Víctor Altés
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Víctor Altés has a total of 36 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Olivier Merlin
9 shared publications- Anaïs Barella-Ortiz
Observatori de l’Ebre, Universitat Ramon Llull – CSIC, Roquetes, Spain
7 shared publications - Pere Quintana-Seguí
Observatori de l’Ebre, Ramon Llull University–CSIC, Roquetes, Spain
7 shared publications - Vincent Rivalland
Centre d’Etudes Spatiales de la Biosphère (CESBIO), Toulouse, 31400, France
7 shared publications - Julien Tournebize
Université Paris-Saclay, INRAE, HYCAR Research Unit
6 shared publications Luis Olivera-Guerra
Centre d'Etudes Spatiales de la Biosphère (CESBIO), Université de Toulouse, CNES, CNRS, IRD, UPS, Toulouse, France
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Retrieving the irrigation actually applied at district scale: assimilating high-resolution Sentinel-1-derived soil moisture data into a FAO-56-based model
Irrigation is the most water consuming activity in the world. Knowing the timing and amount of irrigation that is actually applied is therefore fundamental for water managers. However, this information is rarely available at all scales and is subject to large uncertainties due to the wide variety of existing agricultural practices and associated irrigation regimes (full irrigation, deficit irrigation, or over-irrigation). To fill this gap, we propose a two-step approach based on 15 m resolution Sentinel-1 (S1) surface soil moisture (SSM) data to retrieve the actual irrigation at the weekly scale over an entire irrigation district. In a first step, the S1-derived SSM is assimilated into a FAO-56-based crop water balance model (SAMIR) to retrieve for each crop type both the irrigation amount (Idose) and the soil moisture threshold (SMthreshold) at which irrigation is triggered. To do this, a particle filter method is implemented, with particles reset each month to provide time-varying SMthreshold and Idose. In a second step, the retrieved SMthreshold and Idose values are used as input to SAMIR to estimate the weekly irrigation and its uncertainty. The assimilation approach (SSM-ASSIM) is tested over the 8000 hectare Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district located in northeastern Spain, where in situ irrigation data integrating the whole district are available at the weekly scale during 2019. For evaluation, the performance of SSM-ASSIM is compared with that of the default FAO-56 irrigation module (called FAO56-DEF), which sets the SMthreshold to the critical soil moisture value and systematically fills the soil reservoir for each irrigation event. In 2019, with an observed annual irrigation of 687 mm, SSM-ASSIM (FAO56-DEF) shows a root mean square deviation between retrieved and in situ irrigation of 6.7 (8.8) mm week-1, a bias of +0.3 (-1.4) mm week-1, and a Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.88 (0.78). The SSM-ASSIM approach shows great potential for retrieving the weekly water use over extended areas for any irrigation regime, including over-irrigation.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessRetrieving the irrigation actually applied at district scale: assimilating high-resolution Sentinel-1-derived soil moisture data into a FAO-56-based model
Irrigation is the most water consuming activity in the world. Knowing the timing and amount of irrigation that is actually applied is therefore fundamental for water managers. However, this information is rarely available at all scales and is subject to large uncertainties due to the wide variety of existing agricultural practices and associated irrigation regimes (full irrigation, deficit irrigation, or over-irrigation). To fill this gap, we propose a two-step approach based on 15 m resolution Sentinel-1 (S1) surface soil moisture (SSM) data to retrieve the actual irrigation at the weekly scale over an entire irrigation district. In a first step, the S1-derived SSM is assimilated into a FAO-56-based crop water balance model (SAMIR) to retrieve for each crop type both the irrigation amount (Idose) and the soil moisture threshold (SMthreshold) at which irrigation is triggered. To do this, a particle filter method is implemented, with particles reset each month to provide time-varying SMthreshold and Idose. In a second step, the retrieved SMthreshold and Idose values are used as input to SAMIR to estimate the weekly irrigation and its uncertainty. The assimilation approach (SSM-ASSIM) is tested over the 8000 hectare Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district located in northeastern Spain, where in situ irrigation data integrating the whole district are available at the weekly scale during 2019. For evaluation, the performance of SSM-ASSIM is compared with that of the default FAO-56 irrigation module (called FAO56-DEF), which sets the SMthreshold to the critical soil moisture value and systematically fills the soil reservoir for each irrigation event. In 2019, with an observed annual irrigation of 687 mm, SSM-ASSIM (FAO56-DEF) shows a root mean square deviation between retrieved and in situ irrigation of 6.7 (8.8) mm week-1, a bias of +0.3 (-1.4) mm week-1, and a Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.88 (0.78). The SSM-ASSIM approach shows great potential for retrieving the weekly water use over extended areas for any irrigation regime, including over-irrigation.
- Open Access
- 14 November 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Spanish Journal of Soil Science
- Vol. 14, 13522
Impact of Irrigation Management on Salinity and Volume of Drainage Water in an 8000 ha Irrigation District in the Ebro Basin (NE Spain)
When irrigation is introduced in a region, it adds salts and mobilizes those already present in the soil, changing the soil-plant-atmosphere continuum. These changes may lead to higher salt loads in the drainage water which, in turn, can have an impact on waters further downstream. Knowing the dynamics of these loads at the sub-basin scale is key to accounting for the possible impact that irrigation may have and to determining what improvements could be applied. This study aimed to characterise the different salt types present and to investigate drainage salt loads and their dependence upon irrigation input and their implications in irrigation management in a new, and well-managed, 8000 ha irrigation district located in the Ebro basin, NE Spain. In addition, it is relevant to highlight that the Ebro basin suffered a period of significant drought in 2023. As a result, irrigation restrictions were applied in many irrigation districts. We sought to investigate how these reductions influenced irrigation return flows and salt discharges within a selected irrigation district. The present study was undertaken during the irrigation periods of 2021, 2022, and 2023. We monitored water inputs and outputs in two representative sub-basins belonging to the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district (Ebro basin, NE Spain). We also analysed water inputs and outputs in order to characterise and establish the salt balances in both of the sub-basins that we studied. Our results showed that during 2023, a reduction in irrigation delivery of 31% led to a reduction in drainage volume of 73%, resulting in a decrease in salt exports through drainage of 70%. These data revealed that the application of irrigation restrictions not only led to an increased availability of downstream water resources, but also to a decrease in drainage volume and salt load, resulting in an improvement in irrigation management by farmers. However, it should also be underlined that this drastic reduction in irrigation was, in turn, responsible for a reduction in yield. Re-utilising drainage waters and/or improving irrigation management at the field scale may help to find this point of balance in areas with high water demands.
- 14 November 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Spanish Journal of Soil Science
- Vol. 14, 13522
Open AccessImpact of Irrigation Management on Salinity and Volume of Drainage Water in an 8000 ha Irrigation District in the Ebro Basin (NE Spain)
When irrigation is introduced in a region, it adds salts and mobilizes those already present in the soil, changing the soil-plant-atmosphere continuum. These changes may lead to higher salt loads in the drainage water which, in turn, can have an impact on waters further downstream. Knowing the dynamics of these loads at the sub-basin scale is key to accounting for the possible impact that irrigation may have and to determining what improvements could be applied. This study aimed to characterise the different salt types present and to investigate drainage salt loads and their dependence upon irrigation input and their implications in irrigation management in a new, and well-managed, 8000 ha irrigation district located in the Ebro basin, NE Spain. In addition, it is relevant to highlight that the Ebro basin suffered a period of significant drought in 2023. As a result, irrigation restrictions were applied in many irrigation districts. We sought to investigate how these reductions influenced irrigation return flows and salt discharges within a selected irrigation district. The present study was undertaken during the irrigation periods of 2021, 2022, and 2023. We monitored water inputs and outputs in two representative sub-basins belonging to the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district (Ebro basin, NE Spain). We also analysed water inputs and outputs in order to characterise and establish the salt balances in both of the sub-basins that we studied. Our results showed that during 2023, a reduction in irrigation delivery of 31% led to a reduction in drainage volume of 73%, resulting in a decrease in salt exports through drainage of 70%. These data revealed that the application of irrigation restrictions not only led to an increased availability of downstream water resources, but also to a decrease in drainage volume and salt load, resulting in an improvement in irrigation management by farmers. However, it should also be underlined that this drastic reduction in irrigation was, in turn, responsible for a reduction in yield. Re-utilising drainage waters and/or improving irrigation management at the field scale may help to find this point of balance in areas with high water demands.
- Open Access
- 16 August 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 28 (16) , 3695-3716
Drainage assessment of irrigation districts: on the precision and accuracy of four parsimonious models
In semi-arid irrigated environments, agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can estimate drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, such models' precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri–Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.
- 16 August 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 28 (16) , 3695-3716
Open AccessDrainage assessment of irrigation districts: on the precision and accuracy of four parsimonious models
In semi-arid irrigated environments, agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can estimate drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, such models' precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri–Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.
- Open Access
- 25 March 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-32
Reply on RC1
In semi-arid irrigated environments, the agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can be used to estimate the drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, the precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) of such models have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, that are equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.
- 25 March 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-32
Open AccessReply on RC1
In semi-arid irrigated environments, the agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can be used to estimate the drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, the precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) of such models have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, that are equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.
- Open Access
- 25 March 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-32
Reply on RC2
In semi-arid irrigated environments, the agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can be used to estimate the drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, the precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) of such models have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, that are equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.
- 25 March 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-32
Open AccessReply on RC2
In semi-arid irrigated environments, the agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can be used to estimate the drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, the precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) of such models have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, that are equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.
- Open Access
- 5 December 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-32
Comment on egusphere-2023-543
In semi-arid irrigated environments, the agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can be used to estimate the drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, the precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) of such models have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, that are equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.
- 5 December 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-32
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2023-543
In semi-arid irrigated environments, the agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can be used to estimate the drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, the precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) of such models have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, that are equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Quantifying the Downstream Impact of Implementing Irrigation in a Semi-Arid Mediterranean Basin in NE of Spain
Irrigation in arid and semi-arid regions is key to maintain the productivities and the well-being of farmers. However, irrigation is an important source of pollution to rivers due to the impact of agricultural drainage [1], which may contain high levels of salts, nutrients and other pollutants. In the present study we quantified the impact of implementing irrigation in a 10,000 ha semi-arid basin of the Noguera Ribagorçana river (Ebro Basin, NE Spain). Water quality data obtained during 20 years (2002-2022) in four different sampling points in the river (three before, and one after the main agricultural drainage returns of the basin, which drains 4,366 ha) were analyzed, focusing on nitrate concentration (NO3-, ppm), phosphate concentration (PO43-, ppm), and electrical conductivity of the water (EC, dS/m). In 2002, less than 4,000 ha were under irrigation and during the studied period, a total of 5,571 hectares were brought under irrigation progressively over time, with the implementation of a new irrigation district in the area. Results showed a significative difference in the concentration of NO3- in the river water before and after the main agricultural drainage return of the new irrigation district. However, phosphorous concentration and electrical conductivity showed no significative differences between the sampling points before and after the main agricultural drainage returns. On the other hand, NO3- values at the sampling point after the main agricultural drainage return have increased over time as it did the irrigated area. Thus, along the 18 km of the Noguera Ribagorçana river observed in this study, NO3- levels have increased on average from 1.7 ppm at the first sampling point to 10.9 ppm at the last sampling point, after the returns of agricultural drainage in the basin. Therefore, we could state that implementing irrigation in 5,571 ha represents an increase of 9.2 ppm of NO3- in the water of the Noguera Ribagorçana river in the studied area.[1] Blann, K. L.; Anderson, J. L.; Sands, G. R.; Vondracek, B. Effects of Agricultural Drainage on Aquatic Ecosystems: A Review. Crit. Rev. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 39 (11), 909–1001. https://doi.org/10.1080/10643380801977966.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessQuantifying the Downstream Impact of Implementing Irrigation in a Semi-Arid Mediterranean Basin in NE of Spain
Irrigation in arid and semi-arid regions is key to maintain the productivities and the well-being of farmers. However, irrigation is an important source of pollution to rivers due to the impact of agricultural drainage [1], which may contain high levels of salts, nutrients and other pollutants. In the present study we quantified the impact of implementing irrigation in a 10,000 ha semi-arid basin of the Noguera Ribagorçana river (Ebro Basin, NE Spain). Water quality data obtained during 20 years (2002-2022) in four different sampling points in the river (three before, and one after the main agricultural drainage returns of the basin, which drains 4,366 ha) were analyzed, focusing on nitrate concentration (NO3-, ppm), phosphate concentration (PO43-, ppm), and electrical conductivity of the water (EC, dS/m). In 2002, less than 4,000 ha were under irrigation and during the studied period, a total of 5,571 hectares were brought under irrigation progressively over time, with the implementation of a new irrigation district in the area. Results showed a significative difference in the concentration of NO3- in the river water before and after the main agricultural drainage return of the new irrigation district. However, phosphorous concentration and electrical conductivity showed no significative differences between the sampling points before and after the main agricultural drainage returns. On the other hand, NO3- values at the sampling point after the main agricultural drainage return have increased over time as it did the irrigated area. Thus, along the 18 km of the Noguera Ribagorçana river observed in this study, NO3- levels have increased on average from 1.7 ppm at the first sampling point to 10.9 ppm at the last sampling point, after the returns of agricultural drainage in the basin. Therefore, we could state that implementing irrigation in 5,571 ha represents an increase of 9.2 ppm of NO3- in the water of the Noguera Ribagorçana river in the studied area.[1] Blann, K. L.; Anderson, J. L.; Sands, G. R.; Vondracek, B. Effects of Agricultural Drainage on Aquatic Ecosystems: A Review. Crit. Rev. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 39 (11), 909–1001. https://doi.org/10.1080/10643380801977966.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Inversion of irrigation from satellite soil moisture data with a model based on PrISM (Precipitation Inferred from Soil Moisture)
Accurate irrigation water management is crucial for maximizing crop yield and minimizing water waste. Remote sensing technology offers a promising solution for efficiently estimating irrigation water use at the field scale.In this study, we adapted the PrISM (Precipitation inferred from Soil Moisture) methodology to detect and estimate irrigation events from soil moisture remotely sensed data. PrISM is a well-known approach to correct precipitation estimates using soil moisture data. Its main application is to provide a near real-time corrected precipitation product. PrISM employs an antecedent precipitation index (API) formula coupled with a particle filter assimilation scheme for soil moisture.In this study, we adapted the PrISM methodology to estimate irrigation amounts from soil moisture. The methodology uses initial precipitation estimates and soil moisture profile to detect whenever water excess is present in the soil (not caused by precipitation) and estimates its amount, together with its uncertainty. The methodology does not need extensive calibration and it is adaptable to different spatial and temporal scales. A synthetic study was performed to investigate the effect of a degraded soil moisture signal in terms of temporal resolution (lowering the temporal sampling of the soil moisture time-series), spatial resolution (lowering the percentage of irrigated area in a pixel), and random noise (increasing RMSE values). Results from this study suggested that high spatial resolution is critical in order to avoid underestimation of irrigation amounts. Ideally, a field-level soil moisture (with more than 75% of the pixel irrigated) and a product with low RMSE (0.02 m3/m3) is required for precise estimations (in order to keep the error of annual cumulative irrigation below 20%). Temporal resolution has a lower impact, especially when an assumption on the frequency of irrigation events (deduced from the system of irrigation used at the field-level) is included in the algorithm.Consequently, the developed algorithm was applied to actual satellite soil moisture products at different spatial scales over the same area. Validation was performed using in situ data at the district level of Algerri-Balaguer from the study area in Catalunya, Spain, where ground-based irrigation amounts were available for various years. Additional validation was performed at the field-level at the Segarra-Garrigues irrigation district using in-situ data from a few fields where soil moisture profiles and irrigation amounts were continuously monitored. Our results suggest that PrISM can be used effectively to estimate irrigation from soil moisture remote sensing data and that this methodology could be potentially applied on a large scale, with the only limitation being the quality and spatial resolution of the satellite soil moisture product.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessInversion of irrigation from satellite soil moisture data with a model based on PrISM (Precipitation Inferred from Soil Moisture)
Accurate irrigation water management is crucial for maximizing crop yield and minimizing water waste. Remote sensing technology offers a promising solution for efficiently estimating irrigation water use at the field scale.In this study, we adapted the PrISM (Precipitation inferred from Soil Moisture) methodology to detect and estimate irrigation events from soil moisture remotely sensed data. PrISM is a well-known approach to correct precipitation estimates using soil moisture data. Its main application is to provide a near real-time corrected precipitation product. PrISM employs an antecedent precipitation index (API) formula coupled with a particle filter assimilation scheme for soil moisture.In this study, we adapted the PrISM methodology to estimate irrigation amounts from soil moisture. The methodology uses initial precipitation estimates and soil moisture profile to detect whenever water excess is present in the soil (not caused by precipitation) and estimates its amount, together with its uncertainty. The methodology does not need extensive calibration and it is adaptable to different spatial and temporal scales. A synthetic study was performed to investigate the effect of a degraded soil moisture signal in terms of temporal resolution (lowering the temporal sampling of the soil moisture time-series), spatial resolution (lowering the percentage of irrigated area in a pixel), and random noise (increasing RMSE values). Results from this study suggested that high spatial resolution is critical in order to avoid underestimation of irrigation amounts. Ideally, a field-level soil moisture (with more than 75% of the pixel irrigated) and a product with low RMSE (0.02 m3/m3) is required for precise estimations (in order to keep the error of annual cumulative irrigation below 20%). Temporal resolution has a lower impact, especially when an assumption on the frequency of irrigation events (deduced from the system of irrigation used at the field-level) is included in the algorithm.Consequently, the developed algorithm was applied to actual satellite soil moisture products at different spatial scales over the same area. Validation was performed using in situ data at the district level of Algerri-Balaguer from the study area in Catalunya, Spain, where ground-based irrigation amounts were available for various years. Additional validation was performed at the field-level at the Segarra-Garrigues irrigation district using in-situ data from a few fields where soil moisture profiles and irrigation amounts were continuously monitored. Our results suggest that PrISM can be used effectively to estimate irrigation from soil moisture remote sensing data and that this methodology could be potentially applied on a large scale, with the only limitation being the quality and spatial resolution of the satellite soil moisture product.
- Open Access
- 8 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-32
Comment on egusphere-2023-543
In semi-arid irrigated environments, the agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can be used to estimate the drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, the precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) of such models have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, that are equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.
- 8 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-32
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2023-543
In semi-arid irrigated environments, the agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can be used to estimate the drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, the precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) of such models have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, that are equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.
- Open Access
- 24 April 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2023, 1-32
Drainage assessment of irrigation districts: on the precision and accuracy of four parsimonious models
In semi-arid irrigated environments, the agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can be used to estimate the drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, the precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) of such models have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, that are equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.
- 24 April 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2023, 1-32
Open AccessDrainage assessment of irrigation districts: on the precision and accuracy of four parsimonious models
In semi-arid irrigated environments, the agricultural drainage is at the heart of three agro-environmental issues: it is an indicator of water productivity, it is the main control to prevent soil salinization and waterlogging problems, and it is related to the health of downstream ecosystems. Crop water balance models combined with subsurface models can be used to estimate the drainage quantities and dynamics at various spatial scales. However, the precision (capacity of a model to fit the observed drainage using site-specific calibration) and accuracy (capacity of a model to approximate observed drainage using default input parameters) of such models have not yet been assessed in irrigated areas. To fill the gap, this study evaluates four parsimonious drainage models based on the combination of two surface models (RU and SAMIR) and two subsurface models (Reservoir and SIDRA) with varying complexity levels: RU-Reservoir, RU-SIDRA, SAMIR-Reservoir, and SAMIR-SIDRA. All models were applied over two sub-basins of the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district, northeastern Spain, that are equipped with surface and subsurface drains driving the drained water to general outlets where the discharge is continuously monitored. Results show that RU-Reservoir is the most precise (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.87), followed by SAMIR-Reservoir (average KGE (Q0.5) of 0.79). However, SAMIR-Reservoir is the most accurate model for providing rough drainage estimates using the default input parameters provided in the literature.