Akbota Kanderzhanova
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Akbota Kanderzhanova has a total of 21 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Akbota Tolegenova
Nazarbayev University School of Medicine
7 shared publications - Faye Foster
Nazarbayev University School of Medicine
7 shared publications - Paolo C. Colet
Department of Medicine, School of Medicine Nazarbayev University Astana Kazakhstan
7 shared publications - Valentina Stolyarova
Nazarbayev University School of Medicine
6 shared publications - J. Gareth Noble
Swanesa University Medical School, Singleton Park Campus, Swansea SA2 8PP, UK
5 shared publications Deanne Cobb-Zygadlo
Center for Preparatory Studies, Nazarbayev University, Astana, Kazakhstan
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 22 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
Living With a Permanent Colostomy: An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis of Patients' Experiences in Kazakhstan
Background: Living with a permanent colostomy involves changes that extend beyond physical stoma management to identity, everyday routines, social participation, relationships and emotional well‐being. Although existing research has documented quality‐of‐life and psychosocial outcomes, less is known about how people make sense of these changes and gradually reconstruct everyday life. The study aims to explore the lived experiences of patients living with a permanent colostomy in Kazakhstan. Aim: This study explored the lived experiences of patients living with a permanent colostomy. Design: This qualitative study used Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis and was grounded in phenomenology, hermeneutics and idiography. Methods: The study was conducted in a tertiary hospital in Astana, Kazakhstan. We purposively recruited sixteen adults with a permanent colostomy of at least 6 months' duration. Face‐to‐face semi‐structured interviews were conducted between March and April 2026, audio‐recorded and transcribed verbatim. Data were analysed using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis, with each participant analysed as an individual case before cross‐case comparison. Reflexive journaling, peer debriefing, member checking and an audit trail supported methodological transparency. Reporting followed the Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research guidelines. Results: The initial analytic process generated 107 preliminary analytic notes across the transcripts. Through iterative within‐case and cross‐case analysis, convergent and divergent patterns were identified and organized into 12 emergent themes, which were subsequently clustered into four higher‐order themes: (1) Initial Crisis, (2) Identity Crisis, (3) Social and Functional Reorganization and (4) Adaptation and Transformation. Conclusion: Adaptation to a permanent colostomy involved more than learning technical self‐care. The participants' retrospective accounts suggested an evolving and non‐linear process of adaptation involving interconnected changes in identity, daily routines, relationships and coping. The findings support nursing care that combines technical stoma education with repeated assessment of psychosocial needs, body image, intimacy, disclosure and self‐management across the care continuum. Patient or Public Contribution: No patient or public contribution. Patients with permanent colostomies participated as research participants and shared their lived experiences through individual interviews; however, patients or members of the public were not involved in the design, conduct, analysis, interpretation or preparation of the manuscript. Impact: (1) This study offers an in‐depth, context‐specific account of how patients in Kazakhstan make sense of living with a permanent colostomy. The findings conceptualize adaptation as an evolving process of reconstructing identity and everyday life, rather than merely acquiring technical stoma‐management skills. By bringing patient perspectives from Kazakhstan into the international literature, the study provides a contextual basis for considering how nursing support can address the emotional, identity‐related, social and functional dimensions of colostomy adaptation. (2) The main findings show that patients experience an initial period of shock, fear and emotional distress, followed by a gradual process of adaptation influenced by healthcare guidance, family support and personal coping strategies. Over time, participants reported changes in self‐identity, body image concerns, social anxiety related to stigma and challenges in intimacy. Despite these difficulties, many individuals demonstrated resilience, acceptance and personal growth through meaning‐making and increased health awareness. (3) The findings provide context‐specific insights that may inform nursing assessment and support for patients living with permanent colostomies. They highlight the importance of addressing emotional adjustment, body image, social participation, intimacy and self‐management alongside technical stoma care. These findings may also provide a basis for comparison with experiences reported in other healthcare and cultural contexts. Implications for the Profession and/or Patient Care: This study highlights the critical role of nurses in supporting patients before and after colostomy formation. Findings underscore the need for structured preoperative education, individualized stoma care training and ongoing psychosocial support addressing body image concerns, intimacy issues and stigma‐related distress. Nursing care should extend beyond technical management to include emotional support, counselling and family involvement. Early identification of psychological distress and timely referral to support services may improve adjustment and quality of life.
- 22 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
Living With a Permanent Colostomy: An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis of Patients' Experiences in Kazakhstan
Background: Living with a permanent colostomy involves changes that extend beyond physical stoma management to identity, everyday routines, social participation, relationships and emotional well‐being. Although existing research has documented quality‐of‐life and psychosocial outcomes, less is known about how people make sense of these changes and gradually reconstruct everyday life. The study aims to explore the lived experiences of patients living with a permanent colostomy in Kazakhstan. Aim: This study explored the lived experiences of patients living with a permanent colostomy. Design: This qualitative study used Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis and was grounded in phenomenology, hermeneutics and idiography. Methods: The study was conducted in a tertiary hospital in Astana, Kazakhstan. We purposively recruited sixteen adults with a permanent colostomy of at least 6 months' duration. Face‐to‐face semi‐structured interviews were conducted between March and April 2026, audio‐recorded and transcribed verbatim. Data were analysed using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis, with each participant analysed as an individual case before cross‐case comparison. Reflexive journaling, peer debriefing, member checking and an audit trail supported methodological transparency. Reporting followed the Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research guidelines. Results: The initial analytic process generated 107 preliminary analytic notes across the transcripts. Through iterative within‐case and cross‐case analysis, convergent and divergent patterns were identified and organized into 12 emergent themes, which were subsequently clustered into four higher‐order themes: (1) Initial Crisis, (2) Identity Crisis, (3) Social and Functional Reorganization and (4) Adaptation and Transformation. Conclusion: Adaptation to a permanent colostomy involved more than learning technical self‐care. The participants' retrospective accounts suggested an evolving and non‐linear process of adaptation involving interconnected changes in identity, daily routines, relationships and coping. The findings support nursing care that combines technical stoma education with repeated assessment of psychosocial needs, body image, intimacy, disclosure and self‐management across the care continuum. Patient or Public Contribution: No patient or public contribution. Patients with permanent colostomies participated as research participants and shared their lived experiences through individual interviews; however, patients or members of the public were not involved in the design, conduct, analysis, interpretation or preparation of the manuscript. Impact: (1) This study offers an in‐depth, context‐specific account of how patients in Kazakhstan make sense of living with a permanent colostomy. The findings conceptualize adaptation as an evolving process of reconstructing identity and everyday life, rather than merely acquiring technical stoma‐management skills. By bringing patient perspectives from Kazakhstan into the international literature, the study provides a contextual basis for considering how nursing support can address the emotional, identity‐related, social and functional dimensions of colostomy adaptation. (2) The main findings show that patients experience an initial period of shock, fear and emotional distress, followed by a gradual process of adaptation influenced by healthcare guidance, family support and personal coping strategies. Over time, participants reported changes in self‐identity, body image concerns, social anxiety related to stigma and challenges in intimacy. Despite these difficulties, many individuals demonstrated resilience, acceptance and personal growth through meaning‐making and increased health awareness. (3) The findings provide context‐specific insights that may inform nursing assessment and support for patients living with permanent colostomies. They highlight the importance of addressing emotional adjustment, body image, social participation, intimacy and self‐management alongside technical stoma care. These findings may also provide a basis for comparison with experiences reported in other healthcare and cultural contexts. Implications for the Profession and/or Patient Care: This study highlights the critical role of nurses in supporting patients before and after colostomy formation. Findings underscore the need for structured preoperative education, individualized stoma care training and ongoing psychosocial support addressing body image concerns, intimacy issues and stigma‐related distress. Nursing care should extend beyond technical management to include emotional support, counselling and family involvement. Early identification of psychological distress and timely referral to support services may improve adjustment and quality of life.
- Open Access
The Hidden Curriculum of Autism Care: Informal Learning among Clinicians and Caregivers in Kazakhstan
Background Autism care in Kazakhstan continues to develop amid limited training, unclear referral systems, and uneven provider readiness. While gaps in formal infrastructure have been well documented, the informal adaptations used by families and Physicians have received less attention. Aim To explore how informal learning, peer knowledge, and role modelling shape autism diagnosis and care in Kazakhstan, by examining the everyday behaviours and improvised routines that form a hidden curriculum alongside formal systems. Methods This study uses secondary analysis of two datasets: semi-structured interviews with parents of autistic children (n = 10), and national survey data from parents (n = 190) and physicians (n = 110). A concept-driven thematic analysis was applied to both interview and survey responses to identify recurring informal behaviours and decision-making patterns. Descriptive survey statistics were used to contextualise these qualitative findings. Results Parents frequently reported being left without post-diagnostic guidance, prompting them to rely on social media, peer groups, and personal networks. Physicians, especially those early in their careers, described relying on observation or mimicking more experienced colleagues in the absence of formal training. These behaviours reflect a hidden curriculum, unofficial but influential practices that shape practices that lead to inconsistent post-diagnostic guidance. Conclusion In Kazakhstan, informal knowledge-sharing and improvisation often affect care consistency or outcomes. These practices help fill urgent gaps but also introduce inconsistencies and shift burdens onto families, especially mothers. Policy and training reforms must acknowledge and address these informal structures to improve equitable care.
Open AccessThe Hidden Curriculum of Autism Care: Informal Learning among Clinicians and Caregivers in Kazakhstan
Background Autism care in Kazakhstan continues to develop amid limited training, unclear referral systems, and uneven provider readiness. While gaps in formal infrastructure have been well documented, the informal adaptations used by families and Physicians have received less attention. Aim To explore how informal learning, peer knowledge, and role modelling shape autism diagnosis and care in Kazakhstan, by examining the everyday behaviours and improvised routines that form a hidden curriculum alongside formal systems. Methods This study uses secondary analysis of two datasets: semi-structured interviews with parents of autistic children (n = 10), and national survey data from parents (n = 190) and physicians (n = 110). A concept-driven thematic analysis was applied to both interview and survey responses to identify recurring informal behaviours and decision-making patterns. Descriptive survey statistics were used to contextualise these qualitative findings. Results Parents frequently reported being left without post-diagnostic guidance, prompting them to rely on social media, peer groups, and personal networks. Physicians, especially those early in their careers, described relying on observation or mimicking more experienced colleagues in the absence of formal training. These behaviours reflect a hidden curriculum, unofficial but influential practices that shape practices that lead to inconsistent post-diagnostic guidance. Conclusion In Kazakhstan, informal knowledge-sharing and improvisation often affect care consistency or outcomes. These practices help fill urgent gaps but also introduce inconsistencies and shift burdens onto families, especially mothers. Policy and training reforms must acknowledge and address these informal structures to improve equitable care.
- Open Access
Knowledge, beliefs, practice challenges, training barriers, and needs of Kazakhstani nurses in the care of patients with autism: A descriptive cross-sectional study
Background Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is a neurodevelopmental condition requiring early identification and intervention to improve outcomes. Nurses are key to ASD care, facilitating referrals and supporting interventions, but often face knowledge gaps and limited training. In Kazakhstan, rising diagnoses of ASD, and healthcare reforms highlight the need for nurse education, yet challenges remain underexplored. This study examines nurses’ knowledge, beliefs, challenges in practice, training barriers, and training needs in caring for patients with autism. Methods This cross-sectional descriptive survey assessed the knowledge, beliefs, challenges, training barriers, and training needs of nurses involved in the care of individuals with ASD in Kazakhstan. Data were collected using purposive sampling from nurses aged 18 years and older working in hospitals, schools, and autism centers through an online survey distributed via email, professional networks, and social media platforms. A bilingual online survey (Russian and Kazakh) included 52 questions on demographics, knowledge and beliefs, challenges, barriers, and training needs. Descriptive and bivariate analysis were conducted by using the R studio. Results The study included N=201 nurses, predominantly female (89.05%) with an average age of 37 years. Most worked in the capital city of Kazakhstan, Astana (66.67%) and government facilities (73.13%), with 66.17% having over five years of experience. Although 69.15% had encountered ASD cases, knowledge gaps were evident, particularly in recognizing traits like resistance to change (50.00%), symptom onset before age three (46.00%), and preoccupation with objects (49.75%). Nurses without formal ASD training had the lowest percentage agreement on true statements (45.30%) compared to those with formal education (61.40%) or professional development (60.10%). The support/school group showed the lowest understanding overall. Despite 91.04% expressing interest in training, barriers like time constraints (33.33%) and limited course availability (30.35%) highlight the need for structured educational training programs. Conclusion Nurses in Kazakhstan demonstrated interest in ASD training and face significant knowledge gaps, particularly among those without formal education or in support roles. While many have encountered ASD cases, misconceptions persist, underscoring the need for tailored training programs that address specific barriers such as time constraints and course availability. Therefore, we recommend a structured, accessible education initiatives that will be essential to enhance nurses’ understanding and capabilities in ASD care, ultimately improving patient outcomes. Clinical Relevance This study highlights significant knowledge gaps and training needs among Kazakhstani nurses in the care of patients with autism. Implementing structured, role-specific educational programs can improve early diagnosis, referral accuracy, and quality of care for individuals with ASD in clinical settings.
Open AccessKnowledge, beliefs, practice challenges, training barriers, and needs of Kazakhstani nurses in the care of patients with autism: A descriptive cross-sectional study
Background Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is a neurodevelopmental condition requiring early identification and intervention to improve outcomes. Nurses are key to ASD care, facilitating referrals and supporting interventions, but often face knowledge gaps and limited training. In Kazakhstan, rising diagnoses of ASD, and healthcare reforms highlight the need for nurse education, yet challenges remain underexplored. This study examines nurses’ knowledge, beliefs, challenges in practice, training barriers, and training needs in caring for patients with autism. Methods This cross-sectional descriptive survey assessed the knowledge, beliefs, challenges, training barriers, and training needs of nurses involved in the care of individuals with ASD in Kazakhstan. Data were collected using purposive sampling from nurses aged 18 years and older working in hospitals, schools, and autism centers through an online survey distributed via email, professional networks, and social media platforms. A bilingual online survey (Russian and Kazakh) included 52 questions on demographics, knowledge and beliefs, challenges, barriers, and training needs. Descriptive and bivariate analysis were conducted by using the R studio. Results The study included N=201 nurses, predominantly female (89.05%) with an average age of 37 years. Most worked in the capital city of Kazakhstan, Astana (66.67%) and government facilities (73.13%), with 66.17% having over five years of experience. Although 69.15% had encountered ASD cases, knowledge gaps were evident, particularly in recognizing traits like resistance to change (50.00%), symptom onset before age three (46.00%), and preoccupation with objects (49.75%). Nurses without formal ASD training had the lowest percentage agreement on true statements (45.30%) compared to those with formal education (61.40%) or professional development (60.10%). The support/school group showed the lowest understanding overall. Despite 91.04% expressing interest in training, barriers like time constraints (33.33%) and limited course availability (30.35%) highlight the need for structured educational training programs. Conclusion Nurses in Kazakhstan demonstrated interest in ASD training and face significant knowledge gaps, particularly among those without formal education or in support roles. While many have encountered ASD cases, misconceptions persist, underscoring the need for tailored training programs that address specific barriers such as time constraints and course availability. Therefore, we recommend a structured, accessible education initiatives that will be essential to enhance nurses’ understanding and capabilities in ASD care, ultimately improving patient outcomes. Clinical Relevance This study highlights significant knowledge gaps and training needs among Kazakhstani nurses in the care of patients with autism. Implementing structured, role-specific educational programs can improve early diagnosis, referral accuracy, and quality of care for individuals with ASD in clinical settings.
- Open Access
Two Sides of the Spectrum: A Cross-Sectional Study of Autism Diagnosis and Treatment in Kazakhstan from the Perspectives of Parents and Physicians
Background Early diagnosis and intervention for autism spectrum disorder (ASD) are associated with improved outcomes, but access remains uneven in many low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). Kazakhstan has seen increasing awareness of ASD, yet systemic challenges in diagnosis and care persist. Objective To compare the perspectives of parents and physicians regarding the diagnosis, treatment, and post-diagnostic support of children with autism in Kazakhstan. Methods A cross-sectional, mixed-methods survey was conducted with 190 parents and 110 physicians across Kazakhstan. Structured questionnaires assessed early symptom recognition, diagnostic experiences, treatment practices, training needs, and beliefs about autism. Results While 76.6% of parents identified concerns before age three, diagnostic delays were common, and follow-up support was inconsistent. Physicians reported confidence in early identification (86.7%) but low use of standardized tools (26.7%). Notably, 30.0% believed autism could be outgrown with proper treatment, and 36.7% viewed ASD as having a poor prognosis even with early intervention. Nearly half of parents (46.8%) reported being advised to pursue pharmacologic treatment, often in the absence of behavioural therapy. Both groups identified training gaps, limited access to services, and fragmented care coordination as persistent challenges. Conclusion This dual-perspective study highlights ongoing systemic and perceptual barriers to autism care in Kazakhstan. Addressing misconceptions among clinicians, expanding evidence-based training, and strengthening diagnostic and therapeutic infrastructure are critical for improving outcomes and aligning national practices with global standards.
Open AccessTwo Sides of the Spectrum: A Cross-Sectional Study of Autism Diagnosis and Treatment in Kazakhstan from the Perspectives of Parents and Physicians
Background Early diagnosis and intervention for autism spectrum disorder (ASD) are associated with improved outcomes, but access remains uneven in many low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). Kazakhstan has seen increasing awareness of ASD, yet systemic challenges in diagnosis and care persist. Objective To compare the perspectives of parents and physicians regarding the diagnosis, treatment, and post-diagnostic support of children with autism in Kazakhstan. Methods A cross-sectional, mixed-methods survey was conducted with 190 parents and 110 physicians across Kazakhstan. Structured questionnaires assessed early symptom recognition, diagnostic experiences, treatment practices, training needs, and beliefs about autism. Results While 76.6% of parents identified concerns before age three, diagnostic delays were common, and follow-up support was inconsistent. Physicians reported confidence in early identification (86.7%) but low use of standardized tools (26.7%). Notably, 30.0% believed autism could be outgrown with proper treatment, and 36.7% viewed ASD as having a poor prognosis even with early intervention. Nearly half of parents (46.8%) reported being advised to pursue pharmacologic treatment, often in the absence of behavioural therapy. Both groups identified training gaps, limited access to services, and fragmented care coordination as persistent challenges. Conclusion This dual-perspective study highlights ongoing systemic and perceptual barriers to autism care in Kazakhstan. Addressing misconceptions among clinicians, expanding evidence-based training, and strengthening diagnostic and therapeutic infrastructure are critical for improving outcomes and aligning national practices with global standards.
- Open Access
Closing the Knowledge Gap: The Importance of Autism Education for Medical Professionals in Kazakhstan, Shaped by Parents’ Experiences
Background: In Kazakhstan, families of autistic children face significant barriers in obtaining timely diagnoses and accessing appropriate care. These challenges are shaped by cultural stigma, healthcare system limitations, and insufficient professional training. Understanding parents lived experiences can help inform more effective training for medical professionals. Methods: This qualitative study conducted semi-structured interviews with ten parents of autistic children from both rural and urban areas in Kazakhstan. Participants were recruited through social media outreach, follow-up from a prior survey, and snowball sampling. Interviews were conducted in Kazakh or Russian, transcribed, translated, and analysed thematically. Results: Five key themes emerged: (1) cultural stigma and dismissive attitudes from medical professionals; (2) over-reliance on pharmacological treatments; (3) reliance on informal support networks; (4) limited availability and high cost of autism services; and (5) lack of specialized training among healthcare providers. These barriers contributed to diagnostic delays, emotional distress, and inconsistent quality of care. Conclusions: Parents’ experiences reveal urgent gaps in Kazakhstan’s autism care infrastructure and professional training. Findings highlight the need for culturally adapted training for medical professionals that addresses stigma, improves communication, and promotes evidence-based, non-pharmacological interventions. Integrating parent perspectives into curriculum design can enhance service responsiveness and promote more equitable autism care across the country. Lay Many parents of autistic children in Kazakhstan face serious challenges when trying to get a diagnosis and access care. These challenges often come from medical professionals who may not be trained to recognize the early signs of autism or who hold negative attitudes. As a result, parents are often blamed for their child’s behaviour, dismissed by doctors, or given limited information about what autism means. This study interviewed parents from across Kazakhstan to understand their experiences with the healthcare system. Parents shared feelings of frustration, confusion, and emotional distress during the diagnostic process. They also talked about relying on online groups or other parents for support because professional guidance was often unavailable, expensive, or hard to access, especially outside of big cities. The results showed five major barriers: stigma and blame from professionals, pressure to use medications, limited access to services, poor communication, and a general lack of autism training for doctors. Based on these insights, the study suggests that future training programs in Kazakhstan should include information about autism, communication skills, and support for families. The goal is to help medical professionals better understand autism, reduce stigma, and offer the right kind of help from the beginning.
Open AccessClosing the Knowledge Gap: The Importance of Autism Education for Medical Professionals in Kazakhstan, Shaped by Parents’ Experiences
Background: In Kazakhstan, families of autistic children face significant barriers in obtaining timely diagnoses and accessing appropriate care. These challenges are shaped by cultural stigma, healthcare system limitations, and insufficient professional training. Understanding parents lived experiences can help inform more effective training for medical professionals. Methods: This qualitative study conducted semi-structured interviews with ten parents of autistic children from both rural and urban areas in Kazakhstan. Participants were recruited through social media outreach, follow-up from a prior survey, and snowball sampling. Interviews were conducted in Kazakh or Russian, transcribed, translated, and analysed thematically. Results: Five key themes emerged: (1) cultural stigma and dismissive attitudes from medical professionals; (2) over-reliance on pharmacological treatments; (3) reliance on informal support networks; (4) limited availability and high cost of autism services; and (5) lack of specialized training among healthcare providers. These barriers contributed to diagnostic delays, emotional distress, and inconsistent quality of care. Conclusions: Parents’ experiences reveal urgent gaps in Kazakhstan’s autism care infrastructure and professional training. Findings highlight the need for culturally adapted training for medical professionals that addresses stigma, improves communication, and promotes evidence-based, non-pharmacological interventions. Integrating parent perspectives into curriculum design can enhance service responsiveness and promote more equitable autism care across the country. Lay Many parents of autistic children in Kazakhstan face serious challenges when trying to get a diagnosis and access care. These challenges often come from medical professionals who may not be trained to recognize the early signs of autism or who hold negative attitudes. As a result, parents are often blamed for their child’s behaviour, dismissed by doctors, or given limited information about what autism means. This study interviewed parents from across Kazakhstan to understand their experiences with the healthcare system. Parents shared feelings of frustration, confusion, and emotional distress during the diagnostic process. They also talked about relying on online groups or other parents for support because professional guidance was often unavailable, expensive, or hard to access, especially outside of big cities. The results showed five major barriers: stigma and blame from professionals, pressure to use medications, limited access to services, poor communication, and a general lack of autism training for doctors. Based on these insights, the study suggests that future training programs in Kazakhstan should include information about autism, communication skills, and support for families. The goal is to help medical professionals better understand autism, reduce stigma, and offer the right kind of help from the beginning.
- Open Access
Barriers and Facilitators in Implementing Online Educational Interventions for Physicians: Systematic Review of Reviews
The implementation of online educational interventions for physicians presents both barriers and facilitators that shape the integration of digital learning into medical education frameworks. This systematic review of reviews aims to synthesize evidence on factors influencing the successful implementation of online educational interventions for physicians. We conducted searches across databases including, PubMed/Medline, Cochrane, Web of Science, Embase, PsycInfo, CINAHL spanning the years 2018 to 2023. Inclusion criteria comprised systematic reviews focusing on the implementation of e-learning. Data synthesis followed meta-ethnography principles, with categorization guided by the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR). Twenty-one relevant reviews were analyzed, highlighting factors within the CFIR domains: Innovation, Outer Setting, Inner Setting, Individuals, and Implementation Process. Facilitators included evidence-based practices, adaptability, leadership engagement, and resource availability, while barriers encompassed limited funding, regulatory hurdles, technological constraints, and resistance to change. The results emphasize how crucial it is for healthcare institutions, policymakers, educators, and technology providers to work together in order to effectively incorporate online learning into medical education. In conclusion, the study highlights the importance of tailored implementation strategies and policy recommendations, utilizing evidence-based practices and addressing various factors, to enhance online medical education’s effectiveness and ensure its integration into healthcare systems for improved patient outcomes.
Open AccessBarriers and Facilitators in Implementing Online Educational Interventions for Physicians: Systematic Review of Reviews
The implementation of online educational interventions for physicians presents both barriers and facilitators that shape the integration of digital learning into medical education frameworks. This systematic review of reviews aims to synthesize evidence on factors influencing the successful implementation of online educational interventions for physicians. We conducted searches across databases including, PubMed/Medline, Cochrane, Web of Science, Embase, PsycInfo, CINAHL spanning the years 2018 to 2023. Inclusion criteria comprised systematic reviews focusing on the implementation of e-learning. Data synthesis followed meta-ethnography principles, with categorization guided by the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR). Twenty-one relevant reviews were analyzed, highlighting factors within the CFIR domains: Innovation, Outer Setting, Inner Setting, Individuals, and Implementation Process. Facilitators included evidence-based practices, adaptability, leadership engagement, and resource availability, while barriers encompassed limited funding, regulatory hurdles, technological constraints, and resistance to change. The results emphasize how crucial it is for healthcare institutions, policymakers, educators, and technology providers to work together in order to effectively incorporate online learning into medical education. In conclusion, the study highlights the importance of tailored implementation strategies and policy recommendations, utilizing evidence-based practices and addressing various factors, to enhance online medical education’s effectiveness and ensure its integration into healthcare systems for improved patient outcomes.
- 7 December 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Qualitative Health Research
- Vol. 34 (6) , 507-516
“Who Else If Not Us”: An Exploratory-Descriptive Qualitative Study of Kazakhstani Frontline Professionals’ Experience and Perceptions During the Coronavirus Disease 2019 Pandemic
Little is known about the experiences of frontline professionals in Kazakhstan. Although studies of frontline workers have been conducted worldwide, it is imperative that caution should be exercised when extrapolating findings from disparate societies and generalizing them to Central Asian countries. As such, the purpose of this study was to explore and describe the firsthand experiences, perceptions, and knowledge gained from the experience of Kazakh frontline physicians and nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic. An exploratory-descriptive qualitative (EDQ) study was conducted over the course of a year in COVID-19 hospitals in Kazakhstan, with physicians ( n = 23) and nurses ( n = 7). Each participant was interviewed three times between May 2021 and May 2022. Braun and Clarke’s six-step method was used for the thematic analysis. Three overarching themes and subthemes were identified: (1) Longitudinal Journey (“Nobody knew, nobody understood, nobody was ready”; “It’s just life”); (2) Facets of Professionalism (“In my lifetime this is something unique”; “Who else if not us”; “We survived the war and the enemy”); and (3) Facets of Resilience (“God’s providence”; “A good word heals too”). In light of the lack of research that has previously been conducted in Kazakhstan, the results of this study offer important new insight into the experiences of medical professionals during the COVID-19 epidemic.
- 7 December 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Qualitative Health Research
- Vol. 34 (6) , 507-516
“Who Else If Not Us”: An Exploratory-Descriptive Qualitative Study of Kazakhstani Frontline Professionals’ Experience and Perceptions During the Coronavirus Disease 2019 Pandemic
Little is known about the experiences of frontline professionals in Kazakhstan. Although studies of frontline workers have been conducted worldwide, it is imperative that caution should be exercised when extrapolating findings from disparate societies and generalizing them to Central Asian countries. As such, the purpose of this study was to explore and describe the firsthand experiences, perceptions, and knowledge gained from the experience of Kazakh frontline physicians and nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic. An exploratory-descriptive qualitative (EDQ) study was conducted over the course of a year in COVID-19 hospitals in Kazakhstan, with physicians ( n = 23) and nurses ( n = 7). Each participant was interviewed three times between May 2021 and May 2022. Braun and Clarke’s six-step method was used for the thematic analysis. Three overarching themes and subthemes were identified: (1) Longitudinal Journey (“Nobody knew, nobody understood, nobody was ready”; “It’s just life”); (2) Facets of Professionalism (“In my lifetime this is something unique”; “Who else if not us”; “We survived the war and the enemy”); and (3) Facets of Resilience (“God’s providence”; “A good word heals too”). In light of the lack of research that has previously been conducted in Kazakhstan, the results of this study offer important new insight into the experiences of medical professionals during the COVID-19 epidemic.
- 4 May 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Evaluation & the Health Professions
- Vol. 47 (1) , 11-20
Mental Health Changes in Healthcare Workers During COVID-19 Pandemic: A Systematic Review of Longitudinal Studies
This study provides an overview of research findings on long-term effects on healthcare workers mental health and factors associated with positive or negative changes. Medline and PubMed databases were searched for observational longitudinal studies and 18 papers were included in the review (PROSPERO: CRD42021260307). 12 articles indicated negative changes over time and six studies revealed a positive trend in a variety of mental health outcomes (anxiety, depression, insomnia, and others). Female sex, younger age, nursing occupation, frontline work, longer working hours and concerns about contracting COVID-19 were identified to be associated with negative changes. Conversely, a supportive environment, access to psychological resources, provision of sufficient personal protective equipment and availability of COVID-19 tests were linked to positive changes. Therefore, our findings can assist governmental and institutional authorities with effective interventions to improve psychological care for healthcare workers.
- 4 May 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Evaluation & the Health Professions
- Vol. 47 (1) , 11-20
Mental Health Changes in Healthcare Workers During COVID-19 Pandemic: A Systematic Review of Longitudinal Studies
This study provides an overview of research findings on long-term effects on healthcare workers mental health and factors associated with positive or negative changes. Medline and PubMed databases were searched for observational longitudinal studies and 18 papers were included in the review (PROSPERO: CRD42021260307). 12 articles indicated negative changes over time and six studies revealed a positive trend in a variety of mental health outcomes (anxiety, depression, insomnia, and others). Female sex, younger age, nursing occupation, frontline work, longer working hours and concerns about contracting COVID-19 were identified to be associated with negative changes. Conversely, a supportive environment, access to psychological resources, provision of sufficient personal protective equipment and availability of COVID-19 tests were linked to positive changes. Therefore, our findings can assist governmental and institutional authorities with effective interventions to improve psychological care for healthcare workers.