George Szmukler
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
George Szmukler has a total of 65 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Gareth S. Owen
IoPPN Division of Academic Psychiatry: King’s College London
3 shared publications - Diana Rose
Department of Health Services Research, Kings College London, London, UK
2 shared publications - Graham Thornicroft
Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology and Neuroscience, King's College London, London, England, United Kingdom
2 shared publications - Simone Farrelly
Health Service and Population Research Department,King's College London, Institute of Psychiatry,London,UK
2 shared publications A. Wentworth
Evaluametrics Ltd, St Albans, UK
1 shared publication- Alex D. Tulloch
Department of Psychiatry, Institute of Psychiatry, Kings College London, De Crespigny Park, London, SE5 8AF, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 November 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 24 (12) , 89-91
“Treatment Pressures” and “Informal Coercion”: “Threats” in Mental Healthcare
Coercion in mental healthcare is a complex phenomenon with major ethical implications. A commonly accepted account of “informal coercion”—that is, coercion that falls short of legal compulsion—is t...
- 20 November 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 24 (12) , 89-91
Open Access“Treatment Pressures” and “Informal Coercion”: “Threats” in Mental Healthcare
Coercion in mental healthcare is a complex phenomenon with major ethical implications. A commonly accepted account of “informal coercion”—that is, coercion that falls short of legal compulsion—is t...
- Open Access
- 11 August 2023
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in BJPsych Open
- Vol. 9 (5) , e155
Promoting human rights in mental healthcare: beyond the ‘Geneva impasse’
The past decade has seen a significant growth in attention to the human rights of persons with disabilities, taken to include mental health conditions. Consequently, challenges to important areas of current psychiatric practice have emerged, with which the profession has, in general, shown limited engagement.
- 11 August 2023
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in BJPsych Open
- Vol. 9 (5) , e155
Open AccessPromoting human rights in mental healthcare: beyond the ‘Geneva impasse’
The past decade has seen a significant growth in attention to the human rights of persons with disabilities, taken to include mental health conditions. Consequently, challenges to important areas of current psychiatric practice have emerged, with which the profession has, in general, shown limited engagement.
- Open Access
- 9 June 2023
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in European Psychiatry
- Vol. 66 (1) , 1-19
Opportunities and challenges of self-binding directives: A comparison of empirical research with stakeholders in three European countries
Background: Self-binding directives (SBDs) are psychiatric advance directives that include a clause in which mental health service users consent in advance to involuntary hospital admission and treatment under specified conditions. Medical ethicists and legal scholars identified various potential benefits of SBDs but have also raised ethical concerns. Until recently, little was known about the views of stakeholders on the opportunities and challenges of SBDs.Aims: This article aims to foster an international exchange on SBDs by comparing recent empirical findings on stakeholders’ views on the opportunities and challenges of SBDs from Germany, the Netherlands, and the United Kingdom.Method: Comparisons between the empirical findings were drawn using a structured expert consensus process.Results: Findings converged on many points. Perceived opportunities of SBDs include promotion of autonomy, avoidance of personally defined harms, early intervention, reduction of admission duration, improvement of the therapeutic relationship, involvement of persons of trust, avoidance of involuntary hospital admission, addressing trauma, destigmatization of involuntary treatment, increase of professionals’ confidence, and relief for proxy decision-makers. Perceived challenges include lack of awareness and knowledge, lack of support, undue influence, inaccessibility during crisis, lack of cross-agency coordination, problems of interpretation, difficulties in capacity assessment, restricted therapeutic flexibility, scarce resources, disappointment due to noncompliance, and outdated content. Stakeholders tended to focus on practical challenges and did not often raise fundamental ethical concerns.Conclusions: Stakeholders tend to see the implementation of SBDs as ethically desirable, provided that the associated challenges are addressed.
- 9 June 2023
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in European Psychiatry
- Vol. 66 (1) , 1-19
Open AccessOpportunities and challenges of self-binding directives: A comparison of empirical research with stakeholders in three European countries
Background: Self-binding directives (SBDs) are psychiatric advance directives that include a clause in which mental health service users consent in advance to involuntary hospital admission and treatment under specified conditions. Medical ethicists and legal scholars identified various potential benefits of SBDs but have also raised ethical concerns. Until recently, little was known about the views of stakeholders on the opportunities and challenges of SBDs.Aims: This article aims to foster an international exchange on SBDs by comparing recent empirical findings on stakeholders’ views on the opportunities and challenges of SBDs from Germany, the Netherlands, and the United Kingdom.Method: Comparisons between the empirical findings were drawn using a structured expert consensus process.Results: Findings converged on many points. Perceived opportunities of SBDs include promotion of autonomy, avoidance of personally defined harms, early intervention, reduction of admission duration, improvement of the therapeutic relationship, involvement of persons of trust, avoidance of involuntary hospital admission, addressing trauma, destigmatization of involuntary treatment, increase of professionals’ confidence, and relief for proxy decision-makers. Perceived challenges include lack of awareness and knowledge, lack of support, undue influence, inaccessibility during crisis, lack of cross-agency coordination, problems of interpretation, difficulties in capacity assessment, restricted therapeutic flexibility, scarce resources, disappointment due to noncompliance, and outdated content. Stakeholders tended to focus on practical challenges and did not often raise fundamental ethical concerns.Conclusions: Stakeholders tend to see the implementation of SBDs as ethically desirable, provided that the associated challenges are addressed.
- 5 January 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Schizophrenia Bulletin
- Vol. 46 (2) , 231-235
Involuntary Detention and Treatment: Are We Edging Toward a “Paradigm Shift”?
Recent challenges to conventional mental health laws concerning involuntary detention and treatment of persons with a mental disorder have led to proposals, or indeed an insistence, that fundamental reform is necessary. A key theme has been the need to eliminate unfair discrimination against people with a mental disorder because their human rights are not respected on an equal basis with other people. Some proposals depart radically from conventional assumptions concerning the justification of involuntary detention and treatment. One is a “fusion law,” a generic law applying to all persons lacking the ability to make a treatment decision, whether resulting from a “mental” or “physical” illness. An authoritative interpretation of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (2006) goes so far as to maintain that involuntary interventions are a violation of the Convention.
- 5 January 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Schizophrenia Bulletin
- Vol. 46 (2) , 231-235
Involuntary Detention and Treatment: Are We Edging Toward a “Paradigm Shift”?
Recent challenges to conventional mental health laws concerning involuntary detention and treatment of persons with a mental disorder have led to proposals, or indeed an insistence, that fundamental reform is necessary. A key theme has been the need to eliminate unfair discrimination against people with a mental disorder because their human rights are not respected on an equal basis with other people. Some proposals depart radically from conventional assumptions concerning the justification of involuntary detention and treatment. One is a “fusion law,” a generic law applying to all persons lacking the ability to make a treatment decision, whether resulting from a “mental” or “physical” illness. An authoritative interpretation of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (2006) goes so far as to maintain that involuntary interventions are a violation of the Convention.
- Open Access
- 30 October 2018
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in Bjpsych Bulletin
- Vol. 43 (1) , 35-37
Night-time confinement is an unacceptable hospital practice
Night-time confinement, currently imposed as a blanket restriction on all patients on wards in UK high secure hospitals, constitutes an arbitrary restriction of liberty, not being based on any therapeutic purpose for those so restricted, nor serving a need for the protection of others. Its imposition constitutes a form of ‘degrading’ treatment as well as an unjustified restriction of ‘residual’ liberty. Persons who are vulnerable, especially those who are involuntarily detained as in this case, are particularly at risk of suffering human rights abuses. A compelling case can be made, based on ethics, law and accepted practice standards, for ruling out night-time confinement as an acceptable measure. Declaration of interest None.
- 30 October 2018
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in Bjpsych Bulletin
- Vol. 43 (1) , 35-37
Open AccessNight-time confinement is an unacceptable hospital practice
Night-time confinement, currently imposed as a blanket restriction on all patients on wards in UK high secure hospitals, constitutes an arbitrary restriction of liberty, not being based on any therapeutic purpose for those so restricted, nor serving a need for the protection of others. Its imposition constitutes a form of ‘degrading’ treatment as well as an unjustified restriction of ‘residual’ liberty. Persons who are vulnerable, especially those who are involuntarily detained as in this case, are particularly at risk of suffering human rights abuses. A compelling case can be made, based on ethics, law and accepted practice standards, for ruling out night-time confinement as an acceptable measure. Declaration of interest None.
- 1 December 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
A new United Nations ‘disability’ convention
The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) presents in a tailored form the rights of such persons. Mental health disabilities are included. While the Convention is most welcome, it is hugely challenging when it comes to involuntary treatment. Important authorities have interpreted it as excluding all forms of ‘substitute decision-making’. The Convention demands ‘respect for the rights, will and preferences’ of persons with disabilities. This chapter examines the meaning of ‘will’ and of ‘preference’. A problem arises when a person’s currently expressed ‘preference’ (or desire or wish) diverges from the person’s ‘will’ (taken to mean a person’s relatively enduring and deeply held value commitments). Both cannot be respected at the same time. Which should have precedence? The method of ‘interpretation’ discussed in Chapter 7 allows such a determination to be made, and aligns the ‘fusion law’ proposal with the objectives of the Convention.
- 1 December 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
A new United Nations ‘disability’ convention
The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) presents in a tailored form the rights of such persons. Mental health disabilities are included. While the Convention is most welcome, it is hugely challenging when it comes to involuntary treatment. Important authorities have interpreted it as excluding all forms of ‘substitute decision-making’. The Convention demands ‘respect for the rights, will and preferences’ of persons with disabilities. This chapter examines the meaning of ‘will’ and of ‘preference’. A problem arises when a person’s currently expressed ‘preference’ (or desire or wish) diverges from the person’s ‘will’ (taken to mean a person’s relatively enduring and deeply held value commitments). Both cannot be respected at the same time. Which should have precedence? The method of ‘interpretation’ discussed in Chapter 7 allows such a determination to be made, and aligns the ‘fusion law’ proposal with the objectives of the Convention.
Has the Mental Health Act had its day?
Patients with a “mental disorder” in England and Wales can be detained and treated against their will on legal grounds that are ethically unacceptable. These grounds contribute to the shadow of coercion that hangs over the practice of psychiatry. The relevant law remains fundamentally unchanged since the late 18th century.1
Has the Mental Health Act had its day?
Patients with a “mental disorder” in England and Wales can be detained and treated against their will on legal grounds that are ethically unacceptable. These grounds contribute to the shadow of coercion that hangs over the practice of psychiatry. The relevant law remains fundamentally unchanged since the late 18th century.1
- Top Cited Papers
- 1 September 2017
- Published by Elsevier in International Journal of Law and Psychiatry
- Vol. 54, 90-97
The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities: ‘Rights, will and preferences’ in relation to mental health disabilities
- 1 September 2017
- Published by Elsevier in International Journal of Law and Psychiatry
- Vol. 54, 90-97
Top Cited PapersThe UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities: ‘Rights, will and preferences’ in relation to mental health disabilities
- 1 December 2016
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in The British Journal of Psychiatry
- Vol. 209 (6) , 449-453
We should replace conventional mental health law with capacity-based law
Summary: As general medicine moves away from ‘paternalism’ and places an increasing emphasis on patient choice and autonomy, George Szmukler and Brendan D. Kelly debate whether conventional mental health legislation should be replaced with a model that focuses on the person's decision-making capabilities.
- 1 December 2016
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in The British Journal of Psychiatry
- Vol. 209 (6) , 449-453
We should replace conventional mental health law with capacity-based law
Summary: As general medicine moves away from ‘paternalism’ and places an increasing emphasis on patient choice and autonomy, George Szmukler and Brendan D. Kelly debate whether conventional mental health legislation should be replaced with a model that focuses on the person's decision-making capabilities.