Tatiana Shakhova
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Tatiana Shakhova has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Olga V. Khodakova
Russian Research Institute of Health, Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation, Moscow, Russia
2 shared publications - Alena Bogomazova
Borisovskaya Central District Hospital, Belgorod Region, Borisovka settlement, Russia
1 shared publication - Anastasia Akhramovich
City Polyclinic No. 12, Omsk, Russia
1 shared publication - Dmitry Dobretsov1 shared publication
- Elena Dobretsova
Saint Petersburg State University, Saint Petersburg, Russia
1 shared publication - Galina Sazhina
OOO «LOR plus» Medical Center
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 72 (2) , 18
LAW ENFORCEMENT PRACTICE IN HOLDING MEDICAL ORGANIZATIONS ACCOUNTABLE FOR ADMINISTRATIVE LIABILITY: AN ANALYTICAL REVIEW
Significance. Safety and quality of health care remain key priorities of the public health policy. Control and prevention of violations have become the foundation of reforming supervisory activities aimed at developing digital technologies and improving effectiveness of legal institutions. Despite changes, the principle of inevitable responsibility is preserved, complemented with individualized penalties. The Federal Service for Supervision in Healthcare (Roszdravnadzor) acts as an authority controlling the quality and safety of medical services, initiating about 3,500 administrative offence cases annually. Examining judicial practice and interpreting legal norms remains relevant because of possible contradictions in the classification of offenses. Purpose. To analyze the Roszdravnadzor's legal proceedings from 2022 to 2023 regarding the imposition of administrative liability on medical organizations in order to develop practical recommendations for offense prevention. Material and methods. A total of 380 judicial decisions issued between January 2022 and December 2023 across 59 regions of the Russian Federation were selected concerning the imposition of administrative liability on medical organizations or their employees under Articles 14.1 and 19.20 of the Code of Administrative Offences based on protocols drawn up by Roszdravnadzor or its territorial bodies. The following aspects were studied: distribution of cases by article of the Code of Administrative Offences, types and grounds of control measures, nature of violations, characteristics of objective side of violation, outcomes of proceedings, type of imposed penalty. Results. Most often inspectors identified violations in various areas of medical activity unrelated to paid medical services during unplanned inspections initiated based on citizens' complaints. Cases were most frequently brought against gross violations of licensing requirements such as insufficient equipment of structural units, breaches of the established patient routing rules, failure to comply with the internal control over quality and safety of medical care. In 86% of all cases, courts ruled to impose administrative liability, but mitigated the penalty either by setting fines below the minimum level or substituting the fine with a warning notice. Conclusion. Measures taken to impose administrative liability on offenders are a key element of the risk‑based model of state control. Keywords: medical organizations; court decisions; state control (supervision); quality and safety of medical activities
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 72 (2) , 18
LAW ENFORCEMENT PRACTICE IN HOLDING MEDICAL ORGANIZATIONS ACCOUNTABLE FOR ADMINISTRATIVE LIABILITY: AN ANALYTICAL REVIEW
Significance. Safety and quality of health care remain key priorities of the public health policy. Control and prevention of violations have become the foundation of reforming supervisory activities aimed at developing digital technologies and improving effectiveness of legal institutions. Despite changes, the principle of inevitable responsibility is preserved, complemented with individualized penalties. The Federal Service for Supervision in Healthcare (Roszdravnadzor) acts as an authority controlling the quality and safety of medical services, initiating about 3,500 administrative offence cases annually. Examining judicial practice and interpreting legal norms remains relevant because of possible contradictions in the classification of offenses. Purpose. To analyze the Roszdravnadzor's legal proceedings from 2022 to 2023 regarding the imposition of administrative liability on medical organizations in order to develop practical recommendations for offense prevention. Material and methods. A total of 380 judicial decisions issued between January 2022 and December 2023 across 59 regions of the Russian Federation were selected concerning the imposition of administrative liability on medical organizations or their employees under Articles 14.1 and 19.20 of the Code of Administrative Offences based on protocols drawn up by Roszdravnadzor or its territorial bodies. The following aspects were studied: distribution of cases by article of the Code of Administrative Offences, types and grounds of control measures, nature of violations, characteristics of objective side of violation, outcomes of proceedings, type of imposed penalty. Results. Most often inspectors identified violations in various areas of medical activity unrelated to paid medical services during unplanned inspections initiated based on citizens' complaints. Cases were most frequently brought against gross violations of licensing requirements such as insufficient equipment of structural units, breaches of the established patient routing rules, failure to comply with the internal control over quality and safety of medical care. In 86% of all cases, courts ruled to impose administrative liability, but mitigated the penalty either by setting fines below the minimum level or substituting the fine with a warning notice. Conclusion. Measures taken to impose administrative liability on offenders are a key element of the risk‑based model of state control. Keywords: medical organizations; court decisions; state control (supervision); quality and safety of medical activities
- Open Access
- 20 May 2025
- Published by Sechenov University in National Health Care (Russia)
- Vol. 6 (1) , 5-18
Organization of medical care delivery using telemedicine technologies: Regulatory legal framework in the Russian Federation
Telemedicine technologies (TMT) represent a digital tool within the organization of medical care aimed at increasing its accessibility as well as improving the quality of medical services provided through consultations and medical councils involving third-level organizations, including national medical research centers. A content analysis was conducted of regulatory legal acts, focusing on the application of TMT in various organizational models of medical care delivery. The authors systematized information on regulatory legal frameworks for organizing medical care using TMT, outlined organizational options for interaction among healthcare professionals, as well as within the framework of remote monitoring of patient health. The concept of an experimental legal regime in the field of digital innovations related to medical activities, including the use of TMT and technologies for collecting and processing information about patients health status and diagnoses, was analyzed. An analysis was conducted of the regulatory framework for a pilot project on remote monitoring of patient health using the information system (platform) “Personal Medical Assistants”.
- 20 May 2025
- Published by Sechenov University in National Health Care (Russia)
- Vol. 6 (1) , 5-18
Open AccessOrganization of medical care delivery using telemedicine technologies: Regulatory legal framework in the Russian Federation
Telemedicine technologies (TMT) represent a digital tool within the organization of medical care aimed at increasing its accessibility as well as improving the quality of medical services provided through consultations and medical councils involving third-level organizations, including national medical research centers. A content analysis was conducted of regulatory legal acts, focusing on the application of TMT in various organizational models of medical care delivery. The authors systematized information on regulatory legal frameworks for organizing medical care using TMT, outlined organizational options for interaction among healthcare professionals, as well as within the framework of remote monitoring of patient health. The concept of an experimental legal regime in the field of digital innovations related to medical activities, including the use of TMT and technologies for collecting and processing information about patients health status and diagnoses, was analyzed. An analysis was conducted of the regulatory framework for a pilot project on remote monitoring of patient health using the information system (platform) “Personal Medical Assistants”.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 71 (5) , 26
THE STRUCTURE OF THE WORKING DAY OF A DISTRICT PHYSICIAN: AN OPINION OF PRACTICING SPECIALISTS AND CURRENT AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT
Significance. Optimization of the work of district general practitioners is a key condition for increasing the efficiency of primary healthcare. Inconsistency between current standards and modern professional requirements and real working conditions leads to overload of doctors, higher levels of professional burnout and lower quality of medical care. Purpose. To explore perceptions of district general practitioners about the current and ideal structure of their working day, including appointment duration, distribution of responsibilities, and optimal time allocation for key activities. Material and methods. The study was conducted from November 2024 to May 2025 using the method of online (depersonalized) questionnaire through the Google Forms platform. The survey involved 582 district general practitioners employed in state polyclinics, representing various regions of the Russian Federation. The collected data were processed using the Python programming language. Results. A significant discrepancy was found between the current and preferred work organization model. According to the respondents, the actual duration of an outpatient appointment (total daily time allocated to patient appointments at a polyclinic) exceeds the permissible one, taking into account other job responsibilities. The optimal duration of a patient appointment is considered to be 20 minutes. Most respondents are in favor of splitting the work formats during the day (outpatient appointments and patient home visits), allocating a fixed break, as well as special time blocks for maintaining records and receiving patients on sick leave (allocating non-concurrent slots for these purposes). Almost a unified position is expressed on the need to delegate regular medical examinations to separate medical teams (as a rule, offices of medical prevention). Conclusion. The study has revealed a pronounced request from district general practitioners to revise the existing structure of the working day. The proposed changes are aimed at rational use of the working time of a general practitioner, optimization of the distribution of responsibilities and reduction of professional burnout of doctors. The obtained empirical data can serve as a basis for the development and implementation of organizational solutions within the framework of the lean clinic concept. Keywords: state clinic; optimization; duration of a patient appointment; structure of the working day; optimal working conditions.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 71 (5) , 26
THE STRUCTURE OF THE WORKING DAY OF A DISTRICT PHYSICIAN: AN OPINION OF PRACTICING SPECIALISTS AND CURRENT AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT
Significance. Optimization of the work of district general practitioners is a key condition for increasing the efficiency of primary healthcare. Inconsistency between current standards and modern professional requirements and real working conditions leads to overload of doctors, higher levels of professional burnout and lower quality of medical care. Purpose. To explore perceptions of district general practitioners about the current and ideal structure of their working day, including appointment duration, distribution of responsibilities, and optimal time allocation for key activities. Material and methods. The study was conducted from November 2024 to May 2025 using the method of online (depersonalized) questionnaire through the Google Forms platform. The survey involved 582 district general practitioners employed in state polyclinics, representing various regions of the Russian Federation. The collected data were processed using the Python programming language. Results. A significant discrepancy was found between the current and preferred work organization model. According to the respondents, the actual duration of an outpatient appointment (total daily time allocated to patient appointments at a polyclinic) exceeds the permissible one, taking into account other job responsibilities. The optimal duration of a patient appointment is considered to be 20 minutes. Most respondents are in favor of splitting the work formats during the day (outpatient appointments and patient home visits), allocating a fixed break, as well as special time blocks for maintaining records and receiving patients on sick leave (allocating non-concurrent slots for these purposes). Almost a unified position is expressed on the need to delegate regular medical examinations to separate medical teams (as a rule, offices of medical prevention). Conclusion. The study has revealed a pronounced request from district general practitioners to revise the existing structure of the working day. The proposed changes are aimed at rational use of the working time of a general practitioner, optimization of the distribution of responsibilities and reduction of professional burnout of doctors. The obtained empirical data can serve as a basis for the development and implementation of organizational solutions within the framework of the lean clinic concept. Keywords: state clinic; optimization; duration of a patient appointment; structure of the working day; optimal working conditions.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 68 (6) , 4
METHODOLOGICAL APPROACHES TO FORMING THE STRUCTURE OF THE CENTRAL HEALTH EXECUTIVE AUTHORITY OF THE CONSTITUENT ENTITY OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
Intensification of the rule-making process in healthcare, active position of citizens and their increased demands for conditions of receiving medical services and quality of health care have resulted in increased burden on health authorities. To ensure efficiency in achieving targets in healthcare reforming and modernization, the requirements for quality managerial personnel are being increased. A wide variety of organizational and legal forms of the central health executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, their often insufficient staff size and imbalance in the staffing of structural units necessitate development of unified methodological approaches to the formation of the structure of the central health authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation and substantiate methodology for calculating the staff size. The purpose of the study: to develop a methodology for creating the optimal structure of the health executive authority of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation and methodological recommendations for calculating their staffing. Results. Analysis of the organizational and legal structure and functional responsibilities of the state authorities in healthcare in 13 constituent entities of the Russian Federation has identified significant differences and different competencies, although each constituent entity of the Russian Federation solves general health issues within the competences, therefore, the scope of activities of all levels of government should be coordinated. Staffing of the regional executive authority (REA) should primarily depend on the population size of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation, its density, number of medical organizations, their total bed capacity, planned capacity of units providing outpatient care, and the number of medical personnel. A coefficient has been derived for calculating the staffing level of the state health authority in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation. In accordance with the general calculation criteria, several models of the REA structure were proposed, depending on the population size of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation. For REA with the number of deputies four and over, two versions of the model with different hierarchical subordination were proposed. Conclusion. Active processes of the industry reforming against the background of objective factors that determine new approaches to the healthcare system impose new, increased requirements to the executive bodies of state authority of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, necessitate optimization of the structure, management and functional load of regional health executive authorities.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 68 (6) , 4
METHODOLOGICAL APPROACHES TO FORMING THE STRUCTURE OF THE CENTRAL HEALTH EXECUTIVE AUTHORITY OF THE CONSTITUENT ENTITY OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
Intensification of the rule-making process in healthcare, active position of citizens and their increased demands for conditions of receiving medical services and quality of health care have resulted in increased burden on health authorities. To ensure efficiency in achieving targets in healthcare reforming and modernization, the requirements for quality managerial personnel are being increased. A wide variety of organizational and legal forms of the central health executive authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, their often insufficient staff size and imbalance in the staffing of structural units necessitate development of unified methodological approaches to the formation of the structure of the central health authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation and substantiate methodology for calculating the staff size. The purpose of the study: to develop a methodology for creating the optimal structure of the health executive authority of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation and methodological recommendations for calculating their staffing. Results. Analysis of the organizational and legal structure and functional responsibilities of the state authorities in healthcare in 13 constituent entities of the Russian Federation has identified significant differences and different competencies, although each constituent entity of the Russian Federation solves general health issues within the competences, therefore, the scope of activities of all levels of government should be coordinated. Staffing of the regional executive authority (REA) should primarily depend on the population size of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation, its density, number of medical organizations, their total bed capacity, planned capacity of units providing outpatient care, and the number of medical personnel. A coefficient has been derived for calculating the staffing level of the state health authority in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation. In accordance with the general calculation criteria, several models of the REA structure were proposed, depending on the population size of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation. For REA with the number of deputies four and over, two versions of the model with different hierarchical subordination were proposed. Conclusion. Active processes of the industry reforming against the background of objective factors that determine new approaches to the healthcare system impose new, increased requirements to the executive bodies of state authority of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, necessitate optimization of the structure, management and functional load of regional health executive authorities.