ATAndriy Tsvyetkov

Andriy Tsvyetkov

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Andriy Tsvyetkov has a total of 9 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    MECHANISM OF BANK SECRECY PROTECTION: COMPARATIVE LEGAL ANALYSIS OF SOME EUROPEAN STATES

    by Bychkova Svitlana, Tsvyetkov Andriy, Zaporozhchenko Arkadii, Chubenko Anton, Petrovskyi Andrii

    The global regulation of bank secrecy is defined by two conflicting trends: a move toward greater transparency and liberalization of access to information, versus the stringent defense of its inviolability. Ukraine, influenced by European deoffshorization efforts, has amended its legislation to enhance information sharing. Despite these reforms, significant legal debates persist in Ukraine regarding the scope of information that should be accessible to law enforcement agencies. Specifically, there is uncertainty and controversy surrounding the disclosure of data on account openings/closures (including e-wallets) and safe deposit box leases. This creates a legal gap that hinders effective law enforcement while raising concerns about privacy. This article aims to address this problem by comparing the mechanisms for protecting bank secrecy in Ukraine with those in leading foreign countries, with the goal of formulating recommendations to improve Ukraine's legal framework. The research employs dialectical, systemic-structural, formal-legal, and comparative-legal methods. The analysis reveals that disclosing information on account openings/closures and safe deposit box agreements to law enforcement is a common and effective practice in many EU states. It is concluded that implementing a similar model in Ukraine would be a viable step. Furthermore, the study proves the necessity of amending Ukrainian legislative provisions concerning the designated holders of bank secrecy.

  • The National Bank Of Ukraine As A Party To A Court Proceedings

    by Svitlana Bychkova, Andriy Tsvyetkov

    The purpose of the article is to determine the procedural status of the National Bank of Ukraine in administrative, civil, and commercial cases, as well as to develop scientifically sound proposals for improving the current legislation governing the activities of the National Bank of Ukraine. It has been established that the correct determination of the procedural status of the National Bank of Ukraine is complicated by its plural legal nature, since it may be a party to a court case and act on its behalf as a subject of authority or as a party to civil or economic relations, and also act in court on behalf of the State represented by the National Bank of Ukraine as the relevant public authority within its competence. Therefore, in each particular case, one should proceed from the essence of the disputed legal relationship to consider which entity is their direct participant, and what rights and obligations arise from such legal relationship. When determining the entity that will compensate for the damage caused by the National Bank of Ukraine (its officials), one should proceed from the nature of the legal relationship that will determine the application to a judicial institution for protection. If the claims are related to the activities of the National Bank of Ukraine as a public authority, they will be based on Articles 1167, 1173–1175 of the Civil Code of Ukraine; if such requirements are made to the National Bank of Ukraine as a party to civil or commercial relations, they should be guided by Articles 1166, 1167, 1172 of the Civil Code of Ukraine. In addition, given the plural legal nature of the National Bank of Ukraine, the issue of appealing a decision, acts, or omissions by the National Bank of Ukraine itself or its officials and employees, and engaged experts should be resolved. In administrative, civil, and commercial proceedings, the National Bank of Ukraine may be granted one of the following procedural statuses of a party to a case: plaintiff, defendant, third party, bodies, and persons, who are entitled by law to bring an action in the interests of others. Besides, in cases specified by law, the National Bank of Ukraine acts in court proceedings on behalf of the State. In this case, we can speak of its self-representation. Given the existence of general rules on compensation for damages, as well as provisions on the procedure for appealing against decisions, acts or omission by public authorities, it seems inappropriate to enshrine special rules on filing claims against the National Bank of Ukraine in the Law of Ukraine “On the National Bank of Ukraine”, as they lead to conflicts in the legal regulation of the relevant issues and do not consider plural legal nature of the central bank of Ukraine. In this regard, it is proposed to exclude Parts 2, 3 and 5 of Article 64-1 of the Law of Ukraine “On the National Bank of Ukraine”, while supplementing this Law with a new article “Liability for damage caused by the National Bank of Ukraine and persons associated with the National Bank of Ukraine”.

  • Theoretical and legislative approaches to the definition of «financial services», «banking services» and «banking operations» and their correlation

    by A. M. Tsvyetkov

    The article examines the historical, scientific and legislative approach to the definition of the concept of «financial services», «banking services» and «banking operations». Various interpretations of the bank in scientific articles, monographs and textbooks are systematized. It is also noted that the legislator identifies the concept of «banking activity» with part of the operations carried out by banking institutions. There is a distinction between the concepts of «banking service» and «banking operation», which are considered in different essences of these definitions. based on the above legal norms of the current legislation of Ukraine. It is emphasized that according to Part 2 of Article 125 of Subsection 6 «Financial Services» of the Association Agreement, the term «banking services and other financial services» is used, and a list of these services is given. The emphasis is placed on the fact that currently the main document in the field of harmonization of banking law, which defines the «roadmap» for the implementation of the provisions of the Association Agreement in the banking sector, is the Strategy for the Development of the Financial Sector of Ukraine. A detailed analysis of various scientific approaches to the interpretation of the concepts of «banking services» and «banking operations» made it possible to propose an author’s definition of the terms under study in the Law of Ukraine «On Banks and Banking Activities». Based on the analysis of the current legislation of Ukraine and research by domestic scientists, the following definition of banking services can be given — this is the professional activity of banking institutions that operate on the basis of a banking license by providing the following services to legal entities and individuals in both national and foreign currency for the purpose of making a profit: 1) attracting funds and bank metals that are subject to return from an unlimited number of persons; 2) opening and maintaining current (settlement, correspondent) accounts of clients, including in bank metals, and escrow accounts; 3) providing funds and bank metals on credit at the expense of funds and bank metals attracted in deposits, including in current accounts, in their own name, on their own terms and at their own risk. In our opinion, based on the analysis of various scientific approaches to the interpretation of the definition of the concept of «banking transaction» and its somewhat broad legislative interpretation, it is necessary to clarify and narrow it along with its main features. We propose the following formulation: «banking transactions are a set of specific, interconnected regular actions of a banking institution that has a license from the NBU and performs banking services in accordance with the standards and regulations stipulated in Article 47 of the Law of Ukraine «On Banks and Banking Activities» on the basis of a contract». Key words: services, financial services, payment services, banking activities, banking services, banking transactions, European Union, National Bank of Ukraine.

  • THE CONCEPT AND ESSENCE OF CONSUMER CREDIT

    by Academician F.H. Burchak Scientific Research Institute of Private Law and Entrepreneurship of the NALS of Ukraine, Andriy Tsvyetkov

  • Legal aspects of currency restrictions introduced by the National Bank of Ukraine for business under martial law

    by Andriy Mykhailovych Tsvetkov

    The article examines the definition of such concepts as «currency», «currency transaction», «currency values» and «currency regulation» in the legislation of Ukraine and scientific works of domestic scientists. The introduced currency restrictions and prohibitions were analyzed in accordance with the Resolution of the NBU Board «On the operation of the banking system during the introduction of martial law» No. 18 of February 24, 2022. In addition, a number of resolutions of the NBU Board in 2023–2024 regarding softening and optimization of a number of currency restrictions in order to prevent an unproductive outflow of capital to protect Ukraine’s international reserves and preserve the stability of the currency market were also studied. Thus, the introduction of the regime of managed flexibility of the exchange rate by the NBU was considered, in accordance with the Strategy for easing currency restrictions. The emphasis is placed on the fact that the main criterion for determining the priority of easing currency restrictions is the urgency of correcting distortions in the market and supporting economic recovery, taking into account the relevant risks for exchange rate stability and international reserves in accordance with the Roadmap developed by the NBU. The author drew attention to the limitation of cross-border transfers by Ukrainian ТЕОРЕТИКО-ПРИКЛАДНІ ТА ГАЛУЗЕВІ АСПЕКТИ 480 • АЛЬМАНАХ ПРАВА • 2024 • Випуск 15 • companies aimed at the execution of court decisions regarding foreign companies, settlement agreements concluded in the course of court proceedings and agreements concluded as a result of the court’s review of cases on recognition and granting of permission to execute the judgment of a foreign court. The author draws the attention of businesses to the observance of the deadlines for settlement of operations on export and import of goods, which amount to 180 calendar days and apply to operations carried out from April 5, 2022. Based on the analysis of court practice, it is proposed to make appropriate changes to Clause 14 of the above-mentioned Resolution of the Board of the National Bank of Ukraine No. 18 regarding the addition of clauses 46 and 47 to the list of exceptions to restrictions: «46) all transactions related to the implementation of the Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Court Decisions in Civil or Commercial Matters from July 2, 2019; 47) transactions related to the implementation by resident legal entities of private form of ownership of decisions of foreign courts and settlement agreements concluded by the parties in the process and/or as a result of consideration of the case by the court, including cases regarding the recognition and granting of permission for the implementation of decisions of foreign courts in Ukraine». Key words: currency, currency values, currency operations, currency regulation, currency restrictions, bank, National Bank of Ukraine, banking legislation.

  • Open Access

    Features of legal regulation of franchise agreement in Spain

    by Volodymyr Bobryk, Oleksandra Karmaza, Vitalii Makhinchuk, Andriy Tsvyetkov, Sergii Koroied