A. R. Kalymbetova
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
A. R. Kalymbetova has a total of 20 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Rymkul Ismailova
Astana IT University
3 shared publications - Dana Tubekova
International University of Tourism and Hospitality
2 shared publications - Raikhan Tazhibayeva
International University of Tourism and Hospitality
2 shared publications - Saule Kaltayeva
Ph.D., Associate Professor, Department of Hospitality, Faculty of Tourism, International University of Tourism and Hospitality, Kazakhstan
2 shared publications - Serikbai Ydyrys
International University of Tourism and Hospitality
2 shared publications A. A. Kulbayeva
International University of Tourism and Hospitality
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 2 October 2026
- Published by Turan University in Bulletin of "Turan" University
- No. 3,p. 258-270
The role of Kazakhstan’s ethnocultural heritage in economic development and the formation of tourism brand capital
This article examines Kazakhstan’s ethnocultural heritage in relation to economic development and the formation of tourism brand capital. The preservation of cultural and historical values is directly linked to their appropriate use in tourism. National traditions, historical sites, crafts, and local cultural features reflect the country’s distinctive identity and can increase tourist interest. They can also support the development of regional service industries and create opportunities for new tourism products. The study aims to assess the relationship between ethnocultural resources, the tourism economy, investment attractiveness, and tourism brand capital using empirical data. The study involved 40 respondents. The survey data were analysed using descriptive statistics, the Shapiro–Wilk test, factor analysis, Cronbach’s Alpha coefficient, and multiple regression analysis. The responses showed that participants placed a high value on ethnocultural heritage, authenticity, and the attractiveness of the tourism brand. The factor analysis identified three dimensions relating to cultural value, marketing support, and investment potential. The regression analysis revealed positive relationships between the attractiveness of tourism brand capital and ethnocultural value (β=0.42; p=0.001), authenticity (β=0.31; p=0.008), and marketing support (β=0.27; p=0.015). The model explained 61% of the variation in the indicator under consideration (R²=0.61). The findings indicate that ethnocultural heritage has economic potential in addition to its cultural significance. Its appropriate use in tourism development may contribute to regional economic diversification, support entrepreneurial and investment activity, and strengthen the competitive advantages of tourism destinations. Measures intended to preserve cultural heritage should therefore be coordinated with tourism branding strategies and regional economic development plans.
- 2 October 2026
- Published by Turan University in Bulletin of "Turan" University
- No. 3,p. 258-270
Open AccessThe role of Kazakhstan’s ethnocultural heritage in economic development and the formation of tourism brand capital
This article examines Kazakhstan’s ethnocultural heritage in relation to economic development and the formation of tourism brand capital. The preservation of cultural and historical values is directly linked to their appropriate use in tourism. National traditions, historical sites, crafts, and local cultural features reflect the country’s distinctive identity and can increase tourist interest. They can also support the development of regional service industries and create opportunities for new tourism products. The study aims to assess the relationship between ethnocultural resources, the tourism economy, investment attractiveness, and tourism brand capital using empirical data. The study involved 40 respondents. The survey data were analysed using descriptive statistics, the Shapiro–Wilk test, factor analysis, Cronbach’s Alpha coefficient, and multiple regression analysis. The responses showed that participants placed a high value on ethnocultural heritage, authenticity, and the attractiveness of the tourism brand. The factor analysis identified three dimensions relating to cultural value, marketing support, and investment potential. The regression analysis revealed positive relationships between the attractiveness of tourism brand capital and ethnocultural value (β=0.42; p=0.001), authenticity (β=0.31; p=0.008), and marketing support (β=0.27; p=0.015). The model explained 61% of the variation in the indicator under consideration (R²=0.61). The findings indicate that ethnocultural heritage has economic potential in addition to its cultural significance. Its appropriate use in tourism development may contribute to regional economic diversification, support entrepreneurial and investment activity, and strengthen the competitive advantages of tourism destinations. Measures intended to preserve cultural heritage should therefore be coordinated with tourism branding strategies and regional economic development plans.
- Open Access
- 9 April 2026
- Published by LLC CPC Business Perspectives in Public and Municipal Finance
- Vol. 15 (1) , 115-128
Fiscal decentralization and rural ecotourism: Assessing the capacity of local budgets to improve life quality in Kazakhstan
Type of the article: Research ArticleAbstractThis paper aims to quantitatively assess the functional capacity of local self-government (LSG) budgets to implement green economy strategies. This study uses longitudinal budget data from Turkestan, an administrative region of Kazakhstan (2019–2024), applying correlation and regression modeling. Four econometric models were constructed to define the dependencies between total revenues, transfers, tax yields, and expenditures of rural administrations.The empirical analysis identifies a critical level of vertical fiscal imbalance: the correlation between aggregate revenue (D01) and external transfers (TR-P) reached r = 0.991 (p < 0.01). Regression diagnostics confirm that 98.1% of revenue variance and 98.4% of expenditure variance are dictated by centralized subventions. The study uncovers a state of “budgetary mirroring” (a coefficient of 0.9938 in the expenditure-to-revenue model), in which approximately 99.4% of every tenge received is immediately absorbed by operational costs, effectively neutralizing long-term investment in ecotourism infrastructure. Conversely, an endogenous growth lever was detected: a strong correlation (r = 0.898) between tax yields and the sale of fixed assets. A second-order polynomial model (R² = 0.933) reveals a compounding acceleration in local tax generation, suggesting that the region has reached a fiscal inflection point with the potential to transition toward a self-sustaining development model.To transform ecotourism into a sustainable economic driver, rural governance must shift from a “survivalist” management model to one of active asset stewardship. We recommend reforming transfer architectures to include performance-based grants specifically earmarked for green infrastructure and the commercialization of municipal property.
- 9 April 2026
- Published by LLC CPC Business Perspectives in Public and Municipal Finance
- Vol. 15 (1) , 115-128
Open AccessFiscal decentralization and rural ecotourism: Assessing the capacity of local budgets to improve life quality in Kazakhstan
Type of the article: Research ArticleAbstractThis paper aims to quantitatively assess the functional capacity of local self-government (LSG) budgets to implement green economy strategies. This study uses longitudinal budget data from Turkestan, an administrative region of Kazakhstan (2019–2024), applying correlation and regression modeling. Four econometric models were constructed to define the dependencies between total revenues, transfers, tax yields, and expenditures of rural administrations.The empirical analysis identifies a critical level of vertical fiscal imbalance: the correlation between aggregate revenue (D01) and external transfers (TR-P) reached r = 0.991 (p < 0.01). Regression diagnostics confirm that 98.1% of revenue variance and 98.4% of expenditure variance are dictated by centralized subventions. The study uncovers a state of “budgetary mirroring” (a coefficient of 0.9938 in the expenditure-to-revenue model), in which approximately 99.4% of every tenge received is immediately absorbed by operational costs, effectively neutralizing long-term investment in ecotourism infrastructure. Conversely, an endogenous growth lever was detected: a strong correlation (r = 0.898) between tax yields and the sale of fixed assets. A second-order polynomial model (R² = 0.933) reveals a compounding acceleration in local tax generation, suggesting that the region has reached a fiscal inflection point with the potential to transition toward a self-sustaining development model.To transform ecotourism into a sustainable economic driver, rural governance must shift from a “survivalist” management model to one of active asset stewardship. We recommend reforming transfer architectures to include performance-based grants specifically earmarked for green infrastructure and the commercialization of municipal property.
- Open Access
- 25 March 2026
- Published by Turan University in Bulletin of "Turan" University
- No. 1,p. 102-114
Institutional mechanism of fourth-level budget management in Kazakhstan
The fourth-level budget is a vital instrument for rural development; however, Kazakhstan’s current legal framework is insufficient for rural akims to perform their functions effectively. The absence of a specialized regulatory framework governing local self-government (LSG) budget management remains a significant institutional challenge. This article examines the regulatory and institutional sustainability of the fourth-level budget, focusing on the Turkestan Region. As the region with the highest number of rural settlements and the largest rural population share in Kazakhstan, it represents a strategically vital case for fiscal management research. The study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of the institutional mechanism using correlation analysis of executed budget data from 2019–2024. The findings reveal an “institutional dependency trap”: a near-perfect correlation coefficient between total revenues and received transfers ($r = 0.99$) confirms that the management mechanism remains estimate-based and passive. In this model, rural akimats function merely as transit fund distributors. Conversely, a strong significant correlation between tax revenues and asset management ($r = 0.89$) identifies a crucial hidden driver for fiscal autonomy and self-development. To modernize this mechanism, the authors propose: resolving “institutional dualism” by redefining the Akim as the “CEO of the local community,” accountable primarily to the Kenes (Local Council) rather than the executive vertical; implementing a “Retention Bonus” model, allowing districts to retain 100% of surplus tax revenues without a subsequent reduction in transfers; enhancing public participation via mandatory e-voting on the “Open Budgets” portal for projects exceeding specific value thresholds. The practical significance lies in transforming rural administrations into autonomous, robust institutions of local self-government.
- 25 March 2026
- Published by Turan University in Bulletin of "Turan" University
- No. 1,p. 102-114
Open AccessInstitutional mechanism of fourth-level budget management in Kazakhstan
The fourth-level budget is a vital instrument for rural development; however, Kazakhstan’s current legal framework is insufficient for rural akims to perform their functions effectively. The absence of a specialized regulatory framework governing local self-government (LSG) budget management remains a significant institutional challenge. This article examines the regulatory and institutional sustainability of the fourth-level budget, focusing on the Turkestan Region. As the region with the highest number of rural settlements and the largest rural population share in Kazakhstan, it represents a strategically vital case for fiscal management research. The study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of the institutional mechanism using correlation analysis of executed budget data from 2019–2024. The findings reveal an “institutional dependency trap”: a near-perfect correlation coefficient between total revenues and received transfers ($r = 0.99$) confirms that the management mechanism remains estimate-based and passive. In this model, rural akimats function merely as transit fund distributors. Conversely, a strong significant correlation between tax revenues and asset management ($r = 0.89$) identifies a crucial hidden driver for fiscal autonomy and self-development. To modernize this mechanism, the authors propose: resolving “institutional dualism” by redefining the Akim as the “CEO of the local community,” accountable primarily to the Kenes (Local Council) rather than the executive vertical; implementing a “Retention Bonus” model, allowing districts to retain 100% of surplus tax revenues without a subsequent reduction in transfers; enhancing public participation via mandatory e-voting on the “Open Budgets” portal for projects exceeding specific value thresholds. The practical significance lies in transforming rural administrations into autonomous, robust institutions of local self-government.
- Open Access
- 20 June 2025
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Economic Research & Business Administration
- Vol. 152 (2) , 112-123
Foreign experience of local government budget management: analysis and application
Local self-government in the world is one of the most important mechanisms in solving issues of local importance and is the basis of regional development. The article explores international models of local self-government budget management and evaluates their applicability to Kazakhstan, particularly for rural development. The main research question is how foreign fiscal decentralization practices and citizen participation mechanisms can enhance local budget efficiency in Kazakhstan. Based on a comparative analysis of models from Finland, France, and Germany, the study proposes recommendations to strengthen the autonomy and financial independence of local self-governments. The research employs a qualitative methodology using comparative and systemic analysis. A limitation of the study is the absence of quantitative data and limited coverage of non-European countries. Based on the study of the experience of countries with different models of local self-government, and the work of scientists on this issue, a number of measures are proposed to improve the management of the budget of local self-government in Kazakhstan. These models are grounded in the process of establishing local self-government and the specific characteristics of how local executive authorities interact with state institutions.The study used both dialectical, formal-logical, general and particular methods. As a result of the study, measures have been proposed to improve the budget of local self-government: the creation and strengthening of the powers of authorized bodies, the application of fiscal decentralization practices, and the improvement of the practice of increasing citizens' activity in budget management. The successful implementation of local governance reforms, informed by international best practices, necessitates the adoption of innovative mechanisms of fiscal decentralization and structured civic involvement, tailored to national contextual factors. Key words: budget, local self-government, taxes, income.
- 20 June 2025
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Economic Research & Business Administration
- Vol. 152 (2) , 112-123
Open AccessForeign experience of local government budget management: analysis and application
Local self-government in the world is one of the most important mechanisms in solving issues of local importance and is the basis of regional development. The article explores international models of local self-government budget management and evaluates their applicability to Kazakhstan, particularly for rural development. The main research question is how foreign fiscal decentralization practices and citizen participation mechanisms can enhance local budget efficiency in Kazakhstan. Based on a comparative analysis of models from Finland, France, and Germany, the study proposes recommendations to strengthen the autonomy and financial independence of local self-governments. The research employs a qualitative methodology using comparative and systemic analysis. A limitation of the study is the absence of quantitative data and limited coverage of non-European countries. Based on the study of the experience of countries with different models of local self-government, and the work of scientists on this issue, a number of measures are proposed to improve the management of the budget of local self-government in Kazakhstan. These models are grounded in the process of establishing local self-government and the specific characteristics of how local executive authorities interact with state institutions.The study used both dialectical, formal-logical, general and particular methods. As a result of the study, measures have been proposed to improve the budget of local self-government: the creation and strengthening of the powers of authorized bodies, the application of fiscal decentralization practices, and the improvement of the practice of increasing citizens' activity in budget management. The successful implementation of local governance reforms, informed by international best practices, necessitates the adoption of innovative mechanisms of fiscal decentralization and structured civic involvement, tailored to national contextual factors. Key words: budget, local self-government, taxes, income.
- Open Access
- 6 September 2023
- Published by LLC CPC Business Perspectives in Public and Municipal Finance
- Vol. 12 (2) , 43-54
Exploring the effectiveness of social control mechanisms in fostering citizen involvement in rural local budgeting: The Kazakhstani perspective
The purpose of this study is to explore the involvement of citizens in the administration of local budgets, which significantly contribute to the financial and economic independence of rural areas. The study presents the findings of a sociological research conducted in the Turkestan region, Kazakhstan. The survey included 259 rural residents from 14 rural districts and two significant cities in the region, all aged 18 and above and permanent residents of these areas. The analysis is based on the survey results, focusing on the overall level of citizens’ engagement in decision-making regarding local budget formation and distribution in rural areas. The study reveals a low level of citizen participation in managing the local budget. While general meetings and local gatherings serve as primary avenues for citizen involvement, only 79.9% of respondents reported participating in budget discussions, with only 20.1% of their opinions considered during budget allocation.Finally, the study identifies several factors that negatively affect effective citizen participation in local budget management. These factors include a lack of timely awareness and information about upcoming planning and budget meetings (56.4%), insufficient transparency in the actions of local executive leaders (Akims) (14.3%), bureaucratic complexity and a formal approach to budget discussions (3.5%), and low levels of citizen trust in rural district Akims (5.4%). Acknowledgment This study is funded by the Science Committee of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan (BR18574203).
- 6 September 2023
- Published by LLC CPC Business Perspectives in Public and Municipal Finance
- Vol. 12 (2) , 43-54
Open AccessExploring the effectiveness of social control mechanisms in fostering citizen involvement in rural local budgeting: The Kazakhstani perspective
The purpose of this study is to explore the involvement of citizens in the administration of local budgets, which significantly contribute to the financial and economic independence of rural areas. The study presents the findings of a sociological research conducted in the Turkestan region, Kazakhstan. The survey included 259 rural residents from 14 rural districts and two significant cities in the region, all aged 18 and above and permanent residents of these areas. The analysis is based on the survey results, focusing on the overall level of citizens’ engagement in decision-making regarding local budget formation and distribution in rural areas. The study reveals a low level of citizen participation in managing the local budget. While general meetings and local gatherings serve as primary avenues for citizen involvement, only 79.9% of respondents reported participating in budget discussions, with only 20.1% of their opinions considered during budget allocation.Finally, the study identifies several factors that negatively affect effective citizen participation in local budget management. These factors include a lack of timely awareness and information about upcoming planning and budget meetings (56.4%), insufficient transparency in the actions of local executive leaders (Akims) (14.3%), bureaucratic complexity and a formal approach to budget discussions (3.5%), and low levels of citizen trust in rural district Akims (5.4%). Acknowledgment This study is funded by the Science Committee of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan (BR18574203).
- Open Access
- 4 May 2023
- Published by Narxoz University - Non-profit joint stock company in Central Asian Economic Review
- No. 6,p. 129-139
FISCAL DECENTRALIZATION AS A FOURTH-LEVEL BUDGET MANAGEMENT MECHANISM IN KAZAKHSTAN
The purpose of the study is to identify the role and significance, the main problems of fiscal decentralization as a mechanism for managing the budget of the fourth level. Identification of possible mechanisms for increasing the tax base of an independent budget with the help of fiscal decentralization.Research methodology. For general research, theoretical methods of research, analysis and synthesis, a systematic approach were used. Economic analysis (horizontal and vertical analysis) using qualitative and quantitative research methods was used to analyze independent budget revenues in Kazakhstan.Originality / value of the study. The analysis of fiscal decentralization as a mechanism for managing the fourth-level budget, the analysis of fourth-level budget revenues in Kazakhstan for 2019-2021, the priorities, competencies and responsibilities assigned to state and local government bodies are considered. The main directions of decentralization reform and recommendations for improving the efficiency of fourth-level budget management are identified.Findings: concrete conclusions are proposed based on the results of the implementation of this multifaceted trend. The main conditions for the effective functioning of any level of government are: accountability, transparency and control; possession of clearly defined powers and functions; availability of a personal budget with permanent sources of income; ownership of property.
- 4 May 2023
- Published by Narxoz University - Non-profit joint stock company in Central Asian Economic Review
- No. 6,p. 129-139
Open AccessFISCAL DECENTRALIZATION AS A FOURTH-LEVEL BUDGET MANAGEMENT MECHANISM IN KAZAKHSTAN
The purpose of the study is to identify the role and significance, the main problems of fiscal decentralization as a mechanism for managing the budget of the fourth level. Identification of possible mechanisms for increasing the tax base of an independent budget with the help of fiscal decentralization.Research methodology. For general research, theoretical methods of research, analysis and synthesis, a systematic approach were used. Economic analysis (horizontal and vertical analysis) using qualitative and quantitative research methods was used to analyze independent budget revenues in Kazakhstan.Originality / value of the study. The analysis of fiscal decentralization as a mechanism for managing the fourth-level budget, the analysis of fourth-level budget revenues in Kazakhstan for 2019-2021, the priorities, competencies and responsibilities assigned to state and local government bodies are considered. The main directions of decentralization reform and recommendations for improving the efficiency of fourth-level budget management are identified.Findings: concrete conclusions are proposed based on the results of the implementation of this multifaceted trend. The main conditions for the effective functioning of any level of government are: accountability, transparency and control; possession of clearly defined powers and functions; availability of a personal budget with permanent sources of income; ownership of property.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2020
- Published by EconJournals in International Journal of Energy Economics and Policy
- Vol. 10 (4) , 318-324
ANALYSIS OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ENERGY CONSUMPTION AND ECONOMIC GROWTH IN THE COMMONWEALTH OF INDEPENDENT STATES
Analysis of the Relationship between Energy Consumption and Economic Growth in the Commonwealth of Independent States
- 15 May 2020
- Published by EconJournals in International Journal of Energy Economics and Policy
- Vol. 10 (4) , 318-324
Open AccessANALYSIS OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ENERGY CONSUMPTION AND ECONOMIC GROWTH IN THE COMMONWEALTH OF INDEPENDENT STATES
Analysis of the Relationship between Energy Consumption and Economic Growth in the Commonwealth of Independent States