Imke Sievers
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Imke Sievers has a total of 20 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Till Andreas Soya Rasmussen
Danish Meteorological Institute, Copenhagen, Denmark
8 shared publications - Antonio Sánchez Benítez
Alfred Wegener Institute, Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research, Bremerhaven, Germany
3 shared publications - Lars Stenseng
DTU Space, Danish Technical University, Elektrovej Bygning 328, 2800 Kongens Lyngby, Denmark
3 shared publications Mads Hvid Ribergaard
Danish Meteorological Institute, Copenhagen, Denmark
3 shared publications- Marylou Athanase
Alfred Wegener Institute, Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research, Bremerhaven, Germany
3 shared publications - Shreya Trivedi
Department of Geography, University of California, Los Angeles, USA
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-35
Comment on egusphere-2026-3613
Independently evaluating large-scale sea ice models is challenging because direct observations are sparse and many satellite products are assimilated into the models being evaluated. Moreover, commonly used sea ice concentration products provide limited information on interior pack-ice properties such as ice thickness. To address these issues, we present a framework for evaluating sea ice models directly in satellite microwave radiometer brightness temperature (TB) space. The framework uses an observation operator to simulate all AMSR2 channels except 7.3 GHz. The observation operator couples emission and radiative-transfer models of the ocean, sea ice, snow, and atmosphere for non-melting Arctic conditions. To reduce simulation uncertainty, the snow-scattering parametrisation and multi-year ice scattering properties were constrained using field and airborne observations. We introduce a multi-channel evaluation metric and demonstrate its sensitivity to errors in sea ice concentration, ice-type fractions, thickness, snow depth, and surface temperature. Application to two versions of a pan-Arctic sea ice model showed that improvements and degradations in modelled sea ice thickness are captured by the metric. The metric was significantly correlated with improvements in first-year ice fraction (R2 = 0.31) and ice thickness (R2 = 0.14), but not with snow depth or surface temperature. These results demonstrate that TB-space evaluation provides a complementary and largely independent approach to sea ice model assessment across both the marginal ice zone and interior pack ice.
- 8 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-35
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-3613
Independently evaluating large-scale sea ice models is challenging because direct observations are sparse and many satellite products are assimilated into the models being evaluated. Moreover, commonly used sea ice concentration products provide limited information on interior pack-ice properties such as ice thickness. To address these issues, we present a framework for evaluating sea ice models directly in satellite microwave radiometer brightness temperature (TB) space. The framework uses an observation operator to simulate all AMSR2 channels except 7.3 GHz. The observation operator couples emission and radiative-transfer models of the ocean, sea ice, snow, and atmosphere for non-melting Arctic conditions. To reduce simulation uncertainty, the snow-scattering parametrisation and multi-year ice scattering properties were constrained using field and airborne observations. We introduce a multi-channel evaluation metric and demonstrate its sensitivity to errors in sea ice concentration, ice-type fractions, thickness, snow depth, and surface temperature. Application to two versions of a pan-Arctic sea ice model showed that improvements and degradations in modelled sea ice thickness are captured by the metric. The metric was significantly correlated with improvements in first-year ice fraction (R2 = 0.31) and ice thickness (R2 = 0.14), but not with snow depth or surface temperature. These results demonstrate that TB-space evaluation provides a complementary and largely independent approach to sea ice model assessment across both the marginal ice zone and interior pack ice.
- Open Access
- 11 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- p. 1-35
Evaluating Arctic sea ice models using simulated microwave brightness temperatures
Independently evaluating large-scale sea ice models is challenging because direct observations are sparse and many satellite products are assimilated into the models being evaluated. Moreover, commonly used sea ice concentration products provide limited information on interior pack-ice properties such as ice thickness. To address these issues, we present a framework for evaluating sea ice models directly in satellite microwave radiometer brightness temperature (TB) space. The framework uses an observation operator to simulate all AMSR2 channels except 7.3 GHz. The observation operator couples emission and radiative-transfer models of the ocean, sea ice, snow, and atmosphere for non-melting Arctic conditions. To reduce simulation uncertainty, the snow-scattering parametrisation and multi-year ice scattering properties were constrained using field and airborne observations. We introduce a multi-channel evaluation metric and demonstrate its sensitivity to errors in sea ice concentration, ice-type fractions, thickness, snow depth, and surface temperature. Application to two versions of a pan-Arctic sea ice model showed that improvements and degradations in modelled sea ice thickness are captured by the metric. The metric was significantly correlated with improvements in first-year ice fraction (R2 = 0.31) and ice thickness (R2 = 0.14), but not with snow depth or surface temperature. These results demonstrate that TB-space evaluation provides a complementary and largely independent approach to sea ice model assessment across both the marginal ice zone and interior pack ice.
- 11 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- p. 1-35
Open AccessEvaluating Arctic sea ice models using simulated microwave brightness temperatures
Independently evaluating large-scale sea ice models is challenging because direct observations are sparse and many satellite products are assimilated into the models being evaluated. Moreover, commonly used sea ice concentration products provide limited information on interior pack-ice properties such as ice thickness. To address these issues, we present a framework for evaluating sea ice models directly in satellite microwave radiometer brightness temperature (TB) space. The framework uses an observation operator to simulate all AMSR2 channels except 7.3 GHz. The observation operator couples emission and radiative-transfer models of the ocean, sea ice, snow, and atmosphere for non-melting Arctic conditions. To reduce simulation uncertainty, the snow-scattering parametrisation and multi-year ice scattering properties were constrained using field and airborne observations. We introduce a multi-channel evaluation metric and demonstrate its sensitivity to errors in sea ice concentration, ice-type fractions, thickness, snow depth, and surface temperature. Application to two versions of a pan-Arctic sea ice model showed that improvements and degradations in modelled sea ice thickness are captured by the metric. The metric was significantly correlated with improvements in first-year ice fraction (R2 = 0.31) and ice thickness (R2 = 0.14), but not with snow depth or surface temperature. These results demonstrate that TB-space evaluation provides a complementary and largely independent approach to sea ice model assessment across both the marginal ice zone and interior pack ice.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Multiscale data-driven forecasting of Sea Ice Essential Climate Variables
Short-term forecasting of Arctic essential climate variables (ECVs) requires methods that can exploit the growing diversity of forthcoming satellite observations while remaining robust to sparse and heterogeneous sampling. This study targets sea-ice concentration (SIC) and sea-ice thickness (SIT) forecasting using observations from the new Copernicus Sentinel Expansion missions: ROSE-L providing high-resolution (≈500 m) SIC, CIMR delivering intermediate-resolution (≈5 km) SIC and thin sea ice thickness, and CRISTAL altimeter supplying SIT and sea surface height at similar scales. We propose an online multiresolution neural forecasting framework designed to ingest irregular satellite swaths across resolutions and sensor types, and to produce observation-conditioned nowcasts compatible with operational constraints. The model combines multiscale forecast architectures to explicitly handle intermittency, scale disparities, and sensor-dependent information content. Beyond its operational relevance, the framework is used as a research tool to investigate predictability across scales, enabling a systematic analysis of how submesoscale ice processes impact short-term forecast skill at coarser resolutions. Forecast performance is assessed using resolution-aware metrics, revealing scale-dependent gains in ice-edge sharpness, thin-ice variability, and short-lead SIT evolution compared to baseline methods. By explicitly combining ROSE-L, CIMR, and CRISTAL observations within a unified multiresolution framework, this work enables a direct assessment of how high-resolution sea-ice variability propagates across scales and impacts short-term predictability in operational Arctic ECV forecasts.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessMultiscale data-driven forecasting of Sea Ice Essential Climate Variables
Short-term forecasting of Arctic essential climate variables (ECVs) requires methods that can exploit the growing diversity of forthcoming satellite observations while remaining robust to sparse and heterogeneous sampling. This study targets sea-ice concentration (SIC) and sea-ice thickness (SIT) forecasting using observations from the new Copernicus Sentinel Expansion missions: ROSE-L providing high-resolution (≈500 m) SIC, CIMR delivering intermediate-resolution (≈5 km) SIC and thin sea ice thickness, and CRISTAL altimeter supplying SIT and sea surface height at similar scales. We propose an online multiresolution neural forecasting framework designed to ingest irregular satellite swaths across resolutions and sensor types, and to produce observation-conditioned nowcasts compatible with operational constraints. The model combines multiscale forecast architectures to explicitly handle intermittency, scale disparities, and sensor-dependent information content. Beyond its operational relevance, the framework is used as a research tool to investigate predictability across scales, enabling a systematic analysis of how submesoscale ice processes impact short-term forecast skill at coarser resolutions. Forecast performance is assessed using resolution-aware metrics, revealing scale-dependent gains in ice-edge sharpness, thin-ice variability, and short-lead SIT evolution compared to baseline methods. By explicitly combining ROSE-L, CIMR, and CRISTAL observations within a unified multiresolution framework, this work enables a direct assessment of how high-resolution sea-ice variability propagates across scales and impacts short-term predictability in operational Arctic ECV forecasts.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Disko Bay ocean and sea ice forecast
The maritime industry continues to expand in the waters around Greenland. Apart from fisheries, which by far is the most important income for Greenland, another important element is transportation of goods and tourist, which in many locations are dependent on the conditions at sea. During the last two winters (2022 and 2023) severe sea ice conditions have been seen in Disko Bay. Especially in 2022, there were discussions on whether or not to fly in supplies instead of using the usual transportation on the ocean. A trustworthy high-resolution forecast of ocean and sea ice conditions could have remedied this decision.Currently automated retrievals of observations from remote sensing and forecast model are doing a reasonable job when describing the current conditions and forecasting the short-term offshore conditions, however users are often interested in near shore coastal areas, where resolution matters. The near coastal environment is often not well resolved in Arctic/global models forecast models.This study aim at developing a high-resolution (sub kilometer scale) operational coastal marine forecasting system built on the shoulders of already existing Copernicus services for the area of Disko Bay on the west coast of Greenland. In combination with already, existing products such as automated and manual ice charts it will improve the warning system for the area. A side effect is that the ice service will produce more frequent ice charts for Disko Bay, which will benefit the existing Copernicus Marine Service.The seamless physical downscaling from the Copernicus Marine Services system to the near coastal area in Disko Bay will utilize boundary conditions from the Arctic Marine forecasting system. The system will be forced by a high-resolution none hydrostatic atmospheric forecast from the Danish Meteorological Institute at 2½km resolution. The study is funded by the Copernicus user demonstration program named “COP-INNO-USER”.This presentation will focus on the developments within the service, benefits and challenges. It will also discuss how to integrate the results into operations at the Danish Meteorological Institute.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessDisko Bay ocean and sea ice forecast
The maritime industry continues to expand in the waters around Greenland. Apart from fisheries, which by far is the most important income for Greenland, another important element is transportation of goods and tourist, which in many locations are dependent on the conditions at sea. During the last two winters (2022 and 2023) severe sea ice conditions have been seen in Disko Bay. Especially in 2022, there were discussions on whether or not to fly in supplies instead of using the usual transportation on the ocean. A trustworthy high-resolution forecast of ocean and sea ice conditions could have remedied this decision.Currently automated retrievals of observations from remote sensing and forecast model are doing a reasonable job when describing the current conditions and forecasting the short-term offshore conditions, however users are often interested in near shore coastal areas, where resolution matters. The near coastal environment is often not well resolved in Arctic/global models forecast models.This study aim at developing a high-resolution (sub kilometer scale) operational coastal marine forecasting system built on the shoulders of already existing Copernicus services for the area of Disko Bay on the west coast of Greenland. In combination with already, existing products such as automated and manual ice charts it will improve the warning system for the area. A side effect is that the ice service will produce more frequent ice charts for Disko Bay, which will benefit the existing Copernicus Marine Service.The seamless physical downscaling from the Copernicus Marine Services system to the near coastal area in Disko Bay will utilize boundary conditions from the Arctic Marine forecasting system. The system will be forced by a high-resolution none hydrostatic atmospheric forecast from the Danish Meteorological Institute at 2½km resolution. The study is funded by the Copernicus user demonstration program named “COP-INNO-USER”.This presentation will focus on the developments within the service, benefits and challenges. It will also discuss how to integrate the results into operations at the Danish Meteorological Institute.
- Open Access
- 18 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in The Cryosphere
- Vol. 18 (12) , 5985-6004
Impact assessment of snow thickness, sea ice density and water density in CryoSat-2-derived sea ice thickness
Sea ice thickness is an essential climate variable, which is often derived from satellite altimetry freeboard estimates, e.g., by CryoSat-2. In order to convert freeboard to sea ice thickness, assumptions are needed for snow thickness, snow density, sea ice density and water density. These parameters are difficult to observe when co-located in time and space with the satellite-derived freeboard measurements. For this reason, most available CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness products rely on climatologies based on outdated observations and empirical values. Model- and observation-based alternatives to sea ice density and snow thickness values have been suggested in recent years, but their combined influence on the freeboard to sea ice thickness conversion has not been analyzed. This study evaluates model-based spatially varying snow thickness, sea ice density and water density with in situ observations and the associated parameters used in the classical CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness production. The observations used for the comparison are a snow thickness product from Ku- and Ka-band radar, sea ice density observations from airborne campaigns and ice core measurements as well as water density from a large variety of observation platforms included in the World Ocean Atlas. Furthermore, this study calculates the mean sea ice thickness differences resulting from substituting the parameters used in a classical CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness product with model-based values. The evaluation shows that the model-derived snow thickness, sea ice density and water density compare better to observations than the associated parameters used in the CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness product. The parameters were compared to the weekly CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness (SIT) product from the Alfred Wegener Institute, which uses similar values for snow thickness, sea ice density and water density to other available CryoSat-2 SIT products. Furthermore, we find that the model-based snow thickness and sea ice density separately lead to the largest sea ice thickness differences but that, to some extent, their differences cancel out when both parameters are used in combination. For the water density, we find the average and maximum sea ice thickness difference to be small in comparison to the sea ice thickness differences introduced by the snow thickness and sea ice density, but this is not negligible, as currently stated in most studies. We find that the origin of the assumption that water density is negligible in the freeboard to sea ice thickness conversion originates from a study investigating the seasonal Arctic sea ice density variability, not taking into account the spacial variability. Based on our findings, we recommend using either a water density climatology or an uncertainty value of 2.6 kg m−3 instead of the commonly used value of 0 to 0.5 kg m−3 in CryoSat-2 freeboard to sea ice thickness conversion.
- 18 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in The Cryosphere
- Vol. 18 (12) , 5985-6004
Open AccessImpact assessment of snow thickness, sea ice density and water density in CryoSat-2-derived sea ice thickness
Sea ice thickness is an essential climate variable, which is often derived from satellite altimetry freeboard estimates, e.g., by CryoSat-2. In order to convert freeboard to sea ice thickness, assumptions are needed for snow thickness, snow density, sea ice density and water density. These parameters are difficult to observe when co-located in time and space with the satellite-derived freeboard measurements. For this reason, most available CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness products rely on climatologies based on outdated observations and empirical values. Model- and observation-based alternatives to sea ice density and snow thickness values have been suggested in recent years, but their combined influence on the freeboard to sea ice thickness conversion has not been analyzed. This study evaluates model-based spatially varying snow thickness, sea ice density and water density with in situ observations and the associated parameters used in the classical CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness production. The observations used for the comparison are a snow thickness product from Ku- and Ka-band radar, sea ice density observations from airborne campaigns and ice core measurements as well as water density from a large variety of observation platforms included in the World Ocean Atlas. Furthermore, this study calculates the mean sea ice thickness differences resulting from substituting the parameters used in a classical CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness product with model-based values. The evaluation shows that the model-derived snow thickness, sea ice density and water density compare better to observations than the associated parameters used in the CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness product. The parameters were compared to the weekly CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness (SIT) product from the Alfred Wegener Institute, which uses similar values for snow thickness, sea ice density and water density to other available CryoSat-2 SIT products. Furthermore, we find that the model-based snow thickness and sea ice density separately lead to the largest sea ice thickness differences but that, to some extent, their differences cancel out when both parameters are used in combination. For the water density, we find the average and maximum sea ice thickness difference to be small in comparison to the sea ice thickness differences introduced by the snow thickness and sea ice density, but this is not negligible, as currently stated in most studies. We find that the origin of the assumption that water density is negligible in the freeboard to sea ice thickness conversion originates from a study investigating the seasonal Arctic sea ice density variability, not taking into account the spacial variability. Based on our findings, we recommend using either a water density climatology or an uncertainty value of 2.6 kg m−3 instead of the commonly used value of 0 to 0.5 kg m−3 in CryoSat-2 freeboard to sea ice thickness conversion.
- Open Access
- 8 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-32
Comment on egusphere-2024-2214
The Arctic sea-ice cover and thickness have rapidly declined in the recent past. Snow cover on sea ice, acting as an insulating barrier, was shown to be instrumental in driving the variability and trends in sea-ice thickness. Because of this, the ability of climate models to realistically simulate the present-day annual cycles of Arctic sea-ice properties has become a central measure of model performance in Arctic-focused climate model intercomparisons. However, evaluating free-running model simulations usually requires multi-year observational datasets, which is challenged by the relatively short-term existing Arctic measurements particularly sea-ice and snow thickness. In this exploratory study, we propose a new methodology to improve the meaningfulness of sea ice and snow comparisons to model data. We make use of the exceptional year-long MOSAiC observations to examine the simulated Arctic sea-ice and snow thickness in 10 CMIP6 models. To perform meaningful comparisons with the modeled simulations, we define two “proxy years” selection methods based on sea-ice area and atmospheric criteria, when these conditions in the Arctic are similar to those during the MOSAiC year. We verify the capability of the proxy-year composites to capture the atmospheric and sea-ice variability, by comparing them with the sets of nudged simulations in which the atmospheric circulation observed during the MOSAiC year is directly imposed. Our results show that models tend to simulate similar annual cycles compared to the observations however, with an overestimation in amplitude for snow thickness and a misaligned phase of sea-ice thickness cycles. Overall, the study highlights that regardless of the specific modeled configurations and conditions within individual proxy years, biases in sea-ice and snow thickness remain consistent, even when wind conditions are imposed in the nudged model simulations. This highlights the necessity for a better representation of modeled processes driving the sea-ice and snow thicknesses which will be instrumental in the next generation of GCMs. This first MOSAiC-based assessment of the modeled snow and ice thickness, and the proposed proxy-year-based methodology, pave the way for further meaningful model evaluation.
- 8 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-32
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-2214
The Arctic sea-ice cover and thickness have rapidly declined in the recent past. Snow cover on sea ice, acting as an insulating barrier, was shown to be instrumental in driving the variability and trends in sea-ice thickness. Because of this, the ability of climate models to realistically simulate the present-day annual cycles of Arctic sea-ice properties has become a central measure of model performance in Arctic-focused climate model intercomparisons. However, evaluating free-running model simulations usually requires multi-year observational datasets, which is challenged by the relatively short-term existing Arctic measurements particularly sea-ice and snow thickness. In this exploratory study, we propose a new methodology to improve the meaningfulness of sea ice and snow comparisons to model data. We make use of the exceptional year-long MOSAiC observations to examine the simulated Arctic sea-ice and snow thickness in 10 CMIP6 models. To perform meaningful comparisons with the modeled simulations, we define two “proxy years” selection methods based on sea-ice area and atmospheric criteria, when these conditions in the Arctic are similar to those during the MOSAiC year. We verify the capability of the proxy-year composites to capture the atmospheric and sea-ice variability, by comparing them with the sets of nudged simulations in which the atmospheric circulation observed during the MOSAiC year is directly imposed. Our results show that models tend to simulate similar annual cycles compared to the observations however, with an overestimation in amplitude for snow thickness and a misaligned phase of sea-ice thickness cycles. Overall, the study highlights that regardless of the specific modeled configurations and conditions within individual proxy years, biases in sea-ice and snow thickness remain consistent, even when wind conditions are imposed in the nudged model simulations. This highlights the necessity for a better representation of modeled processes driving the sea-ice and snow thicknesses which will be instrumental in the next generation of GCMs. This first MOSAiC-based assessment of the modeled snow and ice thickness, and the proposed proxy-year-based methodology, pave the way for further meaningful model evaluation.
- Open Access
- 2 October 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-32
Comment on egusphere-2024-2214
The Arctic sea-ice cover and thickness have rapidly declined in the recent past. Snow cover on sea ice, acting as an insulating barrier, was shown to be instrumental in driving the variability and trends in sea-ice thickness. Because of this, the ability of climate models to realistically simulate the present-day annual cycles of Arctic sea-ice properties has become a central measure of model performance in Arctic-focused climate model intercomparisons. However, evaluating free-running model simulations usually requires multi-year observational datasets, which is challenged by the relatively short-term existing Arctic measurements particularly sea-ice and snow thickness. In this exploratory study, we propose a new methodology to improve the meaningfulness of sea ice and snow comparisons to model data. We make use of the exceptional year-long MOSAiC observations to examine the simulated Arctic sea-ice and snow thickness in 10 CMIP6 models. To perform meaningful comparisons with the modeled simulations, we define two “proxy years” selection methods based on sea-ice area and atmospheric criteria, when these conditions in the Arctic are similar to those during the MOSAiC year. We verify the capability of the proxy-year composites to capture the atmospheric and sea-ice variability, by comparing them with the sets of nudged simulations in which the atmospheric circulation observed during the MOSAiC year is directly imposed. Our results show that models tend to simulate similar annual cycles compared to the observations however, with an overestimation in amplitude for snow thickness and a misaligned phase of sea-ice thickness cycles. Overall, the study highlights that regardless of the specific modeled configurations and conditions within individual proxy years, biases in sea-ice and snow thickness remain consistent, even when wind conditions are imposed in the nudged model simulations. This highlights the necessity for a better representation of modeled processes driving the sea-ice and snow thicknesses which will be instrumental in the next generation of GCMs. This first MOSAiC-based assessment of the modeled snow and ice thickness, and the proposed proxy-year-based methodology, pave the way for further meaningful model evaluation.
- 2 October 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-32
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-2214
The Arctic sea-ice cover and thickness have rapidly declined in the recent past. Snow cover on sea ice, acting as an insulating barrier, was shown to be instrumental in driving the variability and trends in sea-ice thickness. Because of this, the ability of climate models to realistically simulate the present-day annual cycles of Arctic sea-ice properties has become a central measure of model performance in Arctic-focused climate model intercomparisons. However, evaluating free-running model simulations usually requires multi-year observational datasets, which is challenged by the relatively short-term existing Arctic measurements particularly sea-ice and snow thickness. In this exploratory study, we propose a new methodology to improve the meaningfulness of sea ice and snow comparisons to model data. We make use of the exceptional year-long MOSAiC observations to examine the simulated Arctic sea-ice and snow thickness in 10 CMIP6 models. To perform meaningful comparisons with the modeled simulations, we define two “proxy years” selection methods based on sea-ice area and atmospheric criteria, when these conditions in the Arctic are similar to those during the MOSAiC year. We verify the capability of the proxy-year composites to capture the atmospheric and sea-ice variability, by comparing them with the sets of nudged simulations in which the atmospheric circulation observed during the MOSAiC year is directly imposed. Our results show that models tend to simulate similar annual cycles compared to the observations however, with an overestimation in amplitude for snow thickness and a misaligned phase of sea-ice thickness cycles. Overall, the study highlights that regardless of the specific modeled configurations and conditions within individual proxy years, biases in sea-ice and snow thickness remain consistent, even when wind conditions are imposed in the nudged model simulations. This highlights the necessity for a better representation of modeled processes driving the sea-ice and snow thicknesses which will be instrumental in the next generation of GCMs. This first MOSAiC-based assessment of the modeled snow and ice thickness, and the proposed proxy-year-based methodology, pave the way for further meaningful model evaluation.
- Open Access
- 4 September 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2024, 1-32
Evaluating Arctic Sea-Ice and Snow Thickness: A Proxy-Based Comparison of MOSAiC Data with CMIP6 Simulations
The Arctic sea-ice cover and thickness have rapidly declined in the recent past. Snow cover on sea ice, acting as an insulating barrier, was shown to be instrumental in driving the variability and trends in sea-ice thickness. Because of this, the ability of climate models to realistically simulate the present-day annual cycles of Arctic sea-ice properties has become a central measure of model performance in Arctic-focused climate model intercomparisons. However, evaluating free-running model simulations usually requires multi-year observational datasets, which is challenged by the relatively short-term existing Arctic measurements particularly sea-ice and snow thickness. In this exploratory study, we propose a new methodology to improve the meaningfulness of sea ice and snow comparisons to model data. We make use of the exceptional year-long MOSAiC observations to examine the simulated Arctic sea-ice and snow thickness in 10 CMIP6 models. To perform meaningful comparisons with the modeled simulations, we define two “proxy years” selection methods based on sea-ice area and atmospheric criteria, when these conditions in the Arctic are similar to those during the MOSAiC year. We verify the capability of the proxy-year composites to capture the atmospheric and sea-ice variability, by comparing them with the sets of nudged simulations in which the atmospheric circulation observed during the MOSAiC year is directly imposed. Our results show that models tend to simulate similar annual cycles compared to the observations however, with an overestimation in amplitude for snow thickness and a misaligned phase of sea-ice thickness cycles. Overall, the study highlights that regardless of the specific modeled configurations and conditions within individual proxy years, biases in sea-ice and snow thickness remain consistent, even when wind conditions are imposed in the nudged model simulations. This highlights the necessity for a better representation of modeled processes driving the sea-ice and snow thicknesses which will be instrumental in the next generation of GCMs. This first MOSAiC-based assessment of the modeled snow and ice thickness, and the proposed proxy-year-based methodology, pave the way for further meaningful model evaluation.
- 4 September 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2024, 1-32
Open AccessEvaluating Arctic Sea-Ice and Snow Thickness: A Proxy-Based Comparison of MOSAiC Data with CMIP6 Simulations
The Arctic sea-ice cover and thickness have rapidly declined in the recent past. Snow cover on sea ice, acting as an insulating barrier, was shown to be instrumental in driving the variability and trends in sea-ice thickness. Because of this, the ability of climate models to realistically simulate the present-day annual cycles of Arctic sea-ice properties has become a central measure of model performance in Arctic-focused climate model intercomparisons. However, evaluating free-running model simulations usually requires multi-year observational datasets, which is challenged by the relatively short-term existing Arctic measurements particularly sea-ice and snow thickness. In this exploratory study, we propose a new methodology to improve the meaningfulness of sea ice and snow comparisons to model data. We make use of the exceptional year-long MOSAiC observations to examine the simulated Arctic sea-ice and snow thickness in 10 CMIP6 models. To perform meaningful comparisons with the modeled simulations, we define two “proxy years” selection methods based on sea-ice area and atmospheric criteria, when these conditions in the Arctic are similar to those during the MOSAiC year. We verify the capability of the proxy-year composites to capture the atmospheric and sea-ice variability, by comparing them with the sets of nudged simulations in which the atmospheric circulation observed during the MOSAiC year is directly imposed. Our results show that models tend to simulate similar annual cycles compared to the observations however, with an overestimation in amplitude for snow thickness and a misaligned phase of sea-ice thickness cycles. Overall, the study highlights that regardless of the specific modeled configurations and conditions within individual proxy years, biases in sea-ice and snow thickness remain consistent, even when wind conditions are imposed in the nudged model simulations. This highlights the necessity for a better representation of modeled processes driving the sea-ice and snow thicknesses which will be instrumental in the next generation of GCMs. This first MOSAiC-based assessment of the modeled snow and ice thickness, and the proposed proxy-year-based methodology, pave the way for further meaningful model evaluation.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in The Cryosphere
- Vol. 17 (9) , 3721-3738
Assimilating CryoSat-2 freeboard to improve Arctic sea ice thickness estimates
In this study, a new method to assimilate freeboard (FB) derived from satellite radar altimetry is presented with the goal of improving the initial state of sea ice thickness predictions in the Arctic. In order to quantify the improvement in sea ice thickness gained by assimilating FB, we compare three different model runs: one reference run (refRun), one that assimilates only sea ice concentration (SIC) (sicRun), and one that assimilates both SIC and FB (fbRun). It is shown that estimates for both SIC and FB can be improved by assimilation, but only fbRun improved the FB. The resulting sea ice thickness is evaluated by comparing sea ice draft measurements from the Beaufort Gyre Exploration Project (BGEP) and sea ice thickness measurements from 19 ice mass balance (IMB) buoys deployed during the Multidisciplinary drifting Observatory for the Study of Arctic Climate (MOSAiC) expedition. The sea ice thickness of fbRun compares better than refRun and sicRun to the longer BGEP observations more poorly to the shorter MOSAiC observations. Further, the three model runs are compared to the Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI) weekly CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness, which is based on the same FB observations as those that were assimilated in this study. It is shown that the FB and sea ice thickness from fbRun are closer to the AWI CryoSat-2 values than the ones from refRun or sicRun. Finally, comparisons of the abovementioned observations and both the fbRun sea ice thickness and the AWI weekly CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness were performed. At the BGEP locations, both fbRun and the AWI CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness perform equally. The total root-mean-square error (RMSE) at the BGEP locations equals 30 cm for both sea ice thickness products. At the MOSAiC locations, fbRun's sea ice thickness performs significantly better, with a total 11 cm lower RMSE.
- 1 September 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in The Cryosphere
- Vol. 17 (9) , 3721-3738
Open AccessAssimilating CryoSat-2 freeboard to improve Arctic sea ice thickness estimates
In this study, a new method to assimilate freeboard (FB) derived from satellite radar altimetry is presented with the goal of improving the initial state of sea ice thickness predictions in the Arctic. In order to quantify the improvement in sea ice thickness gained by assimilating FB, we compare three different model runs: one reference run (refRun), one that assimilates only sea ice concentration (SIC) (sicRun), and one that assimilates both SIC and FB (fbRun). It is shown that estimates for both SIC and FB can be improved by assimilation, but only fbRun improved the FB. The resulting sea ice thickness is evaluated by comparing sea ice draft measurements from the Beaufort Gyre Exploration Project (BGEP) and sea ice thickness measurements from 19 ice mass balance (IMB) buoys deployed during the Multidisciplinary drifting Observatory for the Study of Arctic Climate (MOSAiC) expedition. The sea ice thickness of fbRun compares better than refRun and sicRun to the longer BGEP observations more poorly to the shorter MOSAiC observations. Further, the three model runs are compared to the Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI) weekly CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness, which is based on the same FB observations as those that were assimilated in this study. It is shown that the FB and sea ice thickness from fbRun are closer to the AWI CryoSat-2 values than the ones from refRun or sicRun. Finally, comparisons of the abovementioned observations and both the fbRun sea ice thickness and the AWI weekly CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness were performed. At the BGEP locations, both fbRun and the AWI CryoSat-2 sea ice thickness perform equally. The total root-mean-square error (RMSE) at the BGEP locations equals 30 cm for both sea ice thickness products. At the MOSAiC locations, fbRun's sea ice thickness performs significantly better, with a total 11 cm lower RMSE.
- Open Access
- 14 August 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2023, 1-25
The Variability of CryoSat-2 derived Sea Ice Thickness introduced by modelled vs. empirical snow thickness, sea ice density and water density
To derive sea ice thickness (SIT) from CryoSat-2 freeboard (FB) estimates, assumptions about snow thickness, snow density, sea ice density and water density need to be made. These parameters are close to impossible to observe alongside FB, so many existing products use climatologies, or empirical values. A resent study proposed to use model parameters for snow thickness, sea ice density and water density instead. In this study, we are evaluating this values against in situ observations and the commonly used climatologies and empirical values. We show that the snow thickness and water density is in better agreement with observations, and that the sea ice density is overall too light. Analyzing the difference in SIT resulting from the model parameter vs. the empirical values, we find that the snow thickness leads to the largest differences with up to 30 cm, closely followed by the sea ice density with 20 cm. For the water density we find an up to 7.5 cm difference, which is small in comparison to the snow thickness and sea ice density, but not negligible, as most studies currently argue. We find that the origin of the assumption that water density is negligible in the FB to SIT conversion originates from a study investing the seasonal Arctic sea ice density variability, not taking into account the spacial variability. For CryoSat-2 based SIT products we recommend to either use a water density climatology, or an uncertainty value of 2.5 kgm-3 instead of the commonly used value of 0 to 0.5 kgm-3.
- 14 August 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2023, 1-25
Open AccessThe Variability of CryoSat-2 derived Sea Ice Thickness introduced by modelled vs. empirical snow thickness, sea ice density and water density
To derive sea ice thickness (SIT) from CryoSat-2 freeboard (FB) estimates, assumptions about snow thickness, snow density, sea ice density and water density need to be made. These parameters are close to impossible to observe alongside FB, so many existing products use climatologies, or empirical values. A resent study proposed to use model parameters for snow thickness, sea ice density and water density instead. In this study, we are evaluating this values against in situ observations and the commonly used climatologies and empirical values. We show that the snow thickness and water density is in better agreement with observations, and that the sea ice density is overall too light. Analyzing the difference in SIT resulting from the model parameter vs. the empirical values, we find that the snow thickness leads to the largest differences with up to 30 cm, closely followed by the sea ice density with 20 cm. For the water density we find an up to 7.5 cm difference, which is small in comparison to the snow thickness and sea ice density, but not negligible, as most studies currently argue. We find that the origin of the assumption that water density is negligible in the FB to SIT conversion originates from a study investing the seasonal Arctic sea ice density variability, not taking into account the spacial variability. For CryoSat-2 based SIT products we recommend to either use a water density climatology, or an uncertainty value of 2.5 kgm-3 instead of the commonly used value of 0 to 0.5 kgm-3.