Marit Sandstad
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Marit Sandstad has a total of 209 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Benjamin Mark Sanderson
CICERO Center for International Climate Research, Oslo, Norway
43 shared publications - Norman Julius Steinert
CICERO Center for International Climate Research, Oslo, Norway
36 shared publications - Chris Smith
Energy, Climate and Environment Program, International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA), Laxenburg, Austria
21 shared publications - Ragnhild Bieltvedt Skeie
CICERO Center for International Climate Research, P.O. Box 1129 Blindern, 0318 Oslo, Norway
18 shared publications - Glen Philip Peters
CICERO Center for International Climate Research, Oslo, Norway
16 shared publications - Bjørn Hallvard Samset
CICERO Center for International Climate Research Oslo Norway
14 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Supplementary material to "FASTMIP-CMIP7: A Coordinated Multi-Emulator Ensemble for Rapid, Spatially Resolved Climate Projections under CMIP7 Scenarios"
- 16 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSupplementary material to "FASTMIP-CMIP7: A Coordinated Multi-Emulator Ensemble for Rapid, Spatially Resolved Climate Projections under CMIP7 Scenarios"
- Open Access
- 16 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
FASTMIP-CMIP7: A Coordinated Multi-Emulator Ensemble for Rapid, Spatially Resolved Climate Projections under CMIP7 Scenarios
Earth System Models (ESMs) remain the gold standard for translating socioeconomic scenarios into spatially resolved climate projections, but their computational cost limits the number of scenarios and ensemble members that can be simulated and ties projections to the evidence available when simulations are performed. Climate emulators, which are statistical and machine-learning models trained on ESM output, enable large ensembles and allow projections to be updated as new observations emerge. Here, we present FASTMIP-CMIP7, a coordinated ensemble of seven emulators providing spatially and temporally resolved projections of temperature, precipitation and climate impact indicators for four newly released scenarios from the 7th phase of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP7), spanning very low (VL) to high (H) emissions. Despite scenario ranges having narrowed in CMIP7 comapred to CMIP6, emissions pathways remain the dominant source of uncertainty in regional end-of-century temperature projections, making mitigation the strongest lever for limiting future warming. In 2100, global land temperature reaches 2.3 °C under stringent mitigation (VL), and 3.9 °C under the current-policies scenario (M), approximately 1.4 times the global mean warming. Under M, even the coolest 5 % of years in 2100 are warmer over land than 95 % of present-day years. Precipitation projections are more heterogeneous, with internal variability and regional climate responses often obscuring scenario differences. Nevertheless, robust drying emerges in northern South America and the Mediterranean, where additional drying relative to today is 2.5 to almost four times greater under current policies (M) than under stringent mitigation (VL). Structural differences between emulators and choices in training, testing and validation introduce a new layer of uncertainty to emulated ensembles. Common, streamlined validation experiments are needed to establish confidence in emulated projections and support the broader integration of climate emulators into future climate assessments.
- 16 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
Open AccessFASTMIP-CMIP7: A Coordinated Multi-Emulator Ensemble for Rapid, Spatially Resolved Climate Projections under CMIP7 Scenarios
Earth System Models (ESMs) remain the gold standard for translating socioeconomic scenarios into spatially resolved climate projections, but their computational cost limits the number of scenarios and ensemble members that can be simulated and ties projections to the evidence available when simulations are performed. Climate emulators, which are statistical and machine-learning models trained on ESM output, enable large ensembles and allow projections to be updated as new observations emerge. Here, we present FASTMIP-CMIP7, a coordinated ensemble of seven emulators providing spatially and temporally resolved projections of temperature, precipitation and climate impact indicators for four newly released scenarios from the 7th phase of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP7), spanning very low (VL) to high (H) emissions. Despite scenario ranges having narrowed in CMIP7 comapred to CMIP6, emissions pathways remain the dominant source of uncertainty in regional end-of-century temperature projections, making mitigation the strongest lever for limiting future warming. In 2100, global land temperature reaches 2.3 °C under stringent mitigation (VL), and 3.9 °C under the current-policies scenario (M), approximately 1.4 times the global mean warming. Under M, even the coolest 5 % of years in 2100 are warmer over land than 95 % of present-day years. Precipitation projections are more heterogeneous, with internal variability and regional climate responses often obscuring scenario differences. Nevertheless, robust drying emerges in northern South America and the Mediterranean, where additional drying relative to today is 2.5 to almost four times greater under current policies (M) than under stringent mitigation (VL). Structural differences between emulators and choices in training, testing and validation introduce a new layer of uncertainty to emulated ensembles. Common, streamlined validation experiments are needed to establish confidence in emulated projections and support the broader integration of climate emulators into future climate assessments.
- Open Access
- 30 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (19) , 9263-9288
METEORv1.6: Spatial climate variability and integrated impact emulation
Climate impact assessment increasingly requires spatially explicit projections with realistic temporal variability at sub-annual resolution. METEORv1.6 extends the established METEOR spatial multi-timescale, multi-forcer climate emulation framework with two major capabilities: (1) a monthly climate variability model that generates realistic sub-annual climate sequences with seasonal cycles and inter-annual variability, enabling the generation of ensemble projections and (2) a modular impact assessment framework that translates climate projections into impact metrics. The monthly climate model represents seasonal harmonics and noise, while preserving covariance structures from the source model. Seasonal cycles are represented through harmonic analysis with temperature-dependent parameterization, enabling non-stationary simulation of seasonal timing shifts under warming. Principal Component Analysis is used to decompose monthly anomalies into spatial modes, then their temporal evolution and climate variability is modeled using Vector Autoregressive with eXogenous variables (VARX) processes. The impact assessment framework provides a standardized interface for ensemble processing and uncertainty quantification through a modular system of impact calculators. The initial case implementation includes heating and cooling degree days calculations which are key drivers in estimating energy sector demand, demonstrating ensemble-based uncertainty propagation from climate projections to impact metrics. Validation against CMIP6 data demonstrates that METEORv1.6 accurately reproduces statistical properties of monthly climate variability for a range of future scenarios when trained on a single scenario from an Earth System Model (together with a CO 2 quadrupling idealized experiment). The integrated impact framework enables rapid generation of probabilistic climate risk assessments at the spatial and temporal resolution that sectoral applications require. The implementation is open-source and extensible to additional impact domains.
- 30 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (19) , 9263-9288
Open AccessMETEORv1.6: Spatial climate variability and integrated impact emulation
Climate impact assessment increasingly requires spatially explicit projections with realistic temporal variability at sub-annual resolution. METEORv1.6 extends the established METEOR spatial multi-timescale, multi-forcer climate emulation framework with two major capabilities: (1) a monthly climate variability model that generates realistic sub-annual climate sequences with seasonal cycles and inter-annual variability, enabling the generation of ensemble projections and (2) a modular impact assessment framework that translates climate projections into impact metrics. The monthly climate model represents seasonal harmonics and noise, while preserving covariance structures from the source model. Seasonal cycles are represented through harmonic analysis with temperature-dependent parameterization, enabling non-stationary simulation of seasonal timing shifts under warming. Principal Component Analysis is used to decompose monthly anomalies into spatial modes, then their temporal evolution and climate variability is modeled using Vector Autoregressive with eXogenous variables (VARX) processes. The impact assessment framework provides a standardized interface for ensemble processing and uncertainty quantification through a modular system of impact calculators. The initial case implementation includes heating and cooling degree days calculations which are key drivers in estimating energy sector demand, demonstrating ensemble-based uncertainty propagation from climate projections to impact metrics. Validation against CMIP6 data demonstrates that METEORv1.6 accurately reproduces statistical properties of monthly climate variability for a range of future scenarios when trained on a single scenario from an Earth System Model (together with a CO 2 quadrupling idealized experiment). The integrated impact framework enables rapid generation of probabilistic climate risk assessments at the spatial and temporal resolution that sectoral applications require. The implementation is open-source and extensible to additional impact domains.
- Open Access
- 10 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-33
Response to Reviewer 1
Climate impact assessment increasingly requires spatially explicit projections with realistic temporal variability at sub-annual resolution. METEORv1.6 extends the established METEOR spatial multi-timescale, multi-forcer climate emulation framework with two major capabilities: (1) a monthly climate variability model that generates realistic sub-annual climate sequences with seasonal cycles and inter-annual variability, enabling the generation of ensemble projections and (2) a modular impact assessment framework that translates climate projections into impact metrics. The monthly climate model represents seasonal harmonics and noise, while preserving covariance structures from the source model. Seasonal cycles are represented through harmonic analysis with temperature-dependent parameterization, enabling non-stationary simulation of seasonal timing shifts under warming. Principal Component Analysis is used to decompose monthly anomalies into spatial modes, then their temporal evolution and climate variability is modeled using Vector Autoregressive with eXogenous variables (VARX) processes. The impact assessment framework provides a standardized interface for ensemble processing and uncertainty quantification through a modular system of impact calculators. The initial case implementation includes heating and cooling degree days calculations which are key drivers in estimating energy sector demand, demonstrating ensemble-based uncertainty propagation from climate projections to impact metrics. Validation against CMIP6 data demonstrates that METEORv1.6 accurately reproduces statistical properties of monthly climate variability for a range of future scenarios when trained on a single scenario from an Earth System Model (together with a CO2 quadrupling idealized experiment). The integrated impact framework enables rapid generation of probabilistic climate risk assessments suitable for sectoral applications, bridging the gap between global climate projections and local decision-making needs. The open-source implementation supports broad adoption and continued expansion to additional impact domains.
- 10 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-33
Open AccessResponse to Reviewer 1
Climate impact assessment increasingly requires spatially explicit projections with realistic temporal variability at sub-annual resolution. METEORv1.6 extends the established METEOR spatial multi-timescale, multi-forcer climate emulation framework with two major capabilities: (1) a monthly climate variability model that generates realistic sub-annual climate sequences with seasonal cycles and inter-annual variability, enabling the generation of ensemble projections and (2) a modular impact assessment framework that translates climate projections into impact metrics. The monthly climate model represents seasonal harmonics and noise, while preserving covariance structures from the source model. Seasonal cycles are represented through harmonic analysis with temperature-dependent parameterization, enabling non-stationary simulation of seasonal timing shifts under warming. Principal Component Analysis is used to decompose monthly anomalies into spatial modes, then their temporal evolution and climate variability is modeled using Vector Autoregressive with eXogenous variables (VARX) processes. The impact assessment framework provides a standardized interface for ensemble processing and uncertainty quantification through a modular system of impact calculators. The initial case implementation includes heating and cooling degree days calculations which are key drivers in estimating energy sector demand, demonstrating ensemble-based uncertainty propagation from climate projections to impact metrics. Validation against CMIP6 data demonstrates that METEORv1.6 accurately reproduces statistical properties of monthly climate variability for a range of future scenarios when trained on a single scenario from an Earth System Model (together with a CO2 quadrupling idealized experiment). The integrated impact framework enables rapid generation of probabilistic climate risk assessments suitable for sectoral applications, bridging the gap between global climate projections and local decision-making needs. The open-source implementation supports broad adoption and continued expansion to additional impact domains.
- Open Access
- 10 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-33
Reply on RC2
Climate impact assessment increasingly requires spatially explicit projections with realistic temporal variability at sub-annual resolution. METEORv1.6 extends the established METEOR spatial multi-timescale, multi-forcer climate emulation framework with two major capabilities: (1) a monthly climate variability model that generates realistic sub-annual climate sequences with seasonal cycles and inter-annual variability, enabling the generation of ensemble projections and (2) a modular impact assessment framework that translates climate projections into impact metrics. The monthly climate model represents seasonal harmonics and noise, while preserving covariance structures from the source model. Seasonal cycles are represented through harmonic analysis with temperature-dependent parameterization, enabling non-stationary simulation of seasonal timing shifts under warming. Principal Component Analysis is used to decompose monthly anomalies into spatial modes, then their temporal evolution and climate variability is modeled using Vector Autoregressive with eXogenous variables (VARX) processes. The impact assessment framework provides a standardized interface for ensemble processing and uncertainty quantification through a modular system of impact calculators. The initial case implementation includes heating and cooling degree days calculations which are key drivers in estimating energy sector demand, demonstrating ensemble-based uncertainty propagation from climate projections to impact metrics. Validation against CMIP6 data demonstrates that METEORv1.6 accurately reproduces statistical properties of monthly climate variability for a range of future scenarios when trained on a single scenario from an Earth System Model (together with a CO2 quadrupling idealized experiment). The integrated impact framework enables rapid generation of probabilistic climate risk assessments suitable for sectoral applications, bridging the gap between global climate projections and local decision-making needs. The open-source implementation supports broad adoption and continued expansion to additional impact domains.
- 10 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-33
Open AccessReply on RC2
Climate impact assessment increasingly requires spatially explicit projections with realistic temporal variability at sub-annual resolution. METEORv1.6 extends the established METEOR spatial multi-timescale, multi-forcer climate emulation framework with two major capabilities: (1) a monthly climate variability model that generates realistic sub-annual climate sequences with seasonal cycles and inter-annual variability, enabling the generation of ensemble projections and (2) a modular impact assessment framework that translates climate projections into impact metrics. The monthly climate model represents seasonal harmonics and noise, while preserving covariance structures from the source model. Seasonal cycles are represented through harmonic analysis with temperature-dependent parameterization, enabling non-stationary simulation of seasonal timing shifts under warming. Principal Component Analysis is used to decompose monthly anomalies into spatial modes, then their temporal evolution and climate variability is modeled using Vector Autoregressive with eXogenous variables (VARX) processes. The impact assessment framework provides a standardized interface for ensemble processing and uncertainty quantification through a modular system of impact calculators. The initial case implementation includes heating and cooling degree days calculations which are key drivers in estimating energy sector demand, demonstrating ensemble-based uncertainty propagation from climate projections to impact metrics. Validation against CMIP6 data demonstrates that METEORv1.6 accurately reproduces statistical properties of monthly climate variability for a range of future scenarios when trained on a single scenario from an Earth System Model (together with a CO2 quadrupling idealized experiment). The integrated impact framework enables rapid generation of probabilistic climate risk assessments suitable for sectoral applications, bridging the gap between global climate projections and local decision-making needs. The open-source implementation supports broad adoption and continued expansion to additional impact domains.
- Open Access
- 4 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-46
Comment on egusphere-2026-1875
The Zero Emissions Commitment (ZEC), the residual warming after anthropogenic CO2 emissions cease, remains poorly constrained and directly affects remaining carbon budget calculations. We fit a simple coupled carbon-climate model to ten Earth System Models (ESMs) in the flat10 Model Intercomparison Project. Near-zero multi-model mean ZEC can be decomposed into unrealised ocean warming contributing roughly +0.2 K at 50 years post-cessation, which is almost exactly offset by ~-0.2 K of cooling from atmospheric CO2 drawdown into land and ocean carbon sinks. Yet the thermal term carries more than twice the inter-model spread of the carbon term; as such, in the context of current ESMs, reducing ZEC uncertainty depends more strongly on equilibrium climate sensitivity and the slow ocean heat uptake timescale than on carbon-cycle parameters. Individual models split into a carbon-dominated majority (eight of ten, negative ZEC) and a thermal-dominated minority (positive ZEC), distinguished primarily by their realised warming fraction and equilibrium climate sensitivity. The simple model yields a compact analytical formula for ZEC in terms of component climate and carbon-cycle parameters, reproducing ESM-simulated values to within ~0.03 K (less than 5% of the ~0.6 K inter-model spread). The decomposition also reveals that the carbon cycle buffers ZEC against uncertainty in committed warming to an existing energetic imbalance: recent downward revisions of the realised warming fraction (the ratio of transient to equilibrium warming) imply substantially more committed warming at fixed atmospheric composition, yet this additional heat is strongly attenuated before it appears in ZEC. A reduction of 10 per cent in the realised warming fraction would increase the radiatively committed warming by ~0.5 K at cessation, but this shifts the 50-year ZEC by only ~0.05 K. This allows potential for process-level constraints on climate and carbon-cycle components on ZEC to narrow carbon budgets. Out-of-sample testing on the flat10-cdr experiment shows that CO2 predictions diverge from ESMs within ~50 years of the emission trajectory departing from the training rate, so the framework does not extend to full climate reversibility under sustained negative emissions. Structural limitations, including under-sampled land biosphere diversity across ESMs, may further emerge at higher warming levels or on multi-centennial timescales.
- 4 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-46
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-1875
The Zero Emissions Commitment (ZEC), the residual warming after anthropogenic CO2 emissions cease, remains poorly constrained and directly affects remaining carbon budget calculations. We fit a simple coupled carbon-climate model to ten Earth System Models (ESMs) in the flat10 Model Intercomparison Project. Near-zero multi-model mean ZEC can be decomposed into unrealised ocean warming contributing roughly +0.2 K at 50 years post-cessation, which is almost exactly offset by ~-0.2 K of cooling from atmospheric CO2 drawdown into land and ocean carbon sinks. Yet the thermal term carries more than twice the inter-model spread of the carbon term; as such, in the context of current ESMs, reducing ZEC uncertainty depends more strongly on equilibrium climate sensitivity and the slow ocean heat uptake timescale than on carbon-cycle parameters. Individual models split into a carbon-dominated majority (eight of ten, negative ZEC) and a thermal-dominated minority (positive ZEC), distinguished primarily by their realised warming fraction and equilibrium climate sensitivity. The simple model yields a compact analytical formula for ZEC in terms of component climate and carbon-cycle parameters, reproducing ESM-simulated values to within ~0.03 K (less than 5% of the ~0.6 K inter-model spread). The decomposition also reveals that the carbon cycle buffers ZEC against uncertainty in committed warming to an existing energetic imbalance: recent downward revisions of the realised warming fraction (the ratio of transient to equilibrium warming) imply substantially more committed warming at fixed atmospheric composition, yet this additional heat is strongly attenuated before it appears in ZEC. A reduction of 10 per cent in the realised warming fraction would increase the radiatively committed warming by ~0.5 K at cessation, but this shifts the 50-year ZEC by only ~0.05 K. This allows potential for process-level constraints on climate and carbon-cycle components on ZEC to narrow carbon budgets. Out-of-sample testing on the flat10-cdr experiment shows that CO2 predictions diverge from ESMs within ~50 years of the emission trajectory departing from the training rate, so the framework does not extend to full climate reversibility under sustained negative emissions. Structural limitations, including under-sampled land biosphere diversity across ESMs, may further emerge at higher warming levels or on multi-centennial timescales.
- Open Access
- 3 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (15) , 7111-7133
Reduced Complexity Model Intercomparison Project phase 3: experimental protocol for coordinated constraining and evaluation of reduced-complexity models
Reduced-Complexity Models (RCMs) are a critical tool for synthesising climate science knowledge and providing climate projections for a wide range of emissions scenarios. The Reduced-Complexity Model Intercomparison Project (RCMIP) provides a framework for the coordinated evaluation and application of these models. Here, we introduce the experimental protocol for RCMIP Phase 3 (RCMIP3), which is timed to inform the upcoming seventh assessment cycle of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC AR7). Taking stock of lessons from previous phases, RCMIP3 builds on community climate assessment products to support a common framework to compare RCM output against historical climate benchmarks. The experimental design aims to support a comprehensive assessment of RCMs across multiple climate-relevant domains, with a particular focus on carbon cycle dynamics and climate reversibility. The protocol is designed in tandem with the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 7 (CMIP7), replicating its “Assessment Fast Track” together with complementary experiments which explore wider state dependencies, sampling multiple scenario generations, long timescale response and diverse emissions-driven process representation.
- 3 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (15) , 7111-7133
Open AccessReduced Complexity Model Intercomparison Project phase 3: experimental protocol for coordinated constraining and evaluation of reduced-complexity models
Reduced-Complexity Models (RCMs) are a critical tool for synthesising climate science knowledge and providing climate projections for a wide range of emissions scenarios. The Reduced-Complexity Model Intercomparison Project (RCMIP) provides a framework for the coordinated evaluation and application of these models. Here, we introduce the experimental protocol for RCMIP Phase 3 (RCMIP3), which is timed to inform the upcoming seventh assessment cycle of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC AR7). Taking stock of lessons from previous phases, RCMIP3 builds on community climate assessment products to support a common framework to compare RCM output against historical climate benchmarks. The experimental design aims to support a comprehensive assessment of RCMs across multiple climate-relevant domains, with a particular focus on carbon cycle dynamics and climate reversibility. The protocol is designed in tandem with the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 7 (CMIP7), replicating its “Assessment Fast Track” together with complementary experiments which explore wider state dependencies, sampling multiple scenario generations, long timescale response and diverse emissions-driven process representation.
- Open Access
- 10 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-46
Comment on egusphere-2026-1875
The Zero Emissions Commitment (ZEC), the residual warming after anthropogenic CO2 emissions cease, remains poorly constrained and directly affects remaining carbon budget calculations. We fit a simple coupled carbon-climate model to ten Earth System Models (ESMs) in the flat10 Model Intercomparison Project. Near-zero multi-model mean ZEC can be decomposed into unrealised ocean warming contributing roughly +0.2 K at 50 years post-cessation, which is almost exactly offset by ~-0.2 K of cooling from atmospheric CO2 drawdown into land and ocean carbon sinks. Yet the thermal term carries more than twice the inter-model spread of the carbon term; as such, in the context of current ESMs, reducing ZEC uncertainty depends more strongly on equilibrium climate sensitivity and the slow ocean heat uptake timescale than on carbon-cycle parameters. Individual models split into a carbon-dominated majority (eight of ten, negative ZEC) and a thermal-dominated minority (positive ZEC), distinguished primarily by their realised warming fraction and equilibrium climate sensitivity. The simple model yields a compact analytical formula for ZEC in terms of component climate and carbon-cycle parameters, reproducing ESM-simulated values to within ~0.03 K (less than 5% of the ~0.6 K inter-model spread). The decomposition also reveals that the carbon cycle buffers ZEC against uncertainty in committed warming to an existing energetic imbalance: recent downward revisions of the realised warming fraction (the ratio of transient to equilibrium warming) imply substantially more committed warming at fixed atmospheric composition, yet this additional heat is strongly attenuated before it appears in ZEC. A reduction of 10 per cent in the realised warming fraction would increase the radiatively committed warming by ~0.5 K at cessation, but this shifts the 50-year ZEC by only ~0.05 K. This allows potential for process-level constraints on climate and carbon-cycle components on ZEC to narrow carbon budgets. Out-of-sample testing on the flat10-cdr experiment shows that CO2 predictions diverge from ESMs within ~50 years of the emission trajectory departing from the training rate, so the framework does not extend to full climate reversibility under sustained negative emissions. Structural limitations, including under-sampled land biosphere diversity across ESMs, may further emerge at higher warming levels or on multi-centennial timescales.
- 10 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-46
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-1875
The Zero Emissions Commitment (ZEC), the residual warming after anthropogenic CO2 emissions cease, remains poorly constrained and directly affects remaining carbon budget calculations. We fit a simple coupled carbon-climate model to ten Earth System Models (ESMs) in the flat10 Model Intercomparison Project. Near-zero multi-model mean ZEC can be decomposed into unrealised ocean warming contributing roughly +0.2 K at 50 years post-cessation, which is almost exactly offset by ~-0.2 K of cooling from atmospheric CO2 drawdown into land and ocean carbon sinks. Yet the thermal term carries more than twice the inter-model spread of the carbon term; as such, in the context of current ESMs, reducing ZEC uncertainty depends more strongly on equilibrium climate sensitivity and the slow ocean heat uptake timescale than on carbon-cycle parameters. Individual models split into a carbon-dominated majority (eight of ten, negative ZEC) and a thermal-dominated minority (positive ZEC), distinguished primarily by their realised warming fraction and equilibrium climate sensitivity. The simple model yields a compact analytical formula for ZEC in terms of component climate and carbon-cycle parameters, reproducing ESM-simulated values to within ~0.03 K (less than 5% of the ~0.6 K inter-model spread). The decomposition also reveals that the carbon cycle buffers ZEC against uncertainty in committed warming to an existing energetic imbalance: recent downward revisions of the realised warming fraction (the ratio of transient to equilibrium warming) imply substantially more committed warming at fixed atmospheric composition, yet this additional heat is strongly attenuated before it appears in ZEC. A reduction of 10 per cent in the realised warming fraction would increase the radiatively committed warming by ~0.5 K at cessation, but this shifts the 50-year ZEC by only ~0.05 K. This allows potential for process-level constraints on climate and carbon-cycle components on ZEC to narrow carbon budgets. Out-of-sample testing on the flat10-cdr experiment shows that CO2 predictions diverge from ESMs within ~50 years of the emission trajectory departing from the training rate, so the framework does not extend to full climate reversibility under sustained negative emissions. Structural limitations, including under-sampled land biosphere diversity across ESMs, may further emerge at higher warming levels or on multi-centennial timescales.
- Open Access
- 8 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-33
Comment on egusphere-2026-2029
Climate impact assessment increasingly requires spatially explicit projections with realistic temporal variability at sub-annual resolution. METEORv1.6 extends the established METEOR spatial multi-timescale, multi-forcer climate emulation framework with two major capabilities: (1) a monthly climate variability model that generates realistic sub-annual climate sequences with seasonal cycles and inter-annual variability, enabling the generation of ensemble projections and (2) a modular impact assessment framework that translates climate projections into impact metrics. The monthly climate model represents seasonal harmonics and noise, while preserving covariance structures from the source model. Seasonal cycles are represented through harmonic analysis with temperature-dependent parameterization, enabling non-stationary simulation of seasonal timing shifts under warming. Principal Component Analysis is used to decompose monthly anomalies into spatial modes, then their temporal evolution and climate variability is modeled using Vector Autoregressive with eXogenous variables (VARX) processes. The impact assessment framework provides a standardized interface for ensemble processing and uncertainty quantification through a modular system of impact calculators. The initial case implementation includes heating and cooling degree days calculations which are key drivers in estimating energy sector demand, demonstrating ensemble-based uncertainty propagation from climate projections to impact metrics. Validation against CMIP6 data demonstrates that METEORv1.6 accurately reproduces statistical properties of monthly climate variability for a range of future scenarios when trained on a single scenario from an Earth System Model (together with a CO2 quadrupling idealized experiment). The integrated impact framework enables rapid generation of probabilistic climate risk assessments suitable for sectoral applications, bridging the gap between global climate projections and local decision-making needs. The open-source implementation supports broad adoption and continued expansion to additional impact domains.
- 8 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-33
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-2029
Climate impact assessment increasingly requires spatially explicit projections with realistic temporal variability at sub-annual resolution. METEORv1.6 extends the established METEOR spatial multi-timescale, multi-forcer climate emulation framework with two major capabilities: (1) a monthly climate variability model that generates realistic sub-annual climate sequences with seasonal cycles and inter-annual variability, enabling the generation of ensemble projections and (2) a modular impact assessment framework that translates climate projections into impact metrics. The monthly climate model represents seasonal harmonics and noise, while preserving covariance structures from the source model. Seasonal cycles are represented through harmonic analysis with temperature-dependent parameterization, enabling non-stationary simulation of seasonal timing shifts under warming. Principal Component Analysis is used to decompose monthly anomalies into spatial modes, then their temporal evolution and climate variability is modeled using Vector Autoregressive with eXogenous variables (VARX) processes. The impact assessment framework provides a standardized interface for ensemble processing and uncertainty quantification through a modular system of impact calculators. The initial case implementation includes heating and cooling degree days calculations which are key drivers in estimating energy sector demand, demonstrating ensemble-based uncertainty propagation from climate projections to impact metrics. Validation against CMIP6 data demonstrates that METEORv1.6 accurately reproduces statistical properties of monthly climate variability for a range of future scenarios when trained on a single scenario from an Earth System Model (together with a CO2 quadrupling idealized experiment). The integrated impact framework enables rapid generation of probabilistic climate risk assessments suitable for sectoral applications, bridging the gap between global climate projections and local decision-making needs. The open-source implementation supports broad adoption and continued expansion to additional impact domains.
- Open Access
- 7 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 26 (13) , 9509-9539
A multi-model approach to constrain the atmospheric hydrogen budget
Understanding the global hydrogen (H 2 ) budget is critical as H 2 is expected to play an important role in future energy systems. Tropospheric H 2 sources include direct emissions and atmospheric production via chemical reactions, while sinks are soil uptake and removal by hydroxyl radical (OH). Large uncertainties remain in quantifying the atmospheric production and loss of H 2 due to large uncertainties in H 2 uptake in the soil and the lack of global-scale knowledge of the abundance of OH. We use a suite of global three-dimensional Atmospheric Chemistry Models (ACM) to evaluate key reactive species involved in atmospheric production and loss – formaldehyde (HCHO), nitrogen dioxide (NO 2 ), and carbon monoxide (CO). A box model is then used to simulate the evolution of global mean tropospheric H 2 from pre-industrial to present day; to test different relative contributions in atmospheric production from methane and Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC); and to assess atmospheric loss with different OH concentrations. Isotopic compositions of the different sources and sinks are further used to constrain these terms and assess the potential importance of geological sources to the H 2 budget. Models generally match each other for HCHO, though model diversity exists for NO 2 and CO. From model evaluations and box model constraints, we estimate atmospheric H 2 production of 37–60 Tg yr −1 , and atmospheric losses of 15–30 Tg yr −1 , suggesting that some top-down literature estimates may overestimate production. Box model results suggest an upper bound of 9 Tg yr −1 for geological sources, considerably lower than the 23 Tg yr −1 proposed previously. We recommend more isotopic observations and targeted measurement campaigns to further refine the budget.
- 7 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 26 (13) , 9509-9539
Open AccessA multi-model approach to constrain the atmospheric hydrogen budget
Understanding the global hydrogen (H 2 ) budget is critical as H 2 is expected to play an important role in future energy systems. Tropospheric H 2 sources include direct emissions and atmospheric production via chemical reactions, while sinks are soil uptake and removal by hydroxyl radical (OH). Large uncertainties remain in quantifying the atmospheric production and loss of H 2 due to large uncertainties in H 2 uptake in the soil and the lack of global-scale knowledge of the abundance of OH. We use a suite of global three-dimensional Atmospheric Chemistry Models (ACM) to evaluate key reactive species involved in atmospheric production and loss – formaldehyde (HCHO), nitrogen dioxide (NO 2 ), and carbon monoxide (CO). A box model is then used to simulate the evolution of global mean tropospheric H 2 from pre-industrial to present day; to test different relative contributions in atmospheric production from methane and Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC); and to assess atmospheric loss with different OH concentrations. Isotopic compositions of the different sources and sinks are further used to constrain these terms and assess the potential importance of geological sources to the H 2 budget. Models generally match each other for HCHO, though model diversity exists for NO 2 and CO. From model evaluations and box model constraints, we estimate atmospheric H 2 production of 37–60 Tg yr −1 , and atmospheric losses of 15–30 Tg yr −1 , suggesting that some top-down literature estimates may overestimate production. Box model results suggest an upper bound of 9 Tg yr −1 for geological sources, considerably lower than the 23 Tg yr −1 proposed previously. We recommend more isotopic observations and targeted measurement campaigns to further refine the budget.