CMCalum MacNeil

Calum MacNeil

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Calum MacNeil has a total of 20 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Invading brown bullhead catfish (Ameiurus nebulosus) show thermal niche rigidity and benthic niche plasticity: implications for management

    by Paul J. Blanchfield, Tazi H. Rodrigues, Calum MacNeil, Simon D. Stewart, Finnbar Lee, Brendan J. Hicks, Shane Grayling, Soweeta Fort-D’ATh, Matthew J. Prentice, Cindy Baker, et al.

  • Fish Futures in the Aftermath of the Invasion of Aotearoa New Zealand by the Freshwater Gold Clam ( Corbicula fluminea )

    by Calum MacNeil

    In 2023, the gold / Asian clam ( Corbicula fluminea ) was first recorded in Aotearoa New Zealand (Aotearoa‐NZ). This non‐native species (NNS) could impact Aotearoa‐NZ freshwater ecosystems more than any previous invader. It could alter food webs, physical habitats and water clarity, disrupt nutrient cycling and restructure plankton / macroinvertebrate / fish assemblages. I have reviewed clam impacts on trophic ecology, water chemistry and fish habitat from international studies, focusing on native and non‐native fish species also present in Aotearoa‐NZ and on ecological analogues. I identified fish that could be negatively affected and those which could benefit. Small benthic ‘riffle‐run specialists’ could be vulnerable to some extent, facing both habitat modification and competition for shared food resources. Fish frequenting backwaters or slower‐flowing reaches could be even more vulnerable, as clam densities are often highest here. Native galaxiids, already threatened by habitat fragmentation/degradation, may be at further risk from additional pressures of a clam invasion. Among introduced fish, salmonids may lose spawning habitats, whereas generalist ‘pests’ such as catfish and koi may benefit from clam‐derived food resources. C. fluminea may represent a significant new stressor for Aotearoa‐NZ freshwater ecosystems. The hyptheses generated in this article are important to help anticipate species‐specific responses, which will be essential for strategies to protect native fish.

  • Open Access

    The biter bit; scavenging behaviour of native freshwater crayfish on the carrion of native and introduced fish predators in Aotearoa-New Zealand

    by Calum MacNeil, Finnbar Lee, Ian Kusabs, Robin Holmes

    Freshwater crayfish are important prey items for many fish but are themselves opportunistic scavengers of carcasses of predatory fish. In Aotearoa-New Zealand, kōura, the native freshwater crayfish Paranephrops planifrons , a culturally treasured ‘taonga’ species for indigenous Māori, suffer heavy predation from introduced fish. We investigated potential differences in kōura scavenging behaviour towards carrion of a co-evolved native predator, the long-finned eel Anguilla dieffenbachia and a non-native catfish predator, the brown bullhead Ameiurus nebulosus . Laboratory experiments showed kōura readily leave refugia to feed on dead predatory fish, with little discrimination between eel, catfish or marine (control) fish carcasses. There was no difference in kōura consumption rate of different fish and no difference in the calorific assimilation rate between eel and catfish. Our results suggest kōura will scavenge the carcasses of catfish that have died within invaded systems, even if this trophic interaction is not acknowledged in freshwater food web studies. Local catfish eradication programmes result in culls of thousands of catfish annually. These carcasses are currently wasted and we suggest they could be repurposed as a food resource for kōura, particularly in a future conservation-based aquaculture setting. This could help offset negative impacts the invader is currently having on native crayfish populations.


  • Open Access

    The social–ecological fabric of freshwater fish management: Accounting for feedback loops in human–fish interactions

    by Robin Holmes, Kiely McFarlane, Edward Challies, Calum MacNeil, Jason Arnold

    A holistic view of nature, which situates human relationships and actions within ecosystems, can broaden our understanding of environmental problems and expand the scope and efficacy of potential solutions. Social–ecological systems (SES) research attempts to take this broad perspective. However, a core challenge for the field is accounting for the complex nature of SES, which can develop self‐reinforcing feedback loops and unpredictable emergent properties. Here, in the context of freshwater ecosystems, we consider key conceptual frameworks that have emerged over recent decades to make sense of SES dynamics. We review selected international examples of freshwater SES before outlining three examples from the island nation of Aotearoa New Zealand. We focus on fish as key ecological components of freshwater SES because of their status as a focal point for cultural and social relationships with rivers and lakes worldwide. Within our SES examples, we highlight positive and negative feedback dynamics that either reinforce desired social–ecological states or create “social–ecological traps” that set freshwater systems on stubborn trajectories of degradation. Four SES features were common within our examples of feedback loops leading to social–ecological traps: (1) poor information flow between resource users and managers, (2) the exclusion of Indigenous people and local communities from resource governance, (3) altered hydrological regimes, and (4) introduced species. We suggest that identifying and addressing feedback loops with SES is a valuable focus for environmental management and should occur alongside efforts to promote deeper societal changes toward sustainability. Our conceptual review highlights the mechanics of freshwater SES feedback loops in the hope that further work in this field will widen the scope of sustainability‐focused actions in systems where freshwater fish play a key role.


  • Open Access

    Strangers in a strange land; freshwater fish introductions, impacts, management and socio-ecological feedbacks in a small island nation – the case of Aotearoa New Zealand

    by Calum MacNeil, Robin Holmes, Edward Challies, Kiely McFarlane, Jason Arnold

    Invasive non-native species (INNS) are key drivers of global biodiversity loss. This is particularly evident in freshwater ecosystems, where the rates of both vertebrate biodiversity loss and biological invasion exceed those of marine and terrestrial systems. Aotearoa New Zealand (henceforth Aotearoa) like many other island nations, has a troubled history with NNS. However, it is also unique, as the main islands were the last major landmasses on Earth to remain uninhabited by humans. The endemic fauna had evolved in isolation from any anthropogenic influence or introduced NNS, until the mid-thirteenth century with the arrival of Māori, the first people to inhabit Aotearoa. Centuries later, following European colonisation, many non-native freshwater fish were deliberately introduced by acclimatisation societies. Currently, most of the native freshwater fish species of Aotearoa are at risk of extinction, despite almost 90% of these being found nowhere else on earth. Many of these species are highly valued by the indigenous people of Aotearoa, who have repeatedly highlighted biases towards NNS in freshwater fish management. With the rate of biological invasions increasing, it is timely to address interconnected issues concerning the history, impacts, management and current / future policy directions, including those involving biosecurity, for non-native freshwater fish in Aotearoa. We do this by applying a social-ecological systems (SES) lens, with a focus on causal-loop relationships and feedbacks to improve understanding of the dynamics of drivers, mechanisms and impacts of such invasions. We highlight the tensions that have resulted from managing some NNS as ‘pests’ threatening native biodiversity, while simultaneously promoting a tourism and recreational fishery resource for specific NNS. This has generated extremely polarized views on the ‘status’ of non-native freshwater fish species and given rise to contradictory and divergent goals for their management. We show how a disjointed and often incoherent policy landscape has contributed to legal ‘anomalies’ for NNS, including policy misalignments and gaps, hampering effective use of resources, while also entrenching contradictory management programmes for different stakeholders. Our study shows how these interconnected issues have been manifested in social-ecological feedback loops on core aspects of NNS policy and management, past and present. Consequently, there is a need for increased comprehension of the diverse array of potential impacts of NNS for different environments, stakeholders and Māori while developing coherent and practical management methods to reduce such impacts and improve social-ecological resilience. We conclude that adopting a SES approach will aid this endeavour.


  • Open Access

    Transforming freshwater politics through metaphors: Struggles over ecosystem health, legal personhood, and invasive species in Aotearoa New Zealand

    by Marc Tadaki, Joanne Clapcott, Robin Holmes, Calum MacNeil, Roger Young

    Metaphor, defined as the linguistic substitution of one phenomenon for another, is ubiquitous in environmental science and policy. In science, when used well, metaphors help to make complex and abstract ideas familiar and relatable, while also helping people orient ethically to the natural world. In freshwater science, metaphors structure many aspects of scientific and lay understanding. Yet, while metaphors are often used in environmental science and advocacy, there is a need to join up our currently diffuse understandings about how metaphors can help achieve social transformation for sustainability. Here, we focus on how metaphors are enshrined into institutions, giving them permanence and force as tools for social transformation. We explore three examples of metaphors in environmental science and activism that have ‘gone public’ to shape freshwater politics and governance in Aotearoa New Zealand (henceforth Aotearoa NZ). We focus on the origins, strategic purposes and limitations of the metaphors, the ways they have been institutionalised, and the roles that scientists in particular have played in shaping metaphorical meanings. Metaphors perform diverse political tasks, from mobilising popular support for species removal, to reorienting human obligations to rivers, through to expanding the scope of vision for river management. Scientists play key roles in shaping both regulatory institutions as well as informal norms that affect metaphor implementation. Finally, what makes a ‘good’ metaphor needs to be evaluated in context of who is mobilising the metaphor and what their broader sustainability values and objectives are. Read the freePlain Language Summaryfor this article on the Journal blog.