DTDoǧa Tolgay

Doǧa Tolgay

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Doǧa Tolgay has a total of 73 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    COMAP Pathfinder – Season 2 results

    by D. A. Dunne, K. A. Cleary, J. G. S. Lunde, D. T. Chung, P. C. Breysse, N.-O. Stutzer, J. R. Bond, H. K. Eriksen, J. O. Gundersen, G. A. Hoerning, et al.

    We present a stack of data from the second season of the CO Mapping Array Project (COMAP) on the positions of quasars from eBOSS and DESI. COMAP is a line intensity mapping (LIM) experiment targeting dense molecular gas via CO(1–0) emission at z ∼ 3. Season 2 of COMAP represents a factor of three increase in map-level sensitivity over the previous early science data release. We do not detect any CO emission in the stack; instead, we find an upper limit of 10.0 × 10 10 K km s −1 pc 2 at 95% confidence within an ∼18 cMpc box. We compare this upper limit to models of the CO emission stacked on quasars and find a tentative (∼3 σ ) tension between the limit and the brightest stack models after accounting for a suite of additional sources of experimental attenuation and uncertainty, including quasar velocity uncertainty, pipeline signal loss, cosmic variance, and interloper emission in the LIM data. The COMAP-eBOSS/DESI stack is primarily a measurement of the CO luminosity in the quasars’ wider environment, and is therefore potentially subject to environmental effects such as feedback. With our current simple models of the galaxy-halo connection, we are thus unable to confidently rule out any models of cosmic CO with the stack alone. Conversely, the stack’s sensitivity to these large-scale environmental effects has the potential to make it a powerful tool for galaxy formation science, once we are able to constrain the average CO luminosity via the auto-power spectrum (a key goal of COMAP).


  • Open Access

    COMAP Pathfinder -- Season 2 results IV. A stack on eBOSS/DESI quasars

    by D. A. Dunne, K. A. Cleary, J. G. S. Lunde, D. T. Chung, P. C. Breysse, N. O. Stutzer, J. R. Bond, H. K. Eriksen, J. O. Gundersen, G. A. Hoerning, et al.

    We present a stack of data from the second season of the CO Mapping Array Project (COMAP) Pathfinder on the positions of quasars from eBOSS and DESI. COMAP is a Line Intensity Mapping (LIM) experiment targeting dense molecular gas via CO(1--0) emission at $z\sim3$. COMAP's Season 2 represents a $3\times$ increase in map-level sensitivity over the previous Early Science data release. We do not detect any CO emission in the stack, instead finding an upper limit of $10.0\times 10^{10}\ \mathrm{K\ km\ s^{-1}\ pc^2}$ at 95\% confidence within an $\sim 18\ \mathrm{cMpc}$ box. We compare this upper limit to models of the CO emission stacked on quasars and find a tentative ($\sim 3 σ$) tension between the limit and the brightest stack models after accounting for a suite of additional sources of experimental attenuation and uncertainty, including quasar velocity uncertainty, pipeline signal loss, cosmic variance, and interloper emission in the LIM data. The COMAP-eBOSS/DESI stack is primarily a measurement of the CO luminosity in the quasars' wider environment and is therefore potentially subject to environmental effects such as feedback. With our current simple models of the galaxy-halo connection, we are thus unable to confidently rule out any models of cosmic CO with the stack alone. Conversely, the stack's sensitivity to these large-scale environmental effects has the potential to make it a powerful tool for galaxy formation science, once we are able to constrain the average CO luminosity via the auto power spectrum (a key goal of COMAP).

  • Open Access

    COMAP Pathfinder – Season 2 results

    by J Lunde, N-O Stutzer, P Breysse, D Chung, K Cleary, D Dunne, H Eriksen, S Harper, H Ihle, J Lamb, et al.

    The CO Mapping Array Project (COMAP) Pathfinder is performing line intensity mapping of CO emission to trace the distribution of unresolved galaxies at redshiftz ∼ 3. We present an improved version of the COMAP data processing pipeline and apply it to the first two Seasons of observations. This analysis improves on the COMAP Early Science (ES) results in several key aspects. On the observational side, all second season scans were made in constant-elevation mode, after noting that the previous Lissajous scans were associated with increased systematic errors; those scans accounted for 50% of the total Season 1 data volume. In addition, all new observations were restricted to an elevation range of 35–65 degrees to minimize sidelobe ground pickup. On the data processing side, more effective data cleaning in both the time and map domain allowed us to eliminate all data-driven power spectrum-based cuts. This increases the overall data retention and reduces the risk of signal subtraction bias. However, due to the increased sensitivity, two new pointing-correlated systematic errors have emerged, and we introduced a new map-domain PCA filter to suppress these errors. Subtracting only five out of 256 PCA modes, we find that the standard deviation of the cleaned maps decreases by 67% on large angular scales, and after applying this filter, the maps appear consistent with instrumental noise. Combining all of these improvements, we find that each hour of raw Season 2 observations yields on average 3.2 times more cleaned data compared to the ES analysis. Combining this with the increase in raw observational hours, the effective amount of data available for high-level analysis is a factor of eight higher than in the ES analysis. The resulting maps have reached an uncertainty of 25–50 μK per voxel, providing by far the strongest constraints on cosmological CO line emission published to date.


  • Open Access

    COMAP Pathfinder – Season 2 results

    by D Chung, P Breysse, K Cleary, D Dunne, J Lunde, H Padmanabhan, N-O Stutzer, D Tolgay, J Bond, S Church, et al.

    The Carbon monOxide Mapping Array Project (COMAP) Pathfinder survey continues to demonstrate the feasibility of line-intensity mapping using high-redshift carbon monoxide (CO) line emission traced at cosmological scales. The latest COMAP Pathfinder power spectrum analysis is based on observations through the end of Season 2, covering the first three years of Pathfinder operations. We use our latest constraints on the CO(1–0) line-intensity power spectrum atz~ 3 to update corresponding constraints on the cosmological clustering of CO line emission and thus the cosmic molecular gas content at a key epoch of galaxy assembly. We first mirror the COMAP Early Science interpretation, considering how Season 2 results translate to limits on the shot noise power of CO fluctuations and the bias of CO emission as a tracer of the underlying dark matter distribution. The COMAP Season 2 results place the most stringent limits on the CO tracer bias to date, at ⟨T b⟩ < 4.8 μK, which translates to a molecular gas density upper limit ofρH2< 1.6 × 108M⊙Mpc−3atz~ 3 given additional model assumptions. These limits narrow the model space significantly compared to previous CO line-intensity mapping results while maintaining consistency with small-volume interferometric surveys of resolved line candidates. The results also express a weak preference for CO emission models used to guide fiducial forecasts from COMAP Early Science, including our data-driven priors. We also consider directly constraining a model of the halo–CO connection, and show qualitative hints of capturing the total contribution of faint CO emitters through the improved sensitivity of COMAP data. With continued observations and matching improvements in analysis, the COMAP Pathfinder remains on track for a detection of cosmological clustering of CO emission.


  • Open Access

    COMAP Pathfinder – Season 2 results

    by N.-O. Stutzer, J. G. S. Lunde, P. C. Breysse, D. T. Chung, K. A. Cleary, D. A. Dunne, H. K. Eriksen, H. T. Ihle, H. Padmanabhan, D. Tolgay, et al.

    We present updated constraints on the cosmological 3D power spectrum of carbon monoxide CO(1–0) emission in the redshift range 2.4–3.4. The constraints are derived from the two first seasons of Carbon monOxide Mapping Array Project (COMAP) Pathfinder line intensity mapping observations aiming to trace star formation during the epoch of galaxy assembly. These results improve on the previous Early Science results through both increased data volume and an improved data processing methodology. On the methodological side, we now perform cross-correlations between groups of detectors (“feed groups”), as opposed to cross-correlations between single feeds, and this new feed group pseudo power spectrum (FGPXS) is constructed to be more robust against systematic effects. In terms of data volume, the effective mapping speed is significantly increased due to an improved observational strategy as well as a better data selection methodology. The updated spherically and field-averaged FGPXS,C~(k), is consistent with zero, at a probability-to-exceed of around 34%, with an excess of 2.7σin the most sensitive bin. Our power spectrum estimate is about an order of magnitude more sensitive in our six deepest bins across 0.09 Mpc−1<k< 0.73 Mpc−1, compared to the feed-feed pseudo power spectrum (FPXS) of COMAP ES. Each of these bins individually constrains the CO power spectrum tok PCO(k) < 2400–4900 μK2Mpc2at 95% confidence. To monitor potential contamination from residual systematic effects, we analyzed a set of 312 difference-map null tests and found that these are consistent with the instrumental noise prediction. In sum, these results provide the strongest direct constraints on the cosmological 3D CO(1–0) power spectrum published to date.


  • Open Access

    COMAP Early Science. VIII. A Joint Stacking Analysis with eBOSS Quasars

    by Delaney A. Dunne, Kieran A. Cleary, Patrick C. Breysse, Dongwoo T. Chung, Håvard T. Ihle, J. Richard Bond, Hans Kristian Eriksen, Joshua Ott Gundersen, Laura C. Keating, Junhan Kim, et al.

    We present a new upper limit on the cosmic molecular gas density at z = 2.4–3.4 obtained using the first year of observations from the CO Mapping Array Project (COMAP). COMAP data cubes are stacked on the 3D positions of 243 quasars selected from the Extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (eBOSS) catalog, yielding a 95% upper limit for flux from CO(1–0) line emission of 0.129 Jy km s−1. Depending on the balance of the emission between the quasar host and its environment, this value can be interpreted as an average CO line luminosity L CO ′ of eBOSS quasars of ≤1.26 × 1011 K km pc2 s−1, or an average molecular gas density ρ H 2 in regions of the Universe containing a quasar of ≤1.52 × 108 M ⊙ cMpc−3. The L CO ′ upper limit falls among CO line luminosities obtained from individually targeted quasars in the COMAP redshift range, and the ρ H 2 value is comparable to upper limits obtained from other line intensity mapping (LIM) surveys and their joint analyses. Further, we forecast the values obtainable with the COMAP/eBOSS stack after the full 5 yr COMAP Pathfinder survey. We predict that a detection is probable with this method, depending on the CO properties of the quasar sample. Based on the achieved sensitivity, we believe that this technique of stacking LIM data on the positions of traditional galaxy or quasar catalogs is extremely promising, both as a technique for investigating large galaxy catalogs efficiently at high redshift and as a technique for bolstering the sensitivity of LIM experiments, even with a fraction of their total expected survey data.


  • Open Access

    [C ii] 158 μm emission as an indicator of galaxy star formation rate

    by Lichen Liang, Robert Feldmann, Norman Murray, Desika Narayanan, Christopher C Hayward, Daniel Anglés-Alcázar, Luigi Bassini, Alexander J Richings, Claude-André Faucher-Giguère, Dongwoo T Chung, et al.

    Observations of local star-forming galaxies (SFGs) show a tight correlation between their singly ionized carbon line luminosity ($L_{\rm [C\, {\small II}]}$) and star formation rate (SFR), suggesting that $L_{\rm [C\, {\small II}]}$ may be a useful SFR tracer for galaxies. Some other galaxy populations, however, are found to have lower $L_{\rm [C\, {\small II}]}{}/{}\rm SFR$ than local SFGs, including the infrared (IR)-luminous, starburst galaxies at low and high redshifts as well as some moderately SFGs at the epoch of re-ionization (EoR). The origins of this ‘$\rm [C\, {\small II}]$ deficit’ is unclear. In this work, we study the $L_{\rm [C\, {\small II}]}$–SFR relation of galaxies using a sample of z = 0–8 galaxies with $M_*\approx 10^7-5\times 10^{11}\, \mathrm{M}_\odot$ extracted from cosmological volume and zoom-in simulations from the Feedback in Realistic Environments (fire) project. We find a simple analytic expression for $L_{\rm [C\, {\small II}]}$/SFR of galaxies in terms of the following parameters: mass fraction of $\rm [C\, {\small II}]$-emitting gas ($f_{\rm [C\, {\small II}]}$), gas metallicity (Zgas), gas density (ngas), and gas depletion time ($t_{\rm dep}{}={}M_{\rm gas}{}/{}\rm SFR$). We find two distinct physical regimes: $\rm H_2$-rich galaxies, where tdep is the main driver of the $\rm [C\, {\small II}]$ deficit and $\rm H_2$-poor galaxies where Zgas is the main driver. The observed $\rm [C\, {\small II}]$ deficit of IR-luminous galaxies and early EoR galaxies, corresponding to the two different regimes, is due to short gas depletion time and low gas metallicity, respectively. Our result indicates that the $\rm [C\, {\small II}]$ deficit is a common phenomenon of galaxies, and caution needs to be taken when applying a constant $L_{\rm [C\, {\small II}]}$-to-SFR conversion factor derived from local SFGs to estimate cosmic SFR density at high redshifts and interpret data from upcoming $\rm [C\, {\small II}]$ line intensity mapping experiments.


  • Open Access

    $\rm [C_{II}]$ 158 $\rm μm$ emission as an indicator of galaxy star formation rate

    by Lichen Liang, Robert Feldmann, Norman Murray, Desika Narayanan, Christopher C. Hayward, Daniel Anglés-Alcázar, Luigi Bassini, Alexander J. Richings, Claude-André Faucher-Giguère, Dongwoo T. Chung, et al.

    Observations of local star-forming galaxies (SFGs) show a tight correlation between their singly ionized carbon line luminosity ($L_{\rm [C_{II}]}$) and star formation rate (SFR), suggesting that $L_{\rm [C_{II}]}$ may be a useful SFR tracer for galaxies. Some other galaxy populations, however, are found to have lower $L_{\rm [C_{II}]}{}/{}\rm SFR$ than the local SFGs, including the infrared-luminous, starburst galaxies at low and high redshifts, as well as some moderately star-forming galaxies at the epoch of re-ionization (EoR). The origin of this `$\rm [C_{II}]$ deficit' is unclear. In this work, we study the $L_{\rm [C_{II}]}$-SFR relation of galaxies using a sample of $z=0-8$ galaxies with $M_*\approx10^7-5\times10^{11}\,M_\odot$ extracted from cosmological volume and zoom-in simulations from the Feedback in Realistic Environments (FIRE) project. We find a simple analytic expression for $L_{\rm [C_{II}]}$/SFR of galaxies in terms of the following parameters: mass fraction of $\rm [C_{II}]$-emitting gas ($f_{\rm [C_{II}]}$), gas metallicity ($Z_{\rm gas}$), gas density ($n_{\rm gas}$) and gas depletion time ($t_{\rm dep}{}={}M_{\rm gas}{}/{}\rm SFR$). We find two distinct physical regimes, where $t_{\rm dep}$ ($Z_{\rm gas}$) is the main driver of the $\rm [C_{II}]$ deficit in $\rm H_2$-rich ($\rm H_2$-poor) galaxies. The observed $\rm [C_{II}]$ deficit of IR-luminous galaxies and early EoR galaxies, corresponding to the two different regimes, is due to short gas depletion time and low gas metallicity, respectively. Our result indicates that $\rm [C_{II}]$ deficit is a common phenomenon of galaxies, and caution needs to be taken when applying a constant $L_{\rm [C_{II}]}$-to-SFR conversion factor derived from local SFGs to estimate cosmic SFR density at high redshifts and interpret data from upcoming $\rm [C_{II}]$ line intensity mapping experiments.


  • AN EXTENDED ANALYSIS OF THE MODELS TO ESTIMATE PHOTOVOLTAIC MODULE TEMPERATURE

    by Talat Özden, Doga Tolgay, Muhammet Samet Yakut, Bulent G. Aki̇nOglu

    To estimate the performance of the photovoltaic power systems is the key issue in their techno-economic feasibility analysis. Performances, on the other hand, strongly depends on the module temperatures of the photovoltaic systems. In this study, we evaluated the performance of ten different module temperature estimation models using the measured outdoor data of five different modules. The modules are installed at the rooftop of a building located at Central Anatolia where the climate is cold and semi-arid. The results showed that the models having smaller number of parameters perform better than the others. We concluded that such analysis should be carried out at different ambient conditions so that the best performing models for the site can be obtained. Another outcome of the study is that the seasonal evaluation of the performance of the models should be carried out.