Tomáš Cirhan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Tomáš Cirhan has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jakub Stauber
Institute of Political Studies, Charles University, Praha 5, Czech Republic
1 shared publication - Marek Pršín1 shared publication
- Mattia Collini
Institute of Political Studies, Faculty of Social Sciences, Charles University
1 shared publication - Michal Malý
Institute of Political Science, Charles University, Prague, 15800, Czech Republic
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 5 August 2025
- Published by University of Bucharest (Bucharest University Press) in Studia Politica. Romanian Political Science Review
- Vol. 25 (1/2025) , 139-179
THE CRISIS OF THE LEFT IN THE CZECH REPUBLIC, A PARTY-ELITE PERSPECTIVE (KSČM AND SOCDEM)
For approximately two decades, the Czech Republic has stood out as an outlier in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE), being the only country where a largely unreformed communist successor party, the Communist Party of Bohemia and Moravia (KSČM), has consistently enjoyed stable and significant electoral support. Simultaneously, a robust social-democratic left with no direct ties to the former communist party played a major role in Czech politics. The Czech Social Democratic Party (ČSSD), originally founded in 1878, having been the largest or second-largest party in the country for over a decade. However, in the broader European context of left-wing decline and the rise of anti-establishment populist challengers, both parties have experienced sharp electoral downturns. In the 2021 elections, KSČM lost its parliamentary representation, a fate shared by ČSSD, now renamed Sociální Demokracie (SOCDEM), which faces an even deeper crisis. These setbacks occurred alongside the rise of new populist forces such as ANO and Freedom and Direct Democracy (SPD), which have drawn support from traditional centre-left constituencies. Despite these challenges, both parties remain politically active, with KSČM experiencing a modest revival under a more nationalist-conservative orientation. In light of this context, this paper has two primary aims. First, it traces the electoral decline of KSČM and SOCDEM over the past decade by analyzing election results and party positioning. Second, it explores how party elites interpret the crisis and identify potential sources of resilience. Methodologically, the study combines quantitative data with qualitative interviews and party document analysis. Overall, it contributes to understanding the crisis and transformation of the Czech left within the recent political landscape, as well as its implications for the broader crisis of the left in Eastern Europe.
- 5 August 2025
- Published by University of Bucharest (Bucharest University Press) in Studia Politica. Romanian Political Science Review
- Vol. 25 (1/2025) , 139-179
Open AccessTHE CRISIS OF THE LEFT IN THE CZECH REPUBLIC, A PARTY-ELITE PERSPECTIVE (KSČM AND SOCDEM)
For approximately two decades, the Czech Republic has stood out as an outlier in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE), being the only country where a largely unreformed communist successor party, the Communist Party of Bohemia and Moravia (KSČM), has consistently enjoyed stable and significant electoral support. Simultaneously, a robust social-democratic left with no direct ties to the former communist party played a major role in Czech politics. The Czech Social Democratic Party (ČSSD), originally founded in 1878, having been the largest or second-largest party in the country for over a decade. However, in the broader European context of left-wing decline and the rise of anti-establishment populist challengers, both parties have experienced sharp electoral downturns. In the 2021 elections, KSČM lost its parliamentary representation, a fate shared by ČSSD, now renamed Sociální Demokracie (SOCDEM), which faces an even deeper crisis. These setbacks occurred alongside the rise of new populist forces such as ANO and Freedom and Direct Democracy (SPD), which have drawn support from traditional centre-left constituencies. Despite these challenges, both parties remain politically active, with KSČM experiencing a modest revival under a more nationalist-conservative orientation. In light of this context, this paper has two primary aims. First, it traces the electoral decline of KSČM and SOCDEM over the past decade by analyzing election results and party positioning. Second, it explores how party elites interpret the crisis and identify potential sources of resilience. Methodologically, the study combines quantitative data with qualitative interviews and party document analysis. Overall, it contributes to understanding the crisis and transformation of the Czech left within the recent political landscape, as well as its implications for the broader crisis of the left in Eastern Europe.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft
- Vol. 19 (1) , 1-37
Institutionalization of the Czech and Luxembourgish Pirate Parties: a comparative perspective
This paper contributes to the debate on party institutionalization by including new parties that lack both connections with existing parties and social movement structures, thus unlikely adepts to institutionalize. To that end, we explore two parliamentary-represented Pirate Parties, from Czechia and Luxembourg, that fit these criteria. Utilizing original interviews with party elites to analyze the structural aspects of the internal party institutionalization. On the other hand, the article examines the external dimension of party institutionalization by focusing on voter loyalty and the party’s role within the party system. Additionally, it looks at the objective durability entailing the ability to survive shocks. Our findings offer a comprehensive understanding of the degree of institutionalization of these two similarly successful parties. Particularly in the Czech case, the pragmatic focus on rules and regulations facilitated extensive base-level routinization. Together with early depersonalization and ability to survive shocks, such organizational setup resulted in a relatively high degree of institutionalization. In the Luxembourgish case, the focus on more developed intra-party democracy, together with lower coalition potential of the party associated with its anti-establishment image led to its lower capacity to institutionalize. In conclusion, we provide theory-guided explanations for the institutionalization of these cases. Despite lacking origin in social movement structure, having movement-style founders seems to help these parties to institutionalize. However, genetic imprints do not explain the whole picture, our findings underline the role of pragmatic party elites and learning from successful practices and mistakes of other parties for the ability to adapt and institutionalize.
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft
- Vol. 19 (1) , 1-37
Open AccessInstitutionalization of the Czech and Luxembourgish Pirate Parties: a comparative perspective
This paper contributes to the debate on party institutionalization by including new parties that lack both connections with existing parties and social movement structures, thus unlikely adepts to institutionalize. To that end, we explore two parliamentary-represented Pirate Parties, from Czechia and Luxembourg, that fit these criteria. Utilizing original interviews with party elites to analyze the structural aspects of the internal party institutionalization. On the other hand, the article examines the external dimension of party institutionalization by focusing on voter loyalty and the party’s role within the party system. Additionally, it looks at the objective durability entailing the ability to survive shocks. Our findings offer a comprehensive understanding of the degree of institutionalization of these two similarly successful parties. Particularly in the Czech case, the pragmatic focus on rules and regulations facilitated extensive base-level routinization. Together with early depersonalization and ability to survive shocks, such organizational setup resulted in a relatively high degree of institutionalization. In the Luxembourgish case, the focus on more developed intra-party democracy, together with lower coalition potential of the party associated with its anti-establishment image led to its lower capacity to institutionalize. In conclusion, we provide theory-guided explanations for the institutionalization of these cases. Despite lacking origin in social movement structure, having movement-style founders seems to help these parties to institutionalize. However, genetic imprints do not explain the whole picture, our findings underline the role of pragmatic party elites and learning from successful practices and mistakes of other parties for the ability to adapt and institutionalize.
- Open Access
- 3 December 2024
- Published by Masaryk University Press in Politologický časopis - Czech Journal of Political Science
- No. 2,p. 145-168
New Breakaway Parties in Slovakia: Exploring Intra-party Democracy Shifts
Many new parties are electorally succeeding across European party systems, including in post-communist countries. This is especially true in Slovakia, where it is accompanied by another very specific phenomenon, which in our perspective defines recent parliamentary elections – the prevalence of new breakaway parties. These newly formed parties created by splitting from parliamentary parties are now competing alongside them in early parliamentary elections. The 2020-2023 period, in addition to seeing the fall of governments, and a general political crisis and instability, was also characterized by frequent party factionalism. During this period, turbulent development within SMER-SD, ĽSNS and OĽaNO translated into the formation of three new parties – HLAS-SD, Republika, and the Democrats, which represent our case studies. The aim of our paper is to analyse how these new breakaway parties differ from their original parties organizationally, in the processes associated with intra-party democracy (IPD). We empirically explore their leadership selection, candidate selection and membership policies. The existing data (based on the Populism and Political Parties Database) indicate that their three parent parties are highly personalized with low IPD. The findings of our comparative analysis reveal that the new breakaway parties have incorporated more transparent approaches to intraparty processes compared to their parent parties. However, concerning candidate selection, they have not embraced greater inclusiveness than the parties they originated from. Overall, despite a noticeable trend towards intraparty depersonalization, the opportunity for a broader membership base to participate in the decision making process remains largely unrealized.
- 3 December 2024
- Published by Masaryk University Press in Politologický časopis - Czech Journal of Political Science
- No. 2,p. 145-168
Open AccessNew Breakaway Parties in Slovakia: Exploring Intra-party Democracy Shifts
Many new parties are electorally succeeding across European party systems, including in post-communist countries. This is especially true in Slovakia, where it is accompanied by another very specific phenomenon, which in our perspective defines recent parliamentary elections – the prevalence of new breakaway parties. These newly formed parties created by splitting from parliamentary parties are now competing alongside them in early parliamentary elections. The 2020-2023 period, in addition to seeing the fall of governments, and a general political crisis and instability, was also characterized by frequent party factionalism. During this period, turbulent development within SMER-SD, ĽSNS and OĽaNO translated into the formation of three new parties – HLAS-SD, Republika, and the Democrats, which represent our case studies. The aim of our paper is to analyse how these new breakaway parties differ from their original parties organizationally, in the processes associated with intra-party democracy (IPD). We empirically explore their leadership selection, candidate selection and membership policies. The existing data (based on the Populism and Political Parties Database) indicate that their three parent parties are highly personalized with low IPD. The findings of our comparative analysis reveal that the new breakaway parties have incorporated more transparent approaches to intraparty processes compared to their parent parties. However, concerning candidate selection, they have not embraced greater inclusiveness than the parties they originated from. Overall, despite a noticeable trend towards intraparty depersonalization, the opportunity for a broader membership base to participate in the decision making process remains largely unrealized.
- Open Access
- 18 July 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in East European Politics
- Vol. 40 (4) , 614-636
Leader vs. the party dilemma: the case of a party rebirth in Czechia
- 18 July 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in East European Politics
- Vol. 40 (4) , 614-636
Open AccessLeader vs. the party dilemma: the case of a party rebirth in Czechia
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 60-83
Party membership
This chapter pursues a theoretical argument concerning the role of various features of party membership and electoral success. Both thematically and methodologically, the analysis and the discussion were divided into two parts: on the impact of the number of party members and on restrictions on party membership. As a part of the research design, a cross-regional correlation between electoral outcomes and the number of party members (M/E ratio disaggregated on the regional level) is conducted. The second part of empirical analysis concerns party statutes, specifically the rules concerning the recruitment of members, as well as their rights and obligations. This chapter shows that the number of party members does not have a substantial impact on electoral success. However, party membership still matters electorally by affecting party stability and cohesion. Findings in this indicate that the control and the exclusiveness of party membership are crucial ingredients of the cohesion and stability of the party organization. Screening of party members together with reliance on alternative forms of membership that have no influence on decision-making in the party helps party leadership to maintain stability and control over the party organization.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 60-83
Party membership
This chapter pursues a theoretical argument concerning the role of various features of party membership and electoral success. Both thematically and methodologically, the analysis and the discussion were divided into two parts: on the impact of the number of party members and on restrictions on party membership. As a part of the research design, a cross-regional correlation between electoral outcomes and the number of party members (M/E ratio disaggregated on the regional level) is conducted. The second part of empirical analysis concerns party statutes, specifically the rules concerning the recruitment of members, as well as their rights and obligations. This chapter shows that the number of party members does not have a substantial impact on electoral success. However, party membership still matters electorally by affecting party stability and cohesion. Findings in this indicate that the control and the exclusiveness of party membership are crucial ingredients of the cohesion and stability of the party organization. Screening of party members together with reliance on alternative forms of membership that have no influence on decision-making in the party helps party leadership to maintain stability and control over the party organization.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 25-59
Local party organization
This chapter deals with the relationship between electoral success and local party organization. To test the role of local branches, two aspects of local party organization are analysed – local organizational density and autonomy. Methodologically, local organizational density comprises of the analysis of the number of local branches by region and the electoral performance by region. Local organizational autonomy is measured in the local branches' rights concerning the process of candidate selection. This chapter shows that the more densely built local party organization does not (in itself) facilitate better electoral results. However, the findings indicate that the structure of local branches still plays a role in effecting the electoral success differently. Two ways of local branches' impacts are observed. Firstly, according to the interviewed numerous party activists, the nature and extent of party-themed events and activities organized under the umbrella of the local branches helps to mobilize votes. Secondly, the strict control over the local party organizational autonomy in selecting candidates helps the party to mute party dissent and effectively deal with scandals, keeping the party more united. It also ensures that the selected candidates are nationally endorsed but locally embedded individuals who better connect with the electorate in their constituency.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 25-59
Local party organization
This chapter deals with the relationship between electoral success and local party organization. To test the role of local branches, two aspects of local party organization are analysed – local organizational density and autonomy. Methodologically, local organizational density comprises of the analysis of the number of local branches by region and the electoral performance by region. Local organizational autonomy is measured in the local branches' rights concerning the process of candidate selection. This chapter shows that the more densely built local party organization does not (in itself) facilitate better electoral results. However, the findings indicate that the structure of local branches still plays a role in effecting the electoral success differently. Two ways of local branches' impacts are observed. Firstly, according to the interviewed numerous party activists, the nature and extent of party-themed events and activities organized under the umbrella of the local branches helps to mobilize votes. Secondly, the strict control over the local party organizational autonomy in selecting candidates helps the party to mute party dissent and effectively deal with scandals, keeping the party more united. It also ensures that the selected candidates are nationally endorsed but locally embedded individuals who better connect with the electorate in their constituency.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Party Organization and Electoral Success of New Anti-establishment Parties
This book examines the new anti-establishment parties electorally succeeding at the expense of their established counterparts and argues that party organization matters for their electoral success. It explores a relationship between these parties’ electoral success and their party organization. Using a framework to explain the role of organizational features such as local party branches, party membership, and party elites in this process, it reveals how they help parties to be more stable, cohesive, and legitimate; a state that facilitates better conditions for electoral success. It also shows that control over party organization is achieved partially by the existence of a corporate network associated with party leaders’ businesses. This book will be of key interest to scholars and students of party politics and political parties, anti-establishment politics, and Eastern European politics.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Party Organization and Electoral Success of New Anti-establishment Parties
This book examines the new anti-establishment parties electorally succeeding at the expense of their established counterparts and argues that party organization matters for their electoral success. It explores a relationship between these parties’ electoral success and their party organization. Using a framework to explain the role of organizational features such as local party branches, party membership, and party elites in this process, it reveals how they help parties to be more stable, cohesive, and legitimate; a state that facilitates better conditions for electoral success. It also shows that control over party organization is achieved partially by the existence of a corporate network associated with party leaders’ businesses. This book will be of key interest to scholars and students of party politics and political parties, anti-establishment politics, and Eastern European politics.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 84-103
Party elite
This chapter covers the role of party elite in party organization. It follows an argument about two aspects of party elite's background influencing electoral success by facilitating party cohesion. In regards to the research design, this chapter relied on two aspects of elites' background – type career pasts and specific company where these individuals held position prior to becoming politicians. This chapter shows party elite homogeneity in career backgrounds and professional links facilitates party cohesion which helps parties in dealing with scandals. The findings point out that when party elite is highly homogenous, the party is more cohesive and less prone to conflicts and organizational splits. In the concerned case study, the elite's cohesion stems directly from the fact that part of it consists of managers recruited from the business company owned by the party leader. At the time of crises faced by the party, the elite manifested cohesion and strong support to the party leadership.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 84-103
Party elite
This chapter covers the role of party elite in party organization. It follows an argument about two aspects of party elite's background influencing electoral success by facilitating party cohesion. In regards to the research design, this chapter relied on two aspects of elites' background – type career pasts and specific company where these individuals held position prior to becoming politicians. This chapter shows party elite homogeneity in career backgrounds and professional links facilitates party cohesion which helps parties in dealing with scandals. The findings point out that when party elite is highly homogenous, the party is more cohesive and less prone to conflicts and organizational splits. In the concerned case study, the elite's cohesion stems directly from the fact that part of it consists of managers recruited from the business company owned by the party leader. At the time of crises faced by the party, the elite manifested cohesion and strong support to the party leadership.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-24
Introduction
This chapter covers a general introduction to the book. The chapter introduces a general framework to the study of new anti-establishment parties. Setting up the basic theoretical conceptual debate, the book starts by presenting the definitions and terminology used throughout. This conceptual framework is followed by an overview of the first concerned case. The discussion starts with outlining the societal and political background of the first concerned case study. Then, the discussion continues with looking at the wider phenomenon of new anti-establishment parties in different European countries. The chapter is concluded with an in-depth conceptual discussion of existing theory concerning the overall role of party organization in electoral success of parties.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-24
Introduction
This chapter covers a general introduction to the book. The chapter introduces a general framework to the study of new anti-establishment parties. Setting up the basic theoretical conceptual debate, the book starts by presenting the definitions and terminology used throughout. This conceptual framework is followed by an overview of the first concerned case. The discussion starts with outlining the societal and political background of the first concerned case study. Then, the discussion continues with looking at the wider phenomenon of new anti-establishment parties in different European countries. The chapter is concluded with an in-depth conceptual discussion of existing theory concerning the overall role of party organization in electoral success of parties.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 164-178
End matter
Interviewee 1 – Member of ANO's Executive Committee, a founding member of the party, MP, former minister, prime minister, the party leader. Interview held on 7 September 2016.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 164-178
End matter
Interviewee 1 – Member of ANO's Executive Committee, a founding member of the party, MP, former minister, prime minister, the party leader. Interview held on 7 September 2016.