SSSarah Shugars

Sarah Shugars

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Sarah Shugars has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The structure of reasoning: Inferring conceptual networks from text

    by Sarah Shugars, Xinfeng Gu

    For decades, public opinion scholars have argued for the need to go beyond measuring isolated political preferences to more richly examine how individuals reason about and justify the interconnections between their preferences. While early efforts used interviews and hand-coding to elicit the network structure of subjects’ political reasoning, this manual approach can be time-consuming and difficult. Thankfully, modern computational methods and computing power hold the potential to revolutionize this space and allow for network inference at scale. In this paper, we therefore present a computational, text-based approach for inferring the network structure of individuals’ political reasoning. This method identifies the key concepts a person raises and examines the implicit connections between those concepts—what ideas do they connect to which other ideas? This structural approach is theoretically justified in both the cognitive and linguistic literatures, which repeatedly suggest that humans store, retrieve, and interpret information through network structures. We show that this approach reveals meaningful individual variation that is correlated with known behavioral traits. The ability to measure and interrogate individuals’ expressions of political reasoning holds the potential to shed new light on the dynamics of public opinion and political behavior. Questions of persuasion, ideological fracturing, and conversation quality all rely upon understanding individual styles of political expression. These dynamics are driven not just by what someone says but by how they say it.

  • Open Access

    The Character of Connection: Platform Affordances and Connective Democracy

    by Sarah Shugars, Eunbin Ha

    While social media optimistically holds the potential to ameliorate political divides by increasing cross-cutting political talk, numerous studies suggest that social media has instead exacerbated political polarization. Yet, social media is incredibly heterogeneous and variation in platform affordances may result in markedly different democratic outcomes. In this article, we turn to the principles of connective democracy to inform a cross-topic and cross-platform analysis. Our mixed-methods study compares conversations across Twitter and Reddit, finding that Twitter conversations are highly polarized across topics while Reddit displays some promise for enabling productive, intergroup discourse. We argue that this difference is driven by an affordance of conversational visibility in which users can see and engage with conversations as a whole. We further argue that “community” is a distinctive platform affordance that emerges from shared user expectations. This affordance supports user socialization into democratic norms of productive intergroup contact and therefore may prove particularly important to enhancing connective democracy.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Curation Bubbles

    by Jon Green, Stefan Mccabe, Sarah Shugars, Hanyu Chwe, Luke Horgan, Shuyang Cao, David Lazer

    Information on social media is characterized by networked curation processes in which users select other users from whom to receive information, and those users in turn share information that promotes their identities and interests. We argue this allows for partisan “curation bubbles” of users who share and consume content with consistent appeal drawn from a variety of sources. Yet, research concerning the extent of filter bubbles, echo chambers, or other forms of politically segregated information consumption typically conceptualizes information’s partisan valence at the source level as opposed to the story level. This can lead domain-level measures of audience partisanship to mischaracterize the partisan appeal of sources’ constituent stories—especially for sources estimated to be more moderate. Accounting for networked curation aligns theory and measurement of political information consumption on social media.


  • Open Access

    The Black Pill: (Re)conceptualizing the Black Right in the Era of YouTube Influencers

    by Marisa A. Smith, Sarah Shugars, Shaimaa Khanam, Adanma Mbonu, Om Sai Krishna Madhav Lella, Christina L. Myers

    Political influencers use YouTube to share political media, a practice that has proven integral in the curation of alternative influence networks among the political right. This study examines how Black conservative influencers express Black conservative thought within the broader conservative ecosystem, examining their topics of discussion and comparing these narratives to those of other conservatives within these networks. We employ BERTopic modeling to analyze 17,136 transcripts of YouTube videos produced by Black conservative influencers ( N = 70) between 1 January 2013 and 31 December 2023, and 158,833 transcripts of videos algorithmically recommended from this content. In addition, we use a pre-trained encoder-only transformer model to estimate the ideology of these influencers compared to those of other conservative actors in their network. We find that Black conservative influencers conveyed a statistically uniform narrative when discussing race and discrimination, a topic that was not only the most prevalent among them but also received the highest engagement, particularly coinciding with the political rise of Donald Trump. In line with traditional Black conservative thought, these influencers incorporated color-blind narratives discounting anti-Black racism. However, reflecting modern shifts in conservativism, Black conservatives also adopted cultural conservatism, particularly discussing the existence of anti-White racism. We discuss our findings in consideration of micro-celebrity practices that present Black conservatives as “authentic” voices on race, and its implications for legitimizing racial animus and White identity politics.


  • Open Access

    Critical computational social science

    by Sarah Shugars

    In her 2021 IC2S2 keynote talk, “Critical Data Theory,” Margaret Hu builds off Critical Race Theory, privacy law, and big data surveillance to grapple with questions at the intersection of big data and legal jurisprudence. As a legal scholar, Hu’s work focuses primarily on issues of governance and regulation—examining the legal and constitutional impact of modern data collection and analysis. Yet, her call for Critical Data Theory has important implications for the field of Computational Social Science (CSS) as a whole. In this article, I therefore reflect on Hu’s conception of Critical Data Theory and its broader implications for CSS research. Specifically, I’ll consider the ramifications of her work for the scientific community—exploring how we as researchers should think about the ethics and realities of the data which forms the foundations of our work.


  • Open Access

    Categorizing the non-categorical: the challenges of studying gendered phenomena online

    by Sarah Shugars, Alexi Quintana-Mathé, Robin Lange, David Lazer

    Studies of gendered phenomena online have highlighted important disparities, such as who is likely to be elevated as an expert or face gender-based harassment. This research, however, typically relies upon inferring user gender—an act that perpetuates notions of gender as an easily observable, binary construct. Motivated by work in gender and queer studies, we therefore compare common approaches to gender inference in the context of online settings. We demonstrate that gender inference can have downstream consequences when studying gender inequities and find that nonbinary users are consistently likely to be misgendered or overlooked in analysis. In bringing a theoretical focus to this common methodological task, our contribution is in problematizing common measures of gender, encouraging researchers to think critically about what these constructs can and cannot capture, and calling for more research explicitly focused on gendered experiences beyond a binary.


  • Open Access

    Beyond Digital "Echo Chambers": The Role of Viewpoint Diversity in Political Discussion

    by Rishav Hada, Amir Ebrahimi Fard, Sarah Shugars, Federico Bianchi, Patricia Rossini, Dirk Hovy, Rebekah Tromble, Nava Tintarev

    Increasingly taking place in online spaces, modern political conversations are typically perceived to be unproductively affirming---siloed in so called "echo chambers" of exclusively like-minded discussants. Yet, to date we lack sufficient means to measure viewpoint diversity in conversations. To this end, in this paper, we operationalize two viewpoint metrics proposed for recommender systems and adapt them to the context of social media conversations. This is the first study to apply these two metrics (Representation and Fragmentation) to real world data and to consider the implications for online conversations specifically. We apply these measures to two topics---daylight savings time (DST), which serves as a control, and the more politically polarized topic of immigration. We find that the diversity scores for both Fragmentation and Representation are lower for immigration than for DST. Further, we find that while pro-immigrant views receive consistent pushback on the platform, anti-immigrant views largely operate within echo chambers. We observe less severe yet similar patterns for DST. Taken together, Representation and Fragmentation paint a meaningful and important new picture of viewpoint diversity.