HGHolly Garrod

Holly Garrod

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Holly Garrod has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    What constitutes a community? A co-occurrence exploration of the Costa Rican avifauna

    by Mélusine F. Velde, Elizabeth M. Besozzi, Billi A. Krochuk, Kate M. Henderson, Brian R. Tsuru, Sara Velásquez Restrepo, Holly M. Garrod, Jacob C. Cooper

    The concept of a “community” as a form of organization for natural biological systems is both widespread and widely accepted within the ecological and biological sciences. Communities have been defined as groups of organisms that interact in ways that denote interdependence between individuals and taxa (e.g. as defined by “food webs”) but they have also been defined as groups of co-occurring organisms that are assumed to interact by virtue of their shared spatiotemporal existence. The latter definition has been debated and challenged in the literature, with mounting evidence for co-occurrence being more indicative of coincident ecological niches in space and time rather than being evidence of ecological interaction or dependency. Using a dataset of 460 Costa Rican bird species divided into breeding and non-breeding season datasets, we empirically demonstrate the ways in which co-occurrence can create illusory communities based on similar occupied ecological niches and similar patterns of co-occurrence at different times of year. We discuss the importance of discerning coincidental co-occurrence from true ecological interactions that would manifest a true community, and further address the importance of differentiating communities of co-occurrence from communities of demonstrable ecological interaction. While co-occurrence is a necessary aspect of interspecific interactions, we discuss and demonstrate here that such co-occurrence does not make a community, nor should explicit patterns of co-occurrence be seen as evidence for evolutionarily important ecological interactions.


  • Open Access

    Testing the accuracy of species distribution models based on community science data

    by Mélusine Velde, Jacob C. Cooper, Holly Garrod

    While traditional methods of tracking species, collecting specimens, and performing surveys are known to be accurate, additional opportunities to broaden the data pool are evolving. Community science data 5 has emerged as a new way of gathering large amounts of data, but little research has been done on its reliability for making models for novel locations. The goal of this project was to test the reliability of eBird data as the primary dataset for ecological niche modeling by determining the accuracy of models derived from the citizen-science based eBird dataset. I made species distribution models of 676 bird species in Costa Rica based on eBird observations to predict which species would be found in two localities in Costa Rica that were surveyed. I compared the predictions with these field surveys to determine the prediction success and Sorensen index of the models. Overall, I found that while spatio-temporal factors can affect the accuracy of ecological models, eBird data have great potential as data for species distribution modeling. The models more accurately predicted the community composition in the rural locality as opposed to the more urban locality, and the accuracy of the models increased when compared with data that covered two month as opposed to one month time periods. I tested to see how the number of observations per species influenced the predictive ability of the models and determined that an intermediate number of observations led to better models. These are important metrics to understand because modeling can be an informative and cost effective way to monitor inaccessible areas and can be used in conservation efforts.


  • Open Access

    OVERLAP IN MOLT AND BREEDING PHENOLOGY IN THE HISPANIOLAN WOODPECKER (MELANERPES STRIATUS)

    by Holly Garrod, Joshua B. LaPergola

    ∙ Molt patterns, often useful for determining age of individuals and, hence, demographic structure of a population, are generally poorly known for resident Neotropical birds. Neotropical woodpeckers are no exception to this latitudinal bias. We focused on the Hispaniolan Woodpecker (Melanerpes striatus) to study molt in regards to age and phenology. The objectives of this study were: (1) to provide the first description of the Hispaniolan Woodpecker’s molt pattern, and (2) to describe the relationship of molt within the breeding phenology. For six consecutive breeding seasons (March–July) from 2012 to 2017, we monitored a color‐banded population of the Hispaniolan Woodpeckers in a mid‐elevation (~ 600 m a.s.l.) landscape of wet forest fragments and cattle pastures in the Dominican Republic. We analyzed standardized photos taken during banding sessions to characterize patterns of retained and replaced feathers, resulting in an accurate method for aging. We found similarities in primary covert replacement and differences in secondary replacement patterns to those of congeners. Breeding birds, regardless of sex, were just as likely to be molting as non‐breeding birds showing breeding‐molt overlap. We suggest possible reasons for this pattern occurring in primarily tropical avian taxa including ample availability of resources and parasitism defense. This is one of the only studies to document this on an individual rather than population level.Resumen ∙ Sobreposición de la fenología de muda y la reproducción del carpintero de la española (Melanerpes striatus) Los patrones de muda, comúnmente utilizados para determinar la edad de los individuos y, por lo tanto, la estructura demográfica de una población, son poco conocidos para las aves residentes Neotropicales. Los pájaros carpinteros tropicales no son una excepción a este sesgo latitudinal. Nos centramos en el Carpintero de La Española (Melanerpes striatus) para estudiar la muda tanto en lo que respecta a la edad y la fenología. Los objetivos de este estudio fueron: (1) presentar la primera descripción del patrón de muda del Carpintero de la Española y (2) describir su relación con la fenología reproductiva. Durante seis temporadas reproductivas consecutivas, de marzo a julio, desde el 2012 a 2017, monitoreamos una población de Carpinteros de la Española marcados con anillos de color, en un paisaje de elevación media (~ 600 m s.n.m) compuesto por fragmentos de bosque húmedo y pasturas en la República Dominicana. Analizamos las fotos tomadas de manera estandarizada durante el anillamiento para identificar patrones retención y reemplazo de plumas viejas y nuevas. En base a estos resultados desarrollamos un método exacto para determinar la edad. Encontramos similitudes en los patrones del reemplazo de las cubiertas primarias y diferencias en patrones de reemplazo de secundarias con patrones descriptos para otras especies del género. No hubo diferencia en la probabilidad de encontrar muda en de pájaros carpinteros reproductores y los no reproductores, demostrando la superposición de muda y reproducción. Sugerimos causas por las cuales éste patrón ocurre principalmente aves tropicales, incluyendo un incremento en la disponibilidad de recursos y mecanismos de defensa de parásitos. Este es uno de los pocos estudios que documentan este patrón en un nivel individual en vez de población.