CGCathrine Grimsgaard

Cathrine Grimsgaard

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Cathrine Grimsgaard has a total of 11 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Motmakt på pavestolen – fra Pius IX til Frans

    by Kjetil Hafstad, Inger Marie Lid, Trygve Wyller, Rosemarie van Den Breemer, Einar Egenæs, Marta Maria Espeseth, Cathrine Grimsgaard, Adelheid Hummelvoll Hillestad, Knut W. Ruyter, Kaia S. Rønsdal, et al.

    In his deliberations on power, Michel Foucault also discussed pastoral power. Through distributing the sacraments, especially confession, ministers and churches come in intimate contact with the inner thoughts and motives of believers. Ministers can influence the faithful in local communities worldwide. This generates power. Such power can work by prescribing what to do, but also by issuing condemnations of misbehavior. Domination – and counter-conduct as well – has marked the Catholic Church in the last centuries. The following presentation delineates some power plots in the Church since the Napoleonic war. I discuss the two Vatican Councils and developments until the contemporary changes under Pope Francis. Counter-conduct is a useful analytical tool for understanding such changes within the Church and its relation to the surrounding societies.

  • Open Access

    Makt, motmakt og praksis: Bidrag til kritisk refleksjon innen diakoni og velferd

    by Inger Marie Lid, Trygve Wyller, Rosemarie van Den Breemer, Einar Egenæs, Marta Maria Espeseth, Cathrine Grimsgaard, Kjetil Hafstad, Adelheid Hummelvoll Hillestad, Knut W. Ruyter, Kaia S. Rønsdal, et al.

    Hvilke stemmer, kropper og praksiser har uttrykt en kritisk motmakt til institusjonenes makt, og hvem uttrykker den i dag? Hva står på spill, og hvor er motmakten forankret? Dette er spørsmål som står i sentrum for denne boken. Med utgangspunkt i Michel Foucaults teori om makt og motmakt analyserer og drøfter forfatterne i denne boka de mange spenninger og konflikter som oppstår når tjenestebrukere og pasienter tar (eller gis) en egen posisjon.Institusjoner og profesjonsutøvere har brukt og bruker tradisjoner, teorier og metoder som ofte mer svekker enn styrker tjenestebrukeres, pasientenes og klientens egen vilje og subjektivitet. Kapitlene kommer fra forskere innen mange fagfelt, som teologi, sykepleie, etikk, barnevern, funksjonshemmingsforskning, historie, diakoni og sosialt arbeid. I disse kunnskapsområdene handler det om å anerkjenne og å styrke menneskers verdighet og fremme rettferdighet. Men både historisk og aktuelt viser forskning og erfaring at det motsatte også skjer. Det etiske utspiller seg mellom makt, motmakt og praksis. Synopsis in English Which voices, bodies and practices have expressed critical powerlessness in the face of institutional power, and who is expressing this today? What is at play, and what is the root of this powerlessness? These questions are at the core of this book. With Michel Foucault’s theory of power and powerlessness as a point of departure, the contributing authors analyze and discuss the many conflicts and tension that arise when service users and patients take (or relinquish) a particular position. Institutions and professional practitioners have used and still use traditions, theories and methods that often weaken more than strengthen service users’, patients’ and clients’ own volition and subjectivity. The chapters are by researchers in a variety of disciplines including theology, nursing, ethics, child welfare, disability research, history, diakonia, and social work. In the context of these fields, recognizing and emphasizing people’s dignity and promoting equity are explored. But both historically and at present, research and experience show that the opposite also occurs. The ethical takes place between power, powerlessness and practice.


  • Open Access

    Relevans og conduct. Counter-conduct og resonans

    by Carsten Schuerhoff, Inger Marie Lid, Trygve Wyller, Rosemarie van Den Breemer, Einar Egenæs, Marta Maria Espeseth, Cathrine Grimsgaard, Kjetil Hafstad, Adelheid Hummelvoll Hillestad, Knut W. Ruyter, et al.

    This text is based on experiences from and research in a professional, multicultural, and multi-religious everyday life in a suburb of Oslo. First, reference is made to examples where church leadership favours and aims at increased relevance of the church. This is then contrasted with material from interviews conducted in the aforementioned suburb. Where the church leadership’s conduct is concerned with relevance, the interpretation of the interviews shows that the interviewees are withdrawing from the idea of relevance. Aided by Hartmut Rosa’s concept of resonance, this withdrawal is then specified as a kind of resistance from below. Through the interpretation of the interviews, resonance is brought into dialogue with Michel Foucault’s concepts of conduct and counter-conduct to see if this dialogue helps to develop and to deepen possible forms of counter-conduct. Resonance, due to incidents and actions of counter-conduct, appears to be crucial for the location/localization of the church at these concrete places.

  • Open Access

    Mat og motmakt

    by Helena Schmidt, Inger Marie Lid, Trygve Wyller, Rosemarie van Den Breemer, Einar Egenæs, Marta Maria Espeseth, Cathrine Grimsgaard, Kjetil Hafstad, Adelheid Hummelvoll Hillestad, Knut W. Ruyter, et al.

    The article offers interpretations of food and bodily conduct in contested spaces of hospitality in Oslo. I propose that ways in which food is rejected, received or negotiated may reveal counter-embodiments in unexpected situations. I base this proposal on participant observations conducted in two locations in Oslo between 2017 and 2019: a diaconal soup kitchen offering free food to poor migrants, and the dense, urban area known as Grønland. Looking through the meal lens, food is elevated as a symbol of hospitality, of embodiment and belonging. However, food also appears at a distance, as unanswerable, potentially and paradoxically, disembodying. The article presents three excerpts from ethnographic fieldwork, each involving food and bodies in different spaces. Discussing how to interpret these excerpts, I also draw critical attention to the involvement and affectedness of the research subject as part of the conduct/counter-conduct framework. From interpretations of these excerpts, it seems that counter-conduct may also appear as an intimate, embodied negotiation. The methodology guiding the article promotes a sensing, vulnerable presence as key to discovering and being affected by the vulnerability already present in empirical proximities. The discussion develops from the empirical material, in dialogue with among others Sara Ahmed and Engin Isin, and reveals how attention to embodied contradictions appear central to the discoveries of counter-conducts in contemporary precarity.


  • Open Access

    Barns deltakelse som en vilje til ikke å la seg styre

    by Cathrine Grimsgaard, Inger Marie Lid, Trygve Wyller, Rosemarie van Den Breemer, Einar Egenæs, Marta Maria Espeseth, Kjetil Hafstad, Adelheid Hummelvoll Hillestad, Knut W. Ruyter, Kaia S. Rønsdal, et al.

    The chapter gives priority to children’s voices as ‘counter-conduct’. This is done by analyzing a narrative that describes an event, which takes place in a conversation group for children who have mentally ill and/or addicted parents. A central topic in the interpretation is how children who refuse to take part in activities organized by the professional group leaders, are to be understood. The claim is that the refusal should not be interpreted as a sign of immatureness or developmental disorder, but rather that the children convey a richer variety of life experiences than professionals normally are aware of. The article concludes that the ‘counter – conduct’ found in children’s voices, can reveal knowledge about children’s being in the world, that is usually hidden from adults.

  • Open Access

    Motstand på kjøkkenet. Refleksjoner om å forske med mennesker

    by Kaia S. Rønsdal, Inger Marie Lid, Trygve Wyller, Rosemarie van Den Breemer, Einar Egenæs, Marta Maria Espeseth, Cathrine Grimsgaard, Kjetil Hafstad, Adelheid Hummelvoll Hillestad, Knut W. Ruyter, et al.

    The chapter reflects on methodology in research with human beings, using the motion picture Kitchen Stories (2003) as illustration and example. The discussion concerns whether decolonial research strategies can be understood as significant contemporary counter-conducts. As researchers, we are subject to a range of regulations, and we bring in tried and tested methodological tools decisive to planning and executing our research. To a degree, we order our fields and informants within this framework as well. Recently, many researchers have begun to organise their projects with increasing focus on participation from the research subjects, and at times, the occasionally surprising resistance is explicitly discussed. Methodology that is attentive to the subjectivity of the participants, and that attempts to empower them, may be said to highlight counter-conductive practices. Research subjects participate, negotiate, and decide on their own behalf to be more than the “researched”, and these practices are themselves discussed. Subject-embodied and attentively sensing, participating, and sharing, the research may discover and challenge various kinds of counter-conductive voices, bodies, and practices, as well as the spaces they occupy. The chapter is concerned with who is granted the opportunity to participate in the knowledge production, and who is qualified to have relevant knowledge.


  • Open Access

    Mye pastoralmakt, glimt av motmakt. Paradokser i kampen mot fattigdom og for rett levnet på slutten av 1700-tallet i Kristiania

    by Knut W. Ruyter, Inger Marie Lid, Trygve Wyller, Rosemarie van Den Breemer, Einar Egenæs, Marta Maria Espeseth, Cathrine Grimsgaard, Kjetil Hafstad, Adelheid Hummelvoll Hillestad, Kaia S. Rønsdal, et al.

    The study investigates the story of individuals from a lower-class family during the period of early industrialization along the Aker river. It is based on archival material from institutions established for ‘moral improvement’: hard labor prisons, houses of correction (Bridewell), poorhouses and hospitals. The means for correction are evaluated through the lens of Michel Foucault’s analysis of pastoral power for directing, forming and disciplining behavior and its counter-part, the necessity of contre-conduite to oppose and shortcut moral power, also revealing the paradoxes of the power for abuse and violence, even with the best of intentions. The study searched especially for counter-conduct among priests, the central agents of pastoral power, but found none.

  • Open Access

    En kristendomsform der ikke-troen hører til: Teologisk counter-conduct i dag

    by Trygve Wyller, Inger Marie Lid, Rosemarie van Den Breemer, Einar Egenæs, Marta Maria Espeseth, Cathrine Grimsgaard, Kjetil Hafstad, Adelheid Hummelvoll Hillestad, Knut W. Ruyter, Kaia S. Rønsdal, et al.

    The chapter discusses whether the Foucauldian counter conduct concept also has a theological relevance today. In his analysis, Foucault located counter conduct as a practice, which reformatted and reconstructed the prevailing pastoral power. The intention was to strengthen individual independency in faith issues and to reduce the powers of ecclesial hierarchy. One section in the article presents current interpretations of non-conventional ecclesial practices, from Norway and from Sweden. The discussion part presents significant perspectives from the so-called Scandinavian Creation Theology (SCT). The SCT gives theological prominence also to issues that seem not be directly relevant for faith matters. Everyday life issues are interpreted as aspects which are of strong significance for theology. This means that also what seems to be non-faith practices are theologically important. The final discussion in the article that a practice where Muslims are given a prayer room within the basement of a Lutheran church in Sweden can be interpreted as contemporary, theological counter-conducts. The practice gives significance to people not pertaining to Christian faith. But it also recognizes the life forms of people as relevant for a Christian church. The conclusion is that recognizing non-faith as part of what is ecclesial relevant, can be seen as theological counter conducts today. This practice recognizes people’s identity and reduces ecclesial hierarchies.


  • Open Access

    Uventede rom for andre narrativer. Hvordan Friluftssykehuset åpnet for Lars sin egen stemme

    by Einar Egenæs, Inger Marie Lid, Trygve Wyller, Rosemarie van Den Breemer, Marta Maria Espeseth, Cathrine Grimsgaard, Kjetil Hafstad, Adelheid Hummelvoll Hillestad, Knut W. Ruyter, Kaia S. Rønsdal, et al.

    This article presents how the human encounter at the new cabin, Friluftssykehuset, was the start of a new focus and a nascent hope for a young cancer patient named Lars. For both Lars and his family, this dialogue evoked good memories of their own places, their own summers in the mountains, and nature’s sensory impressions and moods. This development occured on a walk out from the hospital room and up to the cabin at Gaustadbekken. The imagination was set in motion and created new ideas that brought the boy into another mode so that the family as a whole was able to move into a resistance practice. My impetus for writing this article is that I work daily as a clinical social worker and family therapist in the department where Lars was treated, where I have a special responsibility for following up families of children with brain tumors with conversation and social medical support. The parents and the head of the department have given their consent for anonymous narratives from my sessions with Lars and his family to be used in this article.

  • Open Access

    Kristent arbeid for døve som makt og motmakt i perioden 1930–1945

    by Inger Marie Lid, Trygve Wyller, Rosemarie van Den Breemer, Einar Egenæs, Marta Maria Espeseth, Cathrine Grimsgaard, Kjetil Hafstad, Adelheid Hummelvoll Hillestad, Knut W. Ruyter, Kaia S. Rønsdal, et al.

    The chapter explores and discusses Christian religious work for deaf people with disabilities in the period of the eugenics, 1930–1945. The minister for the deaf Lutheran church in Norway, Conrad Bonnevie-Svendsen had a leading role both in the church and at the Home of the deaf, a diaconal institution providing a home and care services for deaf persons with disabilities. As a minister, Bonnevie-Svendsen had a leading role in the underground work under the Nazi occupation of Norway. Simultaneously, the Home of the deaf initiated and administered a work farm for deaf men with disabilities, segregating the deaf from the rest of the society. The Christian philanthropic work for deaf thus both adapted to the contemporary practice of segregation and worked against the occupation. This ambivalence is discussed in light of Foucault’s theory of counter conduct.