Gabriele Benedetti
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Gabriele Benedetti has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Andrea Bistacchi
Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University Milano Bicocca, Milan, 20126, Italy
24 shared publications Daniela Bertacchi
Dipartimento di Matematica e Applicazioni, Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, Milan, 20125, Italy
22 shared publications- Stefano Casiraghi
Dipartimento di Scienze dell’Ambiente e della Terra, Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, Milan, 20126, Italy
17 shared publications - Silvia Mittempergher
Dipartimento di Scienze dell’Ambiente e della Terra, Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, Milan, 20126, Italy
15 shared publications - Federico Agliardi
Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Milano-Bicocca, Milan, Italy
14 shared publications Cristian Albertini
Eni S.p.A, Global Natural Resources, San Donato Milanese, Italy
13 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Reply on RC1
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- 30 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Open AccessReply on RC1
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- Open Access
- 30 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Reply on RC2
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- 30 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Open AccessReply on RC2
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- Open Access
- 15 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Comment on egusphere-2026-2409
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- 15 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-2409
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- Open Access
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Comment on egusphere-2026-2409
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-2409
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- Open Access
- 10 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Comment on egusphere-2026-2409
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- 10 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-2409
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- Open Access
- 12 May 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Statistical Assessment of the Representative Elementary Area for Areal Fracture Intensity (P21) in Digital Outcrop Models
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- 12 May 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Open AccessStatistical Assessment of the Representative Elementary Area for Areal Fracture Intensity (P21) in Digital Outcrop Models
The definition of a representative elementary volume (REV) or area (REA) for a target parameter is a fundamental step toward the upscaling of fracture network properties generated by discrete fracture network models (DFN) to an equivalent continuous medium for in situ applications in engineering geology, hydrogeology, and structural geology. The target parameter of this work is the areal fracture intensity (P21), a key metric often used as a stopping criterion in stochastic DFN simulations, that is derived directly from surface data collected at natural outcrops. We propose a novel approach to define the REA as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. We evaluate the REA range based on three statistical parameters, namely: the shape, mean, and variance of the P21 distributions obtained with progressively increasing scan area sizes. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behaviour of the dataset, supporting informed decisions in defining the REA range. The methodology is tested on two fractured limestone outcrops with markedly different characteristics: (i) an abandoned quarry in the Murge Plateau (Puglia, Italy) and (ii) the Lilstock Benches in the southern Bristol Channel basin.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Statistical Assessment of Fracture Areal Intensity (P21) Representative Elementary Area in Digital Outcrop Models
Among the geometrical parameters that can be calculated from an outcrop analogue, fracture areal intensity (P21), defined as the ratio between the total sum of fracture trace length and the sampling area, represents the stopping criterion of 2D marked point process stochastic Discrete Fracture Network models (DFN) or 3D simulations if properly upscaled to its volumetric equivalent (P32). Given the heterogeneous nature of fracture networks, P21 calculation is inherently scale and position dependent, meaning that its value changes depending on the scan area size and its position within the outcrop boundary. For this reason, P21 calculation cannot be separated from the concept of Representative Elementary Volume (REV) or Area (REA), in case of 2D outcrop studies. Depending on the field of application, REV or REA size definition changes, adapting to the different sampling strategies and parameters specific to that research field. We propose a novel approach to define the REA for the P21 parameter as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. To determine the REA range, we evaluate the shape, mean, and variance of P21 value statistical distributions across scan areas of increasing radius. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behavior of the dataset, facilitating more objective and informed decisions when defining the REA range.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessStatistical Assessment of Fracture Areal Intensity (P21) Representative Elementary Area in Digital Outcrop Models
Among the geometrical parameters that can be calculated from an outcrop analogue, fracture areal intensity (P21), defined as the ratio between the total sum of fracture trace length and the sampling area, represents the stopping criterion of 2D marked point process stochastic Discrete Fracture Network models (DFN) or 3D simulations if properly upscaled to its volumetric equivalent (P32). Given the heterogeneous nature of fracture networks, P21 calculation is inherently scale and position dependent, meaning that its value changes depending on the scan area size and its position within the outcrop boundary. For this reason, P21 calculation cannot be separated from the concept of Representative Elementary Volume (REV) or Area (REA), in case of 2D outcrop studies. Depending on the field of application, REV or REA size definition changes, adapting to the different sampling strategies and parameters specific to that research field. We propose a novel approach to define the REA for the P21 parameter as a range bounded by a lower and an upper limit. The upper limit, often overlooked but nonetheless theorized, identifies the largest representative domain, which is crucial for optimizing computational efficiency. To determine the REA range, we evaluate the shape, mean, and variance of P21 value statistical distributions across scan areas of increasing radius. Each statistical parameter is assessed by combining formal statistical tests and diagnostic plots. Within a multi-parametric framework, the method enables a detailed analysis of the statistical behavior of the dataset, facilitating more objective and informed decisions when defining the REA range.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Accelerating and scaling up SEAS simulations using GPUs in Julia
Sequences of Earthquakes and Aseismic Slip (SEAS) simulations focus on km scale models and consider all phases of faulting from aseismic slip to earthquake nucleation, propagation and termination. Many codes exist that use different approaches to tackle SEAS simulations; however, solutions designed to leverage the potential of GPUs to parallelize and speed up the simulation are limited (although recent examples are emerging such as PyQuake3D). In this work, we propose a GPU parallelized SEAS quasi-dynamic solver written in Julia adopting the Spectral Boundary Integral Method (SBIM). The SBIM approach is optimal for GPUs as it is more memory efficient in respect to other mesh-based solvers, thus enabling to efficiently run high resolution simulations with around 10 million nodes on the fault plane. We rearrange the rate-and-state equations to solve for the slip rate and adopt a slightly modified Newton-Raphson algorithm for root finding. We introduce elastic bulk by using an analytical stress-slip relationship in the Fourier/wavenumber domain. Most of the operations that are carried out in the solver are element wise and thus can be run in parallel on GPUs, significantly cutting down on computation time as the domain resolution increases. While FFT is inherently not fully parallelizable, GPU kernels are available to efficiently perform Fourier transforms on GPUs. Moreover, by using the FFT algorithm, the numerical complexity for calculating the stress is reduced from O(N²) to O(NlogN). To verify the correctness of our solver, we use the BP4-QD benchmark and show comparable results with other outputs hosted by SCEC. We then measure the runtime of the solver on CPU and 2 NVIDIA GPUs, the RTX4060 8GB and the A100 40GB, and show a x5 to x16 speedup for simulations depending on the GPU. Finally, we run the BP4-QD problem on the A100 GPU, decreasing the indicated node spacing and Dc values by an order of magnitude. This simulation yielded 36 events of Mw > 7 and 181 events of Mw between 5 and 6, showing emergence of complexity. Moreover, we observe that the earthquake’s nucleation points are distributed along the edges of the rate-weakening patch. The smaller events are mostly concentrated on the four corners and the two sides parallel to the slipping direction while the bigger events are distributed more uniformly all around the border.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessAccelerating and scaling up SEAS simulations using GPUs in Julia
Sequences of Earthquakes and Aseismic Slip (SEAS) simulations focus on km scale models and consider all phases of faulting from aseismic slip to earthquake nucleation, propagation and termination. Many codes exist that use different approaches to tackle SEAS simulations; however, solutions designed to leverage the potential of GPUs to parallelize and speed up the simulation are limited (although recent examples are emerging such as PyQuake3D). In this work, we propose a GPU parallelized SEAS quasi-dynamic solver written in Julia adopting the Spectral Boundary Integral Method (SBIM). The SBIM approach is optimal for GPUs as it is more memory efficient in respect to other mesh-based solvers, thus enabling to efficiently run high resolution simulations with around 10 million nodes on the fault plane. We rearrange the rate-and-state equations to solve for the slip rate and adopt a slightly modified Newton-Raphson algorithm for root finding. We introduce elastic bulk by using an analytical stress-slip relationship in the Fourier/wavenumber domain. Most of the operations that are carried out in the solver are element wise and thus can be run in parallel on GPUs, significantly cutting down on computation time as the domain resolution increases. While FFT is inherently not fully parallelizable, GPU kernels are available to efficiently perform Fourier transforms on GPUs. Moreover, by using the FFT algorithm, the numerical complexity for calculating the stress is reduced from O(N²) to O(NlogN). To verify the correctness of our solver, we use the BP4-QD benchmark and show comparable results with other outputs hosted by SCEC. We then measure the runtime of the solver on CPU and 2 NVIDIA GPUs, the RTX4060 8GB and the A100 40GB, and show a x5 to x16 speedup for simulations depending on the GPU. Finally, we run the BP4-QD problem on the A100 GPU, decreasing the indicated node spacing and Dc values by an order of magnitude. This simulation yielded 36 events of Mw > 7 and 181 events of Mw between 5 and 6, showing emergence of complexity. Moreover, we observe that the earthquake’s nucleation points are distributed along the edges of the rate-weakening patch. The smaller events are mostly concentrated on the four corners and the two sides parallel to the slipping direction while the bigger events are distributed more uniformly all around the border.
- Open Access
- 12 November 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Solid Earth
- Vol. 16 (11) , 1351-1382
An integrated workflow for parametrization of fracture network geometry in digital outcrop models
Mesoscale fractures, with lengths between meters and tens of meters, cannot be effectively characterized in the subsurface, due to limitations of borehole and geophysical datasets. On the other hand, large quantitative structural datasets can be collected on outcrops by combining direct observations and remote sensing (digital outcrop models – DOMs). These data can be used to constrain geometrical models of subsurface fracture networks with the outcrop analogue approach. In this contribution we present a workflow that leverages DOMs with at least two perpendicular faces and combines multiple types of input data (point cloud, textured surfaces and orthophoto DOMs), to collect a suite of statistical parameters to be used as input in current stochastic 3D DFN (Discrete Fracture Network) models. Orientation data are collected with a semi-automatic procedure applied to point cloud DOMs of the vertical side of the outcrop to extract 2D polygonal facets. Fracture sets are defined with a clustering procedure and different orientation distributions are fitted and tested with goodness-of-fit tests. Fracture traces are digitized on textured surface or orthophoto DOMs. Topological parameters are calculated on the digitized fracture network on horizontal and vertical orthomosaics, also considering relationships between fractures and bedding. Trace length and height distributions are estimated with an innovative approach, accounting for the censoring bias with survival/reliability analysis. P21 (ratio between total fracture length and sampling area) is measured from traces digitized on the large horizontal outcrop, also allowing for the Representative Elementary Area (REA) to be assessed. Even if the height/length ratio cannot be measured on an outcrop by any means, we attempt to relate heights and lengths under the assumption that the two datasets are correlated, with the longest fractures being also the tallest. We discuss the applicability of our workflow on a large high-quality fractured limestone outcrop in the Murge Plateau near Altamura (Puglia, Italy).
- 12 November 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Solid Earth
- Vol. 16 (11) , 1351-1382
Open AccessAn integrated workflow for parametrization of fracture network geometry in digital outcrop models
Mesoscale fractures, with lengths between meters and tens of meters, cannot be effectively characterized in the subsurface, due to limitations of borehole and geophysical datasets. On the other hand, large quantitative structural datasets can be collected on outcrops by combining direct observations and remote sensing (digital outcrop models – DOMs). These data can be used to constrain geometrical models of subsurface fracture networks with the outcrop analogue approach. In this contribution we present a workflow that leverages DOMs with at least two perpendicular faces and combines multiple types of input data (point cloud, textured surfaces and orthophoto DOMs), to collect a suite of statistical parameters to be used as input in current stochastic 3D DFN (Discrete Fracture Network) models. Orientation data are collected with a semi-automatic procedure applied to point cloud DOMs of the vertical side of the outcrop to extract 2D polygonal facets. Fracture sets are defined with a clustering procedure and different orientation distributions are fitted and tested with goodness-of-fit tests. Fracture traces are digitized on textured surface or orthophoto DOMs. Topological parameters are calculated on the digitized fracture network on horizontal and vertical orthomosaics, also considering relationships between fractures and bedding. Trace length and height distributions are estimated with an innovative approach, accounting for the censoring bias with survival/reliability analysis. P21 (ratio between total fracture length and sampling area) is measured from traces digitized on the large horizontal outcrop, also allowing for the Representative Elementary Area (REA) to be assessed. Even if the height/length ratio cannot be measured on an outcrop by any means, we attempt to relate heights and lengths under the assumption that the two datasets are correlated, with the longest fractures being also the tallest. We discuss the applicability of our workflow on a large high-quality fractured limestone outcrop in the Murge Plateau near Altamura (Puglia, Italy).
- Open Access
- 7 July 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-55
Reply on RC2
Mesoscale fractures, with lengths between meters and tens of meters, cannot be effectively characterized in the subsurface, due to limitations of borehole and geophysical datasets. On the other hand, large quantitative structural datasets can be collected on outcrops by combining direct observations and remote sensing (digital outcrop models – DOMs). These data can be used to constrain models of subsurface fracture networks with the outcrop analogue approach. In this contribution we present a complete and rigorous workflow that leverages digital outcrop models with at least two perpendicular faces, in combination with various kinds of DOMs, to collect large multi-parameter datasets optimized to include all relevant statistical distributions. Orientation data are collected with a semi-automatic procedure applied to point cloud DOM of the vertical side of the outcrop, resulting in 2D polygonal facets. Fracture sets are defined with a clustering procedure and different orientation distributions are fitted and if possible, tested with proper goodness-of-fit tests. Fracture traces are digitized on textured surface or orthophoto DOMs. Topological parameters are calculated on the digitized fracture network on horizontal and vertical orthomosaics, also considering relationships with bedding. Trace length and height distributions are characterized with a robust innovative approach, accounting for the censoring bias with survival/reliability analysis. P21 (ratio between total fracture length and sampling area) is measured from traces digitized on the large horizontal outcrop, also allowing for the Representative Elementary Area (REA) to be assessed. Even if the height/length ratio cannot be measured on an outcrop by any means, we apply a realistic assumption and a regression test that avoids making completely theoretical assumptions not supported by data. We discuss the applicability of our workflow on a large top-quality fractured limestone outcrop in the Murge Plateau near Altamura (Puglia, Italy).
- 7 July 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-55
Open AccessReply on RC2
Mesoscale fractures, with lengths between meters and tens of meters, cannot be effectively characterized in the subsurface, due to limitations of borehole and geophysical datasets. On the other hand, large quantitative structural datasets can be collected on outcrops by combining direct observations and remote sensing (digital outcrop models – DOMs). These data can be used to constrain models of subsurface fracture networks with the outcrop analogue approach. In this contribution we present a complete and rigorous workflow that leverages digital outcrop models with at least two perpendicular faces, in combination with various kinds of DOMs, to collect large multi-parameter datasets optimized to include all relevant statistical distributions. Orientation data are collected with a semi-automatic procedure applied to point cloud DOM of the vertical side of the outcrop, resulting in 2D polygonal facets. Fracture sets are defined with a clustering procedure and different orientation distributions are fitted and if possible, tested with proper goodness-of-fit tests. Fracture traces are digitized on textured surface or orthophoto DOMs. Topological parameters are calculated on the digitized fracture network on horizontal and vertical orthomosaics, also considering relationships with bedding. Trace length and height distributions are characterized with a robust innovative approach, accounting for the censoring bias with survival/reliability analysis. P21 (ratio between total fracture length and sampling area) is measured from traces digitized on the large horizontal outcrop, also allowing for the Representative Elementary Area (REA) to be assessed. Even if the height/length ratio cannot be measured on an outcrop by any means, we apply a realistic assumption and a regression test that avoids making completely theoretical assumptions not supported by data. We discuss the applicability of our workflow on a large top-quality fractured limestone outcrop in the Murge Plateau near Altamura (Puglia, Italy).