Druscilla L. Scribner
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Druscilla L. Scribner has a total of 2 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Priscilla A. Lambert
Department of Political Science, Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo, MI, USA
8 shared publications - J. Kevin Corder
Western Michigan University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-14
Gendering Constitutions
Chapter 1 raises the central question of the book: Do constitutional rights matter for women’s equality? To understand whether constitutional gender provisions increase gender equality—and if they do, what the mechanism is—it is important to look systematically for patterns across the world. This introductory chapter previews why constitutional rights and gender provisions matter for women’s equality. It makes the case that constitutional provisions fall into three broad categories (gender-neutral, egalitarian, and maternal) and that the way women’s and gender equality is recognized has implications for women’s social, political, and economic equality. The chapter defines the book’s key terms and provides a summary of the argument, explaining how and why constitutional provisions matter for social change and highlighting the methods, core arguments, and central findings. It concludes with a chapter-by-chapter overview of the book.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-14
Gendering Constitutions
Chapter 1 raises the central question of the book: Do constitutional rights matter for women’s equality? To understand whether constitutional gender provisions increase gender equality—and if they do, what the mechanism is—it is important to look systematically for patterns across the world. This introductory chapter previews why constitutional rights and gender provisions matter for women’s equality. It makes the case that constitutional provisions fall into three broad categories (gender-neutral, egalitarian, and maternal) and that the way women’s and gender equality is recognized has implications for women’s social, political, and economic equality. The chapter defines the book’s key terms and provides a summary of the argument, explaining how and why constitutional provisions matter for social change and highlighting the methods, core arguments, and central findings. It concludes with a chapter-by-chapter overview of the book.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 89-124
Gender Provisions, Rights Advocacy, and Policy outcomes In Botswana and South Africa
Chapter 5 presents a comparison of two countries in Southern Africa, Botswana, and South Africa, which differ in the way they constitutionally recognize gender equality. South Africa takes a substantive approach, constitutionalizing gender differences in an inclusive and egalitarian manner. Botswana’s Constitution takes a more formal gender-neutral approach. The chapter analyzes how these differences affect the way advocates use constitutional rights to challenge the status quo or defend legislative gains. The cross-national comparison examines legislative reform efforts and high court decisions in four policy areas: family and customary law, gender-based violence, sexual and reproductive health, and employment rights. The results demonstrate how a gender-neutral approach to women’s equality can mask and perpetuate systemic disadvantages, particularly when cultural rights are constitutionally entrenched and protected as they are in Botswana. Botswana’s gender-neutral Constitution has limited activists’ ability to push for policies that promote women’s equality and redress systemic gender discrimination. In South Africa, by contrast, strong substantive gender equality provisions support efforts to attain, and then later defend, policy gains. In South Africa, substantive constitutional rights for gender equality have provided a critical tool to prevent backsliding.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 89-124
Gender Provisions, Rights Advocacy, and Policy outcomes In Botswana and South Africa
Chapter 5 presents a comparison of two countries in Southern Africa, Botswana, and South Africa, which differ in the way they constitutionally recognize gender equality. South Africa takes a substantive approach, constitutionalizing gender differences in an inclusive and egalitarian manner. Botswana’s Constitution takes a more formal gender-neutral approach. The chapter analyzes how these differences affect the way advocates use constitutional rights to challenge the status quo or defend legislative gains. The cross-national comparison examines legislative reform efforts and high court decisions in four policy areas: family and customary law, gender-based violence, sexual and reproductive health, and employment rights. The results demonstrate how a gender-neutral approach to women’s equality can mask and perpetuate systemic disadvantages, particularly when cultural rights are constitutionally entrenched and protected as they are in Botswana. Botswana’s gender-neutral Constitution has limited activists’ ability to push for policies that promote women’s equality and redress systemic gender discrimination. In South Africa, by contrast, strong substantive gender equality provisions support efforts to attain, and then later defend, policy gains. In South Africa, substantive constitutional rights for gender equality have provided a critical tool to prevent backsliding.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 38-60
Constitutional Gender Provisions and Equality
Chapter 3 explores the relationship between gender rights provisions and gender equality outcomes. Are there different outcomes where women’s equality is constitutionally valued, protected, and promoted? To address this question, this chapter looks at whether specific rights and provisions are associated with a more women-friendly legal framework in several key policy areas, including family law, reproductive autonomy, and employment equality. Egalitarian provisions are associated with legal frameworks that are more supportive of women’s rights. These legal frameworks may, in turn, contribute to greater gender equality; thus, the chapter also examines whether constitutional provisions, along with other explanatory factors, contribute to greater gender equality as measured by global indicators. This analysis employs the authors’ global database in which each country’s constitution is coded systematically with respect to sex and gender-based rights and protections at three points in time over a 20-year period. The cross-national results show that egalitarian provisions are associated with greater gender equality, while maternal provisions are negatively associated with gender equality.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 38-60
Constitutional Gender Provisions and Equality
Chapter 3 explores the relationship between gender rights provisions and gender equality outcomes. Are there different outcomes where women’s equality is constitutionally valued, protected, and promoted? To address this question, this chapter looks at whether specific rights and provisions are associated with a more women-friendly legal framework in several key policy areas, including family law, reproductive autonomy, and employment equality. Egalitarian provisions are associated with legal frameworks that are more supportive of women’s rights. These legal frameworks may, in turn, contribute to greater gender equality; thus, the chapter also examines whether constitutional provisions, along with other explanatory factors, contribute to greater gender equality as measured by global indicators. This analysis employs the authors’ global database in which each country’s constitution is coded systematically with respect to sex and gender-based rights and protections at three points in time over a 20-year period. The cross-national results show that egalitarian provisions are associated with greater gender equality, while maternal provisions are negatively associated with gender equality.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 61-88
Gender Provisions, Rights Advocacy, and Policy Outcomes in Chile And Argentina
Chapter 4 offers a comparative study of Chile and Argentina, neighboring countries in the Southern Cone region of South America that differ with regard to gender provisions in their national constitutions. Chile’s constitution is generally neutral toward gender, whereas Argentina’s includes several egalitarian provisions. This chapter considers claims in the literature that link constitutional provisions to differences in processes and outcomes, focusing on legislation and constitutional court cases. The comparative study draws on interviews with women’s rights advocates and archival research on legislation, legislative debates, and high court decisions to illustrate how constitutional language and the enumeration of women’s rights influence the content of legislation as well as judicial review of government policy. A comparative analysis of three policy areas—gender-based violence, sexual and reproductive health, and employment rights—highlights key differences. Chile’s Constitution has not helped advocates achieve their goals (and, in fact, its constitutional provision promoting the family has frequently been an impediment). In contrast, Argentina’s Constitution has enabled rights advocates to make progress in the legislative and judicial arenas despite barriers such as low state capacity and less effective gender machinery.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 61-88
Gender Provisions, Rights Advocacy, and Policy Outcomes in Chile And Argentina
Chapter 4 offers a comparative study of Chile and Argentina, neighboring countries in the Southern Cone region of South America that differ with regard to gender provisions in their national constitutions. Chile’s constitution is generally neutral toward gender, whereas Argentina’s includes several egalitarian provisions. This chapter considers claims in the literature that link constitutional provisions to differences in processes and outcomes, focusing on legislation and constitutional court cases. The comparative study draws on interviews with women’s rights advocates and archival research on legislation, legislative debates, and high court decisions to illustrate how constitutional language and the enumeration of women’s rights influence the content of legislation as well as judicial review of government policy. A comparative analysis of three policy areas—gender-based violence, sexual and reproductive health, and employment rights—highlights key differences. Chile’s Constitution has not helped advocates achieve their goals (and, in fact, its constitutional provision promoting the family has frequently been an impediment). In contrast, Argentina’s Constitution has enabled rights advocates to make progress in the legislative and judicial arenas despite barriers such as low state capacity and less effective gender machinery.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 15-37
Why Constitutions Matter for Gender Equality
Chapter 2 situates the study of gender in constitutions in the broader literature. The question of whether women’s equality can be furthered by constitutional recognition is closely related to a fundamental debate about the effect of law on society and social change. The argument advanced is that the ways gender equality and difference are constitutionally recognized shape the strategies with which women’s rights advocates and their opponents pursue policy changes. Whether the provisions are egalitarian, neutral, or maternal affects the content of subsequent legislation, judicial interpretation of laws and constitutional rights, and women’s equality in practice. The chapter lays out the theoretical expectations and then outlines the mixed methods approach taken in the book, which includes both in-depth case studies and large-n quantitative analysis. It also introduces the cross-national database of gender provisions used in this analysis and provides an overview of gender provisions over time and across countries.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 15-37
Why Constitutions Matter for Gender Equality
Chapter 2 situates the study of gender in constitutions in the broader literature. The question of whether women’s equality can be furthered by constitutional recognition is closely related to a fundamental debate about the effect of law on society and social change. The argument advanced is that the ways gender equality and difference are constitutionally recognized shape the strategies with which women’s rights advocates and their opponents pursue policy changes. Whether the provisions are egalitarian, neutral, or maternal affects the content of subsequent legislation, judicial interpretation of laws and constitutional rights, and women’s equality in practice. The chapter lays out the theoretical expectations and then outlines the mixed methods approach taken in the book, which includes both in-depth case studies and large-n quantitative analysis. It also introduces the cross-national database of gender provisions used in this analysis and provides an overview of gender provisions over time and across countries.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 125-134
Conclusion
Chapter 6 concludes by reflecting on the results of the mixed methods approach taken in the book. The quantitative analysis and qualitative case studies confirm that egalitarian provisions have positive effects on processes and outcomes that enhance women’s equality. Provisions that reinforce women’s maternal and caregiving roles negatively impact women’s equality. The chapter moves from a cross-national to a cross-regional comparison of the two cases with multiple egalitarian provisions, Argentina and South Africa, in contrast to Chile and Botswana which have mostly gender-neutral constitutions. Despite the clear regional differences, these comparisons highlight some important commonalities that can be traced to their constitutional rights and provisions. The chapter concludes by considering the constitutional revision processes initiated in Chile and Botswana. In both countries, women are seeking substantive equality.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 125-134
Conclusion
Chapter 6 concludes by reflecting on the results of the mixed methods approach taken in the book. The quantitative analysis and qualitative case studies confirm that egalitarian provisions have positive effects on processes and outcomes that enhance women’s equality. Provisions that reinforce women’s maternal and caregiving roles negatively impact women’s equality. The chapter moves from a cross-national to a cross-regional comparison of the two cases with multiple egalitarian provisions, Argentina and South Africa, in contrast to Chile and Botswana which have mostly gender-neutral constitutions. Despite the clear regional differences, these comparisons highlight some important commonalities that can be traced to their constitutional rights and provisions. The chapter concludes by considering the constitutional revision processes initiated in Chile and Botswana. In both countries, women are seeking substantive equality.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Gender, Constitutions, and Equality
This book addresses whether the "gendering" of constitutions promotes women’s equality. The authors use a mixed-methods approach to explore how constitutional gender rights affect political processes and strategies, legislative and judicial outcomes, and ultimately women’s equality. They employ a cross-national study by constructing a unique database of gender provisions in over 100 countries at three points in time: 1995, 2005, and 2015. Four in-depth comparative case studies on Argentina, Chile, South Africa, and Botswana trace the complex relationship between constitutional law, strategies, and policy change in four policy areas: family law, gender-based violence, reproductive rights, and employment rights. They argue that where egalitarian constitutional provisions are present, women’s rights advocates can use them as a tool to fight gender discrimination and pursue policy changes that address gender-based power disparities. At a time when gender equality provisions are increasingly common in constitutional design, this book clarifies the mechanisms that link constitutional provisions to changes in process and outcomes while also systematically describing and analyzing the effect of gender provisions across countries and over time. Gender, Constitutions, and Equality will inform theoretical debates on gender and politics, law and social change, feminist institutionalism, and constitutional design and its effect on legislation and political strategies.
- 1 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Gender, Constitutions, and Equality
This book addresses whether the "gendering" of constitutions promotes women’s equality. The authors use a mixed-methods approach to explore how constitutional gender rights affect political processes and strategies, legislative and judicial outcomes, and ultimately women’s equality. They employ a cross-national study by constructing a unique database of gender provisions in over 100 countries at three points in time: 1995, 2005, and 2015. Four in-depth comparative case studies on Argentina, Chile, South Africa, and Botswana trace the complex relationship between constitutional law, strategies, and policy change in four policy areas: family law, gender-based violence, reproductive rights, and employment rights. They argue that where egalitarian constitutional provisions are present, women’s rights advocates can use them as a tool to fight gender discrimination and pursue policy changes that address gender-based power disparities. At a time when gender equality provisions are increasingly common in constitutional design, this book clarifies the mechanisms that link constitutional provisions to changes in process and outcomes while also systematically describing and analyzing the effect of gender provisions across countries and over time. Gender, Constitutions, and Equality will inform theoretical debates on gender and politics, law and social change, feminist institutionalism, and constitutional design and its effect on legislation and political strategies.
- 14 March 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Politics, Groups, and Identities
- Vol. 8 (2) , 228-247
Constitutions and women’s rights advocacy: strategic uses of gender provisions in Argentina, Chile, Botswana, and South Africa
We examine gender provisions in national constitutions and their significance for women’s rights advocacy in Latin America and southern Africa. There is considerable debate about whether constitutional rights are merely “parchment barriers” or if they have the potential to further social change. Those who argue that law does matter generally assert that its effect is mediated by social and political actors. What is less understood is how constitutional provisions aid rights advocates’ efforts. What do constitutions enable them to do? We seek to shed light on this question by focusing on the strategies and behavior of women’s rights advocates given a particular set of constitutional provisions. Using archival research and interviews with women’s rights advocates, we examine how gender has been constitutionalized and how constitutional provisions have informed their efforts. Where constitutional provisions for gender equality are substantive, as they are in South Africa and Argentina, these provisions are central to the activities of civil society actors both for policy change advocacy and legal mobilization. In Botswana and Chile, on the other hand, the absence of egalitarian provisions has encouraged advocates to reach around the national constitution and rely on international law as a means to legitimate their claims and fight for favorable policies and court decisions.
- 14 March 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Politics, Groups, and Identities
- Vol. 8 (2) , 228-247
Constitutions and women’s rights advocacy: strategic uses of gender provisions in Argentina, Chile, Botswana, and South Africa
We examine gender provisions in national constitutions and their significance for women’s rights advocacy in Latin America and southern Africa. There is considerable debate about whether constitutional rights are merely “parchment barriers” or if they have the potential to further social change. Those who argue that law does matter generally assert that its effect is mediated by social and political actors. What is less understood is how constitutional provisions aid rights advocates’ efforts. What do constitutions enable them to do? We seek to shed light on this question by focusing on the strategies and behavior of women’s rights advocates given a particular set of constitutional provisions. Using archival research and interviews with women’s rights advocates, we examine how gender has been constitutionalized and how constitutional provisions have informed their efforts. Where constitutional provisions for gender equality are substantive, as they are in South Africa and Argentina, these provisions are central to the activities of civil society actors both for policy change advocacy and legal mobilization. In Botswana and Chile, on the other hand, the absence of egalitarian provisions has encouraged advocates to reach around the national constitution and rely on international law as a means to legitimate their claims and fight for favorable policies and court decisions.