L. R. Katynska
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 12 July 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (3) , 303-308
Legal regulation of dental services advertising in the European Union and in Ukraine
The article is dedicated to the examination of the legal regulation of advertising related to dental services in the countries of the European Union as well as in Ukraine. It also explores the normative restrictions that are specifically aimed at protecting the interests and rights of patients and at ensuring adherence to high standards of professional ethics within the field of dental healthcare. Particular attention is paid to the issue of misleading or dishonest advertising practices, and the article includes a thorough analysis of various regulatory and legal acts that define the legal requirements for the promotion and advertising of dental services. The author draws special attention to a landmark decision of the Court of Justice of the European Union in the case of “Vanderborght” (2017), which significantly influenced contemporary trends in the legal regulation of advertising in the dental sector. This judicial decision has been closely associated with the liberalization of regulatory approaches to dental advertising within the European Union. It has been established that while the advertising of dental services may be subjected to certain limitations or restrictions, a complete and total prohibition of such advertising is incompatible with the provisions of European Union law concerning the freedom to provide services across Member States. Furthermore, the article includes a comprehensive analysis of several European Union directives that govern the broader area of advertising. These include, among others: Directive 2000/31/EC on electronic commerce, Directive 2005/29/EC concerning unfair business-to-consumer commercial practices in the internal market, and Directive 2006/114/EC concerning misleading and comparative advertising. In addition, the author examines the distinctive features of legal regulation of dental advertising in selected EU Member States, namely France, Austria, and Poland. The article also addresses the regulatory framework in Ukraine, focusing on the relevant provisions of the Law of Ukraine «On Advertising», as well as judicial practices that contribute to the development of consistent approaches to the interpretation and enforcement of legal norms in the sphere of medical advertising. The necessity of improving national legislation is outlined, particularly with regard to the integration of modern digital technologies, which not only offer new opportunities but also pose novel challenges for the regulation of advertising within the dental healthcare sector. Among the most pressing and urgent problems associated with the legal regulation of dental advertising in Ukraine is the absence of clearly defined professional ethical standards for dental practitioners. Another critical issue is the underdevelopment of a professional self-governance system for the dental profession, which could otherwise serve as a regulatory body responsible for overseeing compliance with ethical and professional norms in the area of advertising. Moreover, the article emphasizes the lack of systematic oversight and control in this domain, especially in relation to advertising disseminated via the Internet. The absence of an effective regulatory mechanism in this regard has led to a proliferation of unethical advertising practices, which, in the final analysis, may result in direct harm to patients and undermine trust in the healthcare system.
- 12 July 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (3) , 303-308
Open AccessLegal regulation of dental services advertising in the European Union and in Ukraine
The article is dedicated to the examination of the legal regulation of advertising related to dental services in the countries of the European Union as well as in Ukraine. It also explores the normative restrictions that are specifically aimed at protecting the interests and rights of patients and at ensuring adherence to high standards of professional ethics within the field of dental healthcare. Particular attention is paid to the issue of misleading or dishonest advertising practices, and the article includes a thorough analysis of various regulatory and legal acts that define the legal requirements for the promotion and advertising of dental services. The author draws special attention to a landmark decision of the Court of Justice of the European Union in the case of “Vanderborght” (2017), which significantly influenced contemporary trends in the legal regulation of advertising in the dental sector. This judicial decision has been closely associated with the liberalization of regulatory approaches to dental advertising within the European Union. It has been established that while the advertising of dental services may be subjected to certain limitations or restrictions, a complete and total prohibition of such advertising is incompatible with the provisions of European Union law concerning the freedom to provide services across Member States. Furthermore, the article includes a comprehensive analysis of several European Union directives that govern the broader area of advertising. These include, among others: Directive 2000/31/EC on electronic commerce, Directive 2005/29/EC concerning unfair business-to-consumer commercial practices in the internal market, and Directive 2006/114/EC concerning misleading and comparative advertising. In addition, the author examines the distinctive features of legal regulation of dental advertising in selected EU Member States, namely France, Austria, and Poland. The article also addresses the regulatory framework in Ukraine, focusing on the relevant provisions of the Law of Ukraine «On Advertising», as well as judicial practices that contribute to the development of consistent approaches to the interpretation and enforcement of legal norms in the sphere of medical advertising. The necessity of improving national legislation is outlined, particularly with regard to the integration of modern digital technologies, which not only offer new opportunities but also pose novel challenges for the regulation of advertising within the dental healthcare sector. Among the most pressing and urgent problems associated with the legal regulation of dental advertising in Ukraine is the absence of clearly defined professional ethical standards for dental practitioners. Another critical issue is the underdevelopment of a professional self-governance system for the dental profession, which could otherwise serve as a regulatory body responsible for overseeing compliance with ethical and professional norms in the area of advertising. Moreover, the article emphasizes the lack of systematic oversight and control in this domain, especially in relation to advertising disseminated via the Internet. The absence of an effective regulatory mechanism in this regard has led to a proliferation of unethical advertising practices, which, in the final analysis, may result in direct harm to patients and undermine trust in the healthcare system.
- Open Access
- 25 April 2024
- Published by Danylo Halytskyi Lviv National Medical University in Medicne pravo
- No. 1(33),p. 22-28
Legal Basis for Protection of Medical Confidentiality about HIV-status of Person
The article examines the legal mechanism for protecting the medical confidentiality of individuals living with HIV. An analysis of national legislation in this context reveals the peculiarities of the legal regime governing the medical confidentiality of this category of individuals, including the confidentiality of testing and its results, registration and accounting of people living with HIV, as well as ensuring confidentiality in the provision of medical assistance related to HIV. The article explores legislatively established grounds for disclosing HIV diagnosis, emphasizing inconsistencies between the provisions of the «On Counteraction to the Spread of Diseases caused by the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) and Legal and Social Protection of People Living with HIV» and the provisions of subordinate normative legal acts. Special attention is given to the analysis of discrepancies between the provisions of this law and the disclosure of HIV diagnosis by military medical commissions. In light of the resolution of the case «M.K. v. Ukraine» by the European Court of Human Rights, inconsistencies between a subordinate act and a higher legal act regarding the disclosure of information about individuals with HIV are noted. The article also includes specific proposals for improving legislation in this area, taking into account the aforementioned discrepancies and recommendations of the European Court of Human Rights.
- 25 April 2024
- Published by Danylo Halytskyi Lviv National Medical University in Medicne pravo
- No. 1(33),p. 22-28
Open AccessLegal Basis for Protection of Medical Confidentiality about HIV-status of Person
The article examines the legal mechanism for protecting the medical confidentiality of individuals living with HIV. An analysis of national legislation in this context reveals the peculiarities of the legal regime governing the medical confidentiality of this category of individuals, including the confidentiality of testing and its results, registration and accounting of people living with HIV, as well as ensuring confidentiality in the provision of medical assistance related to HIV. The article explores legislatively established grounds for disclosing HIV diagnosis, emphasizing inconsistencies between the provisions of the «On Counteraction to the Spread of Diseases caused by the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) and Legal and Social Protection of People Living with HIV» and the provisions of subordinate normative legal acts. Special attention is given to the analysis of discrepancies between the provisions of this law and the disclosure of HIV diagnosis by military medical commissions. In light of the resolution of the case «M.K. v. Ukraine» by the European Court of Human Rights, inconsistencies between a subordinate act and a higher legal act regarding the disclosure of information about individuals with HIV are noted. The article also includes specific proposals for improving legislation in this area, taking into account the aforementioned discrepancies and recommendations of the European Court of Human Rights.
- Open Access
- 24 March 2023
- Published by Danylo Halytskyi Lviv National Medical University in Medicne pravo
- No. 1(31),p. 43-51
The Right to Timely Medical Care: Mechanism of Implementation
The content of the right to timely medical care is highlighted in this article. An analysis of the national legislation in the field of timeliness of emergency, primary, and specialized medical care was carried out and its comparison was made with international standards in the specified field, as well as with the doctrinal understanding of the timeliness of medical care. While emergency medical care is built on the principle of continuity and the maximum terms for receiving this type of medical care are established, primary and specialized medical care require legislative revision with regards to establishing the maximum terms for receiving primary and specialized medical care, ensuring the continuity of primary medical care, in particular on weekends, public holidays, non-working days. The legislator should pay special attention to ensuring the timeliness of specialized medical care upon referral, as well as the patient’s right to information about the possibility of receiving timely medical care in healthcare institutions. Other deficiencies in the legal regu- lation of the right to timely medical care are identified and ways to overcome this problem are proposed.
- 24 March 2023
- Published by Danylo Halytskyi Lviv National Medical University in Medicne pravo
- No. 1(31),p. 43-51
Open AccessThe Right to Timely Medical Care: Mechanism of Implementation
The content of the right to timely medical care is highlighted in this article. An analysis of the national legislation in the field of timeliness of emergency, primary, and specialized medical care was carried out and its comparison was made with international standards in the specified field, as well as with the doctrinal understanding of the timeliness of medical care. While emergency medical care is built on the principle of continuity and the maximum terms for receiving this type of medical care are established, primary and specialized medical care require legislative revision with regards to establishing the maximum terms for receiving primary and specialized medical care, ensuring the continuity of primary medical care, in particular on weekends, public holidays, non-working days. The legislator should pay special attention to ensuring the timeliness of specialized medical care upon referral, as well as the patient’s right to information about the possibility of receiving timely medical care in healthcare institutions. Other deficiencies in the legal regu- lation of the right to timely medical care are identified and ways to overcome this problem are proposed.