EBEgid M. van Bree

Egid M. van Bree

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Egid M. van Bree has a total of 113 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • E(co)-health evolution: comparative life-cycle assessment of the virtual fracture clinic versus conventional inperson follow-up

    by Florian T Lub, Nicole F M van Vlijmen, Egid M van Bree, Lynn Snijder, Bas Twigt, David N Baden

    Background: The Virtual Fracture Care (VFC) method is designed to minimise follow-up visits for trauma patients seen in the emergency department (ED) with non-complex and stable injuries by adopting a risk-sharing model. Given the healthcare sector’s significant carbon footprint, this study aims to assess the environmental impact of VFC-pathway direct discharge with the standard pathway with inpatient follow-up, focusing on the treatment and follow-up of torus/greenstick fractures. Methods: A comparative cradle-to-grave life-cycle assessment was conducted at a Dutch ED. Data for material use, waste, packaging, transport, energy consumption, and staff and patient travel are included. Carbon footprints were calculated using SimaPro software with the ReCiPe 2016 method. The study compared the carbon footprints of the VFC pathway and standard pathway, identified key contributors, and performed a sensitivity and uncertainty analysis. Results: The VFC pathway resulted in a reduction of 2.8 (95% CI 2.1 to 3.9) kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent greenhouse gas emissions (kg CO ₂ -eq) per treatment compared with the standard pathway, which equates to an annual decrease of 625 kg CO ₂ -equivalents in 230 patients seen in our hospital. Key contributors to the difference in annual emissions were travel movements (411.7 kg CO ₂ -eq), materials (126.5 kg CO ₂ -eq) and packaging (6.9 kg CO ₂ -eq). Sensitivity analysis revealed that eliminating follow-up visits could result in an annual reduction of 805 kg CO ₂ -eq, if all patients travelled by car. Conclusion: The VFC pathway reduces the CO ₂ emission of treating torus/greenstick fractures, primarily by decreasing patient travel, while patient satisfaction and material use do not increase. Broader adoption of a risk-sharing model, that is digitally supported, may reduce environmental impact across healthcare domains.

  • Open Access

    Determinants of sustainable quality improvement for operating room clean air systems: a two-phase sequential qualitative study in Dutch hospitals

    by Egid M. van Bree, Erin N. A. Cornelisse, Roberto A. A. L. Traversari, Evelyn A. Brakema, Nicole D. Bouvy, Rianne M. J. J. van der Kleij

    Background: To address healthcare’s polluting environmental impacts, environmental sustainability is increasingly recognised as a key domain of healthcare quality improvement. Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems are important targets for environmental sustainability-oriented quality improvement, causing 70–90% of operating room (OR) energy consumption and incurring substantial amounts of greenhouse gas emissions. Safe and effective energy-saving measures exist yet are infrequently implemented in practice. This study aims to identify key implementation determinants for HVAC-related energy saving in the OR and to explore their prioritisation and interrelation. Methods: We performed a two-phase sequential qualitative study in Dutch academic and general hospitals. Clinicians, engineers, managers, and infection prevention specialists with HVAC- and OR-related expertise were recruited using purposive sampling. First, we conducted semi-structured interviews based on the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research. Findings were compiled into a shortlist of potential barriers and facilitators of implementation. Next, we performed combined ranking exercises and focus groups in different hospitals. Recordings were transcribed verbatim, coded by two researchers using a deductive-inductive approach, and analysed using Thematic Analysis. Ranking outcomes and focus group findings were combined to map key implementation determinants and processes. Results: We included 42 participants, based on expert interviews ( n = 12) and focus groups ( n = 32, two overlapped) in five hospitals. Prioritised barriers were technical and organisational, linked to hospitals’ size and structure, adjustability of the current HVAC system, and availability of in-house expertise. Limited HVAC-related knowledge and equivocal beliefs regarding HVAC’s contribution to infection prevention shaped perceived feasibility of energy-saving measures and compatibility with OR workflows. Prioritised facilitators were the evidence base for energy-saving measures, organisations’ relative priority to save energy, and presence of a dedicated implementation lead. Both bottom-up and top-down approaches had initiated HVAC adjustment processes in studied hospitals. Conclusions: Implementation of HVAC-related energy-saving measures in the OR is hampered by perceived implementation complexity, technical challenges, and individual knowledge gaps and beliefs. Dedicated multidisciplinary workgroups, managerial priority for energy saving, and collaboration of motivated individuals with complementary expertise and influence appear to support successful local implementation.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Environmental impact of cataract surgery and strategies for mitigation: a life cycle assessment in an academic hospital

    by Emma J. Kooistra, Laura Golsteijn, Egid M. van Bree, Sjoerd Elferink, Evelyn A. Brakema, Floris Hermeling, Pleun Hemelaar, Anne Ottenbros, Niels Crama, Rosalie van Zelm, et al.

    Purpose: To identify the main environmental hotspots of cataract surgery and evaluates strategies to reduce its environmental impact and to compare process-based and monetary value-based methodologies for environmental assessment. Setting: Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen, the Netherlands. Design: Cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment (LCA) following ISO 14040/44 guidelines. Methods: The environmental impact of phacoemulsification cataract surgery was assessed, including all processes, products, and equipment used in the operating room. Key contributors to human health and ecosystem damage were identified. A monetary value-based analysis was performed using the same inventory data to compare methodological approaches. Results: Disposables (35%) and patient travel (31%) were the largest contributors to the environmental impact. Immediate sequential bilateral cataract surgery (ISBCS) reduced the impact by 19%, and simplifying surgical kits achieved a 10% reduction. Additional reductions were observed with renewable energy (−12%) and sustainable transportation (−8%). The monetary value-based approach yielded a fourfold higher carbon footprint than the process-based LCA, while identifying similar hotspots. Conclusions: The main environmental hotspots of cataract surgery were patient travel and disposable products. The most effective mitigation strategy to reduce the carbon footprint is implementing ISBCS. Additional mitigation strategies include reducing the use of disposable products, encouraging sustainable travel options, and switching to renewable energy. These findings highlight opportunities for ophthalmologists to contribute to more sustainable surgical care.


  • Open Access

    The unresolved ethics of trading patient trust for environmental sustainability: a reply to Armitage

    by Egid M van Bree, Eva H Visser, Jiska J Aardoom, Laurens C van Gestel, Evelyn A Brakema, Marieke A Adriaanse

  • Open Access

    Integrating environmental sustainability in clinical counselling: a randomised, double-blind, experimental vignette study in the Netherlands

    by Egid M van Bree, Laurens C van Gestel, Eva H Visser, Jiska J Aardoom, Evelyn A Brakema, Marieke A Adriaanse


  • Open Access

    Environmental Impact of Physical Visits and Telemedicine in Nursing Care at Home: Comparative Life Cycle Assessment

    by Egid M van Bree, Lynn E Snijder, Hans C Ossebaard, Evelyn A Brakema

    Background: The health care sector contributes notably to environmental harms, impacting human and ecosystem health. Hence, countries increasingly set ambitions to transition to environmentally sustainable health care, focusing on resource use, energy consumption, and patient travel. Telemedicine is often considered a promising solution to reduce travel-related carbon emissions. However, underlying environmental impact assessments lack important components such as staff travel and fail to adhere to standardized conduct and reporting. Moreover, assessments of telemedicine use in primary care are scarce. Objective: This study aims to quantify and compare the environmental impact of physical visits and telemedicine visits in the context of domiciliary care and home nursing. Methods: We conducted a life cycle assessment following international ISO-14040/44 standards of all resources required per individual patient visit, either in person at the patient’s home or via video calling with a dedicated user-friendly tablet. We collected anonymous user data in collaboration with a telemedicine service company, complemented by consulting staff members of four nursing organizations. Telemedicine visits were elementary in nature, such as supporting patients in taking their medication or structuring their daily agenda. We quantified average environmental impacts from cradle to grave, using the Environmental Footprint method, and verified the robustness of the comparison via uncertainty analysis. The variability of environmental impacts in different settings was explored using scenario analyses for the available minimum to maximum ranges. Results: Compared to a single physical visit in the studied setting, a telemedicine visit contributed less to global warming (0.1 vs 0.3 kg of carbon dioxide equivalents [kgCO2eq]; –60%), particulate matter formation (6.2 * 10–9 vs 1.8 * 10–8 disease incidence; –60%), and fossil resource use (1.8 vs 4.4 megajoules; –60%). Mineral/metal resource use was higher for telemedicine than for physical visits (1.1 * 10–5 vs 4.0 * 10–6 kg antimony equivalent; +180%). Only water use was not consistently different in the uncertainty analysis. Scenario analyses indicated that telemedicine’s environmental impact could become similar to physical visits only in urban settings (1-3 km of travel distance) with 50%-100% car commuting (0.1-0.4 vs 0.2-0.7 kgCO2eq). In rural settings (5-15 km of travel distance, 80%-100% car commute), physical visits’ environmental impact was higher (1.0-3.5 kgCO2eq), mostly even for mineral/metal resource use. Conclusions: Using telemedicine for domiciliary care and home nursing mostly reduces its environmental impact compared to physical visits. Benefits are larger in rural settings, where travel distances between patients are larger, and apply to multiple environmental impacts but not always to mineral/metal resource use. In urban settings, factors that influence the degree to which telemedicine is environmentally beneficial are whether staff are working from home versus at the office, commuting to the office by bicycle versus by car, and reusing video-calling devices. Accordingly, considerate application of telemedicine is important to support care for both human and planetary health.


  • Open Access

    Integrating environmental sustainability in clinical counselling: a randomised, double-blinded, experimental vignette study of satisfaction with care

    by Egid M van Bree, Laurens C van Gestel, Eva H Visser, Jiska J Aardoom, Evelyn A Brakema, Marieke A Adriaanse

    STRUCTURED Objective: to explore whether advising environmentally sustainable treatment options in clinical counselling affects patients’ satisfaction with care compared to less sustainable (standard) options – accounting for differences in severity and types of medical problems. Design: a randomised, double-blinded, experimental vignette study with a four (between-group, Type of Advice) x two (between-group, Severity) x five (within-group, Medical Problem) mixed design. Participants received short descriptions of hypothetical patient-physician interactions based on their group allocation and subsequently indicated their satisfaction with care. Setting: a general practice or hospital visit. Participants: a representative sample of the general Dutch adult population. Interventions: four different types of medical advice, varying in level of environmental sustainability and whether sustainability is mentioned explicitly. Main outcome measures: satisfaction with care, operationalised as: treatment acceptability, trust in the physician, trust in the treatment, and the feeling that the physician prioritised their health (Likert scales, 1=strongly disagree, 7=strongly agree). Results: 1,536 participants completed the study. Across vignettes, participants receiving the less sustainable advice (M=5.6, SD=1.2) were generally more satisfied than participants receiving the more sustainable types of advice (P’s<.001). Participants receiving the explicitly more sustainable advice (M=4.8, SD 1.6) were generally less satisfied than participants receiving the implicitly more sustainable types of advice (P’s<.001). Differences were larger for the high-severity conditions (mean differences 0.4 to 1.8, P’s<.001), non-significant for most low-severity conditions, and varied per medical problem. Conclusions: advising more sustainable treatment options for high-severity conditions may negatively affect patients’ satisfaction with care, especially when sustainability is mentioned explicitly. However, the presence and size of the observed effect varied across medical problems and was generally non-significant or small for low-severity conditions. Clinicians’ situational awareness may differentiate whether sustainability should be discussed, or only guaranteed through institutional level decisions.


  • Open Access

    The environmental impact of telemonitoring vs. on-site cardiac follow-up: a mixed-method study

    by Egid M van Bree, Lynn E Snijder, Sophie ter Haak, Douwe E Atsma, Evelyn A Brakema

    Aims: Digital health technologies are considered promising innovations to reduce healthcare’s environmental footprint. However, this assumption remains largely unstudied. We compared the environmental impact of telemonitoring and care on site (CoS) in post-myocardial infarction (MI) follow-up and explored how it influenced patients’ and healthcare professionals’ (HPs) perceptions of using telemonitoring. Methods and results: We conducted a mixed-method study; a standardized life cycle assessment, and qualitative interviews and focus groups. We studied the environmental impact of resource use per patient for 1-year post-MI follow-up in a Dutch academic hospital, as CoS or partially via telemonitoring. We used the Environmental Footprint 3.1 method. Qualitative data were analysed using Thematic Analysis. The environmental impact of telemonitoring was larger than CoS for all impact categories, including global warming (+480%) and mineral/metal resource use (+4390%). Production of telemonitoring devices contributed most of the environmental burden (89%). Telemonitoring and CoS achieved parity in most impact categories at 65 km one-way patient car commute. Healthcare professionals and patients did not consider the environmental impact in their preference for telemonitoring, as the patient’s individual health was their primary concern—especially after a cardiac event. However, patients and HPs were generally positive towards sustainable healthcare and willing to use telemonitoring more sustainably. Conclusion: Telemonitoring had a substantially bigger environmental impact than CoS in the studied setting. Patient commute distance, reuse of devices, and tailored use of devices should be considered when implementing telemonitoring for clinical follow-up. Patients and HPs supported these solutions to enhance sustainability-informed cardiovascular care as the default option.


  • Open Access

    Assessing the environmental impact of coronary artery bypass grafting to decrease its footprint

    by Egid M van Bree, Tim Stobernack, Tadzjo Boom, Klaske Geene, Emma J Kooistra, Wilson Li, Evelyn A Brakema, Laura Golsteijn, Pleun Hemelaar, Scott McAlister, et al.

    OBJECTIVES: An urgent transition to environmentally sustainable healthcare is required. The purpose of this study was to identify key areas for environmental impact mitigation for a coronary artery bypass grafting trajectory. METHODS: An ISO14040/44 standardized life cycle assessment was conducted for the functional unit of an individual patient trajectory of elective coronary artery bypass grafting surgery, from operating room admission until intensive care unit discharge. Data were collected for products, processes, and services required for care delivery in a Dutch academic hospital for 12 patients. The environmental impact was calculated using the ReCiPe 2016 method. RESULTS: A single patient trajectory caused 414 [IQR 383–461] kgCO2 equivalents of global warming, equal to 2753 km of driving an average Dutch petrol-fuelled car. Other notable environmental impacts were fine particulate matter, (non-)carcinogenic toxicity, land use, and terrestrial acidification. Operating room disposable products (162 kgCO2eq), energy use (48 kgCO2eq), and employee commute (36 kgCO2eq) contributed most to global warming. The extracorporeal circulation set, surgical drapes, intraoperative salvage set, surgical gowns, and cotton gauzes caused most of the disposables’ environmental impact. Most energy use occurred in the operating room via heating, ventilation, and air conditioning. CONCLUSIONS: A coronary artery bypass grafting trajectory’s environmental impact primarily contributed to global warming. Most impact mitigation could be achieved by avoiding/reducing disposable product use when possible or replacing these with reusables. Optimizing operating room energy systems, switching to renewable energy, and encouraging low-emission employee commute can further reduce the environmental impact.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    A nationwide approach to reduction in anaesthetic gas use: the Dutch Approach to decarbonising anaesthesia

    by Jasper M. Kampman, Egid M. van Bree, Lieke Gielen, Nicolaas H. Sperna Weiland