Bryan R. Muir
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Bryan R. Muir has a total of 37 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- James Renaud
Metrology Research Centre National Research Council Canada Ottawa Ontario Canada
4 shared publications Arman Sarfehnia
Department of Radiation Oncology University of Toronto Toronto ON Canada
2 shared publications- Arthur Lalonde
Université de Montréal de l’Université de Montréal
2 shared publications Dominique Guillet
Centre hospitalier de l’Université de Montréal (CHUM)
2 shared publicationsKarim Zerouali
Centre hospitalier de l’Université de Montréal (CHUM)
2 shared publicationsMalcolm R. McEwen
Measurement Science and Standards, National Research Council of Canada, Ottawa, ON, K1A 0R6, Canada
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 June 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 71 (11) , 115004
Design, optimization, and validation of a novel applicator integrating real-time dose monitoring for ultra-high dose rate (FLASH) electron radiotherapy
Objective. To develop, optimize, and validate a novel applicator for ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) electron radiotherapy that integrates an electrostatically shielded beam current transformer (BCT) for real-time dose tracking, and to perform a comprehensive experimental assessment of the combined applicator–BCT system in a representative preclinical geometry. Approach. Monte Carlo (MC) simulations using BEAMnrc and DOSRZnrc were used to optimize a 3D-printed applicator for the Mobetron (IntraOp, USA). Applicator wall thickness was varied to suppress out-of-field electron scatter, while the length was adjusted to balance instantaneous dose rate and profile flatness for 6 MeV and 9 MeV UHDR beams. Four conductive materials were evaluated for electrostatic shielding of the BCT, with the requirement of minimizing perturbation to the electron beam. The final design was experimentally validated through an comprehensive test using a microchip phantom for tumor spheroid culture, where MC-predicted doses–scaled via the calibrated, shielded BCT–were compared to radiochromic film measurements. Main results. A polylactic acid applicator with a 2.5 cm wall thickness minimized out-of-field dose, while a 12.5 cm length provided the best compromise between instantaneous dose rate and lateral dose uniformity. Ultra-thin conductive Kapton® offered effective electrostatic shielding with < 0.15% loss in beam energy fluence. Experimental validation demonstrated excellent agreement between MC-predicted and measured doses, with deviations of 0.16%–1.68% depending on energy and field size, within experimental uncertainty. Significance. The optimized applicator enables accurate, real-time charge measurement without compromising beam quality, supporting reliable dosimetry for UHDR studies. The external BCT configuration provides flexibility for rapid switching between FLASH and conventional modes, and the simulation-driven framework can be readily extended to other geometries and beam configurations, facilitating broader preclinical and clinical implementation.
- 10 June 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 71 (11) , 115004
Open AccessDesign, optimization, and validation of a novel applicator integrating real-time dose monitoring for ultra-high dose rate (FLASH) electron radiotherapy
Objective. To develop, optimize, and validate a novel applicator for ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) electron radiotherapy that integrates an electrostatically shielded beam current transformer (BCT) for real-time dose tracking, and to perform a comprehensive experimental assessment of the combined applicator–BCT system in a representative preclinical geometry. Approach. Monte Carlo (MC) simulations using BEAMnrc and DOSRZnrc were used to optimize a 3D-printed applicator for the Mobetron (IntraOp, USA). Applicator wall thickness was varied to suppress out-of-field electron scatter, while the length was adjusted to balance instantaneous dose rate and profile flatness for 6 MeV and 9 MeV UHDR beams. Four conductive materials were evaluated for electrostatic shielding of the BCT, with the requirement of minimizing perturbation to the electron beam. The final design was experimentally validated through an comprehensive test using a microchip phantom for tumor spheroid culture, where MC-predicted doses–scaled via the calibrated, shielded BCT–were compared to radiochromic film measurements. Main results. A polylactic acid applicator with a 2.5 cm wall thickness minimized out-of-field dose, while a 12.5 cm length provided the best compromise between instantaneous dose rate and lateral dose uniformity. Ultra-thin conductive Kapton® offered effective electrostatic shielding with < 0.15% loss in beam energy fluence. Experimental validation demonstrated excellent agreement between MC-predicted and measured doses, with deviations of 0.16%–1.68% depending on energy and field size, within experimental uncertainty. Significance. The optimized applicator enables accurate, real-time charge measurement without compromising beam quality, supporting reliable dosimetry for UHDR studies. The external BCT configuration provides flexibility for rapid switching between FLASH and conventional modes, and the simulation-driven framework can be readily extended to other geometries and beam configurations, facilitating broader preclinical and clinical implementation.
- 22 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 29-50
The Role of Standards Laboratories in Radiation Dosimetry
- 22 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 29-50
The Role of Standards Laboratories in Radiation Dosimetry
- Open Access
- 3 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 52 (6) , 4971-4983
Electron beam reference dosimetry measurements obtained at multiple institutions using the Addendum to AAPM's TG‐51 protocol
Background: The TG‐51 protocol describes methods for obtaining reference dosimetry measurements for external photon and electron beams. Since the publication of TG‐51 in 1999, research on reference dosimetry has allowed revisiting the procedures and data recommended in the protocol. An Addendum to TG‐51 for electron beam reference dosimetry was published in 2024, which revises the formalism and procedures and provides updated data. Purpose: To compare clinical reference dosimetry measurements in electron beams obtained using the original American Association of Physicists in Medicine's (AAPM) TG‐51 protocol and its associated Addendum (AAPM WGTG51 report 385). Methods: Measurements were performed in electron beams using the data and methods prescribed by TG‐51 and its Addendum. Nine participants (eight clinics and one primary standards laboratory) provided data and measurements. Results were obtained with 18 linacs using 87 total beam energies (4–6 energies per linac) between 4–22 MeV, representing the range of electron beam energies used clinically. Various cylindrical (6 types) and parallel‐plate (4 types) ionization chamber types were employed, representing most of the chambers commonly used in modern radiation therapy clinics. An analysis was performed to determine if differences arise from the new data recommended for beam quality conversion factors or from changes to the procedure. Results: Results for dose to water per monitor unit obtained using the Addendum are up to 2.3% higher in low‐energy beams and 1.3% higher in high‐energy beams compared to results obtained using the original TG‐51 protocol. These differences are consistent with what was predicted by the Addendum. Differences arise from both the changes to procedure (up to 0.7% from not requiring the correction for cylindrical chambers, 0.5% from the change in the shift of the point of measurement for parallel‐plate chambers) as well as the recommended data (0.8% from differences in , 0.5% from differences in ). Conclusion: This work elucidates where differences arise in results obtained using the original TG‐51 protocol and its associated Addendum for electron beam reference dosimetry. The results presented here provide confidence in the new approach and data recommended by the Addendum. Clinical physicists can use these results to ensure that differences are as expected when implementing the Addendum.
- 3 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 52 (6) , 4971-4983
Open AccessElectron beam reference dosimetry measurements obtained at multiple institutions using the Addendum to AAPM's TG‐51 protocol
Background: The TG‐51 protocol describes methods for obtaining reference dosimetry measurements for external photon and electron beams. Since the publication of TG‐51 in 1999, research on reference dosimetry has allowed revisiting the procedures and data recommended in the protocol. An Addendum to TG‐51 for electron beam reference dosimetry was published in 2024, which revises the formalism and procedures and provides updated data. Purpose: To compare clinical reference dosimetry measurements in electron beams obtained using the original American Association of Physicists in Medicine's (AAPM) TG‐51 protocol and its associated Addendum (AAPM WGTG51 report 385). Methods: Measurements were performed in electron beams using the data and methods prescribed by TG‐51 and its Addendum. Nine participants (eight clinics and one primary standards laboratory) provided data and measurements. Results were obtained with 18 linacs using 87 total beam energies (4–6 energies per linac) between 4–22 MeV, representing the range of electron beam energies used clinically. Various cylindrical (6 types) and parallel‐plate (4 types) ionization chamber types were employed, representing most of the chambers commonly used in modern radiation therapy clinics. An analysis was performed to determine if differences arise from the new data recommended for beam quality conversion factors or from changes to the procedure. Results: Results for dose to water per monitor unit obtained using the Addendum are up to 2.3% higher in low‐energy beams and 1.3% higher in high‐energy beams compared to results obtained using the original TG‐51 protocol. These differences are consistent with what was predicted by the Addendum. Differences arise from both the changes to procedure (up to 0.7% from not requiring the correction for cylindrical chambers, 0.5% from the change in the shift of the point of measurement for parallel‐plate chambers) as well as the recommended data (0.8% from differences in , 0.5% from differences in ). Conclusion: This work elucidates where differences arise in results obtained using the original TG‐51 protocol and its associated Addendum for electron beam reference dosimetry. The results presented here provide confidence in the new approach and data recommended by the Addendum. Clinical physicists can use these results to ensure that differences are as expected when implementing the Addendum.
- Open Access
- 7 May 2024
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 69 (10) , 105016
The effect of electron backscatter and charge build up in media on beam current transformer signal for ultra-high dose rate (FLASH) electron beam monitoring
Objective. Beam current transformers (BCT) are promising detectors for real-time beam monitoring in ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) electron radiotherapy. However, previous studies have reported a significant sensitivity of the BCT signal to changes in source-to-surface distance (SSD), field size, and phantom material which have until now been attributed to the fluctuating levels of electrons backscattered within the BCT. The purpose of this study is to evaluate this hypothesis, with the goal of understanding and mitigating the variations in BCT signal due to changes in irradiation conditions. Approach. Monte Carlo simulations and experimental measurements were conducted with a UHDR-capable intra-operative electron linear accelerator to analyze the impact of backscattered electrons on BCT signal. The potential influence of charge accumulation in media as a mechanism affecting BCT signal perturbation was further investigated by examining the effects of phantom conductivity and electrical grounding. Finally, the effectiveness of Faraday shielding to mitigate BCT signal variations is evaluated. Main Results. Monte Carlo simulations indicated that the fraction of electrons backscattered in water and on the collimator plastic at 6 and 9 MeV is lower than 1%, suggesting that backscattered electrons alone cannot account for the observed BCT signal variations. However, our experimental measurements confirmed previous findings of BCT response variation up to 15% for different field diameters. A significant impact of phantom type on BCT response was also observed, with variations in BCT signal as high as 14.1% when comparing measurements in water and solid water. The introduction of a Faraday shield to our applicators effectively mitigated the dependencies of BCT signal on SSD, field size, and phantom material. Significance. Our results indicate that variations in BCT signal as a function of SSD, field size, and phantom material are likely driven by an electric field originating in dielectric materials exposed to the UHDR electron beam. Strategies such as Faraday shielding were shown to effectively prevent these electric fields from affecting BCT signal, enabling reliable BCT-based electron UHDR beam monitoring.
- 7 May 2024
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 69 (10) , 105016
Open AccessThe effect of electron backscatter and charge build up in media on beam current transformer signal for ultra-high dose rate (FLASH) electron beam monitoring
Objective. Beam current transformers (BCT) are promising detectors for real-time beam monitoring in ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) electron radiotherapy. However, previous studies have reported a significant sensitivity of the BCT signal to changes in source-to-surface distance (SSD), field size, and phantom material which have until now been attributed to the fluctuating levels of electrons backscattered within the BCT. The purpose of this study is to evaluate this hypothesis, with the goal of understanding and mitigating the variations in BCT signal due to changes in irradiation conditions. Approach. Monte Carlo simulations and experimental measurements were conducted with a UHDR-capable intra-operative electron linear accelerator to analyze the impact of backscattered electrons on BCT signal. The potential influence of charge accumulation in media as a mechanism affecting BCT signal perturbation was further investigated by examining the effects of phantom conductivity and electrical grounding. Finally, the effectiveness of Faraday shielding to mitigate BCT signal variations is evaluated. Main Results. Monte Carlo simulations indicated that the fraction of electrons backscattered in water and on the collimator plastic at 6 and 9 MeV is lower than 1%, suggesting that backscattered electrons alone cannot account for the observed BCT signal variations. However, our experimental measurements confirmed previous findings of BCT response variation up to 15% for different field diameters. A significant impact of phantom type on BCT response was also observed, with variations in BCT signal as high as 14.1% when comparing measurements in water and solid water. The introduction of a Faraday shield to our applicators effectively mitigated the dependencies of BCT signal on SSD, field size, and phantom material. Significance. Our results indicate that variations in BCT signal as a function of SSD, field size, and phantom material are likely driven by an electric field originating in dielectric materials exposed to the UHDR electron beam. Strategies such as Faraday shielding were shown to effectively prevent these electric fields from affecting BCT signal, enabling reliable BCT-based electron UHDR beam monitoring.
- 29 December 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 68 (1) , 015019
Calorimeter measurements of absolute dose in aluminum, a surrogate of bone, to validate dose-to-medium in Acuros XB
Objective . While the accuracy of dose calculations in water with Acuros XB is well established, experimental validation of dose in bone is limited. Acuros XB reports both dose-to-medium and dose-to-water, and these values differ in bone, but there are no reports of measurements of validation in bone. This work compares Acuros XB calculations to measurements of absolute dose in aluminum (medium similar to bone). The validity of using selected relative dosimeters in aluminum is also investigated. Approach . A calorimeter with an aluminum core embedded in an aluminum phantom was selected as bone surrogate for the measurement of absolute dose. Matching the medium of the core to the medium of the phantom allowed eliminating the calculation of the conversion between media. The dose was measured at the fixed depth of 3.3 cm in aluminum (∼9 g·cm −2 ) with 6X, 10X, 6FFF and 10FFF photon beams from a TrueBeam Varian linac. In addition, experimental cross-calibration between water and aluminum was performed for an IBA CC13 ionization chamber, a PTW microDiamond and EBT3 Gafchromic film. Main results . Calculations with Acuros XB dose-to-medium in aluminum differed from the calorimetry data by −2.8% to −3.5%, depending on the beam. Use of dose-to-water would have resulted in about 39% discrepancy. The cross calibration coefficient between water and aluminum yielded values of about 0.87 for the CC13 chamber, 0.91 for the microDiamond, and 0.88 for the film, and independent of the beam within about ±1%. Significance . It was demonstrated the value of the dose-to-medium in aluminum (surrogate of bone) computed with Acuros XB is close to the value of the absolute dose measured with a calorimeter, and there is a significant discrepancy when dose-to-water is used instead. The use of an ionization chamber, a microDiamond and Gafchromic film in aluminum required a considerable correction from calibration in water.
- 29 December 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 68 (1) , 015019
Calorimeter measurements of absolute dose in aluminum, a surrogate of bone, to validate dose-to-medium in Acuros XB
Objective . While the accuracy of dose calculations in water with Acuros XB is well established, experimental validation of dose in bone is limited. Acuros XB reports both dose-to-medium and dose-to-water, and these values differ in bone, but there are no reports of measurements of validation in bone. This work compares Acuros XB calculations to measurements of absolute dose in aluminum (medium similar to bone). The validity of using selected relative dosimeters in aluminum is also investigated. Approach . A calorimeter with an aluminum core embedded in an aluminum phantom was selected as bone surrogate for the measurement of absolute dose. Matching the medium of the core to the medium of the phantom allowed eliminating the calculation of the conversion between media. The dose was measured at the fixed depth of 3.3 cm in aluminum (∼9 g·cm −2 ) with 6X, 10X, 6FFF and 10FFF photon beams from a TrueBeam Varian linac. In addition, experimental cross-calibration between water and aluminum was performed for an IBA CC13 ionization chamber, a PTW microDiamond and EBT3 Gafchromic film. Main results . Calculations with Acuros XB dose-to-medium in aluminum differed from the calorimetry data by −2.8% to −3.5%, depending on the beam. Use of dose-to-water would have resulted in about 39% discrepancy. The cross calibration coefficient between water and aluminum yielded values of about 0.87 for the CC13 chamber, 0.91 for the microDiamond, and 0.88 for the film, and independent of the beam within about ±1%. Significance . It was demonstrated the value of the dose-to-medium in aluminum (surrogate of bone) computed with Acuros XB is close to the value of the absolute dose measured with a calorimeter, and there is a significant discrepancy when dose-to-water is used instead. The use of an ionization chamber, a microDiamond and Gafchromic film in aluminum required a considerable correction from calibration in water.
- 13 June 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 49 (8) , 5483-5490
Monte Carlo optimization and experimental validation of a prototype ionization chamber for accurate magnetic resonance image guided radiation therapy (MRgRT) daily output constancy measurements in solid phantoms
Purpose To optimize the design, develop and test a prototype ionization chamber for accurate daily output constancy measurements in solid phantoms in clinical magnetic resonance-guided radiation therapy (MRgRT) radiotherapy beams. Up to 4% variations in response using commercial ionization chambers have been previously reported; the prototype ionization chamber developed here aims to minimize these variations. Methods Monte Carlo simulations with the EGSnrc code system are used to optimize an ionization chamber design by increasing the thickness of a brass (high-density, nonferromagnetic, easy-to-machine) wall until results consistent with no air gap are produced for simulations with a 1.5 T and 0.35 T magnetic field, with a 0.2 mm air gap and varying the placement of the chamber model within the air gap. Based on the results of these simulations, prototype ionization chambers are manufactured and tested in conventional linac beams and in a 7 MV Elekta Unity MR-linac. The chambers are rotated about their axes, both parallel and perpendicular to the 1.5 T magnetic field, through 360o in a plastic phantom with measurements made at each cardinal angle. This reveals any variation in chamber response by varying the thickness of the air gap between the chamber and the phantom. Results Monte Carlo simulations demonstrate that the optimal thickness of the chamber wall to mitigate the effect of an asymmetric air gap between the chamber and the plastic phantom is 1.1 mm of brass. With this thickness, the differences between simulations with and without an air gap and with asymmetric placement of the chamber within the air gap are less than 0.2%. A prototype chamber constructed with a 1.1 mm brass wall thickness exhibits less than 0.3% variation in response when rotated about its axis in the plastic phantom in a beam from an MR-linac, independent of whether its axis is parallel or perpendicular to the magnetic field. Conclusion The optimized ionization chamber design and validated prototype for accurate MR-linac daily output constancy measurements allows utilization of conventional phantoms and procedures in MRgRT systems. This can minimize disruption to clinical workflow for MR-linac quality assurance measurements.
- 13 June 2022
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 49 (8) , 5483-5490
Monte Carlo optimization and experimental validation of a prototype ionization chamber for accurate magnetic resonance image guided radiation therapy (MRgRT) daily output constancy measurements in solid phantoms
Purpose To optimize the design, develop and test a prototype ionization chamber for accurate daily output constancy measurements in solid phantoms in clinical magnetic resonance-guided radiation therapy (MRgRT) radiotherapy beams. Up to 4% variations in response using commercial ionization chambers have been previously reported; the prototype ionization chamber developed here aims to minimize these variations. Methods Monte Carlo simulations with the EGSnrc code system are used to optimize an ionization chamber design by increasing the thickness of a brass (high-density, nonferromagnetic, easy-to-machine) wall until results consistent with no air gap are produced for simulations with a 1.5 T and 0.35 T magnetic field, with a 0.2 mm air gap and varying the placement of the chamber model within the air gap. Based on the results of these simulations, prototype ionization chambers are manufactured and tested in conventional linac beams and in a 7 MV Elekta Unity MR-linac. The chambers are rotated about their axes, both parallel and perpendicular to the 1.5 T magnetic field, through 360o in a plastic phantom with measurements made at each cardinal angle. This reveals any variation in chamber response by varying the thickness of the air gap between the chamber and the phantom. Results Monte Carlo simulations demonstrate that the optimal thickness of the chamber wall to mitigate the effect of an asymmetric air gap between the chamber and the plastic phantom is 1.1 mm of brass. With this thickness, the differences between simulations with and without an air gap and with asymmetric placement of the chamber within the air gap are less than 0.2%. A prototype chamber constructed with a 1.1 mm brass wall thickness exhibits less than 0.3% variation in response when rotated about its axis in the plastic phantom in a beam from an MR-linac, independent of whether its axis is parallel or perpendicular to the magnetic field. Conclusion The optimized ionization chamber design and validated prototype for accurate MR-linac daily output constancy measurements allows utilization of conventional phantoms and procedures in MRgRT systems. This can minimize disruption to clinical workflow for MR-linac quality assurance measurements.
- 25 February 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Physica Medica
- Vol. 94, S61-S62
FLASH Modalities Track (Oral Presentations) PROOF OF PRINCIPLE OF A PYROELECTRIC CALORIMETER WITH ELECTROMETER READOUT FOR THE ABSOLUTE DOSIMETRY OF FLASH RADIATION
- 25 February 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Physica Medica
- Vol. 94, S61-S62
FLASH Modalities Track (Oral Presentations) PROOF OF PRINCIPLE OF A PYROELECTRIC CALORIMETER WITH ELECTROMETER READOUT FOR THE ABSOLUTE DOSIMETRY OF FLASH RADIATION
- 27 January 2020
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 47 (5) , 2267-2276
A modified formalism for electron beam reference dosimetry to improve the accuracy of linac output calibration
Purpose: To present and demonstrate the accuracy of a modified formalism for electron beam reference dosimetry using updated Monte Carlo calculated beam quality conversion factors.Methods: The proposed, simplified formalism allows the use of cylindrical ionization chambers in all electron beams (even those with low beam energies) and does not require a measured gradient correction factor. Data from a previous publication are used for beam quality conversion factors. The formalism is tested and compared to the present formalism in the AAPM TG‐51 protocol with measurements made in Elekta Precise electron beams with energies between 4 MeV and 22 MeV and with fields shaped with a 10 × 10 cm2 clinical applicator as well as a 20 × 20 cm2 clinical applicator for the 18 MeV and 22 MeV beams. A set of six ionization chambers are used for measurements (two cylindical reference‐class chambers, two scanning‐type chambers and two parallel‐plate chambers). Dose per monitor unit is derived using the data and formalism provided in the TG‐51 protocol and with the proposed formalism and data and compared to that obtained using ionization chambers calibrated directly against primary standards for absorbed dose in electron beams.Results: The standard deviation of results using different chambers when TG‐51 is followed strictly is on the order of 0.4% when parallel‐plate chambers are cross‐calibrated against cylindrical chambers. However, if parallel‐plate chambers are directly calibrated in a cobalt‐60 beam, the difference between results for these chambers is up to 2.2%. Using the proposed formalism and either directly calibrated or cross‐calibrated parallel‐plate chambers gives a standard deviation using different chambers of 0.4%. The difference between results that use TG‐51 and the primary standard measurements are on the order of 0.6% with a maximum difference in the 4 MeV beam of 2.8%. Comparing the results obtained with the proposed formalism and the primary standard measurements are on the order of 0.4% with a maximum difference of 1.0% in the 4 MeV beam.Conclusions: The proposed formalism and the use of updated data for beam quality conversion factors improves the consistency of results obtained with different chamber types and improves the accuracy of reference dosimetry measurements. Moreover, it is simpler than the present formalism and will be straightforward to implement clinically.
- 27 January 2020
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 47 (5) , 2267-2276
A modified formalism for electron beam reference dosimetry to improve the accuracy of linac output calibration
Purpose: To present and demonstrate the accuracy of a modified formalism for electron beam reference dosimetry using updated Monte Carlo calculated beam quality conversion factors.Methods: The proposed, simplified formalism allows the use of cylindrical ionization chambers in all electron beams (even those with low beam energies) and does not require a measured gradient correction factor. Data from a previous publication are used for beam quality conversion factors. The formalism is tested and compared to the present formalism in the AAPM TG‐51 protocol with measurements made in Elekta Precise electron beams with energies between 4 MeV and 22 MeV and with fields shaped with a 10 × 10 cm2 clinical applicator as well as a 20 × 20 cm2 clinical applicator for the 18 MeV and 22 MeV beams. A set of six ionization chambers are used for measurements (two cylindical reference‐class chambers, two scanning‐type chambers and two parallel‐plate chambers). Dose per monitor unit is derived using the data and formalism provided in the TG‐51 protocol and with the proposed formalism and data and compared to that obtained using ionization chambers calibrated directly against primary standards for absorbed dose in electron beams.Results: The standard deviation of results using different chambers when TG‐51 is followed strictly is on the order of 0.4% when parallel‐plate chambers are cross‐calibrated against cylindrical chambers. However, if parallel‐plate chambers are directly calibrated in a cobalt‐60 beam, the difference between results for these chambers is up to 2.2%. Using the proposed formalism and either directly calibrated or cross‐calibrated parallel‐plate chambers gives a standard deviation using different chambers of 0.4%. The difference between results that use TG‐51 and the primary standard measurements are on the order of 0.6% with a maximum difference in the 4 MeV beam of 2.8%. Comparing the results obtained with the proposed formalism and the primary standard measurements are on the order of 0.4% with a maximum difference of 1.0% in the 4 MeV beam.Conclusions: The proposed formalism and the use of updated data for beam quality conversion factors improves the consistency of results obtained with different chamber types and improves the accuracy of reference dosimetry measurements. Moreover, it is simpler than the present formalism and will be straightforward to implement clinically.
- 23 October 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 44 (12) , 6641-6646
Technical Note: On the use of cylindrical ionization chambers for electron beam reference dosimetry
Purpose: To investigate the use of cylindrical chambers for electron beam dosimetry independent of energy by studying the variability of relative ion chamber perturbation corrections, one of the main concerns for electron beam dosimetry with cylindrical chambers.Methods: Measurements are made with sets of cylindrical and plane‐parallel reference‐class chambers as a function of depth in water in 8 MeV and 18 MeV electron beams. The ratio of chamber readings for similar chambers is normalized in a high‐energy electron beam and can be thought of as relative perturbation corrections. Data are plotted as a function of mean electron energy at depth for a range of depths close to the phantom surface to R80, the depth at which the ionization falls to 80% of its maximum value. Additional, similar measurements are made in a Virtual Water® phantom with cylindrical chambers at the reference depth in a 4 MeV electron beam.Results: The variability of relative ion chamber perturbation corrections for nominally identical cylindrical Farmer‐type chambers is found to be less than 0.4%, no worse than plane‐parallel chambers with similar specifications.Conclusions: This work discusses several issues related to the use of plane‐parallel ion chambers and suggests that reference‐class cylindrical chambers may be appropriate for reference dosimetry of all electron beams. This would simplify the reference dosimetry procedure and improve accuracy of beam calibration.
- 23 October 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 44 (12) , 6641-6646
Technical Note: On the use of cylindrical ionization chambers for electron beam reference dosimetry
Purpose: To investigate the use of cylindrical chambers for electron beam dosimetry independent of energy by studying the variability of relative ion chamber perturbation corrections, one of the main concerns for electron beam dosimetry with cylindrical chambers.Methods: Measurements are made with sets of cylindrical and plane‐parallel reference‐class chambers as a function of depth in water in 8 MeV and 18 MeV electron beams. The ratio of chamber readings for similar chambers is normalized in a high‐energy electron beam and can be thought of as relative perturbation corrections. Data are plotted as a function of mean electron energy at depth for a range of depths close to the phantom surface to R80, the depth at which the ionization falls to 80% of its maximum value. Additional, similar measurements are made in a Virtual Water® phantom with cylindrical chambers at the reference depth in a 4 MeV electron beam.Results: The variability of relative ion chamber perturbation corrections for nominally identical cylindrical Farmer‐type chambers is found to be less than 0.4%, no worse than plane‐parallel chambers with similar specifications.Conclusions: This work discusses several issues related to the use of plane‐parallel ion chambers and suggests that reference‐class cylindrical chambers may be appropriate for reference dosimetry of all electron beams. This would simplify the reference dosimetry procedure and improve accuracy of beam calibration.
- 8 August 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 44 (10) , 5433-5444
Electron beam water calorimetry measurements to obtain beam quality conversion factors
Purpose: To provide results of water calorimetry and ion chamber measurements in high‐energy electron beams carried out at the National Research Council Canada (NRC). There are three main aspects to this work: (a) investigation of the behavior of ionization chambers in electron beams of different energies with focus on long‐term stability, (b) water calorimetry measurements to determine absorbed dose to water in high‐energy beams for direct calibration of ion chambers, and (c) using measurements of chamber response relative to reference ion chambers, determination of beam quality conversion factors, kQ, for several ion chamber types.Methods: Measurements are made in electron beams with energies between 8 MeV and 22 MeV from the NRC Elekta Precise clinical linear accelerator. Ion chamber measurements are made as a function of depth for cylindrical and plane‐parallel ion chambers over a period of five years to investigate the stability of ion chamber response and for indirect calibration. Water calorimetry measurements are made in 18 MeV and 22 MeV beams. An insulated enclosure with fine temperature control is used to maintain a constant temperature (drifts less than 0.1 mK/min) of the calorimeter phantom at 4°C to minimize effects from convection. Two vessels of different designs are used with calibrated thermistor probes to measure radiation induced temperature rise. The vessels are filled with high‐purity water and saturated with H2 or N2 gas to minimize the effect of radiochemical reactions on the measured temperature rise. A set of secondary standard ion chambers are calibrated directly against the calorimeter. Finally, several other ion chambers are calibrated in the NRC 60Co reference field and then cross‐calibrated against the secondary standard chambers in electron beams to realize kQ factors.Results: The long‐term stability of the cylindrical ion chambers in electron beams is better (always %) than plane‐parallel chambers (0.2% to 0.4%). Calorimetry measurements made at 22 MeV with two different vessel geometries are consistent within 0.2% after correction for the vessel perturbation. Measurements of absorbed dose calibration coefficients for the same secondary standard chamber separated in time by 10 yr are within 0.2%. Drifts in linac output that would affect the transfer of the standard are mitigated to the 0.1% level by performing daily ion chamber normalization measurements. Calibration coefficients for secondary standard ion chambers can be achieved with uncertainties less than 0.4% (k = 1) in high‐energy electron beams. The additional uncertainty in deriving calibration coefficients for well‐behaved chambers indirectly against the secondary standard reference chambers is negligible. The kQ factors measured here differ by up to 1.3% compared to those in TG‐51, an important change for reference dosimetry measurements.Conclusions: The measurements made here of kQ factors for eight plane‐parallel and six cylindrical ion chambers will impact future updates of reference dosimetry protocols by providing some of the highest quality measurements of this crucial dosimetric parameter.
- 8 August 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 44 (10) , 5433-5444
Electron beam water calorimetry measurements to obtain beam quality conversion factors
Purpose: To provide results of water calorimetry and ion chamber measurements in high‐energy electron beams carried out at the National Research Council Canada (NRC). There are three main aspects to this work: (a) investigation of the behavior of ionization chambers in electron beams of different energies with focus on long‐term stability, (b) water calorimetry measurements to determine absorbed dose to water in high‐energy beams for direct calibration of ion chambers, and (c) using measurements of chamber response relative to reference ion chambers, determination of beam quality conversion factors, kQ, for several ion chamber types.Methods: Measurements are made in electron beams with energies between 8 MeV and 22 MeV from the NRC Elekta Precise clinical linear accelerator. Ion chamber measurements are made as a function of depth for cylindrical and plane‐parallel ion chambers over a period of five years to investigate the stability of ion chamber response and for indirect calibration. Water calorimetry measurements are made in 18 MeV and 22 MeV beams. An insulated enclosure with fine temperature control is used to maintain a constant temperature (drifts less than 0.1 mK/min) of the calorimeter phantom at 4°C to minimize effects from convection. Two vessels of different designs are used with calibrated thermistor probes to measure radiation induced temperature rise. The vessels are filled with high‐purity water and saturated with H2 or N2 gas to minimize the effect of radiochemical reactions on the measured temperature rise. A set of secondary standard ion chambers are calibrated directly against the calorimeter. Finally, several other ion chambers are calibrated in the NRC 60Co reference field and then cross‐calibrated against the secondary standard chambers in electron beams to realize kQ factors.Results: The long‐term stability of the cylindrical ion chambers in electron beams is better (always %) than plane‐parallel chambers (0.2% to 0.4%). Calorimetry measurements made at 22 MeV with two different vessel geometries are consistent within 0.2% after correction for the vessel perturbation. Measurements of absorbed dose calibration coefficients for the same secondary standard chamber separated in time by 10 yr are within 0.2%. Drifts in linac output that would affect the transfer of the standard are mitigated to the 0.1% level by performing daily ion chamber normalization measurements. Calibration coefficients for secondary standard ion chambers can be achieved with uncertainties less than 0.4% (k = 1) in high‐energy electron beams. The additional uncertainty in deriving calibration coefficients for well‐behaved chambers indirectly against the secondary standard reference chambers is negligible. The kQ factors measured here differ by up to 1.3% compared to those in TG‐51, an important change for reference dosimetry measurements.Conclusions: The measurements made here of kQ factors for eight plane‐parallel and six cylindrical ion chambers will impact future updates of reference dosimetry protocols by providing some of the highest quality measurements of this crucial dosimetric parameter.