Ranit De
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Ranit De has a total of 64 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nuno Carvalhais
Max Planck Institute for Biogeochemistry
11 shared publications - Sujan Koirala
Max Planck Institute for Biogeochemistry
8 shared publications - Markus Reichstein
Biogeochemical Integration Max Planck Institute for Biogeochemistry Jena Germany
6 shared publications - Alexander Brenning
Department of Geography Friedrich Schiller University Jena Jena Germany
5 shared publications - Ankur Rashmikant Desai
Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, 53706, USA
5 shared publications Borja Ruiz Reverter
Departamento de Química e Física Universidade Federal da Paraíba ‐ Campus II Areia Brazil
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Science Data
- Vol. 18 (8) , 5895-5913
A global dataset of forest disturbance regimes derived from satellite biomass observations
Forests play a central role in the global carbon cycle by serving as critical carbon sinks for atmospheric CO 2 . Yet, the stability and continued capacity of these sinks are increasingly threatened by a growing number, size, and severity of disturbances. Accurately representing the stochastic nature of disturbance remains a major challenge and a key source of uncertainty in our understanding of carbon cycle dynamics. This study presents a novel framework for deriving disturbance regimes characterized by disturbance rate ( μ ), gap-size distribution ( α ), disturbance severity ( β ), as well as background mortality ( K b ) directly from landscape features of high-resolution satellite biomass data. These regimes reflect the characteristics of long-term disturbances at the landscape scale rather than the properties of any single event. Our analysis inverts the model framework developed by Wang et al. (2024), which used a machine learning model trained on a massive synthetic dataset of over 8 million forward model simulations to link known disturbance regimes to spatial biomass patterns. Instead of predicting patterns from regimes, we use observed satellite biomass patterns to infer the underlying disturbance regimes. To ensure robustness, we first identified the optimal spatial resolution for aggregating both simulation and satellite data, minimizing discrepancies in feature value ranges and reducing extrapolation risk. Using this framework, we produced the first globally continuous, observationally constrained dataset of forest disturbance regime parameters and their associated uncertainties, provided at both a 25×25 km tile level and as a gridded 0.25° global product. Additionally, we used a Dissimilarity Index (DIK) to quantify prediction uncertainty and identify potential extrapolation by measuring the divergence of observations from the training set. An empirical evaluation comparing paired forest landscapes with contrasting extremes in their predicted disturbance parameters support the methodology and assumptions used to build the dataset. The datasets are available at https://doi.org/10.17617/3.EF4QGR (Wang et al., 2026). Our global maps of disturbance regimes provide a novel, process-based tool for investigating the coupled dynamics of disturbance, vegetation, and the carbon cycle, with potential applications for improving the representation of stochastic disturbances in large-scale ecosystem models.
- 18 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Science Data
- Vol. 18 (8) , 5895-5913
Open AccessA global dataset of forest disturbance regimes derived from satellite biomass observations
Forests play a central role in the global carbon cycle by serving as critical carbon sinks for atmospheric CO 2 . Yet, the stability and continued capacity of these sinks are increasingly threatened by a growing number, size, and severity of disturbances. Accurately representing the stochastic nature of disturbance remains a major challenge and a key source of uncertainty in our understanding of carbon cycle dynamics. This study presents a novel framework for deriving disturbance regimes characterized by disturbance rate ( μ ), gap-size distribution ( α ), disturbance severity ( β ), as well as background mortality ( K b ) directly from landscape features of high-resolution satellite biomass data. These regimes reflect the characteristics of long-term disturbances at the landscape scale rather than the properties of any single event. Our analysis inverts the model framework developed by Wang et al. (2024), which used a machine learning model trained on a massive synthetic dataset of over 8 million forward model simulations to link known disturbance regimes to spatial biomass patterns. Instead of predicting patterns from regimes, we use observed satellite biomass patterns to infer the underlying disturbance regimes. To ensure robustness, we first identified the optimal spatial resolution for aggregating both simulation and satellite data, minimizing discrepancies in feature value ranges and reducing extrapolation risk. Using this framework, we produced the first globally continuous, observationally constrained dataset of forest disturbance regime parameters and their associated uncertainties, provided at both a 25×25 km tile level and as a gridded 0.25° global product. Additionally, we used a Dissimilarity Index (DIK) to quantify prediction uncertainty and identify potential extrapolation by measuring the divergence of observations from the training set. An empirical evaluation comparing paired forest landscapes with contrasting extremes in their predicted disturbance parameters support the methodology and assumptions used to build the dataset. The datasets are available at https://doi.org/10.17617/3.EF4QGR (Wang et al., 2026). Our global maps of disturbance regimes provide a novel, process-based tool for investigating the coupled dynamics of disturbance, vegetation, and the carbon cycle, with potential applications for improving the representation of stochastic disturbances in large-scale ecosystem models.
- Open Access
- 17 June 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 18 (6)
Inter–Annual Variability of Model Parameters Improves Simulation of Annual Gross Primary Production
Parametric uncertainty can hinder land surface models (LSM) from accurately simulating carbon fluxes, such as gross primary production (GPP). These models generally cannot capture inter–annual variability (IAV) of fluxes well due to missing processes, and temporally varying parameters can partially alleviate this limitation. We evaluated this assumption using two models: a light‐use efficiency (LUE) model with several environmental response functions, and an optimality‐based model that includes parameter acclimation and drought stress. De et al. (2025, https://doi.org/10.1029/2024MS004697 ) concluded that calibrating all parameters per site–year improves annual performance. As a follow‐up, we now inverted parameters of each environmental response function annually at a time, while simultaneously estimating year‐invariant optima for all other parameters, applying this across 198 eddy‐covariance sites. The IAV of GPP in arid sites was substantially improved when hydrological parameters varied annually, both for herbaceous and forest ecosystems. However, for tropical, temperate and boreal sites, IAV improved from annual variation of parameters controlling the GPP responses to temperature, light or atmospheric dryness. Given the paucity of arid and semi‐arid sites, allowing year‐specific parameters for vapor pressure deficit and atmospheric carbon dioxide effects yielded an overall median annual normalized Nash‐Sutcliffe efficiency of 0.733. Re‐evaluating some experiments from De et al. (2025, https://doi.org/10.1029/2024MS004697 ), we found that spatial variation of model parameters was higher than temporal variation, even though yearly varying parameters can improve annual performance. Our results challenge the existing perspective on temporally static parameterizations, reflecting the need to statistically learn temporal parameter variation from observations to improve IAV representation in LSMs.
- 17 June 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 18 (6)
Open AccessInter–Annual Variability of Model Parameters Improves Simulation of Annual Gross Primary Production
Parametric uncertainty can hinder land surface models (LSM) from accurately simulating carbon fluxes, such as gross primary production (GPP). These models generally cannot capture inter–annual variability (IAV) of fluxes well due to missing processes, and temporally varying parameters can partially alleviate this limitation. We evaluated this assumption using two models: a light‐use efficiency (LUE) model with several environmental response functions, and an optimality‐based model that includes parameter acclimation and drought stress. De et al. (2025, https://doi.org/10.1029/2024MS004697 ) concluded that calibrating all parameters per site–year improves annual performance. As a follow‐up, we now inverted parameters of each environmental response function annually at a time, while simultaneously estimating year‐invariant optima for all other parameters, applying this across 198 eddy‐covariance sites. The IAV of GPP in arid sites was substantially improved when hydrological parameters varied annually, both for herbaceous and forest ecosystems. However, for tropical, temperate and boreal sites, IAV improved from annual variation of parameters controlling the GPP responses to temperature, light or atmospheric dryness. Given the paucity of arid and semi‐arid sites, allowing year‐specific parameters for vapor pressure deficit and atmospheric carbon dioxide effects yielded an overall median annual normalized Nash‐Sutcliffe efficiency of 0.733. Re‐evaluating some experiments from De et al. (2025, https://doi.org/10.1029/2024MS004697 ), we found that spatial variation of model parameters was higher than temporal variation, even though yearly varying parameters can improve annual performance. Our results challenge the existing perspective on temporally static parameterizations, reflecting the need to statistically learn temporal parameter variation from observations to improve IAV representation in LSMs.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Towards Understanding the Inter-Annual Variation of Model Parameters Used to Simulate Gross Primary Productivity
A persistent challenge for models simulating carbon fluxes, such as gross primary productivity (GPP), is that the inter-annual variability (IAV) is currently not well-represented, often underestimating the peak GPP values, while also struggling with representing the onset and end of vegetation activity. We hypothesize that the difficulty with representing IAV can be attributed to temporally fixed model parameters, and yearly varying parameters can partially alleviate it. We test this hypothesis using two models: a simple light-use efficiency (LUE) model with response functions of solar radiation, air temperature, vapor pressure deficit, cloudiness, and soil water content, and an optimality-based model that includes parameter acclimation and drought stress. These functions have multiple parameters requiring calibration.First, we calibrated all the model parameters per site-year and found that both models can simulate annual GPP better with annually calibrated parameters (median normalized Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency, viz. NNSE: 0.74 for the LUE model) compared to parameter calibration per site (median NNSE: 0.5) or per plant functional types (median NNSE: 0.23). Thereafter, we focused on calibrating parameters of one environmental response function as year-specific (one function at a time), while simultaneously calibrating year-invariant parameters for all other functions. These exercises were conducted for 198 eddy-covariance sites. The ability to represent IAV of GPP in arid sites was substantially improved when hydrological parameters were allowed to vary between years, both for herbaceous and forest ecosystems. However, for tropical, temperate and boreal climates, improvements in IAV emerged from parametric variability controlling the GPP responses to temperature, light or atmospheric dryness. Given the paucity of arid and semi-arid sites in the dataset, allowing year-specific parameters for vapor pressure deficit and atmospheric CO2 effects yielded a median annual NNSE of 0.73 across the whole dataset for the LUE model. These results challenge our perception on temporally static parameterizations, reflecting the need to learn the empirical relationships between observations and temporally-varying parameters, or improve the representation of missing state variables. It further suggests that these may be strongly linked to below-ground plant dynamics, largely unobserved in current Earth observation networks.However, by analyzing mean absolute deviation of parameter values from per site and per site-year model calibrations, we found that temporal variation of parameters was lower than their spatial variation. For example, spatial variability of parameters, such as optimal temperature for photosynthesis, was 82.6% higher than temporal variability. Though we show that the temporal variability of model parameters is important to better capture the IAV of GPP flux, our analyses are currently limited to eddy-covariance sites, and only for the measurement periods at these sites.As a next step, further research is needed to explain or statistically learn the temporal variability of model parameters using environmental variables, which can be used to predict the spatiotemporal variability of model parameters at sites with no observational data or predict the future temporal trend of model parameters. This, in turn, will likely improve the performance of simulated IAV of GPP and, consequently, enhance our ability to represent unknown linkages between IAV and longer time scales.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessTowards Understanding the Inter-Annual Variation of Model Parameters Used to Simulate Gross Primary Productivity
A persistent challenge for models simulating carbon fluxes, such as gross primary productivity (GPP), is that the inter-annual variability (IAV) is currently not well-represented, often underestimating the peak GPP values, while also struggling with representing the onset and end of vegetation activity. We hypothesize that the difficulty with representing IAV can be attributed to temporally fixed model parameters, and yearly varying parameters can partially alleviate it. We test this hypothesis using two models: a simple light-use efficiency (LUE) model with response functions of solar radiation, air temperature, vapor pressure deficit, cloudiness, and soil water content, and an optimality-based model that includes parameter acclimation and drought stress. These functions have multiple parameters requiring calibration.First, we calibrated all the model parameters per site-year and found that both models can simulate annual GPP better with annually calibrated parameters (median normalized Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency, viz. NNSE: 0.74 for the LUE model) compared to parameter calibration per site (median NNSE: 0.5) or per plant functional types (median NNSE: 0.23). Thereafter, we focused on calibrating parameters of one environmental response function as year-specific (one function at a time), while simultaneously calibrating year-invariant parameters for all other functions. These exercises were conducted for 198 eddy-covariance sites. The ability to represent IAV of GPP in arid sites was substantially improved when hydrological parameters were allowed to vary between years, both for herbaceous and forest ecosystems. However, for tropical, temperate and boreal climates, improvements in IAV emerged from parametric variability controlling the GPP responses to temperature, light or atmospheric dryness. Given the paucity of arid and semi-arid sites in the dataset, allowing year-specific parameters for vapor pressure deficit and atmospheric CO2 effects yielded a median annual NNSE of 0.73 across the whole dataset for the LUE model. These results challenge our perception on temporally static parameterizations, reflecting the need to learn the empirical relationships between observations and temporally-varying parameters, or improve the representation of missing state variables. It further suggests that these may be strongly linked to below-ground plant dynamics, largely unobserved in current Earth observation networks.However, by analyzing mean absolute deviation of parameter values from per site and per site-year model calibrations, we found that temporal variation of parameters was lower than their spatial variation. For example, spatial variability of parameters, such as optimal temperature for photosynthesis, was 82.6% higher than temporal variability. Though we show that the temporal variability of model parameters is important to better capture the IAV of GPP flux, our analyses are currently limited to eddy-covariance sites, and only for the measurement periods at these sites.As a next step, further research is needed to explain or statistically learn the temporal variability of model parameters using environmental variables, which can be used to predict the spatiotemporal variability of model parameters at sites with no observational data or predict the future temporal trend of model parameters. This, in turn, will likely improve the performance of simulated IAV of GPP and, consequently, enhance our ability to represent unknown linkages between IAV and longer time scales.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Constraining vegetation turnover rates in Terrestrial Biosphere Model using L-band ALOS PALSAR backscatter
An improved representation of the carbon and water cycle dynamics in terrestrial ecosystems underpins a large uncertainty reduction in modeling Earth system dynamics. The climate sensitivity of ecosystem processes controls land-atmosphere interactions and the overall atmospheric carbon uptake and release dynamics across scales. Local and Earth observations of vegetation dynamics are key for the evaluation of our understanding and support the quantification of process representation in model development. Previous research has shown the importance in undermining equifinality using multi-variate observation constraints, focusing water and carbon fluxes and stocks.Long-wavelength radar backscatter provides unique insights into the dynamics of plant water and carbon dynamics when compared to optical EO products, as such, embeds the potential for constraining various parameters controlling local climate vegetation responses. In this study, we present an approach for assimilating L-band ALOS PALSAR backscatter data along with carbon and water fluxes measured at FLUXNET sites into a terrestrial ecosystem model to improve estimates of vegetation parameters turnover rates. A semi-empirical radiative transfer model, the Water Cloud Model (WCM), is employed as the observation operator linking modeled plant water content to L-band backscatter. Multiple model–data integration experiments are conducted to assess the added value of radar constraints across different model structures, including configurations with and without plant hydraulic schemes, and across temporal scales ranging from sub-daily to monthly.Our results indicate that assimilating L-band backscatter observations improves estimates of aboveground biomass and strengthens constraints on foliage and woody turnover rates. However, persistent equifinality between plant water and carbon cycle processes remains, highlighting the need for improved estimates of the WCM parameters. Ultimately, this study highlights the potential of L-band backscatter to enhance vegetation carbon cycle modeling, emphasizes the added value of the newly launched ESA BIOMASS mission, and underscores the importance of integrating vegetation water dynamics into carbon models.
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessConstraining vegetation turnover rates in Terrestrial Biosphere Model using L-band ALOS PALSAR backscatter
An improved representation of the carbon and water cycle dynamics in terrestrial ecosystems underpins a large uncertainty reduction in modeling Earth system dynamics. The climate sensitivity of ecosystem processes controls land-atmosphere interactions and the overall atmospheric carbon uptake and release dynamics across scales. Local and Earth observations of vegetation dynamics are key for the evaluation of our understanding and support the quantification of process representation in model development. Previous research has shown the importance in undermining equifinality using multi-variate observation constraints, focusing water and carbon fluxes and stocks.Long-wavelength radar backscatter provides unique insights into the dynamics of plant water and carbon dynamics when compared to optical EO products, as such, embeds the potential for constraining various parameters controlling local climate vegetation responses. In this study, we present an approach for assimilating L-band ALOS PALSAR backscatter data along with carbon and water fluxes measured at FLUXNET sites into a terrestrial ecosystem model to improve estimates of vegetation parameters turnover rates. A semi-empirical radiative transfer model, the Water Cloud Model (WCM), is employed as the observation operator linking modeled plant water content to L-band backscatter. Multiple model–data integration experiments are conducted to assess the added value of radar constraints across different model structures, including configurations with and without plant hydraulic schemes, and across temporal scales ranging from sub-daily to monthly.Our results indicate that assimilating L-band backscatter observations improves estimates of aboveground biomass and strengthens constraints on foliage and woody turnover rates. However, persistent equifinality between plant water and carbon cycle processes remains, highlighting the need for improved estimates of the WCM parameters. Ultimately, this study highlights the potential of L-band backscatter to enhance vegetation carbon cycle modeling, emphasizes the added value of the newly launched ESA BIOMASS mission, and underscores the importance of integrating vegetation water dynamics into carbon models.
- Open Access
- 23 January 2026
- Published by Wiley
Inter–annual Variability of Model Parameters Improves Simulation of Annual Gross Primary Production
Parametric uncertainty can hinder land surface models (LSM) from accurately simulating carbon fluxes, such as gross primary production (GPP). These models generally cannot capture inter–annual variability (IAV) of fluxes well due to missing processes, and temporally varying parameters can partially alleviate this limitation. We evaluated this assumption using two models: a light-use efficiency (LUE) model with several environmental response functions, and an optimality-based model that includes parameter acclimation and drought stress. De et al. (2025, https://doi.org/10.1029/2024MS004697 ) concluded that calibrating all parameters per site–year improves annual performance. As a follow-up, we now inverted parameters of each environmental response function annually at a time, while simultaneously estimating year-invariant optima for all other parameters, applying this across 198 eddy-covariance sites. The IAV of GPP in arid sites was substantially improved when hydrological parameters varied annually, both for herbaceous and forest ecosystems. However, for tropical, temperate and boreal sites, IAV improved from annual variation of parameters controlling the GPP responses to temperature, light or atmospheric dryness. Given the paucity of arid and semi-arid sites, allowing year-specific parameters for vapor pressure deficit and atmospheric carbon dioxide effects yielded an overall median annual normalized Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency of 0.733. Re-evaluating some experiments from De et al. (2025, https://doi.org/10.1029/2024MS004697 ), we found that spatial variation of model parameters was higher than temporal variation, even though yearly varying parameters can improve annual performance. Our results challenge the existing perspective on temporally static parameterizations, reflecting the need to statistically learn temporal parameter variation from observations to improve IAV representation in LSMs.
- 23 January 2026
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessInter–annual Variability of Model Parameters Improves Simulation of Annual Gross Primary Production
Parametric uncertainty can hinder land surface models (LSM) from accurately simulating carbon fluxes, such as gross primary production (GPP). These models generally cannot capture inter–annual variability (IAV) of fluxes well due to missing processes, and temporally varying parameters can partially alleviate this limitation. We evaluated this assumption using two models: a light-use efficiency (LUE) model with several environmental response functions, and an optimality-based model that includes parameter acclimation and drought stress. De et al. (2025, https://doi.org/10.1029/2024MS004697 ) concluded that calibrating all parameters per site–year improves annual performance. As a follow-up, we now inverted parameters of each environmental response function annually at a time, while simultaneously estimating year-invariant optima for all other parameters, applying this across 198 eddy-covariance sites. The IAV of GPP in arid sites was substantially improved when hydrological parameters varied annually, both for herbaceous and forest ecosystems. However, for tropical, temperate and boreal sites, IAV improved from annual variation of parameters controlling the GPP responses to temperature, light or atmospheric dryness. Given the paucity of arid and semi-arid sites, allowing year-specific parameters for vapor pressure deficit and atmospheric carbon dioxide effects yielded an overall median annual normalized Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency of 0.733. Re-evaluating some experiments from De et al. (2025, https://doi.org/10.1029/2024MS004697 ), we found that spatial variation of model parameters was higher than temporal variation, even though yearly varying parameters can improve annual performance. Our results challenge the existing perspective on temporally static parameterizations, reflecting the need to statistically learn temporal parameter variation from observations to improve IAV representation in LSMs.
- Open Access
- 28 April 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 17 (5)
Addressing Challenges in Simulating Inter–Annual Variability of Gross Primary Production
A long‐standing challenge in studying the global carbon cycle has been understanding the factors controlling inter–annual variation (IAV) of carbon fluxes, and improving their representations in existing biogeochemical models. Here, we compared an optimality‐based model and a semi‐empirical light use efficiency model to understand how current models can be improved to simulate IAV of gross primary production (GPP). Both models simulated hourly GPP and were parameterized for (a) each site–year, (b) each site with an additional constraint on IAV (), (c) each site, (d) each plant–functional type, and (e) globally. This was followed by forward runs using calibrated parameters, and model evaluations using Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) as a model‐fitness measure at different temporal scales across 198 eddy‐covariance sites representing diverse climate–vegetation types. Both models simulated hourly GPP better (median normalized NSE: 0.83 and 0.85) than annual GPP (median normalized NSE: 0.54 and 0.63) for most sites. Specifically, the optimality‐based model substantially improved from NSE of −1.39 to 0.92 when drought stress was explicitly included. Most of the variability in model performances was due to model types and parameterization strategies. The semi‐empirical model produced statistically better hourly simulations than the optimality‐based model, and site–year parameterization yielded better annual model performance. Annual model performance did not improve even when parameterized using . Furthermore, both models underestimated the peaks of diurnal GPP, suggesting that improving predictions of peaks could produce better annual model performance. Our findings reveal current modeling deficiencies in representing IAV of carbon fluxes and guide improvements in further model development.
- 28 April 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 17 (5)
Open AccessAddressing Challenges in Simulating Inter–Annual Variability of Gross Primary Production
A long‐standing challenge in studying the global carbon cycle has been understanding the factors controlling inter–annual variation (IAV) of carbon fluxes, and improving their representations in existing biogeochemical models. Here, we compared an optimality‐based model and a semi‐empirical light use efficiency model to understand how current models can be improved to simulate IAV of gross primary production (GPP). Both models simulated hourly GPP and were parameterized for (a) each site–year, (b) each site with an additional constraint on IAV (), (c) each site, (d) each plant–functional type, and (e) globally. This was followed by forward runs using calibrated parameters, and model evaluations using Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) as a model‐fitness measure at different temporal scales across 198 eddy‐covariance sites representing diverse climate–vegetation types. Both models simulated hourly GPP better (median normalized NSE: 0.83 and 0.85) than annual GPP (median normalized NSE: 0.54 and 0.63) for most sites. Specifically, the optimality‐based model substantially improved from NSE of −1.39 to 0.92 when drought stress was explicitly included. Most of the variability in model performances was due to model types and parameterization strategies. The semi‐empirical model produced statistically better hourly simulations than the optimality‐based model, and site–year parameterization yielded better annual model performance. Annual model performance did not improve even when parameterized using . Furthermore, both models underestimated the peaks of diurnal GPP, suggesting that improving predictions of peaks could produce better annual model performance. Our findings reveal current modeling deficiencies in representing IAV of carbon fluxes and guide improvements in further model development.
- Open Access
- 28 January 2025
- Published by Wiley
Addressing Challenges in Simulating Inter-annual Variability of Gross Primary Production
A long-standing challenge in studying the global carbon cycle has been understanding the factors controlling inter–annual variation (IAV) of carbon fluxes, and improving their representations in existing biogeochemical models. Here, we compared an optimality-based model and a semi-empirical light use efficiency model to understand how current models can be improved to simulate IAV of gross primary production (GPP). Both models simulated hourly GPP and were parameterized for (1) each site–year, (2) each site with an additional constraint on IAV ( Cost IAV ), (3) each site, (4) each plant–functional type, and (5) globally. This was followed by forward runs using calibrated parameters, and model evaluations using Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) as a model-fitness measure at different temporal scales across 198 eddy-covariance sites representing diverse climate–vegetation types. Both models simulated hourly GPP better (median normalized NSE: 0.83 and 0.85) than annual GPP (median normalized NSE: 0.54 and 0.63) for most sites. Specifically, the optimality-based model substantially improved from NSE of -1.39 to 0.92 when drought stress was explicitly included. Most of the variability in model performances was due to model types and parameterization strategies. The semi-empirical model produced statistically better hourly simulations than the optimality-based model, and site–year parameterization yielded better annual model performance. Annual model performance did not improve even when parameterized using Cost IAV . Furthermore, both models underestimated the peaks of diurnal GPP, suggesting that improving predictions of peaks could produce better annual model performance. Our findings reveal current modelling deficiencies in representing IAV of carbon fluxes and guide improvements in further model development.
- 28 January 2025
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessAddressing Challenges in Simulating Inter-annual Variability of Gross Primary Production
A long-standing challenge in studying the global carbon cycle has been understanding the factors controlling inter–annual variation (IAV) of carbon fluxes, and improving their representations in existing biogeochemical models. Here, we compared an optimality-based model and a semi-empirical light use efficiency model to understand how current models can be improved to simulate IAV of gross primary production (GPP). Both models simulated hourly GPP and were parameterized for (1) each site–year, (2) each site with an additional constraint on IAV ( Cost IAV ), (3) each site, (4) each plant–functional type, and (5) globally. This was followed by forward runs using calibrated parameters, and model evaluations using Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) as a model-fitness measure at different temporal scales across 198 eddy-covariance sites representing diverse climate–vegetation types. Both models simulated hourly GPP better (median normalized NSE: 0.83 and 0.85) than annual GPP (median normalized NSE: 0.54 and 0.63) for most sites. Specifically, the optimality-based model substantially improved from NSE of -1.39 to 0.92 when drought stress was explicitly included. Most of the variability in model performances was due to model types and parameterization strategies. The semi-empirical model produced statistically better hourly simulations than the optimality-based model, and site–year parameterization yielded better annual model performance. Annual model performance did not improve even when parameterized using Cost IAV . Furthermore, both models underestimated the peaks of diurnal GPP, suggesting that improving predictions of peaks could produce better annual model performance. Our findings reveal current modelling deficiencies in representing IAV of carbon fluxes and guide improvements in further model development.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Evaluating a generic parameterization approach for modelling photosynthesis across eddy-covariance sites
Earth’s climate is strongly influenced by global biogeochemical cycles. Atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) is the main component of one of the most crucial biogeochemical cycles, i.e., the carbon cycle. Terrestrial ecosystems can regulate the atmospheric CO2 concentration, and absorb a substantial fraction of anthropogenic emissions via photosynthesis. Quantifying and understanding the rate of carbon assimilation through photosynthesis, or gross primary production (GPP), at different spatial and temporal scales, is of utmost importance.In this direction, the development of an eco-evolutionary optimality (EEO) perspective on ecophysiological plant parameters has been proposed as a robust theoretical framework to capture GPP dynamics. Its translation into modelling frameworks has been proposed by combining the least-cost and coordination principles and implemented in big leaf light use efficiency models. These models have been contrasted against in situ observations of carbon fluxes from FLUXNET at daily and sub-daily scales, distinguishing between instantaneous (fast) and acclimated (long-time) biochemical and stomatal response of leaf for the latter case. A fundamental assumption and difference to many other modelling approaches is the constant parameterization across all plant-functional-types (PFT) in this case. We further investigate the applicability of the approach in this study.We simulate half-hourly GPP across 191 FLUXNET sites, representing a wide variety of vegetation and climatic zones to evaluate the extent of observational support to a global EEO approach as implemented in the P-model (Mengoli et al., 2022). Model assessment metrics such as Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE), root mean squared error (RMSE), and coefficient of determination (R2) were calculated between observed and simulated GPP at various timescales for this purpose. The analysis is performed globally, but also within PFT and bioclimatic regimes. Furthermore, we relax the acclimation time-periods, gradually from 1 to 80 days, to identify potential changes in acclimation windows between sites and how it varies across PFTs.Negative values of NSE, suggesting poor model performance, were found for almost 50% of sites at half-hourly, daily, weekly, and monthly timescales. Specifically, inter-annual variability of GPP cannot be reproduced for most of the sites when sub-daily GPP was aggregated to annual values. It was observed that the model performs better in croplands, followed by mixed and deciduous broadleaf forests, and then grasslands and savannas. The model can perform better at boreal and temperate sites than at tropical and arid sites. Moreover, we found different time-period of acclimation across different PFT, for example, croplands have an average timescale of 10-15 days for acclimation whereas it is 75-80 days for evergreen needle leaf forests.One known limiting aspect in the current implementation is the lack of the effects of soil water limitation on photosynthesis. As a consequence, we found that model performance was positively correlated with the aridity index of sites. Specifically, model fails to capture annual GPP at arid sites. We further analyse and discuss how exploring soil moisture effects on photosynthesis parameters may lend support to this framework although model performance across some of the energy demand driven sites suggests a cautionary remark on the applicability of the approach.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessEvaluating a generic parameterization approach for modelling photosynthesis across eddy-covariance sites
Earth’s climate is strongly influenced by global biogeochemical cycles. Atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) is the main component of one of the most crucial biogeochemical cycles, i.e., the carbon cycle. Terrestrial ecosystems can regulate the atmospheric CO2 concentration, and absorb a substantial fraction of anthropogenic emissions via photosynthesis. Quantifying and understanding the rate of carbon assimilation through photosynthesis, or gross primary production (GPP), at different spatial and temporal scales, is of utmost importance.In this direction, the development of an eco-evolutionary optimality (EEO) perspective on ecophysiological plant parameters has been proposed as a robust theoretical framework to capture GPP dynamics. Its translation into modelling frameworks has been proposed by combining the least-cost and coordination principles and implemented in big leaf light use efficiency models. These models have been contrasted against in situ observations of carbon fluxes from FLUXNET at daily and sub-daily scales, distinguishing between instantaneous (fast) and acclimated (long-time) biochemical and stomatal response of leaf for the latter case. A fundamental assumption and difference to many other modelling approaches is the constant parameterization across all plant-functional-types (PFT) in this case. We further investigate the applicability of the approach in this study.We simulate half-hourly GPP across 191 FLUXNET sites, representing a wide variety of vegetation and climatic zones to evaluate the extent of observational support to a global EEO approach as implemented in the P-model (Mengoli et al., 2022). Model assessment metrics such as Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE), root mean squared error (RMSE), and coefficient of determination (R2) were calculated between observed and simulated GPP at various timescales for this purpose. The analysis is performed globally, but also within PFT and bioclimatic regimes. Furthermore, we relax the acclimation time-periods, gradually from 1 to 80 days, to identify potential changes in acclimation windows between sites and how it varies across PFTs.Negative values of NSE, suggesting poor model performance, were found for almost 50% of sites at half-hourly, daily, weekly, and monthly timescales. Specifically, inter-annual variability of GPP cannot be reproduced for most of the sites when sub-daily GPP was aggregated to annual values. It was observed that the model performs better in croplands, followed by mixed and deciduous broadleaf forests, and then grasslands and savannas. The model can perform better at boreal and temperate sites than at tropical and arid sites. Moreover, we found different time-period of acclimation across different PFT, for example, croplands have an average timescale of 10-15 days for acclimation whereas it is 75-80 days for evergreen needle leaf forests.One known limiting aspect in the current implementation is the lack of the effects of soil water limitation on photosynthesis. As a consequence, we found that model performance was positively correlated with the aridity index of sites. Specifically, model fails to capture annual GPP at arid sites. We further analyse and discuss how exploring soil moisture effects on photosynthesis parameters may lend support to this framework although model performance across some of the energy demand driven sites suggests a cautionary remark on the applicability of the approach.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Towards Robust Parameterizations in Ecosystem-level Photosynthesis Models
Photosynthesis model parameters represent vegetation properties or sensitivities of photosynthesis processes. As one of the model uncertainty sources, parameters affect the accuracy and generalizability of the model. Ideally, parameters of ecosystem-level photosynthesis models, i.e., gross primary productivity (GPP) models, can be measured or inversed from observations at the local scale. To extrapolate parameters to a larger spatial scale, current photosynthesis models typically adopted fixed values or plant-functional-type(PFT)-specific values. However, the fixed and PFT-based parameterization approaches cannot capture sufficiently the spatial variability of parameters and lead to significant estimation errors. Here, we propose a Simultaneous Parameter Inversion and Extrapolation approach (SPIE) to overcome these issues. SPIE refers to predicting model parameters using an artificial neural network (NN) constrained by both model loss and ecosystem features including PFT, climate types, bioclimatic variables, vegetation features, atmospheric nitrogen and phosphorus deposition and soil properties. Taking a light use efficiency (LUE) model as an example, we evaluated SPIE at 196 FLUXNET eddy covariance flux sites. The LUE model accounts for the effects of air temperature, vapor pressure deficit, soil water availability (SW), light saturation, diffuse radiation fraction and CO2 on GPP using five independent sensitivity functions. The SW was represented using the water availability index and can be optimized based on evapotranspiration. Thus, we optimized the NN by minimizing the model loss which consists of GPP errors, evapotranspiration errors, and constraints on sensitivity functions. Furthermore, we compared SPIE with 11 typical parameter extrapolating approaches, including PFT- and climate-specific parameterizations, global and PFT-based parameter optimization, site-similarity, and regression methods using Nash-Sutcliffe model efficiency (NSE), determination coefficient (R2) and normalized root mean squared error (NRMSE).The results in ten-fold cross-validation showed that SPIE had the best performance across various temporal and spatial scales and across assessing metrics. None of the parameter extrapolating approaches reached the same performance as the on-site calibrated parameters (NSE=0.95), but SPIE was the only approach showing positive NSE (=0.68) in cross-validation across sites. Moreover, the site-level NSE, R2, and NRMSE of SPIE all significantly outperformed per biome and per climate type. Ranges of parameters were more constrained by SPIE than site calibrations.Overall, SPIE is a robust parameter extrapolation approach that overcomes strong limitations observed in many of the standard model parameterization approaches. Our approach suggests that model parameterizations can be determined from observations of vegetation, climate and soil properties, and expands from customary clustering methods (e.g., PFT-specific parameterization). We argue that expanding SPIE to other models overcomes current limits in parameterization and serves as an entry point to investigate the robustness and generalization of different models.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessTowards Robust Parameterizations in Ecosystem-level Photosynthesis Models
Photosynthesis model parameters represent vegetation properties or sensitivities of photosynthesis processes. As one of the model uncertainty sources, parameters affect the accuracy and generalizability of the model. Ideally, parameters of ecosystem-level photosynthesis models, i.e., gross primary productivity (GPP) models, can be measured or inversed from observations at the local scale. To extrapolate parameters to a larger spatial scale, current photosynthesis models typically adopted fixed values or plant-functional-type(PFT)-specific values. However, the fixed and PFT-based parameterization approaches cannot capture sufficiently the spatial variability of parameters and lead to significant estimation errors. Here, we propose a Simultaneous Parameter Inversion and Extrapolation approach (SPIE) to overcome these issues. SPIE refers to predicting model parameters using an artificial neural network (NN) constrained by both model loss and ecosystem features including PFT, climate types, bioclimatic variables, vegetation features, atmospheric nitrogen and phosphorus deposition and soil properties. Taking a light use efficiency (LUE) model as an example, we evaluated SPIE at 196 FLUXNET eddy covariance flux sites. The LUE model accounts for the effects of air temperature, vapor pressure deficit, soil water availability (SW), light saturation, diffuse radiation fraction and CO2 on GPP using five independent sensitivity functions. The SW was represented using the water availability index and can be optimized based on evapotranspiration. Thus, we optimized the NN by minimizing the model loss which consists of GPP errors, evapotranspiration errors, and constraints on sensitivity functions. Furthermore, we compared SPIE with 11 typical parameter extrapolating approaches, including PFT- and climate-specific parameterizations, global and PFT-based parameter optimization, site-similarity, and regression methods using Nash-Sutcliffe model efficiency (NSE), determination coefficient (R2) and normalized root mean squared error (NRMSE).The results in ten-fold cross-validation showed that SPIE had the best performance across various temporal and spatial scales and across assessing metrics. None of the parameter extrapolating approaches reached the same performance as the on-site calibrated parameters (NSE=0.95), but SPIE was the only approach showing positive NSE (=0.68) in cross-validation across sites. Moreover, the site-level NSE, R2, and NRMSE of SPIE all significantly outperformed per biome and per climate type. Ranges of parameters were more constrained by SPIE than site calibrations.Overall, SPIE is a robust parameter extrapolation approach that overcomes strong limitations observed in many of the standard model parameterization approaches. Our approach suggests that model parameterizations can be determined from observations of vegetation, climate and soil properties, and expands from customary clustering methods (e.g., PFT-specific parameterization). We argue that expanding SPIE to other models overcomes current limits in parameterization and serves as an entry point to investigate the robustness and generalization of different models.
- Open Access
- 6 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in ESS Open Archive
Towards Robust Parameterizations in Ecosystem-level Photosynthesis Models
In a model simulating dynamics of a system, parameters can represent system sensitivities and unresolved processes, therefore affecting model accuracy and uncertainty. Taking a light use efficiency (LUE) model as an example, which is a typical approach to estimate gross primary productivity (GPP), we propose a Simultaneous Parameter Inversion and Extrapolation approach (SPIE) to overcome issues stemming from plant-functional-type(PFT)-dependent parameterizations. SPIE refers to predicting model parameters using an artificial neural network based on collected variables, including PFT, climate types, bioclimatic variables, vegetation features, atmospheric nitrogen and phosphorus deposition and soil properties. The neural network was optimized to minimize GPP errors and constrain LUE model sensitivity functions. We compared SPIE with 11 typical parameter extrapolating methods, including PFT- and climate-specific parameterizations, global and PFT-based parameter optimization, site-similarity, and regression approaches. All methods were assessed using Nash-Sutcliffe model efficiency(NSE), determination coefficient and normalized root mean squared error, and contrasted with site-specific calibrations. Ten-fold cross-validated results showed that SPIE had the best performance across sites, various temporal scales and assessing metrics. None of the approaches performed similar to site-level calibrations(NSE=0.95), but SPIE was the only approach showing positive NSE(0.68). The Shapley value, layer-wise relevance and partial dependence showed that vegetation features, bioclimatic variables, soil properties and some PFTs are determining parameters. The proposed parameter extrapolation approach overcomes strong limitations observed in many standard parameterization methods. We argue that expanding SPIE to other models overcomes current limits and serves as an entry point to investigate the robustness and generalization of different models.
- 6 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in ESS Open Archive
Open AccessTowards Robust Parameterizations in Ecosystem-level Photosynthesis Models
In a model simulating dynamics of a system, parameters can represent system sensitivities and unresolved processes, therefore affecting model accuracy and uncertainty. Taking a light use efficiency (LUE) model as an example, which is a typical approach to estimate gross primary productivity (GPP), we propose a Simultaneous Parameter Inversion and Extrapolation approach (SPIE) to overcome issues stemming from plant-functional-type(PFT)-dependent parameterizations. SPIE refers to predicting model parameters using an artificial neural network based on collected variables, including PFT, climate types, bioclimatic variables, vegetation features, atmospheric nitrogen and phosphorus deposition and soil properties. The neural network was optimized to minimize GPP errors and constrain LUE model sensitivity functions. We compared SPIE with 11 typical parameter extrapolating methods, including PFT- and climate-specific parameterizations, global and PFT-based parameter optimization, site-similarity, and regression approaches. All methods were assessed using Nash-Sutcliffe model efficiency(NSE), determination coefficient and normalized root mean squared error, and contrasted with site-specific calibrations. Ten-fold cross-validated results showed that SPIE had the best performance across sites, various temporal scales and assessing metrics. None of the approaches performed similar to site-level calibrations(NSE=0.95), but SPIE was the only approach showing positive NSE(0.68). The Shapley value, layer-wise relevance and partial dependence showed that vegetation features, bioclimatic variables, soil properties and some PFTs are determining parameters. The proposed parameter extrapolation approach overcomes strong limitations observed in many standard parameterization methods. We argue that expanding SPIE to other models overcomes current limits and serves as an entry point to investigate the robustness and generalization of different models.