Ekaterina Martynova
Ekaterina Martynova has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Andrey Shcherbovich
1 shared publication- D. D. Shtodina
Gubkin University
1 shared publication Vera Rusinova
Doctor of Legal Sciences, LL.M (Goettingen); Professor, Head of the School of International Law of the Law Faculty, National Research University Higher School of Economics (HSE University), Moscow (Russia); Leader of the Research and Study Group ‘International Law in the Age of Cyber
1 shared publication- Артем Павлович Евсеев
Национальный исследовательский университет «Высшая школа экономики»; Savina Legal
1 shared publication - Сергей Павлович Сушков
Адвокатское бюро «Дякин, Горцунян и партнеры
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 26 February 2026
- Published by National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE) in Журнал ВШЭ по международному праву (HSE University Journal of International Law)
- Vol. 3 (4) , 75–90
Article 51 and cyberspace: the UN Charter constraints and the expanding frontiers of self-defence against cyber operations
The United Nations Charter, at its 80th anniversary, remains the cornerstone of international law governing the use of force and the maintenance of peace and security. However, the rapid development of information and communication technologies (hereafter — ICTs) in recent decades has introduced unprecedented challenges to its application, particularly in cyberspace. The ambiguity surrounding the interpretation of key UN Charter provisions — Article 2(4) on the prohibition of the use of force and Article 51 on self-defence — in the context of cyber operations has led to legal and strategic uncertainties. States increasingly engage in hostile cyber activities that blur the line between permissible acts and prohibited use of force. This raises critical questions about attribution and international responsibility, as well as escalation risks. This paper examines how the UN Charter’s framework struggles to address cyber conflicts in the context of jus ad bellum. Apart from the applicability of Article 51 in cyber context, the paper considers extra-Charter modalities of self-defence in cyberspace, based on the international treaties within the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, to explore potential legal and institutional adaptations to uphold international peace and security in the digital age.
- 26 February 2026
- Published by National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE) in Журнал ВШЭ по международному праву (HSE University Journal of International Law)
- Vol. 3 (4) , 75–90
Open AccessArticle 51 and cyberspace: the UN Charter constraints and the expanding frontiers of self-defence against cyber operations
The United Nations Charter, at its 80th anniversary, remains the cornerstone of international law governing the use of force and the maintenance of peace and security. However, the rapid development of information and communication technologies (hereafter — ICTs) in recent decades has introduced unprecedented challenges to its application, particularly in cyberspace. The ambiguity surrounding the interpretation of key UN Charter provisions — Article 2(4) on the prohibition of the use of force and Article 51 on self-defence — in the context of cyber operations has led to legal and strategic uncertainties. States increasingly engage in hostile cyber activities that blur the line between permissible acts and prohibited use of force. This raises critical questions about attribution and international responsibility, as well as escalation risks. This paper examines how the UN Charter’s framework struggles to address cyber conflicts in the context of jus ad bellum. Apart from the applicability of Article 51 in cyber context, the paper considers extra-Charter modalities of self-defence in cyberspace, based on the international treaties within the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, to explore potential legal and institutional adaptations to uphold international peace and security in the digital age.
- Open Access
- 30 December 2024
- Published by MGIMO University in Moscow Journal of International Law
- No. 4,p. 85-105
“Journey Beyond Tomorrow”: Navigating Regulation of AI-Powered Cyber Operations in the Realm of the Use of Force
INTRODUCTION. Artificial intelligence (AI) can significantly strengthen cybersecurity systems of States, as well as serve an additional technical means for malicious actions in the so-called cyberspace. Recognizing this, States have started investing in defensive and offensive autonomous cyber capabilities to protect their interests and deter potential adversaries; this has further fuelled the increase in inter-State cyber operations as nations seek to gain a competitive edge in the digital realm. This paper focuses not only on the problems of applying existing norms of international law to situations of malicious use of AI by States, but also on the process of these norms’ interpretation by different actors and, through this interpretation, crystallization of a common (or at least converging) understanding of their applicability. More specifically, this paper examines the path to understanding of how the norms on the use of force apply to AI-enabled cyber operations.MATERIALS AND METHODS. The present study is based on the works of both Russian and foreign specialists on the law of international information security, as well as analysis of documents and materials of groups of governmental experts under the auspices of the United Nations and the positions of States. In addition to general scientific methods (analysis, synthesis, induction and deduction), the theory of transnational legal process is applied to this study, which considers ongoing discussions of relevant issues on various platforms, and, more generally, the interaction of various actors regarding the formation of a pool of rules for responsible use of AI by States through interaction, interpretation and internalization of the interpreted legal ideas and practices into the domestic legal systems.RESEARCH RESULTS. The international efforts to develop a universal set of rules for responsible State behaviour in cyberspace have enjoyed rather modest success. The analysed history of cyber-related debate suggests that the AI-focused discussion for the foreseeable future will progress outside the area of developing a comprehensive treaty framework. Instead, the legal landscape of AI applications will appear to emerge from soft law instruments and private sector initiatives, which would lead to fragmentation of interpretation and State practice.DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS. The complication of inter-State cyber operations by AI technology raises additional questions about the application of international law, in particular its norms on the use of force, to AI-powered cyber incidents. The deployment of lethal autonomous weapons systems and commitment of AI-powered cyber operations could potentially lead to another ‒ this time, AI ‒ arms race, as nations seek to develop and acquire these systems to maintain strategic parity. This could destabilize global security and increase the risk of conflict escalation. This and other political and ethical considerations argue in favor of limiting the discretion of States in the use of AI. However, to date, the incentives for NATO States, China and Russia to agree on an international binding instrument limiting the use of AI for malicious purposes appear illusory. One could argue that corresponding discussions on AI will probably take place outside of the development of an international treaty, given the historical debate surrounding the application of international law in cyberspace and the development of norms governing responsible States behaviour in the use of information and communication technologies. Further analysis of this development, thus, will require examining how transnational norms, such as those emerging from soft law instruments, customary practices, and private sector initiatives, will shape the international legal landscape of the AI application.
- 30 December 2024
- Published by MGIMO University in Moscow Journal of International Law
- No. 4,p. 85-105
Open Access“Journey Beyond Tomorrow”: Navigating Regulation of AI-Powered Cyber Operations in the Realm of the Use of Force
INTRODUCTION. Artificial intelligence (AI) can significantly strengthen cybersecurity systems of States, as well as serve an additional technical means for malicious actions in the so-called cyberspace. Recognizing this, States have started investing in defensive and offensive autonomous cyber capabilities to protect their interests and deter potential adversaries; this has further fuelled the increase in inter-State cyber operations as nations seek to gain a competitive edge in the digital realm. This paper focuses not only on the problems of applying existing norms of international law to situations of malicious use of AI by States, but also on the process of these norms’ interpretation by different actors and, through this interpretation, crystallization of a common (or at least converging) understanding of their applicability. More specifically, this paper examines the path to understanding of how the norms on the use of force apply to AI-enabled cyber operations.MATERIALS AND METHODS. The present study is based on the works of both Russian and foreign specialists on the law of international information security, as well as analysis of documents and materials of groups of governmental experts under the auspices of the United Nations and the positions of States. In addition to general scientific methods (analysis, synthesis, induction and deduction), the theory of transnational legal process is applied to this study, which considers ongoing discussions of relevant issues on various platforms, and, more generally, the interaction of various actors regarding the formation of a pool of rules for responsible use of AI by States through interaction, interpretation and internalization of the interpreted legal ideas and practices into the domestic legal systems.RESEARCH RESULTS. The international efforts to develop a universal set of rules for responsible State behaviour in cyberspace have enjoyed rather modest success. The analysed history of cyber-related debate suggests that the AI-focused discussion for the foreseeable future will progress outside the area of developing a comprehensive treaty framework. Instead, the legal landscape of AI applications will appear to emerge from soft law instruments and private sector initiatives, which would lead to fragmentation of interpretation and State practice.DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS. The complication of inter-State cyber operations by AI technology raises additional questions about the application of international law, in particular its norms on the use of force, to AI-powered cyber incidents. The deployment of lethal autonomous weapons systems and commitment of AI-powered cyber operations could potentially lead to another ‒ this time, AI ‒ arms race, as nations seek to develop and acquire these systems to maintain strategic parity. This could destabilize global security and increase the risk of conflict escalation. This and other political and ethical considerations argue in favor of limiting the discretion of States in the use of AI. However, to date, the incentives for NATO States, China and Russia to agree on an international binding instrument limiting the use of AI for malicious purposes appear illusory. One could argue that corresponding discussions on AI will probably take place outside of the development of an international treaty, given the historical debate surrounding the application of international law in cyberspace and the development of norms governing responsible States behaviour in the use of information and communication technologies. Further analysis of this development, thus, will require examining how transnational norms, such as those emerging from soft law instruments, customary practices, and private sector initiatives, will shape the international legal landscape of the AI application.
- Open Access
- 15 November 2024
- Published by National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE) in Журнал ВШЭ по международному праву (HSE University Journal of International Law)
- Vol. 2 (3) , 52–63
Комментарий к Рамочной конвенции Совета Европы об искусственном интеллекте, правах человека, демократии и верховенстве права
Эта статья — одна из первых попыток дать научный комментарий к Рамочной конвенции Совета Европы об искусственном интеллекте, правах человека, демократии и верховенстве права 2024 года (далее — Конвенция). Авторы анализируют как общие характеристики Конвенции — ее юридическую природу, объект и цель — так и специальные вопросы, касающиеся реализации закрепленных в этом международном договоре принципов демократии и верховенства права, порядка использования средств правовой защиты, круга участников, а также механизмов имплементации Конвенции на национальном уровне. В статье также проводится сравнительно-правовой анализ этого договора и Акта Европейского союза об искусственном интеллекте, который до принятия Конвенции являлся единственным в своем роде документом, подробно регулирующим использование этой технологии. Авторы делают вывод о том, что Конвенция, хотя и воплощает «мягкую» модель международно-правового регулирования сферы искусственного интеллекта, тем не менее способна стимулировать развитие внутреннего законодательства государств-участников. Кроме того, некоторые из использованных в этом договоре подходов могут быть рассмотрены для целей разработки посвященных искусственному интеллекту международных правовых инструментов в рамках БРИКС, ШОС и/или ЕАЭС.
- 15 November 2024
- Published by National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE) in Журнал ВШЭ по международному праву (HSE University Journal of International Law)
- Vol. 2 (3) , 52–63
Open AccessКомментарий к Рамочной конвенции Совета Европы об искусственном интеллекте, правах человека, демократии и верховенстве права
Эта статья — одна из первых попыток дать научный комментарий к Рамочной конвенции Совета Европы об искусственном интеллекте, правах человека, демократии и верховенстве права 2024 года (далее — Конвенция). Авторы анализируют как общие характеристики Конвенции — ее юридическую природу, объект и цель — так и специальные вопросы, касающиеся реализации закрепленных в этом международном договоре принципов демократии и верховенства права, порядка использования средств правовой защиты, круга участников, а также механизмов имплементации Конвенции на национальном уровне. В статье также проводится сравнительно-правовой анализ этого договора и Акта Европейского союза об искусственном интеллекте, который до принятия Конвенции являлся единственным в своем роде документом, подробно регулирующим использование этой технологии. Авторы делают вывод о том, что Конвенция, хотя и воплощает «мягкую» модель международно-правового регулирования сферы искусственного интеллекта, тем не менее способна стимулировать развитие внутреннего законодательства государств-участников. Кроме того, некоторые из использованных в этом договоре подходов могут быть рассмотрены для целей разработки посвященных искусственному интеллекту международных правовых инструментов в рамках БРИКС, ШОС и/или ЕАЭС.
- 7 November 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Computer Law & Security Review
- Vol. 55
Digital transformation in Russia: Turning from a service model to ensuring technological sovereignty
- 7 November 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Computer Law & Security Review
- Vol. 55
Digital transformation in Russia: Turning from a service model to ensuring technological sovereignty
- Open Access
- 2 October 2024
- Published by National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE) in Legal Issues in the Digital Age
- Vol. 5 (3) , 103-128
Collective Countermeasures in Response to Cyber Operations under International Law
The paper examines the application of collective countermeasures — i.e., measures taken by non-injured states — as a means of cooperative non-institutionalized response to malicious cyber-enabled activities undertaken or controlled by a state. Particularly, the paper investigates: the right of the state not injured by a cyber operation to take countermeasures against the perpetrating state under current international law; and state positions towards collective countermeasures and possible grounds for the development of a more supportive attitude within states to this form of collective reaction. General research and special legal methods, as well as game theory, are employed to test the hypothesis the concept of collective countermeasures has been gaining nascent and fragmented support by states in terms of its applicability in the context of cyber operations. The author concludes this emerging trend reflects the general tendency of states to join forces to halt malicious activities in cyberspace and impose political and economic costs upon the perpetrators. This allows one to assume that collective countermeasures in response to cyber operations might become an expectable means of reaction by ‘like-minded’ states. Their legitimation might, therefore, be determined not only (or not so much) by the development of international law due to the practical difficulty in harmonizing positions among states on this issue at the current stage, but rather as a part of the general political trend of uniting the efforts of states to bring wrongdoers in cyberspace to responsibility.
- 2 October 2024
- Published by National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE) in Legal Issues in the Digital Age
- Vol. 5 (3) , 103-128
Open AccessCollective Countermeasures in Response to Cyber Operations under International Law
The paper examines the application of collective countermeasures — i.e., measures taken by non-injured states — as a means of cooperative non-institutionalized response to malicious cyber-enabled activities undertaken or controlled by a state. Particularly, the paper investigates: the right of the state not injured by a cyber operation to take countermeasures against the perpetrating state under current international law; and state positions towards collective countermeasures and possible grounds for the development of a more supportive attitude within states to this form of collective reaction. General research and special legal methods, as well as game theory, are employed to test the hypothesis the concept of collective countermeasures has been gaining nascent and fragmented support by states in terms of its applicability in the context of cyber operations. The author concludes this emerging trend reflects the general tendency of states to join forces to halt malicious activities in cyberspace and impose political and economic costs upon the perpetrators. This allows one to assume that collective countermeasures in response to cyber operations might become an expectable means of reaction by ‘like-minded’ states. Their legitimation might, therefore, be determined not only (or not so much) by the development of international law due to the practical difficulty in harmonizing positions among states on this issue at the current stage, but rather as a part of the general political trend of uniting the efforts of states to bring wrongdoers in cyberspace to responsibility.
- 9 May 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Israel Law Review
- Vol. 57 (1) , 135-174
Fighting Cyber Attacks with Sanctions: Digital Threats, Economic Responses
This article contributes to the understanding of why states resort to targeted, or smart, sanctions to meet the threat of cyber intrusions and whether this type of response is a forced measure or an effective tool to halt, prevent and punish attacking states. The tools of analysis used in the article are legal positivism and political theories, including Mancur Olson's theory of groups and Francesco Giumelli's analytical framework for assessment of sanctions. The authors address the effectiveness of sanctions as a reaction to cyber-enabled activities through the lens of regulation introduced in the United States, the European Union and the United Kingdom, which are the most developed counter-cyber sanction regimes, analysing publicly known cases of cyber-related sanctions.
- 9 May 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Israel Law Review
- Vol. 57 (1) , 135-174
Fighting Cyber Attacks with Sanctions: Digital Threats, Economic Responses
This article contributes to the understanding of why states resort to targeted, or smart, sanctions to meet the threat of cyber intrusions and whether this type of response is a forced measure or an effective tool to halt, prevent and punish attacking states. The tools of analysis used in the article are legal positivism and political theories, including Mancur Olson's theory of groups and Francesco Giumelli's analytical framework for assessment of sanctions. The authors address the effectiveness of sanctions as a reaction to cyber-enabled activities through the lens of regulation introduced in the United States, the European Union and the United Kingdom, which are the most developed counter-cyber sanction regimes, analysing publicly known cases of cyber-related sanctions.