief education supported psychological treatment for adolescent borderline personality disorder: the BEST feasibility RCT
Background: Borderline personality disorder is a severe mental health condition characterised by a pattern of emotional instability, interpersonal dysfunction, disturbed self-image and impulsive behaviour, including self-harm. Symptoms of borderline personality disorder typically emerge during adolescence. Although there is compelling evidence in support of early intervention for borderline personality disorder, current evidence-based interventions are resource intensive, with the result that few young people access timely treatment. Therefore, there is an urgent need for accessible interventions to facilitate early intervention for adolescents with borderline personality disorder symptoms.Objectives: The first objective was to adapt a brief psychological treatment for adolescent borderline personality disorder that had previously been delivered within secondary mental health services for co-delivery within schools and colleges. The second objective was to assess the feasibility of evaluating the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of this intervention in a future randomised controlled trial.Design: We first conducted a rapid evidence synthesis of barriers to and facilitators of the implementation of indicated mental health interventions for adolescents within educational settings and piloted the prototype intervention with three schools/colleges. Based on the findings of the evidence synthesis and pilot, we refined the intervention and study procedures in preparation for a feasibility randomised controlled trial. The feasibility randomised controlled trial involved 12 schools and colleges, whose pastoral staff members received training to deliver the intervention alongside a mental health practitioner. Participants were randomised in a 1 : 1 ratio to receive either the BEST (Brief Education Supported Treatment) intervention plus treatment as usual or treatment as usual alone. Participants were assessed pre randomisation (baseline) and at 12 and 24 weeks post randomisation. Mixed-methods process data were collected to understand how the intervention was implemented, to assess acceptability and to monitor contamination of the control arm.Participants: Young people eligible to participate were aged 13–18 years, reported symptoms of borderline personality disorder above an established threshold and had a history of repeated self-harm.Results: The intervention was refined based on findings of the rapid evidence synthesis, which included 50 studies, feedback from staff participants in the pilot and analysis of session recordings. In the feasibility randomised controlled trial, we randomised 32 participants prior to the premature closure of recruitment. The rate of recruitment was slower than anticipated but would probably have narrowly surpassed our progression criterion over the full recruitment window. Participant retention was high (89.5% at 12 weeks and 73.7% at 24 weeks) and the performance of the proposed outcome measures was satisfactory. We did not find any evidence that participants allocated to the treatment-as-usual arm received the BEST intervention or its components. Fidelity of intervention delivery was high (93.5% of recordings rated as adherent) and the intervention was viewed as offering benefits for individual participants, practitioners involved in co-delivery and the wider school/college.Limitations: The feasibility randomised controlled trial was disrupted by the closure of schools and colleges in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. This reduced the window for participant recruitment and limited the data that could be collected.Conclusions: The refined BEST intervention was able to be delivered successfully within schools and colleges and was found to be acceptable to staff and young people. The findings provide support for continuing this programme of research and would inform the design of a future trial.Trial registration: This trial is registered as ISRCTN16862589.Funding: This project was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme and will be published in full inHealth and Social Care Delivery Research; Vol. 10, No. 37. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project information.
- 24 October 2022
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Public Mental Health
- Vol. 21 (4) , 303-308
A child and adult psychiatrist discussion on the development of a youth mental health service
Purpose: Young people can often “fall through the gaps” between Child and Adolescent Mental Health services (CAMHS) and Adult Mental Health services (AMHS). This discursive viewpoint study aims to reflect a conversation among the authors on how CAMHS and AMHS psychiatry came together to develop and embed a UK community “Youth Mental Health Service”. Design/methodology/approach: This reflective viewpoint study explores the perspectives of three of the lead CAMHS and AMHS psychiatrists from the implementation phase of a community youth mental health service. It explores, in a discursive way, these individuals’ views on some of the key facilitators and barriers in the development of the service that aimed to “bridge the gap” for young people. Findings: These clinicians’ reflections recognise the importance of strong clinical leadership in enabling a youth/young adult model of mental health to be implemented. They also recognise how culture internal and external to a service has a key role to play in the success and sustainment of implementing an innovative model. This study describes a merging of CAMHS and AMHS psychiatry to meet the needs of young people in the most developmentally appropriate way. Originality/value: This reflective study highlights the need for services and systems to think creatively about how they can allow flexibility for CAMHS and AMHS psychiatrists to learn and plan together, as well as gain experiences across the age ranges, to facilitate collaborative working that is developmentally appropriate and meets the needs of young people in a way that is accessible to them.
- 24 October 2022
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Public Mental Health
- Vol. 21 (4) , 303-308
A child and adult psychiatrist discussion on the development of a youth mental health service
Purpose: Young people can often “fall through the gaps” between Child and Adolescent Mental Health services (CAMHS) and Adult Mental Health services (AMHS). This discursive viewpoint study aims to reflect a conversation among the authors on how CAMHS and AMHS psychiatry came together to develop and embed a UK community “Youth Mental Health Service”. Design/methodology/approach: This reflective viewpoint study explores the perspectives of three of the lead CAMHS and AMHS psychiatrists from the implementation phase of a community youth mental health service. It explores, in a discursive way, these individuals’ views on some of the key facilitators and barriers in the development of the service that aimed to “bridge the gap” for young people. Findings: These clinicians’ reflections recognise the importance of strong clinical leadership in enabling a youth/young adult model of mental health to be implemented. They also recognise how culture internal and external to a service has a key role to play in the success and sustainment of implementing an innovative model. This study describes a merging of CAMHS and AMHS psychiatry to meet the needs of young people in the most developmentally appropriate way. Originality/value: This reflective study highlights the need for services and systems to think creatively about how they can allow flexibility for CAMHS and AMHS psychiatrists to learn and plan together, as well as gain experiences across the age ranges, to facilitate collaborative working that is developmentally appropriate and meets the needs of young people in a way that is accessible to them.