Giordano Mancini
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Giordano Mancini has a total of 48 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Moreno Di Marco
Sapienza Università di Roma, Rome, Italy
13 shared publications - Luca Santini
Department of Biology and Biotechnologies “Charles Darwin”, Sapienza University of Rome Rome Italy
12 shared publications - Victor Cazalis
German Centre for Integrative Biodiversity Research (iDiv) Halle‐Jena‐Leipzig Leipzig Germany
9 shared publications - Pablo Miguel Lucas
Department of Biology and Biotechnologies “Charles Darwin” Sapienza Università di Roma Rome Italy
7 shared publications - Ana Benítez-López
Department of Biogeography and Global Change, Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales (MNCN-CSIC), Madrid, Spain
5 shared publications - H. Resit Akcakaya
Department of Ecology and Evolution Stony Brook University Stony Brook New York USA
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 April 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Cambridge Prisms: Extinction
- Vol. 4, e5
The risk of underestimating generation length for extinction risk assessments
Generation length is a key parameter for extinction risk assessment in the IUCN Red List, defining the biological horizon over which population decline is measured. Generation length data are largely unavailable, and a naive time frame of 10 years is often used to represent the three-generation horizon required for assessing decline in short-lived species. This assumption risks introducing biases in the assessment. Here, we quantified how using a 10-year time frame, instead of one based on predicted generation lengths, affects the extinction risk assessments of amphibians: one of the most imperiled groups worldwide. We measured past deforestation trends for 1,278 forest-dependent amphibian species and predicted future climate-driven habitat change for 1,559 species. Using predicted generation lengths systematically increased the percentage of declining species from deforestation (3–29%) and climate change (1–20%). This was also reflected in a higher proportion of species potentially assessed as threatened. Relying on a 10-year period to assess extinction risk can lead to substantial underestimations across both past and future time frames, compared to using predicted generation length. Predictions of generation length can allow applying IUCN Red List criteria in the absence of empirical data and improve consistency of extinction risk assessments.
- 27 April 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Cambridge Prisms: Extinction
- Vol. 4, e5
Open AccessThe risk of underestimating generation length for extinction risk assessments
Generation length is a key parameter for extinction risk assessment in the IUCN Red List, defining the biological horizon over which population decline is measured. Generation length data are largely unavailable, and a naive time frame of 10 years is often used to represent the three-generation horizon required for assessing decline in short-lived species. This assumption risks introducing biases in the assessment. Here, we quantified how using a 10-year time frame, instead of one based on predicted generation lengths, affects the extinction risk assessments of amphibians: one of the most imperiled groups worldwide. We measured past deforestation trends for 1,278 forest-dependent amphibian species and predicted future climate-driven habitat change for 1,559 species. Using predicted generation lengths systematically increased the percentage of declining species from deforestation (3–29%) and climate change (1–20%). This was also reflected in a higher proportion of species potentially assessed as threatened. Relying on a 10-year period to assess extinction risk can lead to substantial underestimations across both past and future time frames, compared to using predicted generation length. Predictions of generation length can allow applying IUCN Red List criteria in the absence of empirical data and improve consistency of extinction risk assessments.
- Open Access
Opportunities and challenges for applying Key Biodiversity Areas Criterion E at large spatial scales
Key Biodiversity Areas (KBAs) are a cornerstone of global biodiversity conservation, influencing international strategic plans and helping protect thousands of species. KBAs are identified through quantitative criteria, among which the most recent is Criterion E. KBA Criterion E uses Spatial Conservation Prioritization techniques to identify highly irreplaceable sites, representing a promising tool for effective expansion of the KBA network. However, it has rarely been tested or applied at large scales. Here, we carried out a continental application of KBA Criterion E in Europe, using Species Distribution Models (SDMs) for 5,529 species of insects and 972 tetrapods. We stress-tested the application of Criterion E by changing the following settings: irreplaceability threshold, metrics of irreplaceability, representation targets, spatial resolution, and cost of planning units. Under the standard Criterion E settings, we identified 23 potential KBAs for insects, mostly along northern European coasts, and 88 for tetrapods, mostly concentrated in Mediterranean islands and southern Europe. These sites slightly overlapped with existing KBAs, showing that Criterion E can capture biodiversity patterns overlooked by other criteria. Our results also showed that the identification of highly irreplaceable areas is very sensitive to analytical choices. The strict irreplaceability threshold currently required, associated with the definition of representation targets, limited the selection of important sites almost exclusively to those containing very narrow-range species, and when such species were absent, important sites were preferentially selected on coasts, where the cost of planning units (represented by land extent) was minimized. Our analysis showed both opportunities and challenges of Criterion E and its applications with SDMs. We propose potential adjustments to the definition and guidelines of Criterion E, to improve its applicability at large spatial scales and on different taxa. Improvements of KBA Criterion E will ensure that KBAs continue to substantially contribute to the global conservation of biodiversity.
Open AccessOpportunities and challenges for applying Key Biodiversity Areas Criterion E at large spatial scales
Key Biodiversity Areas (KBAs) are a cornerstone of global biodiversity conservation, influencing international strategic plans and helping protect thousands of species. KBAs are identified through quantitative criteria, among which the most recent is Criterion E. KBA Criterion E uses Spatial Conservation Prioritization techniques to identify highly irreplaceable sites, representing a promising tool for effective expansion of the KBA network. However, it has rarely been tested or applied at large scales. Here, we carried out a continental application of KBA Criterion E in Europe, using Species Distribution Models (SDMs) for 5,529 species of insects and 972 tetrapods. We stress-tested the application of Criterion E by changing the following settings: irreplaceability threshold, metrics of irreplaceability, representation targets, spatial resolution, and cost of planning units. Under the standard Criterion E settings, we identified 23 potential KBAs for insects, mostly along northern European coasts, and 88 for tetrapods, mostly concentrated in Mediterranean islands and southern Europe. These sites slightly overlapped with existing KBAs, showing that Criterion E can capture biodiversity patterns overlooked by other criteria. Our results also showed that the identification of highly irreplaceable areas is very sensitive to analytical choices. The strict irreplaceability threshold currently required, associated with the definition of representation targets, limited the selection of important sites almost exclusively to those containing very narrow-range species, and when such species were absent, important sites were preferentially selected on coasts, where the cost of planning units (represented by land extent) was minimized. Our analysis showed both opportunities and challenges of Criterion E and its applications with SDMs. We propose potential adjustments to the definition and guidelines of Criterion E, to improve its applicability at large spatial scales and on different taxa. Improvements of KBA Criterion E will ensure that KBAs continue to substantially contribute to the global conservation of biodiversity.
- Open Access
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 52 (11)
On the Importance of Expert‐Informed Variable Selection in Species Distribution Modelling
Aim: Species Distribution Models (SDMs) are widely used to map species distribution and predict future responses to climate change. While the risk of selecting biologically non‐relevant predictors has been raised, numerous studies continue to fully rely on statistical approaches to automatically select predictors solely focusing on climate variables. Yet, relying only on climate can have important implications for the reliability of the estimated relationships and predictions. Here, we illustrate the implications of ignoring species biology when modelling species distribution. Location: West Palearctic. Taxon: Boreus westwoodi Hagen, Crucianella maritima L., Rhinolophus hipposideros (Bechstein). Methods: We compared a naive, statistically‐informed model selection approach (relying on the full set of 19 bioclimatic variables) with expert‐informed models where we included only variables specifically linked to a species' biology. We tested our approach on three case study species: B. westwoodi , a Palaearctic insect related to snow cover; C. maritima , a Mediterranean coastal dune plant; and R. hipposideros , a forest bat occurring across Europe and the Middle East. Results: The two variable selection approaches identified different sets of variables as relevant in all case studies; although the models yielded similar predictive performance. This resulted in consistent differences between predictions under current and novel conditions, along with differences in interpretability of response curves, driven by variables with no clear ecological significance. Main Conclusions: We emphasise the importance of a thoughtful selection of predictors based on species biology over naive bioclimatic models. We argue that taxonomy, general adaptations and biome characteristics can guide variable selection when species‐specific information is lacking and that a rational exclusion of non‐relevant variables is often feasible even with limited knowledge. Strengthening the ecological foundation of SDMs will enhance their utility in climate change impact assessments and support biodiversity conservation efforts.
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 52 (11)
Open AccessOn the Importance of Expert‐Informed Variable Selection in Species Distribution Modelling
Aim: Species Distribution Models (SDMs) are widely used to map species distribution and predict future responses to climate change. While the risk of selecting biologically non‐relevant predictors has been raised, numerous studies continue to fully rely on statistical approaches to automatically select predictors solely focusing on climate variables. Yet, relying only on climate can have important implications for the reliability of the estimated relationships and predictions. Here, we illustrate the implications of ignoring species biology when modelling species distribution. Location: West Palearctic. Taxon: Boreus westwoodi Hagen, Crucianella maritima L., Rhinolophus hipposideros (Bechstein). Methods: We compared a naive, statistically‐informed model selection approach (relying on the full set of 19 bioclimatic variables) with expert‐informed models where we included only variables specifically linked to a species' biology. We tested our approach on three case study species: B. westwoodi , a Palaearctic insect related to snow cover; C. maritima , a Mediterranean coastal dune plant; and R. hipposideros , a forest bat occurring across Europe and the Middle East. Results: The two variable selection approaches identified different sets of variables as relevant in all case studies; although the models yielded similar predictive performance. This resulted in consistent differences between predictions under current and novel conditions, along with differences in interpretability of response curves, driven by variables with no clear ecological significance. Main Conclusions: We emphasise the importance of a thoughtful selection of predictors based on species biology over naive bioclimatic models. We argue that taxonomy, general adaptations and biome characteristics can guide variable selection when species‐specific information is lacking and that a rational exclusion of non‐relevant variables is often feasible even with limited knowledge. Strengthening the ecological foundation of SDMs will enhance their utility in climate change impact assessments and support biodiversity conservation efforts.
- Open Access
Generation length of the world's amphibians and reptiles
Variation in life histories influences demographic processes, from adaptive changes to population declines leading to extinction. Among life history traits, generation length offers a critical feature to forecast species' demographic trajectories such as population declines (widely used by the IUCN Red List) and adaptability to environmental change over time. Therefore, estimates of generation length are crucial to monitor demographic stability or predict future changes in highly threatened organisms, particularly amphibians and reptiles, which are particularly threatened among vertebrates and for which uncertainty in future impacts remains high. Despite its importance, generation length for amphibians and reptiles is largely missing. Here, we aim to fill in this gap by modeling generation lengths for amphibians, squamates and testudines as a function of species size, climate, life history and phylogeny using generalized additive models and phylogenetic generalized least squares. We estimated generation lengths for 5059 (57%) amphibians, 8722 (73%) squamates and 117 (32%) testudines. Our models performed well for most families (e.g. Bufonidae among amphibians, Lacertidae and Colubridae among squamates, and Geoemydidae among testudines) while we found high uncertainty around the prediction of a few families, notably Chamaeleonidae. Species' body size and mean temperature were the main predictors of generation length in all groups. Although our estimates are not meant to substitute robust and validated measurements from field studies or natural history museums, they can help reduce existing biases in conservation assessments until field data is comprehensively available.
Open AccessGeneration length of the world's amphibians and reptiles
Variation in life histories influences demographic processes, from adaptive changes to population declines leading to extinction. Among life history traits, generation length offers a critical feature to forecast species' demographic trajectories such as population declines (widely used by the IUCN Red List) and adaptability to environmental change over time. Therefore, estimates of generation length are crucial to monitor demographic stability or predict future changes in highly threatened organisms, particularly amphibians and reptiles, which are particularly threatened among vertebrates and for which uncertainty in future impacts remains high. Despite its importance, generation length for amphibians and reptiles is largely missing. Here, we aim to fill in this gap by modeling generation lengths for amphibians, squamates and testudines as a function of species size, climate, life history and phylogeny using generalized additive models and phylogenetic generalized least squares. We estimated generation lengths for 5059 (57%) amphibians, 8722 (73%) squamates and 117 (32%) testudines. Our models performed well for most families (e.g. Bufonidae among amphibians, Lacertidae and Colubridae among squamates, and Geoemydidae among testudines) while we found high uncertainty around the prediction of a few families, notably Chamaeleonidae. Species' body size and mean temperature were the main predictors of generation length in all groups. Although our estimates are not meant to substitute robust and validated measurements from field studies or natural history museums, they can help reduce existing biases in conservation assessments until field data is comprehensively available.
- Open Access
- 7 November 2024
- Published by Wiley in Diversity and Distributions
- Vol. 31 (2)
The Neglected Role of Sex‐Biased Dispersal in Range‐Shift Prediction Under Climate Change
Studies aimed at estimating species response to climate change generally employ correlative species distribution models (SDMs) coupled with dispersal scenarios. However, dispersal distances are generally lacking or nonrepresentative, so researchers typically estimate dispersal distance from allometric relationships. Yet, these estimates ignore the role of sex bias in dispersal—where one sex disperses more than the other—leading to important prediction errors. We collected sex‐specific dispersal data for 47 mammal species characterised by different levels of sex bias and projected their distribution under future climate scenarios, either considering or disregarding sex‐biased dispersal. Results reveal discrepancies that can be substantial for species with marked sex bias. Given the paucity of sex‐specific dispersal data, climate forecasting efforts should cautiously use a range of dispersal scenarios, favouring partial dispersal scenarios that are likely to encompass true species' range shifting abilities. Further research and data collection are crucial for refining predictions and understanding the ecological drivers of sex bias in dispersal across taxa.
- 7 November 2024
- Published by Wiley in Diversity and Distributions
- Vol. 31 (2)
Open AccessThe Neglected Role of Sex‐Biased Dispersal in Range‐Shift Prediction Under Climate Change
Studies aimed at estimating species response to climate change generally employ correlative species distribution models (SDMs) coupled with dispersal scenarios. However, dispersal distances are generally lacking or nonrepresentative, so researchers typically estimate dispersal distance from allometric relationships. Yet, these estimates ignore the role of sex bias in dispersal—where one sex disperses more than the other—leading to important prediction errors. We collected sex‐specific dispersal data for 47 mammal species characterised by different levels of sex bias and projected their distribution under future climate scenarios, either considering or disregarding sex‐biased dispersal. Results reveal discrepancies that can be substantial for species with marked sex bias. Given the paucity of sex‐specific dispersal data, climate forecasting efforts should cautiously use a range of dispersal scenarios, favouring partial dispersal scenarios that are likely to encompass true species' range shifting abilities. Further research and data collection are crucial for refining predictions and understanding the ecological drivers of sex bias in dispersal across taxa.
- Open Access
- 24 August 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Biological Conservation
- Vol. 298
Accelerating and standardising IUCN Red List assessments with sRedList
- 24 August 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Biological Conservation
- Vol. 298
Open AccessAccelerating and standardising IUCN Red List assessments with sRedList
- Open Access
- 1 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 38 (6) , e14316
Using comparative extinction risk analysis to prioritize the IUCN Red List reassessments of amphibians
Assessing the extinction risk of species based on the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Red List (RL) is key to guiding conservation policies and reducing biodiversity loss. This process is resource demanding, however, and requires continuous updating, which becomes increasingly difficult as new species are added to the RL. Automatic methods, such as comparative analyses used to predict species RL category, can be an efficient alternative to keep assessments up to date. Using amphibians as a study group, we predicted which species are more likely to change their RL category and thus should be prioritized for reassessment. We used species biological traits, environmental variables, and proxies of climate and land‐use change as predictors of RL category. We produced an ensemble prediction of IUCN RL category for each species by combining 4 different model algorithms: cumulative link models, phylogenetic generalized least squares, random forests, and neural networks. By comparing RL categories with the ensemble prediction and accounting for uncertainty among model algorithms, we identified species that should be prioritized for future reassessment based on the mismatch between predicted and observed values. The most important predicting variables across models were species’ range size and spatial configuration of the range, biological traits, climate change, and land‐use change. We compared our proposed prioritization index and the predicted RL changes with independent IUCN RL reassessments and found high performance of both the prioritization and the predicted directionality of changes in RL categories. Ensemble modeling of RL category is a promising tool for prioritizing species for reassessment while accounting for models’ uncertainty. This approach is broadly applicable to all taxa on the IUCN RL and to regional and national assessments and may improve allocation of the limited human and economic resources available to maintain an up‐to‐date IUCN RL.
- 1 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 38 (6) , e14316
Open AccessUsing comparative extinction risk analysis to prioritize the IUCN Red List reassessments of amphibians
Assessing the extinction risk of species based on the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Red List (RL) is key to guiding conservation policies and reducing biodiversity loss. This process is resource demanding, however, and requires continuous updating, which becomes increasingly difficult as new species are added to the RL. Automatic methods, such as comparative analyses used to predict species RL category, can be an efficient alternative to keep assessments up to date. Using amphibians as a study group, we predicted which species are more likely to change their RL category and thus should be prioritized for reassessment. We used species biological traits, environmental variables, and proxies of climate and land‐use change as predictors of RL category. We produced an ensemble prediction of IUCN RL category for each species by combining 4 different model algorithms: cumulative link models, phylogenetic generalized least squares, random forests, and neural networks. By comparing RL categories with the ensemble prediction and accounting for uncertainty among model algorithms, we identified species that should be prioritized for future reassessment based on the mismatch between predicted and observed values. The most important predicting variables across models were species’ range size and spatial configuration of the range, biological traits, climate change, and land‐use change. We compared our proposed prioritization index and the predicted RL changes with independent IUCN RL reassessments and found high performance of both the prioritization and the predicted directionality of changes in RL categories. Ensemble modeling of RL category is a promising tool for prioritizing species for reassessment while accounting for models’ uncertainty. This approach is broadly applicable to all taxa on the IUCN RL and to regional and national assessments and may improve allocation of the limited human and economic resources available to maintain an up‐to‐date IUCN RL.
- Open Access
Generation length of the world’s amphibians and reptiles
Variation in life histories influences demographic processes from adaptive changes to population declines leading to extinction. Among life history traits, generation length offers a critical feature to forecast species’ demographic trajectories such as population declines (widely used by the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species) and adaptability to environmental change over time. Therefore, estimates of generation length are crucial to monitor demographic stability or future change in highly threatened organisms, particularly ectothermic tetrapods (amphibians and reptiles) – which rank among the most threatened groups – but for which uncertainty in future impacts remains high. Despite its importance, generation length for amphibians and reptiles is largely missing. Here, we aimed to fill-in this gap by modeling generation lengths for amphibians, squamates and testudines as a function of species size, climate, life history, and phylogeny using generalized additive models and phylogenetic generalized least squares. We obtained estimates of generation lengths for 4,543 (52%) amphibians, 8,464 (72%) squamates and 118 (32%) testudines. Our models performed well for most families, for example Bufonidae in amphibians, Lacertidae and Colubridae in squamates and Geoemydidae in testudines, while we found high uncertainty around the prediction of a few families, notably Chamaeleonidae. Species’ body size and mean temperature were the main predictors of generation length in all groups. Although our estimates are not meant to substitute robust and validated measurements from field studies or natural history museums, they can help reduce existing biases in conservation assessments until field data will be comprehensively available.
Open AccessGeneration length of the world’s amphibians and reptiles
Variation in life histories influences demographic processes from adaptive changes to population declines leading to extinction. Among life history traits, generation length offers a critical feature to forecast species’ demographic trajectories such as population declines (widely used by the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species) and adaptability to environmental change over time. Therefore, estimates of generation length are crucial to monitor demographic stability or future change in highly threatened organisms, particularly ectothermic tetrapods (amphibians and reptiles) – which rank among the most threatened groups – but for which uncertainty in future impacts remains high. Despite its importance, generation length for amphibians and reptiles is largely missing. Here, we aimed to fill-in this gap by modeling generation lengths for amphibians, squamates and testudines as a function of species size, climate, life history, and phylogeny using generalized additive models and phylogenetic generalized least squares. We obtained estimates of generation lengths for 4,543 (52%) amphibians, 8,464 (72%) squamates and 118 (32%) testudines. Our models performed well for most families, for example Bufonidae in amphibians, Lacertidae and Colubridae in squamates and Geoemydidae in testudines, while we found high uncertainty around the prediction of a few families, notably Chamaeleonidae. Species’ body size and mean temperature were the main predictors of generation length in all groups. Although our estimates are not meant to substitute robust and validated measurements from field studies or natural history museums, they can help reduce existing biases in conservation assessments until field data will be comprehensively available.
- Open Access
- 2 February 2024
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 38 (3)
A standard approach for including climate change responses in IUCN Red List assessments
The International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Red List is a central tool for extinction risk monitoring and influences global biodiversity policy and action. But, to be effective, it is crucial that it consistently accounts for each driver of extinction. Climate change is rapidly becoming a key extinction driver, but consideration of climate change information remains challenging for the IUCN. Several methods can be used to predict species’ future decline, but they often fail to provide estimates of the symptoms of endangerment used by IUCN. We devised a standardized method to measure climate change impact in terms of change in habitat quality to inform criterion A3 on future population reduction. Using terrestrial nonvolant tetrapods as a case study, we measured this impact as the difference between the current and the future species climatic niche, defined based on current and future bioclimatic variables under alternative model algorithms, dispersal scenarios, emission scenarios, and climate models. Our models identified 171 species (13% out of those analyzed) for which their current red‐list category could worsen under criterion A3 if they cannot disperse beyond their current range in the future. Categories for 14 species (1.5%) could worsen if maximum dispersal is possible. Although ours is a simulation exercise and not a formal red‐list assessment, our results suggest that considering climate change impacts may reduce misclassification and strengthen consistency and comprehensiveness of IUCN Red List assessments.
- 2 February 2024
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 38 (3)
Open AccessA standard approach for including climate change responses in IUCN Red List assessments
The International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Red List is a central tool for extinction risk monitoring and influences global biodiversity policy and action. But, to be effective, it is crucial that it consistently accounts for each driver of extinction. Climate change is rapidly becoming a key extinction driver, but consideration of climate change information remains challenging for the IUCN. Several methods can be used to predict species’ future decline, but they often fail to provide estimates of the symptoms of endangerment used by IUCN. We devised a standardized method to measure climate change impact in terms of change in habitat quality to inform criterion A3 on future population reduction. Using terrestrial nonvolant tetrapods as a case study, we measured this impact as the difference between the current and the future species climatic niche, defined based on current and future bioclimatic variables under alternative model algorithms, dispersal scenarios, emission scenarios, and climate models. Our models identified 171 species (13% out of those analyzed) for which their current red‐list category could worsen under criterion A3 if they cannot disperse beyond their current range in the future. Categories for 14 species (1.5%) could worsen if maximum dispersal is possible. Although ours is a simulation exercise and not a formal red‐list assessment, our results suggest that considering climate change impacts may reduce misclassification and strengthen consistency and comprehensiveness of IUCN Red List assessments.
- Open Access
- 15 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 30 (1) , e17119
Modelling the probability of meeting IUCN Red List criteria to support reassessments
Comparative extinction risk analysis—which predicts species extinction risk from correlation with traits or geographical characteristics—has gained research attention as a promising tool to support extinction risk assessment in the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. However, its uptake has been very limited so far, possibly because existing models only predict a species' Red List category, without indicating which Red List criteria may be triggered. This prevents such approaches to be integrated into Red List assessments. We overcome this implementation gap by developing models that predict the probability of species meeting individual Red List criteria. Using data on the world's birds, we evaluated the predictive performance of our criterion‐specific models and compared it with the typical criterion‐blind modelling approach. We compiled data on biological traits (e.g. range size, clutch size) and external drivers (e.g. change in canopy cover) often associated with extinction risk. For each specific criterion, we modelled the relationship between extinction risk predictors and species' Red List category under that criterion using ordinal regression models. We found criterion‐specific models were better at identifying threatened species compared to a criterion‐blind model (higher sensitivity), but less good at identifying not threatened species (lower specificity). As expected, different covariates were important for predicting extinction risk under different criteria. Change in annual temperature was important for criteria related to population trends, while high forest dependency was important for criteria related to restricted area of occupancy or small population size. Our criteria‐specific method can support Red List assessors by producing outputs that identify species likely to meet specific criteria, and which are the most important predictors. These species can then be prioritised for re‐evaluation. We expect this new approach to increase the uptake of extinction risk models in Red List assessments, bridging a long‐standing research‐implementation gap.
- 15 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 30 (1) , e17119
Open AccessModelling the probability of meeting IUCN Red List criteria to support reassessments
Comparative extinction risk analysis—which predicts species extinction risk from correlation with traits or geographical characteristics—has gained research attention as a promising tool to support extinction risk assessment in the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. However, its uptake has been very limited so far, possibly because existing models only predict a species' Red List category, without indicating which Red List criteria may be triggered. This prevents such approaches to be integrated into Red List assessments. We overcome this implementation gap by developing models that predict the probability of species meeting individual Red List criteria. Using data on the world's birds, we evaluated the predictive performance of our criterion‐specific models and compared it with the typical criterion‐blind modelling approach. We compiled data on biological traits (e.g. range size, clutch size) and external drivers (e.g. change in canopy cover) often associated with extinction risk. For each specific criterion, we modelled the relationship between extinction risk predictors and species' Red List category under that criterion using ordinal regression models. We found criterion‐specific models were better at identifying threatened species compared to a criterion‐blind model (higher sensitivity), but less good at identifying not threatened species (lower specificity). As expected, different covariates were important for predicting extinction risk under different criteria. Change in annual temperature was important for criteria related to population trends, while high forest dependency was important for criteria related to restricted area of occupancy or small population size. Our criteria‐specific method can support Red List assessors by producing outputs that identify species likely to meet specific criteria, and which are the most important predictors. These species can then be prioritised for re‐evaluation. We expect this new approach to increase the uptake of extinction risk models in Red List assessments, bridging a long‐standing research‐implementation gap.